BEYOND ”【海闊天空】” beyond的精彩 LIVE & BASIC [SP Reviews]

[@ericwang8839]

Hi bro, you found the treasure of Chinese Rock music. Love your professional comments! This concert was held after Wong Ka Kui died several years. The bass player is Ka Kui’s younger brother. That’s why he was extraordinarily emotional when singing the song written by his brother. Looking forward to seeing more reactions on Ka Kui’s performance, who is our yyds!

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you, Eric. I plan on livestreaming more of this music soon for live reviews. Should be fun!

[@nanyanguo1]

He, Wong Ka Keung was especially emotional as he was KaKui 's younger brother . Still traumatic for him n his fellow band members as they saw Ka kui fall n dying from his head injuries days later in the hospital . Would take some years for him to get over his brother unexpected tragic demise. Which is why he found it hard to sing that line of the song lyrics with the words " fear I will fall down" and his voice broke down at that moment. Btw pple did wonder if this line in the song was somehow prophecy or premonition by Kakui as he died in the same year he wrote n recorded the song.

[@ppysam4803]

The guy singing in this performance instead of the lead singer who had past away, was his younger brother,. He was also the member of the band. The lead singer Huang, was the soul of the band. He was the legend in those days. He died in an accident of falling from very high stage onto the floor in Japan, when they just started their career outside Hong Kong. Sad!

[@spiderhandspnz]

I am so sad to hear this! A terrible loss for the musical community as a whole. Wonderful music, terrible situation.

[@LCFC_Shiba_In_Seat_25]

His last name is Wong mate. Not Huang.

[@jackzhang4704]

Great thanks for reviewing this song. It's a song which has great influence on a whole gerneration in China(born between 1970-1980). The singer Mr.Wong Ka Kui had not only talent on his music, but also his lyric inspire us to go forward and be strong. When I had some difficuties, this song gave me power and let me stood up. It is more than a song but like a belief for me. Again thank you very much for your professional comments, I can see your empathy and you do really understand this song.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi Jack Zhang, you're totally welcome. I'm glad that this song means so much to you, and that Mr Wong Ka Kui was so positively influential, during his time. And yeah - those were real emotions! Such a beautiful song. Have a great day!

[@赵锴铮]

His power as his name said beyond, beyond voice, beyond nation and age. Even I am very young and before I was born he has already passed away ,but I can also feel him and get touched. Thank you for recommending.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi 赵锴铮 , absolutely. Yes, this music is timeless and incredible - and you're totally welcome!

[@weiboliu6095]

this song is also a reflection of the band's history in pursuing music dream: they were first trying to sell their idea on music, but got very little influence, then they struggled for a while and changed their style in appealing the melody-favored audiences in EastAsia and then got huge success. As the band about to sour high, their leader Huang died at his prime in Japan. what a pitty.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you for filling me in on what this song is about! Yes, such a shame that Huang passed away. Brilliant musicians.

[@KZ88888KZ]

Steve Wong Ka Keung (Chinese: 黃家強; born 13 November 1964) is a Hong Kong musician, singer, songwriter and the bassist for the rock band Beyond. He is also younger brother of lead vocalist and rhythm guitarist Wong Ka Kui, who died in 1993.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you, K Z! I've learned so much about these musicians. I promise you - I didn't know anything about the band, really, before reviewing them. This has been a huge learning curve.

[@LiLi-rv6ww]

I remember your reaction to the guitar solo in the collaboration video, “wow.. spicy… “ 😁

[@hemmahoable]

"where's the solo go !? " 👍

[@spiderhandspnz]

It was a really spicy solo, to be fair! The good kind of spice!

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yeah, I loooooved the solo!

[@LiLi-rv6ww]

@@spiderhandspnz thanks for sharing your comment on this song. I have been listening to this song since middle school, but I never really liked it until now.

[@Chowchow2765]

Me too ❤️

[@hioibo]

热泪盈眶😢

[@spiderhandspnz]

😪

[@it-niner]

Thank you for the professional comments. For years... I have been feeling reluctant to listen to the music again... but music has brought use together. hope to see more video from you!!!

[@missives3894]

This song is an anthem and a classic. Beyond is one of, if not the best band in the Chinese/Cantonese music realm. They're rockstars. Stunning, soul touching music which we don't get very much these days anymore. What a tragedy, such loss of great talent. Listening to Sea and Sky always, always brings tears to my eyes. I just stumbled onto your channel and subscribed! Looking forward to more of your reviews!

