Netizens COMPARE Kpop Idols For Skills & Ability

[@BeBossTV]

But have you guys listened to Rosé's voice in GD's Without You? I really prefer her deep voice there 🥲

[@heifnsn8199]

yes

[@sherlyxavier7489]

She's the GOLDEN VOICE OF KOREA for a reason

[@armyblinkforever4424]

Obviously she is a queen

[@Weirdahh_hooman]

She’s awesome

[@lilyceline8355]

I love Rosé's voice, and she is one of my biases, and her voice is heavenly, However, I listened to her in G-Dragon's song, her voice was HEAVENLY I love it so much.

[@joyou]

I prefer rose's voice cause even though it can be nasal it suites Blackpink's songs and sounds good to me plus her singing just coveys so many emotions like her part in kill this love and lovesick girls is something no one can mimic according to me. ningning's voice is also powerful and verstile and her breath control is amazing. both of them are amazing in their own way

[@nisargarao8524]

Rosé brings out a unique flavour to the songs she sings

[@catnus]

she has a western indie style of singing and it’s gorgeous. one of my favorite voices ever, even with western acts. she sounds so emotional and so unique-it’s stunning.

[@Lovelynigga1]

Yeah but she doesn’t suit every song which is kinda a main topic in being main vocal so I prefer Ningning who suits every voca iCloud but I respect you opinion

[@ivymagno89]

Yes. I respect your opinion. She can convey emotions and has a unique voice, but I think they are talking about the technicality here and Ning is way better when it comes with technique.

[@aaliyah9090]

Any American singer can mimic. It really isn’t that hard lol.

[@kmj013]

Winter was scouted by SM for her dance in the first place, and only started training as a vocalist after she got into SM, she used to be in a dance group and her movements are so fluid and her synchronisation with the beat is always on point which makes watching her performances so addictive, that's why many people prefer to watch her solo fancams more

[@nandid.3733]

Her visuals play a major role tho….Winters fancam weren’t viral for looking gorgeous or for looking cute in the thumbnail

[@SK-sk2lh]

@@nandid.3733 oh then people must have found Winter's visuals much more attractive than the others because the last time i checked she got the most views for every song and the difference is not small

[@mmmh1552]

not trynna be rude, but can't believe she was cast because of dancing. Her stage presence is not it, not worst...it isn't proportional to how her fans overhype it. I don't think the fancam is famous because of her performance, it was because of that cutesy charm...(ngl... she is cute). but looks only cant pay it off. she is a nice performer, but Karina has great facial expression and skills too, so she executes it nicely. But winter lacks facials but has some nice dance skills( sharpness and elegance) tbh, she is talented, and *CAN* be more, that's why people are hesitating about her cause she has the possibility-ability oh crap..long message

[@huo3414]

@@mmmh1552 First dance and stage presence are very different and It's funny how people have their own knowledge about something as subjective stage presence Stage presence is just the ability to catch the attention of audience(in this case non-fans) and each person have their own preference about it so based on the attention winter gets from non-fans i think she is doing quite well And by your logic what use is stage presence if it can't make people watch your performance because if you look at aespa, Winter is the most popular among Korean gp and non-kpop fans so people like to watch her performance rather than the group's that's why in some cases her fancams outview the group performance

[@imamultistan7779]

@@mmmh1552 agree

[@candylover7460]

Yujin is obviously the ACE. When she was a IZ*ONE member ,there're 12 members and so each member gets the limited chance to show off their skills. But now she's a IVE member , it's clear she has improved her skills and I know her talent is not a joke since pd48. If u watch her fancams, you can see her passion through her performance. She always try to improve her skill better and better. Visual ? She has the actress vibe. Her smile is warm and sweet. She is like a bestfriend for everyone.❤️

[@aloraaroura2967]

Yeah but hateing wonyoung bcuz maybe yujin is better is wrong. And for you maybe yujin is beyter but I like wonyoung more anyway.

[@girlgroupkpop4161]

@@aloraaroura2967 lmao he/she didnt even mentioned wonyoung!! Wonyoung fans are so toxic

[@aloraaroura2967]

@@girlgroupkpop4161 yah you'll say that, but the video is obviously comparing them so I just wanted to say that many yujin fans hate wonyoung so just make sure you dont hate wonyoung bcuz you like her. And we're not toxic, wonyoung is just hated alot and I mean *ALOT* so just don't compare them and say one is better than the other. And stating my opinion is not toxic.

[@girlgroupkpop4161]

@@aloraaroura2967 Lmao you can scroll down the comments and see many toxic WONYOUNG fans throws hates on YUJIN

[@aloraaroura2967]

@@girlgroupkpop4161 yah but it isn't as much as wonyoung's. And you can really find reddit posts about "reasons to hate wonyoung"

[@busybody5381]

I agree with Winter precision and details, but Karina dance with style as for me, it is seen more interesting and commercial. Like comparing people who learn through dance classes strictly those who dance through the streets or self-learning, both have their own merits. One of the thing that Karina dances more stylish is because her presence and expression compared to Winter. Winter execute the movement well and clear, and Karina execute the movement' flavor well. Both still are great idols nevertheless.

