Bob Dylan - I Can’t Leave Her Behind (unreleased, remastered 2022)

[@ninapross3337]

Enjoying this sound like the sounds I'm liking now you're presently making

[@davidmoore2325]

Hello dear,how are you doing?

[@philbabb6460]

@@davidmoore2325 great thanks

[@johndoyle486]

To all those who go down the cliched road of saying "Dylan can't sing" - Utter garbage, his voice is beautiful here, amongst many other examples of how great an actual singer he is.

[@ManWithAName425]

Musicians in studios these days go to great effort (i.e. autotune) in order to make the melody unblemished while their musical framework and ideas are garbage. Dylan, I feel, was just not primarily focused on articulating vocal melody because the songs were so complete lyrically and structurally that maybe sounding like a melodic angel was just boring to him. The "Dylan can't sing" argument I hear a lot from friends. It's not just saying "Dylan can't sing", but it implies the guy is overrated and not a quality musician. It's kind of like saying Van Gogh's brush strokes were too broad and not adequately articulate, therefore he sucks. I agree with you John, this clip is an informative glimpse that disproves that myth.

[@leonardkrasner5811]

@@ManWithAName425 No one can sing a Dylan song like Dylan himself, he articulates his lyrics exactly the they are meant!

[@kenbellchambers4577]

Tell the scoffers to listen to 'Corrina Corrina'.

[@Ivan-ze7oz]

To all those who think that Dylan can’t sing, I recommend to listen to “one more cup of coffee”

[@donnajean6663]

@@leonardkrasner5811 Dylan is one of a kind. There will never be another like Dylen

[@PeterDaltrey]

Bob -- never afraid to sing with whatever voice comes out of his mouth. He always surprises and delights us. Please, please, please don`t go anywhere, Bob... Life could never ever be the same without you in our world.

[@janetbeebe6578]

Amen

[@franceshemery5095]

That is a frightening thought.

[@marilenemarques9205]

Bob Dylan ....Bob Dylan como amo

[@danyleforestier]

for shure

[@delriddell]

please don't ever leave❤

[@JollyJordy]

It’s so dang pretty. And somehow the fact that it’s an unfinished idea that was never fully fleshed out makes it more beautiful and mysterious.

[@wendyanne5894]

He said he couldn't. But he did. End of story.

[@jcoltrane8976]

Something tells me her behind is fleshed out.

[@SuperBlackguard]

So true, and these songs still float around just out of earshot if we hear them

[@hazard3020]

it was finished. he just could couldn't say it because he LOVED her. And she loved him. And HE left her like the weazel he was x

[@robinhaar7738]

Agree completely that the early musings for this song make it that much more magnetic and magical for me... so special to have these gems of his musical "doodles"

[@MartyBellvue]

This could have been a hit. Not just a hit, this could have been a standard. He writes standards in his sleep. he writes standards when he's not looking!!!

[@evergreennugz477]

Yes I'm always touched by thus song 🎵 😪

[@neilpepper3575]

Not anymore he does..his words..

[@terribleTed-ln6cm]

He is the standard....

[@Janna52]

L.O.L.

[@maryellendavis8114]

70 TIMES AROUND THE SUN THE OLD STUFF STILL MAKES ME CRY LOVE YOU MR DYLAN

[@wendyanne5894]

Me too. In 3 days I'll be 71 X's around the Sun.

[@jameshopkins71]

Only Dylan could do something like that song, beautiful, there will never be anyone like him.

[@briseboy]

There can Never be ANYONE like anyone ELSE. It's basic genetics and epigenetics. Try not to be a gushing submissive to others.

[@alexanderdupuis]

Jakob Dylan gave an interview to Rolling Stone magazine in 1997 when Time out of Mind came out. The interviewer avoided discussing Jakob's famous dad through most of the interview, but at the end he brought up "This new kid, Bob Dylan, who has a new album, Time out of Mind...what's your take on him?" "His future's bright," Jakob said.

[@ts-eu6mp]

Yep, he is his own man, a fine musician-and- his Father's son. Also, thank you Mom for your contribution. Mainly, thank you, Jakob! Terri S.

