Lecture 1: Knowledge & Religious Experience - مذہبی اور صوفیانہ تجربہ

#reconstructionofreligiousthoughtinislam
This is a description and review of the first chapter of the great philosophical literature written by Dr. Allama Iqbal titled "The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam". It propagates the concept of pursuing modern knowledge since it is in alignment with the message of the Holy Quran. In the 2nd part of the lecture, Iqbal talks about characteristics of a Religious experience which is again a very interesting concept to understand. Their are several themes running across this first lecture but the most profound is the concept of Thought and Intuition. The video will help you understand what it is all about.
The Introductory video of this book can be viewed below.
• Introduction: Reconstr...

[@abuzargallian1162]

What an effort Book buddy. Weldone man. The way you explained show's how much grip you have on the matter and how much you worked hard in understanding it. Thanks for sharing with us this premium knowledge.

[@arkafaquefromknowledgetowi6418]

I am myself an expert in Iqbaliyat but this video is appreciable and made easy for the students of IQBAL that I have ever viewed.

[@zabanshanasi]

اللہ تعالیٰ آپکی اس کاوش کا آپکو ڈھیر سارا اجر عطا فرمائے. آپ نے بہت ہی منفرد مگر عام فہم انداز میں اس بہترین کتاب کے بارے میں تمام ناظرین کو مستفیض کیا. خوش رہیں. آپکی ایمانداری، قابلیت اور خلوص نے سبسکرائب کرنے پہ مجبور کیا. 🌸 ♥️

[@rabiafatima62]

آپ نے ایک مشکل کتاب کے پہلے باب کو بہت آسان الفاظ کے ذریعے عوام تک پہنچانے کی کوشش کی ہے۔ بہترین وڈیو تھی اگلی وڈیو کا انتظار رہے گا

[@abdullahsajidcheema9165]

I endorse this comment.

[@rehanaparveen7662]

The world thinks that our religion does not emphasize logical reasoning even we Muslims thinks like that but I am really fascinated by Iqbal's point of view , how beautifully he explained that Islam emphasize on experimenting, innovations and logical reasoning and how Allah orders us to look upon everything and think about the processes of this life. It's not easy to understand Iqbal's perspective sometimes but once you understand his perspective you feel so amazed. I am excited for next chapters as well. Thank you book buddy

[@harris8n90]

👍....well explained

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

The world thinks that our religion does not emphasize logical reasoning is because our actions are illogical…… actions speak louder than words…..😊

[@piyushdas079]

Some voice spoke to a 56 year old man in desert without witness..very reasonable

[@nitadevi2042]

Who gives the rights to reconstruct Islam through Iqbal.

[@rajasabirali9856]

@@piyushdas079 go ahead and debunk what he preached and then I would second your sarcasm. Instead of putting in the effort don’t blow us away with your sarcasm. 🙏

[@samson1986]

Quran has said earlier that Allah created The whole universe in 7 Days and nights scientists before didn't believe it but now Science has found that Time in space travels at different speeds. They found this with the speed of light that travelled from someplace to our direction and the travelling speed of that light was different. We know that Speed is the distance covered over time, thus scientists concluded that the time we have in our part of the Universe is different from other parts and it is possible that our Million or billion of years could be equal to One day in the other part of the universe. This phenomenon is also defined in Film "Interstellar" I suggest you to watch this, it's amazing.

[@waqarahmad4116]

Randomly watch a video on science and Islam. I find you greatest person.

[@Legendgaming-sa]

Your knowledge is fantastic... You are the one who compels us to study Iqbal. Great job.👏👏

[@maheengul6702]

Allama Iqbal has always been a debated personality just because of his sheer ability to put fear aside and put up revolutionary thoughts like these on the forefront. I am absolutely amazed at how he justifies the strength of the faith embodied by him solely by questioning religion itself. The extraction that I took from this is that it is only the true believers that question faith and religion in the first place because they know that an answer always exists. Islam is indeed the perfect religion. Thank you so much for this review, looking forward to the entire series coming up 😁

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Absolutely

[@samson1986]

100% agree

[@Jugnumohsin489]

یہ آخری بیان بھی قرآن کی ایک آیت سے ماخوذ ہے (جو لوگ اپنی جدوجھد کا رخ ہماری طرف کر دیتا ہے ہم اس کو اپنے راستے دکھا دیتے ہیں)

[@sarimsarhan3937]

I love your work, take a lot of salam and dua from Bangladesh. And keep helping us to think and broaden our view.