[@minarin3428]

Winter is just way more developed in dancing (specifically in popping). I feel like Winter should've been the main dancer, while karina should've been the visual member.

[@Jia20046]

@@minarin3428 Karina is the visual ....are you blind it's obvious Karina is the prettiest

[@minarin3428]

@@Jia20046 Both of them are really pretty. but if you check, Winter has the official position for visual. A lot of people seem to like Karina's visuals more tho, which I can see why.

[@SK-sk2lh]

@@Jia20046 We know who's visuals people like more based on their social media likes and fancam views, Winter>>>>

[@busybody5381]

@@minarin3428 yes, winter is more develop in terms of technique, and how she makes her dance works

[@earthshuman3864]

As long as competitive level and comparison is healthy It's good for idols to improve more

[@muza2137]

Y'all sleeping on Ahn Yujin and I don't understand why. This girl is talented af.

[@Mr360attack]

Exactly. I hate how popular wonyoung is. So undeserved

[@chissea8025]

they are literally best friends whats the point of tearing one to praise the other? and yujin is not the underrated girl that you think she is literally everyone knows her in korea

[@jay4a]

@@chissea8025 where did they even mention another member

[@billliealim]

@@chissea8025 not y’all wy stans being triggered about praising yj even if they they never said anything bad about your girlie

[@chissea8025]

@@billliealim i was probably replying to the other reply but forgot to tag them :/ i love annyeongz

[@liu5461]

ningning is so talented, she'll be remembered as one of the best i'm sure

[@paoolmedo588]

ROSÉ NOT ONLY SING BUT TELLS A STORY EVERY TIME SHE SINGS 💗

[@wangjayujin6080]

The way that I even ult Yujin I mean she's everything you want an idol to be.

[@koog008]

facts

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

Completely agree

[@miow3597]

I personally feel like you cannot compare Jin and Jungkook. Their voice are so different in style and techique . Both are amazing in their own way

[@blink-my2955]

Winters dancing is literally my favourite along with Lisa’s it feels natural and without strain how she moves her body according to the beat and the best part is that she can keep improving

[@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965]

I luv her popping style

[@IZONEOT20]

That's why I hate comparing people sometimes it can make fans argue which whose best, can we just said that there both good

[@sharvaripradhan258]

people shouldn't be comparing idols nowadays things get too toxic

[@girlgroupkpop4161]

TALENTS WISE+ VISUAL+ ACE= IVE YUJIN Wonyoung is good too but I love Yujin more

[@nuts8395]

Same here

[@joemama0096]

New ACE kpop girl

[@lavienrosewon8811]

Yes wonyoung is improved in vocal but her dance skill is well okay ,she did the steps of eleven well .you re forget she was leader dancer in izone n center for reasons (she was ballet dancer in past) You act like if wonyoung isn't overworked when she is overworked person n one hard worker She is highschooler ,mc gig add ambassador of brands. You cant denied she is top idol now Add she was songwriter tho show off she wish being credited in world music

[@nuts8395]

@@lavienrosewon8811 People are the problem we're facing in the kpop community🙄 Op said she's good but prefers yujin When will y'all stop being like this protecting someone that doesn't need protection from you in fact she should be protected from people like you who are blind from the truth "She's a teenager" They're many teengage celebrities 🙄🙄🙄 she's tired yea you must know her so well since you live in the same room as her🙄

[@nuts8395]

@@lavienrosewon8811 yea she's a better vocalist now but I've not seen any major improvement that should be called and improvement You know the truth why not embrace it instead of argue and back her up and make people like me mad🙄

[@ryujinner4785]

I don’t think anybody should be comparing idols. It can be really toxic and obnoxious.

[@dorte3791]

Exactly you ever know if an idol would have seen it

[@gggg-sk7pc]

Just comparing objectively without being rude isn't bad. Youre just soft

[@gggg-sk7pc]

@@dorte3791 you think idols arent already compared since trainee days??? This video would be nothing to them

[@dorte3791]

@@gggg-sk7pc idols get way too compared ITS NOT OKAY even if it’s normal for them it will give them deeep depressing felling they will never be good enough when you debut I should be over

[@hnyuq4049]

@@gggg-sk7pc videos like these appeal to toxic immature fans who will compare idols and then pick their bias as the better idol. blonks especially will attack which makes every normal person’s head hurtttt

[@mulo8174]

Ahn yujin is going to be the next thing..she got the x factor

[@lisasbangsofficial4934]

I agree that Winter's Dancing is Best Her control is also amazing for starting 2 months of stanning aespa I believed Winter is Main Dancer I love Karina she is a amazing Dancer But Winter always catches my attention **Thnx For The Likes I didn't expected**

[@k-poppersince0951]

Very true

[@koog008]

yujin is just sooooo stunning. she stands out soo much when she performs. like shes the total package. shes THE ACE

[@antaraks2007]

No matter what people say about rose 's singing , dancing, stage presence. No body can deny her impact. Yes her voice sometimes may sound nasaly but I still prefer her singing as it just convey the emotions so well, which I think is the main reason for the existence of songs. (No offence to Ning Ning , i was just putting forth my opinion

[@dorte3791]

Exactly people shouldn’t even compare to two different people

[@shravanip9444]

I am not even a blink, i am a once. But i love love love Rosè's voice. I can listen to her singing all day.

