Robert, you are refreshingly right. As a retired priest, I can tell you that many bishops are manager, not Apostles. They avoid anything controversial and want to stay under the radar screen of Rome. Sound doctrine and morals are not of major importance to them. Many are poorly catechized themselves. Priests who have zeal fo souls and insist on the faith are cancelled and retired early. Priests who want power, without zeal for souls, who do what they are told, become bishops. It's like that in US, also.
@francikoen17 сағат бұрын
American Bishops were like that... decades before Francis.
@Leocomander16 сағат бұрын
@@francikoenThose Early 00’s St.JP2 appointments did us real dirty.
@briangalligan786016 сағат бұрын
Yes true they have stayed all quite through all the controversy in last number of years and a mother who’s son was jailed for not being woke had shone light on that with the leaders in Ireland
@danieldimond57349 сағат бұрын
@@Leocomander JPII wasn't a Saint.
@patricianolan46 сағат бұрын
This is a sad day.....but so good about so many of the Irish priests being formed by Bishop Rey and that legacy.....it's like the Church is destroying itself. We need to pray for the Church and the Holy Father. It struck me so greatly when you said he ( Bishop Rey) has such zeal for the Faith. What is to be done? Pray pray pray...
@day167819 сағат бұрын
Well said, brother! Many, many of our Shepherds today lack guts when it comes to standing up to the Truths of Christ.
@laurelannemchugh413916 сағат бұрын
You've hit the nail squarely on the head. St. Pius X and all holy popes of the past, pray for us! 🙏🙏🙏
@draguigirl838820 сағат бұрын
😮 Just hearing this from your video. I'm in the diocese of Mgr Rey and was confirmed by him two years ago. Exactly, he is a dynamic bishop who loves the Church and the Faith. Being a Trad Catholic it's unnerving to see a supporter of tradition treated this way. Praying for Mgr Rey and the apostolic tradition of the Church. 🙏🏻
@attract123422 сағат бұрын
Robert, Our lord had a vocation for you, He had given you the voice to speak the truth through this channel.
@M5guitar123 сағат бұрын
The Lavender clergy are promoted, while the faithful clergy are beaten down. Tell me, which of these will be shamed on Judgment Day?
@user-dl6jz4bh6h20 сағат бұрын
The pink mafia or the Daisy Chain
@cherylnahas-w2j21 сағат бұрын
Thank you, Robert, for your balanced review. I, an American, live in France in the Occitania region south of France not too far from Toulon-Frey home of mMsgr Rey's diocese.. My heart sunk when I heard the Vatican kicked Msgr Rey to the curb just as he did with our beloved Bishop Strickland from Tyler, Texas.. I agree with you that this gentle Bishop has had so much zeal in restoring priestly vocations in his diocese. That was a beacon of light for us in other vacuous regions in France starving for holy priests to keep our churches open. . In the Aveyron diocese here, we would have given anything to have had a kind, gentle Bishop who welcomed seminarians with open arms and stuck by them during their being put on hold for years like pawns by the Vatican. To the popesplainer commenter who gave PF the justification for this and what other harsh actions of punishing and humiliating other Bishops and clergy who are seeking to preach and teach the absolute moral truths to the laity that has been secularized by Rome and the Hierarchy, these, such as Bishop Strickland, Archbishop Vigano, Cardinal Burke, Cardinal Zen, Cardinal Sarah, Cardinal Mueller, to name a few, in my opinion, are courageous white martyrs who stand up for the one true and apostolic Church founded by Jesus Christ. I pray for these good men of God that are like St. John the Baptist who spoke up loudly in his defense of our Lord at the risk of losing his head. The Vatican has become a bullying pulpit with a malfeasance dictatorship spirit from the top down as they spew and gag us with their synodality false ape church teachings just as Archbishop Fulteen Sheen in his time so prophesied. PF's decisions under his own 'zero tolerance' mandate full of hypocrisy and for those who are defying his position is backfiring as these good prelates and clergy keep finding a greater and louder unified voice of Truth that resonates more and more with us the faithful laity. " You will know them by their fruit." We are in an immense spiritual battle today for saving souls for Our Lord, prying them out of the wretched hands of the devil. Pray ernestly for your Priests, Bishops, and Cardinals that they may have the Holy Spirit infuse in them wisdom and the intestinal fortitude to defend our true Church at all costs. Amen.😮❤🎉😊
@cherylnahas-w2j21 сағат бұрын
And pray for this sovereign pontiff and his conversion to the Truth and God's Mercy as his time grows short as well. ❤
@karenc284419 сағат бұрын
@@cherylnahas-w2j amen and amen!!! You could not have worded that any better!
