Book Review: The Study Quran | Dr. Shabir Ally

[@ramialfalastini2053]

You do a very good job of explaining matters and showing that Muslims are actually educated and reasonable people. Thank you for your efforts.

[@theharshtruthoutthere]

Whenever you seek something to read, remember: Basic Information Before Leaving Earth = B I B L E (KJV) and a search: BIBLE + FREEMASONRY. Quran is a book of the little god of this world, lucifer. Placing the name allah to be satan`s another name. So far there is 3 things that give quran away: 1.) it promise carnal heaven, which is filled with virgins. 2.) Souls are willing to pick up the quran rather then the BIBLE. 3.) the god of quran didn´t die for the sins of his creation. Souls must work hard on their “good works” to arrive into imaginary heaven, where a life, like we have here, goes on.

[@PracticalBibleStudies]

Very helpful for Christians to better understand Islam as well.

[@shanerichard826]

@@convert2islaam500 welcome to the way, the truth and the life.

[@shanerichard826]

@truth arent Muslims bowing down to a cube in mecca? just curious

[@shanerichard826]

@truth Muslim travel to mecca, walk around the rock, pray to/at the rock and stick there head into it. sounds like idol worship to me. correct me if in wrong

[@shanerichard826]

@truth how?

[@shanerichard826]

@truth I'm aware of that. Mohammad changed the direction of prayer, after he failed to convert the Israelites to Islam. that's when he changed the direction of prayer towards mecca.

[@marissapriestap6063]

Thanks for this good and objective review. I've been hearing people either exclusively criticizing or exclusively praising this work, and I've wondered what its actual strengths and weaknesses are. This is really helpful!

[@parkerflop]

+Marissa Mowery It promotes what is blasphemou according to Sunnis. Anyone who fails to affirm the kufr of Jews and Christians and the rest of nonbelievers is himself a kaffir. Anyone claiming the Quran does not condemn trinity or that trinity is somehow no shirk is himself a disbeliever. It's not "academic" it's dishonest. The authors blatantly lied against Ibn Kathir(so obviously that one can merely check Ibn Kathir to see they say the exact opposite of what he said) shamelessly.)

[@jsusbdndk1362]

@@parkerflop what did they lie about? Please let me know because I want to check it out

[@Gilamath.]

@@parkerflop they lied about nothing. One will encounter no instance of the authors of the Study Quran referencing the commentary of Ibn Kathir on any ayah and finding any different commentary when checking Ibn Kathir’s own work on that ayah. Likely, this anonymous commenter simply had their own pet interpretation or sticks close to some imam or another who has grounded their own novel position based on a certain reading of Ibn Kathir’s commentary, and is annoyed that the authors of the Study Quran did not entertain their interpretation

[@marcthezani]

Yes you may ask. I I am studying Quran for personal reasons as a seeker of knowledge and truth.

[@kelcarolyn]

I am in the middle of reading the study Qur'an and, although I am not a Muslim scholar, I really appreciate the commentary on different schools of thought. I think it's especially important for the non scholars (Muslim or not) to learn about the different schools of thought ayat by ayat. The other miscellaneous commentary is extremely insightful

[@shahidurrehman8264]

My sister may I ask you that what your opinion about Quran its from God or not.... I mean what you feel when you study...

[@kikaa1884]

​@@NRFPhe was not talking to you bro he was asking her 😂😂😂

[@bobhopeless4106]

I got mine a couple weeks ago, and I've been loving it. I've wanted it for 2 years, but it was pricey (and of course, I wanted the nicest edition, astaghfarullah...).

[@MaherExcel]

Thank you, May Allah bless you, Dr. Shabir and everyone supporting this program.

[@sanobartuba]

Dr Shabir Ally is an amazing scholar. I just come here to the channel for any doubt. You should start a course that is done by Dr Shabir himself. It'll be a great help. We need scholars who deal with the issues of today and make proper interpretations that actually fit today

[@RIFamily]

To repeat a question that doesn't seem to have been answered: What commentary does Dr. David Ally recommend for the common person? In light of Dr. All's expressed opinion about the Study Quran 's commentary, I think it important to provide a commentary suggestion for the common person.

