Army's controversial encounter in Nagaland: Time for AFSPA to retreat? Bisbo

The Indian Army's' recent ambush on suspected insurgents, causing the death of 15 civilians in Nagaland, has once again renewed calls for withdrawal of the controversial Armed Forces Special Powers Act. We look at the history of insurgency, the role of peace processes and the role armed forces in the Northeast.
#nagaland #afspa #indianarmy
Tutorial video on how to join Bisbo's discord
Discord tutorial video link: • How to join Bisbo Discord
Discord joining link: / discord
Sources
Rajya Sabha
Members of Rajya Sabha (State wise list); Dec 30, 2021
Newslaundry
Ambush, mob fury, and a lawless law: A timeline of what happened in Nagaland on December 4; Samrat X; Dec 6, 2021
Manipur ambush: Along borders, a complex weave of militant and ethnic rivalries, history of Myanmar links; Samrat X; Nov 15, 2021
BBC
Nagaland: Indian state tense after killing of 14 civilians; Subir Bhaumik; Dec 6, 2021
Scroll
Nagaland: Day after 13 civilians killed by security forces, fresh violence erupts in Mon district; Dec 5, 2021
The Hindu
Nagaland seeks AFSPA repeal, scraps ongoing Hornbill Festival; Rahul Karmakar; Dec 7, 2021
Manipur and Assam resisted MHA decision to remove AFSPA tag; Vijaita Singh; Dec 12, 2021
The Times of India
Among Oting’s 13 dead, father of two-month-old baby, man married for just 9 days; Yudhajit Shankar Das; Dec 8, 2021
Chorus for withdrawing AFSPA grows shriller in Northeast; Kangkan Kalita; Dec 8, 2021
Army killing Nagaland civilians unfortunate, Shah tells House; Dec 7, 2021
Officer of major general rank to head Army's court of inquiry into Nagaland firing incident; Dec 7, 2021
Meeting intransigence of Naga leaders; Jan 3, 1956
The much maligned Nagas; Harish Chandola; 1956
How Deve Gowda tried to solve the Naga problem; Sugata Srinivasaraju; Dec 9, 2021
East Mojo
Nagaland: Mon massacre shows India has never treated Nagas as equal; Richard Kamei, Roderick Wijunamai; Dec 6, 2021
The Print
I served in Nagaland during the peak of insurgency and without AFSPA; M.G. Devasahayam; Dec 7, 2021
Firstpost
Nagaland killings are unfortunate, but security forces are agents of peace in North East; Utpal Kumar; Dec 8, 2021
Nagaland killings are an anomaly and should not be used to villainise security forces in North East; Jaideep Saikia; Dec 6, 2021
India Today
Nagaland shooting: Latest violence and its links with demand for Nagalim | Explained; Prabhash K Dutta; Dec 7, 2021
Indian Army allows questioning of jawans for deaths of 14 Nagaland civilians; Manjeet Negi, Hemanta Kumar Nath; Dec 29, 2021
Livemint
Why AFSPA has been removed from some areas; Shaswati Das; Apr 24, 2018
Tehelka
Operation Hilltop sparks outrage against Assam Rifles; Ratnadip Choudhury; Oct 2, 2014 Tehelka expose Operation Hilltop: Tehelka scribe risks life, records statement; Nidhin Chandran; Mar 17, 2015
The Economic Times
Assam Rifles brass under scanner for lapses in deal; Manu Pubby; Mar 17, 2020
The Wire
Nagaland Killings: Demands to Repeal AFSPA Continue, Including in Parliament; Dec 7, 2021
Almost Half of All Human Rights Violation Complaints Reported From J&K; Gaurav Vivek Bhatnagar; Jul 15, 2017
Supreme Court Slams Claim That Manipur Fake Encounter Probe Will 'Demoralise' Army; Anoo Bhuyan; Nov 13, 2018
Human Rights Watch
Getting Away With Murder: 50 Years of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act; 2008
Contemporary South Asia journal
The predicament of justice: fifty years of Armed Forces Special Powers Act in
India; Dolly Kikon; Sep 1 2009
Al Jazeera
Tribes along India-Myanmar border dream of a ‘united Nagaland’; AFP; Apr 28, 2020
Indian Express
‘Admit we got aggressive but they killed our brothers, who had done no wrong’; Tora Agarwala; Dec 7, 2021
Intention to murder, injure civilians: Nagaland Police FIR against Army unit; Krishn Kaushik; Dec 6, 2021
Nagaland killing puts question mark on peace talks; Deeptiman Tiwary, Esha Roy; Dec 6, 2021
Explained: Why Nagaland killings have rekindled debate on AFSPA; Dec 7, 2021
Explained: Why Nagaland civilian deaths have cast shadow on Hornbill Festival; Divya A; Dec 7, 2021
Naga talks: What has caused the stalemate so far, and what impact can killings have?; Deeptiman Tiwary; Dec 8, 2021
Explained: In Nagaland case, when Supreme Court laid down procedure for using AFSPA; Apurva Vishwanath; Dec 9, 2021
Explained: What is AFSPA, and why are states in Northeast against it?; Esha Roy; Dec 11, 2021
Explained: Konyak tribe numbers make them crucial to peace talks; Dec 7, 2021
Hindustan Times
Blackened India's image: Nagaland CM asks Centre to repeal Afspa from Nagaland; Dec 06, 2021
Manipur probe almost over, allow SIT officers to do other work: CBI to SC; Neeraj Chauhan & Utkarsh Anand; Apr 07, 2021
The Week
War on drugs and weapons led to killing of commanding officer, jawans in Manipur ambush; Pradip R Sagar; Nov 15, 2021
Enemy at the Gates; Rabi Banerjee; Jan 9, 2022

