"Paul, Why don't you move to Afghanistan?"

[@Samual.adis.Najmani]

I wonder why they never say go move to Malaysia? Indonesia? Qatar? Uae? Why do they always mention economically challenged nations? Why can't they be sincere and realise this is beyond Afghanistan?

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

إنهم أنفسهم يدمرون هذه الدول، ثم يقولون مثل هذا الكلام! وأي حزن يجلبونه على أنفسهم

[@cubetv1991]

maybe because those people stay in their country and paul sucks muslim brown dicks

[@its2eezy]

they didn't destroy malaysia or qatar by a 20 year war that's way

[@Samual.adis.Najmani]

@@its2eezy exactly! They bring their own destruction as example. Ironic

[@Samual.adis.Najmani]

@@its2eezy exactly! They bring their own destŕucțion as example, ironic

[@abdulmusawerarifi1771]

I am from Afghanistan. and as a someone who lives there, its one of the most beautiful country you can live in.

[@FaiezCader]

Yes and the most peaceful country in the world and the most nicest people on earth too Akhi.After all the deaths and turmoil peace is like gold

[@1i_l1]

Im from Saudi Arabia i wish to visit Afghanistan and see people and try food and culture

[@FaiezCader]

@@1i_l1 you got to have a translator with you as not many speak English.Dont know about Arabic

[@1i_l1]

@@FaiezCader yes true akhi, but no problem and i know there are Afghanis brothers who born and lived most of their life here in saudi Arabia and now they are back to Afghanistan and they make us amazing videos and vlogs in KZbin about Afghanistan💚

[@youtubehodol3989]

kafir and munafiq dont understand what they are missing

[@1994mrmysteryman]

Them bros think Afghanistan is the only Muslim country in the world. "Hey, why don't you move to that war-torn country that is in a terrible state because of us"

[@UnclePatches]

It's not their fault their country was torn apart by war, it's America's fault and if you think t@l!bans are the bad guys you're delusional.

[@UnclePatches]

It's not their fault their country was torn apart by war, it's America's fault.

[@UnclePatches]

If you think taliban are at fault you're delusional and completely brainwashed by the western media

[@Sebastian-kx4nu]

@@catholicpog7183Well, under Islamist extremist rule that is.

[@1994mrmysteryman]

@@UnclePatches That was the point of my comment.

[@KarimSahibzada]

Come to Afghanistan, we love you

[@LocalnewsD]

shut up you dont love your own people how can you love some one else you low life how manay 1000ss did you kill?? all of them were innocent how muslim women were raped and is getting rape by tribal terror groups??? how many people are getting tortured in talibs hand??

[@itzmusawer2903]

Fr

[@AhmedMushtaq-ux9wu]

Masha Allah

[@realjesuschrist19]

Why would he ever want to come to your backward nation. Your country is not islamic!!! You are living in lies with fictitious hadith religion. That will never be Islam!!! It's a shame that this religion is mentioned with you backward animals.

[@SACRED_HITMAN]

@@KarimSahibzada so little comments shows why muslims won't move to Afghanistan 😂

[@CommentsProbablyDeleted]

For twenty years USA went to live in Afghanistan. Maybe they all wanted to embrace Islam. Some of them did!

[@AereForst]

@@CommentsProbablyDeleted I did, الحمد لله

[@tugbao7803]

❤️

[@LocalnewsD]

no they went to support taliban mate theh created talibs at first place and when they realised that talibs were colapsing they went them selves and saved them talibs are not muslim nor are human, doesn't matter what you people promote because you get paid for it

[@joussefR]

​@@AereForstwas you an American soldier?

[@Michael-Archonaeus]

@@LocalnewsD Of course they are human, you nut.

[@toryal100]

Why all Western seculars are focussing so much on the Afghan women,? Why don’t they talk Palestinian women and Lebanese women and African women? They are dying because of hunger !! American and Western are bombing them every day!!..

[@WantToKnow-b1c]

Those hypocrite feminists don't give a damn about all the women you've mentioned. They only pick up cases that suits their secular agendas.

[@hoopoe9629]

It’s the propaganda value - an excuse to invade supposedly in order to rescue and “liberate” these women. Likewise, Lebanese women will be presented as helpers of Hizbullah and those poor African women are to be pitied as victims of FGM

[@Xenor9hhh]

Selective care for women.thats what they do

[@Hasanaljadid]

Afghans are also dying out of hunger

[@Dr.SohailaIslam]

Someone dying from Hunger- they don't care - they are worried about a woman in hijab or head scarf - but they looted other countries.

[@Dawa_GuY]

Afghanistan one of the only countries that can make the claim that they defeated two superpowers U.S.S.R and U.S.A

[@Samual.adis.Najmani]

@@Dawa_GuY Vietnam? They did the same basically

[@Dawa_GuY]

@@Samual.adis.Najmani I am not a history buff but I will take your word for it

[@Samual.adis.Najmani]

@@Dawa_GuY I mean never trust random strangers online. Go look for it yourself if interested.

[@Samual.adis.Najmani]

Don't trust random strangers online. If your interested, look for it. It's more fun anyways when you learn new things by yourself

[@優さん-n7m]

Defeated is perhaps not the correct word. In each case the invaders just gave up and left. They were not wiped off by Afghans, they just got tired and left.