[@esfanintan]

Doctor Shabir honestly is refreshing. I wish I could actually learn Quarn by this honest doctor.

[@eclecticreader961]

I'm currently reading "The Study Quran", it is a very interesting edition.

[@hyrunnisa997]

He doesnt give the "average person" enough credit. Many of us do want to know different opinions and interpretations. Islam is not a monolith.

[@NiazMohammad]

probably "average person" is meant to be "the new readers or learners" and hence the different opinions and interpretations could actually do more harm than good. Only scholars can judge the goods and bads well enough based on their researches and scholarly knowledge on the matters

[@ADeeSHUPA]

@Rafael uP

[@hxorasani]

@Rafael I agree, this whole thing about don't study the quraan if you're not a scholar is ridiculous, do scholars come out of their mothers' birth canals with all that knowledge or do they begin studying somewhere...

[@fatamhobbee2906]

@Rafael you are totally true it speaks to all humanity no matter commentaries could be different because its the people's ideas about the meaning and Arabic language is rich in different meanings to the same word but if you feel it speaks to you when you read it thats really spiritual my friend because that is what it is supposed to do / god bless you

[@sendmemoneythanks]

Yeah these Scholars act like their so high up in their asses.

[@Ig310]

I have completed till Surah Anbiya and this is a must read book!! An amazing peace of work. It took some time to develop the vocabulary but once you are hooked with it its addictive. Reading 20 versus each day to complete in 1 year.

[@classicalmusic9658]

جزاك الله خيراً for their comprehensive review. My sister brought this book to my attention and I’d love to get it now after watching your review

[@TheGreatReading]

Dr sahab speaks very well

[@azzy1971]

Opinions of classical scholars are just that, it's their opinions. Al Quran is deff not restricted to any scholarly opinions rather it allows the readers (any and all) who ponders over any verses, taking into account subject matter and context, to arrive at the Truth by him/ herself that is valid before Allah SWT, this is the real meaning of the Ayat 31:27 And if all the trees on earth were pens and the Ocean (were ink), with seven Oceans behind it to add to its (supply) yet would not the Words of Allah be exhausted (in the writing): for Allah is Exalted in power, Full of Wisdom, hence no person no matter how knowledgeable or famous has any monopoly on the truth. The key to this Book must be the accurate translation from Quranic Arabic to English for maximum benefit.

[@dan138zig]

the qur'an is untranslatable so your argument is invalid. correct, no human has no monopoly on the truth. the problem is, if you don't even follow scholars then how can you follow your limited mind with much less knowledge than them?

[@dallasmckinley]

Very informative video. Just the info I was hoping to get about the Study Quran.

[@hanaelkhedri9593]

Very interesting, it gives a good idea of the content of the book, comparing pros and cons has been very useful, jazak Allahu khairan kathiran

[@TheGreatReading]

Thanks a lot for a comprehensive and honest review !!

[@AlanaLikeItCommon]

Thank you for bringing attention to this book, the summer 2023 I came across this book in the library in Brooklyn and I felt bad for not being able to appreciate it and read it, now I understand importance of this book and it really is wonderful that it exists

[@NiazMohammad]

Even being a Muslim, I find it hard to decide what to read? Islam shouldn't lead to multitudes of meanings for a single statement in the Quran, yet it is so hard to find one that is in agreement by all. There shouldn't be any disagreement or ambiguity if the intention of Allah was to convey what He wants to say to us.

[@thealpinerover]

Learn Arabic and much of the confusion will go...

[@MrResearcher122]

@@thealpinerover Differences are in the Arabi. Dr Shabir never said it,or he may have implied it, but the differences are often traced to different schools. Confusion can result for someone new to Islam or for Muslims unaware of other opinions except the Sunni one, or reliant on modern day Arab scholars perceptions of Islamic history.

