BLACKPINK Rosé vs TWICE Nayeon Vocal Battle (Low and Mid-Belting Range)

[@twaeyeon68]

We can see nayeon dominates low register but for mix they both great. Nayeon sound fuller than rose on Bb4 but rose can support up to B4

[@twaeyeon68]

Btw you couldve just put nayeon ooh ahh for her B4 even tho its shallow but its supported

[@liftedb9591]

Rosé support above Bb4 is extremely shallow and occasional

[@twaeyeon68]

@@liftedb9591 sometimes she relaxes tho more than supporting it but its consistent enough to be A4/Bb4

[@Red-dm7qn]

Kinda sad, Nayeon has great potential. She regressed lately, she barely supports notes.

[@soujoudlouhichi9695]

@@Tyyry.tut678 rosé

[@victorsants23]

nayeon and rosé 🥰🥰🥰 i love that two girls great singers and beautiful voices

[@andinho2204]

Nayeon is stronger all the way throught

[@rosevocals806]

Rosé is obviously better in Middle and Upper Register

[@andinho2204]

@@rosevocals806 Rose has better head voice, that's it

[@Twice4_ever]

@@rosevocals806 Nayeon is more consistent on Bb4

[@vivi1601]

@@rosevocals806 no, none of them support head voice, but Nayeon connected head voice up to B5, Rosé only A5, and yes Nayeon is better in all aspects

[@mimi_imfat]

@@rosevocals806 rose isn’t obviously better in the middle register lmao they’re pretty much about the same level. Rose’s better in head voice, nayeon has a better low register and agility so overall nayeon is better.

[@laniakeaselena.7718]

for upper register I think nayeon is better than rose,Nayeon relaxed still Eb5 in head voice,she even supported D5(head voice)(shallow and inconsistent) at her best. and also nayeon has the moments of support B4s( averagely 5 or 6 times).and also nayeon has the C5(Db5) relaxed moments so overall : Nayron( high D+/C-) > Rose (mid D+).

[@rosevocals806]

Rosé relaxed still G5 in head voice.. and nayeon never supports head voice

[@laniakeaselena.7718]

@@rosevocals806 I think even her E5s are airy,strained Eb5s? How does she relaxed G5? even Yuju or Jihyo can't relaxed this range. Nayeon has some Eb5 relaxed while rose strain.Nayeon and Rose are similar vocalists but rose strain some notes while nayeon relaxed or supported shallow.Rose airy most of the times above D5,she doesn't even has connected head voice at F5s and G5s,Nayeon can relaxed Eb5s and can use connected head voice still Gb5.Some D5s (not sure/inconsistent and too shallow) and Db5(sure /shallow and inconsistent)are supported.and also rose can support(too shallow and inconsistent) Db5s and C5s in head voice.

[@miau5875]

nayeon is even close to D+/C-, not consistent on Bb4, and only once supported a B4, Rosé has more consistent headvoice support than Nayeon

[@laniakeaselena.7718]

@@miau5875 she has shown the better B4s since in Pop era, and she consistent in Bb4s,rose only more consistent than nayeon in C5 head voice but nayeon has more wilder relaxed range than rose.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

Jihyo head voice is able to stay relaxed up yo B5, Nayeon "barely" connects hers

[@KingOfGambits]

Lower Nayeon Mixed and Upper Rosie

[@karenmijares1478]

Roséeeee the best

[@reveblinkonceluv1813]

Rosé for sure❤️

[@kanzrifrosie]

Rosé A4 sound so Full and i love Nayeon G3 , Both indeed good vocalist

[@rosevocals806]

Yes! they are still old examples, both have greatly improved the quality of their support

[@blzrxl]

both queens ended jimin

[@Kyovocals_w]

???????????

[@spheksophobiaurinal]

they together can outsing the whole vocal line of bts

[@soujoudlouhichi9695]

@@spheksophobiaurinal Even momo is better than jimin

[@liftedb9591]

@@soujoudlouhichi9695 not really

[@soujoudlouhichi9695]

@@liftedb9591 lol it's a fact

[@parkjihyo7054]

Nayeon for sure.