@DeliaGibbons21 сағат бұрын
Our Lady warned us in many different countries over many years. She also told us what we need to do
@paulfaigl832912 сағат бұрын
And in the focus were and are the formerly most Catholic countries: Ireland, Poland, also Spain and Portugal. Let's go Brandon 🤠
@waddadux23 сағат бұрын
You ask: Where are the young people? One answer is at the Latin Mass, although only in small numbers. At the Latin Mass that I attend, the median age of the congregation is under 30. The church is served by Oratorian Fathers, and they had an ordination last year and three novices. So that particular parish should be well supplied with priests for a good number of years.
@maxcox88828 сағат бұрын
I do not understand why some people prefer the Latin Mass. Why not have a Greek Mass? Original gospels were written in Greek, not Latin. Why not have an Aramaic Mass? Jesus spoke Aramaic, not Latin.
@jacques-laurentaerts17096 сағат бұрын
@@maxcox8882 Because it has been the public prayer of Western Chistendom almost since the begining. It suits Western Christianity, other rites exist for others and that's a good thing. It's not really about the language for the sake of language.
@Insightful_Inquiries15 сағат бұрын
*It was a Good Rant, God bless you* This is a tough spot for the Bishops & any of the Clergy to be in because on one hand they need to say something, but if they do, they will likely get the Strickling, or even the Vigano treatment. But if they don’t, they very well may be doing a great injustice to God, and to the flock they are charged with shepherding! The Sheep’s clothing is starting to fall off the wolves 🐺. Pray for the Church God bless ☦️
@RedRose-il8xjКүн бұрын
For me, the crisis in the priesthood, is a sign of the times we are living in, and I believe we are living the Book of Revelation now. I was saying to my pastor this morning, that when we pray for vocations to the priesthood, in the same breath, we should be praying for the protection of the pre-born. Priestly vocations have declined because they never saw life outside of their mother's wombs. Have many vocations, priests were aborted?
@RockerfellerRothchild177618 сағат бұрын
Lol cope harder! This nonsense been going since day 1 of the church. What you think Martin Luther was talking about!? Smh
@francikoen17 сағат бұрын
@RedRose-il8xj There are several other reasons for the priestly vocations crisis: (1) the clerical sex abuse scandal, and (2) the Novus Ordo Mass is not inspiring, and (3) the new Catholic theology incorrectly makes it appear that the Catholic Church and Sacraments not important. Catholics need to recognize there are other sins, besides abortion, and (4) lavender clergy are promoted, while holy priests are ignored or worse.
@tomhowe715416 сағат бұрын
In the name of the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Ghost. Amen!
@chilpericmerovee981923 сағат бұрын
Mgr Rey is remarkable; we wished we had a Mgr Rey in each French diocese.
@Leocomander16 сағат бұрын
Meanwhile bishop Mcelroy gets assigned to Washington DC as a 24/7 Trump critic. The message is clear bishops are being appointed not to lead the flock and inspire then to live Catholic lives of virtue they are instead appointed to further ideological and political goals. No wonder there are very few inspiring bishops and the ones that there are get Strickland.
@Mylifetime6321 сағат бұрын
This puts me in mind of the recent reading about the groom sending out the wedding invitations with his servants and they either didnt return or they were killed. So the groom invited anyone around to his wedding and it didnt end good for those who rejected the invitation. As my mother used to say..."All for thee oh Jesus".