[@voltage80x]

Read 5:48 in the Quran. If God had willed, he would’ve made you one community, but his will to test you with what he has given each of you. So compete with one another and doing good to God, you will all return then he will inform you “of the truth” regarding your differences. You are encouraged to interpret from your God-given gift of intelligence. You have an inner sense, you’re encouraged to use it my friend. I too struggle with the different interpretations but as we study the Quran we begin to not care so much about that.

[@memonshoyeb]

@@voltage80x most sensible comment you have made , friend :)

[@bluemoon9889]

is there a study quran in print today which includes both modern and classical commentaries? that would be beautiful

[@Cuinn837]

Eventually other Study Korans are likely to come out. This is the very first one. Christians have many different study Bibles to choose from.

[@chrisphillips4064]

Asalam alaikum Alhamdulillah Just received mine today. So happy!!!

[@frinadis]

Very enlighten on the pro and cons regarding the books. Thanks quranspeaks.

[@azizurrahman7347]

Is there any book that not only translates but also explains the meaning of the verses of Quran . Bcoz sometimes it is quite confusing. Please recommend.

[@Danko_Sekulic]

There is - www.amazon.co.uk/Holy-Quran-Translation-Commentary-Abdullah/dp/1902480015/ref=sr_1_8?crid=2C1JSYD703VXS&keywords=abdullah+yusuf+ali+quran&qid=1576666476&sprefix=The+quran+abdu%2Caps%2C224&sr=8-8 It offers detailed explanations, and it is accessible and useful to experts and non-experts, Muslims and non-Muslims alike! It can serve as an introduction, but not the kind of "introduction" that sacrifices the actual meaning and message to the wrong kind of "accessibility" i.e. oversimplification!

[@parvezkewar]

Mufti Taqi Usmani

[@saq546]

“Do you, then, believe in one part of the Book and reject the other? What repayment will there be for any of you who do that except disgrace in this world? And on the Day of Standing, they will be returned to the harshest of punishments. Allah is not unaware of what you do.” [Sūrat al-Baqarah 2:85]

[@muhammadshafique761]

Looking to read The Study Quran...

[@ralphcravey4904]

I have a Study Quran. It is very useful in understanding how different people interpret the Quran. I agree with Dr. Shabir about the classical commentators. I do not agree with many of their interpretations of the text.

[@mirabella2154]

Whether you agree or not is irrelevant.

[@ykhan7563]

It is very marvellous discussion about the translation of Husaain Nasr every aspect of its study is discussed it is an academic strength but still it is a mean of misunderstanding for the beginners...

[@RandomMZ1412]

Anyone see the face on Aisha when he was talking about beating women?

[@abdurrahmanhalis]

It's interesting that Dr Shabir does not reflect on the perennialist (the understanding that Islam does not abrogate the previous dispensations) comments especially on the additional essays in the book. The book appears "radically traditionalist" in this video where Dr Shabir rightfully points out the one sided criticisms on the modern comments regarding the verses, however it includes "radically modern" interpretations like perennialism as well. It would be nice to hear about those points given Dr Shabir's objective attitude.

[@issasuwedi8082]

a very objective and enlightening discussion.....thanks !

[@omarOmar-ow3mc]

Salaam. In the English language the best translation is by Muhammad Asad. 1000 pages with full cross reference to verses. Most of the commentary is based on Tabari Razi Zamakshari and Muhammad abdu. Asad stresses only the original meaning of the Arabic words can help to make the message of the Qur'an clear.

[@NiazMohammad]

There is no best translation. It all comes down to the translator's knowledge and interpretation and the readers' acceptances.

[@MrResearcher122]

@@NiazMohammad Assad's interpretation is rational, informed by great Mutazila hermeneutics, and unique.

[@salmanhassan437]

Pdf available?

[@alexhill1314]

I personally would stop short of calling any rendering into English “the” best but am thankful to Muhammad Asad for making the Kitabullah accessible to my Western mind. There are some specific points I may no longer agree with him but they are minor in comparison to the immense value of his tafsir.

[@solidcreature5950]

I think what 4:34 told us is clear enough. Doesn't the verse clearly state that to only do that if the woman does ill-conduct? and doesn't it advise to do as the last resort only after things getting out of hand when the disobedience is severe, since the same verse gives other options previously?