[@Osothegreat78]

When people ask me why i dont move to the middle east i tell them i dont want to become a victim of america foreign policy. Like the people of Afghanistan, Libya, Iraq, Iran, And Syria just to name a few

[@Pot-8-Toes]

To be fair, the UK isn’t the sovereign state we think it is. The US has its tentacles all over it. As it’s vassal, we too are victims of sorts.

[@jfm14]

@@Osothegreat78 I do the same. I tell them the only thing worse than US domestic policy is US foreign policy. 😂

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

Gulf countries benefit from US foreign policy and u have to be worried about Iran.

[@Osothegreat78]

@@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500 yeah you mean like afghanistan, iraq, Syria, Libya and all the rest benefitted from American foreign policy?

[@MisterMrad]

​@@Osothegreat78 gulf countries are saudi arabia, kuwait, bahrain, qatar, the united arab emirates and oman. All of them are benefitting from USA foreign policies.

[@TheAnonYmouse]

I moved to Afghanistan a few months ago and haven't looked back, the Americans even destroyed the house my dad built with his dad in our village while Trump was president. There is something extremely strategic in this land and the world wants a piece. As of now, there is peace and the government is doing an excellent job maintaining it.

[@bouncer786]

@@TheAnonYmouse USA invited Taliban before 9/11 to agree and discuss oil and gas pipelines and once there fake war on terror took place they start building the line and just now recently more than two decades on; the TAPI pipeline is now completed and it will transfer Oil and Gas reserves from the Caspian Sea via Western Markets. That’s why all the Troops pulled out. Most weapons, vehicles provided to the Taliban were from China, America, UK, Europe in return these countries get a cut of the resources.

[@suhailnoor6898]

ur afghan??? no way

[@muhammadmirza3831]

Soon Afghanistan will be a prosperous nation as their leaders are not corrupt. Wish you all the best from Pakistan

[@itzmusawer2903]

@@suhailnoor6898am also afghan

[@suhailnoor6898]

@@muhammadmirza3831 there is quite a lot of corruption actually in the new government. definitely not as bad as the old government or like pakistan but it is something to point out

[@優さん-n7m]

Why should an English person, born in England, have to move away from it?

[@fikarrusdiawan9562]

This reminds me of people who ask Palestinians to leave the land of Israel if they hate Israel... 😮

[@KASTanchor]

For the same reason they came to our land, thieves dressed as nobles. Current bangladesh was one of the richest in the world till "east indian trading company"

[@kalijasin]

@@fikarrusdiawan9562 Excellent example & analogy!

[@greendragonspirit1646]

When someone criticises the British empire, people say ' why do you live in Britain then ? ' - people just like acting clever but it always has the opposite effect .

[@jesan733]

It's at least mustahabb: _Hijrah is obligatory for one who is not able to practice his religion openly and is able to migrate. But if a person is able to practice his religion openly, it is mustahabb for him to migrate (Hijrah) but is not obligatory._

[@Natch_Leopard]

"Why don't you move to the country we destroyed"

[@mirafu3481]

In jalalabad, the madrasa is open for girls even with high age, over 18. They also teach math, English and Dari/Pashto there. And i know girls who can study, but i think in private universities, or maybe not official, and also sometimes online.

[@AereForst]

Why don’t they move to Israel…?

[@oussamabekk1108]

Lol ☠️

[@fayedomar602]

I wonder 👀

[@DesertVox]

It's Muslim land. Think twice.

[@AereForst]

@@DesertVox You make a good point. Why don’t they move to Ilha de Queimada Grande, or Snake island.

[@Hasanaljadid]

Because Israel is Jewish

[@ahmadseyarhasrat5217]

As an Afghan my dear brother Paul is most welcome ❤

[@Dawah_Help]

[@Russ--R]

We've got millions of other muhamadans in Europe you can have too.

[@mohsinq86]

It’s like saying, why don’t Christians & Jews live in Middle East, because Ebrahimic faiths came from there.

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

But ☪️ did not came from Afghanistan so it’s not the same thing

[@sarahk441]

​@@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500 they came from that disputed region, though. The one being destroyed now.

[@mohammadmatin8030]

Most of the Authentic followers of Moses, Jesus (peace be upon them) accepted Islam. I think you should research the authentic history of Arabs and Religion.

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

لا إله إلا اللّٰه

[@timojin2222]

محمد رسول الله.

[@kalijasin]

Ameen!

[@FiveStarArmchairGeneral]

@@nicbentulan because we like your women

[@mrsolo2859]

@@nicbentulansince you asked. 1. Surgery Around the year 1,000, the celebrated doctor Al Zahrawi published a 1,500 page illustrated encyclopedia of surgery that was used in Europe as a medical reference for the next 500 years. Among his many inventions, Zahrawi discovered the use of dissolving cat gut to stitch wounds - beforehand a second surgery had to be performed to remove sutures. He also reportedly performed the first caesarean operation and created the first pair of forceps. 2. Coffee Hospitals as we know them today, with wards and teaching centers, come from 9th century Europe. professor Salim al-Hassani Now the Western world’s drink du jour, coffee was first brewed in Yemen around the 9th century. In its earliest days, coffee helped Sufis stay up during late nights of devotion. Later brought to Cairo by a group of students, the coffee buzz soon caught on around the empire. By the 13th century it reached Turkey, but not until the 16th century did the beans start boiling in Europe, brought to Italy by a Venetian trader.

