Best Carry On Luggage: 7 Bags Tested Head-to-Head

I bought 7 carry-on bags to give you a completely unbiased review of the best carry-on luggage on the market. The bags considered are all hard-sided luggage and are marketed as carry-on sized.
In this video, I compare the AWAY carry on, Beis carry on, Calpak Hue carry on, July Carry-On Essential, LEVEL8 Cases Textured Carry-On, MONOS Carry-On, and the Nomatic Carry-On Classic. Who won???
LINKS TO THE BAGS MENTIONED
MONOS: shrsl.com/47dbp
LEVEL8: bit.ly/level8c... (Use code "awaytogether" for an extra 10% off your order)
JULY: go.shopmy.us/p...
NOMATIC: bit.ly/nomatic...
BEIS: bit.ly/beiscar...
AWAY: go.shopmy.us/p...
CALPAK: bit.ly/calpakc...
***
Some product links are affiliate links which means if you buy something we'll receive a small commission.
OTHER GREAT RESOURCES:
The Best VPN for Travel:
get.surfshark....
Free Carry-On Only Packing List:
awaytogether.c...
Best Merino Wool Clothing:
shrsl.com/4ews6
TRAVEL TIP VIDEOS:
How we Pack for Full Time Travel:
• How to Pack for Long T...
Our Amazon Travel Must Haves:
• Amazon Travel MUST HAV...
Allie's TSA-Approved Toiletry Bag:
• TSA Carry-On and Liqui...
How to Find Cheap Flights:
• How to BOOK CHEAP FLIG...
How to Survive Long Haul Flights:
• How to Survive Long Ha...
***
At Away Together, our mission is to help DIY travelers like you plan, afford, and enjoy better travel with your friends and loved ones.
Please SUBSCRIBE to follow along:
bit.ly/3ApRy2W
#packing #carryonluggage

[@johndekalb3599]

Those "expansion" zippers are actually "compression" zippers. You're supposed to pack with the zipper open, then after you close your bag, you compress your bag by zipping the compression zipper back up. Cheers.

[@whiskeyntechno1807]

Mindblown haha, never used an expandable luggage.

[@roniesueullrich4649]

@johndekalb3599.....this is really good to know. Thanks for mentioning

[@ducatidoc]

I can confirm that the bigger carryon Away, I used the expansion zipper for a compression "feature" even though they didn't advertise it... Worked great!

[@NomadByNecessity]

Using the zippers as a compression technique is just a hack.. it's intended use is clearly stated by the manufacturers as an expensive feature for when limitations on weight or size won't be enforced.. e.g road trips. A zip will always be a zip and straining it that much continuously over time will wear it out.

[@kerrierohr9341]

Yes!!!!

[@alexander6762]

I work for TSA Baggage and Checkpoint, I will say that most damaged bags are hard shell. TSA does not damage the bags as we dont throw them. As far as what the ground workers that throw bags onto the aircrafts do, no comment lol. Also, the amount you pay doesnt reflect anything. Those LOUIS VUITTON and GUCCI bags get damaged the same. You have to think that it's all plastic... $5 plastic or $5,000 plastic makes no difference. TSA locks are great, but, as a traveller, I never felt the need to lock my bags as they are always with me or the airlines. Most stolen items are the entire bag themselves locked or not. If someone wants access to your bag, it's going to get opened once they steal the entire bag. Heres what I say is better: 1) Soft Shell because the zipper is usually in the front and you dont have to worry about two sides at the same time when the hardshells are split in half. 2) No Gimicky features like a pull out closet or things that add more weight. (For the love of humanity, don't get those electronic suit cases that drive around) 3) TSA locks are great when we need to look inside, and you do not want your bags damaged. Again, no real need to lock your bags unless you're staying at a hotel and want to keep everything inside your bag. Again 2x they will steal the entire thing as opposed to grabbing a few items. 4) Rotating wheels!!! Why the f* do they still make bags with stationary wheels? You can pull and push your rotating wheels the same plus more. 5) The less pockets, the easier it is to find and pack everything. 6) LIGHTWEIGHT. MINIMAL IS KEY. I know they try to market all of these extra features with neat pockets and extra tech like USB ports. Don't be that douche bag. BUT BUT BUT BUT... I will say, that MONOS bag you recommend is really cool. The anti-shake design of the handle is already the best feature for me personally. That blows the other ones out of the water with that feature alone.

[@rachelperrone1260]

What’s a suitcase you recommend then?

[@christopherlazo2064]

@@rachelperrone1260 lol real question

[@1kitts]

What's your recommended all-time suitcase then? PS: I was sold on to the hard case suitcase and thought it was the best as it protects your stuff.

[@chrisstory563]

blame the tech youtubers who love the crap out of bags that have use ports. they love charging the ever loving crap out of there gear. you know, laptop, phone, tablet, camera, and etc.

[@spocksvulcanbrain]

I agree with all but #4. I posted a comment above before reading you post so will repeat it here: I don't understand this obsession with spinner wheels. Those count toward the dimensions for overhead bin use and take away a LOT of storage space inside the bag. I'd rather have a 2 wheeled bag that goes all the way to the ground giving 2 or 3 more inches of storage capacity. If someone is so lazy they can't pull a two-wheeled bag but have to push (harder by the way) a 4-wheeled spinner bag, then perhaps you're carrying too much.

[@CarpeDiemTravelerMel]

When I was looking for a new carry on bag, I went back and forth between Monos and July, and ultimately it came down to the weight factor. July was the lightest which is important to me as a solo female traveler. I traveled through 4 countries in Europe with it and it did very well. Overall it is a great bag. Thanks for the review!

[@plramirez2449]

so did you have any issues with zippers, shipping costs, warranty or the trolley pass through not fitting? I'm really considering this because of it's durable exterior

[@s3uoq]

Unfortunately July under quote their bag weights, I bought their checked luggage and it's 850g heavier than claimed. They tried to say that 2 of the included features are optional but one is non removable without a lot of work and also even after removed still 500g over quoted weight.

