BEE GEES - I Can't See Nobody (Melbourne, 1974) | REACTION

[@hereonthe3L]

*_FOR MY FULL BEE GEES PLAYLIST, FOLLOW THIS LINK BEFORE MAKING REQUESTS:_* kzbin.info/aero/PLSnNE4tdNL-rR68vDdLHlOD-HXQ_vHUHE

[@peggyhinkle6520]

O. M. G.!!! Robin is absolutely AMAZING!!! What an incredibly beautiful voice he had. During this performance a girl stormed the stage. Robin looked over to the right and saw what was going on, Security Guards managed to grab her, but Robin never missed a note!!! He’s an incredible performer!!!! There will NEVER BE ANOTHER ROBIN!!!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️ 🌹🌹🌹

[@elizabethfranco1284]

He wrote this when he was a teenager

[@virginiaconner3340]

Actually written by Robin and Barry. They co-wrote often.

[@annasaylor3566]

Nobody can match Robin or any of them for that fact,but I love Robins voice.

[@sylviategroen1583]

Robins VOICE is amazing...🌸every time he sang😍

[@alexandroquerevalu7811]

Robins voice was unique, and in this song you hear tremble over vibrado.

[@saffronwetter7944]

Robin's voice was unique and priceless. They have never ever been another unique singer like Robin Gibb. Not even his twin brother.

[@alexandroquerevalu7811]

Robin was using his hands to count,and keep the notes perfect. Also putting his hand over his ear to keep some of the sounds out. They didn't have the technology like they have today. Some artists do that. And Robin was a perfectionist.

[@virginiaconner3340]

Think they all were which is evident in their body of work.

[@alexandroquerevalu7811]

@@virginiaconner3340 not like Robin was.

[@personperson8852]

A fan tried to get on stage. Robin didn't miss a beat

[@juanita6479]

@@personperson8852 He never missed a beat, but was not about a fan, one of their songs had reached the charts and it was flashed up on the stage screen. You can see on my previous comment.

[@neilperry2241]

​@@alexandroquerevalu7811nonsense

[@robertaclark2996]

Robin was the best. Just love his awesome voice. Miss him terribly. He was always my favorite. Love Robin

[@anneangels52]

Robin his gift is unbelievable...singing, conducting himself! I love this concert, I listen all the time... just for Robin.... His gorgeous angelic voice.... Simply beautiful 👏👏👏♥️

[@lemondropslollipops6634]

RIP Robin. I will never be able to choose one over the other but this song with Robin on lead is magical. Incredible voice. No comparison. The interruption was a fan trying to get on stage. This whole concert is awesome.

[@kathystammen8774]

This song is a masterpiece. My goodness Robin puts his heart and soul into every single note! I adore him. There will never be another Robin. They broke the mold!

[@robertaclark2996]

Aww Robins hand gestures!! Love them. Love him. Miss him so much.

[@TallyDrake]

So nice to see Robin front and center. 😊🥰

[@kathystammen3060]

I adore his voice. My goodness! He’s angelic!

[@robertaclark3286]

This is one of my favorites with Robin singing lead. I just loved Robin and still do. RIP sweet Robin.

[@amigarcia1959]

He was an angel here literally his face so soft like an angel!

[@kathieovercash8414]

Mine too.

[@christinerose4839]

Robin will always be missed and that beautiful voice ♥️ The Bee Gees love love

[@jamihede4440]

Something that I find exceedingly striking about this song......Robin was 17 years old when he wrote this! There is a video that was done back then, and seeing him back then, bad teeth, complexion issues, those puppy dog eye. He was a poet, through and through.

[@patriciaewing8164]

There will never be another singer like Robin 😁 🎶his voice is hauntingly beautiful 🎶👏🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@pennykaine2306]

He is so AWESOME especially in this song!! THIS IS THE REAL DEAL!!!💖💖💖

[@lydmarl.475]

He took it with grace and never lost his focus, just beautiful track!