[@pynkydoggykaguraminadessss6154]

I prefer ning ning cause her very unique conpareed to other singers!

[@moshimochi2784]

Right its really about conveying the emotions and not just singing impressively.

[@kpop4ever775]

true and Rose was trying new vocal

[@theo_bldm]

yujin’s visuals, stage presence and charisma are literally out of this world

[@lbell9695]

1. Is this even a debate - Yujin obviously. Shas has that charisma and is able to express the meaning of the songs. Wonyoung's stage presence is a little bit superficial as it doesn't dive deep into the message and as a result she lacks in versatility. 2. When it comes to technique, Ningning is indeed better (I'm in love with her vibrato and resonance), but don't underestimate Rosé, she's actually pretty good and is improving day by day. Rosé is now consistently supporting her Bb4's, something she was lacking prior. One thing I would like to say is that technique isn't the sole factor that makes a good singer, every person trained in vocals knows this. Rosé's artistry is off the charts and embodies what an artist really is, and I think that's why all the vocal trainers praise her, along with her unique voice. 3. I think at this point, I will say Jungkook, but Jin in his comfortable mid-range beats everyone else. If Jin continues improving at the rate he's going, he's likely to take over. 4. The gap between all Aespa's members in dancing isn't that big, but at this point Karina edges Winter by a little bit. Winter's really good with isolations, popping and basically hip-pop catered dancing which is Aespa's choreographies so it's no wonder she's standing out. But Karina is really good with adding flavour to the movements, I just adore those head tilts of hers, and she's good with her arms. She has a little bit of a weight-bearing problem and once she's fixed that shifting force in her other leg, she would be really good. Karina's improved a lot too so I think that's commendable.

[@lavienrosewon8811]

Eleven isn't on agressive expression but on fall on love

[@bebexjeans]

Many people compare beauty with stage presence, Wonyoung is pretty but still Yujins face expression is way stronger and more attractive

[@MrWapakelz11]

ahn yujin for me she the best at overall skills

[@onceyouwheeinyoucantwheeout]

Wonyoung is cute but Yujin is the whole package aka an ace! She’s got the skills of a main dancer, main vocalist, visual, amazing leader and I can see her being a potential actress in the future!

[@jiminstolejennieschaneland7834]

Rosie have an angelic voice ❤️✨

[@kpopthetic3702]

She had lost it

[@klopkerna3562]

@@kpopthetic3702 nope

[@kpopthetic3702]

@@klopkerna3562 yes

[@sakura._.]

@@kpopthetic3702 lol look who's talking

[@kpopthetic3702]

@@sakura._. You're pressed. Accept that

[@SpaceRei04]

Both Yujin and wonyoung are awesome but I feel like Yujin charisma grown so much in IVE and she can adapt into different situation of the song but I love both of them and every member of IVE 😭😭

[@badbeachishere]

Though Rosé's voice is nasal sounding it creates a unique sound which makes her voice easily recognizable.

[@vim2339]

Rosa voice is amazing and Ningning voice is amazing.

[@heystahbit7328]

And when you combine Jin’s and Jungkook’s vocal together, IT IS HEAVEN. Like the silver crystal come to join hand with the golden honey to melt your ears and your heart. 💜

[@HASCHWALTH-nh7jv]

I'm agree with winter vs karina because in every performance winter really stand out when in comes to dancing tbh

[@achmadhuda_11]

Yujin is expression genius IMO

[@yoonyoon05]

I stan both Yujin and Wonyoung since produce 48 to IVE. I agree Yujin is way more talented in all aspects. (Not hate) Anyway love them as a WIZ*ONE and DIVE.

[@lavienrosewon8811]

Songwriter wonyoung

[@firstlast4572]

I agreeeee as a wony stan! Wonyoung is more of a center/visual idol & socialite songwriter! An Yujin is what I consider to be more of an idol/singer & performer! Yujin can rap pretty well and is very versatile in many concepts (cute, girl crush, elegant, youthful, etc). Wonyoung so far has only been able to pull off some concepts, which isn’t bad because she still has lots of time to improve her versatility!!

[@moonlightespt3818]

I think wonyoung is better than her in stage presence plus she seems to be more well rounded cause not only she's involved in music industry but also in media/fashion business professionally.

[@JezelAnneLlantero]

@@moonlightespt3818 We're talking about talents which is obviously wonyong hasn't. Don't bring up fashion just to bring up your fave.

[@lavienrosewon8811]

@@JezelAnneLlantero after wonyoung know playing violion piano flute She was ballet dancer in past Obvious you re jealous of her

[@andrewwong6899]

Karina's dancing skills is trully seen in step back , she was totally on par with the legendary boa and shouldnt be taken lightly , Karina hwaiting

[@klopkerna3562]

Karina is a good dancer but she's not on par with Boa

[@tnlkb6115]

@@klopkerna3562 the op was talking about step back dance. And i agree. If you watch the dance practice, most of the time, Karina would overshadow Boa and Seulgi and kept up with Hyoyeon. The choregraphy fit her better for some reason. But the three of them are definitly WAY better dancer than Karina is and probably will be in the futur.