[@akaiadams9100]

I know contents cannot bring positiveness in every way. U're trying to be on a safe side both ways, not blaming u either instead thank u and the team for bringing this incident to a broader sense depicting atrocities of the uniformed Mandate. But, mistake is a mistake, there should not be cover ups to make it look right. Mistakes should not cost multiple lives too, randomly and continuously. Let justice prevail and sustain longer..

[@viphrezoable]

So true👍👍. Cover up their mistakes by bringing out false allegations is not the right thing to do when eye witnesses has already given their statement. To this channel, can you say somethings regarding their lies?

[@hmingirenthlei4665]

True i feel bisbo is BJP puppets, not worth watching.

[@siddharthsoni6734]

They have already started taking action against those responsible for it.

[@POLTunatoAwomi]

.

[@stopekayepthomi6421]

True

[@VishalYadav-qc9ij]

" Direct marise…they shot right at us, no signal to stop, we did not flee" ambush survivor You should have mentioned this also

[@ginglebell2969]

Yeah they shot because they saw hunting rifles on them couldn't use night vision because it wasn't dark enough someone slashed paratrooper gutams neck you guys deserve it

[@GreenPotato25]

@@ginglebell2969 hunting rifle is common for northeast every house in village must have riffle or Airgun..... But the fact is that on that day no riffle was there... Army is trying to depend themselves but yeah I also love Indian Army but truth should be tell

[@MrMuninborah]

If the villagers had carried their guns on that fateful day, there would have been more casualties from both the villagers n the paratroopers.

[@rajivsbora4880]

New bihari naga here 😂

[@lestendsouza9395]

Good work Bisbo but there was a eye witness who mentioned there was no warning shots fired nor any attempt to stop the lorry.

[@LensFromNorthEast5338]

His information is a lie

[@philiplam6975]

@@LensFromNorthEast5338 like your name and the identity of your father

[@hyperlinkcomputerlab7253]

Two eye witnesses are still alive .. and if they were stop why the bullets marks is in windshield. And now way driver would sleep up in such a bad road conditions. I travel in that road everytime with my motor, even with motor bike I can go hardly go up to 20 kmph to 25 kmph

[@noksenwangsa916]

I am a neighbor of that incident. The army did not give any warning and they were trying to dispose off the body secretly. What confuse me is that the army were still loitering around the spot for about an hour until the search party arrived and hell broke out between them. Nowhere in any part of the world would any unarmed civilians attack a well armed troop head-on with just farming tools

[@stopekayepthomi6421]

​@@LensFromNorthEast5338no, you're a liar

[@amanjotsingh6622]

Unfortunate Incident. Army must ensure court martials against officers responsible. Our army is not that week that they will get demoralise from such court proceedings. The common man awaits Justice. Jai Hind 🇮🇳

[@BisboWorld]

Amanjot and Samanyu, we share the feeling that justice prevails in this unfortunate incident.

[@SPM_SS]

@@samanyuxkaushal Who told you that the civilians were asked to stop and that they didn't?

[@arunavkumarsingh3659]

@@SPM_SS its in the video, they were asked to stop the car but they panicked , which any army person or any person would have mistaken as an attempt to flee the scene , first watch the video.. thank you!

[@SPM_SS]

@@arunavkumarsingh3659 So you belive this video more than the survivor? The Para forces released a statement saying they were laying an ambush but the Intel turned out to be faulty. Do you k ow what ambush means? It means surprise attack. Does that involve asking the targets to stop? Does that make sense? It's important to support the troops but they must be held accountable for civilians murders.

[@arunavkumarsingh3659]

@@SPM_SS fair enough! i agree

[@Vigilante123]

Well balanced Video, unlike some extremely bias video in favour of Army. Thanks for the video.

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you, Sanjit.