@Insightful_Inquiries14 сағат бұрын
I didn’t know that about John Henry Weston… It feels like they hate us, amd it feels like the stuff coming out of Rome is adversarial , and antagonistic in nature. They are doing things you would expect of scheming villains. God bless
@adeodata636422 сағат бұрын
I have to agree with you, Robert, despite & to complete my comment on your last community post. The contrast, especially, between the forced resignation of Bishop Rey and the egregious appointment of the new Archbishop of Washington is so shocking, that you have to just throw up your hands in unbelief and supplication for God's mercy and Supreme help 😔🙏
@paulfaigl832912 сағат бұрын
And remember: not even a penny to crooked clergy including pope 😮😢😮
@thetruth-bf6je20 сағат бұрын
Church is been dismantled from the inside out.Can.t unsee when eyes are opened. Our lord will raise back up the church from a remnant.But he will not raise up the majority of top clergy.🙏
@francikoen17 сағат бұрын
The Church was dismantled by the Popes, Bishops and Priests!
@dawgski690Күн бұрын
You know enough. Actions speak louder than words.
@Nihilinstar23 сағат бұрын
And yet we have McElroy elevated. And other heretical bishops in Germany all being kept as bishops. Wow. Just wow.
@paultyrrell949722 сағат бұрын
Great choice for Washington
@tinabren18 сағат бұрын
No matter what do not get bitter and resentful. Forgive and pray that this storm where Jesus is sleeping will be eventually stopped with the Warning
@siobhanmcneenan325323 сағат бұрын
Fr Chad Ripperger, American Exorcist, says we get the priests we deserve
@Beautiful_Sacred_Land22 сағат бұрын
True. Yes I heard him say that in a video I was listening to. 'Find a good priest'. They need our prayers and if no one is praying for them, they are not getting the protection.. I think to be a priest is to be extremely brave, as Fr R would say, they all have a 🎯 on their back from the enemy. and we all do. I like when he has said/ reminds us we are the church militant (on earth)
@francikoen17 сағат бұрын
Fr. Chad Ripperger is blame-shifting, from the bad hierarchical "shepherds" to the followers, the laity. Ripperger is wrong. Followers are not to blame for what the leaders do. Ripperger is a boot-licking coward. The Catholic Church was dismantled, esp after V2, by Popes, Bishops and Priests.
@RayMack-xz7xg16 сағат бұрын
The good, holy priests are cancelled and the Church then gets a choice between the bad and the really bad.
@francikoen16 сағат бұрын
@@RayMack-xz7xg It is the hierarchy, not the laity, who cancel good priests and promote bad priests. Ripperger is wrong. He is blaming the sheep for bad shepherds. *When in fact, bad shepherds make for bad sheep.* Ripperger has it backward.
@CigarMode-4good11 сағат бұрын
@@siobhanmcneenan3253 we must pray for the priests we need or we will get the priests we deserve.
@Leocomander17 сағат бұрын
This is precisely the issue. Rome treating bishops like they are corporate middle management and at will employees that can just be canned for whatever reason and whose only job is to follow the will of the Pope unquestioningly.
@RayMack-xz7xg16 сағат бұрын
So much for the See being against "rigidity" and supporting synodality and "walking together."
@Leocomander16 сағат бұрын
@@RayMack-xz7xgSynodality works one way and that’s in favor of dissenters. Everyone else gets Stricklanded and many priests and bishops are now afraid to preach the faith in fear that they’ll be the next one in line to get canned due to *financial mismanagement* or for *rigidity*. Still we must keep our Faith Christ and persevere and endure affliction and have hope when all seems lost.
@marcokite59 минут бұрын
ANSWER to Robert's question, 'where's the zeal?' = the ORTHODOX CHURCH - great catechesis too!! ☦☦☦
@theburdenissweet586022 сағат бұрын
McElroy promoted. Rey fired. Got it.