[@CarpeDiemTravelerMel]

@@plramirez2449 I have had no issues with the carry-on size that I purchased. The wheels held up great on cobblestones and other rough surfaces , and the zippers slide very smooth.

[@Frasianfamily]

@@s3uoqI watched another video where the person weighed the July bag and also said it was much heavier than advertised.

[@s3uoq]

@michelleassous Do you have a link for that video please.

[@shabbyLaw]

Out of all of the luggage reviews I've ever seen this is the best and most accurate. I am a luggage whore and I've had experiences with many of these bags. You are right on the money.

[@JD-hv5ik]

Respectfully, I completely disagree with your love of the Monos handle. I have a Monos carry on with the front access pocket. The button underneath is ANNOYING. Rolling it around the airport I find it’s constantly collapsing on me because the button is where you put pressure on the handle when you move it around. It’s a good bag, but that button location is the worst. Won’t buy another one.

[@undefeatedgaul3201]

So we recommended the brand with THE WORST customer service & warranty on the market lmfao monos is a dogshit company

[@parthmalhotra4922]

The Samsonite Freeform Carry-on is a worthy contender to add to this list. I own a monos carry on which I love and my wife has the samsonite. I don’t find them significantly different to justify the additional premium for the monos. You can get the Samsonite for $150 and it is just as sturdy and well built. Also, with Samsonite’s network of physical stores, getting the bag repaired would be much easier. My friends with Monos and Away bags had warranty claims that took months to get resolved and in Away’s case, they sent the part which my friend then had to take to a local store to get installed and had to pay for the installation. It is interesting that most carry-on comparisons on the internet are not even considering legacy brands like Samsonite and I myself didn’t consider it when I was getting my carry on but after using my wife’s carryon on a few trips, I would recommend Samsonite just as much as I would recommend the Monos.

[@jerrycote659]

Very good points. I’ve read excellent reviews of the Samsonite Freeform in various publications and it has consistently drawn praise and high marks. It’s curious how it hasn’t achieved the same recognition on the various YT channels specific to travel and baggage.

[@milesbuckhurst504]

I only buy Samsonite and as an intercontinental traveler with decades of travel. Samsonite is without question the best in terms of life (guarantees only matter if the bag fails). And I thought they were expensive until I saw the prices here - it’s economy yet the best. Maybe it’s because they are European produced???

[@anagoldstein1453]

Samsonite is not chic enough - it's your parents bag- that's probably why- I've flown weekly for work and I have a Samsonite soft case- nothing wrong with it

[@alfiefernandez7271]

I had to return the Freeform because it doesn’t work with International airline’s requirements, like Air Canada and all the European airlines

[@alfiefernandez7271]

@@jerrycote659because it doesn’t meet the size requirements of all International airlines like Air Canada and the European airlines. I had to return mine. Not even American Airlines and some domestic, it’s 23 inches in height, most airlines have a 22.5 inch limit

[@alexmanigat]

Great vid! Would like to add - the extendable zipper works for the winter trips, which can mean bulkier clothes. It allows you to extend the bag, seamlessly close it, and THEN close the extender without struggle. And this is coming from someone who is deathly allergic to overpacking.

[@MarlaDeeCS]

EXCELLENT Review - I am just so impressed with your clear guidance and sense of humor Nik!! I have been researching this same topic for the last 2 months. I did end up choosing Monos and it is a gorgeous (and high quality) bag. I also got the clear luggage cover. Thanks for all your value!

[@tonylaudin3777]

My wife and I just got back three days ago after a 25-day trip around the UK and Ireland with 2 Level8 textured carry-ons we purchased right before the trip. We chose carry-on sized bags not so much for the airplane, but for the ability to fit into the luggage compartments of compact car rentals, which we felt more comfortable driving on the tiny roads and negotiating the narrow ramps and tiny parking garage spaces in Europe. After being in the baggage compartments on five flights, lugged around in three rental cars, and checked in and out of 15 hotels, we've got nothing but love for these bags. With available discounts, we got two bags for just a little more than the price of one of the other of your top picks, so definitely agree they have the most bang for the buck. We also got two sets of the Level8 organizers, which after looking around at other choices, we ended up purchasing because they are sized exactly right to fit into the Level8 suitcase. Again, price of one bag plus the organizer set came out cheaper than the price of one of the other bags. To me, having that organizer set is comparable to the 'bells and whistles' features of the other finalists. I'll finish by saying that some of the tips in your other videos were extremely helpful and contributed greatly to the success of our trip. Thanks!!!

[@ctalhame]

I bought the Monos Plus a couple years ago after doing a ton of research. I absolutely love it. My husband loved mine so much that I bought him one. We've taken the Plus international and had no issues. It's such a smooth suitcase, there's no issue moving it around. I always recommend it to friends who are looking for new suitcases.

[@raeleohana8797]

When you say you've taken it Internationally, by any chance do you recall the airlines? Not Ryan or TAP, I assume? Do you just mean, like Virgin and British Airways, bigger more comfortable lines?

[@USMCPFC1]

​@raeleohana8797 I've done Delta, air france, aero Mexico, American Airlines. Same carry-on.

[@Lisa-kz7vw]

Love my Monos luggage great brand 😊

[@rl1111rl]

Please do the same for soft-sided carry ons.

[@AnaKutuz]

no crash test nothing useful just adv

[@AP20009]

It’s unfortunately (for me) that hard shell suitcases are overtaking the market, because the pros and cons still doesn’t outweigh the versatility and functionality of a soft shell. Even for waterproofing reasons…I’ve seen a lot of busted up hardsells at baggage claim, so durability and water sealing doesn’t seem all that great imo. Please luggage companies, DO NOT stop making quality soft shell options. There are still customers who prefer it over the new disposable trend!

