Maybelline Superstay Matte Ink Lip Color VS Sephora Cream Lip Stain || Best Red Liquid Lipstick?

[@beautywithemilie]

I want to swatch the new shades of the liquid lipsticks and lip crayons but I'm unable to get my hands on them in Canada. If someone can help, please let me know!

[@marianagh1939]

Try cleansing balm. It removes the lip stains quickly and with no harsh rubbing. You’ll love it! Very quick and easy! ( I use Clinique btw)

[@Silbusia]

I have stashed one unopened red Douglas' Mattissim matt lipstick, I would love to help and also add an amazing lip balm based on honey that is made in my country (Poland), but it might take a while because of corona.

[@plumpy_space_princess]

I live in the States. I can send them to you, if you'd like. You can dm me on Twitter @honeypie_smith :)

[@andreao5352]

I hope you mean for both sephora and maybelline as both these matte liquid formulas have new shades, especially red ones!

[@diniele.]

same. I am in Toronto and havent seen the new shades anywhere. I have asked Maybelline on IG and they send me this weird message that is available at drugstores but they are not so, I dont know.... I really love the new shades. Let me know, Emily if you find them please! TY

[@tanzinamanzur4514]

Definitely had a flashback, God I'm subscribed here for ages, last time you compared with the shade Pioneer.

[@CherryRussellTraffanstedt]

The Maybelline Superstay Ink lipsticks are my holy grail! I never have to babysit them. Dancer is my favorite shade, too. 👍 And I always use the Garnier micelles water in waterproof to remove it, and my waterproof eye makeup. Works like a champ!

[@johannak1983]

Yes, they're great and the most bullet proof ones out there but the Sephora formula is a bit better and more comfortable imo.

[@darkstraylily1477]

i used to use the Superstay ones, but then found Infallible. Feels slightly better and actually hangs on a tad better i find. Also drugstore. Though i would recommend wal mart because pricing.

[@SixtiesWoman]

Do these hold up with a gloss over them?

[@anaclarafranco1988]

@@SixtiesWoman Yes they do, but I suggest you apply just a little bit in the center and blend it with your finger

[@lr4429]

Maybelline matte ink all the way x

[@MayaMys]

This comparison was exactly what I was looking for, and then it made my heart so happy to see all that NK Jemisin on your bookshelf!

[@Ioanna_g_k]

Team Sephora cream lip stain! Love the formula, tons of shades including many nude and brown ones!

[@francesharmon1223]

i really miss you and your awesome make-up videos!!! i still use them as the basis for color and product choices. i truly appreciate all the time you took to make the videos

[@gracemedina1320]

Tell me why I wanted someone to do this video , the Sephora lip stain lipsticks are very good they last long and don’t feel drying , I’ve been wanting to try the maybelline lipsticks glad you did this video

[@tashaanne]

Actually because of you the Sephora Always Red is still my all time favorite red liquid lipstick!! I tried several other brands but imo nothing can achieve the same velvety look that the Sephora one gives!!

[@leonardkjellberg729]

Thank you SO much for doing this Emily (I love all your videos), as I was nearly going to purchased the "Always Red" but it was $10.00 more than the Dancer one. So now I'll just get 2 of Dancer. I can't believe how the color and texture are just about identical - fascinating! I have also purchased Shot Caller in the Maybelline which I LOVE so this will be just a little different. I'm a RED girl, what can I say LOL. Again thanks so much for all the amazing videos, I just love watching you do swatches as I'm lipstick crazy and am always on the lookout for something that lasts and lasts. Karen (from Auckland, New Zealand)

[@oxfordstyle5807]

I fell in love with the maybelline matte ink crayons because of your reviews 😊

[@marakiAr]

i love inks fronm maybelline, my favourite of all liquids , i have and sephora but i prefer 24 superstay. well done maybellineee

[@mengyu86]

I don't really like the Maybelline Superstay Matte Ink. I find them to be to heavy on the lips. I can feel it all day long, and for me they are quite uncomfortable. I prefer the Maybelline Superstay Matte crayons.