@thecatholicman22 сағат бұрын
He is a worthy successor to Washington
@marcokite54 минут бұрын
@@thecatholicman - answer to your question, 'where's the zeal?' = in the ORTHODOX CHURCH - we have great catechesis too!! ☦☦☦
@marcokiteСағат бұрын
No! this is not 'bad judgement', they know EXACTLY what they're doing!
@seansheehy672521 сағат бұрын
Love for the Apostolic Tradition has been termed by the Pope as "backwardism."
@jackiefisher182023 сағат бұрын
God bless you ,Robert. Don't worry as you get older you'll find the pain will ease,quite a bit!My friend and I were challenging the church from the mid 1980's we were poo pooed ,harassed and I even win the title of "wicked woman"!I wear it with love and pride, I never allowed the priests and prelates to gaslighting me, well didn't I have both an Irish and English grandmother! Now I offer it up and pray for the souls in Purgatory! BUT I'll never pray for these wicked prelates! Look up the words of the song "The Vicar of Bray!" it's all there the love of mammon! Lots of love from Wolverhampton.
@user-rz7cm2we3x10 сағат бұрын
Well, we are to pray even for our enemies… You got too callous in your fighting😢
@unamartin370023 сағат бұрын
In order to chastise us God will send us bad pastors.
@marcokiteСағат бұрын
.......and Robert STILL comes out with the old cliche that 'the Orthodox have problems too'. The 'problems' of the (growing) Orthodox Church don't even show up on the radar compared to the utter chaos of the Roman Catholic Church. Time for Orthodoxy ☦☦☦☦☦☦☦
@J_JYRWA14 сағат бұрын
Extremely sad 😔
@CigarMode-4good10 сағат бұрын
Until nearly 16 mins in, thought the hoodie was a monastic habit. 😅 “where my kids go to school” gave me whiplash; looked closer. Oh, he’s not a religious brother.
@grahamcombs475222 сағат бұрын
If you think the situation is dark now, here's who's coming: Cardinal Robert W. McElroy ( who has been elevated to the highest profile See in the world: Washington D.C. McElroy is nothing less than the most radical cardinal in America and he is being advanced and put into rotation for the Chair of St. Peter by the most radical Holy Father in history. Watch a confrontation at a bishops' conference between McElroy and Archbishop Chaput and the former Bishop of Tyler, TX, Joseph Strickland. The subject was declaring abortion the preeminent concern of our time. McElroy aggressively insisted this is not the case. He questions the Church's teachings on euthanasia, sex, marriage, abortion etc. He is the Pope's man and Fr. Martin's comrade in arms. McElroy is 70 years old. If you believe our immortal souls have never been more at risk for eternal damnation, then putting the face of McElroy in parishes across the world is equivalent to replacing it with a portrait of the Evil One himself. I remained stunned that Catholics believe the current pope is a "one-off" who can be "prayed" from his current reckless and determined course from which he shows no signs of turning back.
@martinmartin13634 сағат бұрын
Kevin smiths film Dogma promoted buddy Jesus the pope must have loved this film as his synodal church replicates it In the film, Buddy is part of a campaign ("Catholicism Wow!") to renew the image of (and interest in) the Catholic Church. Viewing the crucifix image as "wholly depressing", the Church, led by Cardinal Glick (George Carlin), decides to retire it, and creates Buddy Christ as a more uplifting image of Jesus Christ.The icon consists of a statue of Jesus, smiling and winking while pointing at onlookers with one hand and giving the thumbs-up sign with the other hand. Buddy Christ was later produced as an action figure and a bobblehead.The image has since been turned into a popular internet meme
@jdlotus825318 сағат бұрын
I really don't understand the objection to the Latin Mass. I was really happy when Pope Benedict allowed it. I will only ever attend Latin Mass. Latin Mass meant you could travel the world and join in Mass everywhere you went.