[@klopkerna3562]

@@tnlkb6115 we agree for most parts then 😉

[@sndrprk3234]

Yes! Karina's dance skills in Step Back really shined. In some steps, I prefer her over queen BoA.

[@andrewwong6899]

@@sndrprk3234 her footwork is just *chefs kiss*

[@swingoops9432]

sigh the society we're living.. people hate it when they got compared to other people, but still love to compare others. In the other side, giving critics directly without comparing in purpose to give feedback so that person will be improved...nowadays sometimes it seen as "opinion that should've keep by ourself" or "hateful comments hidden behind critics"... confusing 😅

[@seoautumn]

exactly, wheres the lie here

[@chtrne__]

nignings good, but rose unique and I'd like to hear her voice again and again

[@riez45]

Rosé can change her to deep to soft, in bp Coachella performance you can see that she sings with her deep voice and not only Coachella but many other performances (no hate to ningning, i’m both mys & blink and i’m ningning biased)

[@kpopthetic3702]

Yes but nining got a way more strong voice

[@riez45]

@@kpopthetic3702 yeah she sings like a goddess id understand why sme not let them sing live 😭

[@kpopthetic3702]

@@riez45 ikr. But remember when Nining sang If I Ain't Got You, everyone was just blown-up by her powerful vocal

[@riez45]

@@kpopthetic3702 yeah her vocals are more powerful Compare to the other member,

[@kpopthetic3702]

@@riez45 yes

[@minustephen4101]

IVE Yujin is my favorite when it comes to expression

[@chinny1923]

Every kpop idol is hard working so let appreciate their hard work! 😊👍

[@imamultistan7779]

But not every 😅

[@chinny1923]

@@imamultistan7779 yes but some

[@AmericanGBoyDiego]

wonyoung being more popular than yujin shows how visuals are the most important thing. even though beauty is subjective and to me yujin is prettier too, objectively you can't deny that yujin is better than wonyoung in every area.

[@ericjiayu7408]

it's not subjective that yujin is also pretty, during p48 she was a visual with huge impact, korea also loves her. the yj vs wy battle is based more in pure popularity than skills or visual

[@lavienrosewon8811]

I think cause wonyoung is most attractive stand out without trying. Wonyoung is songwriter in izone ,she was leader dancer n fit elegant concepts. She isn't look typical korean I think she will shine in ive come-back in april im sure. She was leader dancer n will show full potentiel as confidence member it girl

[@lavienrosewon8811]

@@ysaquela after wonyoung is taiwanese and korean Liz n yujin re full korean ...

[@lavienrosewon8811]

@@ysaquela in my opinion Liz look like yoon Yujin look exy wjsn Wonyoung look actress jin hyun

[@user-vy6li9kf7r]

@@ysaquela damn you need to chill out, their just expressing their opinion no need to right a whole ass essay💀💀

[@cherries44]

Rose’s voice is more unique. When she sings you know it’s her. Technique can be learned. I appreciate her voice everytime.

[@aliyyahbalogun2686]

This means absolutely nothing because everyone has a unique voice meaning no one in the world sounds like you.Having skill in vocals is far more difficult than having a unique vocal.

[@kpopthetic3702]

@@aliyyahbalogun2686 ikr

[@10000years]

Unique bs. You either hv better technique in controling pitch & range or you dont. YGE focus on instagram brand deal

[@shrestha7224]

@@10000years hshshs

[@PriyanshuKumar-ez6qi]

@@10000years well those brand deals is the reason why they will have successfull career even after their disbandment .... Unlike many artists who just get disappear..... I don't know but seems like you guys don't even know that modelling is not a an easy thing to do and if you can't respect their work and respect fully keep quite please.......

[@narenbarrette9687]

Why are kpop fans so competitive in evrything with idols so much like just let them be talented in peace.

[@seoautumn]

ikr people be treating them like a game characters or pokemons to compare about skins to skills

[@narenbarrette9687]

@@seoautumn yh

[@suyeesia7770]

@@seoautumn yes

[@alisonjoseph450]

Ikr

[@love.nicholegrace]

Both Wonyoung and Yujin have amazing stage presence but Yujin is more versatile and she adapts to different concepts, Wonyoung suited izones concept imo. Now.... Rose and Ningning.. both are really good vocalists but ngl Ningning has better vocal technique than Rose. because rose often strains her voice. But rose has a very unique vocal color! Karina and Winter have DIFFERENT dancing styles, Winter focuses more on being detailed and powerful but i personally think she's focusing more on the dance than her facial expressions nor stage presence, Now karina is more of a flowy dancer, she has a graceful style. but her stage presence is better than winter imo. These are just my opinions so please don't take them offensively :)

[@mehermalik8869]

The golden voice's of K-pop Jin and Jungkook✨

[@acelex1630]

yes!! im agree.. ive yujin is much more charismatic and have more stage presence than wonyoung. wonyoung is just playing cute while dancing she is so tiring to look at. but their agency gave all the spotlight to her. in case of winter and karina. i also agree,, karina is not a smooth dancer,, her movements are so stiff

[@pheonix9929]