[@soooofiaa]

I had the same problem, but since I started applying the thinnest amount possible, they became my favourites!

[@nereanere6036]

For me it's the other way round, I find the crayons so drying compared to the liquid lipsticks.

[@suzy8109]

I love the crayons too

[@meganradford1522]

Same

[@NatalieYTFoster]

Two amazing formulas!! I believe I found your channel from one of your maybelline superstay videos.

[@lovelyerizen8130]

I have been looking for this like a mask proof lipstick vs my fave Sephora 01. Thank you!!! Please do Sephora 01 vs Maybelline Superstay Dauntless and Pioneer? 🥺

[@American1Dfan]

Nice video Emily! Looking forward to you swatching the five new shades for us! 😊 The new colors look so pretty! 😍

[@beautywithemilie]

Trying to get my hands on them!

[@American1Dfan]

@@beautywithemilie Awesome! 💜 Looking forward to watching it and thank you! ☺️

[@lisannenoordzij9814]

I bought the sephora one around 4 years ago based on your recommendation!!

[@agniolki]

The same :)

[@ksenija4695]

Hi Emily, I have a video suggestion/request. I would like to know what are the best hydrating and shiny lipsticks, both drugstore and high-end. Personally, since covid, I have been loving those formulas just around the house, they are a great way to moisturize your lips while giving them a little bit of colour also

[@anaclarafranco1988]

Great idea!

[@banhikanabose9849]

First of all you are looking freaking gorgeous and I reallllllyyyyy do agree with your review everytime🥰🥰Love from India🇮🇳🥰

[@fernandach3378]

The video I was looking for 😱, you have a new spanish-speaking follower ❤️😍

[@beautywithemilie]

What's your favorite liquid lipstick formula?

[@American1Dfan]

The Maybelline Superstay matte inks. 😊

[@hassaanah4988]

Maybelline

[@wildatheart84]

I have some from NABLA and Colourpop and I love them because they are really comfortable. Kat von D are way drier but they have many more shades.

[@isabellelaborderie1968]

Les Maybelline liquides sont les meilleurs! Et pourtant j'en ai testés. Mais ceux-là sont tout simplement indélébiles.

[@natasja8201]

I really like the Yves rocher ones! They are so comfortable. I like the maybelline ones but if I apply it a second time on one day it looks so ugly and dull for some reason

[@cobishome]

Omg YES!!!! I wanted to see this comparison like a week ago :)))

[@AnaTonksCarver]

Omg! I've been watching your book Channel but I'm so excited to see you post here too ❤️❤️❤️

[@glam_by_lydia8995]

Maybelline just came out with a new all red line. Plz swatch!! ❤❤

[@yap4808]

I was one that asked for this😋 i thought that Pionier would be a match to the 01 from sephora

[@samanthashore9627]

Ooh that sunset is stunning 😍

[@Clairemccord]

I bought the shade pioneer because of your video. You’re probably the only KZbinr I buy things because of.

[@hauliwant]

Yes! I've missed your half and half videos.

[@krisdiorsamontanez4838]

There is actually a remover for the superstay matte ink. It’s called the Superstay Eraser Lip Color Remover. It works great. I bet it’s good for other liquid lipsticks as well. Great comparison by the way. 😊

[@kimchichick]

Emily - does the Dancer shade dry down a little darker? you said it's a bit lighter and warmer than Always Red, but I think Dancer dried down a little darker and appears to have the same depth as Always Red in the video!

[@lisay.8911]

BABY OIL! Removes very easy with one cotton disc! Thx for video!

[@bad_egg000]

I've tried them both. I love them both.