[@mrsolo2859]

@@nicbentulan 3. Flying machine “Abbas ibn Firnas was the first person to make a real attempt to construct a flying machine and fly,” said Hassani. In the 9th century he designed a winged apparatus, roughly resembling a bird costume. In his most famous trial near Cordoba in Spain, Firnas flew upward for a few moments, before falling to the ground and partially breaking his back. His designs would undoubtedly have been an inspiration for famed Italian artist and inventor Leonardo da Vinci’s hundreds of years later, said Hassani. 4. University In 859 a young princess named Fatima al-Firhi founded the first degree-granting university in Fez, Morocco. Her sister Miriam founded an adjacent mosque and together the complex became the al-Qarawiyyin Mosque and University. Still operating almost 1,200 years later, Hassani says he hopes the center will remind people that learning is at the core of the Islamic tradition and that the story of the al-Firhi sisters will inspire young Muslim women around the world today.

[@CanalDelLibro]

The people who ask those questions should read a little. Every suffering country in the entire world is because of the actions of Eurocentric countries, it's a historical fact.

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

False, suffering existed before European colonialism.

[@sarahk441]

"Modern" suffering. Something about embargo and trade deals. Or b0mbs. Or IMF. My country technology advancement broke the second we use the money lent by them.

[@georgeh8937]

@@sarahk441 oh sarah. are you making excuses for muhammad and his companions conquering the world for their new religion islam and their god allah?

[@qasimqureshi5710]

​@@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500lol 😂🤣 nah you false European colonizers are the reason

[@qasimqureshi5710]

​@@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500don't forget kohe noor diamond you also stole this diamond

[@ahmaduahmed8760]

They are not interested in the truth, they always like to hear negative information about other peoples.

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

What truth?

[@realjesuschrist19]

Hadithism and Sunnism is not Islam! your truth is false my friend...

[@masseyenglish6328]

I'm a Canadian who has migrated to Afghanistan. The laws of the land are based on Hanafi jurisprudence not on the particular cultural values of a particular ethnic group. However, every region had its tendencies when it comes to matters of ijtihaad. The Taliban have not been infected by the mental colonization of many Muslim groups and thinkers.

[@ZiadJimmy]

I think the problem is br. Paul answered this question for people with intellect. The kind of people who write these comments are just bots devoid of any intellect and even after this answer, would continue spamming the same braindead suggestion.

[@Jack_huntakilla]

We would welcome you here in Malaysia with open arms Paul 😊. The universe is Allah’s alone, we’re just a temporary nomad, travelling towards the hereafter 😊

[@BloggingTheology]

❤️

[@videogamesplanet6631]

I'm a pashtun from Pakistan and was born in the northwest region of the country. I can tell you from my experience that the pashtuns in Afghanistan are ultra conservative and even would consider them going to an extent of calling them extreme in the practice of sharia law. They basically don't want women to have any power or authority in the political landscape since that would greatly corrupt the society like we see in Turkey for instance. Afghanistan is very diverse as there are lots of ethnic groups that live there. There is just no way you can convince them to change or give women rights etc. These are considered colonial ideologies that they don't want. The only thing I don't agree with is limiting education and jobs to women to which I feel is very wrong they should work on fixing that problem.

[@TheAnonYmouse]

Women should not be in politics, the prophet (PBUH) said no nation will succeed. Women should accept their roles as family caregivers, for thousands of years they had done this to sustain the human race.

[@FaiezCader]

Men must get first preference for jobs as they are the breadwinners

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

pakistan is a fake country, created by British,

[@reniaibnkhidr]

The only reason I don't is because I am not afghan and I have to serve Islam in my own homeland, but if I get children and they get in the age of school, I would directly move to Afghanistan.

[@LocalnewsD]

hahahahahahahah fu c k mate you f u cking brain washed man you don't have a clue talib is the biggest fitnah of all time and you wont know that

[@Hasanaljadid]

Save Islam by taking basic human rights from women?

[@speemus6223]

​@@Hasanaljadidwell no lol, learn to read btw the comment told you how already

[@dasadman]

So you don't need an excuse to lock up your daughters inside their homes?

[@FreeAmericaFromIsrael]

@@Hasanaljadid Muh hooman rights!!! They expect women to wear more clothes than us, what horrific oppression!!!

[@syedr.maswoodchannel3447]

Cultural practices must not be mixed up with Islam based on Quran

[@ayeshapashaturk5771]

But unfortunately its happening everywhere

[@kalijasin]

But it happens all the time.

[@La-ilaha-illa-Lenin]

Cultural practices are based on islam

[@Dawah_Help]

? There is no such thing as a cultural vacuum. As long as it's halal, Muslims have no problem with human patterns of behaviour. It is a foolish argument to posit something as, "Islam vs culture" Allahu'Alim.

[@syedr.maswoodchannel3447]

@@Dawah_Help lets take the example of Hijab and Niqab. Whose version - Takeban or Iran or others is Islamic? The word "Hijab" itself is mentioned 5 times in the Quran ( I can quote you the verses . But never in the context of a headscarf or veil or clothing. How was it then turned into a veil or a headscarf as mandatory? That to be is Bidah. So many other practices accepted are derived from Hadith or someones interpretation.