[@jjcasgg]

best band is and will always be superband lol

[@黄开炼]

Thank you!

[@spiderhandspnz]

You're welcome :)

[@chekseng80]

Every time the music plays, i feel like crying. This song has so many different deep meanings for different people at different times even after so many yrs.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yeah, I can imagine that it still hurts people, truly a loss for the music world.

[@mysticnebula23]

Hi Spiderhands love your reviews of Chinese musicians/artists, please continue to collaborate with Sanders, you guys have a good balance, you are very professional while he is comical. Love u both, he draws the attention in to ur comments on the songs. Miss u there 2 :) love and peace ✌

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you, Ayvonne! I appreciate it. Yeah, they were fun times. No plans to collaborate in future at this point in time, buuuut we'll see what the future holds. Love and peace to you too!

[@yuletak]

Didn't know such a raw and emotional version of this song exists. Thank you!

[@joulee26]

this is so so sad, i couldn't stop my tears watching this performance

[@Ilovechineaedrama]

In tears. Every time I hear this song.

[@JohnyLim6393]

This live version is most emotional and the solo guitar is the most soulfully, it touch our heart without a word

[@spiderhandspnz]

yeah, you have to really work hard to be that authentic in your performance.

[@isaachiew676]

ooohhhhh this is super super classic timeless piece. and it sang out the thirst for freedom.

[@realnachewa]

It takes a beautiful soul to produce this song

[@yzl1181]

Many people thought that the lyrics of the song had a curse, because there was a paragraph in the lyrics that said he was afraid of falling. Not long after the song was released, he really fell and died. The song became a posthumous work

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi YZ L - thanks for letting me know about that! Yeah, that's a cruel twist. Such a shame.

[@碧咸碧咸]

this is the 【海闊天空】first time without "黄家驹"........you can see all other band member was so so sad! specially the "黄家强" is his little brother....we love you forever, 黄家驹

[@waynecen1985]

This live is the first live after Wong Ka Kui passed away, the singer was his real brother

[@seaweed9999]

The person sang the song in this video is the younger brother of the lead singer Wong Kai Kui, who had passed away. I've heard other band members sing but no one was as good as the lead singer, and no one was as talented as Kai Kui in composing songs. After his passing, none of the band's new songs really left an impression to me. I believe these are the main reasons the band could not continue to perform after Kai Kui was gone

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yeah - the situation in general seems like such a tragedy, to be honest. Kai Kui was an incredible musician, for sure.

[@ms.chuisin7727]

Paradise is hella good though

[@minniewong1175]

Legendary Hongkongese Super Band ! 😘😘

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yes, Minnie Wong - they're fantastic!

[@alexyang7391]

Thanks, mate, for everything in this video

[@kinfeiyap8283]

Beyond is the legendary live band in HongKong, the leader Wong Ka Kui is the soul of the band. He was composed plenty of songs about the reality, culture, humanities etc. Every song are full of meaning and has it own soul. I recommend "AMANI" and "光輝歲月" to you. This two songs are full of meaning, even many years passed, they are still good. I have watched your reaction video from the Chinese channel, hopefully you can try to make the Chinese subtitle in your video. I will subscribe your channel.

[@hemmahoable]

Amani is a great song!! Anti War!!!

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there Kin Fei Yap, thanks for letting me know all this! Wong Ka Kui sounds like an incredible musician, really was the soul of the band (by the sounds of it). I will add those artists to the list. I have to figure out how I'll do all these songs - I'd like to do weekly reviews of the artists that I've reviewed through Sander's channel first - BUT I will be putting Chinese subtitles in these weekly reviews. So don't worry - while the translations probably won't be perfect, it'll hopefully be helpful for y'all!

[@jianingli6158]

please do more Chinese songs 😁😁😁😁

[@spiderhandspnz]

Will do!

[@yizhou_7752]

背弃了理想，谁人都可以，哪会怕有一天只你共我～

[@spiderhandspnz]

嗨，益州 - 这些是歌词吗？无论哪种方式，感谢您访问该频道并祝您有美好的一天！

[@yizhou_7752]

@@spiderhandspnz Yes. They are part of the lyrics which repeat many times in this song. And I also think that explained the main idea for this song. Very impressive~

[@seaweed9999]

不是柯桑德 brought me here

[@spiderhandspnz]

And I am thankful for this! Cheers for visiting!

