BoA 보아, WENDY 웬디, & NINGNING 닝닝 - Time After Time (원) @ SMTOWN LIVE 2023 (SMCU PALACE at KWANGYA)

[@user-ir3mv6fc8h]

뭐야 이거 노래 개같이 좋네

[@djdne7330]

ㄹㅇ 나 맨날 듣는중 스엠아 이거다 ㄹㅇ;; 캐비어로 알탕 그만끓이고 이런 곡 좀 내줘 ㅠㅠ

[@김중남-j9l]

원래 보아 목소리가 알앤비 발라드 최적화임,,, 댄스 그만하고 이런 노래나 더 내줬으면

[@윤소진-s4d]

닝닝넘이뿌❤️

[@sajjanghotane9370]

Wendy nails everything from higher to lower notes, adlibs, and falsetto. Talk abt the versatility. She is gifted and truly an amazing singer.

[@thomasstang956]

100% agree! She can really do it all!!! Keep the Wendy OST's coming....Just keep the Wendy Songs coming!! Thanks for this SM!!!

[@sevanitors]

but falsetto/head voice was ning2

[@partoftheway4235]

Wendy is a prodigy! Just listen to her crushendo. How she fades her notes inbetween soft and loud. And yet her notes don't loose sustainability. Yeah Wendy shines!!!!!

[@eyebrowstj]

@@sevanitors Wendy has one of the best head voices in kpop. She also can sing in falsetto when she wants to. If you want to hear how amazing her head voice and falsetto are just listen to Look and Ladies Night by Red Velvet. She has one of the most versatile voices in the industry.

[@melliexcx]

@@eyebrowstj they didn’t say she can’t do it lol. They just said she didn’t do it here. I’m not on any side btw.

[@je-st2qf]

There's a reason why NINGNING is the assigned main vocalist in her own group. Listening to her sing is so soothing to the ears. She sings those low notes and high notes flawlessly, still sounding soulful and stable. NINGNING is so good!

[@ffbeexaid4509]

facts

[@acebase555]

I love this because it shows how much Ningning deserves that title.

[@PP-js1qx]

😂some was sound so Irritated of a ear😂

[@kpop_stanjihyun5816]

@@PP-js1qx you're lucky you can't hear me sing🤣😂

[@lachimolalaarmy7323]

It's true ✅

[@Hazzzz-t4j]

와 미쳤다 보아 웬디도 노래 개잘부르는데 닝닝이도 못지않고 와우 .. 무대 기획 누가한거 대박

[@sophsm9860]

Wendy’s vocals are legendary fr…

[@힣히히-l3e]

보아 목소리 진짜 깊고 진하다... sm의 자부심 그 자체인 듯..

[@오늘도집-o8m]

음색 독보적이긴한듯. 국내 가수들 중 비슷한 사람이 없어.

[@udonramenyumz]

3 SM vocalist legends... Wendy is absolutely mindblowing there's just something about her voice that's so crystal clear

[@partoftheway4235]

I agree. As I said above Wendy is my bias. What our me to that level with her is when one day on a clip from her young street she started singing opera for like 15 seconds. But what just blew my mind is that she did it like it was nothing to do! When I seen that it made her one of my top 5 favorite female singers in history in the world. Not just in kpop. Wendy is really a true vocal legend in music history!

[@stippadu64]

No offense like literally no offense im dead serious. Ningnign is really talented but i wouldnt consider her a legend yet. I think its a bit to early to call her that considering that being a legend takes a little bit of time😂😂

[@sims2lovealot]

@@stippadu64 you're probably right that she's not a legend yet, but she's definitely well on her way to becoming one!

[@stippadu64]

@@sims2lovealot she is indeed

[@ok-zs8xu]

@@stippadu64 she's definitely will

[@김재현-u1g8x]

이번앨범에서 이노래가 제일 좋다 진짜... 그리고 이렇게 모아놓으니깐 보아보컬이 진짜 보물같다고 느껴짐..

[@QNFLDZZMF123]

음색에 고음에 미친듯 보아..

[@yoonk3843]

보아는 음색이 진짜 사기... 독보적임 저거 20년 유지한다는게..