[@beinyurame723]

They weren't loading them in a van,in fact,they were hiding the bodies under the sand in a pick up truck,evident videos are there to support this statement

[@tempergamingchannel2947]

If the villagers didn’t arrive on time to see that then they would have told the media as insurgents encounter and will just end the case,these military rats try to act very cunning

[@mosakb2050]

I'm a Konyak,Naga which means Headhunters. I stands to Withdraw ###RepealASPA

[@ramneekxkmphkolkata]

Was on a motorcycle road trip to North East in November, days before the massacre, visited Mon district and found the Konyaks to be nothing but cheerful and hospitable. In my experience of traveling to Kashmir and North East, I strongly feel that like all draconian laws, AFSPA needs to go! Sad, sad and extremely sad! :-( P.S. I have the utmost respect for our armed forces.

[@samarthbarshi1916]

Do u really think they committed this error because they thought anyways AFSPA will save them? Action is being taken, isn't it?

[@ketholelkoso3047]

@@samarthbarshi1916 no actions were being taken till date. There were many fake encounters even before this unfortunate incident, however this time they were caught red handed. The army admitted their mistake. If there's no AFSAP, the justice will be delivered by now, but because of this act, we never find the justice when this kind of incidents happened. I respect the Indian Army jawans, however there are many Indian Army officers and jawans who killed innocent civilians and framed them as an insurgents just to get recognition/awards from the Army. There's not a single case where the Indian Army /Indian Paramilitary Forces jawans faced the legal system of the land. And this video is just a makeup inorder to justify the Army's actions. In reality they (Naga civilians) were killed in cold blood.

[@Rudraksh-ql4ce]

Then please gift northeast to NSCN , ULFA on a platter of you want to remove AFSPA. Army cannot do counter insurgency operations without it. And if AFSPA is withdrawn northeast will become a seperate country.

[@rajashashankgutta4334]

​​@@Rudraksh-ql4cebrother, AFSPA is itself fueling insurgency. If you kill and abuse civilians willy-nilly and still face no enquiry over it, then civilians gonna find justice in insurgency. Want to end insurgency? Use diplomacy and intelligence not brute force.

[@souvastalinpao1578]

Corrections 7:18 Naga People's Front(NPF) is a regional political party in Nagaland and Manipur, it is not a militant group nor was it involved in the killing of Colonel Viplav Tripathi. 11:15 It's Konyak not Koyank

[@DiabloNemes]

NPF separatist hai

[@dictatornagauraauvie5208]

@@DiabloNemes ulu ka banga

[@DiabloNemes]

@@dictatornagauraauvie5208 khankirchele

[@FallenMetsubu1992]

​@@DiabloNemes NPF separatist hai?? 😂😂😂😂 waa baba Moj kar de, It's like saying Modiji ne War rukwade Papa 😂😂😂😂

[@patung1990]

Yes, Col. Viplav Tripathi and his family were killed by metei PLA not naga. I was trying to correct this guy with his half baked truth. He dont want to acknowledge it.

[@aadrath1236]

Wow! Never new this fact about Deve Gowda. He was the PM for less than a year yet the impact was impeccable💯

[@ILikeGoodMusic313]

No other KZbinr is so thorough and entertaining with their content. You should have at least more than 10 million subs.

[@arianbora217]

Please do some home work:....It was not Assam Refiles who did the encounter but Para (Special Forces) Jorhat, Assam Refiles didn't had any Idea on the mission ....You must be responsible before such video

[@ILikeGoodMusic313]

@@arianbora217 does it matter ? Innocents died. Picture your brother or father in the place of people who died.

[@BisboWorld]

We hope to get to the 10 million target soon enough. Thanks for the wishes.

[@sarpinpo]

@@samanyuxkaushal 😂😂😂 who told you the car is running check real interview of victim you would believe what army told because it will damage indian army reputation 👏👏👏....

[@jackofhearts1414]

@@samanyuxkaushal yeah I heard that according to the victims the vehicle did stopped !

[@ngampasangme9477]

As per the survivers of the ambush, they were not stopped. The security fired hiding from the bushes

[@zololaks7249]

100℅ true

[@PEzung1341]

MF🖕🖕🖕go n check the road contacting can't even drive 20 k/h

[@asaxthegamer5655]

Great video, just one thing bro, it was not 21 Para Regiment of the Assam Rifles, but the 21st Battalion of the Parachute Regiment (Special Forces). Separate from the Assam Rifles.

[@BisboWorld]

Yes. We acknowledge this mistake. Missed it in editing. We will be more careful in future.

[@susheeldutt6486]

@@BisboWorldeven i was supposed to point out the same mistake but even their are few mistakes which obviously u might not be aware as u r a youtuber

[@susheeldutt6486]

@@BisboWorld I request u to make a video on history of Assam Rfiles the sentinels of North east friends of the hill people

[@rangerleo81]

What can you expect from these people. Incomplete research. No wonder our country men are so ill informed

[@tuxnoel]

Assam rifles was involved.

