Binding of Isaac: Ranking ALL Four Souls items, Part 1

[@rayderweich]

Alright, I made an oopsie on monstros tooth. The wording states the player it targets does NOT EXCLUDE WHO CONTROLS IT. With this in mind, it’s about B tier. I plan on compiling this videos when I’m done, correcting mistakes like this. So sorry.

[@CairoOmar39]

I love how you just replayed the audio for moms coin purse for moms purse

[@EpicBob3664]

Anecdote regarding the shovel item: Was playing a game, and used an ehwaz rune to get rid of Delirium. Another player used the Shovel to put it back into the monster deck.

[@toastyregrets]

Dry baby definitely deserves A. Most 2+ damage monsters provide handsome rewards. It acts as a health up in many situations, and can even reduce 3+damage more efficiently than a single health up. Also monstro's tooth can target its holder randomly, might have to knock that down a tier.

[@ZombieBacon1337]

Cheese Grater is probably my favorite item. I always make a show of "Grating" the decks, and holler around for a vote on if it Stays or Goes. It's always fun when people all vote "Stay", but I grate it anyways. :p

[@bananatom7653]

TIERLIST VIDEO!!! POG!!! WHY DID I JUST SAY POG? I CAN'T WAIT FOR THAT "Insane Monopoly Property Tier list" VIDEO!!!

[@turtier]

12:36 Small note, you still need the other player to agree to taking your money, so its not always as simple as just giving it all away because people can deny the money if they don't want you getting the stats. 24:25 I won't let this starter deck slander continue! I actually agree that its pretty specific but if you manage to get it in a game where u have 8 loot already, then it means you'll end the turn at the hand limit of 10. At the start of your next turn you'll be at 11 cards, unless you still had your character card available after the end of your last turn, in which case you'll still be at 10 at the start of the turn. In either case, you can guarantee play 2 cards a round and ALWAYS have starter deck trigger again to replace the cards you played. You'll likely have to discard down to hand size sometimes but that also means that dying and having to discard a card isn't really ever much of an issue. Both me and one of my friends managed to get this at 8 cards before and it can be very powerful. Definitely incredibility situational so I still don't think its that good but its definitely not useless :P 30:03 This one however does suck! You can't even do the same cycling play as starter deck since ending a turn with 0 puts you at 2 which means you have 3 at the start of the turn and so you end with 1... 35:16 Can't remember if you mentioned this for eve in the character tier list but a huge flaw with this plan is that anyone can tap their character card and play some money and you loot that instead... can still definitely work on a monster with a high enough loot reward though given that multiple players would need to have their character card available to stop it. Still, scooping a loot card from discard specifically is so easy to counter and you end up getting a card that's probably worse than whats on top of the deck. Can't even use it to screw over other players that well either. Maybe I'm sleeping on this but I feel like using eve's curse on the loot deck only works until people realise the counter to it and then afterwards it feels like its exclusively good for re-triggering good events from the monster deck, which compost can't even do.

[@rayderweich]

I refuse to believe someone rooting for starter deck. Your other points are pretty valid tho, nice catch on the compost one.

[@Lavandor]

You are the goat man

[@rayderweich]

Thanks dude

[@TheWeirdPantsCharacter]

YEEEEES!!! FINALLY MY PROMISE HAS BEEN FULFILLED

[@rayderweich]

Not yet it hasn’t, part 2 soon

[@karisasani7006]

43:58 If a player is using eden and they get this as one of 3 eternals, ooh boy... Better hope you keep a butter bean on hand at all times since now that it gets the eternal effect, this makes the card a menace

[@CairoOmar39]

My very first game of four souls I played Eden and drew Suicide King. That was very, very fun.

[@mrpersoonman]

its been years at this point and i still scream to the void "why is dry baby the item that does that when wafer exists and literally does that in game" and edmund is silent. he leaves me ignorant and my soul remains unfufilled.

[@mrpersoonman]

hey btw on suicide king I think you kept in 2 takes of the same line and I think the first one was better lol

[@jazzpanda5758]

Love the vid. D10 can also be used to draw our event cards for yourself or other people

[@jazzpanda5758]

Moms bra can reduce monster damage so high damaging cards are more nullified

[@jazzpanda5758]

Both still bad though

[@fl00f94]

for monstros tooth, doesnt the fact that it says "a player at random" instead of "another player at random" imply that the owner of the card can be the randomly chosen player? because if so then that would certainly drag down the items tier placement

[@rayderweich]

I was notified of this and forgot to pin a comment, what I’m gonna do is after all my lists, I’ll compile a mega list, with errors like that one fixed. I also was convinced to move up shovel to C tier

[@matery77]

25:55 funny

[@rayderweich]

NOT ANYMORE!