[@watermelon7867]

+Quran Speaks I'd just like to point out that the translators discuss the dress of women in more detail in surah Nur ayah 31. Perhaps, they expect people who are interested in the issue to check that verse as well rather than just repeat what they already said.

[@umarsidbejibreel2485]

Please how can i get a copy. I am student and from Ghana.

[@mohammedahmad8039]

Jibreel Umar You can buy it from Amazon www.amazon.com/Study-Quran-New-Translation-Commentary/dp/0061125865/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?keywords=the+study+quran&qid=1579050528&sprefix=the+study+quran&sr=8-1

[@Cuinn837]

I have mine on Kindle. Amazon sells Study Koran in different formats, but for me Kindle is best for now.

[@serdarerdem1367]

To reach god To reach Allah Have the wish to reach god Have the wish to reach Allah We must have the wish to send our spirit back to god! ‎للوصول إلى الله ، يجب أن تكون لدينا الرغبة في إعادة روحنا إلى الله

[@FrenchHawk878]

The very first Muslim video I’ve seen to not have assalamu aleikum in the beginning.

[@divinechemechanical]

If one of the principle goals of the Qur'an is to provide divine guidance, then the presentation of "multiple views" could hinder simple obedience. It may expand understanding at the cost of spiritual discipline.

[@shahriyarhaq3047]

In my humble opinion,mostly the allegorical or verses conveying scientific import may be differently interpreted.The verses considered muhkamat seldom have different opinions.

[@PinkFlowers365]

Jazak Allah Khayr

[@aanchalbakshi672]

Why this translation is so pricy 2600 something price is so high... Other translations can be bought at 350 and what's it's authentication

[@peacemaker2988]

i love you shabir ally for the sake of Allah (swt) may Allah (swt) bless you higher and higher inshallah can you please give a detailed lecture about the end times about imam mehdi and dejjal because we really need accurate knowlege in these fitna times that we live in.es selamin aleykum ve rahmetullah.

[@amhedduran3896]

Then which would it be a good Study Quran for common people that will not create confusion and misconceptions about what the Quran really says?

[@raushanlatiff96]

Try Tafsir Jalalyn or Ibn Kathir (abridged)

[@zohaibqamar1151]

how can contact to you for more in comming islam related books.

[@adurrouf9551]

Vai, Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullah. Please give me the actual meaning of BAIUUN: I known it means Transaction. It is a process of EJAB & KOBUL. Arabic TEZARAT means business. Tezarat is one kind of BAIUUN / transaction. BAIUUN has lot of classes: Baiuu fasid, baiuu shohih etc.. I will be pleased if clarify by arabic language. Sorry for this inconvenience.

[@saulien3675]

What is to expect, same traditional commentaries, and text with diacritical marks and vowels as the 1924 standard. What if we remove diacritical marks and vowels, and if there are anomalies try Syriac or Aramaic, then you will find that there is cohesion between successive verses, even make more sense for a whole Surat such as with the Surat 97.

[@mydeer06]

Assalam u alaikum, why we pray zohar, asar and some part of magrib and isha 2rakaat calmly, when we get quote from Quran that is neigther pray u r salah calmly nor loudly but inbetween tone. Quran c. 17 v. 111

[@gclowne174]

The one thing ii find missing in this writing team is the lack of Mainstream Sunni and perhaps even a salafi element. While i find it laudable the included shiite and sufi writers why not have included those from these two other currents, one being majority and the other being the more traditionalist. Do these streams lack scholars capable of such works?

[@uzair851]

"Mainstream sunni and salafi" never thought i'd see these words together. The salafis are definitely not mainstream sunnis and I have met many salafis. They only follow an extremely limited set of scholars in creed and reject the understanding of the majority. For example Imam ibn hajar asqalani, Mulla ali qari and Imam jalaludin suyyuti are accepted sources by the salafis in terms of fiqh and hadith but they reject what ever they brought in aqida. Puzzling

[@gclowne174]

@@uzair851 maybe i expressed myself wrongly english is not my mothertongue. I meant mainstream sunni, and salafi as two distint categories, not exactly a single entity. Thank you for your insight i need to read about those scholars if time allows.