[@AP20009]

@@mattymatt1 good to know which materials wouldn’t crack, but some get really scratched the hell up by the conveyor systems and manual handling by airport staff. I love the idea of multiple outside pockets. It’s rare to see a hard shell with that feature…if they do, it’s probably only one pocket that isn’t very deep or flexible. I also hate the way most, if not all, hard shells open. You have to pull the zipper through the dirty wheels and fully to the other side to get anything out. I can unzip a shoftshell 1/3 of the way and get things out due to the flex nature of the suitcase. Also, the slit half concept of hard shells takes up more real estate when opened. If I’m against the wall with a soft shell, I could open the lid of the suitcase and occupy half of the floor space than a hard shell would. Hard shell usually lack internal compartment also, thus forcing you to buy packing cubes, etc.. Most soft shells multiple internal compartments to store items that doesn’t take away from the main packing space. I get it, it’s all a preference. Therefore companies need to continue to produce quality soft shells at a decent level of option variety for those who still prefer it over hard shell.

[@lucasdnln]

Soft shell all the way!

[@Heyu7her3]

And waterproofing is only pertinent if your luggage falls into a body of water. Which, at that point... 🥴 🤷🏽‍♀️ Just purchase a plastic luggage cover.

[@shirleymcdaniel8344]

I’m curious to see the cost of manufacturing the hard shell vs. soft shell. (Ie hard shell using a molding process, more cost effective?)

[@thihal123]

I totally agree. I hate hard shell. I also hate spinner bags as the elevated four wheels waste space. I like soft shell two wheels.

[@marcela.lalala]

It's interesting how each person can have a totally different experience with suitcases. I refused to buy Away it wasn't my favorite design and I wanted something with more attention to details. But now I can admit my husband's bag performed better than mine during out latest trip. When I found Monos, I was excited to get the Carry-On Pro Plus, since I love front pockets. But after purchasing it and using it, I can't say I am completely happy about my investment. I definitely think you need to read the pros and cons before buying! 😕 Reasons: 1) Handle does not feel as sturdy as others in the market. And I am actually surprised to see some reviews saying they felt it was the sturdiest? Very confusing to me, as my husband's Away handle seemed more robust. My Monos handle jiggles a bit and does not have the firmness that I was looking for. Do I think it will break? Not really. But I feel more confident with a handle that has more stability. And I agree with one reviewer who said the location of the button is not the best, as I feel I am always pressing it, even when just walking. 2) If you carry a medium-large backpack, the suitcase has a tendency to fall forward, when placing the backpack on top. This did not happen to the Away bag, and I think the reason is the extension zipper. It makes the bag wider, more stable, like a square block. 3) The laptop compartment!! I struggled to fit my 16'' computer in the designated slot (laptop doesn't even have a case!). Instead, I had to use the next pocket. Despite the specifications, it felt the space was very tight and that the laptop was being squished a bit, especially when closing the compartment. What if I had a case on it? 😓 Also, if storing a laptop, forget about adding any other device or chargers. No space. 4) Lastly, the available space within my bag was noticeably lacking in comparison to the capacity offered by my husband's Away suitcase (which extends in volume considerably after opening the zipper). As a frequent traveler, maximizing packing efficiency is of utmost importance to me, and unfortunately, Monos fell a bit short in this regard. Still better than other tiny carry-ons, but not as great as the other brand. If you're a light packer or business traveler, then I am sure this suitcase works great for you. I loved the style, details and color. But my husband and I often take only a carry-on, and while I am not a heavy packer, I do need to have flexibility in the space available. I feel this carry-on can evolve to include an extension zipper, and a larger front pocket, (maybe by digging more into the suitcase itself?).

[@onewhoisaboveall]

like all products, you really need to test it yourself. reviews are nice but every reviewer has their own bias. by bias is that luggage has to be at first a beauty to look at. with that said i own only rimowas. add to that the wheels, locks, and hard case. . yes expensive but with lifetime guarantee and stores everywhere in the world for repairs etc. just cannot be beat by any of the other brands

[@jennifer_u]

100% No on the Monos! I’ve done a lot of carryon travel the past few years and it does not roll well and the telescoping handle constantly gets stuck. 100% no

[@brypiot]

The title of this should be Best "Hard-Sided" Carry On because everyone of these bags is one of those types that have zero give and have those dumb huge wheels that either don't fit in the carry-on sizer at the gates OR they cause you to lose so much extra space inside the bag. As a former gate agent and flight attendant, I wouldn't even look at one of these. The wheels should be recessed into the bag should be the first requirement. This is just odd...he must have a preference for this type bag.

[@judyfontanella7330]

Thanks for the great comparison. I would really like to see some bags that have expansion, though. I have gone on 5 week tours with carry-on only. I flew KLM with a strict size limit and meager weight allowance, so a smaller, light bag was mandatory on the plane. The expansion was important to me, though. I wore my bulkier shoes and and jacket on the plane. However, when traveling from town to town on the tour, I didn't want to wear those articles on the warmer days. It was nice to be able to expand my bag and to pack them. When you do another comparison, I'd love to see bags with expansions. Thanks.

[@conniekershaw4412]

I completely agree. Expansion is also useful on your way home if you bought too many souvenirs or gifts. You can alway check it in.

[@kirstenveneziano1205]

I'm interested in buying the level eight but I'm not finding any information about the width of the handle. It seems wide and I'm worried that my personal item won't fit over it. Have you tried that yet?

[@marclawhorne]

I am absolutely delighted to have found your channel. You both do a fantastic job! Your content is exceptional. Your presentation is extremely professional. Your articulation of the points you make is concise, informative and interesting. We are getting ready to take our first trip to Europe this fall, and your videos have been among the most helpful we have found. I just wanted to thank you for your advice and insight and encourage you to keep up the great work. I will recommend your channel to anyone needing some travel direction and advice. Look forward to watching more of your additions soon. Thanks again!

