The Maliki Madhab: An Introduction and Clarifying Misconceptions: With Dr. Shaykh Hassan Al-Kettani

Chapters:
- Background of Shaykh Hassan: 00:00-12:00
- Who was Imam Malik? 12:01-19:23
- Prominent Classical Maliki Scholars: 19:24-33:33
- The People’s Practice of Malikism Today: 33:34-41:44
- Major Maliki Scholars Today: 41:45-43:47
- Unique Characteristics of the Maliki Madhab: 43:48-48:20
- Modernists’ Misuse of the Maliki Madhab: 48:31-59:27
- Words of Advice: 59:28-end

[@NajashiProductions]

Bassam Zawadi has been such a great addition to this channel, I love the discussions he holds and the guests he brings!

[@BeefMeat45]

All the 4 madhab we respect. Hanbali, Shafi'i, Maliki, Hanafi. May Allah reward them with Jannatoulfirdouws inshaAllah, they have helped the ummah, so big, with their knowledge and work fiisebeelillah.

[@LearnTawhid]

True, but follow the madhab of Muhammad peace be upon him. The imams never told you to blind follow them. And they were not infallible may Allah raise them to the highest of jannah amiin.

[@asifrana232]

@@LearnTawhid What is the madhab of Muhammad (pbuh)? are you an ahlul hadith? there is no such thing. for 1200 years every sunni followed these 4 madhab. so all of them wrong?

[@asifrana232]

@@LearnTawhid ok. but the 4 Imams are also actually from the 3rd generation. but i understand your point. and btw, we do not really follow their direct fiqh in every case. their students actually corrected many things. and for around 1000 years their opinions and methodology is being revised over and over by thousand of scholars. so, we are not really blind following the Imam himself because a lot of things has been changed and added by our respected scholars who dedicated their whole lives in it. so we actually cannot attempt and succeed at getting this more right than the 4 schools of fiqh.

[@LearnTawhid]

@@asifrana232 akhi, we don't change or add in our religion. That is called bid'ah (innovation), and the prophet ﷺ said every innovation is error. By the way, come to salafiyyah the true Islam. Follow the salaf as-salih( the understanding of the Qur'an and sunnah from the sahaba and their students, the first 3 generations). inshaAllah Allah will guide you, continue to be sincere and listen to scholars of the Holy Mosques mecca and medina. 🕋

[@LearnTawhid]

@@asifrana232 prophet ﷺ said only 1 out of 73 sects will be saved from hellfire, and those are the ones that follow him and his companions and the later generation( the salaf as-salih). Ahlusunnah wal jam'ah. Salafiyyah is the true path.

[@theCordobaProject]

Thats my sheikh, may Allah grant him a long live and keep on blessing him

[@abdurrazzak2970]

May Allah Bless Both of You in this Life and in the Hereafter.

[@redman1300]

In Morocco i would say Shaykh Mustafa BenHamza and Shaykh Sa'eed al Kamali. In Libya Shaykh Saadiq al Ghiryani. Mauritania is full of Maliki scholars. Actually all african countries.

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

Knew I would find you here🤣🤣

[@redman1300]

@@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali 😂😂

[@adam.bashir]

Mustafa ben Hamza, Mawlud as Sariri & Sa'eed al Kamali are the scholarly giants of Morocco rn حفظهم الله

[@alk4262]

You’ll notice Shaykh Hassan often downplays morocco, I think it’s to not encourage misplaced nationalist sentiments. Allahu a3lam

[@dpireader32]

Very good questions asked by the host mashaaAllah

[@hilallazrak]

Mashallah, I didn't know that Dr H.Al-Kettani's English is that fluent, he is a Moroccan gem.

[@siemprestruggle9272]

@@frommoroccowithlove with due respect, your comment in itself is pure sectarianism. Look in the mirror sometimes.

[@siemprestruggle9272]

@@frommoroccowithlovewas ibn abdul birr wahabbi? Or ibn Taymiyyah? How about Ibn Kathir?

[@siemprestruggle9272]

@@frommoroccowithlove you're getting all kinds of political history and islamic theology very confused because it serves your narrative. Think again. Do you believe going to the tombs of sufi 'saints' a good thing?