[@alvinleong173]

The common Muslims need to aim be uncommon!

[@mohsen9503]

Well, so this book is only good for Qur'anic and academic scholars and NOT for common people interested in this great book of guidance. Doesn't sound very helpful for many people who are so eager to learn about Islam from the first-hand source. Dr. Shabir also does NOT mention whether the collection of the interpretations included in this book are from valid and credible Qur'anic scholars or just anyone just for the sake of variety. I also wonder if the book offer a biography of the scholars whose interpretations are included in this book so the reader can better decide about the validity of their interpretation. Honestly, I also found Dr. Shabir's comments on the verse on "beating" woman VERY confusing and NOT helpful at all, especially for a non-Muslim viewer of this presentation. I was quite eager to purchase this book when I visit the US this summer but now I have serious doubts.

[@thedoors669]

Excellent!

[@gazibizi9504]

It's an ecumenical translation of the Quran

[@abdullahsadik5754]

Masha Allah sisther brother welcome to Islam the right way of life you tackel of yourself and give massage to your pelow people

[@Islamis4all]

واساءلوهن من وراء حجاب ما ذَا تفسير هذه الآية What is the commentary of this Verse of the Holy Quran

[@lybrebel14]

Abu Muhammad هذا خاص بزوجات النبي محمد فقط، لان الناس يأتوهن لطلب الفتوى ومنهم رجال! فحفظاً لغيرة النبي صدر الامر بالسؤال من خلف الابواب للرجال.

[@ezzahsaifullah]

Please do a review of the sublime Quran

[@zafarmahmud]

How much its price and How to get I am in Pakistan

[@marcthezani]

I think best to read Quran and seek knowledge of it's language of revelation as well as early to current history in Islamic societies.

[@mohsen9503]

+marcthezani Hello and best of luck to you. I think you will find it really fascinating by just studying the simple - but VALID - translation, and since you're also studying Arabic I think you will do just fine. I personally believe interpretation is only for those who want to go really deep into the verses, which is also fine if you're into it. I just find the simple translation (I use Farsi and English) mesmerizing enough every time I read it (at least 2-3 times per year). All the best to you.

[@marcthezani]

Jazak Allah Khair, may Allah increase us in knowledge

[@comparativereligiondailynews]

❤❤❤ Seeing First Time On 3 April 2024 🎉

[@AliKhan-rj7cj]

What translation/commentary would Dr Shabir ideally recommend these days? For someone with fresh eyes. I'm interested in reading one for the sake of 'learning' about important events/lessons in history. So something contemporary, discrete and prudent would preferably do if you could help me with that? Thank you!

[@parkerflop]

For history, Ibn Kathir cites seerah events and historical events a lot

[@احمدگیلانی-ش1ط]

If you can compile a complementary commentary on it we will be in your debt.

[@Shiraz354]

what about the Quran translated by monotheist group any comment?

[@aftabmahmood8062]

Insight Curiosity. Looking

[@riyazenglish3576]

Respected Dr Shabir. I personally feel good to read the translations: By Abdullah yousf Ali By Abdul Majid Daryabadi. ByM M Pickthal. And as for these they are virtually the best because chances of confusion are lesser. Thanks once again dr Shabir Ali

[@dreamflier]

The translation and commentary by Mohamad Asad is also a good one...the English used is a mix between the modern and the old (eg the flowery style used by Pickthall)...

[@marcthezani]

,I am skeptical of this work and it's timing as a non-Muslim studying Quran who is well read on Islamic topics and other related subjects.

[@بنتاليوتيوبأستغفرالله]

+marcthezani may i ask , why are you studying Quran on a deep level .. are you a student??

[@parkerflop]

+marcthezani It is a blasphemous deceitful lying work, stay away from it.

