Benefit bad gal bang mascara Vs NYX worth the hype mascara | Is it a DUPE?

Hi lovelies,
Benefit bad gal bang mascara Vs NYX worth the hype mascara. Is the new Benefit mascara worth the hype and worth the money or is the NYX version just as good??
Products mentioned:
Benefit bad gal bang mascara
NYX worth the hype mascara
Lancome monsieur big mascara
Too faced better than sex mascara
FYIs!!
My skin is normal with a very slightly oily t zone and early signs of aging like fine lines as well as some sun damage and REDNESS!
My current good foundation shade matches are (Summer/Winter):
Fenty beauty shade - 290/240
Mac - NC30/NC25
Maybelline fit me matte and poreless - 220
Giorgio Armani luminous silk - 6/3.5
Clinique even better glow - Stone/Meringue
Estee Lauder - Dawn/Tawny
Dior Star - 021/031
L'oreal true match - W4/W5
Instagram: charholdcroft84
Twitter: charholdcroft84
Snapchat: charholdcroft
Business Inquiries: [e-mail]

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ok so both of these mascara have been on around 4 hours now and no transfer or smudging from either! 👌👌a few of you have commented feeling that i spent a lot more time on the benefit side hence why it looked better but please be aware that is just due to me cutting the footage down on the NYX side for time purposes!! I have learned from your feedback and wont do this again!! Thank you so much for the feedback xx

[@juliathomas5280]

Charlotte Holdcroft I've had the Benefit one on for 15 hours and no transfer at all. Lashes look as good now as they did 15 hours ago. I have very oily skin but it hasn't budged!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Julia Thomas wowee!!! I'm so glad it works for oily skin too!! I've worn it a few times now and no problems at all either xx

[@violetmoon6233]

Charlotte Holdcroft great review. They both look.great👏😍would you recommend a mascara for sensitive eyes.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Violet Moon hi hon! Thank You! I don't have sensitive eyes so I can't advise I'm afraid but I do know that no7 has a mascara especially for sensitive eyes which might be worth a try! X

[@kellykaelin8810]

Was this hard to remove though? I have a hard time removing benefit mascaras so I avoid them. But this looks amazing on you!!

[@Hundredacredaycare]

NYX is cruelty free too! Benefit isn’t

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

💜💜

[@marciasieber4844]

I just bought the Benefit mascara yesterday and can't wait to try it today! Love your videos!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Marcia sieber ooooh let me know how you like it!! Thank you so much! Xx

[@anetanovakova3965]

Marcia sieber Have you tried it yet? Is it good?

[@AshleyMartinez-lw9zr]

You are great. I really appreciate how thorough you are and really talk it all out. Beautiful transitions or just flow of communication and voice. You’re stunning!

[@stephanien9152]

Your eyeshadow looks stunning !

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you Stephanie!! Xx

[@ruthlinington979]

I too have tried literally hundreds of mascaras & ALWAYS come back to Bad Gal Bang. I can vouch for the waterproof claim - my sister & I got caught in the storm of the year & my mascara did not let me down. Amazing.

[@BrookelynnesBeautyCorner]

That benefit mascara looks amazing can you do a comparison video of that mascara and Lancôme Monsiour big? Xx

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

BeautyAddict92 oooooh yes like a champion of champions! 🤣

[@BrookelynnesBeautyCorner]

Charlotte Holdcroft yes defo xx

[@dawnarabella11]

Trying to make a makeup shopping list and I stumbled upon this video. And I just gotta say thank you for both the great video, and for not putting any effects on the video and that you didn't hide your flaws! Subscribed!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You're so welcome!! Xx

[@Karaskorner123]

Very good review! I just got the NYX myself. You look beautiful! I’m a new subscriber!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Karaskorner thanks so much beautiful! Xx

[@DiamondGirlMW]

