Lancome Monsieur Big mascara vs Benefit Bad Gal Bang mascara | Which is the best for massive lashes?

Lancome Monsieur Big mascara Vs Benefit bad gal bang mascara
Hi lovelies,
So as you know I am a HUGE mascara addict!! I have done a couple of mascara battles and the lancome monsieur big and Benefit bad gal bang were the two winners. They are both dramatic mascaras right up my street, so I wanted to know which one was going to give me the ultimate huge lashes!! Let the battle commence...
Products mentioned:
Lancome monsieur big mascara
Benefit bad gal bang mascara
Makeup worn:
Lancome teint idole ultra wear foundation
Too faced chocolate soleil bronzer
Makeup revolution fast base F14 to contour
Makeup revolution concealer C5
Mac honeylove lipstick
Lancome monsieur big mascara
Anastasia beverly Hills soft glam palette
Hourglass vanish highlighting stick in champagne flash
Mac oyster girl lipgloss
FYIs!!
My skin is normal with a very slightly oily t zone and early signs of aging like fine lines as well as some sun damage and REDNESS!
My current good foundation shade matches are (Summer/Winter):
Fenty pro filt'r - 240/180
Mac studio fix - NC30/NC25
Nars sheer glow - Strombolli/Punjab
Giorgio Armani luminous silk - 6/3.5
Clinique even better glow - Stone/Meringue
Estee Lauder double wear - Tawny/Dawn
Dior Star - 031/021
L'oreal true match - W5/W4
Instagram: charholdcroft84
Twitter: charholdcroft84
Snapchat: charholdcroft
Business Inquiries: [e-mail]

[@mw5425]

And you're right, for me, no such thing as too dramatic. I want my eyelashes to look FAKE, everyday, lol.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yayyyyyyyyy same!!! X

[@jax4868]

I like the Lancome effect more

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Me too, I don't think I'll ever beat it! Xx

[@Golds174]

I rarely buy anything recommended by so called Beauty influencers on KZbin because their views are often very favourable in return for all expenses trips and freebies, but this was a very honest review, and I appreciate that xx

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you so much, i appreciate you too!! Xxx

[@hristinaandonoska1433]

I like the Lancome better, your lashes look longer and as you said fluffier, more voluminous, but with the Benefit looks like the mascara is too wet, so if someone (me) has fewer lashes it will clump them together....But I can't compare because I have only used the monsieur big (and I love it), and not benefit :D lovely review by the way :)

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi beauty! Yeh i totally agree! All time face xx

[@lubazak636]

I love Monsieur Big, all the way!! It’s my HG as well.

[@miaclement7147]

I'm actually quite disappointed in Benefits Bad Gal Bang mascara. It's way too wet and clumps together my lashes already at the first coat even though I wiped off quite a bit of the mascara before applying it to my lashes. I haven't tried the Monsieur Big mascara so I can't compare the two of them. I know that it's a no-go to pump the mascara wand but I'll try to do that over the next couple of days and hope that the formula of the mascara will be easier to work with.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Oh no I'm sorry its not working for you lovely! It IS wet i know what you mean, have you tried blinking down on it instead of wiggling?? If that makes any sense....😂

[@miaclement7147]

Charlotte Holdcroft I know exactly what you mean! It really doesn't matter how I apply the mascara - it's still the same result. It's almost like it glues some of my lashes together and that's just not a cute look for me. I actually had the same problem with Roller Lash and ended up giving the mascara to a neighbour. Luckily, I only bought the small version of Bad Gal Bang and not the full size. I've tried so many different mascaras over the years, hoping to find the Holy grail of mascaras but I always go back to L'Oreal False Lash Wings in waterproof. Unfortunately it has been quite challenging to find it whereIusually buy it - I live in Denmark - and I worry that it has been discontinued. Luckily. I can still find it online 😉

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Nightmare!! I always feel benefit mascaras get better when they've been opened a while for some reason! Glad you didn't waste too much money! Xx

[@nourjamous947]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft agree.. When I first bought bad gal I didn't like it but I gave it a chance and after a while it became amaaaazing.. When u change the mascara, the application should change a bit ( in my opinion) and you will be happy with it.. I used to apply the mascara from both sides of lashes but because my lashes are very long but thin so I just found that applying of bad gal should only be from the front side only and apply a bit of mascara at the back of the top of my lashes not all the way from down to top.. That way it worked amazing for me.. Very light and soft on the lashes.. 😘😘

[@HebaS]

Oooo that’s a tough call. They both look great. I love the mr big. And I LOVE putting several coats on lol. The more the better lol. Great video ❤️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yes agree!! More is more! Lol xx

[@mw5425]

Thank you for doing this! I was struggling to decide which I loved more. I find the benefit bad gal dries out faster which is a bummer. I think it's the Lancome for me.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You're very welcome lovely!! I definitely think the lancome stays good for a looooong time for mascara, it gets even better with age! Xx

[@jessicashaulis7466]

They are both so good! Great idea to pair them for a side by side comparison. I can't decide which one looks better.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I know! I felt like i was choosing between my children! 😂😂

[@jemmamatthews9161]

I am a one coat girl and love the bad girl bang mascara, but judging from your review the Mr Big won. It looked very much like false eyelashes and framed the eye better. Xx 😊

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

You can get so much drama in one coat from either of these which is so good when you're in a rush! Yeh i agree i think it pipped it!! Xx

[@larinadorca5781]

The Hypnose mascara from Lancôme's my fave of all the time.