[@alphachau1326]

where’s the guitar solo👀

[@jiangsun6921]

@@alphachau1326 haha

[@angelashang]

Me 2. Where’s the Gita solo? Very impressing review. And I came here for more.

[@yourfriendlycynic]

im not sure if you know it or not, but the bassist is the vocalist's little brother, that is why it affected him extra hard

[@eunice15mayday]

The lyric he missed is ' im not afraid of falling down‘， where his brother was fell to death.

[@spiderhandspnz]

:( That's so sad! Wow, It is just such a heavy song.

[@dokley007]

This is how concert or live performance in general should be, live band with real live vocals, even sometimes its not perfect, it will show the how they interpret the lyrics with emotions, now days they have live pitch correct and auto-tune which sounds like a robot, my dad said the lyrics was cursed as well, this song was released before the lead singer died. The lyric said Forgive me this life of uninhibited love and indulgence of freedom Although I'm still afraid that one day I might fall Well he felt off the stage when he was performing in Japan R.I.P

[@spiderhandspnz]

It's such a loss to the world, you know. That's so brutal. And you're right, I agree in regards to the authenticity of those live performances from years ago having that rough edge to them... is so human. That's music.

[@nanowong]

You are so professional! You deserve more subscribers!

[@nany169]

I saw your reaction video at bilibili. I really like your professionalism and directness. And your voice is very nice. I don’t know if you are willing to join to bilibili. Everyone welcomes you. Thanks for your reaction, that is very nice. And If we have the chance to hear yourself music work, I think everyone would like to.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there Nany Domoto, Thank you for the feedback, and for visiting this channel. I am considering joining Bilibili soon - just figuring out how it works, first :) And re: my own music - I'll probably put some out, soon.

[@dbrzy8989]

The singer here is the younger brother of the actual lead singer. The lead singer past away from a rehearsal when he fell off the stage.

[@122566145]

beyond…黄家驹🌹🌹🌹❤❤❤👍👍👍

[@golfhk]

Love it !

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you! It's a dope tune, for sure.

[@白白不吃糖]

Beyond is our legend. We will always miss him.AND The questions asked in BiliBili are some quadratic terms. Although we don't know the language, I like your evaluation very much. Please continue to refuel. I also use translation software to reply. Ha ha ha ha

[@leocheng9115]

Nice song and nice review. Hope you could review more Chinese songs

[@alexip9060]

The guy singing in green shirt, actually is Wong Ka Keung's younger brother. It's such a hard moment for him and the whole team

[@spiderhandspnz]

I'm sorry for the error here! I got all caught up in the moment. Beautiful, yet visceral experience. So much respect for these musicians.

[@alexip9060]

@@spiderhandspnz No bro, it is my pleasure to have such a professional review :)

[@alexip9060]

@@spiderhandspnz Sorry I got a mistake here, he should be Wong Ka Kui's brother, and his name is Wong Ka Keung

[@heheha007]

This is so touching and make me cry 😭 I like ur videos. Thanks!

[@Shine-mr4fv]

Thanks for your comments & reactions💪🏻 Nice❤️❤️

[@spiderhandspnz]

You're welcome, Shine! Have a great day

[@mamieliwagener9546]

Come here because of Beyond, my favorite band and singer. Appreciate for your review. Hope I can send my kids to learn music with you. We live in Tauranga.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there Mamie Li'Wagener, Sure! I mean, I'm located in the South Island, so it's a wee way away, but still. Thank you for visiting this page, and have a good day!

[@yidamida]

This song become a legend coz its meaning, Encourage, Eager, and Hope. You can see it played a lot back in a few years ago in Hong Kong, when ppl go onto street to protest Anti-Extradition movement to China.

[@Andsleeter]

Great comments on a marvelous performance. If you know the lyrics is about searching for freedom in HK, you would understand why the audience is also so emotional.

[@looper6120]

Man this song means so much to me.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi LOOPER - that's great to hear! It's an incredible song.