@Arvidholders10 сағат бұрын
@@jdlotus8253 they hate it because it's the full truth
@seansheehy672521 сағат бұрын
He who seldom makes mistakes seldom makes little else.
@thecatholicman21 сағат бұрын
Indeed.
@gerreappleton9585Күн бұрын
As I have said: there is Jesus’ church and there is Bergoglio’ church! I choose Jesus!
@jackiefisher182023 сағат бұрын
Very succinct!
@marcokiteСағат бұрын
.....and therefore you should choose Orthodoxy ☦☦☦
@MrTzarBomb17 сағат бұрын
The “Catholic Esquire” channel is starting a new series on the fruits and failures of Vatican 2. Would you consider following it and contributing your thoughts?
@GaelicGal22 сағат бұрын
Ty Robert
@jeannechristopher593223 сағат бұрын
Where are the young parents to step forward and demand Faith Formation for their children? I pray that at some point the Catholics in Ireland get to the point where they say enough is enough and stand together as the Body of Christ to right the sinking ship! Wish I lived in Ireland to join in and save the Church! I will be praying daily for Ireland to wake up and stand up for our Faith!
@DeeStewart-oj2zj21 сағат бұрын
We are ignored by our priests and bishops!
@eft9453018 сағат бұрын
Parents are the primary teachers of their children Unplug television Learn your faith Adults can form book clubs to read together and discuss solid resources Teach the children
@jeannechristopher593213 сағат бұрын
@@DeeStewart-oj2zj I am very sorry to hear that. I will pray that the situation turns around soon. God Bless🙏🏼♥️
@Utterandcompletenonsense20 сағат бұрын
This will all backfire on them. They tried to destroy Truth once before and He rose from the dead. So it will be again.
@pama.641023 сағат бұрын
Innovation? Isn't that what got us in this mess to begin with? I will take fidelity over innovation any day. Interesting that we see the Pope willing to remove people, but not the people we expect. Definitely a time to stay close to the Lord and the True Faith.
@johnstag139110 сағат бұрын
❤
@GeoTime40213 сағат бұрын
Francis with those in current leadership have designated a focus for the present and future church. Attempting to return to the past can only lead to disruption. I’m open to a future, so I review all comments and be faithful.
@JimmyMclaughlin-n6o21 сағат бұрын
Could not agree more more how these bishops can sleep at night 😊
@sheiladumigan45122 сағат бұрын
🙏🙏🙏
@DonalLeader2 сағат бұрын
All we can do is pray the Rosary. Mary Mother of the Church pray for us.
@marcokiteСағат бұрын
no! that is not 'all' - we can embrace the Holy Orthodox Church ☦☦☦
@matthewkostovny47016 сағат бұрын
In respect, I tip my hat to you for your charity to say this move shows “bad judgment”, for I’d argue that this bespeaks of what the reformers-and that’s being charitable-desired and are desiring within our Holy Mother, the Church. This is a visible sign of the rot that is the revolution that the windows were open to fan the smoke that Paul VI called “the smoke of Satan.” Yet, God is still with His Church but we are being chastised through moves like this by these revolutionaries to awaken sleepy faithful to see what is afoot and seek sure foundations that God has blessed us to shelter the remnant of the Faithful from the wolves in clerical clothing: traditionally minded councilars or Traditional orders holding fast to the revolutionaries wanted to see burned up in that smoke. Another visible sign of God’s love off and for His faithful children.
@pmreynolds454721 сағат бұрын
They send missionaries to countries where faith is growing but leave home dioceses starving for priest. Parishes close consolidate and close it will be a dessert of faith I would love to have a traditional mass in my parish we have asked we’ve asked to have the tabernacle move back to where it rightfully belongs. We are trying but they have taken our youth to a sister parish for ccd so there are no families with children at mass it’s so sad
@luizfilipecouto10303 сағат бұрын
Can you make a video on your view of the Neocathecumenal Way?
@hannahgale857121 сағат бұрын
Sing hymns, form Rosary groups, The laity will save the church.