[@lordtaseen2947]

This understanding of Ghazali is incorrect It is painfully obvious to anyone who ever read Ghazali, that he never spoke against science or empericism, Infact he endorsed it. Ghazali's understanding of cause and effect is exactly the same as the understanding of modern scientists

[@faisalkr]

Thanks for such profound information and realization of life according to Quran.

[@challengers607]

میں آپ کے کانٹینت کے ساتھ علم اور شعور کے لئے بہت شوق سے جڑا ہوں. بہت شکریہ

[@qadeeraltaf5058]

قرآن کا پسندیدہ موضوع انسانی نفسیات ہے..

[@masiramemon4193]

Book buddy it's a request if you can add English subtitles as it becomes a little difficult to comprehend the Urdu words you use while explaining even though it's very soothing to use but difficult to comprehend . Apart from this , a commendable explanation with so much enthusiasm 🙌 Thanks and Jazakallah, From India.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Can't promise Masira.. but will try

[@masiramemon4193]

@@BookBuddyOfficial Appreciated, jazakallah 🙌🙏

[@atifhshah1374]

KEEP IT GOING SIR, WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO KEEP UP WITH THE SERIES.

[@irfanillahi3446]

Great sir ,Allama Iqbal tried to to bring change in mental and physically stability in Muslims ,it's our weakness we are not implementing on Quran.

[@mhghori6237]

Shahrukh bhai I usually do not comment at all but i got compelled to comment on the excellent work you are doing specially with this series. Which I too strongly believe that will be life changing for all the seekers of the truth. May Allah reward you in abundance for your efforts brother. Keep up the great work!!!

[@asmafatima1917]

Allah ka bahot bahot shukar hai ki mujhe ye channel dekhna naseeb hua.. may Allah bless you ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

😊👍

[@Terminators4U]

@@BookBuddyOfficialI am sorry aap ki evolution kay videos achi hain baki aap Jerusalem syndrome aur evolution parh kar bhi logoon Ko misguide kar Rahay hain. Everyone has a full right to question what their parents were believing in. It’s time to study and be right about things. There is no God there.

[@farooqmasoodi3679]

Wow what an impressive exegetical explanation through a crystal clear manly voice. جزاك الله فاروق احمد مسعودى KSA

[@alishahhussaini728]

This is what i gathered. As the book title goes by the name of reconstruction of religious thought in islam. Hence, Iqbal, in my view , has tried to set the premise of continuous learning and use of rational to seek a more intimate contact with the reality. As Islam is like a coin, whose two sides are temporal and religious or deen and duniya or reason and revelation. These both things go hand in hand and parallel. They both are intermixed and cannot be separated as what Christians did with church and state. The backwardness of Muslims are due to the decrees of Ghazali who misunderstood that reason and revelation are completely separate tangibles and hence, swung his weight to the area of predestination when he struggled in some areas and as a result closed the gates of reasoning (ijtihad). This made Muslims backward because for them, the real intimate contact with the reality remained in the traditions of old generations. As for the religious part , the ultimate goal is the mystic experience or intuition which cannot be expressed. I think it is the same state when one's soul gets united with the divine light even when its alive in a physical abode (body). I believe Iqbal wont be staying to just using intellect to study temporal things like science and philosophy. This is just addressing one sphere of the coin i-e temporal, duniya and reason. He might soon stress that Muslims should revisit the physical forms of age long traditions and rituals which are no longer relevant in the contemporary time, place and circumstances. If that's the case, this would be a problem for the Muslims belonging to Sunni interpretation, because they look back to 1400 years old traditions for the salvation. Personally, as a Shia Muslim, i am perfectly okay with this because we believe that the authority of Imams (A.S) from Ahlul Bayt is to reinterpret Islam according to the age & time. Hence, adjusting the practices and forms of the rituals while keeping the essence intact. This would keep the universality of Islam alive in every age and would ensure that Muslims remain forward and not backward.