[@francisbeaton2832]

As most of the other comments express this is indeed an unreleased gem. This is the first time i have heard this song and i have been a Bob fanatic for 30 plus years. What makes it a bit extra special for me is that it was played in my home city of Glasgow 8 years to the day before i was born. I seen Bob on Halloween night last year in Glasgow and he is 81 now and still touring the world and allowing us to bask in his magic. That Glasgow performance was 54 years ago!!!!! I'm saving up just now to be able to follow him on the last 6 months of the RARW tour because he is in his twighlight years now and i want to see as much of him as possible before he leaves us; a day i am dreading. There has been nobody else in my life whom i have not known personally who means so much to me. He means more than some of the people i have known all my life. The world will be a poorer place for the loss. I know you guys all feel the same. We have been lucky to be around at the same time as this man. God bless x

[@marilenemarques9205]

Incrível suas palavras. Amo tanto Bob Dylan Como é bom ouvir lo e saber que estamos juntos aqui. Essa voz é incrível doce e me faz ama lo.

[@Rosemary-u5z3y]

His harmonica is mystical and magical. A meaningful song is like medicine for the body ,mind and soul. Good meaningful songs are like light in the world, they are meant to sing out loud individually or collectively; that can clear away all our negative thoughts and emotions in our disturbed mind. Happy listening, singing and sharing with other. God bless you. Dylan understands the formula of peace - Prince/ ambassador of Peace. Have you heard them ? 1. Do you Hear what I hear? ( Christmas in the Heart) .Listen to what I say. Pray for peace people everywhere... 2. Ring Them Bells Sarah Jarosz - Ring Them Bells (Transatlantic sessions) @Marco Regali ...Oh, the shepherd is asleep where the willows weep. And the mountains are filled with lost sheep.... Ring the bell for the blind and deaf....

[@sharoneavenson3142]

One of the most endearing songs from the early work of Bob Dylan. Even in it’s unfinished state it resonates with the tender feelings found from a spring romance. 💐🎸🎶🥰💞🦋

[@davidmoore2325]

Hello dear,how are you doing?

[@danyleforestier]

That is Bob

[@Sumotori.]

Beautifully written and sung. Thanks for sharing 👍🌟🌟🌟👍

[@shannonmurphy1995]

This song is so beautiful! I have never heard this song!

[@Sammybizness]

When love sings it stops time.

[@skipbuzz-me2564]

It really does

[@theresahealy6176]

Very sweet, tender and clearly heartfelt.❤️

[@rb6338]

Absolutely marvelous ! A gem!

[@sneakydeaky8445]

Great reconstruction. I've had several versions of this recording from bootlegs and this is the first time I've heard the bridge. Many thanks

[@spaceengineer1452]

"U got a bridge for me ?...."

[@rochellecaffee1417]

There is nothing more beautiful than you being you and allowing God to breathe His life in you to share yourself with others, in truth and love. There is no higher calling for anyone….❤

[@janetwebb7076]

So Tender & Overflowing with a Heart full of Tenderness , empathy & missing..brings Tears to ones eyes. Beautiful heartfelt & Tender song by a young man with same characteristics. God bless & Keep Bob Always, please.💟🌹🤟✌️🤣

[@tetesabaker5436]

Beautiful man and song . You are never alone . No matter what . Who loves ya .

[@denisedunbar1829]

So beautiful. Great job on the remix.

[@bennyhillschineseblokechar3689]

Skyscrapers touched by clouds without permission. Skyscrapers once gazed upon by Telly Savalas.

[@Anthony-hu3rj]

I'll put in a plug for Robbie Robertson on the dominant guitar. It matches the beauty of Dylan's voice perfectly.

[@floweromber]

What can be said that isn't already felt..❤

[@mikeweir3680]

Mr. Zimmerman, such an extraordinary song form your two conscience minds, so very heartfelt and "amazing emotional music". I/we wish for you all the pleasent intimate moments that you have written and compiled over a life, for them to come true in your everyday life that just happens when (life) is just happening Man, thanks bob, for all the people that you have made to think how wonderful a time it is to be alive...Cheerz Bud!

[@haroldgann7869]

Its hard to understand how much Dylans music has had on me since the first time I heard Like A Rolling Stone as it came flowing from the radio in 65. Some always say it was the Beatles that put a guitar in their hands, for me it was just as much Dylan too. My wife and I went to see him playing in Indy in 1988. When we got back home to our little town of Fairmount Indiana Dylan was there in a coachliner with family and friends to visit the hometown of James Dean. It was good to meet the man I have so admired. l

[@briseboy]

If a beatle put a guitar in your hands - SELL it, and be rich. If Francisco Tarrega put a guitar in your hands, and you worked at it, play.