[@boomgg7592]

I hope you can do the review about Beyond - 《灰色轨迹》 and i really like the guitar solo in that song

[@tangyeeping]

灰色轨迹 epic 🙌

[@chanwing1000]

The singer is the younger brother of the original lead singer. Hong Kong Fans, 10th June 2023, 30th years R.I.P

[@spiderhandspnz]

RIP. Amazing music and musicians

[@WenpuJian]

Bass player cried physically, guitar player expressed his sadness by letting the guitar cry!

[@huag8409]

haha, finally find you here, soo happy . Hope you can react to more chinese songs or singers. like you comments. very professional. Respect.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you, Hua Guo! I will be putting out a minimum of 3 reviews p/week with subtitles - so long as KZbin doesn't block any. I appreciate the feedback - have a great weekend!

[@yusiliu1848]

Love your reviews and stay safe!

[@ngchoonweng]

I like your professional review. Wish you improve further and get better with your own style.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you ChoonWeng Ng - I will attempt to continue to improve!

[@1994的失约]

Crying guitar, lost voice bass, roaring drums [Crying loudly]

[@teddytse4667]

The vocal in this video (green T-Shirt) one is the true brother of Wong La Kui. Thus he is very emotional when singing this song. ( In fact , also for other band members)

[@alicewong1305]

This is a very powerful spiritual awakening song for FREEDOM.

[@joulee26]

Ka ku, can you see? so many people miss you., I dare to say from all over the world. Hopefully you be grateful and RIP

[@zhangl3355]

You should also check out another legendary HK band called Tat Ming Pair (達明一派），active almost the same period as Beyond did. Probably start with it’s song “story of the stone(石頭記）”. One of its members, 劉以達 （mr Lau) , is also a great guitarist and talented composer.

[@simatnawchiang5685]

Yes！Please check out “Tat Ming pair”, The composer 劉以達（Tats Lau）is very talent! Their songs are also having great significances. PLEASE!!!

[@KZ88888KZ]

Good

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you!

[@RachelLow1004]

光辉岁月， these song Wong Ka Kui wrote for Nelson Mandela. Try for live version. You will love it. These song is talked about dreams pursue , do not give up. RIP Wong Ka Kui 😢

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yeah I wanna check out the music for Nelson Mandela. Cheers for reminding me!

[@lkhkenshin]

i very like u reaction and the beyond is the legend and epic band on we overseas chinese ppl. And the this band show is after "wang kai kui" pass away, singer is "wang kai kui "younger brother ,he name is "wang kai qiang". How a sadness and sorrow for the show, legend is go far, but the song will keep forever on heart , RIP KAI KUI *** IF U HV CHINESE SUBTITLE MORE BETTER, coz my english like Shit.... T_T

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there lkhkenshin, thanks for your feedback! Yes, Beyond is an awesome band. RIP Kai Kui, indeed. I will be putting Chinese subtitles into my re-reviews of my favourite artists - starting with Jay Chou. Your English is okay, though! Keep it up!

[@lkhkenshin]

@@spiderhandspnz like and follow is readyqq

[@nearchen9605]

我很喜欢Beyond另一首歌《amami》，内容是关于世界和平，向你推荐 抱歉我的英文不太好，但很喜欢你对歌曲的评论，加油，已经在Blibili关注你了

[@spiderhandspnz]

嗨，在 chen 附近，我会将那位艺术家添加到列表中！我想我可能会每周为每个艺术家制作一首歌的视频。所以奄美可能会在那里！

[@it-niner]

@@spiderhandspnz I do appreciate your effort reading and replying to our comments.

[@yuhu3615]

Nice to find your channel. I know you through sander kole.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there Yu Hu, Cheers for visiting! Yes, I'm grateful for the mention from Sander - it's been good to meet so many new people!

[@adrianwang4419]

你可以听听他们的 灰色轨迹 1991年红磡体育馆现场版本

[@spiderhandspnz]

谢谢！我想在下周回顾周杰伦，但我可能会在 3 周内研究更多 Beyond！

[@pkkuo1744]

My favor Chinese Rock Band

[@spiderhandspnz]

hi Pk Kuo - that's great to hear!

[@locollection6530]

I've been following you for a long time. You play the guitar very well. Hope to see ur guitar style playing beyong / jay chou's songs .Then explain the perceive of the guitar tune！❤ ❤that would be more topical ❤

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yeah, could do! Thanks for following this stuff.