I so agree!! I use the NYX worth the hype is my ride or die. I loveeee it and use it daily. My second fav drug store is surprisingly by wet n wild. It's in a hot pink tube, called Max Volume plus. The wand literally looks just like the Benefit you were using. It gives me loads , tons of separation and length. I have never tried the roller lash, but I do have and love the Better than Sex . It is gorgeous but for the same reasons, I no longer reach for it because even before I have turned the light on my mirror off...the better than Sex has smudged all over the under eye and flaked and transferred to the upper lid as well. Another more expensive mascara that I like is by #Tarte...lights camera lashes. I like it a lot ...but the only one I grab for on the daily now is the NYX worth the hype! Loved this video...I do not wear falsies either and am always looking for a great mascara. ✌💖👏👏 Much love xxxx

[@1Bucsbabe]

Just bought the bad gal bang and it’s the best mascara hands down, I don’t have long lashes but I’m blown away with how long my lashes look & it doesn’t irritate or flake off like so many. Also I tried the sample size from ultra first to make sure it was a winner 👍🏽 I’m glad they offer mini’s 😊

[@Loralarify]

So WoW! Will have to try that Benefit mascara!!!!!! I’m all about big and luscious lashes also- but the bonus being they still felt soft really caught my ear! Thanks Charlotte!!❤️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You're welcome!! Hope you love it xx

[@emmmmg]

Your eye makeup in this video is stunning!!

[@Golds174]

Fantastic, detailed review, I already have the Benefit mascara, but am going to buy the NYX one after watching this.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks lovely xx

[@caitlinmorley384]

Oh and I just purchased the benefit mascara yesterday, it need to arrive quick!!!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Caitlin Morley fingers crossed you love it!! Xx

[@saharvarona]

Ooh....you should do a top 5 besyascaras series for DRUGSTORE and for HIGH END too!!!!! What's your fave durgstore mascara btw? :)

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Sahar Varona DEFINITELY!! XX

[@lorrainebecchetti4865]

LOVE THEM both but I LOVE the one that brought your lashe that made it looked like you had a great long and black. It looks beautiful on your eye. But I don't like the price. But it looked like the other eye only looked have done. Thank You SO MUCH FOR SHARING YOUR COMMENTS AND how the mascara works.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ha ha i know they're pretty pricey arent they!! You're so welcome thank you for yours!! Xx

[@balkangetaway]

The benefit looks more spidery which i don't like. it also looks heavy so it would weigh my lashes down i think

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Louise L hi hon, yes it is spidery but very light weight xx

[@cait333]

Louise L it’s super light actually! And it is spidery which makes it quite dramatic so I guess it’s not for everyone 😁

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Caitlin Rose it's definitely a love/hate product isn't it!! X

[@maritzagonzalez5324]

I like more the NYC because the benefit yes is longer but too clumpy

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Maritza Gonzalez benefit is definitely longer! I didn't find it clumsy but mascara is so personal isn't it!! Xx

[@katiehellon4970]

Bought this yesterday after watching this ! Benefit has outdone themselves with this one ! X

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Oh yes!! 👌👌

[@JustMe-zg7qo]

Girl.... You brushed the benefits side waaaaay more than you did the other one.😂😂😂😂

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovely, check my pinned comment. It's just unfortunate editing on my part! X

[@shanalee8469]

Rewatched you definitely plastered the benifit in the beginning

[@JasmineAirdelle]

I am OBSESSED!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Makeup by Jasmine Airdelle yayyyyyy!! 😙😙😙

[@heathersvanity8648]

Hi Charlotte! I also consider myself a mascara conessiour. Since I don't wear false lashes I'm always on the hunt for the next best mascara! Loving your videos.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ahhhh me too!! I've yet to find one that beats my monsieur big!! Xx

[@MichelleLewis1969]

I love the Lancome Monsieur Big, but not as much as I like the Benefit Bad Gal Bang. BGB seems to be WET in application but once you get past that wet mess, it dries beautiful and does give me lots of volume and length. It is the one I use every day. I have been trying to like Thrive Causemetics mascara but at this time, I'm not sure if I like it or not. Transferring mascaras get taken back to the store for a replacement of another kind of mascara. I love Lash Paradise, but it is a transfer nightmare for me. I wear contacts and I can't have it flaking into my eyes. I use Lash Discovery on my lower lashes to prevent transferring. Love the video!! :)

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Oh yeh I hate transfer that's a deal breaker....