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

@@frommoroccowithloveyou are just angry that many of the Islamic sheyookh agree with the aqeedah of the السلف الصالح

[@siemprestruggle9272]

@@frommoroccowithlove they were both atharis in their methodology regarding aqeedah, no one would consider them ashari. That is a fact.

[@TheRockeyAllen]

It would be nice to have similar lectures on the other madhabs as well

[@jonathaneffemey944]

Thanks for posting.

[@user-nc2ur5vo3l]

JazakAllah Khair

[@djamalmegari6891]

Algerian people 🇩🇿 follow Maliki Madheb by which our scholars give Fatwa.

[@abdellatifaitbihi1774]

For the new muslims, please know that Dr Al-Kettani is a great Shaykh and he is from my countries, but he is politically allined with the Ikhwan organization. Sometimes, his opinion can be affected by that alliance. for instance, he mentionned the lybian Sh El Gharyani or Qaradawi with such respect, when the truth is those "sheikhs" have many stupid fatwas in favour of Erdogan

[@LearnTawhid]

​@@abdellatifaitbihi1774stay away from ahlul bid'ah/ ikhwanis khawarij etc.

[@malikialgeriankabyleswag4200]

Indeed. One thing I respect in Morroco is the work they did regarding the Madhab. And its only their rulers not being loyal to falasteen that I dislike. But that has nothing to do with the people or their Ulama just like if our government does something bad doesnt mean the people are bad. So I have big respect for this work.

[@smilelikeababy9435]

🌿 Oh ALLAH, you are my Lord, there is no god but you created me and I worship you and I abide by your covenant and your promise as much as I can . I seek refuge in You from the evil of what I have done, I acknowledge Your favor upon me, and I acknowledge my sin, so forgive me, for no one forgives sins except You 🌿

[@crescentviewhs]

Great analysis thanks 👍

[@al-assili-sounds]

Sheikh Al-kattani is one of hidden gems of Morocco, but unfortunately Moroccans doesn't give their scholars the respect and attention they deserve, like they do with other Ulama from middle-east :( BTW the الكتاني family is a famous and long lived family in Morocco with a log of scholars like محمد بن جعفر الكتاني and عبدالحي الكتاني and others.

[@Hamza-iq6gw]

Morocco has no scolars

[@al-assili-sounds]

@@Hamza-iq6gw so you deny that sheikh kattani is a scholar? so where are the scholars then? is a dangerous claim. Ittaqi Allah!

[@Hamza-iq6gw]

@@al-assili-sounds you must be morrocan yourself that's why you look for scholars from your nationality may Allah heal you from this cancer called nationalism

[@moslemabdooullah7901]

Yes, totally agree! They had cheik boukhoubza, and today cheikh kattani, kamali, ikhilat, Issam Al Bachir

[@al-assili-sounds]

@moslem abdooullah صدقت you're right akhi fillah

[@KingKreem]

I am from morocco and I pray with my hands open and I do only one salam and I don´t say the basmallah in prayer and I don´t consider dogs to be impure etc...But yeah he is right. I rarely see other people in the masjid or outside following the maliki madhab.

[@hxyzazolchak]

It's the same for most of west Africa as well

[@coffe2270]

are u allowed to eat cats?

[@Nemo.24]

​@@coffe2270weird question

[@KingKreem]

@@coffe2270 Yes, if necessary. It´s makrooh at best, but not haram.

[@coffe2270]

@@KingKreem nah our malikis brother cold with it. might have to become one

[@MA-fq2hw]

Hello Paul, could you check out a book called Modern Egypt by Lord Cromer i really want to see you discuss the book it talks about several historical accounts made by Lord Cromer whose an orientalist

[@siemprestruggle9272]

Salaam, does anyone know where Sh. Kettani is based in Morocco, where abouts in Morocco?

[@abubakrbinmuhammed8927]

Is there anyway i can contact the sheykh please .. can anyone help me , ( purpose is to learn maliki mazhab clearly) please

[@isa-atm]

Sheikh says that the school of Medina was not that influenced by Ali (rad.) coz he shifted the capital to Iraq and thus the Hanafi school was more influenced by him. But .... During the first 3 caliphates (about 24 years), if im not wrong, Ali was in medina and relatively away from politics, and so we can expect that he would have taught the people of medina more than the people of Iraq (where he spent only about 5 years and his term was filled with political turmoil, which means relatively no time to teach).

