Difference between Shia and Sunni (Urdu/Hindi)| After The Prophet | Lesley Hazleton | Book Review

#shiasunniconflict #aftertheprophet #lesleyhazleton
Today I present a detailed review of a classic book written by Lesley Hazleton "After the Prophet". In the video, I discuss in detail about the main reasons of conflict between Shia and Sunni muslims. I also discuss the circumstances and the state of affairs right after the death of Holy Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). The video will give you a deep insight into what went wrong after the Holy Prophet left the world. The review is based on all the incident which have been quoted in the book but I give my perspective at the end of the video.
Press the Like and Button and Subscribe to my Channel for regular video Updates.
*************************** ****************************** . ******************************
Time to ignite and initiate your learning habits.
I am Shah Rukh; a corporate professional, a teacher at heart, a learner by thought and a reading enthusiast by design. Book Buddy is my initiative to rejuvenate the learning and reading culture in our country. Book Buddy is a platform through which you can acquire knowledge and learning as I dissect and comprehend books for easy understanding.
All you need to do is view my videos where I summarize books and key learnings part of their text, so it’s learning on the go. The platform also enables me to talk about vocabulary words so my audience can simultaneously improve their reading and writing skills. I also dedicate some time to shoot informative videos on interesting topics, which can help you learn and grow. I want every person in the country to have a penchant for reading and learning. Therefore, my mission is known as "Mission Read Pakistan."
Subscribe to my Channel to start your learning Journey. Like, Share and Subscribe
/ bookbuddyoff. .
You can also follow me on Facebook, by clicking the below link
/ dabookbuddy

[@ahsrizvi6264]

I appreciate your conclusion.

[@alinatasneem1]

And, it is the Jewish author who is researching our religion and taking advantage! and we muslims are just in conflict with each other. Hope muslim ummah will reunite one day!

[@user-dq8jv6lf8o]

Wow your last words is magical I second you Hazrat Muhammad swa mentioned his successor in a very loud voice Man kunto mola fahaza Ali yun Mola💓

[@danyalkhaliq915]

And Who did Prophet Mohammad SAWW made Imam of Namaz during his life time ?

[@jawadmalik9938]

@@danyalkhaliq915 mola ali as

[@danyalkhaliq915]

@@jawadmalik9938 kis Kitaab Mai parh liya Bhai ? Har Kitaab Mai Naam ha tu Sirf Abu Bakar RA ka

[@danyalkhaliq915]

@@jawadmalik9938 and in Quran Khalifa bananay k liya Khalifa ka word hi use kra ha Allah nay moula ka vague word use nahi kra khalifa bananay k liye. Prophet Mohammad SAWW bhe Khalifa hi word use krte agr iska meaning wo hota Jo aap loog lete hain

[@mohammadhaider4417]

@@danyalkhaliq915 Allah k bandy, khalifa Kam darja ha jabke Mola supreme darja ha, khalifa ko tum pr tumhari Jano sy ziada haq nahi jabke Mola ko Jo Rasool ( s.a.w) ne waziha bhi kia ! Usko humari Jano pr humsy ziada haq ha!! Or ye bat Rasool (s.a.w) ne ghadeer me khud Khai!!!

[@najmhassan7310]

18 zilhaj khutba huj tul wida ko Hazrat Muhammad p.b.u.h NY fysla kr dea tha .. And GoD bless u sir bhot acha review dea.

[@khadija4801]

At 9:39 an important correction, as per Shia's believe, The marriage of Hazrat Ali's Daughter Umm Kulthum with Caliph Umar never occured.

[@ruhmafatima5142]

Exactly

[@bahauddinkhan6303]

The crux is the conclusion of the story .... but I think we don't have to fall into minor differences, let's get together and be a strong ummah and take our glory back....

[@dawarali6176]

Mola Ali (a.s)

[@MSKhan-vg7wm]

Its is not important that who is first or fourth Khalifa..........the important thing is we all believe in 1 kalima .....la ilaha ill-lalla Muhammadur rasulula

[@fareedchaudhry6814]

Absolutely. However we should also read history in detail and research who was right and who was not? If Yazid was such a villain beyond any shadow of doubt, I want to know who put him in charge of the Muslim ummah? What was that person thinking? Also, who in his/her sane mind would challenge a towering figure like Ali ra? I would be on Ali's side any day even though I am a sunni by birth.

[@shohrathussain2673]

Saath mein ali wali ullah bhi lagaein, jo sarey fisaad ki jar hey.