[@matery77]

Nice

[@haydenlong6819]

Want to mention that Mom's Bra can reduce the damage dealt to a monster so you can use it to prevent another player from dealing big damage to a boss monster. Still doesn't make it a very good item but it does give it a use case beyond being a worse dry baby.

[@laurenttelmosse3375]

Super video! Just a question. How does modling clay cant copy one of your own items? Its not specified on the card

[@laurenttelmosse3375]

And is it able to copy an item in the shop?

[@rayderweich]

It can copy any item in play, meaning if it’s on the table not in discard, it is fair game, including yours

[@karisasani7006]

11:31 This is assuming they don't have something like a death card which outright kills you

[@vitalikorol9571]

11:45. This item is good with Bambo.

[@pandoxyy]

the mom's (coin) purse bit is great

[@rayderweich]

Thank you, I had fun editing it

[@solid4645]

19:24 you could have picked up judas’ shadow and maybe gotten brimstone either way it’s a damage up

[@yup635]

I was playing one on one against a friend, and they ended up with sacred heart and eternal D6, and the ONLY thing that kept them from running away with the game was me buying Dad’s lost coin, seriously that game was wack.

[@_kartofeleek]

cool

[@aaron_exe6449]

goddamn thats a lot of items for a 1st part

[@watchrandomuser395onyoutube]

5:21 why did you take baby-bender over rotten penny?? You don’t even have any familiars for it to have any form of benefit, while rotten penny gives you a fly on every instance of a common pickup. I don’t play fiend folio so is there some interaction i’m missing out on? 6:46 you wasted your chariot card, (unless fiend folio changes it) you can open that chest with dark arts 29:10 NEVERMIND you just skip hush, i honestly can’t think of a single hard attack he has that tainted judas can’t handle 30:45 ok my comment didn’t save and i just lost 87% of it. 30:45 this is the one situation where i’d see why you’d skip the penny trinket, you’re going down, and you are on sheol alreday 30:52 i’m just going to repeat (because it didn’t save) you haven’t used hemoptysis a single time (and again the striped red line is under hemoptysis even though i looked it up, when i’m spelling it it’s in the recommended words thing, and i looked it up to make sure i’m spelling it right)

[@rayderweich]

I play bad on purpose to farm engagement

[@watchrandomuser395onyoutube]

@@rayderweich oh ok, fair enough you got me

[@Bruhmidium]

19:18 i know you were MAAD you couldn't get brim

[@ecbrd8478]

you sound like the joker when you talk about some of these

[@rayderweich]

Which… joker…

[@ecbrd8478]

unfortunately i cannot say with any certainty as i have only experienced the joker through random clips and people doing impressions.

[@jerryjefferyson288]

Why didnt he get the brimstone in the backround footage :(

[@rayderweich]

Didn’t wanna

[@dockboys2023]

One thing to note: for items with, such as ones with ""when a x number is rolled" effects, the degree to their efficacy varies how strong it is. Examples: 1) Eye of Greed (when a player rolls a 5, gain 3 cents) is WAYYY better when playing with 5 players than with 2 players; 2)Monstro's Tooth (start of your turn, a random player destroys an item) where more players means you are less likely that you'll be screwed over, thus, more likely to pull down your competition - I don't like controlling that item because I tend to play 2 and sometimes 3 player games, and that random player selected tends to be the one who controls the tooth. 3) My Shadow (gain the penny and loot card a player would die due to the death penalty): profiting from others demise. More players, more likely of others dying, more money and loot for you - even trash loot is valuable loot due to many reasons you could think of. 4) The Map (end of your turn, look top 4 cards of monster deck, choose what order they go in) - two players, great item! Play around with the monster deck, so the top card is never or rarely a soul for the other player to attack. 3 or more players, this item becomes more unusable. Essentially, you'll most likely see and plan for the monsters and events other people will be drawing. The rankings of some of these items can be quite dubious due to this fact of player count variation. Enjoyed the video! Keep up with raising up the Four Souls presence on KZbin :)

[@moamelali5122]

I love you pookie bear i wanna hold you❤❤❤

[@toastyregrets]

Bro... what the fuck...

[@mothtrith]

Your paired that into with an hour long video and named it part 1. cool anyways bro

[@adubs543]

BORB

[@Corrupted_computeR]

I love leaf blower revolution