Booing Tonali sub… right or wrong?

[@Arqueto176]

Why would Tonali be in the team to score goals? He's never been a goal-scoring midfielder. He scored 7 goals for Milan in 130 games; he's playing him in a role he isn't suited for. His heat map from his Milan days clearly has him playing a much deeper role. His set piece delivery is also top notch. It's actually weird watching the way Howe is trying to use him.

[@paolo7688]

Totally agree - I'm bemused why he isn't used as a deep lying midfielder, I assumed that's why we bought him...

[@shauntaylor6040]

Answer swap Tonali and Bruno.

[@philip244]

It’s the British disease. Every midfielder should be a box to box Gerrard. Prime Xavi wouldn’t be rated by these clowns

[@MichaelHeslam-z2z]

Totally agree he plays as the breaker up for Italy and did for AC Milan, Eddie's the problem not playing him in his best position.

[@craighope_dailymail]

And that's something I touch on briefly - is a change of position/role needed? Because there is a quality player there - for me, we're not seeing that right now.

[@herewegoagain8237]

We have a striker who can’t hold the ball up, we have two of the worst RW’s playing alongside Tonali. No one stopping in the 6 to allow Tonali to get forward. And worst of all, Tonali doesn’t get a foot in on set plays.

[@NuFc0X0Longbenton]

It’s alarming when Trippier himself said Tonali is the best set piece taker in the club, and since the Villa game last season we’ve hardly seen him on them

[@paolo7688]

I''m totally confused as to why we're not using Tonali as a deep lying midfielder and pushing Bruno further forward, certainly when we play at home. Eddie also has to consider playing two defensive midfielders away from home - certainly until we have better players to control games.

[@craighope_dailymail]

I do miss the version of Bruno who got forward and scored goals, and so does the team more importantly!

[@paolo7688]

@@craighope_dailymail Yeah I think someone on here said Bruno was at his most effective when Shelvey was sitting deep. That could be Tonali - would also protect the centre halves, but what do I know.

[@patera83]

This is the way

[@corronord]

100% agree

[@adamm622]

Our midfield 3 are not providing assists or goals… and they are not protecting the back 4. So it begs the question. What are they doing? They are all great players but they are not showing it, individually or collectively.

[@Hustlersambiton]

@@adamm622 it’s Howes formation and tactics they’re unable to shine although the effort is there

[@adamm622]

@ I don’t think it’s on Howe. The players have a responsibility to perform and they haven’t.

[@leefylee73]

Eddie's subs are pre picked before kickoff.. soon as the fans get the line up most of us could pick the subs he will use and give the times within a few minutes... you can set your clock by his sub timings.. so predictable

[@TonyODOnnell-tt8gh]

Yep ... 65/70 mins... So dam predictable, indeed. Eddie, Howe's game management is piss poor. He's always Re-active , with his substitutes. Rather than being Pro-Active... How long have we been saying this. He just doesn't learn. Or is to stubborn , idk 🤷‍♂️

[@jackanwyll]

Sadly this is a massive negative about his game it's Southgate-esk and an aspect I detest to watch other than that he's a great manager and it frustrates me soo much

[@scottdavison5584]

I'm sorry Craig but our press pack are an absolute disgrace and that Press Conference today was an embarrassment. You'd think we were 5 points clear at the top of the league if you didn't know any better. From Edwards criticising fans and calling them entitled and then writing puff pieces, Lee Ryder asking whether James Bunce is helping and others asking the tamest questions possible it's beyond a joke now. Usually it's asking him whether he prefers Oasis or Blur ffs. Bruce would never get anywhere near the leniency and kind questioning Howe gets. Today I appreciate Howe was asked about our midfield, but surely you (or someone else) should be taking him to task when he says it's not a problem, when you and others repeatedly disagree with that outside the press room. The only question of substance today put to Howe was about set pieces and even then he fell back on xG as a cover story. I appreciate as journalists (this isn't necessarily a criticism of yourself, I think you're one of the better ones) yous need to ensure you still keep the communication channels available and have to keep some semblance of a relationship with the manager, but our press is bordering on being club mouthpieces than journalists now.

[@ToonBano]

Well said. All our NE reporters have their heads so far up Eddie's arse it's untrue.

[@TyneBridge90]

"Hi Eddie, Morning Eddie" 🤢🤮

[@scottdavison5584]

@@TyneBridge90 You'd think it was a meeting of the CCP.

[@ozzy6162]

Why do you think that YOU, and any journalist, knows better than Eddie and the coaching team? Guess what - YOU, & THEY, DON'T. Toon fans have become a laughing stock with many other clubs' fans who see our lack of loyalty and our entitled attitude since the takeover. We've lost a few games & all of a sudden Eddie isn't good enough for us & all the players are shite - great supporters. 🤮🤮🤮

[@scottdavison5584]

@@ozzy6162 It's literally their job to ask questions not to caress his bollocks. Nobody is frustrated because of a few games. At least show a basic level of understanding before commenting like that.