[@awaytogether]

Marc, I can't tell you how much this means to us. We are here to help. I am so EXCITED for your first trip. Please let me know how it goes. Thanks for watching and happy travels!

[@bmccuan]

No lie, I JUST hit the purchase button on the Level 8 Textured Carry On after some thorough research on my own (including crushing disappointment that Solgaard lost their minds and upped their bags by $100) and got the email notification for this video - feeling very solid about my purchase now!

[@jenocean824]

You will love it! We have two and they are perfect!

[@samvocella]

​@@jenocean824 Can you poke a pen into the zipper and open the luggage? Unless the luggage comes with double coil zippers, I'll take a hard pass.

[@highnoon9333]

I love the way hard-sided cases look, but i've always found soft-sided luggage to be more useful.

[@awaytogether]

Thanks for commenting! Would you mind expounding on why you see it that way? (I could be researching for a future video right now)

[@johntayor9511]

Interested to hear your thoughts on how they’re more useful

[@Unknown-xq5km]

The one thing that I hate about soft shells is they are a magnet for bed bugs, mildew, stains etc. soft shells are the carpet of homes and hard shells are hard wood floors.

[@markmonninger7568]

@@awaytogether Do you really need a hard case carry on if the bag never gets checked in? Bag is lighter and it's going into overhead storage...so why the need for an expensive hard shell?

[@lillysquires]

I have travelled the world and gone through tons of luggage. I have been using the Monos carryon almost exclusively (when not using my Cotopaxi backpack) this past year and it is the best roller bag I've ever had. It has been through the wringer and handles cobblestone streets like a champ. Not only is it the lightest but it holds a ridiculous amount of clothes etc.

[@shannarchy]

I have the monos and the July bag and I choose the July everytime hands down. That wider handle means my personal item doesn’t spin under the bag. The compression straps seem to hold up better. The July is also way easier to close if you are taking it to capacity. I will say the July does scratch more easily though. The most important part to me is that July customer service is ultimately the easier of the two to deal with and they had a replacement to me in less than a week when I had a problem with the luggage. I had to unfortunately test out that lifetime warranty and it came through in a pinch when monos tried to fight me when they sent me packing cubes with a messed up zipper.

[@jrgulmatico]

How's the July luggage holding up? I've read multiple negative reviews for July specially with the Customer Service

[@shannarchy]

@@jrgulmatico I’ve obviously had a different experience with customer service, but the bag itself has held up fine and I’ve been using it for 2 years now. It scratches more easily than other luggage, but that doesn’t actually affect function.

[@rebeccablashock3829]

So well done! I appreciated you testing all sorts of features, especially the wheels on brick sidewalk. Thank you for the super content! :D

[@Echo11Niner]

I agree with the Monos being put on the top of the list. Not only because I own one, but have taken my Plus carry-on with me to Chicago and LA these last 4 months. Both times unfortunately I was forced to check it in because the had "ran out" of head space compartment. Both times the Monos came out like a Champ, bruised and battered with scratches, but firm and sturdy when I pick it up at baggage claim. Took a magic eraser to the scratches and was good as new.

[@shamilton6328]

My away bag has been on over 300 flights the last 5 years and at least 75 of those has been checked. A magic eraser and a little water and it looks brand new. No scratches. The paint on the zippers has rubbed off and the wheels look a little faded. But that’s it.

[@lynnbrady4193]

No TravelPro or Samsonite in your contenders? No Tumi or Briggs & Riley?

[@stephenjarzombek2903]

Same question here...especially as the Travelpro Maxlite Air compact carry-on strictly meets the 22x14x9 dimensional limit, is lighter than the Level8, and usually a bit cheaper.

[@citybright8925]

@@stephenjarzombek2903 Exactly the same question here. For all the time he spent comparing luggage, other travel writers have done a better job and included TravelPro MaxAir and VersaPack Crew, Tumi,, Briggs & Riley and Rimowa, both soft-sided (which I prefer) and hard-sided (hello Delsey Chatelet), many of which are superior to the few choices reviewed here.

[@peteoday235]

Ok. So I bought the Monos carryon based on this video recommendation, and I traveled for four weeks through Switzerland (by rail) and northern Italy and France. The bag worked well, very light with great wheels. I had to check the bag to Zurich from US and from Geneva to US because of trekking poles (banned on carry on). The bag got destroyed between Newark and Chicago on return trip. Not Monos’ fault - but nonetheless, if I hadn’t also purchased the Monos bag cover (which fits awesomely) my stuff would have been scattered everywhere. So if you’re sure you’ll never check it - get the Monos bag WITH the cover; otherwise go with an aluminum or soft shell bag.

[@HRCnailsANDdiving]

How did the bag fail that caused it to bust?

[@claudiapolomusic]

I was secretly hoping your number one pick was the one you selected as I purchased it about a month ago! I’m still trying to find the best way to pack on the compression side but overall I’m so happy with the Monos!

[@thaiswinmill2153]

Awesome video! I did months of research as well for a 10 day Europe trip October 2022. I was in between beis, away, monos and July. Ultimately narrowed it down to July and monos and went with monos since it was $50-70 less. I adore my monos carry on! I’ve used it several times since then and it’s perfect

[@alliepettola3808]

I just used the Monos medium checked bag for Europe and loved it so much. Worth every penny

[@jboutame9113]

I got a Level 8 Road Runner in Aug 2021 and have used it on over 100 flights. I love it, and my wife bought one a year ago. We have no regrets! And would not consider any others. What you need matters most but if this looks good, I think you’ll love it too.