[@친엄마-h4m]

보아 미쳣네 ㄷㄷㄷ

[@jjhm3844]

보아목소리는 진짜 공연에서 더 빛을 발함... 깊이가 다름

[@eulalia3468]

Ningning if she's treated right she can be the next legend

[@marvel3734]

I don't think that SM will promote her better They want only to promote Winter

[@alanrodrigues2483]

​@@marvel3734unfortunately

[@Kimnabi123]

@@marvel3734 yes the kpop industry treats foreign members so bad

[@thevoiceofthefuture2]

Unfortunately it looks like SM only cares to promote Winter as their vocalist

[@marvel3734]

@@thevoiceofthefuture2 It's obvious and I am really annoyed Ningning tries so hard in all fields and they promote Winter who doesn't try to improve her stage presence

[@martina770]

다들진짜 잘하는데 보아가 진짜미쳣다... 목소리 겁나유니크한데 겁나 잘어울리고.. 보아 노래 이렇게 잘하는거ㅜ모든사람들이알았으면좋겟다아ㅏ

[@jkjcord762]

Amazed that Ning Ning, being so young, could hold her own with those two legends.......WOW! The is mind blowing!!!!

[@kittygalore7344]

Bcs shes already a singer predebut since she was 12-13 years old, shes already singing on stage, so shes quite experienced.

[@butterfly-fx7wm]

@@kittygalore7344so does everyone, mind you boa debut when she is 13 yrs old and wendy was a soprano in richmond choir in 2012. cant wait how much improvement will ningning show when she has the same experience as them as she is so amazing now too

[@rosetyong]

@@butterfly-fx7wm she‘s talking about ningning why are you dragging others?

[@ryvulet8639]

@@rosetyong Ningning won't be near Wendy.... Sad truth but you can just tell from the technique issues she already has.

[@sleepyjoe4529]

@@ryvulet8639 shut up nerd

[@McKavian]

NingNing's smokey alto voice contrasts with Wendy's bell like soprano so very well. BoA is a beautiful balance.

[@wadidawyeye9688]

Ningning is freaking sopran

[@McKavian]

@@wadidawyeye9688 not in this song she's not.

[@yesitsims]

@@McKavian she uses another key for this song, but she is still a soprano

[@McKavian]

@@yesitsims You are right. She is. But, not for this song.

[@aenning]

@@McKavian Not at all, she just sang in a lower note in the harmonies...

[@jaebird411]

Ning Ning’s lower register is so sultry and her high notes are so clear. This was the perfect showcase for her. We already knew legends BoA & Wendy would tear the stage up. I loved everything about this 💗

[@belgarauth13]

100%

[@lisaseokjinbts2901]

@hihihihi no one care

[@lisaseokjinbts2901]

@hihihihi do i care?

[@lisaseokjinbts2901]

@hihihihi what your age seriously? Hating ningning but you cant do better, you show your jealous by hating on her praise comment its pathetic lmao, 💀

[@lisaseokjinbts2901]

@hihihihi hating on ningning because you cant have her voice? And because You cant singing with wendy? its why you hating, hating mean jealousy, i hope you will learn not to be jealous and have envy

[@happyjgl2126]

보아는 진짜 레전드다. 춤이면 춤 노래면 노래...비주얼이면 비주얼. 그때당시엔 진짜 대단했지.

[@1유튭-u6u]

노래 넘 좋다...다들 엄청 잘부르는데 보아 목소리가 진짜 잘 어울림.....완전 쫄깃

[@QNFLDZZMF123]

보아 진짜 미친듯 너무잘하네

[@ekgp0147]

보아 진짜 개쩌네.. 목소리가 넘사벽이야.. 맑고 깊이있는데 또 허스키하고 .. 개좋네 노래 ㅠㅠ

[@사람-f5c]

웬디사랑해

[@jayvlv3800]

For those wondering, they sang this song live but sm putted the prerecorded one instead of their live vocals for this performance. Wendy confirmed it on bbl

[@user1-b2g]

why??? their vocals is surely not bad.

[@shiningyoonie]

I don’t get why SM does this???

[@vaniakanti593]

Ikr, some performance live but SM editing their voice like so many back vocals and removed breath noise

[@jebablessysalomi3451]

Live doesn't have acting. Bcz fans wanted only visuals not skills. That's why. Fans often find size of nostrils and mouth...