[@nateb335]

The GENIUS at work on his craftsmanship

[@patriciaamato4263]

Bob at his most tender and vulnerable. Video of this is fantastic.

[@keithcyr9535]

Damn, I’ve been wondering about this song for decades. The only part I’ve ever heard or seen. Is the final scene in Eat the Document. He and Robbie are playing a bit of it. This is fabulous. Thank you for posting.

[@Stein56Roise]

What a MASTERPIECE

[@jeann-louismaillard9870]

Encore une petite perle des années de jeunesse de Bob Dylan qui enchante ma vie depuis plus de 50 ans .

[@sylvemason6509]

Absolutely Love This Timeless Love Song So Adorable 🌸🧡🧡🌸

[@hazard3020]

Thanks for removing the noise. For Her. Silver Dreams Always x

[@jeffmcrae795]

Holy smokes. That's gorgeous.

[@Littleduck192]

Such a lovely song

[@ninapross3337]

Great Shot! I'll never forget it!

[@davidmoore2325]

Hello dear,how are you doing?

[@positivevibe8426]

Where she leads me i do not know Well she leads me where she go I can't find her nowhere. Well she needs me here All aware i just can't hear her walk I just can't hear her talk Though sometimes you know you will. And when she comes my way I'll just be there standin' any night and day I will hear her say that i don't really try I tried, also cried But i cant leave her behind. (then replay of "verses" 2 and 3) North British Station hotel, Glasgow UK - 19.may.1966 SWINGIN' PIG restaured audio version (youtube june 16, 2021) ... and i just can't wait for you i can't just ... i ... my discontent And i walk, where she leads me i do not know Well she leads me where she goes I can't find it no way Whenever she comes by It makes me hurt to see her cry ... I just can't ride But i can't say some ... But i can't leave with her behind. Like you might think it's foolish to be ... this way that i can't say to her And you might think it's ugly To go back and not to ride/rally But i can't hide, you don't know what it does to me Well, she needs me how All her way i just can't hear her walk I just can't hear her talk But sometimes you know you will. And when she comes my way I'll just be there stayin' any night or day I will fear her say to you that i don't really try I tried, also cried But i can't leave her behind. ... Any time that i'm on my way I just talk to hear me stay ... pretend to mind here too What else i should have found If i don't make it and you do I swear to you that if you don't cry Try to ride besides ... it took behind. But she hear you walk back when i was young ... you anything but i ... say not she's the one And she's still gone And when i hear from you more than i heard from anyone All my herd ? ... I just rode I swear i trade to you This whole wide world is your own ... But i can't help you but i try to tell to you That i just can't ... leave her behind.  Lyrics as performed by Stephen Malkmus and Lee Ranaldo on "I'm Not There" soundtrack Where she leads me i do not know Well, she leads me where she go I can't find her nowhere Well, she needs me here All aware i can't hear her walk I just cannot hear her talk Though sometimes, you know you will And when she comes my way I'll just be left any night or day I will hear her say that i don't wanna try I tried, also cried But i can't leave her behind.

[@小蜜蜂-l5t]

thank you

[@liambrammall1764]

it's like the pre-heartbreak and ensuing bitterness still in love with her 'just like a woman'

[@RobieRose52441]

Tears in my eyes heart breaking love mi Corazon. ❤

[@sethkaicer319]

Bob Dylan never leaves anyone behind

[@littlezimgirl]

What a voice like seriously who else can sound like that?! Uniqueness all the way... This song is very beautiful, thank you for sharing. I'm thinking the man has experienced a lifetime of heartache from a young age...you are not alone. Soothing to say the least. I would love to sing this song, someday. Who was that who said "bridge"?? I wonder how old he was here...

[@whitleyrobinson244]

That’s Robbie Robertson of the band (Dylan’s touring band and collaborators on the basement tapes) who says “do the bridge”

[@littlezimgirl]

@@whitleyrobinson244 thank you for that! Thats awesome! 🙃

[@michele-33]

@MT, your username seems familiar. I might have replied to you before - on a vid of Bob's of course! Youtu.be/ Ioxkm6Ld-K8 There's a longer version but I don't have time to find it atm. It was also included in a Dylan documentary but can't recall the name. What did you think?😎

[@littlezimgirl]

@@michele-33 I would guess that you're prolly spot on there, I comment sometimes... Not sure if that's a good link...

[@janepiepes2243]

I wonder who said bridge, also.