I think in Jin vs Jungkook.... They both are skilled in their own ways, Jin is known for his high notes whereas Jungkook for his stable and powerful vocals.... But overall Jungkook is better when it comes to live performances with choreo because he can maintain stable vocals even with choreo despite having more lines but Jin can maintain his stability mostly in songs with less choreo despite having less lines...Jungkook can even sing Jin's solo songs easily and we have seen that many times So overall Jin has an amazing voice for high notes and emotional songs whereas Jungkook is a powerful vocalist.... So comparing them is a bit weird

[@sentikalalongkumer2457]

Woonyoung only one expression I actually agree with that..her pretty face saves her alot

[@gladyshazelvalles7482]

Love queen Rosé gorgeous voice

[@kpopthetic3702]

She had it, but not now

[@soyaahh_luvies3148]

@@kpopthetic3702 are a vocal coach in each comment I always see you commenting against rosé jealousy btw rosé is more successful than you and your faves

[@kpopthetic3702]

@@soyaahh_luvies3148 lmao- more successful? Lol- your rosè doesnt even come near by IU and WENDY when it comes to Vocal 😂🖕🏻

[@sgaf7001]

Wonyoung used to have a stronger stage presence in IZ*ONE than Yujin. However, Yujin in IVE has better stage presence now.

[@yk_zyk]

because izone and ive has different concepts, that's why wy shines more in izone since izones theme is elegant and cutesy while yujin shines more in ive

[@Marte0107]

It’s a preference thing in the end. Wonyoung is clearly more focused on being a pretty idol while Yujin is more of a performer. I prefer the latter. It genuinely frustrated me for a moment watching Wonyoung & Sunghoon’s MC ‘Butter’ stage by the sheer lack of.... a performance (idk) Wonyoung gave, particularly in the chorus. But I only saw love for it because it was a visually appealing stage (visuals, bright colours, well styled) I like i idols who are better performers and give energy/ great dancing (Wendy, Tsuki, Chaeyeon) but some some people prefer a prettier performance which is fine! We all have our preferences so while Yujin can appeal to one group Wonyoung can appeal to others.

[@bareeraasad4718]

HONESTLY I LOVE NINGNIN AND PREFER HER MORE THAN ROSE (I AM BLINK AND MY BOTH) AND I LOVE JIN VOCALS MORE THAN JK

[@aura4773]

There is another comparison done the most : winter and karina in visual position

[@kmj013]

and Winter clears all

[@aura4773]

@@kmj013 it's karina for so many ppl

[@kmj013]

But it's still Winter though based on social media engagements and fancams🤷

[@usri43]

@@kmj013 dont bring that clickbait-y fancam here. Everybody knows why it went viral. She lacked in charisma and dancing. But it got 10m views because of her expression. She has at least a 1000 plastic surgeries. So no. Karina for me in both dance and visual.

[@kmj013]

@@usri43 are you triggered lol? She also has most views for all their songs , seems it's pretty clear who catches people's attention more and she doesn't need the attention of rats like you

[@soomiewleng5227]

When I looked twice I realised yujin gives me ryujin vibes

[@mfg1946]

Yup. 4th Gen Girl Crush.

[@mfg1946]

I honestly don't want Yujin And Wonyoung to be compared to each other. Cause when that happens I have no choice but to defend yujin from "some "Wy toxic fans. Those toxic fans can't accept constructive criticism from other people. Bottom line I don't want any fanwar.

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

Exactly

[@yk_zyk]

i stan izone because of yujin's fancam in sequence lol bye. ❤️

[@remortale3542]

agreed to ningning vs rose, cause ningning is better vocalist and that's a fact. Many people seemed to be confused with "who's a better vocalist" to "which vocalist I prefer more" ; vocal color and emotion is something subjective so opinions may vary, so that doesn't mean one is better than other, technique on the other hand is objective no one could deny a fact. If someone said otherwise they're indenial🙃

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

Exactly

[@juliasuarezsaldivia4274]

As a dancer myself karina is clearly better than winter. Even do people say that winter is really fluid she actually only highlights robotic movements. Karina is versatile dancer whith precise movements.

[@lilaC-qj7jz]

I have no idea why people are comparing ningning and rose like their singing abilities and techniques are so far from each other.

[@kpopthetic3702]

But Nining got better than Rosè

[@utkarshbxsharm2901]

1- yujin for me to be honest , her being an ace is no joke 2- rose voice is relaxing while ningning's being stronger. I myself is a strong singer (not professional in a hobby way) but i love that soft and relaxing voice . So rose. 3- Jin for me , he has some reason husky and magical vocals and his technique is great too. Jungkook have a clearer and melodious voice but Jin for me . - Winter , her dancing is soft and firm at the same time.

[@ketakikhobragade7168]

My faves 1. Yujin 2. Rosé 3. Jin and jungkook 4. Karina

[@chtsho]

U slayed

[@minustephen4101]

Rosé voice is unique.. We can easily identify her voice. She always conveys story through the song. I feel emotional when I listen to her singing After all yg is the house of unique vocals. But Nining voice is like any other kpop idol typical voice. Just like any other SM GG groups voice with lot of trained techniques. Very strong and powerful and hitting high note that's it. Sometimes it hurts your ear when you listen to such powerful voice. Eg: if ain't got you. (when Rosé sing you can feel the pain and emotion, while ninning's was sounded like a kpop song with very high notes)

[@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965]

pfft- name an idol that has a similar voice as her

[@avaagarde6925]

People who criticize Rosé should watch Sea of Hope. She shined there. And ultimately it all goes down to preference but she isn't using a damaging technique atleast according to vocal coaches. It isn't a fake voice, it's hers!

