BFDI: THE GOOD ENDING - Original Animations Comparison

ALL CREDIT GOES TO JACKNJELLIFY (And also maybe Kevin Macleod) (...and uberduck.ai)
BFDI 25: kzbin.info/www/bejne/r5bCeX56lKhopZI
BFDIA 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nqTTo5iZo92Gqac
BFDIA 3: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mom4dmqFe86dlas
BFDIA 4: kzbin.info/www/bejne/e2KaZaKdd5lsrtU

[@UnexplainableTammy]

I like how teardrop and pin decide to rotate 360° degrees to “Total Firey Island,” in the end.

[@NotACopyAnimates]

@Caleb Deshoutel hello

[@VCOTABFONDD]

And needle

[@user-kz5bc8sz4x]

@@VCOTABFONDD yes

[@LouisianabaII]

*psst* everyone does

[@ravvenkok8510]

0:31 firey blushed

[@Coinyiscool2763]

Oh yeah

[@sonatapastelcocoart]

fireafy /jk

[@cirkulx]

@@sonatapastelcocoarti hate you

[@GachaObjects]

you know Firey has never touched a girl so it’s new for him

[@XanderMatthewsHusband]

​@@GachaObjectsI'm taking that out of context

[@bruh9757]

0:32 Perfect Timing

[@ZTAN26]

1:04 what abour golf ball: cursed talking

[@GirlyMosses-YouTube-channel]

bfdi 26

[@carseat2004]

Lol love how they all collectively forgot woody was dead 💀

[@Pen_islandBfdi]

They did remember, they just didn’t care

[@SteveMan_Steve8]

Actually Firey brought up woody.

[@Nofelicidad]

0:32 He was blushing firey

[@user-hm6cg3mnuilgreenboy]

Yeah AYO!

[@andy-gamer]

0:52 teardrop isn’t happy with this ending

[@Monizn2827]

Bubble is puffball? 1000/1000

[@Lightmations2024]

puffbub

[@Robloxx219]

And COINY IS NICKEL

[@sey-seysworld1572]

Puffble Buball

[@Sadanna_flowercute]

😂😂🤣🤣😂😂🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂😂🤣😂😂😗😂😂

[@randomturkmapper]

@@Sadanna_flowercutechill out

[@yamilethyazmindiazarauz4694]

I love this ending, but with it we wouldn't have a second season.

[@maqramirez966]

Yeah, I liked season 2s ending more! Glad it wasn't cancelled or anything.

[@Gd-bb4ch]

​@@maqramirez966it cancelled but idfb is not idfb maybe season 6

[@Aqua2Solar]

@@Gd-bb4chr/woooosh

[@CamOrSomething]

@@Gd-bb4chbfdia has a 6th episode now

[@thedanishlord]

Bfb would be season 2 Instead (although yeah Bfdia and Idfb wouldn't happen)

[@lordwoody8352]

I like now in the Alternate Ending, they just swapped Nickel’s role with Coiny in the factory scene Very clever

[@give_me_a_break_get_it]

i like how firey named the island and pen led them into the island

[@RamonGonzalez-xx7cd]

Yeah he got to be the new nickel instead of the new coiny

[@KenyaNebula]

and they forgot u were dead

[@tzarg]

1:23 ooh I like how you edited it, very clean edit

[@Potato_Animations]

fla

[@kellydickinson2724]

If the alternate ending was real, BFDI shouldn't have got a second season. Edit: Dang, I didn't expect this to blow up. I thought this was gonna be another dumb comment with no likes and replies. Please reheart.

[@Moltenbacon_boss]

Yea but idbf and bfb would exist

[@marianolucs]

@@Moltenbacon_boss yes, because BFDIA and BFB were made as sequels, IDFB and TPOT to fill the gaps and explain what happened next.

[@Unitelous]

This isn’t the reason. Cary and Micheal told the viewers to vote if BFDIA would happen or not. But, a entirely different season would happen.

[@MB32904]

@@marianolucs BFDIA was a sequel season, not BFB

[@CUBEANIMATES0]

unless..

[@FamouslyRandom]

Fun Fact: David did not show up at all(even when the contestants we're looking at dream island)

[@traviscunningham7062]

Probably because he’s a recommended character.

[@ColinJoesseppiVEVO]

After the events of the alternate ending… After bringing Dream Island (Or Total Firey Island) out of Golfball’s Factory, everyone near North Goiky have seen the light shining from the area at night. Which means more and more people like Donut, Gelatin and Puffball come over to visit and stay. (Firey’s own Speaker Box even starts a game show to keep everyone from being bored in the meantime!) A year after all of the BFDIA Contestants move in, they visit Yoyle Land since they’ve all hear Announcer wanted to bring them over to catch up. Years after they return to North Goiky, Four and X show up out of nowhere and start another season of BFDI. And with that, with Dream Island safe for keeping with the mention of the B.F.B, Season 4 begins.

