BFDIA What If: The teams were determined by the votes?

[@patgaming4973]

Someone who respects spongy

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@patgaming4973 He’s definitely not my favourite, but I also don’t hate him. He’s alright imo.

[@Micah_YT]

20:19THERE'S 2 ROCKYS

[@BFDIan-y4t]

Double the barf

[@vincentbangert6619]

Best universe ever

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@vincentbangert6619 One is more than enough barf.

[@GJBFAH]

“Spongy can be used as an anchor” 💀

[@BFDIan-y4t]

He basically makes his team win the first challenge so W Spongy.

[@Ryder_Gorilla_Tag]

Caseoh

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@Ryder_Gorilla_TagOne of my favorite streamers on earth.

[@BogusTheGreatKid]

Did you know spongy is caseoh v2

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@BogusTheGreatKidI can see why.

[@Helentar]

Pre-hiatus eliminations go from mid to fan favourites

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@Helentar Well some of them wouldn’t be fan favorites in this universe, or just might not be as liked anymore.

[@CarneiroDaNeve]

Donut was not rude in the second season, he was mad because the game wasn't fair and nobody was agreeing with him. In this scenario, Donut would never be perceived as "mean" by the fandom, because he wouldn't have trouble with teams (both have 11 members here) and wouldn't have that fight with Pencil

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@CarneiroDaNeve True, that’s a fair point. I do think they would make him mean though in a different way and make him first boot.

[@CarneiroDaNeve]

@BFDIan-y4t probably. I do believe in the theory that Donut was put UFE against Coiny and Pin just so they could get rid of him as he is harder to animate

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@CarneiroDaNeve Interesting, I haven’t heard that before. I just thought they wanted to get rid of him easily since he was against two ogs.

[@BFDIan-y4t]

Hey! I tried going a bit faster in the video, so let me know if I went too fast or not. Also I didn’t notice until too late but the bar at the bottom is blocking some stuff, Sorry.

[@steeljace]

Good speed

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@steeljaceThanks

[@JaeFresh504]

FINALLY SOMEONE SEES THE VISION OF SPONGY AS AN ANCHOR 😤

[@BFDIan-y4t]

The most useful Spongy has ever been.

[@asquid3498]

19:53 for yf, why are you using something that happened wayyy after bfdia

[@YourLocalSpaceMarker]

People vote for contestants in things that happened in bfb/tpot

[@BFDIan-y4t]

Yeah people sometimes blame stuff that doesn’t happen yet in BFDIA.

[@lonnie3626]

Match getting further 🔥

[@BFDIan-y4t]

I tried giving her sympathy after everything that happened, hopefully it wasn’t too much.

[@Freaky_brightney]

​@@BFDIan-y4t match just better

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@Freaky_brightney I find her alright, she can be a bit rude sometimes.

[@Freaky_brightney]

​@@BFDIan-y4t I just have a spot for rude characters idk

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@Freaky_brightney That’s fair, they certainly make the show more interesting.

[@CookienPiggy]

I feel like in BFDIA 9 Ruby would be eliminated but not too far off Gelatin with around 100-1000 different votes as Gelatin still kind of did mess it up for Pin which is on the enemy team.

[@BFDIan-y4t]

It would definitely be close, but I see Gelatin barely edging her out in votes.

[@YIPPIE_n9]

Wait who did tb make a alliance with?

[@BFDIan-y4t]

He would’ve had one with Golf Ball but she gets out really early now. So maybe could form one with Firey since they’re good friends.

[@YIPPIE_n9]

@ I’m sad gb got out early and firey and tb were friends in bfdia so that would work

[@BFDIovertaker]

3:38 so arguably, dora is cooked here

[@BFDIan-y4t]

It would probably be close, but I still see Donut getting out.

[@Gelnuti62]

I'm glad Pin does not get tortured.

[@BFDIan-y4t]

Yeah, now it’s Match’s turn.

[@Freaky_brightney]

​@BFDIan-y4t i swear i made an au about this lol

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@Freaky_brightney Interesting, do you have a video on it.

[@Freaky_brightney]

​@BFDIan-y4t no it's all posted on my tiktok but I'll summarise it soon

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@Freaky_brightney Nice, I would appreciate that since I don’t like nor do I have tiktok.

[@mi1key]

27:24 why couldnt icy have answered it? And how does td having no voice make her boring?and what plot are you talking about when you say she has no "plot relevance"?

[@BFDIan-y4t]

Pin’s the one in the chamber and Icy guesses what she’s doing, but now Icy’s in the chamber and Pin can’t guess because of Gelatin’s headphones around her. In season 1 Teardrop was considered pretty boring for not doing anything and not speaking so getting Match’s voice would help but they just switch back next episode which ends up making her boring again. She also has no plot up to this episode since she gets Match’s voice and can speak, but she loses it so she has no more plot again and very quickly gets called boring.

[@mi1key]

@BFDIan-y4t but she did do stuff,she was helpful in most of the challenges she was in (before her elimination).And not speaking doesnt automatically make you boring.And people definitely don't think she's boring since if she was she wouldn't have had the 5th most votes to join bfdia.Not to mention that she only had 5 compared to snowballs 18 votes in her bfdi elimination (and that elimination made 0 sense too)and her bfdia one was literally rigged (and before anyone says that she wouldnt have gotten the most votes even if it wasn't rigged,coiny actually had the most before it was rigged by derpy hooves)

[@BFDIan-y4t]

For some reason people thought her elimination in BFDI was unfair, so I can see that’s why she got that much votes to join BFDIA. Yeah she was helpful in the challenges before but becoming boring can get someone eliminated fast. TBF I can see her surviving at least 1 or 2 more eliminations, maybe I eliminated her a bit too fast but eh.

[@mi1key]

​@BFDIan-y4t people though her bfdi elimination was unfair because pencil didnt vote witver her alliance and had a dumb reason for voting snowball.But you arent explaining how she IS boring.if her not being in the "match losing her features" thing makes her boring,then wouldnt that apply to everyone on the odd team? (Besides ice cube and maybe tb at the end).

[@BFDIan-y4t]

@@mi1keyI would expect other people to be at least talking and have interactions with each other, while TD could probably just interact with people but it wouldn’t be enough to save her.

[@Ep1cthebox]

892(nickel's)isn't an even number

[@BFDIan-y4t]

It’s based on their placement, Nickel got the 2nd most votes so he’s on the evens.

[@BFDIovertaker]

BFDIA: The worst alternative

[@BFDIan-y4t]

It’s definitely an interesting one.

[@Freaky_brightney]

Limbless match is cursed what

[@Freaky_brightney]

THIS IS CURSED

[@BFDIan-y4t]

True but it’s also cool to see what could happen.

[@Psychictypecontestant]

I prefer this final 8 anyways

[@BFDIan-y4t]

I think it’s cool, but I also like the final 9 in BFDIA

[@Psychictypecontestant]

@ yea yea both are nice