[@valentinamose]

The bad gal bang is my favorite mascara ever: I discovered it thanks to one of your videos and it works fabulously on my short and straight lashes. I love it so much that I recently bought 3 pieces thanks to a Sephora discount just to be sure to never be without it! 😂😘

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Its such a good one!! Xx

[@Mcoogie]

Same with me! Its my ride or die. The brush is nice and small, quick, and performs.

[@Mcoogie]

I'm now wondering how that new magnetic one compares to bad gal...but no one is comparing the two..

[@tb102775]

Great review Luv the zoom in

[@carolroe9586]

Thats what i like about the Bad Gal bang, its quick!

[@1savdsoul439]

HSN has the Monsieur big mascara buy two + eye make up remover for 29.99 today. They are offering AutoShip! Your left eye looks bomb!

[@michellemakeupandnails]

I spoke too soon LOL you are correct, for me, which I am a one-coater, for me I do think the Benefit one is better at one coat- I will keep on with my badgalbang then :D

[@elizabethsmith583]

LMB looks amazing ✨🇦🇺🌺

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I think so too! Xx

[@sonjawilliams989]

I would be a wierdo and use the badgirl as a first coat, then use MB for the second coat to have the best of both 😂

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ha ha love it!! X

[@reshmisaha]

Lancome side looks way better than the benefit one. I have tried a lot of mascaras too and my all time fav is marc jacobs velvet noir and. I think monsieur big is going to be the next one i try.

[@stephanyhoffman6875]

Yes!!!! Awesome thank you for doing this!

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Ha ha you're very welcome!! Xx

[@michellemakeupandnails]

@9:19 ok, I was thinking it was neck to neck in the race until this moment right here, Lancome still wins! wow! It was barely ahead the whole time, and I was secretly routing for the Bad Gal Bang bc I like the brush more, but my true-blue Lancome, still is the top dog! :D thank you for this video *I know I am way late to this party, as this video is super old but it is relevant to ME right now lol xo

[@dahliam.gonzalezgonzalez4572]

Lancome is better❤❤❤❤

[@bugsybaby4944]

Have you tried to switch the brushes and see how the formulas perform

[@susylopez9308]

Man this one is a hard one. I too like them both and can probably use them depending on the shadow look. I'm jealous of your lashes, I had long lashes and dumb me made the mistake of getting extensions, well when the extensions started to fall out so did my natural lashes 😩. Oh well, you live and learn. Bye bye bye, mua mua mua.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I know it was very tough!! Ah thank you!! I can't believe that happened to you what a nightmare! 😚😚😚

[@Foxy-rm3qv]

I love your eyeshadow! Do you find the monsoir big flakes?

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thank you! No not at all xx

[@Hogwartskid]

How do you clean off the bad girl bang, it drives me nuts when it’s time to clean my face.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi lovely! I use clinique take the day off!! Xx

[@julianursten6399]

Have you watched Mel Thompson’s tutorial on “My natural lashes” tips etc. You also have lovely long lashes and I think you’ll find it interesting

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

No I'm very happy with my lashes! X

[@jacquelinewatson3479]

Hi Charlotte your eyelashes are lovely,do you get panda eyes and smudging,if you do how do you prevent it x

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I don't!! I think its a skin type thing probably x

[@moniquehorishny6292]

Lancome looks best

[@thelondongreatescape]

Can't decide which one I like best! I've only tried Bad Gal Bang but I might need to get me the Monsieur Big. My concern with both is the lumps. I guess I'm asking too much out of a mascara Love your mascara videos, they are giving tons of tips and ideas regarding what to buy next!(as you know I LOOOOOOOOOVE mascara)

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yeh its so hard to choose! I think the main thing is to keep brushing through and let each coat set to avoid too much build up!! Xx

[@thelondongreatescape]

Charlotte Holdcroft That's what I do too. I also put a single coat, meaning I just brush the mascara on once to avoid getting too much. It really does help!

[@oololaliciousoo9914]

Monsieur big is nicer

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

I agree xx

[@melaniecarter6014]

LMB for me x it's very close

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

It is!! Xx

[@glammedbynatalia]

Benefit for sure. I just got the Lancôme and I may return it. The best drug store máscaras are essence.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Really?? My monsieur big is my holy grail...I'm on about my 6th tube!! Lol. I've never got on with any of the essence ones sadly, we must have different lashes!! x

[@Mcoogie]

Bad gal all the way.

[@kuangray3581]

My lashes look spidery and the volume drops after a while when I use bad gal

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

So annoying!! Xx

[@Fudezen]

What do you use for your lower lashes? xoxo

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Hi there, I used the same mascaras on top and bottom x

[@Fudezen]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft Thank you. I have really tiny bottom lashes.... nearly non-existent hence I really struggle to find a mascara for my bottom lashes... for the top i like MR. Big 😁😁😁... do you recommend anything for tiny bottom lashes? thank you ❤️❤️❤️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

@@Fudezen MB is my absolute fave! I have the opposite problem so I cant offer much help I'm afraid as i have to be very careful as mine are so long! X

[@Fudezen]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft luckyyyyyy!!!!!! Thank you anyhow xoxo