[@andrewvaughan5686]

there's way more to worry about involving this club than booing this sub. a bit more alarming from the press conference was eddie thinks there's currently nothing wrong with the midfield?

[@craighope_dailymail]

He gave a robust defence of it, and I know why. And yes, I would stick with it - but I'd want to see far more from them.

[@thecouncilestatekid2116]

I have watched this channel for a long time i have moved to the geordie journos they give balanced veiws. Your just a Howie lover no matter what the results. he is playing the wrong formation because he is stubbon and no plan B Tonali is outstanding for Italy work that out ?.Saying that I would love howie to win something he has done so much for this club. But i love Newcastle united and if he loses to Chelse,Arsenal and Forest he is in trouble. Big clubs are ruthless we may need to. ​@craighope_dailymail

[@andrewvaughan5686]

@@craighope_dailymail i don't really care what he says tbh i just want him to get it sorted. i agree the same trio should keep playing together, but the flat 3 clearly needs some changing. thanks for the response

[@nickthornton5175]

If he wants the boo's to stop he needs to make better in-game decisions. He's turning the fans against him with his poor management and predictable approach

[@ozzy6162]

How many teams have you and these "fans" managed? Try supporting the manager & the team instead of criticising all the time & pretending you know better.

[@TonyODOnnell-tt8gh]

@@nickthornton5175 totally agree

[@jakesy2569]

Bang on

[@sid-d4w]

​@@ozzy6162 It's called having an opinion, fans have always had one.

[@iainchiz17]

I think it hillarious how reporters who spend their life slating the club and looking for headlines feel they have grounds to dictate how the paying punter should react or vent their pleasure / frustration. Similar to the other week when a bloke who doesnt have to pay or queue for tickets feels the club should not increase the capacity to make sure all fans get access. Living in cloud cukkoo land detached from reality just like majority of the players.

[@TonyODOnnell-tt8gh]

Well said

[@craighope_dailymail]

If you notice the tone of my point, I'm not saying you shouldn't boo, I'm saying I believe the justification for this particular booing isn't there. That's an opinion based on performance, not a supporters' right to boo or not. That's nothing to do with me.

[@stevenphillips4494]

@@craighope_dailymail. That’s true, but haven’t the press missed the point ? .. fans aren’t booing one isolated substitution .. this has been in the making for two seasons .. substitutions set in stone before kick off regardless of how the match is going… go back to us being dominant vs Liverpool at home… Tonali was having a great game, Howe took him off and we lost control in midfield.

[@kevinhamilton1177]

your wrong Craig howe needs to play tonali in his prefered position watch Italy`s games and see where he lines up and you will see how he plays differently also having team-mates alongside on the right who are shite doesn`t help either also the amount of runs he makes beyond defences gets totally ignored by whoever of the 2 numpties is playing and when they make wrong decisions and lose the ball Tonali is hoplessly out of position start watching the match as a whole instead of watching the ball then you might see the problems that the fans are seeing

[@craighope_dailymail]

That’s a different argument - a change of position could get more, for sure.

[@richardoliver4997]

Not this nonsense again Craig. The booing is because we can see a brilliant player that is not being used effectively - either because of the system or favouritism towards others. It's very good spin to attach it to Sean Longstaff coming on etc. but this is way wide of the mark and you know it. Tonali is head and shoulders above our midfielders and we want the midfield built around him not the preening and ineffective show pony that is Bruno.

[@Hustlersambiton]

Howe does not understand change. Tindall must just nod like a dog

[@terrybutler1096]

Tonali normally (Italy and AC Milan) played in the same position that Bruno plays. Perhaps that is the problem.

[@TonyODOnnell-tt8gh]

👌

[@shauntaylor6040]

Those in the know know this but we have a very stubborn Manager

[@philip244]

@@shauntaylor6040British managers don’t understand deep lying playmaker role only box to box

[@SensibleMoniker]

Yes, but so does Longstaff and he does what he's told

[@craighope_dailymail]

I've often wondered what swapping the two would do - maybe worth a go?

[@SlabISO]

Tonali can’t break from midfield when they’re having to cover the massive gap in front of our defence..! If Howe wants Tonali to create chances, then Bruno (or someone else) has to play number 6 and protect the defence. We haven’t got Botman’s pace to sweep-up behind the midfield and the fans are getting frustrated that Howe just doesn’t get it.

[@billmoore7137]

Botman doesn't have much pace mate

[@TheIncredibleBeard_]

Exactly, we play a system where no player can be confident of being covered if caught out of position

[@carlmoat2443]

The issue the fans have is that tonali has not been the worst of the 3 midfielders in any of the games yet is always the one sacrificed

[@DanielCordone9]

Tonali is a Championship player

[@billmoore7137]

​@@DanielCordone9yeah and AC Milan and Italy are championship teams too.

