Bitcoin Q&A: SegWit and Transaction Malleability

[@KaptainLuis]

❤❤❤❤

[@inocencia-q6j]

Thanks for the breakdown! Could you help me with something unrelated: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (air carpet target dish off jeans toilet sweet piano spoil fruit essay). How can I transfer them to Binance?

[@nion456789]

Smashed the like

[@ZacheryGlass]

Would you like to see Bitcoin adopt Confidential Transactions?

[@syrop26]

I don't think bitcoin will ossify too much. Look at Android: it's way more complicated than bitcoin (its implementation weighs 1+ GB, while Bitcoin Core only weighs 70 MB), it is bound to hardware, and still people manage to upgrade Android every year. Currently the most popular Android is Marshmallow, which was released in 2015, so there is a few years worth of delay, yet people do upgrade eventually. Ubuntu is still more complicated than Android (the distribution weights 4+ GB), yet people somehow manage to upgrade every two years. Even dollar hasn't ossified yet, as there are still new kinds of financial instruments denominated in dollar being introduced. Still, bitcoin may run over the old implementation of TCP/IP, but it doesn't have to be some old implementation of bitcoin.

[@SerPapus]

syrop26 doesn’t work like that dummy

[@tio.semilla]

just one sound board. or one mixer. descent mic. world of difference.

[@jumo311]

great video, terrible sound

[@spotshortmanipulators4721]

Hi Andreas Love your Explanations but the Sound is So Horrible what a Pity !! As we Say Shoemakers are Always the Least Well Shod

[@usmansheikh7717]

Get a google bass booster for chrome. This will tremendously upgrade the sound.

[@spotshortmanipulators4721]

@Liteoshi I Hope less !

[@steph1804]

Smashed de like

[@FirstLast-sr5ht]

That explanation of why signatures were removed from transaction ids doesnt make sense to me. Why couldnt limits be put on the signature so that it could be included in the transaction. Like if it is 5 then you have to write it 05. Always 2 digits. Idk that smells fishy. Is that the reason why bch broke off

[@Alex-nn6xb]

Why does it smell fishy? It doesn't sound like you have any technical foundation here to make that statement. And obviously BCH hardforked because they (the greedy miners) were in favor of a block size increase so they can have more power/control over the network.

[@Patatmetmayo]

BCH forked off because some users and miners (mainly Bitmain) weren't satisfied with the current blocksize limit and they didn't get consensus to change it on Bitcoin itself. They used the timing of the segwit soft fork and created some bullshit controversy around it in order to attract more people when their fork went live. Lots of other fishy stuff going on around the BCH fork like Bitmain's asicboost, but let's leave that aside for now. By the way signatures are still part of the transaction itself, just not part of the transaction id when it is being calculated. It's not possible to do it the way you are suggesting, but you need a better technical understanding of how it works to understand why. Saying it smells fishy without any technical expertise of how these things work is baseless criticism. If you don't understand something it's generally better to withhold judgment.

[@FirstLast-sr5ht]

Things i see as not-making-sense/fishy are kept suspended in my mind until I get more information to the point of overwhelming evidence of their truth. Keeping the fishy ideas suspended allows me to more easily search for patterns between them if they exist. My post reveals this. If you wish to explain further why the signatures cannot be constrained to be put in the blockid, that would be great. I understand programming. I havent got much extra information yet that i havent known.. well other than this post has seemed to stir some people

[@Patatmetmayo]

​@@FirstLast-sr5ht Then why don't you dig through the source code yourself to find the answer? Segwit was een elegant way to solve transaction malleability without doing a hard fork, and also allowed larger blocksizes which is a side benefit. If you want to think this is fishy be my guest, I'm not going to stand in the way of your paranoid suspicions. Have a nice day.

[@sandile84]

You are woke, everyone else just swallows information without critical thinking.

[@rabiealkamouchi1490]

Bitcoin cash