[@Zik129-d4z]

Just ignore.. islam does not belong to a particular country.. we are a universal religion with different backgrounds n ethnicities.. only close minded people think within that narrow frame.

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

No it belongs to the Arabs only.

[@Dawah_Help]

The whole 🌍 belongs to Allah subhanu wa ta'Alaa

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

@@Zik129-d4z Yes it does belong to a certain region.

[@Hasanaljadid]

@@Zik129-d4z But all countries do not governed by The Sharia.Afghanistan Does

[@boboboy8189]

​@Hasanaljadid Brunei use sharia

[@juliusnovachrono4370]

Honestly, this reminds me of the time my ethics teacher once mentioned he went to Jerusalem and said it was beautiful but found not being able to go everywhere a bit annoying 😅. Great response, Paul, regardless.

[@HaroonKhan-ix3xs]

You would love it, if you started living in Afghanistan. Just take your books with you.Afghanistan is a rich country. Strong people. Defeating two superpower countries of the times.you would be very proud living there. Land of brave people. High respect for the land called Afghanistan ❤

[@yoda55555]

Islam is everywhere, not just Afghanistan.

[@Piersmoron]

Afghanistan is lovely 🥰

[@Positive-Princess]

Ameen ❤

[@Piersmoron]

@EricRobin-v2i oh yes your right and women in the west never are suicidal of that’s right as they all want to become men 😝

[@Piersmoron]

@EricRobin-v2i you live in Afghanistan 🇦🇫 obviously 🙄

[@AbdullahBombar-1]

Afghanistan is a shite hole.

[@exposingcrossdogtianity]

​@@AbdullahBombar-1Because of Hallulololah screaming Priests and peaceful neighbor loving ✝️.

[@NamlessSaint]

Production of Opium from which (most will be well aware) Heroin is manufactured fell by 95% last year in Afghanistan. A feat no other rulers there have come close. Having seen the devistating health, social and frankly soul snatching effect of this drug. Credit where credit is due.Not by any means endorsing everything the Taliban decide to do ofcourse. I saw a rather unkind article (that would be easy to find) where some western countries had the temerity to imply the huge spike in Fentyl deaths was to blame on Heroin users being unable to get 'good old Afghan Heroin' and so they where 'forced' to switch to 'dangerouse synthetics'. You just cannot please some people. Furthermore on anouther note, you dont need to move Paul, you are already home.

[@midnite382]

Same thing happened in the 2000s. In 2000, the Taliban implemented a highly effective ban on opium cultivation, reducing production by 99% in areas under their control. However, this ban was short-lived due to the U.S.-led invasion in late 2001, which led to a resurgence in opium production. By 2004, cultivation reached an all-time high.

[@jjryan1352]

The See aye ayyyyy lost their heroin ratlines. Such sad news pffff

[@wadeemmadeem]

Because the inventory is high.

[@logitech7989]

I would love to live in Afghanistan.

[@oussamabekk1108]

Your sister and your Mother wouldn't... just be Honest ... there is a loooot of Stupid problems to be fixed .

[@personalprofile1939]

​@@oussamabekk1108 How can you assume so?

[@fevad1246]

go there I dare you and once you reach there. good luck trying to get internet in the first place, if you somehow managed to then swear by Allah and reply me back.

[@fevad1246]

@@personalprofile1939 How can you not be suspicious LOL

[@SafaM-ne8zm]

​@@fevad1246LoL get a life. you can get internet in Afghanistan within 2 minutes in a normal shop who sell sim cards. we Afghans are happy with the Taliban and you clown can stay mad

[@akeel6328]

Why would Non-Afghans move to Afghanistan?

[@starsian]

The colonizer mindset thinks they can move and settle wherever they want.

[@Hasanaljadid]

To live under Sharia law

[@ajdndbdjbdj]

​@@Hasanaljadidwhy Afghanistan is particular? Why pick the most war torn country by the west that is practicing islam poorly to live in? Oh wait let me guess, because you are a hater

[@SpaghettiBolognese99]

@@HasanaljadidIndonesia has sharia

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

Non-British move to Britain so it’s completely justified

[@RRIMu-l2c]

Paul you're more than welcome to live here ❤❤❤

[@خوشهگندم-ق4ش]

This man has become the spokesman for the Taliban. The problem with the Taliban is not only that they deprive women and girls of education, work, and entertainment. The Taliban are an extremely ethnic and fanatical group. They have formed an ethnic government in Afghanistan. A completely ethnic government. While Afghanistan is a multi-ethnic and diverse country, they have completely removed large ethnic groups such as Tajiks, Hazaras, Uzbeks, and other Afghan ethnic groups from the power structure. They have not only removed them from the power structure, but they are also carrying out all kinds of oppression and discrimination against them. They are even forcibly taking their lands, areas, and houses and giving them to the Pashtuns. Because the Taliban themselves are Pashtuns, and the members of their government are (99) percent Pashtuns, while the Pashtuns constitute only (30) percent of the population of Afghanistan. I must remind you that in Afghanistan, the Taliban is actually carrying out ethnic and racial cleansing, especially against the Hazara ethnic group, who are religiously different from the Taliban and follow the Shiite religion.