[@beawesometoday.4411]

Bilkul Bhai Kalmi ko poora kary Ali un Waliullah

[@MdImran-th9tu]

Right my brother ❤️

[@sa2164]

@@shohrathussain2673 نام تمہارا شہرت حسین ھے مگر تم علی یون ولی اللہ کو فساد کی جڑ کہہ رھے ھو۰ اصل میں اگر سب علی یون ولی اللہ وصی رسول اللہ پر متفق ھو جائیں تو سارا فساد ختم ھو جاۓ گا -

[@aftabahmed1441]

بے شک علی علیہ السلام ہی نبی آخر الزماں صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے نامزد کردہ جانشین تھے

[@Sajidkhan-tk5pm]

There’s no evidence that prophet declared his successor.He left this to the his companions to decide.Islam is clearly against dynastic politics then how prophet would have selected his son in law as a caliph.No one denied the status of Hazart Ali.

[@zahidkarim9541]

Ali Ali dam hama dam Ali

[@zoeyanaqvi-zn7482]

Very good book. A great research article ! I love the research work. It is a part of my library. I had subscribed your channel just yesterday. Wonderful effort ! Keep it up ! Reading and research is the sign of a living nation

[@whistleblower9052]

I recently read "The Cold War In The Islamic World". It is also a wonderful book to understand the context of current conflicts b/w muslim countries, particularly Iran and Saudi Arabia.

[@Mrymkhn]

Hazrat Ali (R.A) status is already high in our Prophet Muhammad's life. Islamic history says that Hazrat ABI Bakr and Umar(R.A) sent proposal for Fatima's (R.A) but Prophet Muhammad's SAW preferred Ali's (R.A) proposal. Keep in mind that our Prophet Muhammad's (SAW) never did anything without Allah Subhanahu WataAllah's consent. So Ali (R.A) was chosen for Fatima (Jannah's keys holder) by Allah Subhanahu WataAllah. It was obvious to be the first khalifa because Prophet Muhammad's SAW chose Hazrat ABI Bakr as His companion for Khare dhor/sor and Hazrat ABI Bakr (R.A) was the first companion who believed our Prophet (SAW) after Lalatul Mairaj when everyone doubted. That's how He got the name Siddique.

[@mehsumabbas72]

Amazing review sir especially loved how you concluded with your opinion, I think it’s very logical explanation that the greatest human being on earth could never leave the Ummah without a successor. Hats off sir ♥️

[@cacacompany5869]

It’s the same argument between Sunni Shia which you mentioned in the review. That the Sunni accepting reality as it is and Shias looking the ideal what should have been. Despite your talk about logic and coming terms with the conclusion based on evidence, you have gone for the conclusion ‘what it should been’. It appears to me the The Prophet PBUH did not explicitly state his heir without ambiguity and did not mention a name. Your statement he wouldn’t have gone without naming his heir is fallacy and not based on fact but on wishful thinking. If the Prophet PBUH had named a name, then one assumes it would have been stated in an official announcement rather the in potentially ambiguous statement in front of few people. Accept the fact that no public announcement was made about the heir in Prophet’s PBUH lifetime and leave it at that.

[@kumail9090]

​@cacacompany5869 of course the Rasool e Kareem saw the last prophet who had brought the last message of Allah to the whole humanity has announced his successor publicly at Ghadeer e Khoom. He (saw) left no stone unturned to appoint and announce his successor. But after centuries of false history which was written under the brutal and barbaric monarchs of Banu Ommia and Banu Abbas how could you believe in this fact. Even in Sahee Bukhaari it is narrated that the Holy Prophet saw during his last moments asked for pen and paper to document his successor to legalise and decreed it further but his faithful companions deprived him and at that crucial historic moment the whole omma lost the last and final opportunity to be united forever.

[@fqureshi100]

As a book lover myself, and somewhat dismayed by general population not taking too much interest in book reading, your efforts are a breath of fresh air. Kudos to you. Keep it up. I m sure it is helping generate interest in books in many a people.

[@ashokaagniashokaagni1876]

Loved your review, very to the point and succinct, Best of luck to you Shah Rukh. Love from Iran

[@shujahaider5899]

our PROPHET (SAWW) on his last HAJJ ADDRESS to the Whole MUSLIM UMMAH and tell them that, two most important thing he is gonna left between us is, 1) QURAN 2) AL'HEBAIT (sa) its clear then who would be the successor.... !!

[@hafizhasnainashraf3382]

what is wrtten in surah ahzab verse 59 surah toubah verse 40

[@icsp94]

The Event of Ghadeer in the Holy Quran1) “O Messenger (of Allah)! Convey what has been revealed to you from your Lord. And if you do it not, then you have not, delivered His message (prophethood), and Allah will protect you from the people. Surely Allah will not guide the disbelieving people.” (Surah Maidah, 5:67). 2) This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed. My favor on you and chosen for you Islam as a religion.” (Surah Maidah, 5:3) 3) “One questioner demanded, the chastisement which must befall.” (Surah Ma’arij:1) “O Messenger Convey…” (Refer first verse). The Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) on divine command, announced the leadership and mastership of Hazrat Ali (a.s.). He made Hazrat Ali (a.s.)’s obedience compulsory and enmity towards him tantamount to enmity against Allah.