[@alternando101]

I have an Away Luggage, this exact suitcase that was tested to be exact. One of the perks of the Away is it has a built in (removable) charger for your gadgets, cell phones, etc. I haven’t tried the Monos and don’t know if it has this feature, but it’s a nice perk if you ask me. The luggage suits me fine and has gone on as much as 21 day international trips, no probs. I’m with Away!

[@alecsaebeler3741]

I have had nothing but good experiences with Monos bags; I had an issue where TSA has broken the "TSA accessible lock" and Monos helped send over a replacement locking mechanism, which I was able to receive and install on my own. Monos is communicative and stands behind their products. I have certainly had family notice my bags roll, stow, store, and remain undamaged far easier than cheaper or lesser bags. Just my two cents as a happy user; I have tried the Carry-on, Carry-on Pro Plus, and both Checked bag sizes.

[@jennbrown8]

I'm an Away girlie. I have the bigger carry on, the medium, and the Expandable Bigger Carry-On. I LOVE them all!

[@omhomelin]

You’d never get on many Euro & Canadian flights with a 22” carry on without paying an oversize fee. I guess this video is for US travel. Consider doing an international travel video for bags that you can actually take outside of America

[@cattalystt]

Terrific video! So just like you, I have recently done extensive research on carry on bags lately- minus the actually trying them all out in person part. :D I am glad that you confirmed that my final purchase, just a few weeks ago, was the right choice- the Monos carry on! I am really liking this bag. There are tons of bags out there and your video really helps to get down to the details of choosing one over another. Beis would've been more of a contender, if the sizing was actually carry on size; it would be terrible to be charged as a check on suddenly if I get to the airport and they enforce their sizing restrictions. Anyway, I have not been able to travel with it yet, but the Monos is a solid build. The quality, feel, and details put it in a great tier. Gotta love those compression straps. Keep up the good work!

[@lwarteman]

I hate clamshell suitcases. It's just too hard to get things in and out easily. But then again, I don't double pack with cubes either. I still don't see the point and I have tried packing with them and they just frustrate me. All that being said, if I decide to upgrade my carry on and am forced to get a clamshell, I am going with a zipperless version to prevent theft at hotels, etc. Knock on wood, I have never been ripped off when traveling, but I am considering upgrading to a zipperless carry on for travel abroad. I would like to see a comparison of budget friendly, theft resistant, zipperless bags. On another note, we are getting ready to fly Lufthansa overseas and it says they only allow 16 lbs. on your carry on which is really light which concerns me. How often have you ever had your carry ons weighed? That would also be helpful to include in a video. Thanks!!

[@awaytogether]

EARLY BLACK FRIDAY ALERT: Get the MONOS Carry On up to 30% off HERE - shrsl.com/47dbp

[@JillianCarver]

i've been doing research for my next carry-on and am frustrated by how many there are that do NOT meet most airline size requirements (9x14x22 inches). Even the one I looked at from your video, Level 8, is 9.2 x 14.5 x 21.5. I've actually been asked to put my luggage inside the box to see if it meets size requirements. I don't think these will fit and therefore don't want to buy them. Have you had any experience with bags that don't measure up perfectly still fitting in the box? Would appreciate any insight you might have.

[@dand5829]

How can you find the “best” carry on without testing legacy brands like Brics, Tumi, or Rimowa?

[@someoneelse7629]

The best of the best will last you 5 flights.... If they invent a better bag, the airlines invent a worse handeling...

[@3Days3Noches]

As a fellow emerging travel creator, this is an amazing video! The fact that you spent all of your own money to make this video shows how much you love your people!! Goals! And I use the Level 8 and looove and feel the same about the wheels

[@karenwelch6860]

So glad to have found this video! I had been eyeing the Beis and had similar thoughts about it being a carry-on! Although I am also eyeing their weekender bag too! A few things I might add to your video is packing the same items in each bag to see how it all fits, and then testing the weight of the bag post-packing. I usually carry-on a cloth bag because then tend to be lighter in weight and when you are trying to heft the bag in an airplane overhead compartment, the hard case bags are a little heavier. I also like bags with a shoe compartment, and none of the ones you featured have that. Another thing I would add to your video is the warranty offered by the manufacturer. I know the Away bag has a pretty friendly warranty so if the zipper breaks or a handle breaks, you can send it back for a replacement bag. Not sure though how their warranties stack up and whether or not its a hassle or they take the suit cases back with no questions asked. I buy a LOT of suitcases from either Marshall's or TJ Maxx (known at TK Maxx in the UK), and find LOTS of quality bags that are all under $100.

[@Steve-ls3yy]

As a first time international traveler on my upcoming trip to the UIK, I really appreciate your insights. Thanks. I'm a little less nervous about it.

[@tkozikow]

Interesting, but hard to convince me to switch to any hardside bag from my Briggs & Riley ZDX 22" spinner. Expands when needed, looks great, and a fantastic warranty.

[@anitas5817]

I love my Tumi softside. Not switching to hard shell. Had it 20+ years, domestic and international travel. Never a problem.

[@annepatno9677]

Great video! I bought the Beis carryon a few months back and I really like it. I also have used it as a carryon on Alaska, Southwest, and United (I was kind of surprised TBH that it didn’t get flagged for checking at the gate); neither time I had expanded though. The wheels are super smooth and I just like everything about it. For me when I was purchasing it came down to Monos, and Beis. I am really happy with my choice but I do know it is a bit larger but I do think for the price it is a really nice bag.

[@sammychem5920]

Thank you for the review and recommendations! IMHO, the ultimate test for wheeled bags is to take them up/down steep hills and cobblestone streets. That's when you will know whether your bag can handle different pavements. I also wish these bags would come with "brakes" to lock the wheels in place when on a steep hill.

[@vinney27]

I love my BÉIS carry on. I’ve travelled within Canada and internationally and never had any issues. It always fits in the cabin

[@Elainevanderhoop]

Thank you so much for that, I just bought one and was nervous about the size!