[@edwardkikon2259]

We will never forget this incident

[@Rikam786]

Team Bisbo you guys should research about tha incident deeply. Hear the victims statement they said there where no signal to stop by the assam rifle and the suspect didn't tried to flee . Assam rife they just started open firing without any warning....

[@pritamkar2277]

Bro it is army not bloody terrorist , they never open fired without any warning. Do you have any common sense

[@Rikam786]

😒😒😒 goo hear the victims statement first ...don't support murderes.. The people you are calling army with respect even tried to hide the dead bodies........ You should go and hear the ground report it's still available on KZbin

[@BisboWorld]

We listened to both sides, Rikam. And came to the conclusions.

[@Rikam786]

@@BisboWorld 👍

[@sapkarronya9081]

@@BisboWorld i hope you missed the part where they got shot from front not from behind fleeing.... how can someone fleeing get shot head on

[@niranjanvasudevan8957]

Rip 😞😞😞. May peace and prosperity rise in our North Eastern States. Love and support from Tamilnadu ♥️♥️♥️.

[@toshiolongkumer]

Great effort in research and the presentation notwithstanding the fact that the graphics depicts the amount of effort that went through in making this content. I am a Naga from Nagaland and I am glad your team made this content. It is time what happens here reaches the mainstream.

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you. Glad to hear from you.

[@Downwithimperialism]

So u agree that they were trying to flee... Then I guess there is no need for investigation or removal of Afspa left

[@nchuhyemkonyak9298]

@@BisboWorld Kindly study the ground level and make the contents. Need to rectify, Bruh..need to rectify..!! Thank you

[@eastlife3048]

Villagers were asking for the dead bodies but the forces tried to hide under a tarpaulin. Upon seeing this, clash took place between them and the force fired and killed another 7 villagers

[@shamleemossang6277]

Great effort in bringing out the true scenario and the problems faced by us North Easterners.

[@naveents1732]

very nice explanation. And the crossfire animation, in the end, is shown very well, this is absolutely sadly but true

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Naveen. Glad you liked the animation

[@The_truth85]

Appreciate that u finally came out with a video. But I wanted to make a slight correction that they were not stopped but it was purely an ambush. U can get the real facts from the those who escape from this ambush. Thanks anyway.

[@mayanglambamregal8809]

Wow Manipal capital Imphal , there is no state called Manipal ,it's Manipur , 21st Para are not Assam rifles , pls correct this mistake otherwise this will lead to many mistakes to viewers

[@BisboWorld]

We regret the error in editorial oversight and will put it in our video description.

[@Allinonezzz]

There are many mistakes in this video

[@mahidharsingh]

👍

[@Chishiisuka]

I'm glad that u made this video for our Nagaland thank you ❤️

[@BisboWorld]

Welcome Isuka

[@alphonsuisile3768]

Your research and efforts are greatly appreciated...What a nice explanation! AFSPA should be removed as soon as possible.

[@tl-favourites]

May Peace prevail in Nagaland !! GOI must act for the benefit of Naga and peace. Thanks Bisbo ..such a great narrative as every word mentioned is truly on fact.

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you Sir

[@timothydiswang8423]

No offense, Frankly every words mentioned is Truly facts.?

[@abenkikon]

The irony is that one of the injured victim was a retired para commando

[@nonlempkmun4307]

The first fired occurred at 3:10 PM on 4th December 2021. At 03:10 PM, it was not dark, anything can be visible. Errors 1.The army didn't signal the pickup carrying the miners to stop but directly fired them. 2. The villagers did not attack on army but the villagers just came to the spot on hearing unusual gun shot. 3. After reaching the spot, villagers asked Army whereabouts of coal labourers but they responded that they didn't know anything about them but the death bodies were ultimately found hiding loaded on the army vehicle. Thus, it shows that those army involved were absolutely false if not it was a premeditated killing If you want more authenticity and evidences there are many victims of the same incident still survive and alive. There are several errors in the contents. Please do not mislead and misguide the viewers. Let the justice be serve to the innocent civilians.

[@KhowKho]

It's very much clear that either the top officials want to score some point for promotion or some medals with fake encounter, or some top think tank want to made it look like surgical strike across the border. This type of incidents r nothing new only innocent civilians pay the price.

[@ejem872]

Efforts in making the video was great..... But one thing for sure the Para military never asked to STOP the vehicle but they directly shot them and this is said by one of the survival of the ambush so I wish you could collect the information more mindfully. Thank you RIP brothers♡

[@hyperlinkcomputerlab7253]

It's a lie they try to stop them. Two eye witnesses are still alive .. and if they were stop why the bullets marks is in windshield. And now way driver would sleep up in such a bad road conditions. I travel in that road everytime with my motor bike, even with motor bike I can hardly go up to 20 kmph to 25 kmph. Narrow road and in bad condition. A road build by villagers. A muddy road.

