They Lied about their 9V Battery Capacity

Рет қаралды 12,371

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 72

@noctambulomissthesun3858 11 ай бұрын

thanks for the info You should make a new video with the current 9v batteries to know how much you get from a 600mah batt

@Mulakulu Жыл бұрын

mAh is a stupid unit to measure battery capacity. We should use Wh or just J, since then you don't need to know what voltage is being used to know how much energy is actually stored

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

Agreed.

@fr_schmidlin 3 ай бұрын

True. But at least ZNTER and Etinesan both show their battery capacity using both units.

@1903bretep 6 ай бұрын

Thank you that explanation was very clear and informative, I am about to buy a couple of these so now I know what to expect from them.

@volodumurkalunyak4651 13 күн бұрын

0:28 - yes, you can 1. So called "1.5V" alkalines arent 1.5V, those have 1.6V fully charged, 1.3V mid-piloint and 0.9-1.1V almost empty. 2. Li-ion "3.7"V is full at 4.2V, has mid point at 3.7V and almost empty at 3.2-3.3V. 2 of Li-ion fit in perfectly in 6×Alkaline 9.6V - 6.6V range. Even battery level indicator will work almost fine (except it will maybe have 70-80% on 100% charged 2S Li-ion and rest of the readings scaled proportionally). I have those packs so I do really know - those do really work and yes, they work fine.

@prooffypro5834 3 ай бұрын

You should take in account the consumption in the converter circuit.

@williammchugh4361 10 ай бұрын

I have another brand that I use with a similar charger with alligator clips. These do not have a usb port. These do not advertise that they are True 9 volt. The voltage is max 8.4. I assume these are just 2 cell batteries which operated at a lower voltage. I set the charger to 2 cell, and charge them to only around 8.1 volts. The lower voltage doesn't seem to matter to my smoke detectors. I'm surprised you could even charge these batteries with alligator clips if the power coming out is running through a boost circuit! Perhaps you meant you charged around the USB connector. I like these other type so far and do a top off charge about every 3 months, the batteries in the smoke detectors are barely drained and only require maybe 20 mah each to top (and the capacity of these batteries is like 500+ mah). Thanks for letting me know that these true 9 volt batteries are not the way to go UNLESS your device is unhappy with top voltage under 9 volts. Incidentally, while it sounds like a ripoff that they advertise "deceptive" capacity based on true battery voltage, the manufacturers of USB Power Banks often do the same thing. That's why people complain about true use capacity vs advertised capacity of these power banks. They're advertising the capacity of the cells Before the voltage gets boosted.

@exgenica Жыл бұрын

Some of these "true" 9V batteries with booster circuits do not like high current loads (like 1A). I've seen a couple that claimed a limit of something like 300mA if I recall correctly...which is still pretty hefty for typical uses of a 9V battery in this small "6LR61" form factor. I've also seen a number of these batteries CLAIM they retain 75%-80% of their stored capacity after a year on the shelf. So their circuits must consume considerably less than 100uA when not connected to anything external (or they are lying, or using some non-standard testing protocols to bump up that percentage).

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

Gotta put it to the test. Theoretically it's possible to put in an output circuit that can do 300mA and have a standby current around 10uA even. That would be a great 9V battery. =D

@NameyNames Жыл бұрын

@@BeatTheBushDIY Yeah, I bought a Pale Blue "true" 9V with booster circuit, and it's useless in high current loads. I'm using it in a mini vacuum designed to trap spiders and insects, and the fan rpm is noticeably lower than with an alkaline 9V, and it also lasts for a laughably short time before needing a recharge. But at least Pale Blue doesn't appear to lie about the capacity (at least not in the same way), since it's rated for a reasonable 500 mAh. It's proven to be VERY hard to find any tests or reviews that actually test high current loads on rechargeable 9V lithium batteries (especially those having voltage booster circuits), so it would be really great if you could do it! Also, many thanks for this video, it's the most thorough examination I've found so far!

@fredvankempen2177 5 ай бұрын

I have the TQTHL variants of this battery - same thing, of course.

@victorpiedra6742 Жыл бұрын

It looks pretty good, but that type of batteries with a voltage booster circuit cannot be monitored on the device in use to indicate the charge level or when it is getting low, that is, you cannot see at what point the charge of the battery 🔋 is, but at a certain point without prior notice the device will turn off when the battery charge has dropped to the point where the internal electronics cut off the operation of the internal voltage booster, for a toy or a device such as a multimeter yes I would use it, but not on something critical like a fire alarm or smoke detector

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

GOOD POINT! VERY good point. They almost need a warning on these 9V batteries for that.

@clintoncoker6 2 ай бұрын

That's true, but it's no different from a normal battery for normal people in practice. It's only different if you're a nerd like us and go around measuring all your battery voltages with a voltmeter :)

@jeanrossel19 4 ай бұрын

2:48 your image shows: 1300mAh / 0,137mA . Should be 1300mAh / 0,137 A. Then you get 9,489 hours, wich is a much more realistic operating time.