[@klopkerna3562]

It's haters who are bringing her down ..

[@euphoriavss1363]

yess yujin for sure.

[@ihaveapurpleheart1233]

Wonyoung and yujin case is one of the best examples about how people care for visuals more than talent, yujin is super pretty too, but people usually appreciate wonyoung more which i find so offensive, wonyoung is talented but her expressions are cringe, she winks 6968685890 times in one performance and it's super annoying, dancing too, she was so good in iz*one idk what is she doing in I've, whereas yujin's expressions are powerful, versatile and her dance is powerful, wonyoung definitely needs to improve,. I believe she has potential

[@lavienrosewon8811]

In pd48 wonyoung wink much but in izone she did less But in ive she did well as controlled n expressive . If you act when you re dancer Herself Ive choregrapher praised wonyoung dance skill for being flexible n didnt overdancing

[@ihaveapurpleheart1233]

@@lavienrosewon8811 you're mistaken, go take a look at any "Ranking I've's dancing skills" video, every single person states how powerless and weak wonyoung dances, if you have watched wonyoung's fancam, you should have noticed how wonyoung couldn't do hip locks AT ALL!!! Look at "1,2,3,4,5,6,7" part, she isn't even moving her hips and then compare her to yujin

[@lavienrosewon8811]

@@ihaveapurpleheart1233 well wonyoung was ballet dancer also this is normal she is Less powerful than others ,she did well as dancer she trying her best I think rei is worst dancer cause she forget the step in her fancams She get skinny also this is pilate exercice ruined her body I seen rank dancing herekzbin.info/www/bejne/e6PYi6SemtiCaas

[@iheartden]

@@ihaveapurpleheart1233 ok but all of the members except yujin and gaeul had a hard time with the hip locks. it wasnt just wonyoung.

[@imamultistan7779]

So true, I agree👍🏻

[@Roseanné-g7s]

In my opinion rosé's voice is just legendary . She has the most beautiful and angelic and unique voice. Ning Ning is good but I prefer rosé.

[@kpopthetic3702]

Yes but if you see, Rose had a angelic voice before but now her voice was damaged idk why but if you see than you will understand.

[@k-poppersince0951]

The thing is Rose has a unique voice which stands out and really gives flavor and edge to blackpink songs. She is a good singer but because her voice has become really weak due to straining too much, she really sounds off when she’s singing anything besides blackpink songs. I’ve never enjoyed any of her covers because everytime she just sounds like she’s really struggling to sing. Her voice doesn’t flow smoothly. I’m not hating on her it’s a fact. I feel like she had the potential to be a strong vocalist but because of the technique she uses ( I don’t know it’s true that yg made her sing a certain way), she has to strain her voice so much that she can’t to sing openly.

[@klopkerna3562]

@@kpopthetic3702 her voice is not damaged. On the contrary she doesn't damage her voice comparing to her rookie days

[@Roseanné-g7s]

@@Kudoscookery It's based in preference you prefer other likewise I prefer rosé. I didn't say that she have good techniques I just said in my opinion she sounds angelic and so I like her voice more than others.and I can't say any specific one person is best someone can be good on techniques but not have that much of a good and pleasing voice colour. It is just preference

[@kpopthetic3702]

@@klopkerna3562 She have! Just see it carefully

[@levisbabygirl1947]

Well I think that they do not need to be compared,but they are some who need improvement 💁‍♀️just saying

[@reis_svisa]

Every Kpop idol are talented.

[@katykim]

I don't think rosé or any idols was forced to change their voice it can literally destroy her voice

[@breadandjiminslostjams2459]

Twice Momo is forced to change her voice, her voice is naturally deep

[@katykim]

@@breadandjiminslostjams2459 she's not forced to change her voice they make her sing in a higher pitch if they made her change it she wouldn't be able to sing

[@justjudy2909]

I think there is a big chance of them being forced to actually, let’s be honest, Rose is famous for her unique (still beautiful) voice, and that’s exactly what YG is aiming for, unique idols, as you’ll stand out more, and gain more popularity. I unfortunately don’t think they really care about destroying a voice, they are also destroying the idols in many ways (extreme schedules, diets) It’s the money they’re after. The kpop industry is really harsh unfortunately. (This is not meant as an attack by the way! I’m just sharing my opinion on this situation)

[@enidiag9548]

I prefer Rose voice too. She sing on live and her voice i so angelic and unique

[@chanelvibes4664]

Rosie’s singing live makes me cry, I don’t cry often . She has a voice that tells a story. I didn’t like “ on the ground” at first but it’s my favourite now that I can relate and I cry everytime I listen to it coz it’s so beautiful

[@arushibhakuni9203]

YUJIN IS AN ACE

[@ma.catherinelozada814]

Tbh, Yujin is more charismatic and eye catching than Woonyoung. I love both of them but Lee Seo, Yujin and Gaeul always caught my eyes they are natural eye catchy plus Liz ethereal visual

[@blinkoverhere4649]

Ok so here are some reasons why Rosé and Ningning can't be compared 1. Rosè belongs to 3rd gen and Ningning to 4th gen 2.Rosé has more experience than Ningning 3.Each company has its own style of vocalists But I think I prefer Rosé. Her voice, whether nasal or deep,is truly a blessing.