[@MSKhan-vg7wm]

I don't believe in shia sunni .....I only believe In Allah

[@alizaffar1272]

Agr apko Srf khuda pr yakeen ha to ap yakeen krien gy k bhala Muhammad wa Aly Muhammad se koi b afzal nai ho skta ap dekhien jin hastiyon pr khuda pak or khuda pak k farishty... jab wo khuda pak jo Malik hain hr cheez k wo Muhammad wa Aly Muhammad pr drood bejty hain to mera nai khyal k isse Bari koi ibadat ho skti ha beshk Allah pak ki zaat sab se Bari ha Mola pak hm sab ki hidayat krien Ameen ....

[@muhammadsajid2709]

It doesn't matter what you believe, rather matter what is reality.

[@Abbas-px7sy]

Have you read the Quran? Haven't came across ayat e mawaddat ?

[@tariqismail1051]

You have presented this sensitive issue and review in a very respectable way because all our religious personalities are honorable for us. After the prophet ( p.b.u.h) our history 0f caliphate is complex due to conflicts, confusion and conspiracies of all the enemies of Islam. Only Allah knows best.The holy Quran and Sunnah is our guideline to succeed in hereafter .

[@syedzaidi8902]

All muslims should follow sunnah but the question is who should we take the sunnah from. Shia historians say the holy prophet(PBUP) prayed with hands down and sunni historians say he prayed with his hands folded. When Muawia came with an army to fight Ali(AS). Ali(AS) called upon muslims by saying: we are Ahle beit you should fallow us, in response muawia came up with a slogan saying we are ahle sunnah, you should follow us. Allah has given free-will to every one, who we follow depends upon who we are from inside.

[@shohrathussain2673]

History of khilafat is not complex, it is made complex by shia yahudies. Hazrat ali RA had never never objected over any khalifa, and accepted khilafat of all the 3 khulfaa.

[@mominayahya4632]

Very beautifuly reviewed. I had this book siting in my shelf for quite some time now, now I'm motivated to read it

[@tasadduqmehdi1756]

Great analysis at the end. I appreciate you for your unbiased analysis. I was thinking to write what you said at the end. May Allah help all of us to reach real truth.

[@poetryhub9852]

I apreciate you, since you have summarized the whole book in few minutes, a little addition from my side to your excellency is that the book was no doubt a masterpiece, and the author has vividly jotted down the actual crux of Islamic history. Yet painful, however interesting to discuss the horrendous sagas of Islamic history, how and why those catastrophic events happened despite the clear appointment of Hazrat Ali A.S as the successor. We must be unbiased when it comes to history and need to know those kinds of gruesome and heart-wrenching incidents.

[@ikramumer717]

Bro, thanku for let us know about you 🙂 Strongly having firm believe in your reviews.

[@syedabbashashim6763]

Mola aap ko Shaad rakhain Bhai .. full of logic opinion... Mujhe poora yaqeen h hamare Sunni Bhai bhi yehi sochtay hongay lekin unki bhi majboori h ya tou family religion ko Manain ya reality ko.

[@eshaalkhan8368]

Sir a humble request , which is that u should use subtitles through which we can easily understand the tough words of the context, it might b helpful while debate with someone in English language.. thank u 😊

[@usmanliaqat350]

Good Review. @Book Buddy 👍 And also like your opinion at the end. But i think If He (P.B.U.H) had appointed His successor, His Companions would have obeyed his order. Even weak believers like us cannot dare to disobey Him then how could His Companions who had strong believe had dare to disobey His order !?

[@asmamehmood9944]

Kon tha prophet pbuh ka successor ?

[@zainabalmas2192]

@@asmamehmood9944 Hazrat Ali 🙏🙏🙏

[@asmamehmood9944]

@@zainabalmas2192 Indeed he is...

[@Anarchist369]

​@@zainabalmas2192hazrat ali aur hazrat Abu Bakr donon nhi tha successor...balki Nabi ka Furman hai Khilafat quraish mai rahega...Allah ki marzi thi hazrat Abu Bakr pehla aur hazrat ali chotha ban gya... listen to engineer Muhammad Ali

[@GhareluNuskhe1]

Bhai Allah aap ko salamat rakhe Good conclusion by you Specially your opinion in last about wasiyat of Rasool Allah s.a.w

[@waqarhussain2060]

I appreciate your conclusion buddy. I read this book a long time ago and you reviewed it extremely to the point

[@AliAli-zw4zf]

At Ghadeer e Khum , Rasool (as) has clearly said by raising the hand of Imam Ali (as) that Jis kha mein mola aus kha Ali mola

[@VoiceOfAamna]

You are my favourite ... My inspiration ... Keep it up ❤

[@babarkaleem]

Last lines of your video cleared everything. Great job buddy.