@BeatTheBushDIY 4 ай бұрын

That's just standby time on its own. It's not that bad.

@photoniccannon2117 2 ай бұрын

I'm not a huge fan of those lithium ion rechargeables because of this. They make sense for certain devices that chew through 9Vs like crazy, but often, 9Vs go into things that need to last a long time. These just aren't very useful for those kinds of devices because of the self discharge issues as well as general calendar aging for lithium batteries. Unfortunately, nobody really makes good NiMH rechargeables either. The highest capacity ones on the market are about 300mah, which is only about half that of a regular alkaline battery, and the ones that are explicitly marketed as low-self-discharge are usually only around 200mah. They're fine, but the capacity is a bit disappointing considering 9V batteries have about 4.5x the volume of a standard AAA battery, and it should be possible to build a 500-600mah 7-cell 9V battery based on the volume (assuming a similar energy density as a normal low-self-discharge AAA NiMH battery).

@edneyhelenedossantos1875 2 ай бұрын

nice video thank you

@mhnoni 6 ай бұрын

I bought one of these 9V 6900mAh, I wonder what is the true mAh of it. even if I divide it with 3.7 it still doesn't sound right. what kind of scam is this? I assume they measured it with 1.5v?

@NameyNames Жыл бұрын

AFAIK this battery would not be allowed to sell in the EU, because of intentionally misleading marking/marketing. And I noticed that it can't be found in any of the Amazon stores in the EU, so that may be why. 🙂

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

Buyer beware!

@wengfongcheah 2 ай бұрын

will it be safe for these types of battery to be use for a device in a car as i was thinking to get ont for my tol charging device. Sorry if i sound stupid here

@BeatTheBushDIY 2 ай бұрын

I doubt they test these in extreme temperatures.

@philgibe 7 ай бұрын

Very nice ! Please please a new video with this time good surprises and great 9v rechargeable you could then advise.

@BeatTheBushDIY 7 ай бұрын

I don't understand.

@meahnicholas7352 10 ай бұрын

which one would be the best to buy

@audiovideoes Ай бұрын

He is just preparing material about another product. Quite an interesting approach to analysis. However, from what you show it turns out all manufacturers are lying. On the casing should not be 1300mAh but 400mAh. The battery operates at 9V so the entire calculation should be done at that voltage. I have one battery from the tests disassembled checked it in the same way as an alternative to the rest.

@bretthermance8154 4 ай бұрын

I knew that the top MAH is not really so. But it still works.

@oldrichsibek2631 5 ай бұрын

Very usefull video. Could I please kindly ask you what is total weight of this battery named "9V 1300mAh" incl. skeleton? I bought from Ali "DAWEIKALA 9V 28000mAh" weighting in total 20 grams (incl. skeleton, i.e. not disassembled). Apparently the Li-ion cell itself must be there even smaller..

@BeatTheBushDIY 5 ай бұрын

This one is 27g for the entire battery with the plastic case. Hope that helps.

@MrM4Goo 21 күн бұрын

Wow

@johnnyverhoeven5378 11 ай бұрын

I tested the same from and other supplier and also came out at about 400mAh @ 9V

@paul.phillips 2 жыл бұрын

People expect 1300ma @9v. It's probably a 1300ma cell @4v. Somebody didn't do the conversion. I really wish they would state battery capacity in watt-hours..

@exgenica Жыл бұрын

SOME IDEAS ON THIS... They would likely just provide the Wh for 3.6 or 3.7V, e.g. 1.3Ah x 3.6V ~4.7Wh I'd start from there, take about 15% off for conversion losses yields ~4Wh. Thus as a LOOSE APPROXIMATION for 9V constant output voltage we see... mAh=4Wh/9V~440mAh. With lower conversion losses, they might get this higher to be able to claim nearly 500mAh as a 9V output. I've seen some other true "9V" batteries claim 500mAh...so perhaps this is on the right track. Then again, I'm not feeling well and am taking some pain meds so I may be thinking unclearly. EBL has a similar "9V" battery, Model 9V600 that they claim has 5400mWh. Looking at the model number, I wonder if the "600" represents 600mAh as a 9V output (even though at 15% conversion losses it calculates to just over 500mAh). Perhaps they have a really efficient converter...along with interesting test protocols. Again, depending on their testing protocols they can move that mAh number around a LOT.

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

At least for larger batteries they state the Wh. For these tiny ones, seems like there are not regulations.

@clintoncoker6 2 ай бұрын

@@BeatTheBushDIYEven for large USB power banks, they always state the capacity in mAh at 3.7v, even though you can never access the energy (without disassembly) at 3.7v, only at 5v or greater. Marketing marketing marketing.

@HasanSaclay 4 ай бұрын

Nice vid . I was wondering about the output noise and whether this kind of battery suitable to use with amplifier As it contains a boost converter

@BeatTheBushDIY 4 ай бұрын

I am sure you can measure some amount of spurious noise at the output, the question is how many dBs down and how many you need for your particular amplifier to be below the noise.