[@MTaraV]

Ugh I am so sad because for me the Maybelline one has the type of formula that really is impossible for my lips. It’s so thick and drying for me (I even tried it with lipbalm underneath and it’s the same) and it always disappears on the inside of my lips leaving only like a thicker lipline behind. I have no idea if it’s my lips or what? I don’t even have to try hard to remove it at all. And I did try multiple ones so I definitely did not get a bad one

[@mixy8]

I have the same problem! It feels drying and uncomfortable, yet it doesn’t seem to dry down fully because it transfers, it crumbles off on the insides and leaves a line on the outsides. And my lips have peeled after every time I’ve worn them. I’m bummed because I’ve heard good things and I love the colour (Fighter) so I don’t get it.

[@MTaraV]

@@mixy8 I experience the exact same thing! My lips never peeled so much as they did with this product or with the Milani one that everybody lives but is literally powdered chalk on my lips😭 the only products that feel comfortable and are somewhat matte are the Maybelline vivid mattes, the NYX soft matte lip creams and the MAC powder kiss lipstick (my absolute favourite formula ever for a lipstick). But they are not longwearung or transfer-proof😓

[@Jacksoncinema]

It does come off

[@maddielc204]

Are you going to do a video after your get your invisalign off? I've been considering getting it and would love to know your thoughts! 😊

[@Silbusia]

I always use coconut oil to remove any makeup, then I normally wash my face. This way my skin is never dry or irritated - any makeup remover irritates my skin, I tested many. I waited for this video :) I love all red lipstick tests and I was always curious about comparison of these two :) I'd love to see tests of L'Oreal Color Riche Matte lipstick (I have Paris Cherry, beautiful rich red and long lasting) and Douglas' Mattissim mat lipstick (I have number 5, Libertine Smile, strong red that lasts whole day), because I'd love to have some comparison in the test. It's easier to decide whether I want to give a lipstick a try when I don't know what they are like next to the ones I know and love. And for some reason those two, L'Oreal Color Riche and Douglas' Mattissim, don't really have many thorough reviews like yours. So I would love if you made tests of them both or any of them in the future :) ❤

[@Silbusia]

P.S. I remember I subscribed to your channel because I accidentally found your video about red lips for Christmas and I loved it :)

[@TaylerGibson]

I got the Sephora lip stain in a Electric Ruby for the Taylor Swift concert! I need something that will last the concert! I’m so glad I made that choice! I also have the Maybelline super stay in a pink which I also love! Thank you for this!

[@jnl3564]

These are my favorite two formulas as well. The only problem I have is when they start to rub off a bit on my inner lips, it’s impossible to fix. If I add a second layer it all gets crumbly and flakes off. The only way is to remove and reapply. I eat a lot of soups and salads and it dissolves the lipstick in the middle. I have no solution.

[@anaclarafranco1988]

It happens the same to me, so I always carry a cream lipstick with similar shade to the matte ink for touch ups and works great for me

[@smilingtiles]

Same problem here … I’m experimenting with a lip stain that sticks to the inner lips. I have to reapply that though.

[@annarroyo7204]

I always look forward to your lipstick videos love them💯🥂

[@tyaarum7958]

Beautiful Emily as always ❤️

[@sara35ish]

Maybellene is my pick. Thanks to you. The sephora one for me is NOT transfer proof. The Maybellene lasts ALL DAY , is not dry and Dancer is a beautiful color.

[@haidyhatem4409]

U really don’t know how useful this video thank u, i purchased dancer thank u

[@samanthashore9627]

I have a few of the sephora ones from my trips to America. I love the smell of them

[@OsloTime]

O0oo, Emily! Thank you for the great comparison! Also, I noticed you have Circe in the background on your bookshelf. I just got that book, can't wait to read it while wearing the Maybelline red lipstick. 🥰

[@brittiny.charee]

I love the Maybelline ones! I was out of makeup remover once, didn't think of it...and let my 7yo do my makeup with a darker purple shade of that. I had to let it wear off over like 3 days lol

[@threewishes777]

I just subscribed because your video was great and you help me by reminding me to buy remove make up cleanser 😅

[@brokenangel956]

OmG ur liner is on point. Just love it...♥️♥️

[@Chiara0608]

I tried both of them and in my opinion no lipsticks are as good and lasting as the Maybelline ones.

