BOOK READERS REACT | A Good Girl's Guide to Murder - 1x4

Manny and Jane react to and discuss season 1 episode 4 of A Good Girl's Guide to Murder!
WARNING FOR NON-BOOK READERS: We discuss the book series in detail throughout the video, so beware of spoilers for future events!
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder: Episode 4
____________________
a good girl's guide to murder, reaction, react, reacts, review, discussion, book reader reaction, book readers reaction, book readers react, book reader reacts, book fans reaction, book fans react, book fan reaction, holly jackson, book, novel, adaptation, episode 4, ep 4, episode four, 1x4, S01E04, season 1, season one, episode, book fans, book readers, book fan, book reader, reaction mashup, pip, pippa fitz-amobi, ravi singh, andie bell, sal singh, max hastings, scene, clip, emma myers, zain iqbal

[@ChannelNamePending699]

EDIT: Welcome to any new viewers joining us for the first time, now that the show has officially released on Netflix as of August 1! I read and respond to all comments, so feel free to share your thoughts down below :) WARNING FOR NON-BOOK READERS: We discuss the book series in detail throughout the video, so beware of spoilers for future events! Note: We recorded all of this in a tiny room with a fan pointed at us so it kind of messed with the mic's ability to pick us up at times. There's a few moments where I added subtitles for when the audio quality dips. Probably should've done that a lot earlier, but oh well. Sorry about that!

[@MariaEduarda-lb5pf]

just a little easter egg, idk if y'all noticed but holly jackson makes an appereance at the hotel scene, she´s the woman in a white robe with a towel over her head

[@ChannelNamePending699]

We didn't notice! Now I gotta rewatch lol

[@Nily8233]

I feel the thing with Victor's name being in the guestbook, isn't coz Pip suspects him of having something to do with the Andie Bell case, but instead, like Pip & her mum discussed, it suggests he had an affair. And the whole point is that it parallels how all the evidence is starting to point against Sal, and Pip is struggling with knowing what to believe (what she feels is true in her gut, or what the evidence says)

[@ChannelNamePending699]

We had the same thoughts! It's cool that they added a little more depth to Victor's character.

[@iris3dits]

The scene with young Pip Sal and Andie actually changes in the way she thinks of it. At first when she thought he was innocent Sal smiled at pip and he wasn't suspicious and now that she isn't as sure of his innocence he comes of aa suspicious and he doesn't smile anymore

[@3rineee]

I noticed it too!! I was like “Sal’s face changed he looks more serious now!!”

[@iris3dits]

​@@3rineeeYeah its so well thought of and done!

[@ChannelNamePending699]

We definitely noticed that when the flashback plays for the last time in the finale. Really nice way to show how Pip's inner thoughts change throughout the show.

[@BryanWasHere89]

As someone who has watched ALOT of TV and hasn't read the book (but has seen all of the show), I get why they added the thing with her dad. It helps fuel the suspicion of Sal for Pip (and subsequently the non-book reading audience). If this seemingly great guy did something possibly shady, what does that mean for Sal? I think it's a smart move, especially after we just spent 3ish episodes finding out that other people in her life were holding dark secrets.

[@ChannelNamePending699]

I agree! I think it also served to show that not all secrets have malicious intent behind them. Pip also gets a chance to learn to rebuild her trust in her dad after her faith in him was shaken, as it was with Sal.