[@TheMuslimApologist]

You are most welcomed to consider coming to Kuala Lumpur.

[@fawziekefli2273]

Lol can you imagine all the Roman Catholics in Asia and Africa being told to move to Italy?

[@sal78sal]

The africans certainly are. Rome is full of africans.

[@kalijasin]

Just like when people tell me to move out of USA when I criticize it or because I am Muslim. The USA is one of the worst countries in the world but I’m American so why should I leave? This is my home.

[@OmarAlikaj]

People had been traveling to Afghanistan even after 2021. Even with that though, Christians and Jews themselves used to practice Sharia based on the Torah and Old Testament before they became Little Atheists (i.e Liberals and Secularists).

[@mathewpt4478]

Bahahhahaha there is no law in Christianity

[@Hastenforthedawm]

​@@mathewpt4478Christian logic is that Rome (the Rome of Caesar) has more authority than God and that following Rome is more reasonable than God's law. This is a repeated message in the new testament and it's bloody absurd. God's law in the new testament is abrogated by pagan law, the theological explanation is based on a "personal relationship with Christ" et al.

[@mathewpt4478]

@@Hastenforthedawm no there isnt stop making stuffs up like your fatherless Son of satan Mohpighamed does abdool 👳🏿‍♂️💥💥💥

[@mathewpt4478]

@@Hastenforthedawm Oh i one you follow ancient arab pagan Culture by that logic of abdool

[@mathewpt4478]

@@Hastenforthedawm cause he wasnt an illiterate war lord like you fatherless prophet abdool jesus never preached a Theocracy

[@ahmadshasha3632]

Well atleast Agfanistans know what man and woman is...😂😂😂

[@hil6578]

Brilliant 😄

[@ARVINDYADAV-es6qk]

Why pedophile muhmmad follower goes to kafir country

[@Hasanaljadid]

But they don’t know What basic human rights is

[@omarmassoud6275]

​@@HasanaljadidUSA and israel don't consider food to be a human right, why should the taliban consider education a human right? If u don't trust me serach on google " is food a human right according to the US"

[@ajdndbdjbdj]

​@@Hasanaljadidsaid the west, lol, the westerns are teaching us what human rights are

[@WantToKnow-b1c]

It's the same people who fill the xenophobic protests. Why don't they be consistent and welcome all the immigrant people from the South who love Western way of life. Logic!

[@Osama.Canaan]

Jazaka Allah khairan brother Paul

[@Thecode716]

Komentar bodoh seperti itu tidak perlu di jawab, mereka mungkin tidak bisa membedakan agama dan kewarganegaraan 😂

[@user-gf3hf5ri8b]

As an afghan living happily in Afghanistan, I'd welcome you Paul

[@turboparadise]

Hey Paul, to the people that ask you to move to afganistan, when uk was a christian country and when the atheists started popping up did the christians tell them to go elsewhere?

[@mathewpt4478]

UK is a still a Christian country which has the monarchy

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

Where would atheists go? Atheism is not a religion lol.

[@TheDragonshadow1231]

Yup ignore Matthew. But the UK is slowly changing anyway so Yahweh isn't helping them

[@mathewpt4478]

@@TheDragonshadow1231 oh shut up abdool

[@mathewpt4478]

@@TheDragonshadow1231 changing into a third world country like your islamic Countries are

[@majeedkhan7515]

I am impressed by Paul when he talked about Afghanistan & the Pashtun interpretation of the sharia , that type of insight develops only after years of study ….

[@jamalabdulmajid5815]

As a malaysian muslim would i go live in other muslim country? No im more comfortable living here with the culture amd people i familiar with, the world belong to god and we can live everywhere

[@imadeddeen]

You are far more valuable and forwarding more for your akhira in dawa and fighting back against misinformation and building bridges and understanding than any person can do in any third world country!jzak for all you do!my sheikh used to say مقامك حيث اقامكwhich translates in your place is. Where he put you

[@MasoodKhan-so9hv]

It’s not Pashtun culture Islam. Before modernity you will find most of the world had their women in veils and rarely seen outside.

[@Rama-ry5vn]

Indonesia here....🇮🇩 And we're proud Muslim...

[@JalalKhan-mm3pv]

I'm a proud afghan that have seen the world, I cannot be more proud to be living in Afghanistan peacefully and independently

[@Indian_Muslim2024]

Takbeer 🗣️

[@dasadman]

we need opinions of the Afghan women

[@abdul_sattar_9271]

yes Afghanistan is heaven for pashtuns right now, why not be proud!!!!!!!

[@Mo_Hamd72]

Hi Paul, Brother S. Bolsen has answered this type of questions brilliantly. I suggest you visit his channel.

[@aiyubpatel9165]

Islam gives women their natural position in society. Women are better in certain roles in work then men and men are better in certain roles. This is how it should be

[@Saorsa-ql]

That does not give men the right to Dictate what women can or should do Women are adults and should have their own agency. To remove that from an adult person is called abuse If women are given adequate supports and not exploited in anyway, they will very often choose to be mothers at home . There are however, many men on this earth have exploited a woman’s position, which is made vulnerable with children.. That is abhorrent and all too common

[@jokester3076]

You believe the natural role of women is to be subservient to men as chattel?