[@zameerabbas3357]

so great! informative video,thanks bai. may allah bless you

[@safwanmujawar9102]

Very well explained bhaijaan, keep making such beautiful videos

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

thanks Safwan

[@muhammadtalharaja2119]

Shahrukh bhai what i have deduced that if Hazrat Umar R.A had given page and pen to write will that there would be discrepancy after my departure when Beloved S.A.W.S asked for then these discrepancies and horrible nature of conflicts would never have arisen.on the matter of successor i concur with your last words.Beloved Prophet A.S said my relation/association to Ali is aken to relation/association between Hazrat Musa and Haroon A.S.So when hazrat Moses would go anywhere he would designate his brother to instruct and guide his nation.So what should be inferred from it.I think hint is enough for the sage ones

[@hamzakhan9045]

Oo please shut up... Don't needed your false opinion

[@syedshariquebabar3193]

Beautiful summary/review of the book.

[@cricketlover-sc5zd]

Kudos to your hard work and honest history review, you really have done a great job where the majority of Muslims avoid speaking about Islamic history or having the least knowledge that always creating misunderstanding between sects within Islam...

[@TheUndergroundRockstar]

Thank you for summarizing such an important book in such a wise and mature way.

[@muhammadmehdi4710]

خدا تمہیں سلامت رکھے حق بات کرنے پہ

[@jahanzebmalik7924]

Though I’m in process of reading this book but this is one of the best and simplistic review I have ever came across Good Job!!

[@SaimyPk]

buhat shandar ap nye revirw kia aur apna opnion bhi dia.. Its really a very bold step.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thank u Saima

[@husnainjabbar6064]

"Ali is testimony to the fact that the most beautiful ideals must perish in the world of sordid politics."

[@sripal.jain4]

ShahRukh - I appreciate your knowledge and fluidity (raftar) on the subject ... 👌

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thank u Mr. Jain

[@glamgalvogue9741]

This is my first time at your review and I must say that you explained the notorious situation post Prophet Muhammad really well.Keep up with your research and simple explanation bcuz we are done with long clueless fatwaas

[@shohrathussain2673]

Jahilon ko tau tamaam fatwey clueless hi nazar aaengay. Tu sunaker khizar hayat sahab ko.10 moharram mananay mein konsa fatwa nazar aata hey, ghhora sajaney mein konsa fatwa nazar aata hey.Shia yahudion ka koi mazhab nahein siwaey sahaba par tabarra kerney kay.

[@ansaqeel1109]

This is one of the best book I have read and it cleared a lot of my queries regarding this Shia Sunni difference.

[@hadihassan372]

It’s obvious when you read the book who’s the heir .... love what you did at the end.

[@naghmayasmine9152]

Nice explaination, Plz do more and more videos bhai.

[@asifriaz6308]

You have greatly done true justice with this review brother! Completely agreed with your conclusion

[@anfal6664]

I completely agree with your last point.

[@ZakirHussain-px5ou]

either you avoided or forgot to talk about event of pen and paper mentioned in this book too!

[@thevision3603]

Listen according to Sunni scholars there is consensus that that was a misconstrued story came down orally as there was no mechanism of writing history with authentic sources so there was alot fabrication in stories which was come down ear to ear or speculated. And then you , I believe , read this which has alot academic flaws because on several occasions ,the writer turned very subjective and tried to enforce her conclusion on the reader , and developed alot of assumption which presented as judgements , you can find the word such "seemed , suggested , implied ,etc which indicates that the writer has developed her own conclusion to give a new meaning to a whole event...

[@alessonoftheday7860]

Well done 👍...You have presented this very well...I have many reservations on the authenticity of sources...Tarikh Tabari written by Imam Tabari RA is very weak which contains many narrations of Abu Mikhanf like narrators..which were Galee...

[@ghadeeri6636]

Excellent review, you concluded perfectly and truly, welldone brother. Man Kuntu Mola Fahaza Ali Mola. Baqol molana Tariq Jameel sahab Mola ka matlab Sardar or leader k hain.. Jannat kay sardar Ali k baity han, jannat ki oraton ki sardar Fatimah Jo jo jannat ma jany k leya koshish kr rha hay is Pak hastioyon ka daman tham lo bhaiyon. Ali haq k sath hay or Haq Ali k sath...