@glbernini0 Жыл бұрын

Is that battery several times better than a 250 rated version?

@thedanyesful Жыл бұрын

In the video on the Tenergy official channel, they claim to use 2 li-ion cells in their 9V battery and they say it's a nominal 7.4V, so apparently no boost converter involved.

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

No way they can output 7.4V in a 9V battery. It just wont work! I think when they say nominal, it means 'the batteries inside nominally is" 7.4V.

@thedanyesful Жыл бұрын

@@BeatTheBushDIY well... they do go on to say that some devices require a higher voltage and to use their 8.4V NiMH battery in those devices - so that kind of tracks.

@volodumurkalunyak4651 13 күн бұрын

@@BeatTheBushDIYno it DOES WORK. In fact no way should they call Alkaline cell a 1.5V cell. It goes below 1.4V at only 20% discharged. Wouldn't typical device designed for 6LR61 only work down to 80% energy remaining in such 6LR61?

@RaptorRotorHead Жыл бұрын

Wait till you discover the fake Ernie Ball Chinese strings

@vevenaneathna Жыл бұрын

ugh i hate these. the buck converter makes a 50 hertz garbage buzz that gets really bad at higher current draws so its useless for audio equipment/microphones. I also believe the poorly tuned oscilator voltage step thing messes with smoke detectors and even though it has capacity it will randomly wake u up at 2am with a fire alarm/low bat chirp. also, i presume because of how poorly tuned that buck converter is, it has a lot of loss of something like 15%. i dont think anyone has put one of these on a oscillaskope yet but im guessing it will look like a guangzhou sawtooth electrical grid frequency mismatch at 6pm on a monday

@eddiejr Жыл бұрын

great video, thanks for writing out the math, keep them coming !

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

Thank you!

@makestuffwork9205 8 ай бұрын

Any chance of seeing the 9v output voltage sag, if any, under load?

@BeatTheBushDIY 8 ай бұрын

Alkaline 9V sag a lot but I usually use these in low current products so didn't think about high loads.

@makestuffwork9205 8 ай бұрын

I meant the li-ions actually. I've found some don't keep up the full 9v or 1.5v on AA regulated properly under load and drop their voltage. An indication of the quality of the regulator circuit I guess.

@BeatTheBushDIY 8 ай бұрын

Good point. I think most times they don't design them for high drain situations. Works well for low drain stuff.

@SpiderMan-o4x 9 ай бұрын

4.837 wh Battery Output: "kwh or wh is correct power rating" (E x I = P) 9v (E) x 1.3 x 3.7 / 9 (I) = cancel the 9s and 1.3 x 3.7 = 4.837 wh (P) The electronic ckt onboard will maintain the 9v constant. The labe states 9v x 1.3ah false rating of 11.7 watts per hour. Note the battery of 3.7v @ 1.200 wh is the factor only, voltage is only the product of that with a loss. So fully charged is a joke due to 4.3 to 4.15 is minutes apart on any lipo or lion battery test if you ever did many tests I have. 550 alkaline to lion is okay. Maximum amperage rating should be included in sale. "9v 4.837wh 1.5amp(max amperage)" the output IC limits amperage usually by it's thermal internal ckt.

@RaptorRotorHead Жыл бұрын

You be way better off to get a 9-volt battery holder that holds two double a batteries and put in the lithium 14500 battery cell those batteries are about 1,000 Ma and your project will last a lot longer

@BeatTheBushDIY Жыл бұрын

The way you suggest might result in over discharging as there's no cell over discharge protection.

@RaptorRotorHead Жыл бұрын

@@BeatTheBushDIY not in that circuit that you're taking apart my friend you charges batteries up in a regular lithium charger and then their balance then you put them in the battery holder and it put that into your project now you have 8.4 volt battery

@TYGAMatt Жыл бұрын

Better off using a DC load and actually measuring at the 9V output. Then you'll get a real reading. Your maths doesn't include the efficiency of the boost converter which is not going to be anywhere near 100%.

@iammeobviously6815 10 ай бұрын

If im not wrong, that aint an ion, its a li polymer

@Timanator Жыл бұрын

So we are not so advanced in battery technology after all lol

@theChef1337 2 жыл бұрын

Rechargeable batteries: EXPOSED

@BeatTheBushDIY 2 жыл бұрын

I'm a bit miffed.

@theChef1337 2 жыл бұрын

@@BeatTheBushDIY perhaps the rating was affected by continuous operation? Did the temperature of the battery increase and possibly affect the output? Probably wouldn’t make enough of a difference at this scale although who knows I haven’t tested it myself. Just buy another battery and call it a day 😁

@BeatTheBush 2 жыл бұрын

@@theChef1337 The 100mA draw probably reduced the capacity and I might see 1350mAh if drawn at say 25mA. However, the 1350mAh is for the 3.7V and not 9V.