[@alishahhussaini728]

@@nomisatti1650 Lol... Hum kafiron k kafir, kafir khuda hamara !!!

[@malimed]

غزالی صاحب کا مقابلہ ایمانوال کانٹ سے... مجھے تو سوچ کر ہی الٹی آ گئی، کونسی بھنگ پیتے تھے علامہ صاحب

[@raziaghani9843]

Please tell your name when you start the program

[@missimiss5948]

I loved it 💕 Looking forward for chapter 2

[@sadiqhussain157]

صوفیانہ تجربے استادوں کی فنکاری ھے ۔یہ ماسٹر لوگ اپنے تجربے مصنوعی ذھانت سے لوگوں کو محسور کرنے کے لیے نۓ نۓ تجربےکرتے ھیں

[@noorzatkhan3111]

یہ درست ہے کہ اس فلسفے نے مسلمانوں پر جمود تاری کردیا کہ سب کچھ خدا کرتاہے۔ یعنی انسان کو سوچنے کی ضرورت نہیں بس سب کچھ خدا کی مرضی سے ہورہاہے ہم بس صرف تماشائی بنے اور تارک دنیا ہوکر ایک کونے میں بیٹھ کر ذکر الٰہی میں مشغول ہوکرمشاہدات کی منزلیں طے کرکے اعلیٰ مقام حاصل کرے اور یہ دنیا دنیا داروں کے لئے چھوڑ دیں ۔ جسکی وجہ سے ہم غیروں کے محکوم ہی رہیں گے۔ بس سب علم غیب سمجھ کر صرف نظر کرے حالانکہ پچھلی صدی کا علم غیب اب علم ظاہر بن گیا اور جوجو انسان کوشش کرے گا اسی طرح راستے کھولتے جائیں گے

[@senseijashin]

My dad used to say “Himmat e mard, maded e khuda” the last statement by Iqbal is what he was referring to and he has never read Iqbal! Goosebumps.

[@RaoAslam]

Shahrukh ,Ur work for nation building remarkable !

[@nasrullahadilnasrullahadil6620]

Shahruk Bhai. I watch your all videos from Balochistan. I'm your big fan. You made this book easy

[@usmanyounis4505]

مذہب میں بھی logic. لگتا ہے پر انسان کی عقل محدود ہے جو رب کی عطا ہے۔۔ اس کی عقل اتنی کامل نہیں کہ ہر چیز کا منطقی جواب نکال سکے اور یہ کہنا اسلام بلکل منطق کے مخالف ہے یہ بات غلط ہے جہاں تک انسان کا شعوراور عقل جاتی ہے اسے اسلام سمجھ آسانی سے آجاتا ہے بات آگے ایمان الغیب کی ہوتی ہے جو انسان کی عقل سے بالا تر چیزیں اللہ نے رکھ دی وہاں تک انسان نہیں پہنچ سکتا۔۔۔ یہی فرق ہے اللہ کے علم میں انسان کے۔ ایسا سمجھ لو اللہ کا علم سمندر ہے اور انسان نے جتنی بھی ترقی کی آج تک logic کے ذریعے عقل کے ذریعے وہ ایک قطرہ کے برابر بھی نہیں۔۔۔

[@sadiqhussain157]

دین اور قرآن میں فلسفہ نہیں حکمت ھوتی ھے فلسفےاور حکمت میں فرق ھے فلسفہ گمان ھے جبکہ حکمت حقیقت ۔فلسفےکا نہ نصاب نہ ادب جبکہ قرآن ایک مکمل خداٸ ادب بھی نصاب بھی مغرب نے فلسفے کو ساٸنس میں تبدیل کرکے اسے فطرت کا علم بنایا

[@kashifshahi9670]

کئی بار سن چکا ہوں ہر بار ایک نئے رنگ اور ذایقے سے آشنا ہوتا ہوں ❤

[@azadkhawaja]

Beautiful work and research, really made it easy to understand for a person like me. Congratulations on this effort. Looking forward to the next video.

[@sobanahmed2012]

ASR e Nou Raat hay ,Dhundla sa sitaraa TU hay...... Ustaaz Book Buddy is love...