[@alizaazam5719]

sahaba pur sub sai afzal ali a.s hai

[@mansooriqbal86]

All I ll say is..... I am in love with ur content.... Stay blessed always 🥰🥰🥰

[@syedabushrah]

Very comprehensive review, I must say! Hats off! You explained all the key points without getting controversial or crossing the fine line! ❤️ totally loved it.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Appreciate your comments Bushra

[@mujtabashah3667]

I appreciate this rather sedate and impartial review Shahruk. It is quite comforting to see how openly such issues; that were once extremely sensitive, are being discussed in todays Pakistan. I believe the flashpoints of Muslim history and it’s consequences can be gauged from the actions of certain groups and personalities. One simply needs to see the current state of the muslim world and wonder how things went so wrong. Fantastic archeological research has been conducted by western academia, and one can see how the narrative fits according to written records and events from muslim historicity. As the adage goes that we learn history to make sense of the present, but the sad fact is that not many do. Early records of muslim history, or hadith, was written several centuries after the demise of Prophet Muhammad (saw), and a lot of it is contradictory and coloured to the ruling arab dynasties that emerged from those strifes. It is sensible to make note that any semblance of the religion of love and compassion that has been salvaged can be attributed to the sacrifices and works of the Prophetic lineage. We live in an exciting age where we’re now able to renew our understanding of religion quite openly.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Agreed with whatever you have stated Mujtaba. Bullseye...the aim is to promote discourse in our society so we have the inner tolerance to tolerate pluralism and difference of thought

[@AbdulHameed-bw4cg]

Agreed. Another sad part of today's Muslims is one group is controlled by Iranian Rdgime and mosta others by Arab Regimes. So, best approach for a common Muslim is to avoid these influences and adopt habit of research. That is why I follow(not blindly) AL MAWRID

[@muhammadharis847]

@@AbdulHameed-bw4cg are you talking about the institution Al MAWRID?

[@AbdulHameed-bw4cg]

@@muhammadharis847 Yes, mostly Mr. Javed Ahmed Ghamidi. But, not as last word.

[@History_Times412]

Great sir, I think according to the history of Mohammad the successor was Ali; the door of knowledge.

[@ummah1016]

so nice information for everyone of us thanks for giving information to us

[@asadshahbukhari8928]

You are doing a great job book buddy Keep it up ✨

[@GoodDeedsLeadTo]

Mufti Tariq Masood is an outstanding scholar & has authored few books. He is one of the right people to hear from on this subject. Dr. Yasir Qadhe out of east Plano Epic Islamic center is another one. They are back the objective, critical thinkers and speak with solid evidence. Where did Leslie Hamilton get her information from, what books?

[@Customfoodmachinery]

I have read this book . After one minute u said "لاکھوں فالوورز" ۔۔ and i m trying to recall where is this statistics mentioned in the book . Could u pls enlighten me with the page number where لاکھوں is mentioned .. i b obliged n corrected.

[@zeeshansarfraz6951]

Almighty Allah give unity to whole Muslim Ummah that they may become like five fingers in a hand. Ameen

[@atifullah204]

Sir, the question you left blank is circulating in my mind for a few years but i could not find the answer. Please help me finding this, only the name is enough.

[@techsmartpro7438]

I am leaving behind two precious things (thaqalayn) among you. The first of the two is the Book of Allah. In it is guidance and light. So get hold of the Book of Allah and adhere to it." Then he urged and motivated (us) regarding the Book of Allah. Then he said, "And my Ahlul Bayt (family). I urge you to remember God regarding my Ahlul Bayt. I urge you to remember God regarding my Ahlul Bayt. I urge you to remember God regarding my Ahlul Bayt"'" .... (Sahih Muslim, part 7, Kitab fada'il al-­Sahabah [Maktabat wa Matba’at Muhammad ‘Ali Subayh wa Awladuhu: Cairo] pp. 122-123.)

[@zeeshanbhat6862]

Hadees are mere historical narrations can't say every hadees is 100 percent true

[@techsmartpro7438]

@@zeeshanbhat6862 Can you explain what's philosophy behind this narration. Can you share authentic narration.

[@adilsidd8063]

@@techsmartpro7438 not everything which you rafidhis like is authentic that's the problem with you peoples you peoples cherry picks Hadiths which suits your beliefs system that's not how history works and that's why you peoples are minority in Islam and muslims are majority with 1.6 billion followers

[@shohrathussain2673]

Ehle bait mein sirf hazrat usman RA ki family shamil hey. Rasool allah ki 2 betiyan hazrat usman kay nikah mein rahein jabkey hazrat ali kay nikah mein ek.

[@techsmartpro7438]

Nasraniyon k sath mubahila ma Rasool Ullah SAW na kis kis ko apne sath le k gaye the...aur quran ma sadqeen kin ko kaha gaya ha...

[@janmengal6450]

This is not Islamic history, but this is the history of Muslims.