[@ManishSingh-jz2hx]

thanks for the informative video bisbo!

[@BisboWorld]

Glad you liked it, Manish.

[@satishkumarramteke3162]

I don't know what exactly happened but I'm sure it has definitely dented the peace process and we all know which country or countries would be benefiting from it. I'm actually disappointed from our intelligence agencies it's their incompetence that has led to such a horrific incident.

[@BisboWorld]

Satish, we hope an unbiased enquiry that is happening will lead to even more clarity and things will get sorted.

[@ishwarchandrajkumar1634]

Great work Brisbo!! Looking forward for more underlying stories of the Northeastern states.

[@AbhishekDesair]

People make fun of Deve Gowda. I have too. But after watching Dr Subramaniam Swamy's video on Pgurus channel my view about him changed. This video shed light on him too. In fact he was the one who opened Bofors files which led to his govt falling.

[@BisboWorld]

Well pointed Abhishek. His approach to resolve this issue was novel.

[@kevinzu9039]

Thanks bisbo for making this video... We northeast salute,,, and huge hugs and love from nagaland

[@BisboWorld]

Great to hear from you, Kevin. Thanks a lot for the overwhelming wishes 🌹🙏

[@kevinzu9039]

@@BisboWorld have been subscribed your channel long time ago both english and hindi version,,, may you gain more ☺☺☺

[@yukeme8441]

It's Time for Konyak It's Time for Nagas to pressure on a government to deliver justice JUSTICE DELAY IS JUSTICE DENIED

[@zimbolimbo2408]

Thankyou for taking the time to make this video and that too in the most unbiased manner.

[@truethat7681]

I don't want AFSPA in the north east as they are pro India but there should be APFSPA in Punjab and West Bengal.

[@tivo3720]

Ohhh really... Seem you know more..rather then raw?!! Haa? Why only wb and panjab bcz.. BJP can't win there... Really.. What a rascal

[@shabashachi1238]

Yes

[@truethat7681]

@@tivo3720 Add Afspa in Kerala as well.

[@dem0_o14]

First in shithole states like UP Bihar

[@siddharthjain9611]

​@@tivo3720bengal needs it because of Bangladeshis

[@User360iskon]

95% true. Great research work

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you Anurag, why not 100%?

[@Bedroom_Musician]

It's so unfair that They're still unpunished till now.

[@thebookworm4567]

I just love watching ur videos, bisbo !!!! They're very informative and the narrative style is just amazing!!!!! I can listen for hrs to u 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗

[@BisboWorld]

Happy to hear that. Thanks, The Bookworm.

[@dr.victorperumal1248]

Damn bro... Didn't know India has a state named "Manipal" with Imphal as capital... 11:04

[@FrancisMossang]

Error 🚫404

[@BisboWorld]

Regret the error, Supratim. Will be more careful.

[@dr.victorperumal1248]

@@BisboWorld Not many people accept their mistake... Thnx fr doing tht... Actually, we, North Easterns are so ignored and overlooked by rest of India that we have become a bit touchy about these names and stuff....

[@VATSSAMEER]

The story made me sad when I saw it first time. Kudos to team for this video on such a sensitive topic with great professionalism. _/\_

[@mrenankrastogi2404]

Very informative video Would just like to point out a correction: 11:03 AFSPA was removed (2004) from MANIPUR'S capital Imphal [Not Manipal]

[@thecollectorsite6392]

Bro...I really really appreciate❤️how you presented n show this sad story 😭.. people will now start to understand more properly

[@spearz6183]

it pains to know that you misinterpreted the Oting incident......you need to go for more indepth research about the incident before presenting such sensitive news........

[@zorojuro7731]

What did he missed out?

[@NCI_2024]

@@zorojuro7731 you think the armies stopped the vehicle standing on the road and they sped away?

[@satyasiddhamishra4950]

Congratulations on reaching 500k subscribers hope you reach a million subscribers as you totally deserve it.

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks a lot for inspiring us Satyasiddha 🙏

[@erica8332]

Hopefully, those involved in this fake encounter would be punished, for killing so many innocent civilians, not only did they try to get rid of evidence they also killed the villagers who tried to prevent the soldiers from disposing of evidence and dead bodies. They shouldn't get away with murder.