[@shreyahkr]

thats weird because the chanyeol had live vocals

[@라이언하트-u3g]

보아웅니 목소리 미쳤다....ㅠㅠ

[@osori4690]

보아는 진짜 레전드다

[@irenemakesmehappy8145]

Wendy Carey 💙 Boayonce 💙 Ningriana Grande

[@rebm7505]

lmao

[@kylieyu5138]

😂

[@Lyf4rMusic]

Nice puns there ;)

[@paunamidatta9000]

It's so accurate

[@gvsTV]

😂😂😂

[@mjk3487]

보아ㅠㅠㅠ💛💛💛💛💛

[@zenniebinnie]

보아 목소리는 정말 독보적이야

[@헐랭-c6w]

돋ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@zenniebinnie]

@@헐랭-c6w 예 독보적이요 예^^

[@uch6468]

보아 음색 진짜 홀린다..

[@나원-w3m]

보아 목소리가 가사에 딱 맞는 느낌... 중저음은 정말 대단해.

[@shinp3697]

들어도들어도 질리지가 않아.. 보컬 셋 너무 잘어울리고 밸런스 좋고.. 특히 보아 음색 왜케 단단하고 처절해… 쉽게 불러보이는데 .. 쉽지 않다는게…

[@김은혜-s6y1u]

보아는 음역대도 다양하고 진성 가성 진짜 적재적소에 잘 씀,,,,, 맛깔나게 부른달까

[@Loveandjoy9]

웬디 목소리 나오자마자 귀가 트이는 느낌..

[@흐흐-j7j]

권보아 ㅠㅜㅜ💛💛💛 도랐😍

[@qmdkdkd]

에스파에서 닝닝 없었으면 큰일날뻔.. 닝닝 목소리가 진짜 안정적이고 듣기 편안함ㅜㅜ 이런 노래 앞으로 많이 해줬으면

[@힣히히-l3e]

보아 목소리 진짜 깊고 진한 와인 같음

[@Sisisisi_]

맞음. 헐 나도 이말 친구한테 했음 ㅋㅋ

[@여신님-p8t]

립싱크아니에요?

[@aaaaaaa624]

@@여신님-p8t아니에요

[@숨-d4f]

2:07 부터 보아 웬디 닝닝 고음차력쇼… 언니들 사랑해요 진짜 ….

[@행복하기-c5n]

보아 자체가 장르임 와 진짜ㅜㅜ 중딩때 부터 서른 넘은 지금까지 쭉 팬인데ㅜ 이렇게 계속 앨범내주고 무대에 서줘서 너무 감사함ㅜㅜ내 최애 가수의 공연을 무대에서 계속 볼 수있다는게 넘 큰 행복♡

[@yourer]

Wendy's vocals really be everything.

[@lee-3-]

웬디 저렇게 고음이 계속되는데도 아름답게 소화하는게 너무 대단함 ㅠ 그리고 권보아는 신이다...

[@148ESTHER]

Wendy is not only an incredible, masterful vocalist, maybe one of the best at SM, but she also is such a nice and relatable human being. Humble, kind, sweet. She deserves all the praise and love!

[@dzulviyahya5256]

@@hihihihi1339 ooh so, you are a Wendy's fans? but why are you hate ningning that much? spread hate in every comments about ningning.. so childish..

[@alifaturohmah]

@hihihihi kzbin.info/www/bejne/mICxo2qqj5yJf7c

[@amorfati1105]

보아는 이런 재지한 곡 너무 잘어울려 보아만의 감성과 창법 음색이 애절하게 맘을 녹인다 ㅠㅠ

[@kpopmammy6057]

NINGNING VOCALS ON THE NEXT LEVEL

[@JIyuziyu]

다 좋은데 난 갠적으로 닝닝이 음색이 여기 제일 맘에든당ㅠㅠ 닝닝 원곡한 거 듣고싶다

[@user-yq9lj3qj6z]

웬디야ㅠㅠ💙

[@boringsiot]

Wendy looks so good, it's ridiculous

[@lqzwb]

보아는 신이야💛💛💛

[@user-uv1qt1kr1h]

햐..드디어 올라왔구나 보아 중저음 레알 도라버려 닝닝이두 파워풀하고 웬디 목소리 너무 듣기 편함.. 이거 라이브로 한거래요 웬디님께서 말씀해줌.. 슴콘에서 라이브로 듣고 싶다..ㅠ 권보아 사랑함💛

[@riadancefit]

와...갓더빗도 그렇고.. 보아 연차에 이렇게 한참 어린 후배들과 함께 그냥 하나의 팀처럼 무대를 한다는것 자체가 진짜 대단한 듯👍🏻

[@user-zeous]

울 웬디 언니 넘 잘한다…….🫶

[@닉스-o3r]

보아 각선미.. ㄷㄷ

[@nazarena1171]