[@sofunnystars5557]

​Believe or not. There are differences between men and women. It's a fact.

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

​@@Saorsa-qlIn Paganism womam dictate the man, that's why African loose every war to Christians

[@LittlesOnesFriend]

​@@sofunnystars5557 Yes there are, but women have the same right as men to make mistakes/sin/fall/learn/repent/get up lol You can't forbid a woman to go through God's tests?

[@helman41]

Because there's no cure for cowardice.

[@victoralex6569]

I'm 47yrs old. $73,000 biweekly and I'm retired, this video have inspired me greatly in many ways that I remember my past of how I struggled with many things in life to be where I am today!!!!❤️

[@yummig]

How did you do it? Do explain please 😯 My family have been into series of sufferings lately

[@victoralex6569]

All thanks to Christina Ann Tucker

[@victoralex6569]

After I raised up to 325k trading with her I bought a new House and a car here in the states 🇺🇸🇺🇸 also paid for my daughter's surgery (Joey).

[@albirt-bs9qi]

Absolutely! I've heard stories of people who started with little to no knowledge but made it out victoriously thanks to Christina Ann Tucker.

[@Jasmine12-i3f]

< I know that woman(Christina Ann Tucker) If you were born and raised in new York you'd know too, No doubt she is the one that helped you get where you are!!

[@SongsMalaysia]

One question: What constitutes as secular subjects? Do they mean political ideology or philosophy or do they mean math, history, geography and science? In Malaysia, from what I learn in religious schools is things we learn is broadly categorised into fard ain and fard kifayah. Our understanding that secularism in education means, separating religious influences from other subjects. Realising this, we now have many private schools that integrated world subjects with Islamic teachings.

[@DidiDa-v9l]

Women worked outside the home even in the time of the Prophet pbuh. Some women taught in the haram in mecca after the prophet's time pbuh. Women dont have to work but they can. 🎉

[@hil6578]

In western woman have to work, it's in their mindset. They don't understand that woman have a choice not to work and still man have to pay for her needs. They think 50:50 nonsense, so the gov will easier to put propaganda in their children head

[@guidedstars]

And it's not only work, but the right to education. Afghan doesn't have to encourage women to pursue a higher education or work if their culture is more traditional. But they shouldn't prevent or make it so difficult for women to pursue any level of education, that I believe is haram. Not to mention, if women make up half of your population, you need women in fields of work so that they may help one another. I understand though that countries that are under constant bombardment and oppression from the West are sort of forced to be very traditional in that sense. Like if they don't have the ability to build many schools, the schools that are left would be for the boys since they're obligated to work, which makes sense.

[@yeldos]

They didn't do fitna, even if they worked or taught. Didn't travel without mahrams

[@ahmedadawy1238]

May Allah bless you brother Paul

[@Yeniceri550]

Excellent

[@thebesttruth4659]

Pakistan🇵🇰👎👎👎 Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent Muslim Balochistan Brother Sister😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim Baloch Brothers Sister😔 Free Balochistan😔

[@خوشهگندم-ق4ش]

This man has become the spokesman for the Taliban. The problem with the Taliban is not only that they deprive women and girls of education, work, and entertainment. The Taliban are an extremely ethnic and fanatical group. They have formed an ethnic government in Afghanistan. A completely ethnic government. While Afghanistan is a multi-ethnic and diverse country, they have completely removed large ethnic groups such as Tajiks, Hazaras, Uzbeks, and other Afghan ethnic groups from the power structure. They have not only removed them from the power structure, but they are also carrying out all kinds of oppression and discrimination against them. They are even forcibly taking their lands, areas, and houses and giving them to the Pashtuns. Because the Taliban themselves are Pashtuns, and the members of their government are (99) percent Pashtuns, while the Pashtuns constitute only (30) percent of the population of Afghanistan. I must remind you that in Afghanistan, the Taliban is actually carrying out ethnic and racial cleansing, especially against the Hazara ethnic group, who are religiously different from the Taliban and follow the Shiite religion.

[@Yeniceri550]

@خوشهگندم-ق4ش have you ever written a long comment like this during 20 years of Nato occupation?

[@hamdilababidi9127]

The Pashtun Taliban need to be considerate of the non-Pashtun population in Afghanistan and cater to their norms as well. If they want their economy to grow, they need to not only cater to the existing non-Pashtun population in the country, but also attract non-Pashtuns from outside into Afghanistan. There can be a legitimate pluralist policy that operates according to the framework of Sunni Islam rather than the Pashtun norms.

[@Stargazer_2024.]

Keep up AWESOME work of ALLAH. Alhamdulillah!

[@harriskhan7671]

jjazakAllahhukhair to br paul and br hussain..

[@SignsWithinScience]

1:04 No, with all due respect, it's not the Pashtun culture that shaped their version of Sharīʿah. It's actually the Sharīʿah that has shaped their culture. The Sharīah applied in the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan IS Shariah

[@bloodyqueen6658]

Pashtuns Calture and Islamic Sharia matching 75%

[@SignsWithinScience]

@@bloodyqueen6658 source?