[@malikialgeriankabyleswag4200]

And Ali RA was a Qadi for many years when he was not Caliph so he surely did influence the traditions. He was the one giving fatawa. But still, Umar RA had probably the most influence and the other Khulafa.

[@Kzam19-ux8wg]

Aal-e-Imran 3:105 وَلَا تَكُونُواْ كَٱلَّذِينَ تَفَرَّقُواْ وَٱخۡتَلَفُواْ مِنۢ بَعۡدِ مَا جَآءَهُمُ ٱلۡبَيِّنَٰتُۚ وَأُوْلَٰٓئِكَ لَهُمۡ عَذَابٌ عَظِيمٌ And do not be like those who split ˹into sects˺ and differed after clear proofs had come to them. It is they who will suffer a tremendous punishment.

[@ProLookout]

This is the fifth time I had to turn back on notifications for a Muslim dominant channel…. WHY?

[@voltaire29]

Nice

[@jasonatreides2542]

I remember when Uthman ibn Farooq featured him for none other reason than this teacher Shaykh Hassan Al-Kettani refutes (sadl) the well known position of leaving the arms at the sides in the prayer. Although Shaykh Bin Bayyah does practice Qabd (clasping hands). @34:40 notice the jab against sadl. Why did he feel that was necessary? Actually this is a great tactic by Salafis. Dress up people like Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanafi etc. and package them with their aqidah and send them back to the Muslim lands as defenders of those classical traditions. It is a genius albeit devious chess move.

[@jasonatreides2542]

@@Ben_B. "stop this sectarianism" followed by "pseudo ashari" That's rich. That is just rich. Good day to you.

[@redman1300]

I agree on the sadl part and have translated some videos in defence of sadl. He shouldnt have taken a jab at it akhi.

[@jasonatreides2542]

@@redman1300 exactly ty. I mean he can defend qabd as the mashur but the way he made a snide remark and at rulers of countries btw! I thought the Salafi Modus Oprandi was to avoid unnecessary critique of rulers.

[@unknownpng650]

salam alaykom brother , im an ashari maliki , what do you think about this sheikh ? does he represent correctly the maliki madhab?

[@jasonatreides2542]

@@unknownpng650 walakum salam wrwb, I am no authority in the school. I would advice you to bring that up with teachers you trust respected brother.

[@JumpaKage]

Sheikh Ibn Taymiyya (ra) said: “The path of the Malikiya, Hanafiya, Shafi’iya and Hanbaliya are the path of a righteous believer..” (Majmu’ Fatawa, V. 14, P. 263)

[@aali8874]

وَعَلَيْكُم السَّلَام وَرَحْمَةُ اَللهِ وَبَرَكاتُهُ

[@muhammadbenjuraij7734]

The Kattaanis are well known. I have numerous chains and ijazaat that pass through the Kattaanis and abnaaus Sadeek or the ghimaariyyeen. Although traditionally they are scholars of tasawwuf as well as the outward sharia and they do not endorse the position of sheikhul Islam Ibn Taymiya رحمه الله regarding tawassul and the like.

[@Kzam19-ux8wg]

Al-An'am 6:159 إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ فَرَّقُواْ دِينَهُمۡ وَكَانُواْ شِيَعًا لَّسۡتَ مِنۡهُمۡ فِى شَىۡءٍۚ إِنَّمَآ أَمۡرُهُمۡ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ ثُمَّ يُنَبِّئُهُم بِمَا كَانُواْ يَفۡعَلُونَ Indeed, you ˹O Prophet˺ are not responsible whatsoever for those who have divided their faith and split into sects. Their judgment rests only with Allah. And He will inform them of what they used to do.

[@rajababy2009]

remember these four madhab emerges due to process of relying the method to solve day to day Problems in Worship and daily life , For Example Imam malik lived in Madina So he consider the City of the Prophet pbuh is enough sources for Islamic information So he collect information from Madina city , Imam Abu Hanifa relies upon Kufa (City of Iraq) Sources because many famous Sahaba Karam R.A moved to Kufa which was capital of Islamic caliphate SO he lied upon Kufa sources , remember at that time traveling was so difficult and expensive So thats why these four school become Prominent because they had strong sources to backup heir claims regarding a fatwa they issued but some did mistakes as well

[@afsalpsalu6663]

Their mistakes better than our understanding.