[@patriciabarkley735]

This is the best song by my favorite singer. I would love to have gotten my hands on him back in the day. He was gorgeous and sexy. He had the most beautiful voice ever. Rest In Peace, Rob. You are truly loved and missed. ❤️🌹❤️

[@pennykaine2306]

There is no other voice like Robin's@!!💖💖💖

[@sylviategroen1583]

Robin is so gifted. Wow...could listen to him n the gib brothere all day 💜🔥💓

[@dianeoliver9041]

Who wouldn’t want to be the center of his attention! Love this song, Love Robin’s voice, Love Robin!!! Love this Concert, I’ve watched it several times, great concert!! ♥️♥️♥️👍🏻

[@tammychan3093]

And the sun will shine is another fabulous song presented by Robin in this concert, please try to react🤩

[@mariemac3608]

Yes, please 🙏 🎶

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

'And The Sun Will Shine' is an absolute favorite of mine. Such a beautifully poignant and melancholic song. Love watching Robin sing it live when he was young. You can just watch the feelings wash over his face as he closed his eyes and got lost in the music!!

[@amigarcia1959]

@@gloriamaryhaywood2217 love that song too, sung perfectly by our songbird

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

@@amigarcia1959 It almost has a 'Spiritual-feel' to that song!?🤔💖

[@rwilson7197]

LOVE Robin's voice. He hits those high notes effortlessly & Ive never heard a voice like his! Just beautiful!!❤❤❤

[@shantaylor3686]

Robins voice is sublime. Maurice and Barry's voices are sublime, but Robin just melts me singing this.

[@LuckyDawgProductionsModerator]

One of the best performances of this song. Robin is magnificent, and he never skips a beat when he gets distracted by the fan that runs up on stage, and grins during it the entire time. Absolutely love this one! Thanks for the review, Chad. Spot on!

[@juanita6479]

It seems that it was not a fan runnin up on stage, you can check my previous comment.

[@seanjohnson6186]

I am not sure exactly what the disturbance was that was happening to the audiences left, but whatever it was illustrates Robin’s professionalism, because he clearly showed he saw something but his voice never faltered.

[@pennykaine2306]

Robin was distracted but he wasn't which showed his strength and showmanship.

[@anitarikard5941]

A girl was trying to get on stage and security was keeping her from getting on with the bee gee

[@juanita6479]

One of their songs had reached the charts and it was flashed up on the stage screen. My previous comment is complete.

[@deewhitford4910]

I w as s there absolutely amazing

[@sheilashoulders9291]

So grateful to have been born during this incredible time. 💓 Robin was the definition of perfection. Love this so much.

[@pearlegates7079]

This whole concert is really enjoyable.

[@dieseldog00]

"Every single word you hear is coming from this heart of mine". I love that phrase, so typical Robin.

[@ruthgrimley7653]

What is NOT to love with the bee gees... I've been in love with them 45+yrs.

[@susieq9801]

Robin's hand gestures were obvious and vital to his performance. He actually seeks out notes like a conductor. When he is about to hit a high note, he physically reaches for it with his hands. To sustain a note he clenches his fingers. He is acting out the song physically to match his voice. A lot of people cover Bee Gees songs but often avoid standards that were sung by Robin because they know they are inimitable. As you said, his voice is unique and nobody has been able to duplicate it. His vibrato is astounding and his inflections are marvelous and yet so natural and instinctive to him. He did a much better version on The Midnight Special in the 70's He really ad-libbed a lot and got into it, eyes closed and belting it out full voice. Just for your own interest to compare, not asking for a reaction - kzbin.info/www/bejne/kIqyZX6Hadhjf6s

[@lauriebarnes2999]

Suzie Q, you couldn't have said it better! And I'm glad you shared the 1973 "Midnight Special" version with Chad. I really want him to watch that wonderful performance, too. His emotions just poured out of him that night! What a wonderful performance, what a wonderful man!