[@asherakatze4611]

mascara is one of the few makeup things that I choose to go high-end for, and it's worth it. pretty much everything else I go drugstore, but i find drugstore mascara, at the end of the day it looks like it's just gone! like the darkness is still there (my lashes are blonde-ish), but the volume and definition is gone after a few hours. Im fine with paying 20 for mascara bc it doesn't disappear by the end of the day

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I never used to think it was justified until I tried monsieur big! X

[@savannahlawrence-davis6780]

I actually think the Nyx looks better. The Benefit was a lot clumpier first couple of coats.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I love a clump! 😂😂 its so personal isn't it! Xx

[@glittermafia5759]

The benefit side looks miles better, gorgeous!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Glitter Mafia I'm always rooting for the affordable option but sometimes you get what you pay for don't you!! Xx

[@glittermafia5759]

Charlotte Holdcroft you sure do! 🙌

[@HeidiAnn5]

Hello Charlotte!!! New subscriber here...#701!!! Whoo Hoo!! You came across my feed and I was very curious to see your reviews on this mascara. xoxo

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Heidi Ann hi beautiful!! Thank you so much I'm so happy to have you!! Xx

[@juliebarnes7425]

Hi from the US! I just found your channel. Gonna take a look around! My favorite mascara is Essence lash princess in the purple tube

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Julie Barnes hi Julie!! Thank you so much I hope you enjoy it!! I don't think we can get essence here 😌

[@eneums]

New sub here! Just picked up the Nyx one today. What are you wearing for shadow? It’s lovely.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Emily Wasley hi lovely thank you so much! Lovely to have you with me!! It's the modern renaissance palette xx

[@janetn9942]

What color eyeshadow are u wearing ? It’s so pretty ! Thanks for the video 👌🏻

[@Makeupbyrach18]

Janet N yes, I was wondering the same thing. The shadows are so nice! Just bought Badgal Bang, excited to try it out tomorrow!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ah thank you both! I used the modem renaissance palette shades buon fresco and Vermeer x

[@janetn9942]

Charlotte Holdcroft 😫😫 palettes are so expensive , I can never make myself buy one - it’s like over $60 here in Canada

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Janet N i think that's actually less than the UK conversion, here is £43 which would be 74 CAD according to Google!! 🙈 I got mine for my birthday but it is a lot cheaper than buying 12 singles that's how i think of it!! Xx

[@jda58tex]

Comparing different mascaras on different eyes would not be a fair. My eyelashes are sisters, not twins. They are just too different to compare in this way.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

REALLY?!!! I have NEVER heard that before (brows obviously lashes never!). I don't have any noticeable differences between mine at all that have ever made any difference to how they look using mascara. So on my eyelashes personally I'd say it's pretty fair! xx

[@lup6974]

jda58tex hahaaa, like some ladies have a bad hair day, I'm expecting bad eyelash day even though they are sister, one side is miss behaving lol

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

😂😂

[@jda58tex]

Mine are fine and curly. The right eye is thicker and my left are longer, plus the outer lashes curl back on themselves . By far applying mascara takes the most time in my makeup application. the struggle is real :)

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

jda58tex no way!! How frustrating. Why do our faces do these things!! Xx

[@iuliaolteanu335]

I have really long lashes and I was so excited to try the NYX mascara and the only problem I have with this mascara (which I love) is that I need to be super careful applying because if I apply too much my lashes would be too long, I mean, with only one layer of mascara my lashes almost touch my eyebrows

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

That is an AWESOME problem to have lol! If you used the bad gal bang you'd probably take off!! Xx

[@nicolethomson912]

Will Defos try the NYX after watching this. I bought the benefit one a while ago and love how it looks but it smudges everywhere on me and I've never had a mascara do that before so was really disappointed. When wearing I became so self conscious when talking to people as I just knew it was everywhere and when i looked in the mirror i was right :( xxx

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Oh no!!!! Isn't that strange, the Too Faced better than sex does that to me, but tons of people love it!! Xx

[@tantiaglae1043]

The benefit side looks better because she applied more of it to begin with...didin't anybody saw that? Geez