[@sabeenaahmad2363]

Growing up in a Muslim family it becomes so hard to put hard logical questions regarding religion in front of our adults although it is encouraged in our religion... I believe such initiative will not only improve our thinking and reasoning for our generation to come and also enhance our own relationship with Allah and Islam.

[@realenlight92]

Bro in that you are not alone. So don't blame your muslim origin.

[@MajidMajid-rr4rg]

کیا جس مسٹک تجربہ کی بات کی گئی ہے وہ قران سے یا حدیث سے ثابت ہے ؟ شاید اسی مسٹر تجربے کے شوق نے مسلمانوں کو عمل سے ہٹا کر مراقبون ہر لگایا ہے۔ اگر ایسا خوئی تجربہ ہے بھی تو وہ عمل کی دنیا میں رہتے ہوے ہونا چاہیے جیسا کہ صلح حدیبیہ سے پہلے حلف کے موقع کا ذکر کرتے ہوے اللہ تعلی کہتا ہیکہ ' انکے ہاتھ پر میرا ہاتھ تھا' ۔

[@questionstothinkshamas]

Great... Philosophy is necessary for religious beliefs as well. Logically explained. Thank you

[@ehsanulhaq9382]

یونانی فلسفہ اور ہندوستانی جوگپن سے الگ قرآن کا اعلی پیغام اقبال ہی سمجھ سکے تھے، یہ تصوف کے نام پہ دکانداری چمکانے اور سجادوں کے نام پر جن نکالنے اور موروثی جاگیرداری چلانے والے کبھی نہیں جان سکیں گے. حکایتیں گا اور سنا کر سلانے والے لٹیرے ہیں سب کے سب

[@MajidMajid-rr4rg]

مسلمانون کے پیچھے رہ جانے کی ایک بڑی وجہ بے شک یہی ہیکہ انہونے دین کی تعلیم کو سمجھا کہ وہ دنیا کی تعلیم سے علحیدہ ہے اور دنیا کی تعلیم غیر اہم ہے اللہ سے تعلق کے لئے بلکہ اس تعلق مین رکاوٹ ہے۔ یہ تصور 6 یا 7 سو سال بعد مسلمانون مین جڑ پکڑ گیا۔ اگرچہ کے قران نے انسان کو اسکی پہلی عظمت دنیا کی تعلیم ہی کے ذریعہ دی یعنی حضرت آدم کو اسماء کا علم دیکر فرشتون کو انہین سجدہ کرنے کا حکم دیکر اور دین کی تعلیم کے لئے کہا کہ جب وہ جنت سے دینا مین پہنچے تو انہین اللہ تعلی کی ہدایت پہنچے گی جس پر عمل کرکے وہ دوبارہ جنت کا حصول ممکن بنا سکتے ہین ۔ اس لئے اسلامی تعلیمات مجموع ہین دینی ہدایات اور دنیا کو سمجھنے کا۔ لیکن صوفی ازم کے نام پر اس تصور کو بھلا کر خدا تک پہنچنے کا راستہ ہی بدل دیا گیا۔ آج بھی لوگ مراقبون کی بات کرتے ہین حالانکے پورے قران مین ایسا کوئی تصور نہین اور مسلمان کا راستہ اس سے کہین بلند ہے جو ہیکہ اس دنیا مین رہتے ہوے اسکی ساری آزمائشون سے گزرتے ہوے اللہ کی محبت اور اسکے احکامات کو ہر دم ذہن مین رکھنا ہی مسلمان کا مراقبہ ہے۔

[@shafiqrahman2332]

اپ نے بہت خوب اور اسان زبان میں کایئنات، انسان اور قران کی دعوت کو سمجھانے کی کوشش کی ہے شکریہ

[@transformme1]

The explanation is fantastic but I understand it after watching the video for 3 times and now I feel headache .But I thank BOOK BUDDY for explaining such an astonishing Book Which is hard to read and understand .

[@muhamedjunaid6778]

Islam has no answer to skepticism…so I will still remain agnostic.

[@junaiddar6929]

Islam is answer and ultimate answer. U have met few illogical so called teachers. You tell me here and I tell you. Quran is not a book, it is the word of Allah and word of Allah is his knowledge to share with.

