Bonnie’s ACTUAL Killer FOUND: RUIN’s Biggest Mystery Solved, Lore Reveal Theory

[@InternetInferno]

BlackRoseSwagz (on DeviantArt)- bonnie/killer models

[@hashirww]

im not saying your theory is wrong, (it's actually quite reasonable), but the thing is that there is a secret cut out of a concerned bonnie in the monty golf gondola ride, falling of the tornado (with the decapitated freddy statue). so if you don't mind, i would like to ask a question of why that is there

[@StrikeCrossoverNexus]

so do we have anything on foxy? Roxanne definately replaced him because the roxy raceway used to be a foxy ride so where did foxy go?

[@goteamslugs]

@@StrikeCrossoverNexus I think Foxy was the original Daycare attendant.

[@hashirww]

@@StrikeCrossoverNexus foxy was originally the daycare attendant. in the posters of "kid's cove" in the original security breach game, we can see foxy's lighthouse and the exact daycare play structures we see in the daycare, which has led a lot of people to believe that foxy was the original daycare attendant, and sun/moon were actually in the fazbear theatre, hence the reason we find masks of comedy and tragedy that match sun and moon, and if you think about it, comedy and tragedy is actually what you would see in the fazbear theatre

[@Dahman-qc6cd]

I have a theory that Bonnie saw Vanessa hiding the princes quest game in her hideout and decided to play it and that’s why she killed him

[@mad_quack]

I always thought Monty being the culprit was just way too easy of a mystery. And what if he’s always angry because of Bonnie’s disappearance? I’d be angry too if my best friend went missing and I got blamed for it.

[@avery5920]

idk man looking at your profile you seem a little biased

[@Mutucaroxa]

@@avery5920 Well what he said makes quite a lot of sense, sure, he might be a BIT biased but it makes sense

[@goteamslugs]

How truly sad . .

[@zeus6324]

I don't think Monty killer bonnie

[@Fredcat11]

Either that, or the virus got the better of him. See that Roxanne's still herself and Chica became unstable structured girl.

[@a_balloon]

Honestly I do agree with this and prefer this theory over "Monty being jealous and destroying him because it makes total sense". But man do I wish we'd seen more of Vanny, she was obviously much more influential in SB than we thought yet appeared twice

[@windego64]

Do you know that feeling when it's too obvious? When there's too much evidence pointing at something? Like the "murderer" on the train is the one who have all fingers pointing at them? Yeah that one

[@santiagoarrieta2175]

I think they created Monty for the sole propource of replace the broken anymatronic, likely the prototype present several issues that make more viable make a whole new animatronic, maybe something was off in his programation.

[@santiagoarrieta2175]

Well I think Vanni is more influential in this game than it look. It's likely Mxes don't have a real appearece, and the Vanni's mask simply generate and asigned his Bunny apearence and all of the thing related to him.

[@Rajd_is]

Since when it made any sense? Jealousy of popularity? No, SB notes says he skipped some shows because of his stage fright Aggressivness? No, notes says that he became agressive after getting claws And yes, both these notes and Monty ride confirm that before deccomission of Bonnie there was regular Monty and his stage.

[@IggyIsOuttaHere]

Tbh, I agree as FNaF SB js ends so quickly with nothing rlly revealing but with 2 endings.

[@JinxeBlaq]

I really wish they gave Monty a more visible heart in the story. He was kinda just a wild animal the entire time, it’s kinda disappointing.

[@distinguishedallureproduct879]

I agree I would of love for Cassie to "fix" the Animatronics, and show that they don't want to hurt children it's just a bad virus. When I saw you can get Chica Voice box, I thought Cassie would be the one to "restore" them

[@Redbunnydude]

FINALLY SOMEONE WHO IS Actually SMART

[@ray2dasherthedragon336]

Im so happy someones mentioned this. It came to my head yesterday that monty has became just become an animal and doesn't even a human like personality anymore. Like fair enough I think he spoke less then the othere in the game (maybe) but when he looses his legs he just stops talking. In ruin hes becomes even more of an animal then he was as shattered monty

[@Rajd_is]

He lost his legs, returned to the surface. Of course he wildened! But yeah it is kinda sad

[@xyreniaofcthrayn1195]

makes sense for monty to go ham, first his programming is full of errors thanks to vanny and then the constant pain or the animatronic version of pain: report to maintenance directive that just pop's up and errors away every two seconds.

[@Victor-056]

Also, the "green hue" is something that can occur when Fiberglass gets scratched up and muddied with dirt, which can distort the pigments in the material, and in some cases, can result in Purple or magneta "Paint" getting discolored to look like there is a green tint. This is notable when looking at the aftermath of Car Accidents, mainly on cars that use Fiberglass parts. Even if Vanny didn't spraypaint Bonnie's body, the greenish discoloration of the Fiberglass would be considered by Vanny to be a Lucky coincidence. Adding to that, Monty's Claws (The part of his hands that would actually cause the damage) after his "Upgrade" were Purple tipped, which sets off alarm bells to see a Green Tint that looks like Wet Paint rather than paint scrapings (Paint coming off and sticking to something else, would come off in streaks, rather than a big patch.), and that is not even considering that we don't see any sign of Deep Purple marks on Bonnie.

[@DavinFaulkner]

Monty might not even hate Freddy, actually. All of our "evidence" amounts to conveniently placed shadows and some details in an arcade game Monty obviously didn't make himself. Reading their body language in the intro cutscene, the two actually seem to be partners more than anything else, playing off each other instead of one trying to outshine the other. Not to mention... Freddy being replaced by Monty in the Van ending was ultimately an executive decision. It's even implied albeit not confirmed that Monty is the most popular/beloved Glamrock in the game's universe (definitely not real life sadly). These incidents could instead show that Fazbear Entertainment knows they have something special with Monty to the point of being willing to abandon the character they are literally named after in the name of profit. They have secretly been planting little... things around to subconsciously shift customers' attention off of Freddy... so no one will complain if he mysteriously goes missing and needs a replacement.

[@DavinFaulkner]

This could also explain why bonnie was in that tornado. Fazbear entertainment has always been about "out with the old, in with the new", unless there's profit to be made from nostalgia-pandering. They had to have made that cutout for it to be there. This was just another way they said goodbye to an animatronic... gone with the wind in a way that almost no one notices.

[@nathangamble125]

Fazbear entertainment is definitely pushing the promotion of Monty. Why else would the pizza-flavoured drink be called "Monty Mystery Mix"?

[@anthonyloveschickens]

THANK YOU! People act like Monty runs the pizzaplex 😭

[@ZaZi-Zeta01]

I love how Markiplier's mem-defense for Monty seems a lot more plausible now

[@ryuknight5236]

Would you mind telling me what his meme-defense for him is, or at least a title for a video Markiplier mentions it?