[@alexandroquerevalu7811]

Its tremble over vibrado you hear in Robins voice. Unique

[@isabellabourchier3498]

@@lauriebarnes2999 absolutely agree. Incredible man.

[@isabellabourchier3498]

I adore this version too kzbin.info/www/bejne/pKTaq3qvZ6-DgrM

[@janetevelynsmithmefford7391]

@susieq9801 Thanks for posting this version, my favorite. This is the artist, song and video of my life hands down. I melt listening to this version and love love love him at this stage in his life when he still had his baby face on. We were born just months apart and this song peaked when we were 16-17, amazing he was this excellent, so young, SO wish I could have known him then. (Does anyone know if there is a video of this same performance, but not cut off at the end with acknowledgements?)

[@bassboybazza]

I guarantee Mo would have made matters worse, when she stormed the stage. He saw the funny side of everything.

[@lisacecil449]

Which is why I love Mo!!!!!

[@astridsolle4226]

Robin deine Stimme wird mich immer begleiten super toller Sänger unvergessliche ❤❤❤

[@DiscoDoll79]

Flawless performance, despite the fan disruption. Bee Gees were absolute professionals on stage. I've never been aware of anyone who complained attending their concerts. Listen to the notes - flats and sharps - as Robin Gibb sings with his unique vibrato and delivery of the lyrics. No one who has covered this song was able to come close to the sound of the original. Chad, I'm so pleased you finally listened to this lesser known but brilliant song from the Brothers Gibb.

[@gloriaarnaud5459]

Robin is my favorite singer I'm 77 years old now .I still listen to the bee gees robin voice will always be the voice of the decads

[@tammychan3093]

Love this concert very much…Robin just like a hipster singing beautifully.

[@SunCityLady]

Whatever the cause of the commotion, Robin never lost focus. Wonderful reaction, you're getting better all the time ! Thanks !

[@jennifernadela3574]

That is why they are legit legends. Incomparable.brothers

[@lydiavivero8154]

One of the signature songs of my favorite The Bee Gees. I really miss Robin.💖 Thanks again Chad.

[@robinpadilla6683]

I can't tell you how psyched I was to see that you chose this. This isn't something that reactors choose to do! 🥰🥰

[@LillyMarz777]

I think it was someone trying to get on stage. He wouldn't have had such a sustained reaction to Mo being funny. It's my oldest brothers favorite Bee Gee song, as he says, despite the grammar! I am thankful God let us borrow them for as long as he did.

[@dieseldog00]

Robin looked to his right several times b/c a female fan came onstage and tried to kiss Maurice lol.

[@sgtcheerylittlebottom]

so many of my favourite Bee Gees songs are sung by Robin, it has a vulnerability and emotion that has never been matched, and probably never will be.

[@lena-mariag.louis-charles3579]

Not only was Robin Gibb extraordinarily gifted musically, he stayed a professional (and did it with a big smile...), AND didn't miss a beat during this performance - all while a fan tried to storm the stage! I agree with You, Chad - one can only benefit from keeping an open mind - and be willing (and eager...) to listen to upcoming artists.💕 (One day, once You've gotten through all of our Bee Gees requests, I'd like to see Your reaction to his final Masterpiece, "THE TITANIC REQUIEM" - which he did in collaboration with his youngest son, Robin-John. Robin's solo performance in "DON'T CRY ALONE" [which was completely spontaneous...] is a Masterpiece within a Masterpiece...).

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

I absolutely adore 'Don't Cry Alone.' It almost always moves me to tears! But Robin wrote and recorded that song back in 2008 I think? I'm so glad he decided to include it in though!😉

[@ellapere7599]

Absolutely loved this live performance ❤ Robin is the best of the best! Thank you Chad!