[@marcthezani]

+‫بنت اليوتيوب :P‬‎ Hi thanks I am a non-Muslim studying for spiritual reasons as a seeker of knowledge and truth.

[@marcthezani]

+Mustafa M I haven't studied it to go that far but some of the things in it caused me to not want to study it. I am studying Arabic to read at least in part the Original. Thanks be well

[@firasdahche]

Nth beats Abdullah Yusuf Ali translation of the Quran !

[@lybrebel14]

This one beats Yusuf one big time

[@harambedemandsjustice1559]

In my opinion tb irwin also beats yusuf ali's translation..

[@dreamflier]

@Arastushukooh You can have a look at the translation by Mohammad Assad, a Jewish Muslim scholar and author. His is a mix between the modern and the classical English and the explanations given are good too.

[@dreamflier]

@Arastushukooh Yes, I read that he uses ijtihad and rationality to explain some verses in the translation which may not sit well with some traditionalists (and the reason he is not accorded full recognition and respect for his works and various books and when he passed away, it hardly made news in the Arab world ). And though he did quote from Zamakhshari quite a lot, to be fair, he also used sources from other commentators and scholars as comparison.When I tried to compared between translations, I just used the Surah Al-Fatihah and the last three short suras to check out how the translations are fleshed out in all their eloquence. But I guess when it comes to preference, to each his own!

[@dreamflier]

@Arastushukooh Yes, there is one Quran English transaction book where in the Surah Al-Fatihah, the last verse about " ..not the path of those who have incurred your wrath nor of those who have gone astray." was added with a bracket ( the Jews and Christians)! The translators (could be that Hillal and Khan guys that you mentioned) certainly had an agenda to demonise the Jews and Christians so non-Arab readers, and new converts etc who rely on this translation will think it is in the Quran itself, got radicalised, and took it upon themselves as a call to do harm against the Jews and Christians.and put Muslims.in a bad light. And this translation is also used by anti-Islam groups to point out, among others, that the Quran is prejudiced targetting the Jews and Christians as the bad guys.

[@Knowledge.Seeker13]

Well, I guess I won't be buying this book any time soon.

[@SARAHIJAZ]

Read the Translation in ur Native language

[@nancymohass4891]

Would you like to explained Jihad to non Muslims?

[@thealpinerover]

Jihad literally means "struggle" and it can't be translated as "Holy War". Any constructive measure for the betterment of Mankind in the Light of God's decree can be termed as Jihad. For example...The Prophet (PBUH) said, # If you refrain from sins, it is Jihad. # If you serve your parents, it is Jihad. # If you serve the poor, orphans, disabled, it is jihad. # If you help the needy in times of distress, it is Jihad. # If you educate the illiterate, it is Jihad. # If you feed your family by earning via honest means, it is Jihad. # To judge unbiased and fairly is Jihad. # Maintaining Law and Order justly is Jihad. # If you help the oppressed, it is Jihad. In nutshell, any constructive effort taken for the Cause of Almighty God can be termed as Jihad.

[@LeixWUxLong]

@@thealpinerover Nice explanation, you beat me to it.

[@thealpinerover]

@@LeixWUxLong Thank you, I am humbled 😇

[@anoopchalil9539]

From review feels confusion for ordinary people because of various thoughts... may be good for academic people...

[@Sinnfullworld]

I like shabir for the sake of God

[@abubakarsurajoibrahimkirar9086]

I wish I can meet DR. Shabir Ally in my life. I have a very important message (+ something) to him.

[@pillarbinwolfs848]

Abubakar Surajo Kirari why dont you send him a message?

[@testing-je7yz]

You would be better of reading tafsir ibn kathir. This is the classical translation of the Quran, compiled with evidence. Now a days people are trying to change Islam, a new understanding as if they are better than the prophet Muhammad pbuh.

[@fourteenten4147]

You will meet him in shaa Allah, he's trying actually, may Allah guide and protect him and all our sincere scholars. Regarding this compilation, it was going to be better if they have not included the view of shi'ate who rebelled against Allah and His messenger(saw)

[@Risperi1]

4:48

[@maymoonahislam2851]

I loved the color of his khuffs ( Leader socks)

[@fedesetrtatio1]

To study the Quran you need the bible, the Torah, the Mishnah, the Alexandrian tales, the Syriac Christian literature, and pagan and agnostic literature otherwise you cannot study the Quran.