[@howardteh4182]

多多和柯桑德合作吧！对你有很大的好处，会增加非常多的华人观众。加油😊😊

[@spiderhandspnz]

桑德和我可以在某个阶段做到这一点，但这取决于他。我选择停止和他一起拍视频，所以我理解他是否不想偶尔合作。

[@howardteh4182]

@@spiderhandspnz 他还介绍你的频道呢，所以他还是很支持你的。

[@Lila_Z]

@@spiderhandspnz maybe you two can start a new channel together, to do Chinese music review only. It would be fair for both of you~

[@cathychen7170]

@@spiderhandspnz I think 桑德 would like to work together with you for some music review video occasionally! (I saw him promoting your channel). Your review is so good and professional and 桑德 is so funny and even translate your music review in an attractive way. I think you can keep your version of music review in your channel and give him a copy of your review video. Then you may gain more followers or more source of incomes lol (some percentage from 桑德 haha). Anyway, hope you two would open to the co-op! Looking forwards!

[@deathberry74]

I don’t know if this is what you’d be into, but another song with an enjoyably long guitar solo is Norwegian Forest (by Wu Bai and ChinaBlue), I personally liked the live version collab with Mayday for the sheer number of guitars involved. (Link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iZm8fZqmm7xql7c) Also R.I.P. to Wong Ka Kui. My mother introduced me to BEYOND when I was a teenager and they blew me away. Cantonese is a very musical language as it has more tones (well, in comparison to Mandarin I guess, which is the only other Chinese language I know 😅) and well-written lyrics will sound almost song-like even when just read aloud, as the tones of each word lines up more or less with the rise and fall of the melody, which I thought was very cool.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi Ryun, thanks for your suggestion! I'll add that song to the list. I'm planning on doing weekly reviews of artists that I've done through Sander's Channel, but I will probably start doing fan requests in a while's time. If you want the song done sooner - feel free to check out the Fiverr link in the video description, and (providing on when the order comes through) it'll probably go on the channel within the following week. I am a massive fan of guitar solos - so this looks like fun. RIP Wong Ka Kui. It sounds like you had a very special relationship/history with the band, and it sounds like Beyond were meaningful to a lot of other people, too. Beautiful music.

[@deathberry74]

@@spiderhandspnz Sweet, can’t wait! I’ve been loving the way you do your reactions/review and how you really get into the music. Will be sticking around for more!

[@kittyhello8710]

歌曲末尾，吉他哭了

[@shiaqi]

Music Is Universal!!! I hope that the world will no more racists, no more war, no more disaster. STAY HOME, STAY SAFE.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there Jong Chian Ching! I totally agree with you on that.

[@manbin]

the concert is called live and basic, only the band and the instrument on stage,striping anything else is because there was a lot of doubt to the 3 remain members of the band, the lead singer Ka Kui was the brain, the leader, the soul of the band, most of beyond's song are composed by him, and this was also the time they released a new album which is thru and thru beyond style/spirit, now only Paul Wong carry on creating music, he is the godfather of band scene in Hong Kong. Beyond influence a lot of people because how diverse of idea in Ka Kui's era, the care about grassroot community, the desire for freedom in Hong Kong/ China after tiananmen square massacre, dissing bad behave media/awards

[@gogogo7262]

This live version is impossible to surmount, watched many many times😭😭😭

[@sengfishing720]

I love it T. T

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there 勝任有魚SENG Fishing - welcome to the channel! Glad to hear that you loved the review! More to come :)

[@kevins9243]

Beyond was the Beatles to Asia!

[@spiderhandspnz]

Heck yeah!

[@yoojboy4024]

It’s not just a song for chinese. Something huge behind

[@danapan3567]

兄弟，等你上了中文字幕我再来关注你！

[@spiderhandspnz]

你好，Dana Pan！以后我会尝试加入中文字幕--我关于周杰伦和他的首张专辑的视频将附有字幕和转录。感谢您的光临，祝您有美好的一天！

[@danapan3567]

你好，我非常喜欢你的点评，你的很多点评能引起我的共鸣！中国有许多歌手的音乐陪伴这无数人成长，他们对于我们来说就是青春！让我们一起享受音乐！关注你了！❤️

[@fennecluna994]

Fans coming from bilibili🥳

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yes, it's been a great time! Thank you.