[@shamkhan9020]

Bohat achi tarah aap ne explain kia we need this type of youth who can explain Islamic history in a simple way mashallah God bless you

[@epic1ish]

Looking forward thank you Shahrukh

[@sajjadkazmi8921]

Lesley Hazleton beautifully explained the pre-cursor events of the post-departure of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him and his progeny) that lead to the tragedy of Karbala. What she failed to highlight in her book is that it all started with Abu Sufyan ibn Harb who a leader, and a merchant of Mecca, accepted Islam out of fear of death when Prophet Muhammad peacefully took over Mecca in the conquest of Mecca after the treaty of Hudaybiyya was breached by the Banu Bakr, allies of the Quraysh, attacked the Banu Khuza'a, who had recently become allies of the Muslims. Here my question to our Muslim brothers and sisters is that, after accepting Islam out of fear of death one would love the founder of Islam or hate him? Clearly, this hate was deliberately inculcated in the son and grandson of Abu Sufyan ibn Harb who schemed not only against the prophet but his progeny as well. This is a well documented Islamic history. Yazid the son of Muawiyah son Abu Sufyan ibn Harb specifically took revenge of these defeats of his father and grandfather and to complicate the matter, some companions of Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him and his progeny) did not take the will of the prophet referred in the hadith as “The Calamity of Thursday”. Although, the succession of the Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him and his progeny) was already chosen by Allah, however, some companions deliberately not wanting to accept this fact and that’s why “The Calamity of Thursday” occurred just before Prophet’s (peace be upon him and his progeny) departure. One thing is very clear to me that, it’s not up to man to choose the successor of a Prophet, it's up to Allah who He chooses as a successor after the prophet. Like other prophet came before Prophet Ibrahim (PBUH), and came after him until the seal of the prophets, Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him and his progeny). In addition to more than 300 verses, Allah directly revealed in the Quran in favor of Hazrat Ali (PBUH), the following hadith of Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him and his progeny) clearly reflects that Hazrat Ali (PBUH) is the successor of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him and his progeny). “Will you not be pleased that you will be to me like Haroun (Aaron) to Musa (Moses)? But there will be no prophet after me.” Regardless of Shia and Sunni scholars’ commentaries, it is my belief that our Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him and his progeny) would not have uttered above words if he is not permitted by Allah (God) - read Surah Najm (53). Finally, what our Prophet (peace be upon him and his progeny) did is to bring the people closer to each other, and in doing so, he did not step back from sacrificing his own life, he also sacrificed his family (progeny) in Karbala to save Islam from the corruption of Yazid and his thugs. Otherwise, today Muslim ummah will be openly doing what Yazid of his time had done so. Few examples are doing Jumma on Wednesday instead of Friday. Eating and drinking prohibited articles such as pork, and alcohol. Yazid made Kaaba a horse stable and a womanizer, and many more examples like these. To bring ummah closer to each other, I would ask the following questions and you all already know the answers. But, you need to follow them through. 1. How can we resolve this conflict? > Do you want to choose a corrupt guardian or a “Just” guardian who listens from an ordinary person to a leader of a society? > If you choose a “Just” guardian, will you follow him to the letter or make shortcuts? > If you follow him to the letter, do you think society/ummah will be better or worse? > If you think that society/ummah will be better, then the guardian will not only a “Just” person but also a pragmatic one that will make no errors or mistakes to alleviate and elevate mankind to the next level. > Imam-e-Zamana (a.s) will be that personality that will alleviate and elevate mankind to the next level. And to bring him in the front as a leader of the ummah, we as a collective Muslim ummah must find “Just” guardians at every level to help Imam-e-Zaman in his ultimate fight against the evil in society. > Over the centuries invested world powers used this divide for their own benefits. Therefore, it is imperative to get the truth out in the open and educate general masses of the purported lies that were spread by the invested world powers and increase individual knowledge objectively rather than from the emotional point of view. Source Links: Abu Sufyan ibn Harb: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Sufyan_ibn_Harb Muawiyah 1: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muawiyah_I Umayyad tradition of cursing Hazrat Ali: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umayyad_tradition_of_cursing_Ali Yazid: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yazid_ibn_Abi_Sufyan Hudaybiyya: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Hudaybiyya Banu Bakr: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banu_Bakr_ibn_Abd_Manat Banu Khuza'a: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banu_Khuza%27a The Calamity of Thursday: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadith_of_the_pen_and_paper Succession: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Succession_to_Muhammad Quranic Lectures: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iJ-8Y35md9Rjd5I, kzbin.info/www/bejne/b5O0Y6egaJmLerM Surah Najm (53): quran.com/53 Prophet's, and Imam's Divine Knowledge kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpnYYXiZaK9-iKs

[@superpower1349]

ya waqiat sub sucha ha hazrat ali as boatmozloom ansanha

[@shohrathussain2673]

Agar rasool allah, hazrat ali RA ko khalifa moqarrar kar gaey thay tau ali khamosh kiyun rahey. Kiya shia yahudi sher e khuda ko buzdil sabit ker na chahtey hein. Sari zindgi hazrat ali teenon khulfa kay peechey namaz parhtey rahey aur jangon mein hissa leytey rahey. Shiaon kay motalliq ijmaey ummat yeh hey keh yeh fisaadi hein.