@johnnybgood583619 сағат бұрын
The High Priests are again driven by fear and pride it seems...
@katiebarron623922 сағат бұрын
Can he just say “no”!?
@gerreappleton9585Күн бұрын
Choose Jesus’ church , or Bergoglio’s church. I choose Jesus!
@justoneman13184 сағат бұрын
Tale of two Churches: The Traditional Catholic Church and the jewish/protestant catholic church.
@gerrymccarthy956822 сағат бұрын
The salvation of souls and the conversion of ALL humanity to the One Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church, SHOULD consume them, and that only. Otherwise, they should resign.
@martinmartin13634 сағат бұрын
The Catholic Church is a corporation a business like Disney and Netflix and they like the Catholic Church promotes the new Catholic Church the synodal church
@simonwesteng361023 сағат бұрын
`yes-men` who make no mistakes are surely those who have no mind for "listening"! This bishop had just 3 years left, yet the pope just cannot wait because he doesnt like "listeners". After all, he's in a hurry to get the job done. Yes, to be "Stricklanded" is an apt condition.
@gerardosullivan164220 сағат бұрын
The seat of the church will move to Thurles. The senior shepherd is leading the flock astray.
@angelikamaris872820 сағат бұрын
Robert, are you used to receive applause after you have spoken? I never. I like it that way!!!
@mishasumi682721 сағат бұрын
When will we speak the truth about Francis?
@josephwagner322421 сағат бұрын
Thought we were all synodaling together, no?
@marcokite52 минут бұрын
I hope your comment wasn't a sin against Synodality!! 😆😅😂😂😅😆
@philipconnolly136217 сағат бұрын
sorry to say this but you actually seem surprised that he would do this
@vonhalberstadt359019 сағат бұрын
Some bishops need to refuse to leave their posts. That would shake things up. Orémus Y'all.
@thecatholicman19 сағат бұрын
That does not work in the Roman Catholic Church, God will show his power in the obedience of those persecuted Bishops
@marcokite49 минут бұрын
The problem with the Roman Catholic Church is the heresy of papal 'supremacy', a heresy with origins in the 11th century. It's time for Holy Orthodoxy ☦☦☦
@jonathanstensberg17 сағат бұрын
Strickland went over the sede cliff before he was removed. Don’t compare Rey to Strickland.
@stevecalovich368215 сағат бұрын
Another Mason plays his part in the biggest Dinner Theater / Costume Party ever!
@KellyS_7723 сағат бұрын
You're not the only one that sees it. There are people on one side that are willingly blind (or blinded by their own motives), and people on the other side that are blinded with contempt for the current Pope and all his compatriots. Neither side seems to be concerned with what is best for the actual Church and the laity. It does seem like the Church is going through some sort of trial at the moment, will She make it through the trial intact? Will there be any Priests, Bishops, etc left that are true to the Church and to Jesus? Only time will tell.
@robertryan254220 сағат бұрын
We must pray Almighty God calls Francis to his reward soon.
@magdalenep849722 сағат бұрын
The persecution from the false church against faithful clergy is a travesty. I will never be a part of some 'sin-nodal' protestant religion.
@dawgski690Күн бұрын
Sedevacantism makes sense… the novus ordo is not Catholic
@karlheven832823 сағат бұрын
It does not make sense. It is not catholicism to go against the visible church and create an imaginary one. There have been crises before also liturgical.
@dawgski69023 сағат бұрын
@ that is exactly what the Vatican II novus ordo is doing
@theburdenissweet586022 сағат бұрын
@@karlheven8328Isn't Pope Francis going against the visible church? How many the ways? When will enough be enough?
@declancooney102922 сағат бұрын
so what are you doing listening and writing comments on this "not Catholic" YT channel???? better watch lifesitenews or pope marshall......
@timfronimos45920 сағат бұрын
The average American bishop is a poser with a crosier. Certainly prayed for the good bishops.But even more pray for those who seem to have lost their faith.That god sends them the grace to be zealous faithful shepherds