[@Hinduhere-s9j]

Thanks for the Comment.

[@Chandransingham]

Good review. Those who studied Bible in some depth should find this book helpful to reach similar depths in the Quran. cf New Jerome's Biblical Commentary and articles on the Bible. Shabir refers in review to Surah 9/5 (pagans) , 21/31 (creation) and 4/34 (daraba - husband/wife issue). Quickly one is able to figure out the Christian and Quranic paradigms to form a personal enlightenment - a sort of 'Nirvana' on earth itself.

[@esfanintan]

there is absolutely no way to understand the Quran without knowing Arabic.

[@alirezaakbari459]

Whenever Muslim nations sit together united you can offer a united conclusion of quran ,so never

[@SARAHIJAZ]

Just Read the Holy Quran instead of reading other Books

[@muhammadaryan3979]

Yes, even if you have read the Qur'an 100 times, the wisdom in it is infinite. No matter how much you read it, it will never get old as long as you understand Arabic in its original meaning.

[@Ken-tc3nq]

If my doorstop speaks to me, I'm burning it

[@whowhatwhenwhyhow9265]

Computer come with an inbuilt hardware.... how comes God did not inbuilt his message in us, instead of having to rely on “holy “ revelations given to other humans AKA prophets? Free your minds

[@ajazzshake]

First thing first does God even exist? Ajazz Shake's answer to Is there a God? If yes, what is God? Why did Allah create us? www.quora.com/Why-did-Allah-create-us/answer/Ajazz-Shake

[@ahmedshinwari]

Good question (Mr. Q). Well, computers are built to serve. Are men as well? Ibrahimic religions dictate that the life is a test. Each soul is going through this life which is crafted to be a test, the most difficult one.

[@billygene589]

Actually humans have an inbuilt disposition e.g. you instinctly know certain things are good or bad. Everyone can agree murder is bad. Similarly, you have it inbuilt within you that when you recognize the truth, you are compelled to follow it. So I highly encourage you to study Islam properly and you will see that your soul will be drawn towards the truth.

[@samyelsayed900]

Where is the video of Shabir Ally's view on the verse of wife beating that he is referring to?

[@reggjackson3915]

Astagferllah...my intention is not to leave a negative comment but what I hear him saying is that the average muslim is unable to draw conclusions when given different interpretations on the Quran and that muslims are to be followers of the so-called Scholars. Well not all Scholars agree and none of the Scholars are guaranteed 100% correct. No one wants to be led to slaughter like cattle. People that are not mentally deficient are responsible for themselves and must do their own critical thinking. InshaAllah we are all granted Paradise.

[@billyb6001]

Im glad theres no hellfire in real life or this book would be scary

[@bintrashed19]

Your living a delusional life which will come to an end and if your not a believer in Allah and Muhammad صَلَّىٰ ٱللَّٰهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِهِ وَسَلَّمَ‎ being the last Prophet then your end will be scary.

[@joeymac6970]

9:35 - 9:55 LOL.

[@saltypancreas5866]

thank you for pointing out this contradiction

[@joeymac6970]

@@saltypancreas5866 Islam is a field day for it.

[@saltypancreas5866]

@@joeymac6970 rather the speaker

[@saltypancreas5866]

@@joeymac6970 speaker is good, but he contradicted himself Islam speaks for itself,

[@joeymac6970]

@@saltypancreas5866 Shabir Alley is one of Islam’s better champions to be honest. Try Zakir Naik for a laugh.

[@hamdanhamdan1259]

Question to be answered by Mullahs, Syeikhs, Imam and Muslims Scholars..(1) Why Islam splits into many sects (2) Why Quranic verses conflicting? (3) Islam claimed that the corpse of prophet Muhammad remain intact and does not decayed..Why not you guys reopen the prophet Muhammad's grave as to proof your claimed ???? Muslims ummah now CONFUSED !!!!