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

And most important point you forgot to mention Technique wise Ningning is much better even though she's junior

[@madisonangelo7051]

Yujin and wonyoung, i 100% agree

[@lomengg]

Theres a reason why karina was the only member introduced as the all rounder member of aespa! Karina stage presence is wonderful and her dancing keeps improving you can check the got stage and she is on par with sm main dancers and boa!

[@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965]

naur winter is the all rounder plus she was only known as sm's secret weapon ik yall gonna deny is saur let me elaborate: winter is the official visual and often mistaken as the main dancer and she can be the main vocalist is several groups plus her rap in savage was great and she would be astonishing with proper training . karina is a great dancer and rapper but she dosent have the potential to be a main vocalist the way winter can be a main dancer plus we can also look up to actress winter as she was trained

[@lovingmyselfright]

@@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965 Karina could be the main rapper, while Winter cannot. Winter is the all rounder while Karina is an ace.

[@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965]

@@lovingmyselfright ace is someone who can do everything with a potential main position in all of them including producing and even lyrics writing an all rounder is someone that can be a main in all positions

[@lovingmyselfright]

@@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965 have you heard Karina in savage? She definitely could be the main/lead vocalist if she does more of high notes! Remember this is SME idol, who are good in vocals so doubting Karina or even Giselle in vocals is lame.

[@staysafebutdonteathandsani3965]

@@lovingmyselfright whatever helps u sleep but winter IS the all rounder and aespa dpsent have an ace as of now

[@kpaysha5937]

Visual can beat talent in kpop, in every group hot looking or stand out looking members are always popular, example v, hyujin,karina,wonyoung,are popular because of their visual, they are really talented,but they mainly known for their face,there is soo many talented members like suga rm changbin Lee know are being underrated in their group just because they don't have attractive visual s,it really sad that people choose beauty over talent

[@onlyiichan]

it's fine to compare, but as fans, whoever our preferences are, we shouldn't be over-stepping. i see a lot of people masking their hatred with "constructive" criticism term when in fact it's already a direct hate. let's just hope for idols to improve, and if they can't, well we can't do anything about it, perhaps just stan an idol to your preference

[@myyouniverse338]

Jin is my ult bias and his voice is pure heaven. But if I ever get to only listen to one voice all my life I'll choosee Jungkook without a second thought. Jin's voice sounds angelic and joyous like his voice can make me cry and dance at the same time and Jungkook's voice is too soothing and calming it just feels like listening to his voice without doing anything. Both the boys have a way to make me emotional just with their voices, but Jungkook's in a fun way yk what i mean and jin's ina asorrowful way.

[@vicccccctoria]

MAYNNNN ALL R AMAZING IDOLS NEZITENS NEED TO CHILL AND FIRST COMMENT I LOVE UR CHANNEL😍

[@sherlyxavier7489]

Last time I checked Rosé was the GOLDEN VOICE OF KOREA.

[@Jungkook_fr]

Well those titles are given to idols by fans whom voter for them so fame contributes a lot to these titles so I wouldn't take it to seriously and make it the basis

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

@@Jungkook_fr exactly

[@rositamamoy2831]

I don't mind Rose vocal but yeah Ningning vocal is on another level

[@pheonix9929]

Let's just be honest.... Yujin is really the ace of ive.... She has a very good stage presence, powerful vocals, versatile expressions.... Whereas won young.... I really want to know... Does she think that she is some sort of angel or something, like why is she so obsessed with that dreamy, angelic expression all the time.... She really needs to show some improvements, she is not a rookie anymore unlike the other ive members

[@salamaabrahams]

Aespa have the most talented in Kpop ... visuals ,vocal ,Rap , dance & achievement ...Aespa is world class that fact ‼️

[@MinThant07]

No offense to BTS but no one in BTS was trained vocally in a proper way. They don't know how to use vocal techniques properly and even the main vocalist JK has shallow support with limited supported vocal range throughout his career. I don't know why netizens act like vocal experts when they know nothing about vocal techniques and stuff.

[@assyle_]

I can only comment to the comparison in vocals since singing is so normalized in my country with a wide variety of genres. Vocal technique is a show of your versatility and range of your vocal tone with your natural singing voice. Most people who have a nice vocal tone ignore this aspect in singing and prefer their normal singing voice with no variety because why bother when you already have a nice voice that attract a lot of people. But to a trained ears it's just a good voice nothing else like how can you get inspired in singing technique's when that's just their normal vocal tone that appears easy because it's really easy to do with their vocal tone. But vocal technique on the other hand show's how much more hardwork you put to your singing because hardwork can't lie but fans can. Comparison isn't bad but forcing your own opinion to your fave to others is. To those who say they have more emotion, obviously didn't her other people that's not in kpop cover's of that song and lack a proper comparison of real emotion versus vocal tone that makes them emotional.