Ningning Grande 😯😍

[@dystephiary]

Ningie’s low register is just amazing

[@みょうがです]

이 노래 제일 좋아해… 닝닝 너무 잘했던 거 같애

[@하느리-l7w]

연말 시상식에서 이걸 불러줘야 되는 거 아닌가요 대박이다 고음 미쳤고 노래 넘 좋아..ㅠ

[@bluewannie9103]

red velvet is so lucky to have Wendy on their team

[@lalalar4191]

보아 너무 고급지고 이쁘고 노래도좋구🤭

[@집갈래요-g5d]

우리 닝이 목소리 ㅁㅊ다 최고야❤

[@파란-i2p]

웬디넘예쁘고 라이브최고였당

[@메롱-n7h]

보아짱💛

[@opheliankim]

Wendy's ti i i i i ime sended me straight to heaven

[@PhuongTran-gj7jt]

C’mon cameraman! Wendy deserves more screen time!

[@yulkim4042]

어머 보아님 이런컨셉 좋아요! 이런 분위기에 목소리도 너무 잘어울려요❤

[@Saihein98]

Wendy the best vocalist of her generation

[@mr.manbong3787]

Wendy's timeeee~~~ after timeeee~~~ was so argh!! Make me feel things

[@o_o348]

이곡은 보아 노래 인듯 너무 잘해 ㅠㅠㅠ

[@leehsiaohui5234]

Wendy💙💙💙

[@kico___]

스엠은 왜 이건 안 올려줘..

[@sgamingandmore12]

ningning is so insanely talented and beautiful, they all did amazing!!

[@zoey4148]

Ningning so pretty

[@우낭-p5r]

보아 너무 독보적임..역시

[@Kimnabi123]

2:33 wow that was a high note Ning Ning hit they all did so good as expected from boa and Wendy tho

[@guardian9271]

NINGNING SLAYING BOTH LOW AND HIGH REGISTER

[@flhandbbt]

Wendy is absolutely STUNNING

[@Rvnju]

닝닝 헤메코 레전드네

[@auragaga]

Wendy is just on another level, all those adlibs were crazy

[@blas_de_lezo7375]

Wendy adlibs are probably my fav thing in red velvet songs, they just add so much.

[@auragaga]

@@blas_de_lezo7375 she's the vocal powerhouse of red velvet

[@Proto1215]

Wow. Wendy just killing it.

[@theretheresia]

Wendy you are still stunning even with a bad camera work 😇💙

[@tanisha6024]

Wendyyyy 🥹💗💗💗💗

[@꼬마언니]

오마이갓… 갓보아

[@secimbarbar4894]

wendy amazing singer boa queen ning superstar

[@lindatran79]

Ningning’s vocals 😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️🫶🏼🫶🏼

[@홍심-g8w]

보아 보컬 진짜 개좋아ㅠㅠ

[@Cc-td3vl]

Wendy wowwww!!!!!

[@Rosy-yo4nr]

Ningning sounds so heavenly

[@dobrasko208]

Wendy's vocal is always gonna be my favorite

[@alejandraromerorodriguez2270]

Wendy’s vocals are legendary

[@tenjangchup8844]

Ohh my goddess Wendy can’t deny her voice 🤌🏻

[@sims2lovealot]

My favourite performance! Ningning sounds so beautiful next to Boa and Wendy, and they all look so elegant and classy!

[@o_o348]

태연이한테 악플달고 다니더니 여기 있누 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@peremiss5318]

BOA sounds so good holy shit

[@febria7418]

Wendy ❤❤❤

[@춤과코난베르무트를사]

아니 진짜 보아 목소리 는 참ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 대체 몇가지 음색이 있는 걸까.......... 진짜 음색이💙💙💙👍👍👍👍👍

[@poppopkpop5430]

There is no limit to what NingNing could achieved if given proper attention. Amazing

[@jane-nd9oj]

웬디 발성 정확 편안 크

[@sochvilchez8751]

NINGNING

[@lqzwb]

무한반복중. 이번 앨범 중 이 노래가 젤 좋다구요😳😳😳

[@silint8856]

BoAの声が耳心地良すぎる。。

[@zoey4148]

Ningning i love you ❤

[@realmagrib5921]

Another wendy vocal 🥶🥶🥶🥶

[@yoshi-l8k]

💗wendy💗

[@na_nariana2416]

Wendyyyy

[@blahblah8423]

WENDY YOU GODDESS