[@lauriebarnes2999]

Chad, I dropped everything when I saw in my notifications that you reacted to "I Can't See Nobody" from Melbourne in 1974! What an amazing reaction! I've been waiting for a very long time for this wonderful Robin lead to be done. With a full orchestra accompanying them and Robin's emotional performance, I don't think there is a better version out there for you to have used and you did not disappoint! To answer your question about what was distracting him during the performance was that a fan had made it onto the stage and was headed for Maurice and was detained by security before the situation got out of hand. And yes, our precious Robin kept his composure and didn't miss a single word because of it! A true testament to how amazing he was every time he performed live. And, on your recommendation, I will check out your Anjelina reactions. Looking forward to them.

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

Yes. Robin sounded Awesome here!!! But did you notice that he missed a whole verse here and repeated the same one?😁lol. The verse Robin left out was "Don't ask me why little girl- I love you, and that's all I can say. You're every breath that I breathe- You are my night, my night and day!"😉 I looove our sweet Robin!, but he was known to do this sort of thing fairly often!! This is taken from probably my very favorite concert of theirs!😍

[@kimbarrett4179]

@@gloriamaryhaywood2217 think you need to recheck because he doesn't x

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

@@kimbarrett4179 Yup. I reviewed the whole beautiful song again. And Robin does indeed leave out that verse. Nothing New about that. Sometimes Robin would even make up new lyrics on the fly!😉lol. Doesn't really matter though, as he always sounded SO Amazing!!😎

[@kimbarrett4179]

@@gloriamaryhaywood2217 totally agree an amazing singer x

[@donnakilpatrick2117]

Maybe the girl trying to get on stage distracted him a bit

[@elizabethmencia6027]

His attention ventured off because a fan got on stage and security stopped her at the last minute. 🥰🥰🥰

[@dcjak1]

I felt like jumping up on the stage just watching from here!! That was brilliant, heartfelt, grabbed me

[@pearlegates7079]

LOVE this song!!!!!! Love all of them! 60's, 70's, 80's, 90's. Excited for this marathon!

[@nancydiaz5666]

MY FAVORITE . ROBIN I LOVE .❤FOREVER ❤

[@RandomJane104]

Thanks for doing this one! That distraction was a mystery and up for debate for a long time. Apparently it was a girl rushing the stage.

[@monicshastings8945]

Haven't heard this song in years. It was one of my favorites on their live album. As usual, really appreciated your on point remarks Chad

[@pamelahunter987]

Absolutely stunning performance! Thanks, Chad! ❤

[@RK-gg4dd]

This particular concert is great to watch in its entirety. They have an orchestra playing behind them. The music is live. Also Mo was the comic relief in this concert. He is hilarious at times!

[@robinpadilla6683]

Everyday I check to see if any reactors are doing any Bee Gees songs. So suuuuuper psyched you're doing a Marathon!! Made my weekend!

[@Georgia__Girl]

Me too. I think I have requested all of them on KZbin to please react to Close Another Door…..finally someone has❣️❣️

[@lclark6854]

Great reaction Chad. Robin's voice and expressiveness were spectacular in the 70s (which I think he toned down a bit later). There are so many great live performances in this era from Melbourne, Chicago Soundstage, Midnight Special etc. I could watch them over and over.

[@lindagarcia8826]

Perfect music to start the weekend with, great choice. The early Bee Gee music is "Top Notch" you have that right. Thank you for your Bee Gee Marathon Weekend, great and interesting review Thanks much love.

[@gabaker81]

I just went back and watched this again, cause it’s one of my very favorite songs with Robin in lead but it took all 3 to create that genius harmony!! I waited so long for you to react to this one. Robin never missed a beat even when the fan stormed the stage…how professional was that!!! RIP Robin and Mo and of course Andy… Thanks Chad…you’re the best!!! Please react to the making of Tragedy!!!

[@trudywolfe2795]

ROBIN IS SO VERY VERY TALENTED

[@jackielh1]

So happy you reviewed this song, this concert was done after they reunited, before fever. I was lucky to have seen this tour "Mr. Natural " they were amazing. Will always be a BG fan.