[@ehsanullah3253]

Hazrat Alama Almashraqi aor Hazrat Maulana Wahidudin ke thafseer es bara ma bahoot Mufeed han

[@ehsanullah3253]

Ketaba Maarafat Of Maulana Wahidudin is also help full

[@questionstothinkshamas]

Wow The ending statement touched my emotions. Thank you sir Keep it up.

[@elvis-slippers]

This statement has brought me to a state where it's really difficult for me to stay strong and act on the basic practice of my Deen.

[@aimanshahbaz]

@@elvis-slippers It has brought to me a point where I have found clarity to some questions that I have been asking Allah since a few days.

[@1huzaifaa]

Very well explained. Thank you Sir for making it so easy for us ❤

[@sultanaqamar372]

علامہ اقبال رحمتہ اللہ علیہ تو اب ہم میں نہیں ہیں آللہ تعالیٰ انکے درجات بلند فرمائے تو یہ کتاب وہ لکھ کر گئے ہیں یا انکے نظریات اور تحقیقات اور تجربات کو کسی نے ترتیب دیا ہے اگر ایسا ہے تو وہ کون صاحب ہیں ان کے بارےمیں بھی جاننا چاہیں گے شکریہ

[@samson1986]

You are Amazing Man!❤️ just love you🏵️ sending you lots of prayers❤️ keep enlightening us✨

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thank You! 😊

[@Atharva1973]

Sufism is Polytheism same as Hinduism. In islam the Creator & his creation is separate. In Sufism & Hinduism they are one.

[@onlyitj]

It is because of Greek thought and philosophy, Muslims started scientific inquiry, and it sparked a golden age in the Islamic civilization. Which also lead to enlightenment in Europe. Iqbal philosophy has led us to Pakistan, and even Pakistanis doesn't understand it. In my observation, you're too impressed and biased towards Iqbal, and have surface level knowledge of Greek or Stoic philosophy, just to put them aside.

[@zainmalik457]

Exactly What we need, this lecture is far far better what universities are delivering

[@asadijaz7875]

What a knowledge delivered by sir sharukh nadeem, i hope these video series help to change the mind myths and cultrual misconceptions about islam. & also help to understand that islam is not a name of just ibadat.

[@AlviSultan]

🇨🇦 Mr. Shah Rukh, Please tell us how much time and effort did it take for you to understand this series on Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam, by Allama Iqbal? Thank you.

[@ekasnav]

Started listening to you excellent endeavor. Having said that you mentioned at around 1130 in this lecture that Iqbal went that far to conclude that due to Ghazali muslims left everything to Hukm Illahi and stopped using knowledge (to which I agree) but where does Iqbal say this?

[@KrishanKaura]

Mein samjta hun aap ki majburi, kyon quran ko knowledge ka chasma bata rehe ho, agar quran knowledge aur science ka chasma hei to fir yeh dunya bhi jannat hi hei. Are jo ved puran gita gyan aur kuchh had tak science batate hein mein unhe bhi nhi maan sekta to quran ki kya baat any how u r nice person mein aapki majburyan samjta hun, go on

[@waliul280]

in Quran, Allah SWT said "afalaa ta'qiluun". This shows that Allah instructed use to think rationally. Allah SWT also made multiple claims of Quran being free of contradictions, which is another example of the value of rationality. Logic is objective and whatever we perceive is via logic. Anything which is not logical is contradictory and doesn't make any sense. So Islam has to be in line with aql. Or else it will be false. I agree we need both spiritual experience. But we also need sound reasoning too . Or else there will be no objectivity. Everyone will have subjective truths. Truth is objective. Truth does not care about our feelings or perception. Intuition/Fitrah is hardwired into us by Allah SWT as a catalyst to know the truth (that Allah exists). But the problem is our fitrah can be clouded due to external influences of our society, cultural upbringing etc. Therefore logic is needed as an apriori parameter which will pave the way to absolute truth.