[@johnadair8850]

Howe and Perma Tan found out not good enough for premiership

[@givenright]

Joelinton has never been a midfielder and never will be. Doing a temporary job in there as an enforcer does not make you a midfielder. As you said in your last video, LW is his best position and he should be Gordon's back up for that position, which makes the Barnes signing even more silly

[@DanielCordone9]

Barnes isn't great from open play. He's just a good finisher. Saint Maximin is a better footballer

[@philip244]

@@DanielCordone9yeah, saint maximin is also much more creative than Anthony Gordon. Anthony Gordon is average in tight spaces

[@tomruddell-h7t]

Spot on

[@DanielCordone9]

The boos will stop once Sergio Conceicao is appointed as new manager

[@TyneBridge90]

please don't stop the boos 🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺

[@tooncrier]

It's a weird season, difficult to get your head around. Failure to strengthen the Squad in two windows, Clubs don't want to buy our dead wood so we can't generate PSR/FFP head room, the board level changes, players getting a year older, changes perhaps to training/injury handling and prevention, perhaps a reduction in intensity and a pile of players not playing well and looking undercooked. What's the solution? It's difficult to say....changing Manager is not going to help, reinforcing in January will help, showing patience will help, but as supporters that's bloody hard to do watching these performances. Luckily it is still early in the season, it is a marathon not a sprint......we just have to learn to be patient, support the team as always and let things unfold....oh a for me...drop Bruno and Joelinton for a couple of games...bring in Miley and.....Longstaff.

[@shaunbrennan5882]

Steady there bonny lad, you'll start a riot. P.s I do agree a change of manager is not the solution.

[@tomruddell-h7t]

It's not just Tonali. It's the fact it's almost scripted, every week. It's amateur beyond belief. It was like in the 22/23 season him rotating Isak and Wilson on 60min every game. I just shows he's not adapting to what's unfolding on the pitch, it's more to keep people happy. I'll be glad to see the back of him

[@manakara9821]

Opposition have seen through Eddie's plans because they are the same as last seasons. Close marking of our players when we have the ball and off the ball just running into spaces leaves us stranded and their choices of multiple passes. Look how much grass Palmer had every time he had the ball. None of our team could even catch him never mind tackle him.

[@givenright]

Exactly. Found out tactically and no plan B

[@terrym61]

(IF)Picking the midfield was down to fans it would change every fifteen minutes.

[@rossmcfarlane1219]

Wrong to boo a sub which happens every game at the exact same time, then replacement comes on and offers nowt. Can see the local journos starting to circle the wagons around Howe. Eddies done, coming out with Bruce comments. SJP will be the same as usual when its a big match, absolute dire.

[@levstone415]

Great reading of Howe's press conference. I do feel slightly sorry for Sandro as he got in the box against Forest and Murphy refused to pass to him.

[@SensibleMoniker]

I think Mr Hope needs to read the room - it's nearly over for Bournemouth 2.0 (Eddie is now a busted flush) the next incumbent will allowTonali to flourish

[@MichaelFerrand-nx1dt]

I agree about the booing which is not helpful, but I do think that you have it in for Sandro Tonali. He is better at ball retention than both Sean and Joelinton and has put some wonderful passes into the box in the last 3 games. Sean and J7 are better ball winners. For me, I think that 433 is not the best shape for us against the better teams, as we are too easily played through and Bruno/Tonali are too far back and unable to back up the front 3, but Eddie knows better than me. Let's hope for a massive (or any) win tomorrow night....

[@TonyODOnnell-tt8gh]

Tonali should never be brought off for an inferior player in longstaff. I dont think eddie is playing him in the right position. Like he plays for italy. Not to mention the inferior lack of quality, he's playing with at nufc at present... what are they doing, or not doing on the training pitch, is what concerns me.

[@davetherave597]

It's not wrong Bruno has been shite for a year yet gets captaincy

[@DanielCordone9]

He has a strange kicking technique. Has no backlift. It's like he scuffs it everytime

[@Cory-lh3yp]

It’s not hugely controversial but if you’re saying trust your eyes then Tonali has played better than Joelinton all season. He’s one of my favourite players but other than Southampton, J7 has been awful this season.

[@Chez114]

J7 actually had a very decent game against Chelsea. He supported Hall well and kept Madueke fairly quiet

[@Cory-lh3yp]

@ not sure I agree but it’s all about opinions. We need more from a CM than just supporting the left back, they need to influence the game at both ends which he didn’t do. I’d play J7 and Tonali as 6s and put Bruno in the 10 further forward where pace doesn’t matter and he can unlock defences in a time where we are struggling to create chances.

[@PaulFranks-cx3yd]

Straight into the usual anti-Tonali spiel and later on too . Groundhog Day . Did you watch Bruno on Sunday - embarrassingly outpaced by Palmer for the offside goal and then way out of position for the 2 goals - but we all know Bruno’s untouchable , undroppable. Hopefully for Sandro he’ll get snapped up by a top club who’ll play him in the centre in January . Mind you, Eddie’ll be out by then. Eddie is asking the 3 midfielders to push up and that’s leaving a massive gap in front of the back 4 - that’s on Eddie .