[@Roselle264]

A girl was trying to go to the stage that’s why he’s smiling.

[@bpfromowc]

This is a great version, but (live in Midnight Special) might be even better. Nice channel man. The Bee Gees rule. ✌️

[@amigarcia1959]

I agree

[@DianaJG8]

I wondered for YEARS who was there OR what was going on? I've read about a girl trying to get on the stage BUT recently I read, from someone that was there, that Andy had walked in. THIS makes more sense to me to account for Robin's grin, the applause, and the photo flashes! Perhaps it was both? But this is my FAVORITE rendering of this song!! Robin looked and sounded GREAT here!! ❤❤

[@anastasie_0214]

In 1974 Andy would have been only 15 or 16 years old being he was born in 1958. Was he that popular yet ? In any case Robin’s smile was Adorable 🥰.

[@DianaJG8]

@@anastasie_0214 - His three #1 hits were at age 19 his own band was playing locally prior to that. Plus, this concert was in Australia so..... Yeah, they probably did know who he was, but I can't swear to that. I'm just going by what one of the people said who was there. 🤷‍♀️

[@wnsafford1854]

I don't think most people would have recognized Andy in 1974. He was still close to 3 years off from becoming known (1st record released April 1977). I was a young adult in 1974 & a Bee Gee fan since the 60s & I wouldn't have had a clue who he was.

[@DianaJG8]

@@wnsafford1854 - I wouldn't have either, especially being older than him, but, as I said, this was IN Australia so maybe that's the difference.

[@lydmarl.475]

You might be so wright, it is the way he grinned, my first thought was by looking at him, it was someone he knew, because he was so pleased!

[@andrewbrown1295]

Sends shivers through me. So poignant, sad and happy, hope and loss at the same time; delivered with such feeling

[@josephinegomez2466]

I have watched the full concert just here in KZbin.. they're indeed amazing.. every song were performed perfectly ☺️

[@amymarckel420]

Oh my goodness I’ve been waiting for you to finally react to this song! I still remember hearing it for the first time when I was around 7 or 8, I found it while going through my parents record collection, both the song and Robin’s beautiful vibrato have stuck with me ever since. I was so lucky to grow up with the music of the Bee Gees (the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack is the first album I remember saving my allowance to buy) and it’s just wonderful to see a whole new generation learning to love and appreciate their music. Bee Gees forever!

[@jeric7740]

His right hand is to his ear duplicating a ear-monitor that had not been invented yet. That's how good he was.

[@rosemariehyderivera9682]

Love this song ❤️

[@cindyknudson2715]

That long hold near the end was Robin and Barry together. Their voices together were another whole sound from each individually. Thanks for the reaction. 👍 Could you please react to Every Second, Every Minute from 1971? It was a surprise to me when I heard it a year or so ago.

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

Love when their voices blended or started over-lapping each other! Truly Mesmerizing!!!😍 Love their trading off on lead verses in a song! And adding backing-vocals for each other. Each of their voices accentuated the other! I can usually instantly hear when Robin comes in, BUT not in a couple songs. One where they are so perfectly blended is in the song 'Fanny Be Tender.' I swear I Can't tell who is who there in certain parts. Now That don't happen Often!!😉

[@barbaraforde9213]

Robin was looking to the side at the disturbance as an over excited girl tried to get on stage to probably hug Robin but the security guard detained her. Once Robin turned his head back around realizing what had happened, there was a slight smile on his face. Ha, ha ! Through all of this, Robin never missed a beat nor his perfect notes.

[@vilmagapic-pc8ey]

They'll never be really any another BeeGee...Miss them so much esp.Robin.

[@annemarinelli7303]

He was simply perfect……one of my favorite songs and I believe the best performance of it …..he was looking stage right because a girl had gotten on to the stage …..he was smiling and didn’t miss a beat …..I’m 70 years old and remember when this song first came out and was on the radio ……in those days Robin sang lead in almost every song …..