[@marti.111]

No once

[@hesham-r9r]

Nayeon has improved from that era in hitting B4 and has become beautifully supported

[@klymxes]

I really like Rosé's voice vibrato, it's really catchy

[@Eva-fun-j7n]

Upper registers-falsettos-low register ==nayeon the best ofc

[@IshfaqueSadib]

Rośe vocal range is G5 without any falsetto or siren voice. (Proof) just dance a yg trainee ft.rosé.she can also sing as opera with b5 range

[@Forever_2424]

In my opinion Lower register : Nayeon >>> Rose ( consistent support up to G#3 sometimes G3 too ) Mix Register Nayeon > Rose ( oops ) ( I know rose can support upto Bb4 consistently but Nayeon too Nayeon best is till C5 and rose best is till B4 Nayeon has shown some proper moments of support in pop behind recording and she was hardly shallow she also supported some C5 while rose has the problem with tightness in her cords she can't connect her cords as Nayeon does ) Upper register Rose>>>> Nayeon ( although they both use connected head voice which means they both are underdeveloped but i am going with rose cause she can connect her hesd voice till G5 sometimes till A5 at her best while Nayeon has only connected her head voice till Eb5 only ) So overall Nayeon >> Rose Don't hate me these is the truth and u have to except it thanks

[@rheynotryan]

i'm sorry but how is this accurate, rose has connected head voice up to G#5, not A5 and so does nayeon in queen of hearts

[@Forever_2424]

@@rheynotryan sorry i was not knowing that plzz forgive me

[@Forever_2424]

@@rheynotryan cause they both can't properly support there they can you connect that's why underdeveloped

[@munggo_lloyd]

@@rheynotryan Nayeon had a sustained G#5 to Bb5 head voice in QoH to be specific.

[@rheynotryan]

@@munggo_lloyd the G#5 was sustained, the Bb5 wasn't but yes the G#5 was sustained connected hv

[@amarjeetsingh-cq9ph]

Rose

[@lyricsarmyup2979]

Still people say Nayeon>Rose obv no!. Nayeon just better than Rose in Lowest register. Even she isn't maintains (consistent) her G3/G#3 are. Even her G4s are shallow in her middle register 🤦‍♀️. Nayeon doesn't have upper register and her head voice is inconsistent and not good. Rose Supported some Bb4/C5 even + C#5 in her upper register with inconsistently. But Nayeon? Nah. Pls accept it Rose>>>>Nayeon.

[@holyd5835]

in ranking nayeon D+ rose D/D+ Nayeon high weak average ~ low average rose mid weak - low weak average

[@husky7444]

Rosé d+ Nayeon high d+

[@rudra_tea]

Both are D+/^D+

[@Shaikhyahya1102]

Nayeon is Nasal and tensed she often sounds pressed or pushy above G#4. Rosé has more openess and cleanliness in her support. With good larynx position

[@Jihyooooi]

​@@Shaikhyahya1102Nayeon doesn't sound tense anymore 💀 please it's not 2017/16 anymore update

[@thatoneperson731]

@@Shaikhyahya1102nasality has nothing to do with vocal technique lmao, even ailee and wendy one of the best vocalists in kpop get nasally. it doesnt stop her from being a better vocalist than rosie

[@dlwlrmauaena2331]

Of course nayeon ❤

[@infj-mr7fe7hd3d]

I think that twice vocal line (jihyo jeongyeon and nayeon ) better than rosé

[@andinho2204]

Those G#3s by Rosé are strained

[@tenznor2758]

Lmao sure

[@andinho2204]

@@tenznor2758 Glad you know

[@jjngemoh7274]

They sounded really strained to me

[@Shaikhyahya1102]

How?? They are engaged with depth sound and modal phonation The airflow is controled

[@DucNguyen-vi7if]

Rose is very best than Nayeon. I think Rose C and Nayeon C-

[@Jihyooooi]

Neither rosé nor Nayeon are C or C- yet, both are D+ but I think Nayeon is getting closer to being C-! I think it's rosé too.

[@thatoneperson731]

both wrong, nayeon D+^ rosie D/D+

[@vespa_Kpop]

Rosé no support b4 and Bb4 Nayeon support Bb4(b4)