[@ZaZi-Zeta01]

@@ryuknight5236 It's in the currently most-recent release on Mark's end - FNaF Ruin Part 6, right at the very end. He pretends to be livestreaming with Dawko about finding Bonnie and delivers a "theory" on how Monty just happened to stumble across the corpse and place the four Wet Floor signs to mark of the danger of the slippery floor, of how Bonnie killed himself by flinging the bowling ball so hard into the wall and the ball ricocheting and killing him in a sudden explosion. His concludes with saying that Monty is actually a hero and a saint for increasing the safety of Fazbear Entertainment.

[@ryuknight5236]

@@ZaZi-Zeta01 Lol thanks for that. I forget how unhinged Mark can be.

[@Furyisdead46]

​@@ZaZi-Zeta01 Lmao

[@hoohaa549]

​@@ZaZi-Zeta01The way you explained makes it sound so serious it made me almost choke, despite already knowing the context lol

[@aedaniammx7559]

To be honest I always thought that, whoever actually dealt the killing blow, Vanny was the one that programmed whoever it was to kill Bonnie. Even back when it seemed irrefutable that Monty had done it, I never thought that he did it of his own will, and of course the DLC seems to show that he actually *idolizes* Bonnie if anything, so I think that the only motives here are Vanny’s, and even if Monty technically destroyed Bonnie then he was nothing more than a tool for her

[@Victor-056]

WeakFreak Pointed out something we have missed out... And that was the fact that Bonnie's Greenroom is loaded with destroyed STAFF Bots. It would explain the Chest Wound on Bonnie, as they likely managed to grab him and start tearing into his chest, only for Bonnie to fight back and get the upper hand over the STAFF Bots... So Vanny smashed a Bowling Ball over Bonnie's head, which finished him off.

[@Katsuraage]

THIS is exactly what I was frustrated when trying to get out into words! Especially after seeing how everyone was interpreting the scene like Dawko. Our boy Monty is INNOCENT! (In this specific case) The only thing I want to see if I can get a discussion on is the thought that Bonnie had passed the role of Bass Guitarist to Monty at some point beforehand, not afterwards. As a member of the band he would have had his own dressing room like the others in the same spot as Monty's current dressing room, but his dressing room is hidden away behind Bonnie Bowl instead of shown off like the others. He has his own stage, sure, but to me it seems a little bit off. Realistically though, the main piece of evidence that shows me that he was no longer a main member of the band is the fact that the bass players need special claws. Bonnie has a set of fully replaced hands that have no claws and the crime scene is likely quickly sealed up after the deed was done. So if Vanny took the claws and then gave them to Monty while Bonnie was mysteriously missing, then why go back and replace them with a normal set of hands? This does open up the fact that Monty having the claws would make him again a suspect, but wouldn't that mean that Monty had even less of an alibi and would be easier to frame if he already had the claws? As a miniature side-theory, there is evidence in Security Breach, maybe just from Freddy's first few lines, that the band members only started to act up in their super aggressive way they act towards Gregory very recently. Like that very night recently, or when Vanessa started working at the Pizzaplex. Maybe Bonnie was resistant to Vanny's programming and needed to be eliminated. If Cassie's father turns out to be a mechanic of the Pizzaplex that helped design the animatronics, Bonnie being his favorite, we could tie it in somehow to MXES as well, being a security protocol made in the image of a blue rabbit. Food for thought!

[@flainnite25]

Underrated comment! I also thought about the Monty theory, I know it could be a possibility but it's just so easy to put the blame on Monty just because he replaced Bonnie. I'm this video exists as well as your comment because it could help anyone know that Monty could be innocent. Btw, I also love your mini side-theory~!

[@artypawsstudio8129]

This actually makes a ton of sense and I think it ties up the missing Bonnie case very nicely. It also explains why Monty and Freddy have such a bad relationship and why Monty is so aggressive as well. Considering the behavioral patterns of the Glamrock animatronics being similar to young children, shown in the books, as well as incredibly atonomus, it makes sense for this version of the story to explain their feelings towards each other. Stick with me, it's story time. (Note: This is just my new HEADCANON though! I'm not sure if it'll totally make sense with the actual canon.) Monty did admire Bonnie, but that made Freddy jelous. We already know how much Freddy loves Bonnie as a friend, maybe that childish part of him was a little annoyed that Monty wanted to be best friends with his already best friend. Freddy starts acting bitter towards Monty and Monty responds accordingly. They don't like each other, but it's fine since they can mind their own. When Monty gets framed, trying to explain he didn't do it just makes him look like a liar and Freddy only dislikes him even more. The animatronics are never informed of what really happened to Bonnie since knowing might make them act up. (Like how Freddy wasn't allowed to see the room of endos.) Now Monty is chosen to fill in for Bonnie and given his part, his glasses, and his guitar. Freddy hates this and doesnt think Monty deserves this, he's envious that the annoying gator that tried to steal his best friend now gets to have their part as well. Monty is not Bonnie. Freddy doesn't want to accept Monty because he feels like he's just being replaced. He continues to have a bad attitide towards Monty. Despite his sweet, chill personality from before, Monty starts getting sick of Freddy's attitude. Even before the incident, he'd always gotten the side eye and a bitter taste from Freddy. It only angers him more now that Freddy refuses to belive that he didn't hurt Bonnie. He never hears the end of it and Freddy always has something to complain about. Monty always seems to be doing something wrong in Freddy's eyes. Rehersal, preformance, meet and greets, anything- He starts to get a little snappy after a while and Freddy complains about that too. They get into arguments often and dislike becomes bitter hate. Freddy being the band lead, he doesn't get talked down nearly as much as Monty and the others don't really critisize him. He's in charge and keeps everything running smoothly. Monty gets pushed off to the side and he begins to feel angry about the fact that the great Freddy Fazbear has say in everything everyone else gets to do and that he gets picked on. Freddy denies and they keep having their childish quarrels. Freddy is able to move on smugly, knowing he'll get away with his behavior, but Monty has no way to let out his emotion besides having destructive temper tantrums. His chill demenor was wrecked by Freddy's arogance. Monty can think of nothing more satisfying than getting Freddy kicked out of the band. All he ever did was admire Bonnie and then got the honor of filling the role of his idol, but Freddy had to go and ruin it all, bulling him and talking him down, shaming him for something he didn't even have any part of. He destroyed any bit of joy that came out of this and continues to torment him, but Monty cant do anything because it's Freddy Fazbear. The end :D

[@prufan]

That's an interesting read, but Freddy never acts like that in the game itself.