[@micheladonofrio2285]

The Bee Gees said that this song was written in Australia and was on their first album "Bee Gees 1st" in 1967.

[@kylegreen3247]

Their first BRITISH LP, not their first one.

[@micheladonofrio2285]

@@kylegreen3247 o.k., but it was called "BeeGees 1st".

[@trudywolfe2795]

I LOVE YOU ROBIN AND MISS YOU

[@bluesky-rb8fn]

Hauntingly beautiful!!!!❤❤

[@calablanca]

Hooked on Bee Gees. A blast

[@janetevelynsmithmefford7391]

My favorite song ever, love Robin Gibb.

[@annethomsen7648]

was 25 years old ha been singing together for18 years incredable...

[@onenight0666]

"And then you happened girl" one of the best Robin lines ever.

[@denisehedden5108]

🥀I've always loved this song it's soothing but Powerful. There's so much I could say about the Brothers Bee Gees but you did a great job on them. Your right no one can replace The Brother's Bee Gees 🥀☝️🥀

[@marieskapars4766]

Chad our funny mo was making him laugh as hes messing about n trying to break our Rob n trying barry too. Ul never ever get two. Unique. Godly sent. We were lucky they graced this world. Xxx

[@agnetamalmqvist9075]

I Love them!!!!!

[@sylviategroen1583]

So British...im from the Oxford area..so luv the BeeGees🌹

[@dubivxler]

bee gees crying everyday

[@sylviategroen1583]

Fans or fan trying yo storm the stage...didnt get to him!!! He saw the funny side of it thats Robin 💖

[@sylviategroen1583]

Mo was so spontaneously funny, you can see the luv between all 3.i lololo each time i see Mos antics on stage...it never gets old...Barry loses it n enjoys it to.

[@jean-mariepierre2629]

From france, Hello ' Chad' ', À great performance Robin, Incroyable.. Je comprends, Ton admiration. Tu nous fais partager, Tes sensations. C'. Est, extraordinaire. Merci, mon ami, I love BEE GEES, FOR EVER 💙💚💜💗👍🍀🍀🍀🍀, Péter, MERCI

[@daleannphillips3730]

Not sure if anyone answered your question but there was a concert goer who tried to get up on stage and security tackled them so that’s what got his attention. I watch another guy who actually analyzes videos who breaks down the singing and voice performances. He explained why Robin kept looking to his right and mentioned that Robin was able to not miss a beat even being distracted. True masterpiece

[@sometimeslyrical]

At last, my Robin! Thank you, Chad!

[@j7l5m4]

Robin is Obviously Dedication, to His Lady Love In the Audience ! 💖💖🎶🎶💌😍💯💓💓💓

[@leeannep.7652]

This whole concert is pure eye candy for us Robin girls, and ear candy on his lead songs. Incredibly impressive that he never missed a beat or an amazing high note, especially on such a serious song, at the distraction. Which I had heard had something to do with Maurice and Yvonne but maybe the others on here know better about that.

[@LMICaretaker]

He was looking off the side because they fan. A girl tried to get on the stage and security stopped her and the crowd reaction and Robin didn’t miss a beat, but just smiled and kept singing.

[@vernacohen6988]

I'm behind with your channel so I have catch up to do.I love the Bee Bees, always have. Robin is my favorite. Officially a new sub & have truly enjoyed your reactions. 😁

[@micheladonofrio2285]

This song is very reminiscent of the period that it was written in (around 66/67) and makes me think of the Moody Blues.

[@Georgia__Girl]

I would love to hear Robin tell me. I can’t see nobody. My eyes can only look at you🥰🥰🥰…❣️Robin Gibb ❣️

[@trudywolfe2795]

ROBIN ❤️❤️❤️. ROBIN ❤️❤️❤️

[@jennifernadela3574]

Very nice piece as always from the legendary Bee Gees.

[@doolie165]

his attention was directed to the side of the stage because they had an audience intruder that was trying to get to them and security was dragging her off.