[@tmk5]

Urdu subtitles please

[@omnas6053]

Four schools of intellectual - mazhab. Hanafi, Maliki, Syafie and Hanbali. 😇

[@diazzable]

Assalaam, aleikoum brother, its Madhab and not mazhab...and Chaafihi

[@LearnTawhid]

Follow the madhab of the prophet peace be upon him. The imams told you not to blind follow but to follow Qur'an and sunnah

[@omnas6053]

@@LearnTawhid that's where's they called schools of thoughts.

[@RayOfHope8]

❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹

[@formusic5947]

Hi is there somewhere we can ask personal questions to you about islamic philosophy? :)

[@mugeesa_bint_hamid]

Shaykh alsadiq algiryani. Shaykh bultaar Ahmad tahir rayaan Allama bahh Abdullah bin faal alalawi

[@HussainFahmy]

*_First class_*

[@thewisetzar5363]

Kettani a great Athari scholar

[@crescentviewhs]

The prophet ordered us to follow Quran and suna. Hadith are not suna but a clue and record of suna. Thats why i trust hanifa and malik as were all confirmed by imam shaffi as great sholars with integrity as compared to later generation scholars. The swahaba never followed a single hadiths but the practices of the prophet pbuh and quran.

[@LearnTawhid]

Alxamdulilah we follow the madhab of the prophet peace be upon him. We don't divide our religion by blind following the imams who clearly told us not to take their speech if their speech goes against the prophet peace be upon him. We love and respect all the 4 imams of ahlusunnah.

[@malikialgeriankabyleswag4200]

You're a Jahil

[@abdellatifaitbihi1774]

For the new muslims, please know that Dr Al-Kettani is a great Shaykh and he is from my countries, but he is politically allined with the Ikhwan organization. Sometimes, his opinion can be affected by that alliance. for instance, he mentionned the lybian Sh El Gharyani or Qaradawi with such respect, when the truth is those "sheikhs" have many stupid fatwas in favour of Erdogan

[@A.--.]

Someone should have told him the dirt the Prophet walked on likely had scattered away by wind so imam malik didn't have to make up his own strange superstition rules.

[@bouchraandyourlordisneverf3789]

👍🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦

[@lahleholivia7398]

The Australian lungfish, native to the Burnett and Mary Rivers, is the closest living fish relative to humans and other land dwellers - Natural History Museum.

[@willp.8904]

THIS CHANNEL IS BECOMING AN ISLAMIC INSTITUTION

[@n.a.1397]

Malikis were Sunni (Ashari) throughout history.

[@Ben_B.]

ibn zaid al qarawayni the "little Malik" and sheikh al islam ibn abd al barr were atharis affirming that allah is above His throne with His essence. Imam ibn Abd al Barr even wrote a book against ilm al kalam. Both of these scholars are encyclopedias and no maliki can deny them. Andalus was Athari but became Ashari when scholars traveled to seek knowledge from ghazali. Then they came back to andalus and spread it. You have no knowledge about islamic history.

[@n.a.1397]

@@Ben_B. Yeah, undermining the entire history of the ummah with exceptions and anecdotes and accusing people you don't know of ignorance is the hallmark of petrodollars. Condemnation of kalam was always done when it was for debate/unnessecary. No, Allah transcends space and time. The Ummah agrees on that. The real Athari are not so-called salafis.

[@conjugatemethod]

@@n.a.1397 Ignore Ben he seems to be just another one of the resident ignorant Wahhabi pontificators here in the comments section of Blogging Theology.

[@Ben_B.]

@@n.a.1397 Allah is still with His essence above the throne. Thats what both (Ibn Abd Al Barr and Qarawayni) said. Both critizied people who make Ta'weel or deny the apparent meaning of the attribute. I bet you didnt even read 1 of their books lol and yet you are here talking.

[@n.a.1397]

Qarawayni was Ashari, and even authored a work defending our creed against Mutazila. Followers of psuedo-salafism should be honest and not put on the appearance of Ahlus Sunnah. Your leaders have condemned and made takfir of traditional Muslims. Why call yourself something your not?

[@MBeats27]

If I wasn't hanafi I would be Maliki

[@fletcher9328]

جحال على جحال

[@DrWoofOfficial]

جهل على جهل؟

[@A.--.]