[@richardoliver4997]

Yep. More Brunophilia and anti Tonali nonsense from CH

[@CBTCOnline]

For me it’s the automatic nature of the Tonali substitutions. I can already tell you from now that Tonali will start and be taken off between 65-70th minute against both Arsenal and Nottingham Forest; irrespective of how the game is going. He does have a knack of auto cue-ing substitutions. Last season he had Barnes and Wilson to come on for Isak and Gordon on auto-cue. They always came on together; never separately. I just think subs should be based on the current game and how it’s playing out. At times Bruno isn’t playing as well as Tonali but he gets to stay on even though there is an option to sub Bruno and allow Tonali to take on the Bruno role as orchestrator of the midfield.

[@stevenphillips4494]

Exactly, as a striker you can spend 70/80 minute working a defence, making little false runs and setting them up so that when they think they’ve got your game sussed you change it up and score 1 or 2 in the last 20 minutes … last season the forward rarely saw 65/70 minutes before being replaced

[@audreyhall8644]

Tonali will be away i n Jan. He must be seriously disilusioned with this sh1tshow,with Howe/ Tindale farce.

[@NuFc0X0Longbenton]

It must be infuriating for Tonali when he makes them clever runs off the ball, into the box, and is ignored by Murphy/Livramento. Eddie’s job is to get the best out of his players and he’s not doing that with Sandro, a player who is clearly gifted based on his performances for Italy

[@damienreilly4347]

I think the fact Howe doesn't see anything wrong with midfield is the most alarming. It means he won't change it and he doesn't see it. He needs to go I think.

[@silvafox7719]

Really? Who do you think would get better results with this team? PSR has stopped investment in the team for two windows, while teams like Man Ure, Chelsea, Tottenham, Brighton and West Ham have invested heavily. We're falling behind, not because of Eddie, but due to finacial constraints. The summer was diabolical in terms of freshening the team up. Wilson is finished, and our right side is weak for any kind of goal threat. Still we'll have Botman back before too long, and next summer, we can spend a lot more due to PSR drop offs. This year is a transitional year due to budgets.

[@givenright]

​​@@silvafox7719It was Howe that wanted Barnes when we really needed a RW. It was Howe that dug his heels in with Guehi rather than having a plan B

[@DanielCordone9]

Howe out

[@davidrobinson2776]

Tonali does not look like a £60million midfielder up to now. It seems as though he is heading the way of Jon Dhal Tomasson, Thauvin, Merino and Viana. All were good players but they never got going for us. I really hope not and I believe Tonali will never take off under Eddie Howe. We need a new manager sooner rather than later.

[@fredjames9867]

Think if the press asked real questions not sugar coat the fans wouldn't have too

[@SwagDragon1]

The midfield has felt particularly ineffective since the city game (and some of the Brighton game), and I think a large part of that is that there is so little for them to actually link up. With the wingers staying wide and the fullbacks overlapping them, the outlets when Newcastle have possession are pretty much marked out of being effective if the opposing fullback goes right to the winger and the midfielder tracks the run of hall/tino. That leaves the forward pass really only capable of going towards Isak, who has to drop deep to collect, compressing the game even further, or having to take the ball between both centerbacks. For the most part, this is what seems responsible for the sideways/back passing. As for the press, I think the midfield is supposed to make forward runs in possession to free up 1v1s for the front three, but with most of those players too easily marked out of the game, and the frequency of possession loss, they are out of position to cover against the counter. It seems simple. They stop pressing because they’re worried about the transition.

[@NUFC2412]

Opinions are like...... as they say. When the booing happened vs. Brighton at home. Tonali was poor I thought. And again on Sunday.

[@equaltemper]

The writing is on the wall when an NUFC manager starts criticising the fans

[@grahamsidney9214]

I want eddie to succeed i really do but if im to ask myself if i actually trust eddie then my answer would be no! I dont.

[@alancharlton109]

I completely disagree with you. Every week you have something to say about Tonali and it’s always negative. Sean longstaff has been awful every time he’s came on for Sandro who played miles better than him. I’m not arguing that Tonali can’t improve because he and most of the team need to be better but I think the frustration is coming from taking someone off who has the ability to unlock a defence and replacing them with someone who at times can’t play a 5 yard pass

[@x0Matty0x]

Long one coming.... For me that is the midfield 3 we need, just in a different set up. Tonali's 2 games back for Italy and he was phenomenal in the left of a 3. His quick, creative passing would suit Gordon or Barnes on that side with their pace in behind. Bruno has always had that good relationship and understanding with Miggy and Tripps on the right. Joe sitting, being an enforcer, not necessarily a playmaker but breaking things up. He would have saved Burn n Schars 'need' to press Palmer in that position. I think he could thrive as the 6 if he took less risks and played as simple as possible. Another point on set pieces. I watched Tonali after we signed him at Euros (21s) and again in his recent games for Italy and his corners were wicked to say the least. It's beggars belief that he does not take them for us. Incidentally, I thought other than set plays he was anonymous at u21 euros but for that......he played right of a 3 man midfield. Would love you to question Eddie on the corners and Tonali taking them if nothing else. If you can, look back. They were so dangerous.