[@albapinillaperez5051]

Which foundation and eyeliner are you wearing? They look amazing! ❤️❤️❤️

[@beautywithemilie]

Thank you! The stila eyeliner (bit.ly/3ey3TIs) and the Lancome foundation (bit.ly/3kyNCUO) ❤️

[@albapinillaperez5051]

@@beautywithemilie thank you Emily! 😊 Also, do you notice any difference between Maybelline Superstay Matte Ink and L'Oreal Ultra Matte Liquid lipstick formulas? Thanks in advance ❤️

[@20-NYC]

I love Maybelline ink SUPERSTAY love how they aren’t too drying especially when u first apply them. Later on they get a bit dry but at least they last longer then most liquid n look less drying then then them too

[@ivoryandgold88]

I recommend Always Red to my stepmom to wear on her honeymoon with my dad bc she wanted a Mac Retro Matte liquid that a makeup artist used on her wedding day but the Mac counter was closed and we could only find a Sephora. I was shocked to hear she didn't like the color. ☹️ She liked the formula but said Always Red wasn't the right shade. I think her wedding day red was Feels So Grand by Mac.

[@arpanayadav7785]

Ruby woo is cult favourite mac among retro Matt it's absolutely gorgeous red probably the best red ever..u shoul suggest her to buy one ruby woo you can buy it online also

[@mochabomb]

Once d world is covid free completely, one of d most exciting things I wana wear is lipstick again. But who am I kidding? I still wear liquid lipstick under my mask! 😁 Love u Emily! ❤💋

[@beatrizsandoval4395]

I’m with you. I personally hardly ever wear lipstick under the mask but I can’t wait to wear it once we don’t have to wear masks.

[@mykesorange]

You look so pretty today! Love the curtain bangs on you!

[@thesavage6442]

the video I wanted to see, you are fantastic you read our mind

[@emmaphilo4049]

Such fun videos 👍👍👍 I wanted some of the Coffee collection because they are quite a good fit for my complexion unfortunately I can't seem to find them anywhere where I live (France).

[@arpanayadav7785]

Maybelline has recently launched beautiful coffee collection all of them are really beautiful u can definitely get ur hands on them you will love them

[@dreamof_me]

Yay I finally got a notification! An hour late but I’ll take it!

[@dreamie9868]

Does anyone else get extremely nervous before applying the matte ink?

[@Βασιλική-ΝικολέτταΣακελλάρη]

Emily could you please review thrill seeker from Maybelline? I literally only kept the Maybelline ones because i loveeeee the staying power and the "glossy effect" they have ❤️. And i really want the Maybelline black but i have seen bad reviews on it 🤔 Also i live in Greece so getting it will be expensive for me.

[@purpleir]

Μπορει να το φέρουν κι εδώ ποτε δεν ξέρεις! Είναι limited edition σωστα? Αν κ η εμπειρία μου λέει τα μαύρα κραγιόν από τις μάρκες ευρείας έχουν συνήθως θεματακια.

[@Mystearicia]

Copper Blush from Sephora collection is my all time favorite

[@pjnkblue]

I bought a red shade of the Maybelline for a long outdoor wedding but somehow I can’t make it work. With thin amount it comes up uneven, thicker amount feels sticky and heavy. When I tried to fix the outline it doesn’t come off the way normal liquid lipstick does but more like literal ink. I still like the Maybelline line though, just not this one. Maybe I will try the Sephora next time.