When you learn about these imams you realize how much stuff they made up. Whdn you compare thfm to Sahaba you realize how strange their actions were compared to Sahaba.

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

In his background section, this "shiekh" seems to have omitted the fact that he was imprisoned in Morocco for 9 years for terrorism and for having been one of the instigators of the 2003 Casablanca bombings. Please Paul, next time do a background check of your guests before inviting them to your channel.

[@redman1300]

False allegations and false charges. You do some research instead of believing false charges against innocent men. Show me a video of his where he calls towards terrorism? You can't because he never calls for it.

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

@@redman1300 And who are you to decide whether or not he was innocent? The morrocan judicial system found him guilty of "constitution of criminal gang, endangerment of state security, assassination attempts and terrorism". Are you aware that you are defending a man who manipulated 12 young men to go blow themselfs up in the middle of the city of Casablanca killing 33 people? What would you say to Allah in the day of Al Qiyama when the 33 victims will reproaching you for supporting mad sheiks like this one? You asked me for an example of what he preaches, but you don't have to go back that far. Just see his opinion during the fall of kabul: "This is one of God's days, a day of joy, happiness and joy. God is great and thank God very much, praise be to God who extended our lives to see this day, and while we wept 20 years ago for the fall of the Islamic Emirate, today we weep with joy at his return." www.bladi.net/hassan-kettani-retour-talibans-kaboul,85584.html And if you're one of those salafists or wahabists who still supports talibans after all they've done, then there is no need discuss this any further.

[@user-ch3ck7ir7c]

And you trust the Moroccan authorities? We all know for a fact that people in muslim countries are being put behind bars while they are innocent, unfortunately. If this man is guilty you should provide evidence that he is guilty. Put the evidence for everyone to see if you are truthfull. If don't have any evidence and you rely only on statement of unreliable authorities than you better be silent, unless you are comfortabel with the prospect to being hold accountable for your accusations. I have more trust in the statements of this scholar who has said that he has in no way or form contributed to attacks of 2003 in Morocco.

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

@@user-ch3ck7ir7c Morocco is well known for their effort to conter terrorism and extremist preachers contrary to other islamic countries that let them run free until they gain a lot of followers and join well known terroristic organisations. According to global terrorism Index 2022: Morocco is among the world’s safest countries, so yes I trust Morocco when it comes to arresting dangerous preachers. During his high-profile trial in Morocco, he had the opportunity to defend himself against these charges with his lawyer and he was found guilty of being the ideological leader of the Salafia Jihadia movement (its a Salafi jihadist militant group based in Morocco and Spain with links to Al-Qaeda, they were also responsible of the 2004 Madrid train bombings that killed 191 people and wounded over 2,000). If you have more trust in this despicable individual instead of the moroccan authorities who are doing a good job of stopping these extremists who infect our ummah, then you should maybe meditate about this and reconsidere your views.

[@canbest7668]

I hope they clarify how a sexist and ridiculous it is

[@montecristo7963]

ههههههههه الكتاني الارهابي المسجون بسبب الارهاب في المغرب 😂

[@A.--.]

If Sahaba peed in Medinah and wore slippers then why would imam malik make up his own rule not to? Sounds like a very superstition guy.

[@kay1057]

The Ashari heretics madling in the comments is great.

[@Ryan-lf6ds]

it's spelled asharis are tearin wahhabi heretics a new one.

[@abdellatifaitbihi1774]

For the new muslims, please know that Dr Al-Kettani is a great Shaykh and he is from my countries, but he is politically allined with the Ikhwan organization. Sometimes, his opinion can be affected by that alliance. for instance, he mentionned the lybian Sh El Gharyani or Qaradawi with such respect, when the truth is those "sheikhs" have many stupid fatwas in favour of Erdogan

[@Ben_B.]

Again pseudo asharis crying when paul puts a video online who doesn't share their corrupted aristotle aqeedah. 🤣

[@conjugatemethod]

Don't get too excited, Hassan Kettani is not a bigoted Salafi he has called Muhammad Ibn Abdal Wahhab's actions extremist; he respects true Sunni scholars including Imam Ahmad Rida Khan; he also celebrates Mawlid - what do you have to say about him now? is he a mubtadi'?