[@tobystark8119]

Chinese fans coming

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi there! It's nice to talk to all these new people!

[@alphachau1326]

If possible, I think you may have “不是柯桑德” a treat, he brought so many of us Chinese fans for you after all

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yeah! I have to admit - it's been a wild time, but he did eventually link to my material, which I do appreciate, and have thanked him for. I'll be making a video about this, at some point, because I think that it'd be good to look at how this all started :)

[@seeyoudec]

His name is Wong Ka Kui

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you for clarifying that for me!

[@seeyoudec]

@@spiderhandspnz I recommend you can listen 光耀歲月. it，s also a song by Beyond. kzbin.info/www/bejne/jX-0mXSIh9Rropo kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqOqpHSDl8yInpY I have seen your comment of Chinese singer on 不可柯桑德 channel. I like your view and you provided a different view of the song. You did not just focus on the signer skill and the lyrics. You also commented on musical instruments and the performance stage. I really like that.👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@hemmahoable]

I agree with you, The guitar solo is a little different, it seems to telling that : We are still chasing the dream, but we really miss you, brother.....

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yes, the guitar solo is so emotive, isn't it? It's calling out. It's like a wondrous voice.

[@kaikaikkk]

介紹你聽「喜歡你」和「光輝歲月」😊

[@ansontang9421]

Where's the solo goes. There's another KZbinr brings me here. Hope you can review another Beyond's song named Glorious Years（光輝歲月） which dedicated to Nelson Mandela. Thanks

[@spiderhandspnz]

I would love to review more Beyond! I will probably review this song in September, I think, if that works for you :)

[@本初君]

he is not huang ka kui . he is borther

[@spiderhandspnz]

This is true! I made a mistake here - sorry about that!

[@adrianwang4419]

快上中文字幕吧！💪

[@spiderhandspnz]

你好阿德里安！我会尝试为我将来审查的中国艺术家提供中文字幕 - 我计划重新审查一些我最喜欢的音乐家。

[@adrianwang4419]

@@spiderhandspnz thx bro！！

[@matarey-u8k]

You had done another review of this song earlier this year, with a different live performance of it, right?

[@spiderhandspnz]

Correct! I hadn't reviewed that song on this channel, though - so I am glad that I have, now. It's such a good song that I can listen to it twice.

[@一寸-n7j]

百元哥。

[@whenever4585]

You’re very well. We neeed caption,, text explain

[@spiderhandspnz]

Yes, I'm sorry! I will try to include subtitles on all the videos, once the channel grows a bit bigger.

[@gajnk1182]

Come from bilibili. You are very popular there,dude.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi GaJnk, thanks for letting me know! Sander mentioned that I should probably go check out Bilibili, so I will, soon.

[@陈晓峰-l8u]

谭晶的《九儿》

[@bbzbbz292]

Where is the guitar solo go! Where is the guitar solo go! Bro, We really miss you.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Bbz Bbz, that was a phenomenal guitar solo. I wish to hear more!

[@royteng8692]

if subtitles can be included in this video it would be much appreciated. as quite a lot terminology is used in your talking :)

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi Roy, thanks for your feedback! I plan on putting subtitles into my reviews of Chinese artists, in future. The next one will be a review of Jay Chou's album, out next week.

[@chaozhang7440]

you believe or not...I am GamingTZ..😎

[@spiderhandspnz]

Chao Zhang / Gaming TZ! My friend! Welcome to the channel, and cheers for getting me to review this song!

[@THEONE-yx4ej]

I believe there must be no one in china didn’t listen the song whet they growing up

[@spiderhandspnz]

I can imagine that this'd be the case!

[@THEONE-yx4ej]