[@artypawsstudio8129]

@@prufan I mean, not towards Gregory. We don't quite see him acting the way he's described in the books though either. It could be situational. You don't complain about a coworker or annoying teacher every second of every day, right? My idea here is all just speculation though :)

[@FireBlock101]

Now I may not agree with your intrepertation/theory, as I just cant see freddy acting like a jerk, I will say that this is an interesting take on the situation. Sounds like a potential fanfic story/pos

[@artypawsstudio8129]

@@FireBlock101 Haha, yeah, I'm definitely a fanfic writer, lol. I love making up their interactions and stories! I see him as more passive aggressive though, not an outright bully if that makes sense.

[@FireBlock101]

@@artypawsstudio8129 I can tell/pos. A passive aggresive freddy is something I would like to see play out. If it isnt a bother, what site do you use to write fanfics? And what is you username? Im abit interested in reading one of your stories.

[@faynelor]

I think the only reason why Monty, didn't do anything about Freddy is because even though he was jealous of Freddy, he wouldn't hurt him because his idle was such good friends with Freddy

[@Thedragonlover95]

Yeah, he can be jealous, but wouldn't harm him,

[@faynelor]

@@Thedragonlover95 yeh

[@rainbowbrony12]

If you look at the carpet underneath Bonnie, it's the same carpet used in gator golf. Not sure why or how it's there, but I think it's the dev's trying to get the point across that Bonnie was destroyed there.

[@eggggg12345]

Or maybe Bonnie wasn’t killed there and his killer placed the carpet there to frame Monty.

[@so12productions]

​​​@@eggggg12345 Bonnie was definitely killed in Gater Golf since he was last seen there, but it doesn't mean Monty was the one who did it. We also know Fazbear Entertainment wanted to cover up this whole incident so they probably erased the evidence.

[@jinja-ninga97c21]

This is a theory I've been mulling over for a bit but now reading that there's a rug from Gatoro golf under Bonnie is setting some last pieces for me Bonnie goes to Gator Golf for whatever reason, gets serious INJURED there. Then is dragged over to the bowling section though the corridors and then is finished off there with a bowling ball. I wonder why Bonnie even went there in the first place. Also just a detail I saw in Markipliers video on the game is there's a bowling bowl that was chucked at a screen and I've been trying g to think of ways as to why there's one even in the screen and its a bit odd but probably not to deep as I can't think of a reason at all

[@Rajd_is]

@@so12productions He was last SEEN in there that mean he could get to his bowl with no one noticing

[@so12productions]

@@Rajd_is which means something happened to him there, especially after the message where Bonnie was last seen in Gator Golf, he is said to be out of commission after.

[@QueenofAgnus]

My theory is that Monty, before joining the band, idolised Bonnie. When you see these cutouts with a young Monty, you can see him stare directly at Bonnie, and the spotlight is on Bonnie, Roxy and Chica... But not on Freddy. I think that Monty was jealous of Freddy, with him being Bonnie's best friend and all, so i'm guessing Monty's desire to be apart of the band was so he could BE friends with Bonnie, and replace Freddy entirely (Monty Golf in base-game FNAF: SB) So i think that the Monty-killing-Bonnie thing is wrong, but thats just my little pet theiry

[@GamerJoseKun]

The idea of "Monty is jealous" feels so weird to me because of how things are contratictory, there is that scene in the Mini-Game that shows Freddy on the trash and people define as he wanting the spotlight so.. why would he target Bonnie, and not Freddy? It feels off, I think the mini-game shows the animatronics under Vanny control against Freddy. Also we have that lore of Monty actually skipping shows going back to Monty Golf and that he got the destructive impulse after getting the claw upgrades, to me this shows he trying to take off the upgrades somehow and avoiding the "spotlight" he so much wants. I mean, the only animatronic we have with clearly traits of narcissism... is Roxy. She wants to be the best, wants to be the favorite, to be number one, etc. The idea of wanting the spotlight makes more sense with that, buuut she is a fanfavorite, so let's ignore that :p Also even with that, I think the idea of "This animatronic likes the spotlight, so they gonna destroy the other to take their place because yes" a bit too easy anyway, there would have to be the concept of the virus like the books that affected them. It is also upsetting that both Monty and Chica really didn't get any personality or more defining traits in the game like Freddy and Roxy, they start like the others but them they don't really have any special phrases or something more to give them depth (no, Chica saying I smell Pizza and Monty saying Rock and Roll are not depth). The first cutscene shows Chica shocked when Freddy bugs out, and we see her rocking her guitar on her greenroom, and Monty having a rage attack on his, but after that and after their 'boss battles' it really adds nothing to them, the only new thing we get is that Monty is very sensible to light by how much the poor guy scream if you flash his eyes when he lose his glasses.

[@Thedragonlover95]

Thankyou for clearing the Gator man

[@ritaowusumanu3130]

5zgfhhjgkf65dtd74dud5ude7t8f452qw54e7576z79z64zswrzdehkxvöi8eduthkcz7😢🎉😂😂😮😊😅

[@zerotodona1495]

Just hear me out. Roxy did it. She has green nails naturally, eyes that sees things she shouldn’t, and is strong willed. She saw Bonnie being infected, attacked him in confusion cause of her special eyes, and then was infected herself.

[@so12productions]

Or her ego made her kill him out of jealousy like we think Monty did.

[@ThatPigNamedGummi]

Idk why would roxy do it like roxy was normal back then

[@Rajd_is]

@@so12productions You need high ego to kill anyone She has barely above surface, if not already below

[@Rajd_is]

But that would mean that Roxy somehow did not entered Night Mode like Freddy in SB and why would only Bonnie be the one? But that makes sense (not to much, but this is there)

[@so12productions]

@@Rajd_is Roxy does have high ego.

[@coffee-ouji]

I like this theory! The green paint felt too in the face for me too, it was almost funny, but still made sense jejeje. I also saw the big hit mark on the wall behing Bonnie at hands-height and that there's another similar scene in another part of Bonnie-Bowl with a massive screen smashed by a bowling ball (lol) so if it really was someone "framing'" Monty and Bonnie saw something he shouldn't he might have been chased (?)

[@Xx2abattery]

Best ruin theory I’ve seen so far tbh. Ruin is really confusing to me but this makes a lot more sense than Monty doing it. I just don’t understand why he would? Like he probably wasn’t even an existing character yet until Bonnie went missing.

[@itspaperbagkid]

YES SOMEONE ELSE WHO HAD THE SAME THEORY -- I had theorised a while ago that Bonnie had seen too much, or at the least knew something that he shouldn't have. Leading to the framing. I still am not 100% confident that Monty *wasn't* involved one way or another, because of the claw marks in particular (I can't think of anyone else atm that would be strong enough to make those marks), but I definitely agree and I'm glad someone else had the theory as well. 💀 I definitely don't think everything is as it seems, given the way the FNAF franchise is.

[@Rajd_is]

Monty didn't had claws back then. Only one that had those was Bonnie atp (I mean upgraded, destructive ones)

[@itspaperbagkid]

@@Rajd_is I mostly meant that I’m not 100% convinced that he wasn’t involved. But yes, I know he didn’t have them at the time. :) I had worded the comment pretty badly. 💀 I’m still confused by the claw marks, though, and I’m curious where those came from in particular.