[@Jenbaggs]

@@Elainevanderhoop are you able to bring it on international flights?? I want to buy it as well but thinking I may need the small carry on as I fly to Europe

[@maritamanaha1443]

I’m going to Greece in October and bought the Level 8 20” several months ago because the 22” was to heavy empty for my 67 y/o arms to lift over my head 😂 loved your review ❤

[@angelajuneau7457]

Does anyone know anything about the Hanke? I am looking at this one and it has some really cool features.

[@paddyanne2024]

I bought one and loved it on a recent trip to England, rail, air, wobbly sidewalks, etc. It is not as fancy as my sisters' AWAY, but I thought my Hanke was right up there, and it's just slightly over Air Canada's requirements. It is still over sized for WestJet. My Sisters' AWAY would be too large for carry-on for Air Canada by a 1/2 inch and that was too much of a risk for me. Having said that, Toronto now has a few digital measurement systems with lasers - if they want to get "tough" many people will end up having to check their carryon's!

[@allisonthompson1447]

Thanks! Love your efficiency. Watching you is like getting a bullet point todo list!!!

[@fjschneider]

Great review! So, I am in a sort-of frozen state and that is the debate between the Monos Carry-On and Carry-On Plus. The plus is above many airlines' standard of 22" and I do not want to check anything in. I am still figuring out trips but am looking at various parts of Asia (Bali, Thailand, Vietnam), Spain, and England. What are your thoughts on what I should go for? This will be long term as I am, essentially, going nomad.

[@ShawnMcGovern]

I’ve had a Calpak for over five years now. Bought it from Marshall’s for $40. Still works great! Nothing has broken.

[@ActionJ322]

Thank you for the hard work, however, your reasons to kill the BEIS were the reasons that I was searching for. I want the largest carry-on possible. Southwest, Delta, and Hawaiian are my preferred airlines. I just didn't like its weight, 8.36lb is on the heavier side. I'm gonna check it out at Nordstrom. Otherwise, I was about to pull the trigger on the Travel Pro Platinum. Thanks again!

[@conniekitten2409]

I was so glad to see July included! Most reviews are limited to just Away and Monos with the occasional mention of Level8. I have the July carry-on light, also in Moss, which I have traveled with for the last 2 years. At just 1.8 kg or 3.9 lbs, it might be the lightest thing out there, but it does only hold 32 liters. I don't mind that it is small because it's impossible to overpack when you only have 32 liters. I have had no complaints about the handle, which is only 6" wide in this model, but with the case being so small and light, the little bit of wiggle is probably less noticeable than in the regular carry on size. If I were to use a larger carry on, I have a 13 year old Samsonite that weighs 6.8 pounds and has traveled the world and still looks pretty new, so I probably wouldn't invest in a newer carry on, as much as I love all the new colors. Thanks for the great video. I love your honesty and your videos are always so fun.

[@filhodarosa7512]

Most of these are way too expensive for the casual traveller.

[@wandervingjews7520]

I actually have the Beis and have never had a problem with its size as a carry-on. But I was also wondering why it had the same 50 lb weight indicator as the check in size.

[@pamearly6800]

I to never had any problems with Beis traveling internationally… Love love this Beis carry on… Great video 💫

[@wandervingjews7520]

@@pamearly6800 I've never had an issue either

[@marygrigsby7292]

Any reason soft carryons aren’t included?

[@yckieh568]

Travelled for a month in May and was on 10 different flights in different countries. Local and international. The Monos Luggage is a trooper. They have lifetime warranty too.

[@yeomantrader9505]

Well done. The organization is fantastic, detailed excellent, and concise, you didn't drag this out like so many of your competitors. You clearly spent a great deal of time on the script as well. Again, Well done.

[@craigavery8213]

I have viewed so many bags and best lists over the last two or so days, full time. Nearly all that are advertised as carry-on are too big, in one or two dimensions, for Air France, my upcoming carrier. I may have to accept the risk that I may not be able to carry on my preferred carry-on. I like your review but even your top pick, which I like a lot, is not quite small enough for my trip to Italy. So, like other international travelers, I am stuck with a few alternatives that may not be perfect, like your top pick, but are within dimensions and have acceptable quality. The search continues---if I want all the cool features plus total peace of mind that my bag is in fact carry-on size in all dimensions.

[@luceaschild]

I have been watching so many of these bigger selection comparison videos, and I appreciate them all. Your video, however, has to be the best amongst them. You are pointing out some concerns that I haven't considered before, and that other videos missed, such as the width of the luggage handle affecting trolley pass-through. I think I'm sold on the Monos, with the Level 8 being a close contender due to its interior set-up. Thank you for all your work!

[@kylequindo5554]

Anyone else not from America and find these types of carry ons useless? Like they weigh at least 1-2 kilos each, and with strict carry on weight limits in Australia/NZ/Asia/Europe, a laptop + camera will already be like 4-5 kilos

[@sunspot42]

I was worried about getting nabbed when I traveled to and around Europe back in 2018, so I got the lightest-weight carryon I could find at the time, from Delsey. It's a couple pounds lighter than most of these, holds just as much, and has decent features. I actually don't want all of the compression / organization features built into the bag, because depending on where I'm going and what I'm carrying (in particular, the season) I might not even need most of them or their weight. I already have packing cubes and other strategies for managing the stuff I'm packing. The Delsey feels a little flimsy, and the light weight means it's more prone to tipping over. Pack the heavy stuff on the bottom to help counteract that, and don't put something heavy like a laptop in the outer pocket (I save that for the dirty laundry bag, cables, the giant Ziploc bag I take to do laundry in, detergent sheets and other lightweight indestructible flat-ish junk). I did manage to wrench the pop up handle out of alignment while schlepping the bag thru Manhattan once, but it somehow managed to correct and re-straighten itself with use and the bag is still going strong.

[@David..]