[@allanmogensen2122]

After he sings "i cant leave her behind"comes 1bar and then the same 4break notes as in "let it be"by the Beatles.Only Bob seem to be first in 1966.

[@ivegotpetercriss]

You mean descending from the fourth down to the root in a major scale? The Beatles and Bob has certainly done a lot of groundbreaking things, but I don't think either can claim first for that.

[@ts-eu6mp]

GREAT of you to do this. Even greater of him, natch-you agree, I can see/hear/know. Coulda been another contender--song, that is, obviously. Terri S.

[@sallyvernon9579]

I don't think it could get any better.

[@TheMidnightModder]

His singing is beautiful in this song! I much prefer this style over what he's known for.

[@jarikuukasjarvi7824]

Just great

[@StephenS-2024]

Wow! Bob Dylan you say? Yeah, kid sounds good. Any other songs? 😏

[@whitleyrobinson244]

On the way brother 🤝

[@gloriahopkins359]

Magical....

[@rossheathorn121]

I will miss cherry forever. Sorry I was so funked up that's how it is. I hope one day she realises how much I had to say to her. She wouldn't believe me the type of people I know. I thank god for knowing her x

[@michaelmcloughlin8237]

Mpchael McLoughlin Bob Dylan never fails to amaze me,he's been doing it over 50 yrs.

[@alltogetherfitandproper4252]

60, man. 60.

[@viviandarkbloom100]

Wonder how many of these "half finished" songs Bob has written? Or like Love is a Four Letter Word just tossed aside.

[@Bluesagebrush22]

Yes ..another beautiful one is To Fall in Love With You

[@maxtalley6710]

What a timeless classic from the period when he was so prolific he basically hrew away gems like this. With that incredible delicate descending pre-chorus chord progression. A minute of this song (different version) was in the Scorsese documentary No Direction Home, with Robbie Robertson. And Robbie is speaking in the background of this version, reminding Dylan of the bridge.

[@RobbieSmith-x4h]

The Master at work❤

[@ninapross3337]

Leaning on your piano that night singing only to me you looked exactly how you looked now Exactly

[@wendyanne5894]

Nice try Nina

[@longasaya]

In yer dreams kid.

[@debragordon-hellman3779]

Nothing wrong with dreaming and fantasizing...Go Nina!

[@guinnesstrail6799]

Coincidentally, it’s what I tell my wife when I see her walking away.

[@johntyberg3796]

I'd say this is an early version of "You're a Big Girl Now"

[@learningsevenresearchgoals1127]

When I first saw ETD 20 years ago now on a VHS tape lol, I was totally transfixed on the sideline singing clips they did, this "song" most importantly. I always wished they did a full version on one of the albums, seems it would have been a better album ender than sad eyed lady, a song I never really cared for. I honestly think the melody they are working with here shows influence of Beatles songs and that makes a lot of sense given the time and place.

[@rochellecaffee1417]

Kindred spirits forever…❤😊

[@charlottehuang1207]

Thanks

[@markpattison127]

I've just started making play lists and this is the first entry on the one I call my "real folk" list. He was the perfect conduit for musical energy.

[@HarryGuit]

That „remastering guy“ must have been quite a guitar fan. The voice is so much in the background …. it seems to be accompanying the guitar.

[@whitleyrobinson244]

i did my best bro its not a high quality recording, and two guitars are playing

[@olivier3847]

@@whitleyrobinson244 love the guitars

[@damonarvid3548]

The predecessor to "You're a Big Girl Now."

[@janepiepes2243]

Yeah. Nina below me ... She's right ... It's like it, 's happening right now. This is in G ... Yeah,,, but you're all the way on the fret board .. what 12 half steps ,, yeah .. Janey

[@earllsimmins9373]

Epic quartet: Dylan,Waites Stewart and Crocker would make dogs howl for miles.

[@kathleenfitzgerald50]

I had some bootleg cassette tapes 25 years ago .. One track I haven’t been able to find again is “ Angel Flying to close to the ground.. any ideas.. oh and Thank you so very much 🙂✨

[@kathleenfitzgerald50]

Since getting into recovery from Alcoholism ✨

[@hilahennahum2849]

שלמות מופתית 💕⚓🐚

[@simonerusso6920]

Aw gental is this song

[@paulbrinkman952]

Unleash AI to help "lift up" this absolute gem.

[@sharyllee7094]

I feel him, here...