[@Fbih2o]

I mean the security bots had left claw marks on freddy

[@avery5920]

@@Rajd_is i feel like he already had claws and they had just made them up, as the whole reason he got them was to play the bass but he already played the bass. And even if he didnt, the security bots were able to claw up freddy without claws so it wouldnt be that much of a stretch to say a giant metal gator could too

[@kja6336]

look at the claw marks on freddy in the ending where he gets disassembled

[@lunamelody2025]

I feel like it's Moon who killed Bonnie. The gator golf carpet and Bonnie himself were covered in oil and the only individual to leave a scene of the crime clean of all evidence is The Daycare Attendant himself! Plus, Moon has the strength to pull Bonnie like a doll.

[@princessmarlena1359]

I thought the same!

[@so12productions]

One thing I don't see people noticing is in the Monty ride where you see Monty in his Glamrock form using his bass to make a twister thing to destroy Freddy (at least it looks like it), you can see a very small Glamrock Bonnie at top in shock looking like he is being blown away.

[@The_Bot420]

I might be blind cause I don’t see it

[@fvntm3da5y89]

@@The_Bot420 Look at the top left of the scene.

[@fvntm3da5y89]

Fr, people keep mentioning it as evidence that Monty isnt 100% innocent and everyone just ignores it bc they think you can only see it with hacks, when that isnt true.

[@lightrealmrapono]

@@The_Bot420 it's there, just hard to see since it's so dark and the Bonnie cutout is kinda small

[@zeemmy33]

@@fvntm3da5y89 except if you want to accept that as evidence that monty killed him, then you also have to accept the rest of the cardboard cutouts as well (bonnie giving up his position, monty living in a swamp, etc). the tornado bonnie gets swept up in isn't actual evidence, it's just part of the coverup. you can't just pick one and pretend the others don't exist

[@WeakFreak]

I think the timeline of events is wrong. I bet Bonnie was demoted before being killed, placed to the Bowling area since he has his own greenroom there. if he was replaced just for having his appearance damaged, the company would just need to pick any random endo and put on the appearance of Bonnie. I'll put my theory in the comment bellow what I think happened.

[@WeakFreak]

I believe someone wanted Bonnie for something specific. all the other glamrocks (not sure about Freddy) got these upgrades, so perhaps Bonnie got one himself that's unique from the others. having him step down from the big scene and only appear once or twice a day at the bowling stage, he could be put to work on other things behind the curtains. we can see parts of STAFF bots in his greenroom, which is rather odd. did he fix or improve the bots to do something? we can see the green hue of moss on the robot parts laying around in the room, just like the sewer bots. meaning that Bonnie had some direct involvement with them.

[@WeakFreak]

if Bonnie worked on something that was from the underground pizzeria, perhaps they found something. or someone. in the secret room where broken Bonnie is, there's a floor carpet laying in the middle of it, full of scraps and robot parts. so it's likely that what it was a robot in that pile, which was covered in green moss since it's been down there for so long. but as Bonnie was close to it, the robot woke up and grabbed his legs (since there's damages there) that made Bonnie fall over, facing the wall. see the paint on the wall that's gone? that's where Bonnie's chest landed, giving it the green hue as he was pushed hard to it. when he fell back to the floor, this unknown robot grabbed the purple bowling ball and made the final blow. Afton must have something to do with it, but the question is who. it could possibly be Gregory, if he really is a robot, climing through the vent and running around the pizzaplex for a while before he decided he wanted to leave. is my theory true? not likely. but that's what I came up with with what I've put together from it all.

[@Victor-056]

@@WeakFreak "We see parts of STAFF Bots in his Green Room"... This can only mean one thing: Vanny ordered the STAFF Bots to tear apart Bonnie... Only for Bonnie to actually smash them to bits, even as he took damage (Hence the Chest Wound)... So she resorted to smashing one of Bonnie's Bowling Balls over his head, which finished off Bonnie.

[@1cyghost]

I watched 8-BitRyan play Ruin and I like his theory most. I believe Freddy getting attacked by the robots Vanny sent after him in one of the main game endings was the cannon ending. Freddy was missing his head, had a gap in his stomach, and was torn apart due to being attacked from the robots when chasing Cassie. Since Freddy's body was destroyed by the robots I feel like the Entity could have taken what was left of the empty husk to chase Cassie like it did with the other animatronics and that's why Freddy's body was so aggressive. I also dont believe Gregory betrayed Cassie, I assume The Mimic got the radio back and tried to turn Cassie against Gregory by making it seem like Gregory betrayed her but in reality The Mimic manipulated the situation and cut the elevator line causing Cassie to fall, Gregory had no control of the elevator since he said he wasnt even in the Pizzaplex. Also when Gregory said "we" in the elevator I believe he was talking about him, Freddy, and Vanessa, that would also explain why he was missing since they all left the Pizzaplex together in the ending Freddy was attacked in. But back to Bonnie, since the robots attacked Freddy I think they also went after Bonnie previously because he has the same marks Freddy had when torn apart. The green paint was, what I believe, Monty trying to save Bonnie because you can also faintly see Monty's tail marks in the room Bonnie died in. I believe Monty, as suggested in the video, was bestfriends with Bonnie and admired him greatly so I dont think he attacked Bonnie. I believe Vanny used the robots to attack and kill Bonnie for some reason and Monty was just attempting to save him.

[@Rajd_is]

I thought Vanny used green paint to frame Monty, but that is also good theory. Mimic in Elevator, yeah "But we can't being followed. I am sorry" those are his words. Gregory was supposed to say "But please make sure it won't follow you" Ruined Freddy is comepletely different one. Has protype mark on sole because first difference (bigger size) wasn't possible to notice without using hacks and spawning Glamrock Freddy right next to him.

[@hyperlaserrebrn]

thanks but i aint reading allat

[@Fredcat11]

Knew that the message on Dufflebag was an "Unreliable Narrator". Monty don't have the gloves that granted him claws attack by the time Bonnie left the band. Many people "blamed" on Monty didn't know that Monty was framed. Just look at "Disassembling Vanny" ending. Glamrock Freddy ended up in the same position as Glamrock Bonnie did. They also forgot that the BOWLING BALL was what killed Glamrock Bonnie.

[@Fredcat11]

Also, Monty wrecked anything after he's already Glamrock member, it was the virus that changed his behavior. The same virus that overloaded Chica into some unstable structure woman and tried to corrupt Glamrock Freddy (who happened to have Safe Zone booted in). Roxanne's full of herself and happy to help out whenever needed, which made her not heavily influenced by the virus.