@@spiderhandspnz I hope I'm not disturbing you, but I'd like to share with you these interesting histories of Chinese POP music.From the perspective of pop music, Chinese music includes China, Taiwan, Singapore, Malaysia, Hongkong and Macao. You can understand this as greater China. Hong Kong, Macao and Guangdong Province of China are pure Cantonese speaking areas, while people in other parts of China, Singapore and Taiwan usually speak Mandarin. The difference between Cantonese and Mandarin is much greater than that between American English and British English. Although Mandarin and Cantonese have almost the same grammar and characters , some vocab and pronunciation are very different. Although I can speak Mandarin, I can understand and simply speak cantonese because I like Hong Kong music. Cantonese is more suitable for singing and has more tones. Creators often need to ensure the combination of tone of the every single word and melody of the song. And miraculously, they did, so Cantonese itself sounds like singing. You can listen to Eason's songs, "十年" and "明年今日".Or “爱情转移” and “富士山下” One is the Mandarin version and the other is the Cantonese version. They have the same melody but completely different lyrics. I hope you can experience the subtle differences. In the 1980s, Hong Kong played an important role in the popular culture of Greater China because of its economic rise. Cantonese songs in the 1980s and 1990s became a necessity for almost all listeners in Greater China. Jacky Cheung, Alan Tam, Anita Mui, Andy Lau, beyond, Chen Baiqiang, Leslie Cheung, Eason Chan and Faye Wang are all singers of that era. However, around 2000, the Hong Kong music world began to decline, old singers gradually retired, or began to pay attention to the Mandarin song market. The 2000-2010 year is the golden age of Mandarin songs. The pop singers in Chinese mainland and Taiwan have created one myth after another, which has accompanied the growth of the younger generation of listeners, just like our collective memory. The representative singers of this period are: leehom Wang, Jay Chou, JJ Lin, Eason Chan, Joker Xue. Unfortunately, the current Chinese music world is declining again. Although more and more new songs are released every year, there are no good classics anymore🥲🥲🥲

[@THEONE-yx4ej]

@@spiderhandspnz Jacky Cheung made his debut in Hong Kong in 1984. His record sales has not been overtaken so far (Greater China). His record sales were second only to Michael Jackson in 1995, so he received an award from Bill broad. Jacky has many hits in Mandarin and Cantonese songs.In the 1990s, he was called the "God of singing" just like the “King of Pop” by the audiences in the whole greater China region. Both Mandarin and Cantonese listeners love him very much. He is also the idol of Jay Chou, JJ Lin and Eason Chan . In 1995, Eason Chan made his debut in Hong Kong. Until 2000, Eason Chan gradually gained recognition and was praised by the media as "the successor of the God of singing". To this day, Eason Chan is regarded by the media as the last king of Hong Kong's music world, but it is a pity that he has not reach the legend of Jacky Cheung. Also in 2000, Jay Chou made his debut in Taiwan. His legend doesn’t need more explanation. He is like a storm sweeping the whole greater China and inspiring us today.

[@Cykb1234]

😭😭😭😭

[@Maydaydddd]

很喜欢你的节目，请添加一个中文字幕吧。😂

[@cristinami6]

B站上有中文字幕，刚从B站看了过来😂

[@spiderhandspnz]

很抱歉没有字幕! 我已经为将来的评论添加了它们，实际上已经用录音室版本重新评论了这首歌。

[@littlemonster1477]

I'm from Bilibili, it's not easy, hahha...cuz it is hard to land youtube in china. i really like your reaction videos and hope you can give a reaction about 腾格尔--《天堂》

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you for coming to visit! The difficulties are why I have set up a Bilibili channel, which now appears to be doing okay. I have added your recommendation to the review list - cheers for that, and have a good day!

[@黄文亮-g8y]

You have many fans in BiliBili.. not everyone can visit KZbin in China

[@spiderhandspnz]

Thank you! Yeah, 70k fans now, which is pretty ridiculous. Just gotta keep up the reviews. I may even be doing some other types of videos too, soon :)

[@lishiwang5948]

More Chinese songs reaction please

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi Lishi wang - definitely putting out more Chinese song reactions in future - at least one per week! Will be reviewing Jay Chou's debut album next week :)

[@lishiwang5948]

@@spiderhandspnz Great！！！

[@pengfeiluo9194]

The volume of this song is too low, and the listening experience is not so good. By the way, I like your cooperation with “不是柯桑德”, with your comments, his translations and exaggerated expressions. really good.

[@spiderhandspnz]

Hi Pengfei Luo - I am sorry to hear that you didn't enjoy the listening experience! This whole "video review" thing is something that I'm still improving on. I'm glad to hear that you enjoyed those collaborations! Unfortunately, there won't be any more videos like that, as we've decided to go our separate ways. If videos like this one aren't to your tastes - I respect your opinions and views. either way - thanks for visiting the channel, and have a good day.

[@pengfeiluo9194]

@@spiderhandspnz To understand your video, I really need to start learning English.