[@hilahennahum2849]

אני אוהבת איך שאתה מפרק לי את הלב

[@sharonegri]

💙

[@helenbostock2350]

Go and see the gypsy then he come back then think what I do walk away yes sorry can't give you love you want

[@bennyhillschineseblokechar3689]

Went to see the gypsy. Gypsy 's horse likes carrots. Gypsy's horse name of Achilles. Lucky heather cost me a fiver.

[@mariadaconceicaofigueira8816]

Lindo.

[@ChelseaRideout]

✨💛

[@ninapross3337]

Exactly how you looked leanin on g

[@wendyanne5894]

Now you're becoming bothersome.

[@marakaretsos5204]

⭐️⭐️⭐️

[@hilahennahum2849]

דילן עושה אהבה עם הבל פיו ! פשוט יצירת מופת

[@freebootercinema9157]

"Title reminds me of an old joke me mateys always larfed at, all aboot a young Greek boy who - after turnin' 18 years - refused to leave home because he didna wanna 'leave his brother's behind.' Arrrrr!"

[@briseboy]

The spider who couldn't keep his hands off his mate's flies. Or how hard it is to separate the men from the boys in San Francisco.

[@cinders1413]

Does anyone know all the lyrics ?

[@jillfryer6699]

Eyolf Ostrom if anyone, that is my bet! !!! If not now they will come. And the music tabs too

[@helenbostock2350]

Enjoy me life. Don't worry about her she not going to cry. I don't mind you leaving me alone because you where never mind to being with. I never behind you anyway. Lol

[@davidmoore2325]

Hello dear,how are you doing?

[@jameskennedy721]

Some of the same musical ideas you hear in ONE MORE CUP OF COFFEE . Bob sure played more complex guitar in those days .

[@andrewdavison3293]

It's Robbie on the guitar lead.

[@barbarapowell137]

Great

[@davidmoore2325]

Hello dear,how are you doing?

[@ericddenison4016]

Where she leads me I do not know Well, she leads me where she goes I can't find her nowhere Well, she needs me here All aware I can't hear her walk I just cannot hear her talk Though sometimes, you know you will And when she comes my way I'll just be left any night or day I will hear her say That I don't wanna try I tried, also cried But I can't leave her behind

[@wendyanne5894]

Beautiful words he wrote. For ????

[@kilaniraouf3032]

Chanson de ma jeunesse, Bob dylan extraordinaire. Nous avons vieilli ensemble.👍

[@evergreennugz477]

Yes this song is very touching and that's beautiful way to look at getting older ❤️

[@rochellecaffee1417]

❤

[@maritaulmanen8793]

Kiitos

[@philbabb6460]

ol Bullet Dodgin' Bob

[@juancruzpereyra8994]

Temón

[@tonyrobles2696]

💓💓💓💓

[@照夫西田]

ディランって根本が一緒で、ずっと変わってないんやなぁ~~と・・改めて思ぅた・・(?_?)

[@謝育霖-f8f]

Some like Lennons'blue

[@ruthpaul7572]

What a great voice So beautiful

[@rrCHRISxx]

Any others?

[@maritaulmanen8793]

Sanat koskettaa

[@RobieRose52441]

💔💔💔🐈‍⬛💔💔💔

[@helenbostock2350]

😍

[@davidmoore2325]

Hello dear,how are you doing?

[@lionstandingII]

Can't even understand the words and it moves one to weep...

[@philwinchester6465]

What year would you say that Dylan song is from ?

[@whitleyrobinson244]

1966

[@brianbiechele1958]

When is this???

[@michaelmiller2397]

where? when?

[@grunntalll]

didnt know this long version existed... or is this edited together?

[@greshami]

Same. What is the origin of this long version? I've only heard the fragments before?

[@helenbostock2350]

I heard beauty not truth

[@davidmoore2325]

Hello dear,how are you doing?

[@briseboy]

Then you missed Keats & the Greek Urn.

[@laneykane8062]

Joan

[@Tahhan00]

Is this song on Spotify?

[@patriciaamato4263]

Your tube.

[@viviandarkbloom100]

doubtful...not really a completed song

[@Tahhan00]

@@viviandarkbloom100 ok thanks

[@bonscottrocks1728]

This guy's almost as good as Post Malone

[@guillermokersh7270]

he's getting there lmao

[@timbrittain]

You having s laugh

[@Nick-Emery]

This sounds like something Pete Doherty would sing