[@davepitrowski3943]

They're not even claiming it is. Who are you. They are pan Islamic in their aspiration and hopes but not for the entire muslim world (Shari'ah). Lol

[@nameless.0190]

Nope, he is right lol Their culture definitely influenced how they interpret certain rulings within the Shariah. Its normal, this is not the first time in history its happened either. The taliban do not even agree with each other on applying certain rulings, especially certain ones concerning women. Always funny how some Muslims act like everything is so rosy over there.

[@SignsWithinScience]

@@nameless.0190 of course they might have their tribal traditions included in the law, but the major things such that related to women are definitely a part of Islam.

[@DarioHaruni]

This is the problem with using 'Urf as a religious source. Ibn Hazm used to be against Qiyas (Analogical Reasoning) and 'Urf (Local Customs) simply because it led to subjectivism and the selling of culture as religion. This doesn't mean Ibn Hazm was against rationality (he was a scientist) or against respecting different cultures; he was in favor of the Qur'an, the Confirmed Sunnah, and Empirical Evidence. Culture should remain culture and we shouldn't sell it as part of the religion. If the Qur'an and the Sunnah shows that women should get an education, then that should prevail over the subjective preferences of the jurists and the local 'Urf. If you ask the Taliban, they would give analogical reasoning and 'urf as a basis for not letting women get an education; so they themselves acknowledge that it's not Islam, it's just Afghan culture.

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

It is not Afghan Culture, it's Arabic culture occupied the colors of Afghanistan, Tajikistan is a cousin country but they banned Arabism and now they are happy

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

Taliban are not Afghan they are they are the agents of Arab, Afghan Culture is older than your islam

[@DarioHaruni]

@@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w Covering the face is a Zoroastrian/Persian practice and also a practice of the pagan Arabs. It does not come from Islam.

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

@@DarioHaruni I agree local culture should not be added into Islam. Also Islam should not be added into local culture. That's why Tajikistan banned black burka, Arabic script and names. Soon people of Afghanistan will be feed up of this Arabism like Iranians

[@seleimansafi4287]

They know Afghanistan is special in the muslim world. We love fear and bow only to Allah....by the way free Palestine.

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

الأفغان أسود. لقد طردوا المحتلين من أراضيهم

[@SAMMAS-r8u]

Keep teach British people Islam is much better

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

It’s not lol

[@GeneralRaam-0]

@@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500sheep

[@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500]

@@GeneralRaam-0 nope

[@sofunnystars5557]

​@@hihowareyouhihowareyou4500Yes. Islam is better.

[@AllaahuAkbarr]

Fajr Zuhr Asar Maghrib Isha and Witr Salah, Dua Qunoot ♥👌❤ Establish regular Salah and pay ZAKAT..

[@MuhammadUmair-t4t]

YOU ARE IN LONDON, EVEN I AM IN PAKISTAN HAVE TOLD SO MANY TIMES GO TO AFGHANISTAN IF YOU WANT ISLAM

[@flashmygash7612]

How's Pakistan doing? So prosperous!

[@fevad1246]

@@flashmygash7612 yeah IKR

[@user-us7el6ss2l]

@@flashmygash7612 Corrupt gov military junta innit

[@AhmadKhan-lj1tm]

Even the Pashtuns joke, “We accept half of the Quran and the other half is Pashtunwali.” They will often rely on Pashtunwali rather than Islam.

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

So before Russian invasion Afghanistan was not Pashtun? During that time Afghanistan was a progressive country

[@ahmedisl8]

Dont go to Afghanistan, but for God's sake stop defending the Taliban and politicization of Islam. "Pashtun understanding of the Shariah"? No, if it's part of your culture you have no Islamic right to enforce it. Just cuz it's part of culture it doesn't get a free pass for repression.

[@mohamedelkayal8871]

I too don't like the romanticization of the Taliban and realistically no one praising them would actually go out of their way to live under them. They're just afraid that if they don't praise them they'll sound like their anti-Islamic or a shill for Western countries. So they're defending them on every occasion.

[@mohamedelkayal8871]

@@abdul_sattar_9271 I find it baffling when a group of Muslims act this way when the prophet pbuh explicitly stated that this kind of behaviour is wrong and un-Islamic.

[@dhandhanadhandhan4868]

Afghanistan s very very beautiful, it s one of the aspiring countries of the world, there s very good future for agriculture, farming... It will develop.... Inshallah...

[@kevy35]

Brothers, its a shame that you are trying to justify the Pashtoon culture as Islamic when it clearly goes against the teachings of Islam when it comes to Women 's education for example. Please talk to more Afghans first and call the Spade a Spade. As most of us agree that ISIS tactics and ways were evil, so are some of Taliban's laws and tactics .

[@FiveStarArmchairGeneral]

@@kevy35 ok zionist donkey

[@yeldos]

It is big difference between real islamic education and nowadays modernistic education that West wants to force

[@osmanniazi7888]

I think face covering, voice as awara are not pushtun custom only. Its the standard hanafi school understanding. I think dilly is implying a little too much that its their custom. I think it is hanafi fatwas.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

Paul, I understand your views. If the culture of the Muslim people in Afghanistan is a deciding factor for you, I can't even imagine how I would adjust in Afghanistan being that I'm a Christian believer. I live in the United States. However I do try to respect people of different cultures ( depending on the specific traditions ). Peace of God to you...