[@nyeixneang5366]

Very important thank you sir

[@arianbora217]

Please do some home work:....It was not Assam Refiles who did the encounter but Para (Special Forces) Jorhat, Assam Refiles didn't had any Idea on the mission ....You must be responsible before such video

[@BisboWorld]

We apologise for this mistake, Arian. It slipped in the final editing phase. We acknowledge that the ambush operation was undertaken by the Special Forces. Assam Rifles only became involved once their buildings were set on fire. We will be more careful in future.

[@arianbora217]

@@BisboWorld Thank you

[@arianbora217]

@@BisboWorld Be Careful before making any video on Indian Arm Forces...its a sensitive subject

[@dwanithlol]

there way of telling the stories literally leaves me thinking about the situation also after the video ends

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Dwanith. It's nice to hear that our videos evoke people to think further.

[@tonozhimo745]

The Army has made a mistake and even if they try to cover up their guilty it won't bring back the lives of the innocent citizens....... Let justice be serve at the earliest!!! Until justice been served their souls will never rest in peace!!!!

[@Su19.f]

BIASED+ONE SIDED STORY.

[@nagabhushanbn2497]

Congratulations on 500k. I hope you achieve a lot more as you deserve it ☺

[@arianbora217]

Please do some home work:....It was not Assam Refiles who did the encounter but Para (Special Forces) Jorhat, Assam Refiles didn't had any Idea on the mission ....You must be responsible before such video

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you for the wishes, Nagabhushan.

[@HYDRASUMI]

Another good video without a better prove! 👎 They didn't try to flee nor they was signalled to stop. AFSPA just ambush without any warning ⚠️ it's the answer.

[@chentonkonyak8419]

The army didn't signal the poor coal miners to stop, they opened fired on their truck, (according to eye witnesses). Please research properly.

[@arunavkumarsingh3659]

pls attach the source!

[@dem0_o14]

@@arunavkumarsingh3659 Source: Whatsapp

[@yourneighbourhoodaround803]

Get your facts check properly! I used to one amongst your followers but this topic is not true, 1 the road conditions is so underdeveloped that the question of vechile fleeing at speed is not possible plus the bullet riddled windshield infront makes it doubtful the action of the army, despite no retaliatory gunfight they shower several rounds, 2 the pickup vechile behind had no hood to conseal any passenger's behind at around 3-4pm in a broad daylight. 3, the army personnels lied not knowing what anything and when confronted the villagers found the slain bodies conseal underneath the equipment n bag with some even being striped naked, Dear Bisbo please get it right

[@saitamasensei1984]

This video should get viral as no one knows about this thing

[@lamkhoginhaokip3055]

I still recall the day when all the men in our Village got beaten up

[@KL_tzy]

Please don't mislead the information. One and only survivor from that incident said that they were shot directly from different directions without any signals .... So be very careful when u update anything on yt from next time

[@tanishqshukla1252]

Great video, I understand that this topic would have been a very difficult one to cover requiring in depth analysis and finding root causes of situation. It requires a lot of work to create it as a digestible feature.

[@BisboWorld]

Well said Tanishq! We get trolled from all sides for this!

[@makesense2931]

Is it possible it was a conspiracy? Someone gave them bad intel or they missed the real insurgents somehow? Either way it is sad when both jawans and innocent civilian life is lost.

[@debpanda3863]

Dialogue is the key to resolve north east problem. Certain vested interests are creating situations where common man is suffering.

[@moaimsong4132]

Don't ever upload video or never descript without knowing the truth,they shoot without any reason

[@guilinthinangmoita1684]

Col. Viplov tripathi and family was not killed by manipur Naga United liberation front (there is no such UGs in manipur) as said by the Commentators actually it's only meitei UGs.

[@vibrationsled6215]

Thank you Your team done a great job covered lot of information and acts, making easily understandable and also about the laws specifically elaborative way .... excellent work....🙏👌🙏🙏🙏

[@neiwangkonyak3272]

Thanks for covering Oting incident 🙏👏

[@57_yashtakle61]

Great job bisbo, I knew what afspa was but not the history. Your analysis has given me better insights

[@arianbora217]

Please do some home work:....It was not Assam Refiles who did the encounter but Para (Special Forces) Jorhat, Assam Refiles didn't had any Idea on the mission ....You must be responsible before such video

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Yash. Glad to know that.

[@litazo6574]

@@arianbora217 to kya hua shutiye , hai to army hi na . AR or Para doesn't matter who committed the crime

[@icedsushi7957]

The actual truth. One of the survivor said that they never asked them to stop and instead fired at them without warning

[@wangpohsajahyenshu9073]

Great video but it's a fake ,the army didn't gave any sign to stop and the workers doesn't tries to flee...don't miss lead the people.

[@aspirants899]

Good report bisbo but as a citizen of nagaland ,we only want peace and progress.however we r keep in sandwich between insurgents and state making our lives hell.