[@terrym61]

I don’t even think some fans know what they are booing at regarding tonali. I watched a fair few podcasts after the Chelsea game and the majority were very critical of his performances, and some were even shouting for him to be sold.So WHY were they booing eddies decision to sub him.THEY DONT KNOW

[@slowthian]

Context Craig don’t select comments to suit your narrative. Eddie did also say fans are entitled to make their feelings known but would prefer they left it to end of game and that the boos showed how much fans loved Tonali which he liked. He also did not single out Tonali as a player who needed to improve and score goals he said we need everyone to step up and I believe all can improve. But that doesn’t suit your narrative.

[@craighope_dailymail]

Howe said: “Of course there is more to come from him and the whole team. More from him means more influence on the game. Technically, he is an outstanding player. To see that technical ability, we want him to get the ball more. Playing as a No.8 we need more of a goal threat, too. That is such a key thing for the players in those positions. We have struggled for goals as a team. We need goals from every angle. Everyone has to contribute.”

[@slowthian]

@ yes I know I watched the press conference in full. My point is he doesn’t single out Tonali for wanting and needing more but your reporting suggests he dies by only talking about him.

[@Adamm357]

The writing was on the wall last season. Brighton away in particular. You can't play 3 players that want to press the other teams defence. Howe's downfall will be the decision to not sign a DM. Bruno's best form came when Shelvey was playing.

[@craighope_dailymail]

Brighton away was the warning sign. And it hasn’t improved massively since, for me.

[@DanielCordone9]

Guimaraes is a defensive midfielder

[@shauntaylor6040]

Howe calls it risk and reward, I call it balance.

[@mark.lawrence]

nufc started season badly but got very lucky putting 12 pts on the board form has not changed but the luck has so we have only managed 2 pts from the last 5 games & personally i think it will be 2 pts from 7 games after arsenal & forest EH refused to sell wilson & trippier, & wants to extend contracts for burn, schar, & longstaff here is the problem in plain sight, & craig, we go home & away, & if we want to make vocal our displeasure, we bloody well will, ok? EH OUT.

[@DanielCordone9]

I think we'll draw with Arsenal and lose against Forest

[@tomruddell-h7t]

👏

[@levstone415]

You make some good points and then ruin it by claiming our form hasn't changed. Clearly it has City, Everton, Brighton was way better than the early matches.

[@tomruddell-h7t]

@@levstone415 city game was better because of effort but that should be a given. Everton and Brighton sat back and let us have the ball so it looked like we were doing better. We never really looked like scoring other than a penalty

[@ianrichardmorrissey6082]

The noise is getting louder and the fans are close to mutiny captain. It was quite obvious this group of players were not happy for whatever reasons on day 1 against Southampton. Looking at the schedule and our current performances for November and December it ain’t gonna be a cakewalk and we could by January 1 st be in the bottom 6 group of teams trying to avoid relegation. Whatever is causing this malaise needs to be dealt with quickly. There has been a number of excellent comments from fans, journalists etc regarding player’s performance, or lack thereof, team tactics, managerial head scratching decisions on multiple levels and one thing is clear. We are NOT a possession based team with multiple useless passes going nowhere trying to finesse our way to the opposition goal.

[@chrisk3189]

Bruno JoeLinton and Tonali isnt working. Much like the defense and the forwards. Like you said however not much options to change it. Which comes back to the 2 poor summer windows. I feel its 2 games now to save his job, 2 poor performances with 2 defeats and think Eddie will be gone.

[@SilverArrow-p9g]

I am with you on this opinion. I like him but he needs to fix things now otherwise he will probably have to go. Shame but you live and die by your results. Too much money has been spent since he was boss.

[@paulm6455]

Hope so.

[@DanielCordone9]

Howe will be sacked after the Forest game,

[@chrisk3189]

​@@DanielCordone9 Performances and wins can save his job, but cant see it with so many misfiring. Concern would be who comes in next. Would have said Tuchel before England, so do they go and pay for someone at a club, and have another excuse for PSR, or go for a manager out of a job. If its the unemployed route Terzic and Mancini are the ones I can think of (not sure Mancini would want to work for Saudi again thou?

[@JakeD98]

It’s not just the midfield though. The defence is so fragile

[@steve-toon]

Great video as always Craig. Our fans should never boo our own players or manager unless they want them out. We are a long, long way from that.

[@peterdodsworth2272]

Eddie’s a great coach but as a manager not for me.