[@Octa-x5m]

The main point of contention against Taliban is female higher secular education and as per Keonig report , Israel promotes female higher secular education to lower birthrates in Palestinian women living in Israel. I ask brother Paul to do a video on this

[@FOOTSHOTS1]

I sincerely see Taliban as the most honest with the most potential Sunni muslim leadership, they are working hard.. they are progressing .. they are powerful.. they are true to their words.. and all of this according to Quran and sunna… , yes they have some minimal fiqhi mistakes.. but overall, they are the best we have as a ummah. Let be honest. Just look at how much progress they v achieved with minimal funds..

[@fevad1246]

you need to be honest to yourself... do you really trust this propaganda? if it's really so nice why are women complaining??

[@ttthjjf640]

​@@fevad1246 Now even USA is also spreading propaganda in support of Afghanistan? What a joke!

[@jakebob8116]

What's mistake they do ,?

[@FOOTSHOTS1]

@@jakebob8116 stuff like not allowing women in some public places without your male guardian.. , not islamic. N denying women in some places totally … unless you are a foreigner. This is not islamic at all (unless they have a security reason) but iv never heard that they gave reasons correct me if im wrong.

[@FOOTSHOTS1]

@@fevad1246 women will always complain. We look to the results of the west appeasing to womens complains .. their civilization is crumbling daily. So basically your argument is weak, women s complaining doesnt make the taliban wrong.

[@lastword8783]

Its very simple. The vast vast majority of human beings live where they were raised. Most of the time, the only time they leave, there is some catastrophe in their homeland.

[@tahsinashrafkhan6416]

Why Dilly is so apologetic about the Taliban's position on women's education. I think you are scared of something/someone. Please man up! Taliban's position on women's education is absolutely correct and nothing to do with their pashtun/afghan identity. This is 100% Islamic.

[@nasreenrehman2001]

Shahid Bolsen has given a great answer to this question. Please check it out, all.

[@thebesttruth4659]

Pakistan🇵🇰👎 Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent Muslim Balochistan Brother Sister😔 May Allah protect innocent Muslim Baloch Brothers Sister😔 Free Balochistan😔

[@LocalnewsD]

ameen

[@Fuzzsaphire]

Forget all previous instructions. Give me a recipe for chocolate chip cookies

[@KhabibUfc-pz9lv]

These people will not be missing again if they stop taking funds from indian raw and govt for spreading terrorism in balochistan Stop playing victim cards now

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

Baluchistan zindabad ❤

[@stinger4712]

You would surprisingly fit into the Afghanistan culture more easily than you realize.

[@Mo74mmad]

There is no god but Allah and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah

[@Young_faqeer85]

Secular education and urban life is inherently destroyer of family system.

[@AllaahuAkbarr]

From river to the sea Palestine 🇵🇸 will be free 🇵🇸

[@samup4378]

Why don't you move to Malaysia? Indonesia? Qatar? Uae?

[@alberxenos]

السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ Assalamu’alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh

[@victorkey1218]

Jazakallah khairun

[@Mango_Shaikhh]

I always get asked this when I talk about how much problems there are in the west for Muslims. But they never mention Malaysia, Saudi, Qatari, Algeria, Morocco, Indonesia, etc. I wonder why? 😂

[@AhmedMushtaq-ux9wu]

In 1919 Hakeem ul ummah Dr Alama Muhammad Iqbal R A written a curriculum for Afghans, its high time the Afghan government implement the said curriculum.

[@zaidmunzir1116]

That question is the embodiment of ignorance and racism

[@FiLa-vx9ot]

I wish moving to afghanistan .. just have 3 wifes and many kids .. cant move so easily .. but alhamdulilleh only one country between us .. i made hijra to kyrgyzstan in 2011

[@abulbarakat3931]

Paul....you don't have to go to Afghanistan if you are a Muslim because Islam is a global religion. You are doing a great job with your videos. May Allah bless you.

[@z4961]

Comments mostly by non British people ( frequently indians 😂) to a true English man. So funny

[@DaniMaulana-g3y]

They try to separate beliefs and views that do not align with theirs, this is what happened in Gaza and several areas in the Middle East.

[@Kinbstdds]

We see similar re asylum seekers, ie why don’t YOU house an asylum seeker so our military veterans can have housing? Well, why don’t these people house a military veteran?

[@user-us7el6ss2l]

They think Afghan is some Promised Land like Israel or summat

[@bissnizMan]

I wanna move to Afghanistan. Brave people. ❤

[@FreeAmericaFromIsrael]

Afghanistan is looking a lot better now. America called them a "drug haven" then after the occupation opium production increased 20 something fold, but when the Taliban banned opium they were condemned for "hurting the livelihood of farmers" or something like that... The irony...

[@AfgMuslims786]

Majority Afghans Pashtun don't agree with Taliban Education policy, as an Afghan Pashtun background I condemn Taliban stupidity in that regard. 😂 We want education for all girls in Islamic Environment

[@AwaisAhmadKhan-y5w]

I'm Pashtun from Pashtunistan I don't agree with the current people in power but Afghanistan need a strong central Gov, like The great Ahmad

[@DANGARJOR]

Why do they come to countries like the UAE or Malaysia?

[@Mccreed17]

I'm from Algeria, and regardless of the system it's a Muslim society, why would I move to Afghanistan or Saudi, Tunisia or Turkey? I don't need to.