[@saleemjafri1696]

In his book "The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam," Iqbal praised Imam al-Ghazali as a great philosopher and mystic who had a profound influence on Islamic thought. He referred to al-Ghazali as the "reviver of the second half of the Islamic intellectual tradition" and highlighted his contributions to theology, philosophy, and Sufism. Iqbal also praised al-Ghazali's approach to philosophy and his efforts to reconcile reason and revelation. He argued that al-Ghazali's emphasis on the importance of inner spiritual experience and direct knowledge of the divine was essential for reviving the spiritual dimension of Islam. Iqbal saw al-Ghazali's philosophy as a way of combining rational inquiry with spiritual practice and achieving a deeper understanding of the nature of reality. Please clear this thing while discussing Gazali!

[@WaqasAhmad-fo4iy]

In the first chapter of the book reconstruction of religious thought , there's a profound verse from the Quran, Surah Al-Baqarah, which encapsulates a fundamental aspect of knowledge. It recounts the dialogue between Allah and the angels when Allah declares His intention to create a vicegerent on earth. The angels express concern, questioning why Allah would grant authority to humans who might bring about destruction and shed blood. Allah responds, asserting His wisdom beyond their comprehension. Then, Allah teaches Adam the names of all things and presents him before the angels, challenging them to name those things. However, the angels fail, while Adam successfully names everything. This verse highlights a crucial concept: the essence of knowledge begins with naming. It's through our ability to assign names to things that we comprehend and communicate about them. Whether it's trees, atoms, or genes, the foundation of knowledge lies in the act of naming. This profound insight from the Quran underscores the significance of language and naming in the acquisition and dissemination of knowledge.

[@zameer859]

beautifully explained, couple of years i bought this book but i couldn't understand it very well.

[@redroses4237]

You are doing great job. It's difficult to read a book and later explain as well. Less views indicate our national interest in book reading or logical approach to some issue.

[@mshahzaib4195]

Good explination by the Book Buddy. But wow! I have never seen more hand-waving reasoning in life. Make claims so big that people get awed and fooled.

[@shahidvirk1856]

Not sure what is your mother tongue But if you are Punjabi, you can explain better, because Punjabi is the richest language on the planet Depending on your vocabulary of the great Punjabi language

[@farhanpathan2976]

I think Greek philosophers were also interested in how the universe works not just on human social life, that's why Democratis came to the conclusion that everything in nature is made of tiny particles (atoms) to form different forms, and sophists who were worried about how nature works, on of the Greek philosophers said that sun is only a giant ball of fire and not a god, and they were the first to came to conclusion that everything must have a single primary cause, Greek philosopher Plotinus who was a follower of Neoplatonism school called this it "THE ONE" which most probably is the steping stone of monotheism.

[@justaaim]

It is impossible for a rationalist to fathom the depth of spiritual experience as they would not let go their intellect to dare exploring and experiencing spiritual world. Thy would rather stay at the margins and call the "dare devils" naïve. Unfortunately there are many ilks of Perwaiz Hoodbhoy who are using their ill directed energies to deny Iqbal the status of a philosopher. The reconstruction of religious thought in Islam may be a guide to them.

[@akkuboddu]

Quran is copied from book of Thorah. Zameen chapti hai ...yeah quran kehtha hai....kya yeh sach hai?

[@exploretheglobe358]

At one point you said the Quran guided the Muslims towards the observation of physical world and non-Muslims were not aware of it until modern discoveries. Later on, you mentioned that the Quran is not for Muslims only in its purpose but for all human. This thing is the negation of your first comment that I think you uttered without considering what are you saying. Although, its s very precise essence of the first chapter but you left many things unattended or without explanation.

[@sabeelahmad27]

Dear buddy, you have made a generic video that is good for an amature to learn Iqbaliyat. Please include the scholarly interpretation of all the philosophers and scientists mentioned by Iqbal in his chapter, as well as the teleological, cosmological, ontological debate, time-space, finite, and infinite discussions.

[@RakeshKumar-x5x1g]

Ex Muslim sahil , Sameer,adam,jaffar heritic,harrish sultan,fatima ,noor ahmad ,dekhe islam me akal ka dakhl ho jayega

[@UsmanGhani-vf3ow]

Because of this lecture I subscribe your good channel. Thanks for sharing these kind of super thoughts

[@questionstothinkshamas]

Sir, as per my experience we can measure happiness level of someone. Although the subject directly may be unable to explain clearly about his/her happiness.