[@yasminchan7425]

Am I the only one that thinks NingNing and Rosè sounds too different to be compared? I think Jungkook is better but that's just my opinion, I'm not a vocal coach or even a singer I just prefer jungkook's over Jin's(both are great though)

[@syllogist_666]

I really wanna punch these "netizens" 🙂🙂✨ They literally don't have any other work 😂

[@otuya]

Jin is skilled

[@oncetwice4954]

yg prefers unique voice for main vocalists while sm focuses on good technique.They both are doing good according to their company's preferences.

[@ani5593]

Why r ya mentioning Height with regards to Winrinas dance as if being shorter is a disadvantage while dancing , it's NOT unless ur disproportionate 👽

[@earthshuman3864]

It's sad that rose had to change her voice tone I like that she sing with more emotions But at same time I also think what it would sound if sing with old tone

[@MaruBi8]

I am Winter bias and I think Winter really dance well and is more suitable in aespa’s choreography. But you’ll see Karina’s dance best in Girls on Top. She is so amazing there!! I dont know much about dancing techniques and stuff tho.

[@Justme-mu6qf]

I really like rosie vocal compared to ning2 I really hate comparison but i think rosie vocal make me always emotional ♥ no hate to ning2 but i prefer rosie unique vocal

[@kpopthetic3702]

Yes. Agreed

[@JiaPia3]

Look up Karina dancing to Bola Rebola, and you’ll see why she’s the main dancer. 😭

[@hosneyarafat9858]

No matter what they said to her, rosè is talented with a unique voice. I admit the Ningning has a strong vocal but rosè vocal is heaven ❤😍

[@anistardi]

Many k-pop group are manufactured at their debut. Some of k-pop idol grow become an artist. But in the end, it is about money. Money is the first concern of the label companies. Many fans do not understand about vocal technique, dance, etc. Most of them stan their idol because they connected emotionally, they like their visual, personality, and their fashion. So, the label companies search the visual first because it can attract their fan. They can train them, and hopefully they can sing and dance. It is about making money.

[@mamibawitlung2086]

I still can't forget my anti-kpop sister asking me who is the the artist of the song which i was playing "Moon" by jin.....she told me that his vocal was angelic and calm.....You would't understand how happy i was....🤧🤧

[@salamaabrahams]

NingNing of course forever vocal Queen 👑👑👑👑👑👑

[@ElleAlyssa18]

I am not a fan of IVE but in term of skills i'd choose Yujin 1000000x over Won Young. Yujin displays professionalism on stage. She displays maturity, she seems to be aware of her surrounding and i am sure she is a good leader to her team members. Won Young...she is pretty, thats it. Oh wait, she is good at winking (please just stop already), maintaining her dreamy eyes, i must stay she also put a lot of effort to stay cute, alluring and perhaps trying to appear elegant (based on her interpretation perhaps). Girl, you dont have to try that hard, you already have that preety face. Well...I dont know..i feel that when she is among other idols, you can see her face that says "no, sorry, im not paying attention to you..im the prettiest here"..its seldom that we can see she looked directly in people's faces (especially female idols)..hurmm

[@gabii7779]

I hope you feel good about bashing someone for being pretty

[@ElleAlyssa18]

@@gabii7779 well, thats my opinion and you dont have to agree with that. You also can write your own opinion if you want. I need to add, being preety is not a crime at all. Its being preety with the bad attitude thats putting idol into hot spot for critism. The truth hurts i guess. We all need to understand, an idol dont have to be just preety, they need to be talented and improve their skills

[@lavienrosewon8811]

You know nothing her Ive members said wonyoung is naturel bubbly

[@candylover7460]

@@ElleAlyssa18 Yujin has both. Talent and Visual.😍✨ I'm so proud of Yujin. She is a young & talented leader.She never makes everyone to feel cringey to watch.

[@ElleAlyssa18]

@@candylover7460 yup, could not agree more. Like i said, i m not a fan but i would watch ive videos because of Yujin

[@jjk1990]

i’m sorry but jungkoook is one of the best vocalist of our generation, you can’t compare him

[@aliyyahbalogun2686]

Neither Jin nor Jungkook are good vocalists

[@liu5461]

@@aliyyahbalogun2686 they're both very good vocalists

[@aliyyahbalogun2686]

@@liu5461 Nah,neither of them are good but that's okay I guess

[@liu5461]

​@@aliyyahbalogun2686 they've been praised by professionals for their vocals so yeah

[@kamalhossan5694]

@@liu5461 don't even explain that person...

[@shadedwizard8566]

I honestly think that they cannot compare them that straight forward because they are all unique in their own way. For example, about Yuyin and Wonyoung, I personally think Yujin improvisation is better and her stage presence as well but I think that Wonyoung facial expressions are quite on spot. The fancam with the vibrant pink dress shows that her expressions in the introduction of the song are insane and on another level

[@girlgroupkpop4161]

Yujin's stage presence and overall performances more better but anyway I respect your opinions

[@justinneaustria1654]

Golden voice of Rośe👌💅

[@kpopthetic3702]

Was not now

[@seyedearinahosseini39]

Yeah right 😂