[@esswasim]

It maybe that you may like a thing but is harmful for you and maybe you maybe dislike a thing which is good for you. So Dr. Shabir Ali how can you say that A man is not allowed to beat a women if she is lewd? I am not a scholar but Quran is the word of Allah and everything Quran says is the moral definition of what is good and what is bad. So good and bad are defined by Quran not by how we feel or think. If Allah states a man has certain authority over women that means that is the good thing, it is the moral way, it is the right way. There must be no objection to it for Allah says of the believers " They Hear and They Obey". They do not criticize, they do not add or subtract, they hear and they obey. There is no modern in Islam, There is no Modern Islam. Anyone who thinks he is following Modern Islam has to stop and rethink. Islam is an unchangeable religion and cannot be changed no! You can either believe in what was revealed and be a believer or not believe in what was revealed and be a disbeliever. That means everyone who has problem what the simple explanation of the Quran, because Allah mentions it Allah made Quran easy for us. So What is apparent is the truth of Quran. Anyone who has problem with what is Apparent and Clear, has to really reconsider the problems and Make Taubah and Submit to what Allah has revealed without being Apologetic. Truth is clear and even if truth is bitter yet truth wins. So why you people try to so called modernize Allah's revelation when it is meant to be a warning and a good message only. It is not meant to please the disbelievers neither is it meant to please any creatures rather it is a warning and a glad tiding for those who fear Allah not duniya.

[@billybro1403]

brother you can beat your wife all you like, we don't really care. You can kill her too, but yeah there are consequences for that and jail isn't very appealing.

[@tornado1789]

I think this book has a really big problem with Aqeedah! It contains some sufis and Shia interpretation , which are considered by Muslims as Kufr and heretic ones! This book was written with agenda! As its propaganda has shown in CNN, it is written to withdraw Quran from Khawarij! However, they ended with the same problem that Khwarij has., which is radicalization the text but with the other side! It has a problem, not only with the interpretation but also with the translation itself. They have translated Surah 3:19. إن الدين عند الله الإسلام They said The religion for God is submission !, which is a trial from them to omit the clear message from that ayah that God accepts Islam only . Yes, islam is the religion of all prophets, but now The only reflection of that Islam (submission) is by what the prophet Muhammed taught and indicated . , Finally, All the authors are obsessed with sufis! , so you can imagine what kind of that book looks like! Personally, I don't recommend that book!

[@tornado1789]

***** YES!

[@بنتاليوتيوبأستغفرالله]

+tornado 1 how can i have it(the book) am from KSA (written with agend) i think so too

[@tornado1789]

بنت اليوتيوب :P Amazon!

[@بنتاليوتيوبأستغفرالله]

tornado 1 thanks

[@brothermuhammad6640]

+tornado 1 Asalamualikum brother, you stated: "I think this book has a really big problem with Aqeedah!" There are various schools of thought regarding Aqeedah, which one do you think is the correct one? "It contains some Sufis and Shia interpretation , which are considered by Muslims as Kufr and heretic ones!" Over 200 leading Muslim scholars from over 50 countries (including Saudi) declared that Sufis and Shia are Muslims, not kufar or heretics. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amman_Message Or did you mean that some of their interpretations are "kufr" and heretical? "They said The religion for God is submission !"; The actual quote is "Truly the religion in the sight of God is submission..." - The Study Quran pg.135 In the commentary section the authors mention that some classical commentators share your position, and others don't, what is wrong with stating such a fact? "Finally, All the authors are obsessed with sufis!" That is understandable, as sufis are delightful company ;)

[@007kash007]

It also contains pantheism

[@bangtanshook4271]

NO

[@myswordandshield]

These guys trying to sanitize their EVIL book!

[@ameerkhusro777]

Love Aisha khawaja Aisha will u marry me

[@bustarhymes6188]

Ameer Khusro shut ur mouth, commenting every vid

[@anoopchalil9539]

onathinte edakku poottu kachavadam..