[@joylobo9649]

@@shohrathussain2673 ijimai ummat nhe ijmai e yazeediat. Haha

[@moderndesigns123]

Agr aj ka dor ka kooi b Sacha Muslim ho wo insaaf ka khilaf kam nh kry GA tu hazrat abu Bakar r.a or hazrat عمر r.a jin ki tarbiyat nabi pak S.a.w ny ki wo insaaf k khilaf kam kr rhy thy Astaghfirullah.... Hazrat abu Bakar r.a wo jis ko ALLAH ny quran mn nabi ka Rafiq yani dost kaha... Jis ko ALLAH tu nabi ka dost kahay quran mn or shia uth ka kahay ka mn abu Bakar r.a ko nh manta tu btao mn ALLAH ki Mano yah shia ki? Allah firqa bnana sy mana krta h quran mn or hadees mn ata hai ka ALLAH ka hath jamat pa hai... Matlb Allah us ka sath hai jis mn zyda log hn... Ab sunni tu hn 90% jb ka shia hn 10% tu aisa ho nh sakta ka ALLAH ny 90% Muslim ko gumrah kr dia nozbillah...

[@alessonoftheday7860]

According to me...what I have l learnt that Hazrat Abubakar RA was the rightful heir... If someone would say Hazrat Mola Ali AS is the right heir according to this Hadith: من كنت مولاه فهذا على مولاه Then what for Hazrat Zaid according whom Prophet SAWW said قال لزيد أنت أخونا ؤ مؤلانا

[@habibullah266]

Amazing, I have never heard such conclusion in simple words.

[@hameedyousafzai8689]

Hazrat Khudija died in 620 A D.. and Hazrat Ayesha born in 614 AD. so it means that hazrat Khudija passed away before the marriage of hazrat Muhammad with hazrat ayesha.. then how the writer blamed about the jealousy of wives..

[@hameedyousafzai8689]

@Hassaam khan brother, we are blaming non Muslims for such work but unfortunately all these stories has been written by Persian Muslims, like Imam Tabri, Imam Bukhari etc... So these are the main sources for Islamic history.. Just see that first history of Islam has been written by Imam Tabri in 350 Hijrah. There was no written or published work of any Islamic history before.. The question is how he wrote these stories. Just by asking peoples???? Us nay es say suna us nay us say suna.. blah blah

[@SepahEMahdi]

aisha was not the only other wife

[@AhmedTuri1]

Best review of the book! Love your style of reviewing book!! The establishment of that time was as strong as today’s Pakistan or KSA! No one dare to ask or tell anything about Govt! Your favorite IK is making same Riaysat e Madina! Referring to Jamal fighting, how they were fighting with each other! By the way Ummulmumineen Hazrat Aysha And Maiwaya is regarded respectable but they fought Caliph Ali and lead Muslim stat to destruction.

[@ashiqhussain873]

موجود سیاسی حالات کے تناظر میں ریاست مدینہ کا مطلب ہرگز یہ نہیں کہ ریاست مدینہ کی جنگ و جدل اور خونریزی کو دھرایا جائے یہ تو تاریخ اسلام تھی پر اس تاریخ کا اُن اصولوں کے ساتھ کچھ لینا دینا نہیں جن کی بنیاد پر ریاست مدینہ کی بنیاد رکھی گئی اور میرا ذاتی خیال ہے کہ خان صاحب نے بھی اتنا گہرا مطالعہ نہیں کیا ہو گا تاریخ اسلام کا خان صاحب جس ریاست مدینہ کا ذکر کرتے ہیں وہ اس ریاست مدینہ کے اخلاقی پہلو کا ذکر کرتے ہیں یعنی ایک سوشل سیکیورٹی سٹیٹ جیسے ناروے فن لینڈ سویڈن وغیرہ اور وہ اس کا کئی بار ذکر بھی کر چکے ہیں یہ میری ذاتی رائے ہے اس ضمن میں شاید آپ اس سے اتفاق نا کریں جزاک اللہ

[@gulkhan4998]

Good crux by the Writer.. Being a non Muslim, he also favoured sunni stance on khilafath..

[@taniyabanoo6815]

Please sir which is name book?