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovely, lots of people have made the same comment lol!! You're not alone!! Unfortunately as i previously explained i edited the footage down to keep time down and so it looks like i spent more time on the benefit side 🙈i have learned my lesson and didnt do that for my last mascara comparison so thank you for the feedback! Xx

[@kristelm.3812]

I prefer the Nyx one, looks better, more natural, I mean, where can you go with the Benefit mascara with 3 coats? Its too much, (looks kind of cheap to me), unless only with 1 coat, max 2.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Anywhere you want lol. I love huge lashes and have mine like that every day x

[@michellinda25]

Buying the benefit to tomorrow😍😍 I love the Monsieur so I'm sure I'll love this

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Diiva Ma I hope you love it just as much! Xx

[@michellinda25]

Charlotte Holdcroft I love it. My new holy grail thanks to you😘

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Diiva Ma oh yayyyyyy that makes me so happy!! Xx

[@ShaleaNelson1]

Which mascara was easiest to remove, Benefit or Nyxx?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Shalea Nelson hi lovely neither was particularly difficult! Both were harder than 'better than sex' which is very easy but they weren't particularly tough xx

[@jessica-repadrnos9976]

Can you do a video of how you did you make-up? It looks beautiful and I would love to know how to do that!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you lovely! Sorry the video is really old I've no idea what i used! I know I have modern renaissance palette on my eyes but otherwise not sure xx

[@YvonnePollard]

Hey Charlotte,love your videos! I've subscribed here and to your Instagram aswell. Do you use a lash serum or anything like that? Your eyelashes are beautiful! 😊

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yvonne Pollard thank you so much lovely!! I don't I'm just lucky! Xx

[@Debbie7351]

It sounds like you mainly use high end, but I was wondering if you have tried any of the Essence mascaras? I like the Lash Princess False Lash and didn't like Lash Paradise which everyone else liked (maybe mine was bad). I am curious if there is anything that is even more like false lashes in drug store. You did a very good review and the Benefit looked awesome. I just don't buy high end.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yes I'm definitely in high end girl!! I have tried the green essence one and didn't get on well with it at all sadly. The Rimmel wonder wings is very good and of course maybelline lash sensational! I have reviews of both xx

[@melsue1026]

First coat definitely put way more of the benefit on

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Melissa Huff Hi lovely, i think that's just because of the edit that i cut out some of the application. I did a good coat of both til i was happy so I'm sure it wasn't exactly the same but bare in mind i cut out some of the NYX application xx

[@thelondongreatescape]

Just subbed the moment I heard you are obsessed with mascaras, just as I am. Have you tried any of the Chanel ones? Lancome (oh the Doll Eyes) and Chanel (Le Volume and Dimensions) were my faves (along with better than sex of course) but I picked up BadGal Bang and I'm loving it. It's just incredible. I have problems with the clumping though. I live for massive lashes but can't stand the clumps. Yours didn't look like that and you didn't brush them in between...? (I do). Do you have a technique? Mine is very similar to yours but I'm still getting clumps! Too much product? Anyway, loved the video!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

thelondongreatescape yayyy so glad to have you!! I LOVE mascara he he! I haven't tried any chanel yet I need to! I haven't had any clumping issues with the benefit but I'm definitrly going to do a mascara routine soon because I feel like I've nailed my technique over the years and have lots to share lol x

[@thelondongreatescape]

Charlotte Holdcroft YES PLEASE DO I'M ALREADY EXCITED!!! love anything mascara related and always looking for ways to get bigger better nicer lashes!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

thelondongreatescape on it...😙

[@HeatherGerhardt]

I have a dupe as well that works just as well as the benefit. plus it's 20 bucks cheaper! Love both but I am saving my money for other stuff.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I never used to bother with high end mascara until monsieur big it's changed my life lol! Xx

[@monicakoutsoukos5697]

👍 great I’m looking for a good non transfer mascara, I think this will help me, I’m going to try both , will let you know ~

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yes please!! Xx

[@SydneyChow30]

What blush are you wearing?! I'm loving the color on you!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Sydney Chow hi lovely it's mac coppertone! Thank you xx

[@Missquichante]

What is on your cheeks? The blush and bronzer? I love the color! Thxx

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Missquichante thank you sweetheart! It's too faced chocolate soleil and macs coppertone blush xx

[@beautymaroccain1157]

Volume mascara bangal bang from benefit i love it 😍 😍 😍

[@angelabarnes5904]

Can I ask the eyeshadow shades pls?