[@samsam3845]

Apply it with a brush

[@pjnkblue]

@@samsam3845 thank you i will try ;))

[@miralolar6069]

I pretty much gave up on wearing lipproducts :( wearing a mask basically at all times is mandatory where I live

[@deja1366]

Could you do Lime Crime and Sugarpill? Thank you!!💖💖

[@auralside]

How do each smell? That’s the tie breaker in my book. Frustrated finding a new lip product only to be turned off by the scent it gives off - perfume, powder, plastic etc…

[@kierstencarey]

You are adorable. And I find your eyeliner distracting. Because it's awesome!

[@purpleir]

I get along with the sephora ones way better. The Maybelline ones stay sticky on my lips no matter how much time has passed and I always use a tiny amount because my lips are on the small side. Still... Here, the sephora ones I think are a couple of euros cheaper too. And I also didn't get along with the scent of the Maybellines. And I was sooo excited to try them back when they came out.☹ I have already decluttered them.

[@beautywithemilie]

Have you tried their lip pencils? They last a similar amount of time and no stickiness!

[@purpleir]

@@beautywithemilie no I haven't tried them yet! Are they drier than a liquid lipstick? Thank you Emily for pointing that out to me! Trying them is actually a very good idea! I guess they must be easier to reapply as well?

[@beautywithemilie]

They don't feel dry at all and definitely easy to reapply!

[@purpleir]

@@beautywithemilie Great! Then they are going on my shopping list to try next 😉👍! Thank you Emily 🌷

[@marielabarajas1476]

I have both and I love both 🥰

[@haded3000]

Please recommend more face mask proof lipsticks if you can 🙏

[@MLD.Ltd.]

Interesting... I will go pick up Dancer for starter because I’ve been looking for a dupe that won’t move when wearing masks, which the Sephora DID TRANSFER on me. I don’t know why it didn’t move at all thru drinks and food. And I fear for the worst on the Maybeline I don’t know why or how but IT DOES NOT MOVE at all, lasts me thru a full bowl of pho noodles. Just saying if they have that kinda of lasting power thru oils, why isn’t anyone else doing it?

[@samanthashore9627]

I've recently bought a Maybelline one. Will be interesting to see if it lasts on me. I hsve really thin lips, so lipsticks don't last 5 minutes on me

[@zoezzzarko1117]

How did you like it?

[@shoesuite]

Still georgeous

[@karenjimenez9804]

I bought 13 Shades from the Sephora colección and I love it. But after 3 years expired 😢 now I bought maybelline only 6 color with coupons on cvs I pay like $5 each

[@nohemis3856]

I love it😍❤ saludos desde México🍃

[@beautywithemilie]

❤️

[@Lily-g6o1i]

Thanks for sharing ❤️. Love from India ❤️

[@trixb.f3051]

The maybelline one is very drying on my lips. Will be trying the sephora one!

[@zoezzzarko1117]

How did you like it?

[@allysonadame1841]

Thank you for this video. I like the Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink but want sure what I was doing wrong as it is sticky sometimes. Now I know what to do. Maybe I'll try Sephora.

[@priscillablount6862]

Pretty colors. I want to try the Sephora

[@donnafrangona7590]

I have number 20 in Pioneer. I ate powder sugar donuts and coffee and it wore off😊

[@Skettymaker]

That Sephora lipstick is my favorite of all time.

[@MM-uw5tt]

I've been looking for Long Lasting Red Lipsticks ever since I've discovered makeup. It was my one and only goal. I've watched countless videos for years. Updated myself every now and then. I wanted to find my holy grail item. I've tested, tried and found... Maybelline Superstay. I am an absolute fan of it. I can go partying, on a date, travel. It's something I wear during Christmas every year. Literally anything and it won't come off. I'm a sucker for hard to remove makeup so I also own solely waterproof mascara. I love when people ask me about my lipstick when after 10 hours it looks just as good as when I put it on, mind you I touch up every now and then. It's impossible not to. But it's just so nice to finally own a reliable item that I can stick to. I am thinking of stocking up on my favourite shades since honestly this is the only lipstick I ever want to use from now on. Never have I ever owned a dark and red shade so pigmented too. Their burgundy shade (sorry for forgetting the name) isn't patchy, thank god. I'm biased but when you have small lips that rub on eachother - you know how tear inducing it can be to finally find something that doesn't rub off. Anyway, love it but you made me interested in trying the Sephora one too! Who knows, maybe I'll like both.