I’d just go with the TravelPro Flight Crew 5 rollaboards. Those things are built like brick shit houses, have tons of replacement parts. My 22” pilot rollaboard is like $200 bucks and better built than all but strong bags or luggage works.

[@traci2024]

I travel for work in the US frequently & have used my BÉIS as a carry on for every single flight this year - best bag I have ever traveled with. As someone else mentioned, the ‘expanders’ are for compression. I agree that it’s not a good option for international travel due to size, otherwise I highly recommend it.

[@dessison3782]

I used Beis for international trips as a carry on with no problem, Italy and Philippines.

[@leahkathryn6734]

I carry on my Beis bag for business and personal travel constantly, I have literally never had a problem. My bag was grabbed at check-in twice in Europe, both times flying out of smaller airports in non-EU countries, and they were taking almost everyone's bags anyway. I have several other Beis products, I love them all. If you don't like what the brand offers, go buy something else, but if the brand speaks to you - it's great!

[@LK-nb1eu]

My family of four have been using this bag since last summer. We've traveled quite a bit since. Including to Europe and didn't have any problems carrying them on. I do agree that they can get heavy if you over pack. Lol but that's the same with any other bad. That being said my son and I both did a 9 day tour to Italy and we only brought our carryons and packing bags.

[@alphamore3554]

Monos carry on plus bags are the same size as the beis, and Monos has said most major airlines allow a few extra inches from the 22x14x9 standard. Might be unfair to review beis poorly simply on size when most airlines will allow it.

[@luceaschild]

@@dessison3782 I had my Beis carry on checked four times on international trips. It worked as carry-on on the first leg of the trips, but once I had to make any connection it was too big. On the way back the staff had me check it for the entire trip home. It's a fantastic suitcase, but I found it was not worth the hassle internationally. :( So I'm looking for something smaller. I really hate checking luggage.

[@pranavkhatri4505]

"You're not here for good, you're here for BEST" 😆Awesome video man

[@garysandhu5082]

Briggs & Riley Sympatico hard case carry on would have been a great contender! Lifetime warranty. Very well built.

[@ramkaran1]

I have been using my Travelpro for about 8 years now on at least 20 trips, and it's still going strong.

[@dawncrossland3028]

I LOVE My TravelPro Set!!! 💜

[@AngryCalls]

Travel Pro is what they required when I was a flight attendant. 🥳🥳🥳

[@atam168]

We are in Japan now. Here we found the brand Proteca and amazed that it's the only bag made 100% in Japan. Amazing quality and craftsmanship. It is so light and rolls so easy. We are a family of Tumi but since they are now China made. Rimowa is a joke. This is the Lexus of luggage. Trust me.

[@davidanderson6736]

I disagree with the underlying assumptions in this video. Clamshell carryons are unable to accommodate bulky items that you may need to pack in your carryon. And bags with 4 wheels waste space compared to 2 wheel bags, and maximizing usable volume is critical. I also get a lot of value out having an expandable bag; on my Delsey carryon the expansion zipper doubles as a compression zipper, which is super handy.

[@KenshoQuest]

Thanks for the comparison! I've been eyeing the July Carry On Light. I need the lightest weight suitcase possible, because if it's over 7kg I won't be able to carry it on most the airlines we fly. 🌺Heidi

[@RobynCitizen]

I have a monos and while it’s mostly ok it scuffs SO easily. The first time I used it I came back with tons of scuffs and this is a carry on bag so not like TSA was throwing it around

[@wehavefamily]

i read monos has a lot of bad customer service when it comes to warranty but I still bought one and then experienced that customer service myself. One of the wheels kept sticking and would rotate my luggage as I rolled it, i reached out with videos and proof and they said it was: 1. surface I was rolling on (i used at airports, concrete and my own house) was the issue and didn't care how i tested it It doesnt make sense it would happen on all surfaces if that was the case. 2. the items i put in my bag caused weight shifting to one wheel which caused it to turn (last I checked, there are no suspensions in the wheels). 3. how i packed it decided how the wheels turned (also point 2). safe to say i was super disappointed, but i can't deny their hybrid luggage is still the best on the market imo. They only offered to help when I said I would dispute them with the proof I had. great video though!!!

[@foodieforlife8263]

Also some key areas to consider when selecting the best bag… A. Type of wheels… double wheels, ball-type wheels etc B. Zipper with cover to avoid getting wet at the zip, single zip - which can be opened by pushing a pen etc thru it v/s a double zip which cannot to messed with except a blade cut etc. Btw which country are these brands from, never heard of any of them. What about Samsonite, Delsey, VIP, Lojel, Carrera etc. These cover all budget groups and are far more value for money than any of your brands.

[@Lint323]

typical review by excel and not by real use

[@wadkins101]

I have the monos carry on plus because I travel Southwest the most. It is a great quality bag. Your review was sincere, genuine and exceptional. Considering getting a regular size carry on and was looking at the July brand. Now I’m not so sure. I thought I’d get something different. 🤷‍♀️

[@Donna-C]

Great review. Thorough, comprehensive & straight to the point in this video. Thanks for your research.

[@Seroc99]

Travelled as a Consultant for over 10 years before taking a job with Disney. May be going back in the road again. Appreciate the review. Wonder if anyone has built a bag where the wheels can be pushed up into the bag. Wouldn’t it help with sizing as well as protecting them if you check the bag?

[@bluehannah8696]

Too bad you only tested clamshell bags. I just don’t think they are as efficient to pack as both sides need to be optimized and it’s nearly impossible. You can’t put small things on the compression side or they fall out when you open it. Maybe they are better for men who don’t have as much toiletries, shoes, hair styling accessories and things that are just flat cloth items.