[@therifler5308]

And that is how BFDIA, IDFB, and BFB would've never existed

[@HalfBreadOrder]

bfb would probably still have

[@Tairex777]

​@godly136in bfb they're battling for the show, not the island also the bfdi and bfb appeared to be just "hard" copies of the show

[@fury_furry]

And people on the LOL will just live there forever

[@хзктоэто-п0х]

also tpot

[@Lightmations2024]

love this ending idc if bfdia exists im just here for the 360 spin and fireafy friendship

[@jordancurry1086]

The alternate ending is like the good ending. I wish that was the real ending

[@JustAFireafyHater]

In 0:31 if you pause it at the right time firey blushes

[@TepicneoriTFFBAS]

0:31 look closely to the alternate ending.

[@annamariesabando1334]

The blush!?

[@DaACTUALLYREALReddie]

Bro 💀

[@realcrowny-OSC]

BRO WAS BLUSHING💀

[@Battle_for_nacho_cone]

@@realcrowny-OSC hell nah da shippers are coming

[@realcrowny-OSC]

lol💀

[@Jesus.Christ0000]

I think I know how Leafy survived the crushing: She simply layed down.

[@renanthefangameplayer]

Oh yeah, that's true. She can't be easily crushed.

[@EeteThang]

Me:firey could toutch leafy but fire burns leaves or firey destroyed the laws of physics

[@Scarde0]

​@@EeteThangFirey's limbs don't burn, only his body does

[@ewwjelly]

"WHAT SHOULD WE NAME OU-" -Bubball, 2023.

[@JustMonaco]

0:30 BRO FIREY BLUSHED

[@AreaConfirmedFan]

1:03 If you dont know what she said, "What about Bubble?"

[@Shimodragon]

this looks so good

[@ezrarieker]

2:26 there’s a tiny pin in the corner

[@Snowball_Butterfly]

The alternative ending is much better! 😄

[@vecinalfish]

For real Bfdi 25 should have ended like this

[@Nes5867Pie]

But then we wouldn’t have gotten BFDIA

[@EeteThang]

It would be total firey island

[@ashertheking5023]

TBH, this would have been better than the ending we got.

[@MineZack2]

So Total Firey Island happens in an alternate timeline, and takes place after BFDI?

[@-trickythetikytikimccooI666ok-]

Wut

[@mayettemacabeo549]

​@@-trickythetikytikimccooI666ok-u said furry so u said wutt

[@The-amazing-speaker]

0:32 bros blushing 💀

[@Happy20246]

0:24 DoNt TeLl Me GiVe Me ThAt

[@BoyfendCh]

Alternate ending: end of bfdi trilogy Normal ending: more lore

[@Nice-pk4nr]

0:32 Firey Blushing

[@THIS_IS_A_ROLEPLAY_CHANNEL]

Firey just blushing for a split second-

[@ant_0775]

I like this ending better than the original one

[@elianebarrosdelima8207]

0:32 💀💀

[@dadam.5420]

Alternate ending is super!

[@level20XD]

The alternate ending is so wholesome!

[@oghcuteanimationhq5121]

Looks like ice cube isn’t the only one who wants revenge

[@makar4ik_cat]

Alternate ending is definitely needs to be in real bfdi

[@Firefly256]

@godly136BFB would still happen, since Four always wanted to be a host for BFDI

[@Beefescapesfloods]

And tpot would happen because bfb still exists

[@ninteenth]

@@Firefly256 if the alternate ending is canon then Bfdi would be Season 1 Total Firey island would be Season 2 Bfb would be season 3 tpot would be season 4 And the season which name we don’t know yet would be season 5

[@ninteenth]

But I guess the reason of Bfb and tpots existence is because Bfb is the 4th season

[@makar4ik_cat]

@@ninteenth 4 appeared in season 4 because look at the season's number

[@froghaven]

The perfect ending for us Firey fans!

[@freshinaba22763]

i like how they just fly around into dream island at the end oh I'm sorry "total firey" island

[@TheBears11-happy]

People who thought that the alternate ending was better:

[@ana_potato_360]

If the alt ending was canon, maybe not bfdia but idfb bfb and tpot will exist

[@ana_potato_360]

But idfb will be much different

[@Fermin95YT]

if that would, happen... bfdia, idfb and bfb would'nt be created in the first. TPOT would happen after years of living in "firey island", which it would have the bfdi series only BFDI and TPOT and TPOT would have been made in 2011. TPOT would have 13 episodes, half-way in. What about four? Four would be the host for an unknown show for the third show in the alternate BFDI series. Let's dont forget about X. Announcer would have came in like TPOT 9-10. and be the co-host for it. PLS LIKE I HAVE TAKEN 10 MINUTES OF MY TIME TO WRITE THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@DajoAnimations]

nice!! this is a neat theory

[@kellydickinson2724]

That's exactly what I just said.

[@Fermin95YT]

@@kellydickinson2724 in a different way, less explained

[@foxlime286]

I think bfb will still happen but i think it would be like ii s2 with some s1 charachters and recommend characters

[@foxlime286]

The events may change and maybe tpot wouldn't happen cause two came because of four message

[@CaioSilva-j2g]

bfdi 25 + bfdi 3 + bfdi 4 ! :D

[@ODXBurst]

if bfdi just ended as a single season

[@soapycanthandle]

HE JUST PRESSES THE BUTTON AND LEAFY MATERIALIZES

[@El_Ale_turuleco]

Good ending yeah!