[@philldavison8607]

For what it's worth here's what I think went wrong v Chelsea and is typical of what has been happening recently. Firstly, we can't keep the ball and give it away cheaply..all other prem teams look after it better at the moment. An example is Barnes losing the ball deep in their half for thsir break and subsequent goal. Decision making at the back, Schar sliding in and mis timing the tackle on Neto. Isak's decison making when he didn't pass the ball late on. A dreadful VAR decison when Bruno was through on goal. These are all fine margins thet either, aren't going our way, or are down to the points I made earlier. It could have been so different and therefore a completely diffrenet presser.

[@andrewford119]

Tonali facts. £55 mill fee; £10 mill wages, 1 goal; 0 assists; creates nothing; can’t last 90 mins; banned for 10 months… Another fact. Lewis Miley who cost nothing and is paid a fraction of our “ Italian Superstar” had a far greater impact on Newcastle’s midfield when he played last year when he was 17… Tonali has been a massive let down apart from his debut against Villa… If we could get our money back I’d sell him tomorrow….

[@TyneBridge90]

but hold on he's got a really catchy song that the fans can sing and dance to for ages...."SANDRO OLE OLE OLE " 🎶🎵

[@DanielCordone9]

Miley is awful. His career will go like Gael Bigirimana's

[@andrewford119]

@ SMB

[@shauntaylor6040]

I agree Tonali will be sold at the end of the season for PSR.

[@mrchalkie1]

@@TyneBridge90 😂😂🥂🥂

[@RonnieHenderson-v1g]

You disappoint me Craig. Sunday’s game raised far more important issues than whether Tonali’s substitution should have been booed. After Sunday’s performance you said on your video that the problems were formation ( I agree ) and players playing out of position ( I agree ) . Both these issues are down to the Manager , and yet you continue to be soft on Eddie Howe and pull your punches on him. Why didn’t you confront him on this at the press conference? To waste your opportunity to hold him to account by instead asking the uncontroversial question “ is tomorrow’s game season-changing ? “ in order to get a quote for your headline is such a pity.

[@broonybroony9564]

I would try 4,1,3,2 with Tonali in front of the back 4 to help them and cover our slowish midfield 3.Can’t wait for Miley to come back,one of our class players.As for the right side Tino is a great overlapping option,better than Miggy !! It’s time to try options because the next 3 games WILL define our season and Eddies future IMO.Great video Craig.On point as ever.

[@RENCHER]

Not sure why some fans are so defensive of Tonali. He's a tidy passer, but not exactly a game-changer. If anything he's lucky to be starting based on his form. He needs to do more.

[@LloydCreagh]

When Tonali played for Milan he seemed to be everything we needed to add to our midfield. He’s played 17 games now (could be wrong) and other than 1 or 2 games where he’s shown moments of class he’s been quite poor imo. Which is worrying because he’s got the talent around him to show his class. He’s had almost a year to get fit enough and strong enough for the PL but can’t seem to show it in matches. Is it because the three of them in midfield don’t work together? Or could be something as simple as he’s just not settled here and isn’t happy?

[@edwardmeehan2364]

Something is up but also, with Milan and Italy he was/is playing with elite players. We don’t have a squad of elite players. We have a few but they’re unable to flourish in the current squad. The top dogs need to make some decisions and also make some shrewd financial decisions. The bubble has burst but I’m sure we will get back to winning ways whether it’s under Howe or a new manager. Things have gone stale. An injection of new blood would definitely help the current squad. Then fan base are deflated at the moment and there is no better feeling than when we are firing and winning. I know we can’t win every game but this season is scary at the moment. A win against Chelsea in the Cup might lift their confidence but we need at least 3 signings in January or at least a right winger and striker. They don’t even have to be household names just grafters who can put a shift in. We all need a lift! 🖤🤍

[@andygallagher6897]

Apologies for the long comment but a lot to unwrap from that press conference and the game at the weekend! I don't boo & don't think booing a sub is helpful even if I think the subs are increasingly confusing (for the record I just checked & Tonali was subbed at 62 mins as usual against Forest). I agree we have to use our eyes & not just stats - my eyes tell me that chasing the game even a tired Tonali is a better bet than Longstaff. That's not to hate on Longstaff, he was no better or worse than anyone else when he came on against Chelsea but I'd hope there's nobody going to suggest he's a better footballer than Tonali. We have to be incredibly grateful to Howe for the job he has done since he came in and I want him to succeed but it does feel like he gets a free pass on some things. Me, my friends at the match and those who watch on TV and even True Faith can pretty much predict the subs made and when they will be made. Similarly there's a lot of talk about lack of support in the transfer windows (and PSR) and that's fair. By his own comments in the summer Howe admitted he was heavily involved until Mitchell so he's at least in part culpable for blowing the budget we did have on 2 left wingers and 2 CM who want to do the same thing and a backup CF he only trusts with 5 mins. It's a continuation (or worsening) of last season but without the mitigation of extra games & injuries. I don't see training but based on matches I find it staggering he doesn't think there's a problem in midfield.