[@CreeperLover649]

Ok, Bonnie, yay... *Silence* *Clears throat* WHERE'S FOXY

[@creativecreeper6147]

You gotta remember though, Monty has an anger issue, so he still might've attacked Bonnie, but then regretted it afterwards after going through an anger phase, that could also explain why he is also prone to destructive behavior around the pizza plex as well

[@jjrobotnik]

It's possible that the anger issues started after

[@Victor-056]

Monty's Anger issues and Violent tendencies only happened Post-Upgrade, long after Bonnie was Decommissioned.

[@pinkzep8500]

I think it went like this: Montys jealousy of freddys high position was getting too bad. Monty wanted to go straight to outing freddy. but there was one problem, monty wasn’t strong enough. So he wanted to make Freddy weak, he wanted to break freddys heart with a wound that would never heal. He was going to kill bonnie. One night, golf night, was going to be his time to strike. He knew Bonnie always went to monty golf on that day. Once Bonnie walked into the attraction, it was montys time to strike. He grabbed Bonnies guitar and sprung at the golfing bunny by surprise and bashed the bunny’s head at full force. Bonnie was battered and beaten by the gator as monty stole the sunglasses from Bonnie. He broke the bunny’s legs and dragged the still-struggling rabbit backstage in bonnie bowl. He grabbed a bowling ball and almost killed bonnie. The bunny was trapped in a limbo between life and death. He couldn’t move or talk or anything at all, but he was still alive. Bonnie was suffering and Freddy had fallen.

[@superkirbsonic9333]

The judge: okay I declare Monty not guilty Monty: *sniff*

[@mariahsart]

There isn't really alot of supporting evidence for Vanny being responsible. She doesn't seem strong enough either. But... like Monty being killed in RUIN by the Bonnie neon sign... seems like narrative karma to me. Even so, I still don't think Monty ... or anyone has been proven guilty yet.

[@so12productions]

The Neon Bonnie light that killed Monty definitely has a significance and is a metaphor for something involving Monty. If Monty is the murderer, then it would be representing karma.

[@fvntm3da5y89]

Fr, how would Vanny be able to pick up a whole bowling ball and crack something metal over the head with it so hard it caused head trauma. I dont think robots, especially with advanced technology, would be fragile. And shes just a human in a bunny suit with some limited powers.

[@Victor-056]

@@fvntm3da5y89 There is a suspiciously high number of Destroyed STAFF Bots all over Bonnie's Greenroom. Also, Monty's Clawtips are PURPLE. Where are the Purple scrapings on Bonnie's chest?

[@fvntm3da5y89]

@@Victor-056 I don’t think paint would scrape off, especially if the claw is tearing off a portion, but the green finger tips definitely could. And what does the broken staff bots have to do with anything? They aren’t torn, they’re deactivated.

[@user-cd4eq4vr1v]

​@@fvntm3da5y89She was boosted by Mimic's control. And maybe she used staff bots.

[@santiagoarrieta2175]

We could add another layer to this, if the Freedie we encounter in Ruin is really a prototype(the mark wasn't a added detail), could be this the one who really destroy Bonnie and later Vanny and the paint. The point it's Monty know or at least suspect was Freedie who did it and hate him for it, but he has the wrong Freddie.

[@fvntm3da5y89]

Bonnie existed in the time Security Breach happened, meaning this really isnt likely.

[@dieselpics]

I literally noticed this myself. HE WAS FRAMED. So glad I'm not alone in this theory!

[@dieselpics]

I figured this out around the same time you made the video hahahahaha

[@Blue-di9hw]

I just saw a small theory in a comment section and it says that they think the wet floor signs are Bonnie watching everything and that's why when you disable all of them Bonnie's eyes go dim, the one near Monty's weird pile of stuff could have been crying because Bonnie was sad about how Monty was framed by Vanny and then destroyed by Gregory. I feel like Bonnie would be sad because Monty was his biggest fan and also because all his friends were destroyed

[@OmarUddin-vr9or]

Everyone’s over here talking about Bonnie dead but everyone just forgets about Foxy when we know he used to be apart of the band because of his log fume ride in the Ruin DLC. Also it’s obvious Roxy replaced him since Foxy’s log fume ride is behind Roxy Raceway in the Ruin DLC. It’s sad everyone forgets Foxy, hopefully we see more Foxy in Help Wanted 2 in December 2023.

[@LaiDiegue]

I always thought is was Burntrap. His model seems to have newer parts, including his foot and some other parts. So maybe he destroyed Bonnie to repair some of his parts?

[@kinuuki]

I have many thoughts on this topic specifically: you presented some really good points! Something I always found it odd that there's a bowling ball that's been used to crush his head. Any sort of animatronic SHOULD have the force to dent or cause damage to each other: it's not entirely hard to. But to need to use a bowling ball to get a strike (no pun intended) implies the culprit to some degree had less strength than the opponent and needed a leg up. The thing is, hasn't the Burntrap ending been essentially retconned? Ruin seems to imply the Burntrap ending never happened. And if Vanessa/Vanny did it, then she has no reason to spraypaint his chest green to shift blame because she hid him away in a location presumably where he'd never be found.

[@Victor-056]

It's likely paint Discoloration, where an Object either made of Fiberglass or is metal, but also has multiple paint layers, gets a layer scraped off, distorting the paint and making it look as if it is a different color. Dirt getting onto the scraped surface can further discolor the paint and make it look like a different color.

[@kinuuki]

@@Victor-056 Honestly, hadn't even considered this. Thanks for bringing it up! Would Fazbear even bother with multiple paint layers during manufacture? Can't recall if the main glamrocks ever showed that sort of detail.

[@brandimullins8813]

This would also explain why Monty has such rage towards everything in SB. Destroying his room, destroying staff bots. He's exhibiting grief through rage because he lost his idol

[@100_NightTime]

Internet inferno is the best youtuber for FNAF Content!!

[@Roblox-Bedwars-Elite]

same

[@Spider-BearProductions]

True

[@Dripfarted]

The way you wrote it, it just sounds like you dont mean it.. im not saying he isn't, but dang.

[@Spider-BearProductions]

@@Dripfarted Wdym?

[@Dripfarted]

@@Spider-BearProductions it just sounds so emotionless, like he just said it because he just wanted to.