[@Ben_B.]

@@conjugatemethod no but ibn qudama would call u a zindiq mubtadi' since u r ashari

[@Ryan-lf6ds]

seems like aristotle had a better aqeedah than wahhabi kafir retards. 🤣 we cryin on yo a$$. lmao

[@n.a.1397]

@@Ben_B. The Israelis and Yanks call you partner, since you are upon the minhaj of saood and their house scholars.

[@lawlietlawliet]

@@Ben_B. then you can call Salahuddin Al Ayubi a mubtadi since he’s an Ashari as well

[@sdeeyoktar8442]

this guy has been to prison for reasons...

[@ily2383]

The 4 Imams and Abu taymiyyah was also In prison, what’s your point ?

[@younessboustta6525]

and what is the problem if he went to prison we know that half of the scholares in so called muslim world in the prison because of the liberal states that rulled the muslim world

[@dortoka]

@@ily2383 Abu Taymiyyah 💀💀💀 be quiet man

[@redman1300]

False charges and false allegations.

[@n.a3642]

@@dortoka He obviously meant Ibn Taymiyyah.

[@truthprevails5173]

Never stand against Jehovah/Yahweh, the True Creator God, the God of Abraham, the God of Israel! What is God's program as prophesied in Bible, 2500 years ago, for the Holy Land? Ezekiel - Chapter 37 21 say, "The Lord Yahweh says this: I shall take the Israelites from the nations where they have gone. I shall gather them to- gether from everywhere and bring them home to their own soil. 22 I shall make them into one nation in the country, on the mountains of Israel, and one king is to be king of them all; they will no longer form two nations, nor be two separate kingdoms. 23 They will no longer defile themselves with their foul idols, their horrors and any of their crimes. I shall save them from the acts of infidelity which they have committed and shall cleanse them; they will be my people and I shall be their God. 24 My servant David will reign over them, one shepherd for all; they will follow my judgements, respect my laws and practise them. 25 They will live in the country which I gave to my servant Jacob, the country in which your ancestors lived. They will live in it, they, their children, their children's children, for ever. David my servant is to be their prince for ever. 26 I shall make a covenant of peace with them, an eternal covenant with them. I shall resettle them and make them grow; I shall set my sanctuary among them for ever. 27 I shall make my home above them; I shall be their God, and they will be my people. 28 And the nations will know that I am Yahweh the sanctifier of Israel, when my sanctuary is with them for ever." '

[@BABA-ORUC1761]

It's makes me extremely sad that great kettani family got influenced/infiltrated by "𝙒𝙖𝙝𝙝𝙖𝙗𝙞 𝙞𝙙𝙚𝙤𝙡𝙤𝙜𝙮". IMAM JAFFAR AL KETTANI (RA) WAS WELL KNOWN SUNNI SCHOLAR.

[@kay1057]

Al-Ashari are nothing more than heretics even Kuwarij are closer to the people of Sunnah than them.

[@Al-Azdi]

Don’t worry, he’s the only one. + in the Arab world all Sunnis know he’s a Wahhabi, and the irony is that although he tries his best to please them the Wahhabis don’t accept him. saying (he’s too lean and has “agendas”).

[@BABA-ORUC1761]

@@Al-Azdi jazakalhu khair brother.

[@abdellatifaitbihi1774]

i am from his country. Can u give me one example against Sunnah, explaining the 𝙒𝙖𝙝𝙝𝙖𝙗𝙞 𝙞𝙙𝙚𝙤𝙡𝙤𝙜𝙮

[@Ryan-lf6ds]

@@abdellatifaitbihi1774 it's a k afir cult.

[@Traveler012]

Why complicate the deen so much? Islam is simple and beautiful why make it so complicated? Look i love to learn and study in depth but it's so dangerous that it makes you fall into sects and start to devide people, who is following better, what shaikh is more correct, which country is more muslims and on haqq and so on. You can clearly hear when these brothers speak the shaikh mentions Uae and he totally X them from following the Maliki medhab not to mention who he considers to be a top scholar in what country. This is so dangerous, and if you ask these people where did Allah or Prophet saaw tell you to practis Islam like that they have no answer.

[@aali8874]

وَعَلَيْكُم السَّلَام وَرَحْمَةُ اَللهِ وَبَرَكاتُهُ