[@jerrycote659]

Excellent video and I had already purchased my Level 8 Luminous Textured Carry On in Navy and I’m really impressed with this bag for the price point. I am currently in Florence Italy, having arrived after 3 days in London and this bag has rolled through both cities, particularly the uneven stone streets in Florence like a dream. I was able to pack for 10 days and followed a previous video you had with tips on how to select items which can be used in multiple combinations and it really helped me focus on my choices and it totally worked. Your beat tip though was when you said if considering an item to ask yourself if it’s something you wear regularly and often when not traveling, and if it isn’t, then why even consider it because it’s going to be the same wherever you are traveling to, so, don’t even consider it. Sounds sensible, but, hearing it makes you recognize the obviousness. I enjoy your channel and appreciated the video you had about Florence with your wife. Great tips I’ve used in planning and now using while I’m actually here, staying right next to Santa Maria Novella Church and Piazza. Gorgeous city.

[@awaytogether]

Thanks so much Jerry! Appreciate you taking the time to write and VERY glad we could help you in some way.

[@TheMobilemak]

why not include rimowa, briggs and riley and tumi hardshell carryon?

[@fotocindy]

I bought 2 Monos carry ones and 2 medium check ins last week. Looking forward to using them on an upcoming trip!! Your video was very informative!

[@patriciateague8677]

I bought the Away Carry-on a few years ago when it seems every influencer was promoting it. It's been a good bag and I'm glad it at least made your top 3. If I ever need to replace it I would definitely consider Monos.

[@sdophoto1405]

Great video!!! I started watching hoping that my personal choice would not make the worst list and it did not it was your top choice. I recently switched from tom bihn as I was finding that backpack style was getting uncomfortable as I have gotten older. I love everything about the monos so far.

[@Phoenix-ni1or]

Do an add on video comparing the Briggs and Riley - those are really next level suitcases

[@epp]

I have the July Light Expandable. It's only 4.9 pounds and it's really nice. The non expandable is under 4 pounds! It didn't seem that the other companies made anything that light.

[@thetravelingwoman]

My Monos carry on performed excellent, however don’t get the beige color. It shows every mark and after having to check it last minute on my last flight it looks like it’s been through a tornado.

[@sonnyangelSid]

After watching this video, along with other research, I think I will be purchasing either the Away or July carry-ons, as they meet most national & international measurements as a carry-on. I really appreciate the detail about the handles of both the July & the Monos carry-ons. It's definitely an important factor to consider & might even be a deal-breaker for most purchasers. Thanks so much for the video & I'll be sure to purchase using one of your affiliate links!

[@andrewbactol8493]

Rimowa didn’t make the list?

[@Gajbotron]

Timestamps pls!

[@richardg8651]

Why only hard shell bags ?

[@marcosperelloorel1289]

I think RIMOWA diserved a check here. Without a doubt, THE best luggage and most popular in EUROPE.

[@greggwade]

Good list. Thanks for the research! What are you going to do with the extra bags? 😂 I prefer a 70/30 split (or even 90/10) over a clamshell for when the bag is on a narrower luggage rack and you can’t completely unfold. I also like expandability for when you have extra stuff to bring back and need a checked bag. (Generally when you expand it goes beyond carryon size). Warranty is also a good point of comparison. Sometimes higher priced bags have a longer warranty period.

[@greggwade]

The 70/30 width also gives you a bit more room to play with for any larger items. Some expandable bags allow you to push down and compress the contents like the whole thing is a packing cube. It can be a handy feature, especially when you travel on airlines with no weight limit.

[@ducatidoc]

Can you share some examples of 70/30 and 90/10 split bags? Thanks!

[@philwebster3914]

Thanks for the video, we have just purchased a July light carry-on, weight 1.8 kgs (around 4 pounds). With most airlines allowing up to 7kgs (just over 15 pounds) we feel more comfortable with a light carry on to enable us to carry more "stuff", your thoughts ?

[@barryhaley7430]

My wife uses a hard shell and I use a soft shell. I find the soft packs considerably more than a hard shell of the same size. And you can generally squeeze an overstuffed bag into one of the airline frames and the overhead bins.

[@goostador]

I too use a soft bag for travel. Biggest problem is carrying in airports when my family roll their bags. My duffel works for, may not for others

[@barryhaley7430]

@@goostador My soft shell still has wheels. It’s 30 years old and only has 2 wheels but has all of the packing features. I only recently started using only a carry on and was easily able to pack for 2 weeks without needing to do a laundry.

[@geepismyname]

We got Quince 20-" expandable carryon. Meets size reqs for most European airlines and weighs about 6.8lbs empty. very similar to monos and Away at about half the price (130 when not on sale or coupon) and they just instituted a lifetime warranty. Only real gripe is the telescoping handle had piece is not flush with the poles it is attached to, so trolley bags can get stuck a bit when pulling them off. Have you looked at this?

[@mechanical-hub]

Great video, thanks for putting in the work!

[@danielshetler123]

What feedback do you have for the extra-stringent carry-on criteria of RyanAir? The depth of 8in(20cm) is a very difficult dimension to find.

[@shannonvanduren5703]

Really appreciate this video! I was tempted by Away, but looking into Monos now. One feature of Away that I haven't seen on other carry ons is the underside handle on the bag itself. This is very cool because you can easily grab your bag from almost any side. I haven't seen this on any other website and didn't see it mentioned in the video.

[@rosalinekanu9272]

I am going with AWAY they have new bags that came out 1-2 months ago. It addresses all the issues he mentioned.

[@Anna.Marin1]

I love my Monos carry on plus! I was thinking of ordering their new carry on the Hybrid Carry On. I just haven’t seen many reviews on it.

[@MomDocTravels]

Great overall review however I have to disagree that Beis is the BEST! I’ve flown with it internationally on several airlines without any issue! Thanks for making this video!

[@tammychiu8695]

I have both Away and Monos carry-on, you nailed it! The away zippers annoyed me so much, and when i packed too heavy, it becomes a work out in my forearm to pull. Love this vidoe, thank you for sharing!