NINGNING, BoA, & WENDY 'Time After Time' SMCU REACTION | I HAVE NO WORDS 😍

[@susantoarismunandar1933]

BoA with raspy voice, Ningning with angelic Disney voice, Wendy is something in the middle. They're a complete trio.

[@saskoreacts]

Can't believe SM just dropped an all-time great b-side and performance on a Christmas/winter album, this song is insane and so is the combination of singers! This could easily become my most played song of the year!

[@cklambo]

like this song more than priority

[@MindOfMando]

Same on the plays! I’ve already had it on repeat. Whoever the masterminds behind the song are need their props too. & obviously these 3 sang it incredibly

[@aedream.u]

@@MindOfMando also react to Changmin x Taeyeon x Winter "Priority" ❤

[@Password9141]

the best song in SMCU winter album, simply magical. NingNing's adlib too, everything!

[@himaliyacute6639]

NIngning really slayed even tho she was not idol long enough like them

[@BEcauseILoveYooh]

It's the way Wendy has mastered her voice and I can't wait to see ShiNing's voice mature and grow. Not that it's not fire now. Then you have BoA's sultry voice. The reason SM vocals will always be at the top is cause they know how to nurture their talent where as other companies change the way their vocalists sing.

[@nachyn]

Right, absolutely

[@chengsheung6206]

NingNing❤

[@ニコベレス]

God Vocalist Wendy OMG she is so powerful

[@jaebird411]

I’m a luvie so I always expect Wendy to sang down. But NingNing on the lows gave me goosebumps. We need this trio on a three song mini album 😭

[@sgtboruto265]

Ningning has such a contemporary voice

[@TAPANGTAPOON]

When I hear BoA ​​voice I know it's her voice. Her voice is so unique and full of emotional.

[@NancyGraceville]

Time After Time = Ballad of 2022.... I'm not a vocal fanatic by any means but this song is simply amazing from start to finish. I absolutely love it. Since BoA is on the board of SM and guides quite a few of the productions one could easily thank her for the vision she's had in orchestrating many of the vocal collabs over the decade.

[@mariaaliciaurquiagagonzale9622]

Boa te amamos 💗

[@drinksndrive112]

This is why SM are the powerhouse of vocal.... sure they do lypsinc sometimes... it's to preserve their vocal cords so why not... but when they sing it live... magical things happens...

[@ZIP2022]

All of them have a fantastic voice but BoA. Her voice is so different from other kpop artists. She has RnB vibes and is unique like you can tell easily it’s her, and sounds so classy without trying hard because she has experienced it for 22 years.

[@ashleywong6378]

I can't get enough of BoA's voice. That raspiness adds so much depth and her emotions really shine through. Some people are put off by her tone, but I'm... Definitely not one of those people!

[@Dibi-Jo]

YES!

[@Magekenric]

'Might as well be a legend already' may be the best way to describe Wendy-ssi

[@LizzieCG]

The whole song is an eargasm 😳🤌🏽 but omg I'm obsessed with that riff by BoA and how she brings a husky voice at times, like makes the mood of the song 1000% better 🔥 she really brought the experience in this type of songs And yes, like you said, i loved that each of them has their shinning moment and sound heavenly together despite having distinct voices. Easily the best track on this SMCU album. Collab of the year already

[@MindOfMando]

Amazing from all of them & YES! BoA’s voice has that huskiness to it & it’s so satisfying to listen to

[@yleseoul7578]

Best song of the album I'm afraid. The vocals and the emotion 🔥 Miss BoA that dress, and that vocal run? So sexy of her

[@christopherh2694]

nah Priority is THAT song

[@fara2022]

@@christopherh2694 respect others opinion tho

[@sgtboruto265]

Ningning has found her comfortable spot now!

[@CristhianDeCastro]

The 3 combined reproduced the Red Velvet Quality: Wendy deep round tone + BoA's raspy/warm tone (equivalent to Irene's/Seulgi tone) + Ningning middle air bright tone (equivalent to Joy / Yeri). That's why they sound so good together.

[@Lyf4rMusic]

One of those iconic Vocal flex performances that is gonna be talked about for years !!

[@Lunafreya_Nox]

And KNETS left the group.. lmao. ..Imagined KNETS debating whether Idols should sing live or not??

[@mbismbismb]

BoA voice is so distinct… u know its BoA’s right away!

[@dianahaokip5665]

Gawddddd. I love your reaction soooooo muchhhhhh. .... Exactly how I reacted❤❤❤❤

[@rowellsg]

Lol I enjoyed your reaction! BoA fighting❤

[@jnvrflrs]

Ning Ning has Potential.. Wendy is Godly

[@mintyell4225]

My fav song SMCU 2022, that's insane!!!

[@dubu-tofu8989]

Best reaction ❤

[@amairadey6258]

NingNing deserves her own album tho.