[@tashabella3902]

wauw love your eyes and make up.. especially the lids and lips. what do you wear on the lips?? :)))

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Tasha Bella thank you sweetheart! It's mac really me xx

[@gloriasalsman1017]

Love the colors of eye shadows you have on, what's the brand and colors if you don't mind?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovely, thank you so much! It's the ABH modern renaissance palette shades buon fresco and vermeer xx

[@anjeliiique8384]

I bought the nyx one the day it came out so I’ve been using it for a while I love the length it gives me but I noticed it does flake

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

anjelique eurgh how annoying!! I haven't had any flaking with it I hate that so much! X

[@janetn9942]

I just caved and finally bought this mascara tonight I’m nervous - my lashes are so crazy sensitive -‘I’m just really hoping it doesnt smudge or transfer -‘that’s my Biggest issue with non waterproof and even some waterproof 😫 Btw you have gorgeous lashes and I love the color on your eyes - What is it?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovely, should be listed in the description box x

[@gloriasalsman1017]

Hello, I asked plus there other ladies asking what brand of eye shadow and colors you are wearing'

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Gloria Salsman Hi hon, I've replied to your comment and all others who have asked! Its the ABH modern renaissance palette Xx

[@skyology13]

What eyeshadow are you wearing? Thanks for the review.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovely, it was the modern renaissance palette Xxx

[@MosleydollMUA]

So which would you say is better out of the maybelline lash sensational or the NYX? Xx also do you find the benefit one to be a bit clumpy? I did 😭😭😭

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Mosleydoll78 they're very different! So it depends what your preference is! I'd still probably prefer my lash sensational as it's more similar to the benefit but the NYX is very similar to the Too Faced so if you like that look better then go with the NYX! I didn't find it clumpy at all!! Xx

[@MosleydollMUA]

Thanks hunni! Xx

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Mosleydoll78 of course! X

[@TheKimarion]

First coat ypu spent longer on the benefit side!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Kimarion Dallas hi lovely I can't say I was timing it, just did what I felt was a good coat on both sides!! But I did also cut the application in the edit to keep it to a minimum so it wasn't as big a difference as it may look x

[@stephanyhoffman6875]

In your opinion, would you rather badgirl bang or monsieur big mascara?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Stephany Hoffman I THINK I'd still go with my Monsieur big but I need to give this one more chance as I've had that and loved it a lot longer (on my 3rd one!) Xx

[@tatum5645]

hiiiiiii! So I’m watching this video and I’m wondering if either of these would be good for my lashes. I have lashes that naturally are very long but pretty thin, but the downside is that they stick straight out and almost down a bit. If these aren’t good for them do you know some that are?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Tatum Carrasco hi hon! The main benefit (pardon the pun) of the bad gal is that it's extremely lenghtening, not mich volume really but it is very lifting also. I think roller lash may be a better fit as it's more volumising and very lifting as well xx

[@tatum5645]

Charlotte Holdcroft thank you 💛💛💛

[@cait333]

Tatum Carrasco the benefit would be perfect for that! I have it and it works sooo good because it really thickens and lengthens the lashes and lifts them so it would make them look long and thick and even like you curled them when you didn’t hope that helped💕

[@EverydayKitten]

definitely my next mascara buy! ^^

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

So good....xx

[@IamIceQueen7]

i needed this ! thank you

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

IamIceQueen7 you're very welcome! Xx

[@salsabil8265]

I want to get the benefit one but my concern is that it wont hold my curl and it would just fall. Do you think it would hold my curl?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovely, I haven't noticed any issues with that, it feels really lightweight so I think it should! Why not try the smaller size first xx

[@amandaslominski3972]

You’ve probably already made your choice, but I just bought this and I was playing with it and didn’t even curl my lashes and it still looked amazing! I think it even added some curl!