[@Rajd_is]

Staffbots destroyed Freddy in Vanny Ending, and he didn't got silver paint all over his stomach hatch That means this paint HAS TO BE attempt of framing Gator

[@lancelopez855]

Just putting this out there. What if Bonnie was supposed to be a vessel for Burntrap? What if Vanny lured Bonnie behind the bowling alley and hit him with the bowling ball in order to supposedly prepare him for the eventual revival of afton? What if some events transpired before the start of security breach which led to Monty having been told by Freddy to finish off Bonnie in order to prevent that from happening? This would support the idea that Monty is jealous of Freddy because of the connection they shared and knowing what is best for Bonnie. Another theory I have is that M.X.E.S is not just a bunny character to spite Burntrap. What if it was actually part Bonnie? If saving Vanny was canon in SB, then that would suggest by saving her we free her from glitchtraps control. After that, knowing full well what was going on, setup these counter measures to prevent the release of the mimic. This would support the idea that by turning off the wet floor signs everywhere including Bonnie's spot, where essentially turning of the Bonnie which is part of security

[@spinneryourdinner]

I swear I saw a clip here in youtube of someone with Bonnie that got some audio lines working, and these lines basically told the story of Bonnie seeing and trying to report something he obviously shouldn´t have. I´m surprised more people haven´t even heard about those voice lines

[@Lizuma]

I haven’t! I’ve been looking for more stuff on Bonnie since he’s my favorite. Do you have a link or know the title?

[@spinneryourdinner]

@@Lizuma I saw it the day it came out and haven’t found it since. Weird

[@setitcal5998]

Bonnie definitely has more significance to the lore but we just don’t know yet

[@oregano8716]

Why does Bonnie look like he'd actually choke you in the thumbnail I'm a big fan, personally...

[@hAppy-sAd24]

I knew from the start of the theory that Monty didn’t do it im so glad theres finally somebody agreeing

[@brendinveness]

The only thing I disagree with is Monty hating Freddy, because why would Fazbear Entertainment program him to hate or be jealous of him? Freddy being in the Trash in the Monty Golf Minigame is such a weak piece of evidence at this point, Monty can't have anything to do with that game, how is an Animatronic gonna be capable of creating a whole arcade game and just show his hatred for Freddy? Even if an Animatronic could do that, I seriously doubt Monty would be smart enough to be a Game Creator. It could just be a sign of how much his Popularity had grown, a Message saying how Monty could be more popular than Bonnie, Vanessa saying that Monty will run the show until Freddys Casing is on a New Endo, and Monty becoming the Lead when Gregory and Freddy escape in the Loading Dock Ending. In the Monty Mischief Message, it gives the hint that Monty didn't even want the Spotlight and wanted to stay in Gator Golf where he already had a spotlight. And of course, Freddy himself never spoke less of any of his friends, he spoke of them all equally

[@tea830fae8]

Hmmm, I like this theory of Monty being framed. There are bigger plots at work, and what I think is that, like Freddy and Roxy, Bonnie might have been the first Animatronic to become "self-conscious" and deviate from Glitch-trap's schemes. Unfortunately for him, he was the first loose end to tie up.

[@SnowblastStudios]

It was mr hippo!

[@heatheroutre]

Holy shit i just realized Monty only got his mohawk to emulate Bonnie's o.o Also with the Glitchtrap virus there's also the possibility that Roxanne was used to take out Bonnie, given her green nails

[@michaellynes3540]

I think Vanny killed Glamrock Bonnie. Bonnie must have accidentally gotten too close to the truth about what Vanny was doing. In response, Vanny smashes a bowling ball onto Bonnie’s head and, to cover her trail, smashes Bonnie’s chest and spray painted his chest with green paint to make it look like Monty did it.

[@ALIv827]

There is message in game files from bonnie about vanessa and her sus behaviour so it only confirms that bonnie saw something that he should have not see

[@seanscanlon7465]

Here’s the real question tho, where is foxy? We see cut-outs of him and the first security breach game, he even has his own pirate cove. So how come he is also not in the game?

[@coffee-ouji]

I love this style of editing, really gives that "playing with jpegs like dolls" vibe and I'm here for it heheheh

[@Zarton3601]

Another point of monty not likeing freddy is at the end of the ride, hes blowing freddy apart with his guitar wind. Also didnt freddy mention losing consciousness multiple times? Vanny may have used freddy instead to destroy bonnie, no gurentee vanny had the strength to hit bonnie hard enough to take it down and break the bowling ball.

[@renzod9252]

I think whoever made the graffiti around the pizzaplex is mocking Bonnie's death. In the music man section of bonnie bowl, you can see graffiti at one area saying something like "forever & ever", which is pretty much the same thing Freddy wrote on the poster in Bonnies green room (You & Me forever & ever).

[@Blue-di9hw]

These theories are better than game theory theories-

[@mrflipflop1321]

GT has been doing nothing but spewing shit for the past year or so

[@CJK_781]

Many many people would like to have a word with you, (i like both Theory crafters but i like Game Theorys entertaining presentation)

[@canadianpeashooter4321]

This guys theories are so underrated

[@marcelocaro6956]

I think Monty hates Freddy is because he doesn’t play an instrument and the rest do

[@briannelollmao]

Maybe Bonnie knew that something was going to happen to him, so he went into monty golf to "pass on his bass" maybe literally or figuratively somehow. maybe monty became out of control when bonnie passed because he knew what happened, or that something happened? What if Monty woke up saw his claws and was upset because he knew what happened to bonnie?(i do think monty was always aggressive, but not to the extent we see him) That raises a lot more questions, but just food for thought. Those were all just random thoughts while watching your video. Great job!

[@henryvaughan7283]

I think it’s the good news to get answers. I mean we’ve all been wanting to get answers and I’m dumb so I don’t know how to find out.. thanks man for letting us know this mystery

[@bobythefurry]

Bonnies hands is still on him so Monty's claws aren't from Bonnie

[@Poisongyal]

In monties jump scares he uses his TEETH. The Mimic uses his Claws, just leaving that there as food for thought.

[@Roblox-Bedwars-Elite]

nice investigating internet inferno😃

[@darkstormgaming2065]

What's the music in this video

[@milketodorova6114]

Dam. Vanny and Glitchtrap are masterminds

[@Nsb.gage0]

One year ago: where Is bonnie? fnaf ruin: oh he's gone he's gone he's gone.

[@Lucas-sl1dw]

Or monty threw a bowling ball on his head, that would be more logical

[@andyandrew2453]

Didn't know that you can destroy an animatronic only using a bowling ball. "A bowling ball per day, keep the animatronics away". :)

[@markovidovic2155]

This has been mind blowing and does make a lot of sense. This was well found mate!

[@njmo_salam]

wait a second bonnie has a broken stomach hatch and who has a broken stomach hatch too freddy so maybe vanny disassembled bonnie like she did with freddy and you can clearly see that he is disassembled his legs are apart his hands but still there is hope he will come back because his eyes has light on them and steel wool did not put that for no reason . but i think we will get more informations in the next game.

[@themymelodyCafe]

So I have something that backs this up , Monty has anger issues because of Bonnies death and he believes that Freddy killed bonnie because bonnie and Freddy were so close before his death so that’s why he is jealous and hates Freddy!

[@joshuahstubbs6753]

It was me the whole time... Bonnie did not get my chicken nuggets on time a ultimate sin, so a ball to the head would not be that bad.