[@lamthaikhiam5844]

I appreciate your work but please work out thoroughly because the issue is sensitive and some information is misunderstood regarding Oting ambush by the 21 para security forces.

[@Xavier-cm1vt]

They didn't drive away, they stopped and also the armies tried to hide the bodies cover with their belongings....that's wrong information.

[@lara.kh9724]

It should not be Manipal's capital imphal it should be Manipur's capital Imphal

[@BisboWorld]

Oops. Yes.

[@rahuldey9544]

@@BisboWorld what do you mean by oops.. shame to see you don't have any knowledge

[@ankur.mahajan]

The suggestion that each state must have equal no of MP in Rajya Sabha just like US Senate is very much needed. For proportional representation, we already have Lok Sabha. Also, each RS MP must be elected directly by people of the state rather than the Legislative Assembly as most of the time RS is used as backdoor entry into the parliament.

[@srikar5781]

Even BISBO doesnt know how para special forces operate apart from general regiments. HOME WORK IS IMPORTANT.

[@BisboWorld]

We acknowledge and apologise for our mistake, Srikar.

[@srikar5781]

@@BisboWorld apologizing doesn't help anyone when your wrong statements are still in the video. ( The last statement should be changed. and at 6 :50 you used JUST LIKE KASHMIR .... the Kashmir has a different problem, you are directly without any explanation claiming that the problem is the same as Nagaland about the separate flag and constitution. Hope you won't turn the tables when it comes to reality.

[@Socialist20thcentury]

They hid their dead bodies when the villagers came but luckily the villagers became suspicious and check and found it hidden under stacks of food supplies. They were trying to cover up this murder.

[@imtiyaszsa9532]

11:04 Manipal capital Imphal seriously????

[@BisboWorld]

Oops. Manipur it is.

[@imtiyaszsa9532]

@@BisboWorld appreciate your work... Keep going... All d best...👍

[@ekdoek]

Bhaiyo beheno! No nid to argue here, dnt side with the army (read as those para commandos involved in this incident) because this is not a rare incident, fake ambush/ fake encounters have been happening since 1947. It's just because of this so called "afspa", that the high handedness of both assam rifles n army have been covered up. If this incident had happened in the 90's the army wud have easily lied and their version wid hv been taken as the truth. But today we r living in social media era where every little incidents are captured and shared all over internet. So instead visit the victims n listen to their voices too if u really want to knw the truth..

[@luke-ld8tv]

Don't mislead,they didn't charge and more no truck was asked to stop...

[@arkscrew]

In arunachal too they open fired on civilians protesting against dam in the heart of the town under the pretext of insurgency doubts. And mind you that town has no history whatsoever of insurgency.

[@kaustubhshukla5311]

Well for your information, my friend was on a trip to Nagaland. He was from Assam. They killed him and one of his friend who was a pillion. His bike was stolen and sold. We reported the incident to the Nagaland Police. First they didn't registered the FIR. In order to get the FIR registered, we have to go through court and after 6 months of date and again date , an order was passed to register FIR. Till now we and his family are waiting for the justice to be served. We thought this was a one off case. Then we came to know that this is something very common in Nagaland. Those having any doubts should ask to Assamese drivers. They have mamy such horrific tales to tell. Also for a glance on how much they love India, one can have a look at their local newspapers. It is filled with hatred and fake news regarding the other parts of India and it's people. Talking about human rights, it is not that when a personal wears an army dress,he or she give up on their own human rights. Those army personnel are also human with their own loved ones and their own family to feed back home. Those who are talking about repealing AFSPA, put yourself in army boots, you will realise what an army personnel goes through. You want them to protect you and your family. You want them to put their life at risk at all times surrounded by separatists and terrorist and at the same time are unwilling to provide them with some immunity. Where is sense of proportionity in this debate?? When a Major and his family along with a 7 year old boy was killed, they were going gaga by reacting 😂😂 on the news and editorials. When CDS Bipin Rawat was killed they were saying lol and 😂😂 on the comment section. And when some of them got killed they are like how can you do this?? We are too liberal. Despite of all the things that I have gone through, we were sad for those were killed in Nagaland. And now they want us to believe that what Army has told us is wrong. Sorry to say to my Indian brothers, I believe my Army more than those people who once advised me on the death case of my friend that I should leave Nagaland as soon as possible if I want to be alive. I respect my Army to work in those tough conditions to make our borders safe and for the same I believe giving AFSPA to such regions is absolutely correct and it should not be repealed till Nagaland and it's people come to normalcy as other states like Mumbai and Karnataka.

[@sendong8485]

Mr.Shukla, if you have the Guts to speak the Truth. Share you phone Number and your Story. If you are scared that the Nagas will harm you, screenshot this comment and print it and give it to your Nearest Police Station. I think it is High Time for People like you to come out in Open and Prove your Accusations against the Nagas. I hope you will have all the proofs ready when the Local Police Station from Dimapur Nagaland contacts you. Best Wishes and may the Truth come to light soon.