[@Moai_con_insanidad]

This is the perfect ending for leafy lore

[@swimmerdude176]

Maybe it can make an alternative version of BFDIA 1 with leafy and bubble still in the game

[@diduardnoob8023]

Veeery cool!

[@kasq10ma]

everyone gangsta till 2nd season starts off with sinking dream island

[@Zuryafisadopted]

Fun fact:total firey island is a lost season from jacknjellify and it's a book. Hyper crystal made a video about it and the winner gets 1 million dollars and the winner is also pencil

[@Readyornots-fk5wh]

*me talking to hypercrystal* I once before did look up to you … *walks away*

[@_care.]

this felt so real

[@thetopanimator]

BFDI finale if it was actually good.

[@arelisseverino4261]

The alternate ending was better than the original 2:19

[@pman_2763]

1:58 Bubble = puffball!

[@gardeniaangel4403]

1:57

[@JuniorJOOJO02]

1:26 I have this dr eam sauce

[@unerringsalt6325]

And so they lived inside golfs ball underground factory inside dream island

[@glorymargutierrez287]

I want that happened i'm bfdi 25 for real

[@Derpmaster-zy7qi]

The other alternate ending: Announcer sells Dream Island to Nonexisty and they all compete again

[@MondySpartan]

Canon event disrupted.

[@robertosan0169]

well edited

[@fursec_is_real]

+1 sub for you made this super ending! Enjoy it:)

[@kfpocs]

My new canon

[@BFDIFAN2K2025]

This is why he had to stay away from the explosion

[@BigWhale.]

wowzas

[@jessicafranks7361]

Nonexisty is ruby now

[@aesthetixx3617]

though, we wouldn’t have had a second season because leafy wouldn’t have fell off of the hang glider.

[@damucho5776]

Alternate is good

[@Jesus_Is_King70]

This is what should have happened

[@HBIsBlessed]

No because no bfdia, idfb and bfb

[@Jesus_Is_King70]

@@HBIsBlessed it gets boring after oh idk 4 REBOOTS OF A SHOW bfdia got canceled idfb was great but got canceled in bfb some of them didn't even want the bfdi tpot just does not feel fresh this is my opinion I love all the shows I just said it would be cool if it ended like this

[@HBIsBlessed]

@@Jesus_Is_King70 In my opinion, bfdia is up there with being my favorite season so I don’t want that to go (despite it being cancelled). Idfb is probably not finished yet and I totally want bfb and tpot to exist because it is needed for this show

[@Jesus_Is_King70]

I agree bfdia was a good season

[@Lexi_is_good]

This vid made me what bfdi means

[@haiyingsu3739]

nobody cared about woody or flower

[@DanTheFan85]

the alt ending is beautiful but if that happened bfdia, idfb, bfb and tpot would have never existed

[@martyscantlen]

0:19 I Laughed Heard My So Medium🤣

[@arindammukherjee8298]

Yellow face is blocky?

[@leonanimates175]

I love alternated ending

[@Karsonandkaceystorymaking]

I hope there’s an alternate ending of match getting eliminated in Bfdia without using the elimination prevention thing.

[@Penciltastics]

I give the alternate ending a 2763/2763

[@I_love_space.]

Ya know it’s not an island if it’s not surrounded by a body of water

[@matthewbanes6591]

And so, Total Firey Island began...

[@Applecore99]

If the alternate ending, we wouldn't have gotten BFDIA or idfb

[@Thecyanpult]

when you forgot david:

[@Moonlight_animates-q7f]

1:04 "gobba gop gobble-"

[@DaACTUALLYREALReddie]

Ykw, even if the current ending is good, i still like the alternate ending better, it’s more like a good ending than normal ending, but i can see why they chose the current one. Since they want to continue bfdi.

[@5yearoldsbrainrotted]

Kokoko from chicken gun💀

[@SoraClara31]

Why they got no limbs after they want to go to the dream island?

[@хзктоэто-п0х]

bfdi seasons if there was alt ending instead of original:↘↘↘↘↘

[@amauro1385]

Is this a fan made ending or scrapped

[@PaperLeafyYT]

Fan made I think

[@cartergray9397]

umm wheres david

[@DajoAnimations]

they forgor 💀

[@LucasandRoccopikminplushysands]

Alternative ending is good ending

[@Italy-plays]

That good ending

[@pixelatedluisyt]

Now we need michael and cary to voice act this

[@ProfessionalBugLover]

i like this ending, but the old one was bettee bc tpot wouldn’t exist

[@ImDaCliffordBoi1963]

Cool!

[@Pen_islandBfdi]

Where’s David?

[@ROBERTOPISCO-t5l]

and also you make this alternate ending and jacknjellify made the original episodes

[@wmsTN78]

I love the Alternate ending More

[@albert-f9r]

1:04 his voice is blur voice effect

[@itstimeforanwalk]

bad end leafy dont die

[@stapoldypropagandaaccount]

💀