[@marcardevolruizdevaldivia6335]

Even if under Vanny's control, i think Monty doesn't regret killing him, he intends to do the same to Freddy lol

[@internalscreaminge512]

Ok so pretty good theory and no disrespect to you or anyone. So one point is that Monty wouldn’t have had any claws when Bonnie was the star but if you look at Freddy in the base game before all this upgrades he has claws because he’s a bear so it’s very safe to assume Monty also had some of course not a sharp as his now but they are there. Also if I remember correctly Gregory after looking at the blueprints of Monty says he got better claws keyword being better as he would’ve needed claws in the first place to have better sharper ones for the bass. Again no hate towards your theory or anyone that agrees with it I just think that the designs of the animatronics definitely come into play here. Then there is the fact that Monty looked up to Bonnie and didn’t hate him at all in his ride. N ow it is possible Monty did look up to him but I think it’s a cover up and some might say well that’s stupid why would they cover up Monty doing something to Bonnie well first there’s kids and the parents might not want them to known about death even and animatronics but also Fazbear covering something up is NOT out of the question I mean help wanted was basically a game made to joke about the deaths and try to say it was fake. Sorry if this was long or didn’t make sense tried to put it as coherent as possible. PS sorry for bad grammar and punctuation I’m on a phone and I’m not a good typer anyway hope you see my point of view and even realize some things if you want to make a new therory if not and just over look this totally understand dude

[@NFROST]

2:21 please music name 🙏

[@heftyrumble]

Yo. I did not catch that bowling ball detail. Also, the detail with the claws is absolutely insane. I didn't even think about that.

[@Halo44327]

I doubt it. You’re telling me Vanny was able to physically shove Bonnie so hard he hit the wall and collapsed and then finish him off with enough strength of the bowling ball? That makes zero sense.

[@enderman7097]

another thing: people say the green stains on bonnies chest mean monty attacked him, yet they fail to point out chica has the exact same stains all over, maybe bonnie got covered in trash at one point?

[@alegk8394]

wait, but Vanny has a signal jammer in her suit, making the sight of all near by animatronics go static, so Bonnie couldn't have possibly seen something he wasn't supposed to, the only animatronic that can see past the signal jammer is Roxy, we know this because in one of the endings Freddy says "I can see you now Vanny, I have new eyes" these are the eyes from Roxy, unless for some reason Bonnie also has the ability to see past the signal jammer, then Vanny or Vanessa had ZERO insentive to kill him

[@kdxl3603]

My headcanon is that Monty killed freddy and was hoping to take his place in the group, however since freddy was too important too replace the higher ups decided to make a prototype, thats why freddy glitched out in the first game and thats why we see the word prototype on the bottom of his foot. Monty looked up to bonnie and wanted to be freinds with him, however when bonnie found out what monty did to the previous freddy they had an altercation that left bonnie dismantled

[@RW1A]

Hell, the idea hes angry could be due to bonnie being missing

[@butterssscotch]

If people think the green hue on Bonnie’s chest matters so much, than with that logic it’s roxy who did it since she has green nails/claws.

[@bryao5]

Just spitballing here but we know the mask is the only way to deactivate the caution bots, so that further proves it was her opening the one place that didn’t have cameras

[@m-yday]

The only thing that irks me about this is: Bowling balls are not easy to break like that. Vanny had to be incredibly powerful or use something incredibly powerful to do that. (Could be explained away by Steel Wool not realising this fact) Secondly, somehow this damage doesn’t cause Bonnie to get up, in the same way all the other animatronics get up and survive their decommissioning. Something else happened here to ensure Bonnie stayed down

[@Springfreddy29]

The claw marks looks like just like freddy's after he got damaged by the staff bots

[@Nonexistance707]

I just want to understand why G.Bonnie's eyes glow the same color as the mop bots, and when you deactivate the remaining ones his eyes stop glowing. That is very interesting

[@DeniseJenkins-nq8tw]

Everybody's just waiting for matpat to show up

[@AlphaWolf-vy2cr]

Your theory is nice but u do know that Bonnie and Freddy were really close so maybe just maybe when Bonnie didn’t give much attention to Monty , Monty let his anger out

[@bigchonka3442]

This is just my theory but what if Monty was human. In the ride they show Monty as more of a human boy figure rather than an animatronic, what if Monty was a human boy that loved Bonnie so much that he snuck in back stage after every one had left so that he could see Bonnie up close,but sense it would probably be night time (when everyone had left) Bonnie lured Monty(the boy) into his room and stuffed him into a suit. Another theory is that Bonnie learned he would be getting replaced so he gave Monty his guitar to him and then went back where no one could see him and killed himself by ripping himself open and then smashing his head with a bowling ball and that also kinda explains why they just show Bonnie giving Monty the guitar instead of him coming out of his room and giving it to him. Another theory is that Bonnie learned he was getting replaced so he gave Monty the guitar and then later slashed himself open and then knocking himself out whilst also being kinda hidden so that when they found him they would think it was Monty so that he would feel what it’s liked to get replaced

[@VanNessy97]

I had this same theory about Vanny being the one who killed Bonnie and pinning it on Monty. I just had a different motive, because I thought Bonnie's chassis would go on to become Burntrap.

[@madog61]

FINALLY I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO THINKS MONTY IS INNOCENT!!!!!!

[@marti_dim]

I HAVE A BIG THEORY... Vanny manipulated Boney to killhimself with a bowling ball like she did with the staffbots when she tell to the staffbots to kill freddy. But now Casey have the VANNY mask and when she deactivate all the bots around bonney, his eyes turn off or with other words UNmanipulate Bony when its too late bc hes now destroyed...

[@marti_dim]

I know some people won't understand bc I type really bad in English

[@marti_dim]

I'm from Bulgaria 🇧🇬 но дори и да не разберете, аз ще си го имам като собствена теория

[@marti_dim]

After I watched the full video be like😅😅😅😅

[@partyfoxdavy]

I always thought it was Monty because he could've been jealous of Bonnie's fame and popularity. But after this video I'm thinking Monty still killed Bonnie because he wanted to be Bonnie's best friend and not Freddy, so he killed Bonnie out of spite.