[@jesmine_597]

What is Maybelline lip shade name?

[@magdaloeralopez5484]

118 dancer

[@user-my8qj]

You're so beautiful and u have a really nice teeth🤩u rock red lips🔥

[@nibeditabairagi6619]

I love sephora one.You are very gorgeous.👍👍👍

[@lr4429]

Maybelline matte ink all the way xx

[@stephanietorres5679]

The superstay has a special remover just for that maybelline.

[@neongarden8974]

to me they are both the same and very pretty

[@PersianPowergirl]

A makeup remover balm gets it off in one swipe. Put it on, leave it for 10 secs and just swipe it off. No need to rub our delicate lips ever. 🤫

[@beautywithemilie]

I tend to use cleansing balm or oil to remove my makeup but during lip swatches (or to show in these videos!) garnier works well :)

[@athena263]

My maybelline one with pioneer color never dries out. It sucks. My lips stuck each other ugh:(

[@valeriatello3612]

You have to put the minimal amount of lipstick in your lips, it works!

[@briesullivan883]

I wish she did this with cheeseburgers from a drive through or frozen pizza.

[@stephaniestanley8041]

Very unusual eyeliner.😮

[@RMMFamily-zx7iq]

Maybalin is amazing formula

[@fadiacohen3784]

Im really still confused between red maybelline pioneer and red maybelline heorine 🤦🏻‍♀️ what can i choose

[@IxziRose]

Pioneer is a blue-based red. Heroine is more orange toned. I have a pink undertone, so I prefer Pioneer. I hope that helps.

[@fadiacohen3784]

@@IxziRose thank you dear 😊 i think you’re right because i need a real red 💄 i hate orangish red so I will choose pioneer .

[@IxziRose]

@@fadiacohen3784 I'm glad I could help. 🙂

[@Mikuchan018]

You really look cuter and prettier now ❤️

[@nanaashraf6270]

I’m early ❤️❤️💋

[@kalliopiskiathiti9683]

Its expensive shephora;;;;; always red is orange red???

[@melissamutesi859]

Lovely

[@SaucerJess]

❤️❤️❤️

[@Mikmaqdrag]

After Covid I don’t love lipstick as much so sad lol

[@sigh_anna]

No CC 😕

[@brokenangel956]

OmG u r so prettyyyy... Ur teeth are so white... What u have done with ur teeth ??. Red lipstick attracted more when ur teeth are beautiful...

[@rebeccawhite2582]

You really do not need to wear a mask when out doors, and not close to others.

[@nereanere6036]

Are you from Canada like her? Because in my country is compulsory to wear a mask wherever you are no Matter how close to other people.

[@lhalaa]

I’m curious to know how Sephora performs compared to Fenty Beauty stunna lip paint. I think these 2 are always compared a lot. I might give Maybelline another shot. I owned poet and ended up throwing it, just so sticky and uncomfortable. Edit: i just found your video 😅 for fenty vs sephora 2 years ago

[@beautywithemilie]

I was about to link it haha (Just in case someone else is curious! kzbin.info/www/bejne/iqqTdK2jr9WWppY)

[@lhalaa]

@@beautywithemilie just want to thank you for making these videos. I have literally fenty on my cart when I saw this vid and went back to your fenty sephora comparison and now I replaced my fenty with the sephora. I have both brands in diff shades, and i wanted to get a red one and looks like Sephora is the winner. Thank you so much! 😘

[@threewishes777]

2024 Feb 6 I just got sephora one