BoA, WENDY, & NINGNING - 'Time After Time' | SMTOWN LIVE 2023 | REACTION

[@izonexbae]

Everyone is talented and crazy but woah Wendy was singing as if she got through divorces and way more

[@itsmejadu]

I have to agree

[@abigailfhlor2033]

They sang like the rent is due tomorrow 😭😭😭✨

[@gimmelovee]

wendy is so a good vocalist I can't 😭

[@Lyf4rMusic]

Wendy's ad-libs are really on ultimate level ! You just know she's coming for all the vocalists one has heard in their life ;)

[@zapunaru]

Not surprise because they are from SM, the agency with the best vocalist in this industry.

[@genieu636]

BoA's vocal is no joke.

[@vaniaasinaga]

ALL ARE GORG BUT WENDYYYYYY RED VELVET REALLY FIREEEEEEE

[@milindawilson9175]

This performance of "Time After Time" by NingNing (aespa), BoA (legendary solo artist) and Wendy (Red Velvet) is also one of the stages from SM's New Year's Eve 2022-23 SMTown: SMCU Palace concert that was streamed live with live recorded videos of all of SM's groups and artists performing special stages for this SMTown concert at the beginning of the year. It is no surprise that you are impressed by everyone's vocals because, as you know, that is just something the SM is known for. BoA's amazing vocals are one of the reasons why SM is now known as the vocal powerhouse of the industry, and everyone else follows after her. You literally can't be an SM artist without having amazing vocals and dance skills, even SM's rappers get intense vocal training, so all of SM's artists are some of the best singers in the industry. BoA is the ultimate Idol of Idols. Her talents are unmatched. This is why SM selected her to become a trainee when she was 11 or 12 and why she debuted in 2000 when she was only 13 years old, because she is so amazing. BoA is one of the originals in the Kpop industry. she has been in the industry for more than 22 years now and she is only 36 years old. :D She was one of the youngest artists in the industry when she debuted and she is now one of SM's longest held artists. She started under SM and is still represented by SM. So she has been in the industry for more than two decades, and, yet, she is still younger than a lot of artists who have come after her. That's how much of a legend she is. :D BoA is an OG of OGs. There is almost nothing she can't do. Everyone regards her as more than just an Idol, she is so well respected that she is a mentor to most Idols in the industry. And she is even a member of SM's board of directors and she is now in charge of the health and mental well-being of SM's artists. Wendy is the main vocalist of Red Velvet, who is also known for her powerhouse vocals. She is Korean, but she lived for a long time in Canada and the U.S. so she speaks English like a native speaker. Red Velvet debuted in 2014. BoA and Wendy are also members of the girl group GOT the Beat. And yes, NingNing is the youngest member of aespa, who is also the main vocalist. She is Chinese. aespa debuted in 2020.

[@JChris21]

Each offered a vocal flex! Boa being a legend as well as Wendy and Ningning a legend in the making! If priority takes the rnb approach, this one is jazz, it reaches transcendental level with these three vocals! I like both in a different manner but I must admit, I listen to time after time so many times like an obsession!

[@hehe-fl6vm]

Sameee both are my fav but time after time is on repeat

[@binuhunk7430]

boA still no 1 she was the first SM artist that I knew and until now I like all artists from SM

[@CristhianDeCastro]

Saying Wendy is good is like saying Lionel Messi is good at football.

[@BrockTheDon]

True 😂. However it must still be said

[@ningninghotwife2695]

I love ningning grande

[@LizzieCG]

Love this song so much because theybare my 3 fav SM vocalists but my gawd Miss BoA?!!! Her experience maybe? But her tone here? Took the song to another level 🔥 i need an album with these 3 I swear

[@z0ls]

Appreciate the reaction to this masterpiece. It's the song that i got on repeat out of the album, and i just hope that SM will be sane enough to actually upload this officially like the other songs.

[@himaliyacute6639]

Ningning is a legend

[@irenetao]

ningning is amazing🎉

[@pedrovictorsantos6658]

Ningriana grande goddess 🗣️🦋✨

[@makeup-beauty8802]

Ning Ningriana grande 😭😭

[@vafelnaavafelka]

don’t compare ning with ari

[@itzelayala7323]

@@vafelnaavafelka ya van a empezar de t0xicos

[@hpfanfan09]

I really like Ningning’s voice here.. so angelic ❤

[@dearannaiam]

Ningning and Wendy good collab😍 boa so good too ❤🎉

[@Natasha-26]

Get ready for Red Velvet 2023 Domination❤🧡💙💚💜

[@a.l.dvorak1841]

I don't see how the other four are capable doing justice to this song?

[@ニコベレス]

Taeyeon and Wendy very powerful and beautiful vocals

[@psumoror]

BoA has an angelic voice and her eyes is so charming.

[@izonexbae]

Wendy is crazy

[@mndkind]

ariana what are you doing here

[@izonexbae]

@@mndkind currently watching time after time reactions to see if everyone reacts like me

[@Lyf4rMusic]

One of those performances where you gotta keep your stank face ready !! I mean those insane vocal runs and riffs are bound to make one make the face :D

[@YSL_Lawrence]

Theses womens really said: Imma gonna have the best stage presence without moving, Just vocals!

[@aexiize]

Another song from sm idols no one will ever be able to cover it better than the original

[@NancyGraceville]

Needless to say this is a bona fide masterpiece. Thank you so much for reacting to this. I'm pleased you are able to make more people aware of how damn good the vocalists are within SM Entertainment.

[@jtyhsgu1164]

every collabs are such a bop

[@andydang9647]

It was NingNing who sang the Ariana note 🤭

[@jejamis4506]

ears have been blessed indeed

[@onceyoujongintheresnowaytojong]

Sm knows that kpopies hate their artist for no reason and said they have no talent so Sm came up with this winter album,,,the whole album is masterpieces

[@Basketcase6925]

Music is peace

[@annisafortunaagsty8812]

Yass thank you for ur reaction

[@mahyanabila4084]

yes I know u would like this song, btw can u please react more songs of this album? Like "jet, the cure, good to be alive, where you are, happier"

[@itskeelycc]

Hopefully you can react to Red Velvet recording behind video

[@paskaliasarinajaya6263]

Top tier vocal❤❤

[@masoandrovolana7914]

thank you

[@khentravencontez7764]

Yours by Chanyeol, Winter, Mark, and Raiden plsss

[@Kurapika26]

Ning Ning had so much potential .. Wendy is on God Level

[@oupiuopi641]

you should watch their behind the scenes!

[@Clov205]

Waiting for your reaction of exo love shot and first snow performance in smcu

[@aexiize]

If I ever will get married and then having a divorce, this is the song I will listen to first!

[@itskeelycc]

Red Velvet recording behind please 🙏

[@joerembeltran1537]

React to recording of TIME AFTER TIME

[@thomasbato9834]

Please react to Birthday recording behind

[@mahyanabila4084]

and u should react to EXO CONCERT or EXO " FIRST SNOW/LOVE SHOT " AT SMCU PALACE CONCERT

[@ondayjosephineroseo.3403]

Waiting for ur reaction to exo first snow and loveshot.❤

[@anisahhumairahh3896]

Exo love shot frist snow at smcu

[@aisyahlamura5346]

Reaction nct u baby don't stop stage video please

[@ondayjosephineroseo.3403]

Pls react to Jet

[@Moonwalkmj]

please react to JET

[@JennysainHainna]

Please react to the performance of EXO AND EXO MEMBERS in SMTOWN LIVE 2023, Thank u.

[@Fishy_flops.]

Woah head voice was Ning not wendy there's proof