[@wahoobidy4912]

Something I'd like to say is the passing down was made ONLY after Bonnie disappearance. It's likely he has no higher feelings for Bonnie. I do think he is jealous of Freddy though, seeing him as the star while he isn't. Also I don't think vanny could destroy Bonnie because of just how there generally not that strong or strong enough to do that damage. I personally think vanny is being controlled by spring trap via the chip, thus explaining why she didn't just go down there and get you while facing burntrap in the cinematic ending. The virus isn't Affton imo, but he did design it and uses it to control them. I also think the cooperation that owns fnaf is aware of Affton, and allowing him to use Vanessa in order to "give therapy." Using his genius in technology to make these animatronics using soul stuff and engineering. That's at least my theory

[@PasteIie]

another thing to note that throws a wrench into the theory of monty being the one to bonk bonnie into the next life is that in the base game of SB, the duffle bag message about bonnie's movement around the pizzaplex that points to him going into monty golf also states that he leaves his green room IN rockstar row ( 12:24AM - Bonnie is seen leaving his green room in Rockstar Row heading East towards the atrium.), whereas in ruin we see bonnie's green room is not in rockstar row, implying he'd already left the main band. so, if bonnie had already left the main band, why would monty want to off him at all? if bonnie was broken then and there in monty golf, why build him a separate green room somewhere else when its clear they cant just make a new bonnie?

[@nightshademasquerade4703]

I think it was Roxy (while being controlled by Vanny). Be warned, this is a kinda complicated train of thought: - It's hard to imagine that a human could do that kind of damage. Do you know how much strength it takes to THROW a bowling ball like a basketball or something, much less throw one so hard that it damages an ANIMATRONIC? Damages it so much so that it's the "fatal" blow? - The Wet Floor Bots sound like crying children, meaning they're probably the spirits of kids who have died at the Pizzaplex (like from the Tales books - there's no way the boys from HAPPS don't haunt this place, they died so horrifically!) When the Wet Floor Bots around Glamrock Bonnie are deactivated, the light in Bonnie's eyes also dies. I think the kids' ghosts were trying to communicate through / possess Bonnie. It is confirmed that Roxy is herself a security node. Security nodes simultaneously keep Mimic at bay and allow Glitchtrap (and therefore the cult) to do more. I can see Roxy being sent to get rid of Bonnie so the kids couldn't interfere or bring attention to themselves. - Roxy has green claws, which would explain the green stains. And she had her claws before Bonnie went missing. - Freddy and Chica both keep one of Bonnie's bowling balls in their room to remember him. Monty doesn't, since he never even knew him; he ONLY joined the band after Bonnie went missing. Roxy, though she would've known Bonnie, does NOT have anything to remember him by. - Monty's personality vs Roxy's personality. We see in one of the duffle bag messages that Monty, on multiple occasions, doesn't show up for shows. It seems strange that Monty would be so willing to kill for attention just to blow off opportunity for said attention. But who doesn't do that AT ALL, EVER? Roxy. "Under Construction" takes place VERY soon after the Pizzaplex opens, and already there's only mention of Freddy, Chica, Roxy, and Monty. Bonnie's gone at this point, long before the virus. "The Storyteller" even says verbatim that "Monty was always dramatic, but he had been harmless" pre-virus (99). On the other hand, "The Storyteller" also shows us that even pre-virus, "Roxy had always enjoyed poking at people's insecurities because of her own deep-seated self-esteem issues" (98) or "the mean-for-the-sake-of-being-mean quality" (98) or "her inherent lack of empathy" (99). While lapses of judgment and spur-of-the-moment things do occur, it is worth looking at their patterns of behavior. A violent person is more likely to be violent than a non-violent person, after all. And if Monty can be called JEALOUS, what does that make ROXY? I'm skeptical that non-virus Monty would do something like that, but I can easily believe that non-virus Roxy would and could. - How do we know that Cassie isn't a Glitchtrap minion like Gregory was (maybe just newer or not as "high-ranking") and that's what is making Roxy act nicely toward her? In Security Breach, Gregory had already decided to turn against Glitchtrap, so her hostility there isn't a plot hole. Besides, it's a good plot twist to see this "protective, motherly" figure being the one who caused one of the biggest betrayals Bonnie fans have endured LOL. A wolf in sheep's clothing is more than a warning~ I'm studying to become a forensic psychologist IRL, so between this and William Afton, FNAF is a WONDERFUL exercise for me!

[@glitch-tv7504]

What if Fazbear Entertainment destroyed Bonnie and replaced him with Monty due to either budget cuts or Monty was more popular.

[@Pixiemage]

I'm curious, since nobody has managed to find a solid answer for this yet: why is it that Bonnie is found lying on top of a piece of carpet from Monty Golf? It looks like someone used it to drag him back into that room, but I'm not sure how solid of an assumption that would be. I'm also wondering why someone would go to the effort of creating a crime scene to frame someone else, when that room was never found prior to Ruin? Bonnie was hidden somewhere he wouldn't be found, so why bother to frame anyone at all? Especially when, if it was Vanny, she has the ability to control other animatronics and could have very well made someone else get rid of Bonnie for her?

[@nerdsferatuskeep3902]

This is why the box never opened in 4. Because y'all's head canon and stretching what is right Infront of you into fantastic proportion means if you don't like the canon you'll simply ignore blatant evidence literally handed to you and weave your own fairy tales.

[@thisisyouraverageperson]

Your completely right, this community will never accept theories they don’t like and make theories with little to no evidence to fit their narrative

[@Thesawapprentice]

I love this theory so much more than The 'Monty killed bonnie' theory I mean Monty killing Bonnie was to easy of a 'Mystery'

[@matiasvidlund1672]

Just for curiosity 1:27 This scene was in third trailer, but not fully scene, where did you got this scene?

[@callumjones9664]

one thing i would like to bring up about this theory about vanny destroying bonnie, the bowling bowl is completely shattered in several pieces, idk how someone with the stature of vanny would be capable of hitting bonnie hard enough or enough times for it to shatter into several pieces, it likely couldn't have been vanny herself who dealt the blow because of that, likely one of the other animatronics, i'd think either monty or freddy personally, in SB when vanny walks past freddy and he says there hasn't been a bunny for a long time, it could both mean, that freddy is sad that bonnie is missing, or that he knows he was responsible for bonnies death but wasn't able to stop himself from doing it

[@Victor-056]

In Bonnie's Green room, we find piles upon piles of destroyed STAFF Bots. Also, when looking at the Ceiling, we see what looks like a Vent above Bonnie... So either Vanny was Lurking in the Vent and dropped the Bowling ball on Bonnie... Or she made a Rube Goldberg type trap to kill Bonnie with the Bowling Ball. ...That, or her suit is hiding an Exorig under the cloth.

[@callumjones9664]

@@Victor-056 if she is, how did she hide something like that from fazbear entertainment? her purchases were being tracked and surely they would've noticed if pieces of animatronics just went missing. i also had the exosuit vanny suit thought but thought it couldn't be plausible due to how form fitting the suit was but anything is possible in fnaf lore

[@tsuaririndoku]

So you’re trying to say. Monty Jealous of Freddy because he like Bonnie but Bonnie never noticed him and instead seeing Freddy as a Friend? Actually, this is kinda weird Love Triangle I see here. But I’m not complaining, the Mimic is Bonnie’s killer theory is also decent too considering that Mimic is incredibly strong and it is the only character who is strong enough to bend metal at least.