[@candiechatman3316]

New subscriber already love your video I love mascara too

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Candie Chatman oh thank you so much!! Xx

[@thejennifercatherine]

The benefit side looks li spider legs.. 😢😢

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Jennifer Grasso 😂😂

[@BethanyRoseYT]

Really enjoyed this! I just posted the same video and I'm obsessed! XO

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

BethanyRose thank you so much sweetheart! X

[@honeybeebumbleful]

Really good review!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Fia Jackson thank you beautiful! Xx

[@gennyjones87]

Have you tried loreal lash paradise?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Genevieve Jones hi lovely, no I haven't yet!! Xx

[@gennyjones87]

Charlotte Holdcroft it’s essentially l’oreals version of too faced better than sex but it is waterproof and doesn’t flake

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Genevieve Jones yes I've heard that!! Xx

[@fyi_beauty]

The Badgal bang didn’t work as well for me 😫 xxx

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

FYI Beauty awww no way!! How annoying!! It's definitely not what I expected AT ALL from the description!! Much more lengthening than volumising but I'm enjoying it! xx

[@shanalee8469]

You layered the benifit more

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Check my Pinned comment x

[@caitlinmorley384]

Your so pretty!!!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Caitlin Morley thank you so much so are you!! 😙😙

[@gretad.herring2860]

Caitlin Morley. D

[@BobbieLovesBeauty]

Thanks for the review

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you for watching!! Xx

[@yenu4230]

Is it water proof or water resistant?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yen Ü hi there, benefit claims to be water resistant, nyx is not xx

[@ashleyhadfield7786]

I would love to see you review Younique's Epic mascara👍

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ashy Kae hi lovely I tried it ages ago and didn't like it!! Left little specks all over my face 😮

[@rebbypeg3967]

is the nyx one waterproof?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Kaitlin P. Hi lovely, no it's not xx

[@kerrymaupin1771]

Wow both are amazing!!! Now which one to buy....or maybe I’ll get both!! 😍😍😂😂

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Kerry Maupin ha he that is usually my solution! Xx

[@estrella264]

Omg I want this so bad

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Itsjust Me ha ha at least they do the little ones so you can save some bucks!! X

[@crystalvela9681]

You should try the lash paradise by loreal, it’s a total dupe for the two faced better than sex mascara! (:

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Crystal Vela ooooh thanks for the tip!! Xx

[@donnagrammas7584]

3rd coat looks like fuzzy spiders. 2 coats good.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Donna Grammas 😂😂 3 all the way for me!! Xx

[@moushmeshmesh5088]

This mascara leaves annoying mascara marks under my eyes

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

moush meshmesh oh no!! How strange I haven't had any transfer at all but I hate that!! Xx

[@hannahdavies6169]

compare to better than sex! please!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hannah Davies hi lovely I don't get on with better than sex at all! It's very similar to the nyx but it transfers badly on me! Xx

[@hannahdavies6169]

Charlotte Holdcroft, hi! I’ve definitely heard really mixed feedback on Better than Sex so I totally understand! Thank you for this review by the way, super helpful 💕💕

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hannah Davies YES! Lots of people love it so I was really disappointed it didn't work for me! X

[@michellepack4134]

L'Oreal lash paradise!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Michelle Pack ha ha, what about it?? 😙😙

[@michellepack4134]

I feel like it's the closest to the too faced better then sex and don't feel like it transfers cause that always happens to me especially on lower lashes

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Michelle Pack ahhh I see!! Ha ha. Yeh the better than sex transfers on me too! But i dont usually have that problem just with that one! X

[@michellepack4134]

Sorry totally got distracted from what I was first saying once you started putting on that Bang mascara 😄🤗 it's awesome and yoour lashes are banging

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Michelle Pack 🤣🤣

[@sherrymorrow2517]

I cringe watching all these girls applying mascara. Wiggling, blinking onto brush and applying more than one coat just causes a huge mess.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I disagree, I apply it exactly in the way I want to to achieve exactly the look i want. That's how I like to wear mascara, it's makeup and completely personal preference xx