[@wangschem8452]

wow! well done.

[@Comical_LLama]

Afspa gives absolute power, remember that

[@arianbora217]

Please do some home work:....It was not Assam Refiles who did the encounter but Para (Special Forces) Jorhat, Assam Refiles didn't had any Idea on the mission ....You must be responsible before such video

[@SAChishi]

Well said.

[@phoenix2105]

I know you have made this content seeing the report given by Amit shah,but as we all know that those reports were totally fake,it is more likely to be said as scripted or whatever.Please don't mislead the common people with fake news or content.

[@minpuedits2798]

Remove/Revoke AFSPA is Mandatory from Nagaland. Bisbo bro, Story of yours in the video is wrongly shown or inform to the world. Before any inquiry report how can you tell your own video report. Still waiting for Justice for our 14 brothers (innocent civilians/daily wage earners) who were massacred by Para SF Indian army for the word Mistaken identity. Incredible India

[@shreyandattagupta7387]

Om Shanti for the 15 victims The best PM of India of all time at 6:26

[@KNgulie...4732]

The army never stop them nor a mistaken identity but a direct ambush on public as always..

[@ronaltherai]

My father is from 22nd Assam rifles and I can genuinely confirm that Assam rifles wasn't involved, it was para military.. requesting you to do ur homework properly 👍

[@BisboWorld]

Request heeded. We will be more careful.

[@ajmanghangshing6425]

Good research done.representations entertaining n interesting .great output.

[@piyushrangdal8141]

Congratulations on reaching 500k subs Bisbo, you deserve it

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you Piyush.

[@LoneWolf-yp9qw]

Rest in peace innocent lives lost. Jai Hind Bravehearts. We must resolve internal affairs amicably as repealing AFSPA would embolden external enemies to create havoc

[@aakashpal2311]

if army not protect Nagaland then many terrorist group stands there and start killing more people.. so we should appreciate Army.. the best example is .. afganistan you can see what happened when no army left there.. Think and then blame our armed forces.. because there are many terrorist groups in Nagaland..if we talk with one .. another stands and kills innocent people's.. that's why army has special power in this land to protect tribs..

[@प्रतापसिंहचौहान-य6ध]

बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद आपका काम सराहनीय है

[@Hingdahegui]

Please don't misinform and misinterpret 🙏🏽 You will be sued for that.

[@ekheniiekhe2626]

Collect all the facts and then you post anything. you are misleading the public.

[@myupsc7142]

Reality is quite different. No Army officers or Jawans want to get involve in this type of event with local tribe, they also have family at their home. Para Regiment is well trained and Elite forces of our Indian Army. A region which is under AFSPA & every citizen there knows it, then WHY Vehicle does not stop at Army check post??? raised a BIG Question. It may be a suspicious event that Army fired without warning!!! But it is not a hidden truth that particular area is having greater influence of Terrorists (yes, Deliberately mentioned it) which are being supported and well funded by China & Myanmar to disturb India's Sovereignty. 🇮🇳We are lucky that INDIAN ARMY is Securing our country's Border. 🇮🇳 Its really easy to comment while sitting inside BLANKET or besides a HEATER and commenting that ARMY OFFICERS and JAWAN must be punished, who are protecting us from these Terrorists organizations in this HARSH WINTERS. 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳Even if by mistake it all occured, our Army need our support and understanding.Ultimately they are doing it for us, INDIA🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@KewongkhumJangpuh]

This incident will never be forgotten

[@prashantsingh1280]

1.They didn't stop at 2 consecutive check post. 2. As one of them was carrying a hunting rifle soldier mistook them as insurgent 3. After incident soldiers didn't ran away they were carrying all the wounded to hospital.4. Attack by public with machetes and knife may have been pre planned 5. If anythings the major who is still hospitalised due to this should not be treated as some kind of criminals.6 despite informing local police they delayed their movement leading to further casualties.

[@Vigilante123]

Where is the source of your narrative

[@equinsuucha1110]

I heard that too. They even tried to revive the dead bodies but the mobs did not allow them to. That is why the army had to shoot to get valuable time to save those who already died.

[@prashantsingh1280]

@@equinsuucha1110 if they would have wanted they could have just vanished from the site without informing local police

[@prashantsingh1280]

@@equinsuucha1110 just a month back commanding officer of Assam Rifles was killed with his family . I found no one discussing terrorism. Its High time Naga should come forward and fight against these terrorist organisation who are even involved in drug trafficking

[@prashantsingh1280]

@@Vigilante123 just read any source without opinion just providing information about what happened

[@wangyohawang7438]

New subscriber keep it up brotha 👍👍