[@JackBurton3963]

We aren’t usually a booing bunch. There was reluctance to boo Steve Bruce after some of the most disgraceful performances in the clubs history. I think fans started booing when we drew 1-1 at home to Leeds after Raphinha scored but we improved.

[@alanlittle3941]

Linden Rd is looking lovely Craig lol. You can tell i used to be a postie around there. I was Pavs postie who lived in the estate off Salters Rd. A lovely man sadly missed. Anyway Sandro hasnt pulled up any trees yet but just like the team/squad hes stuttering. Has our front foot atracking football disappeared due to rhe fear of playing that way and the injuries it caused last season? Great video Craig

[@78dgray]

For tomorrow’s game against Chelsea I would shift Tonali to the left with Bruno in the center and Longstaff on the right. If Gordon is not available then I would put Joey up front on the left with Isak and Murphy. Hall, Burn, Schar, and Tino in the back or Trippier if he can go.

[@littlewood6]

Perhaps Tonali would be able to show his stuff in a different style of football. Plodding forward/backward doesn’t look like his style.

[@philip244]

He doesn’t suit Newcastle. Newcastle style of play culture has always been kick and rush

[@THEPete_]

As soon as Eddie stops playing Longstaff regularly and we start winning again, I can't wait for the PL to introduce new rules about the number of English players in the starting 11

[@craigarkle1077]

My worry for the Chelsea game is just lack of options if we need to chase the game there is an inability to freshen up the final 3rd when Gordon & Wilson are out. I’m hoping the team performance might improve once Botman id back and we can play a higher line and that will help the team knit back together

[@stevemartin1107]

I would change the system personally. 3-5-2 Use wing backs . 3 centre half’s to be solid with wing backs asked to run their hearts out and change at 60 mins . 5 across the middle to flood the area . Not sure with Gordon out though who plays along side Isak . I know Howe won’t . Your thoughts Craig ?

[@graemepentland2108]

Couldn't agree more. Tonnali has so far been dissapointing,. I see comments of, he's brilliant, he's a class act,etc etc.Well sorry, but so far im yet to see it.

[@jrws89]

Supporters have a right to boo if they are not happy with a decision if they do not agree with it. Fans pay an absolute fortune to attend games (particularly away from home) and whilst i understand Eddie saying it doesn't necessarily help the player coming on maybe he would do well to take on board what the message is from the fans regarding substitutions and certain players coming off all the time during the same time during games

[@jrws89]

another point i would make as well is that this team is absolutely crying out for Lewis Miley. Appreciate that he isn't there at the moment with coming back from the injury but i think he would be that perfect foil in midfield against what we have at the moment

[@Hustlersambiton]

Especially when we’re seeing the same crap subs every week. And the same crap formation. Nothing changes

[@Hustlersambiton]

I don’t think booing should be a common thing but we’re allowed to express ourselves when the same crap is happening every week

[@jrws89]

@@Hustlersambiton when have Newcastle fans last booed? It NEVER happens and it wouldn't happen for no good reason. You have to take the rough with the smooth i am sure Eddie knows this he isn't stupid

[@ozzy6162]

Criticising & questioning every decision or selection won't win us the games against Chelsea & Arsenal. Time to show proper support for the manager & the team.

[@philldavison8607]

Why would I boo Howe. He's the expert, he's the UEFA coach. He has seen and managed numerous players. He sees the players day in day out. I could have an opinion but that doesn't make me correct.

[@tomruddell-h7t]

🐑

[@kendo5862]

The number of dreadful hospital passes Bruno gets coz our players can’t play under pressure really highlights the dearth in quality and attitude of our old guard

[@std6385]

Feels like it needs a formation change. The formation we never deviate from was successful when running ourselves into the ground and pressing throughout the side. Now that's gone, it isn't working, and we are too easy to play through. Can't understand booing though at this stage, if we were to lose next 3 then maybe but Tonali hasn't really done anything to not be taken off, although you could throw that at nearly every player

[@DavidMcKenna-b5x]

Craig It,s not the mid-field the defence are giving the ball away to much and the front line can,t keep hold of it are create. At the last game Joe Willok while warming up didn't,t luck committed. Craig keeping going you speak from the heart

[@MarkWeir-cr5tk]

We should be Newcastle UNITED, booing weakens our support and strengthen the opposition. Scrape a win tomorrow night and we have something to build from which will make late Edinburgh train liveable.

[@TyneBridge90]

Eddie said "its important that I dont blindly stick with something that clearly isnt working" Im sorry Eddie but thats exactly what you are doing, in terms of formation, teams and substitutes

[@andyo22]

I had no issue with subbing anyone off on Sunday. Something had to change. You know, we're ranked 2nd in the "Dispossessed" stat this season so far... 🤔

[@nij1541]

Hi guys, so frustrated with the midfield.They can't control games and they have no cutting edge.Big Joe is doing well but Tonali and Bruno really need to step up.