[@AlviSultan]

🇨🇦 How can you measure the level of Happiness of anyone, including your own? Please explain!

[@Malikjamil-z6b]

*VVV* *الحمد. لللہ رب العالمین* *الرحمن۔ الرحیم* *مالک۔ یوم۔ الدین*

[@muhammadrazirizvi1777]

تیمور الرحمان فرماتے ہیں کہ دین صرف پرسنل ہوتا ہے آپ ان سے متفق نہیں

[@thetirelesscrusader4745]

Dr WHodbury would disagree with what you are claiming in this video.

[@Tanzeela-i2y]

Please make a detailed video on Fyodor Dostoevsky please...and also on his famous novel Crime and Punishment

[@with_HU]

did you itself experienced it? it is subjective in nature , not objective then without 1st experiencing it how can say anything about it?

[@manzoorahmed1951]

Great work and explanation. Excellent use of words and vocabulary. Thanks 🙏

[@esotericwisdom49]

Thanks Shahruk Bhai for your wonderful explanation.i recommend you one more book of Nasir khusrow ( between reason and revelation.(twin wisdoms reconciled) translation from the Persian by Eric ormsby. another book of this great philosopher is (make a shield from wisdom) translated and introduced by Annemarie schimmel

[@baljitchopra6054]

Your posts are highly inspiring . Keep your good work for the benefit of humanity.

[@lyzaal_official]

Teachers: Iqbal was just a poet nothing else (wo aya aur shayari karke chala gaya) Me: laughing 🤣😁

[@mirirfan1318]

It's very difficult to understand the message of God and universe. God sent the Prophets ,scholars and philosophers to decipher the same message but it needs an effort in our part too to reach our cognitive and intuitive results. Religion as well as analytical thought are two inseparable things.

[@iqbalinstitute6999]

I always said that,there is no deeni or dunyavi ilm,every knowledge is from god,which is revealed for those who think.

[@alfaizabdullah2935]

" God helps them who helps themselves." ( In short a famous saying)

[@akkuboddu]

Most of the phrases Iqbal ne Geetha se copy kiya hai...hindu se convert huva tha na....hehehe

[@abdulkhaliq5151]

زبردست جناب ❤

[@KhanKhan-mr3hj]

wow ,last statement ny meri aik question solve ki may hamesha soochta tha k kaisy aik Ayatullah Humini ny ny inqalab berpaa kiyaa... matlub k akily kaisy ! aub samja yaar.....

[@diamondtv8894]

بہت خوب

[@rehanjawaid]

Good lecture . detail are at initial stage.

[@HappyKafir]

Molvi soch ki truck ki batti = Aapki pasmandagi ki wajah

[@MuhammadAsif-ln6ez]

Your 25-minute video took 3 hours to understand it. Sure, it was a very dense video or knowledge.

[@faisaljamil9279]

This is much better methodical approach to explain nuances, would appreciate if you can take us much deeper into the concepts

[@hamzaslife1234]

You are using a lot of word's from old Urdu which is hard to understand it would be Great if you use simple modern day Urdu

[@piyushdas079]

Some voice spoke to a 56 year old man in desert without witness..very reasonable

[@factsfinder4359]

Our education, experience, skills are stored on brain memory as a knowledge and thought is responce of that knowledge. When memory of brain at certain problems is pressurized to find the solution then intuition is developed.

[@AlviSultan]

🇨🇦 At the end of your vlogs, instead of goodbye, say till we meet again!

[@funterestingstudio4848]

This video demands your 100 percent concentrations

[@amirali25555]

Very informative speech Shah Rukh Sir appreciate your efforts. Dr Allama Muhammad IQbal ❤️

[@rajaaashraf4799]

MashaAllah , keep it up 🎉, well done

[@kashikhan3052]

sir kindly some vedios uploded for formhative phase of pakistan khalid bin sayed

[@IqbalMuhammad-n7j]

Bhai men apko dawt data hu k AP al ktab by Ahmed esa ya naba7 documentary dakhen apka opr asy raz khulaga k AP dng rajaenga?

[@drteeka7883]

Qur'an Pak non believers k liay aaya tha ,na k Muslims k liay. Jo iss ki maan gya who Muslim ho gya