[@lymlyn6732]

i really need the english version of this song

[@纯凉]

年度好歌啊

[@mariaaliciaurquiagagonzale9622]

Yes

[@christopherh2694]

SM just hit different

[@wallaceavila6560]

this was hands down my favorite song on that album, they murdered it, they could totally be a fixed unit!!!💖💖

[@อดิศาขุมทอง-ฬ4ซ]

I love your this reaction. lol 5555 😍😂

[@Hgoenge81]

Yeah, this track truly slaps. I love that old 50's doo wop feel

[@esmeraldarose9398]

ae1 need to come now!! I can’t wait anymore 😭😭😭

[@sieghart7514]

best reaction channel MY GIRLS related. period. 🖤

[@cjvariant]

new-found reactor that is in love with SM artists specifically aespa? SIGN ME UUUPPP

[@johanaveliz4261]

Maravillosas 👏👏👏👏🥰

[@qneonic690]

I really hope you would react to the entire album

[@christopherh2694]

Bro Priority is SOTY

[@enzi022]

Man, imagine a trio of duets between Taeyeon, BoA, Wendy, would break Korea and the world.

[@AStone-ov8wz]

We had Ningning, BoA and Wendy. No need for a different combo.

[@heather9014]

let’s not bring Taeyeon in every single song.. Ningning, BoA, and Wendy is more than enough for singing this song yk

[@mbismbismb]

No taeyeon no… just no

[@gabyreveluv]

we dont need taeyeon if we have wendy hunny

[@mfallplants955]

Ouuhhhh you must do the Priority too broo 🔥🔥🔥

[@json2201]

priority is soo good

[@mfallplants955]

@@json2201 yess .... idk why but there is something magical about that song

[@stups9975]

Can you say vocal flex….

[@이상훈-f2t]

🤣

[@mox1118]

please react also to priority..it so good..i love their voice..

[@mndkind]

WHERE DID U GET UR HAT???/

[@amargurung9091]

I hope you will react to STAYC - summertime and the latest video that they posted today, if possible 🥺 Its really good

[@danissegomez7953]

Notice in the first two verses, in the beginning of the song they gave the low notes on Ning, she excels so much and her tone is so good and techniques on lower registers. She reminds me of Taeyeon. Wendy and Boa is good but their lows are not as good as Ning and Taeyeon. They excel on highnotes but heck even Ningning can do those highnotes, Taeyeon too. I am just saying Ningning will be a beast of a singer when she grows up, she is still young her voice will mature more and her range just keeps on increading and the fact her low registers are already perfection. SM and aespa is lucky to have her, now I know why SM did not let go of her and the sole survivor of SMrookies. From day 1, SM knew she will be a part of the new group

[@vanyvan9951]

bet you've only heard Wendy's few low notes. Ningning is good but she is nowhere near Wendy's level yet.

[@vanyvan9951]

and just to add, she won't be considered as the female idol who has the widest range in kpop for nothing.

[@marie_nicolas]

Ningning being a beast of a singer is still yet to be proven while Wendy and especially BoA already have years to prove their worth, in 4th gen a lot of groups have a power vocalist you need to hope and pray NingNing will stay in the game and won't be buried by better vocalists so you could actually see for yourself if she'll really be at the top and a beast of a singer at the end just like what BoA and Wendy is in their generation.

[@thacellogirl]

I agree 100% with this, Ningning is so young and masters her voice already, she sings effortlessly and more than anything is so clear tone! Is insane! She will keep maturing and her voice will change little by little into this reach beautiful voice like aghhhh can't wait!!

[@fishheadnoodle]

lol yes Ningning can do the high notes but they just sound so sharp all the time.. sometimes i just feel uncomfortable listening to her high notes.

[@blessmeachoomarkmadcity9586]

SM Ladies FTW!! 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼 Can I recommend a COLLAB song? I would really appreciate it if u can react to BAEKHYUN & SEO MUN TAK : HURT. Please~ U will not be disappointed I promise.

[@leonardomendes7078]

REACT TO PRIORITY - TAEYEON, WINTER, CHANGMIN. PLEASEEE

[@bywvinter]

Can u react to priority by changmin, taeyeon, and winter

[@leonelbasangan5206]

Please react to Jet, sadly, there's no dance performance to it but it's a BOP 🔥

[@enisawahdania7652]

Please reaction to Taeyon, Changmin, Winter - Priority

[@alejandrochairez5134]

Mando i have a suggestion for you, you should check out Arin x Choi x Yuqi x yena x Chuu step cover from the mbc music festival

[@danissegomez7953]

its a good thing Taeyeon is not here. cuz if she is, I think it will be the death of me and their voices is the reason i will ascend to heaven haha

[@yleseoul7578]

Yeah, I'm glad she is not too, cu the energy would have dropped 😳 so thankful