[@ToonArmyNL1892]

Tonali should be encouraged to take more set pieces/free kicks. After Trippier, he is one of our best.

[@Toenala]

If we get nothing out of Wednesday and Saturday is Eddie Howe at risk? The first Premier league manager has already gone.

[@JackBurton3963]

4th spot is between Chelsea and Villa. Don’t think Spurs will be consistent enough but still have them finishing above us. Conference spot is between us, Brighton, Man Utd and potentially Forest or Fulham or West Ham if they get their act together.

[@nickthornton5175]

When we are chasing the game (again) you dont replace Tonali with Longstaff, the same as you dont take a dynamic Hall off and replace him with a lumbering Dan Burn

[@MrComicy]

Swap Bruno and Tonali around, allow Tonali to play CDM. Also please let’s see Osula play up front alongside Isak.

[@terryn777]

I think Eddie needs to be much more creative; go 4-1-3-2 but have Joelinton sit in front of the back four)doing the destroyer role that David Batty, Rob Lee used to ) Tonali left midfield, Bruno middle and assuming Gordon is missing, Longstaff or Willock right midfield, Isak and Barnes up front. Big Joe gets straight onto Palmer when they have possession. And he pushes up when we have the ball.

[@jayaychare7318]

Depressing to think longstaff going on to score goals 😫 Tonali not being utilised in his best position so we aren’t going to see him as productive as we maybe should Midfield is all over the place

[@madmac4723]

No victory tomorrow Eddie can't polish these stones into gems anymore. They have lost their sparkle.

[@dwm4968]

Tonali, Bruno & JoeLinton are our best three individually but not collectively, I don`t see them playing together all the time. NUFC high press has been found out and/or played around. Eddie needs to adapt his tactics to suit, not sure if he can.

[@RH2930]

your fascination with Tonali worries me. He is world class.

[@ToonBano]

How do people not understand the booing? Sandro Tonali should not be coming off the pitch on 60-65mins every single game. Not when we're playing shite or not getting results. This is DAMNING to the Manager. He isn't using him properly. He is failing to get the best out of one of our best players. The fans are frustrated. They don't wanna say it. Especially when you're brining on Sean bloody Longstaff. It's a ridiculous situation. All of Eddie Howe's doing

[@johnreay5522]

Play hall in midfield he has a bit about him

[@craighope_dailymail]

He was a midfielder through the youth ages.

[@iainchiz17]

He’ll be out de bruyne in years to come.

[@littlewood6]

Who would plat left back then?

[@shauntaylor6040]

Then we don't have a left back.

[@philip244]

No just no.

[@jamesmilligan2797]

Tonalis bang average, a liar & a gambler..should av booted him bak to Italy 11 months ago & sued AC

[@ToonToon-q3z]

Eddie Howe makes the same mistakes all the time and doesn’t seem to learn from them. Same formation every game, subs always between 60-65 mins that weaken us when we’re chasing the lead, rarely plays his best side, scared to drop his underperforming favourites, weak tactically and so it continues game after game. I love Eddie and the way he develops players but his in game management is woeful. Stevie Wonder can see things before he does.

[@Saudi_Mags]

I would change formation. 4-2-3-1. Possibly use Gordon as a number 10. Free role. Pope Livramento - Schar - Burn - Hall Bruno - Tonali Barnes Joelinton Gordon Isak Something like this.

[@kyletomey43]

You dont boo during the game, simple as. Its not going to have a positive impact on anyone during the game. Leave any frustrations until after the game.

[@anon-zk6iz]

Hi Eddie 😂

[@keithnicholson9100]

Ok Craig!! Why not take off Bruno or Joelinton? Why always Tonali? Why not Bruno? He gives the ball away a lot more! Using my eyes!!!!!

[@grahamtowler1761]

Crux of the matter is whoever the manager is a lot are passed their sell by date so can't do much more with them ,needs upgrading somehow in the next window, Guardiola couldn't make a difference as it is at the moment

[@jackanwyll]

In eddie we trust ❤️🙏

[@user-ls1lu7gu4u]

Tbh Tonali is probably our highest quality player even more than Bruno. Bruno has not been good this season. I think it could be time to change our formation because you can’t fit Bruno Joelinton and Tonali in this formation.

[@jasonenglish8133]

Only winning the League Cup will save Howe's job. I think another season of no European football will make EH very vulnerable.

[@parallaxview6770]

Eddies lucky . Always gets an easy ride from the local press .

[@stevenphillips4494]

It’s not right or wrong … it’s up to each individual fan how they react to anything they watch … Howe, you, or me doesn’t get to instruct the support on how to behave !

[@Bereal711]

2-1 at Chelsea and isaks starts drifting to the wing where he likes to play and Howe doesn’t have the balls to bring osula on and play him up top. I don’t get howe at all. His 1 game plan just doesn’t work