[@onelife1633]

But this is an unavoidable fact that for this book "After the prophet", the only source of information for auther is the book of AL-TABRI history as you also mentioned and the book of AL-TABRI was written in third century of Hijra, means after 250 years of death of Hazrat Mohammad peace be upon him. Furthermore, the author of Al-Tabri was a Persian historian name Mohammad Ibn Jarir Al Tabri. These two facts which personally related to writer of Al-Tabri, create doubt on the authenticity and crediblity of history Al-Tabri. First, the author is Persian. He may be biased and inclined to his Persian identification. After all, these are facts that dHazrat Mohammad (peace be upon him) and his four caliphs, his wife Hazrat Ayesha (raza Allahtala Anha) and all his thousands of devoted companions (except a few), all were Arabic origin. These Arabic people had no power, were weak before Hazrat Mohammad (peace be upon him). These Arabic villagers had no central government. All scattered in multiple tribes. They had no international influence. In those days, there were two international powers, one was Rome and other was Iran and surprisingly and fortunately these two powerful international empires were demolished by these unnoticed and unpopular Arabic villagers. Secondly, after 250 years, it is easy or comfortable to distort facts or write stories as one can wish or think. Based on above, who can trust on "After the prophet" which is being written after 1500 years, and is totally based on a book that itself has been written after 250 years of death of Hazrat Mohammad (peace be upon him). Also I would not agree with what you said that in old days every religious leader announced his successor so Hazrat Mohammad (peace be upon him) must had nominated his successor. Here, with due apology, I would say you extremely and fundamentally mistook. Hazrat Mohammad (peace be upon him) was a prophet and not a king or emperor of any state or country. He was sent by Allah as a prophet for a specific and spiritual caws and when he accomplished his goal, he was died. As a position of being Prophet, while he is alive, he could not nominate his next otherwise his contemporary opponents or enemies and the opponents who were to come in coming ages or next centuries, could label another blame on his character that his action of nomination of his successor is proving that whatever efforts he made in past, were actually his hidden agenda or his personal desire or his power hungry intention to procure a land or establish a Kingdome and all of us can understand that the land or kingdome is a symbol of material power. Prophets come to bring spiritual revolution or moral reformations in the society and when they leave the world, they leave a legacy of morality and glorious character. Prophets don't come to gain material power or to get a land over which they would rule or govern. I hope I have been able to explain my point. Lastly, for those who are interested in knowing the history specially about the start of disputes in Islam. I would refer a book which name is "اسلام میں اختلافات کا آغاز". Its meaning in English is "Begining of conflicts in Islam". It is written in Urdu by the second caliph of Jamat Ahmadyia whose name is Hazrat Mirza Bashiruddin Mehmood Ahmed Sahib.

[@yusufmeer7929]

The question is How an 21st century writer can know the history better than someone who wrote the history 250 years after the death of Holy prophet ( saw ) 👏🏻

[@IamKhattak-UsmanKhattak]

Hazrat Ayesha was alone on the camel. Hazrat saffan didnt even speak a word and silently kept walking in front of the camel while holding the rope. ALLAH has clarified this matter in the Qur'an.

[@aniszaidi2470]

You missed........... Sa'ad bin Ubaada....... great leader of Ansaars

[@biologist6640]

Superbbb video, personally I don't believe on any fiqa , we all are Muslims and we should avoid implementation of out thought on all others.

[@Lovetosailforbiddensea]

I have read this book but you are explaning this book in a right way.

[@sumbul_ka_samandar]

Can you tell i should read it or not? As i have heard some bad reviews about it..

[@Lovetosailforbiddensea]

@@sumbul_ka_samandar I think you should go for this book.Doing urself is better than hearing from other.

[@abdulhaadi2453]

Kindly Tell us who lead the Prayers during the illness of Muhammad (peace be upon him ) & In my view Prophet did not mentioned the Caliph to break the trend of Nominating without consultation & he wanted a system based on Consultation not on Nominating ..Kindly correct me if I am wrong

[@na789]

Excellent review, no doubt it’s difficult topic, explained very well, thanks a lot. Keep it up. I would recommend a book to read for better understanding originally in Urdu and it’s translation. Whatever you like please. The Outset of Dissension in Islam by Hazrat Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad, Khalifatul Masih II(ra) This is a lecture delivered by Hazrat Mirza Bashir-ud-Din Mahmud Ahmad(ra), second Successor of the Promised Messiah(as). The primary purpose of this lecture was to provide a correct and accurate historical account of the conflicts which arose most prominently during the Khilafat of Hazrat Uthman(ra). In this lecture, Hazrat Mirza Bashir-ud-Din Mahmud Ahmad(ra) has shed light on the life of Hazrat Uthman(ra), his piety and righteousness, and his status in the eyes of the Holy Prophet(sa). Moreover, he has expounded upon the virtues of the companions of the Holy Prophet(sa) and has explained how conflicts actually arose in the early period of Islam. Moreover, he has refuted various allegations levelled against the person of Hazrat Uthman(ra) and his companions. The lecture is an academic masterpiece of scholarship and explains the events of the era of the third Khilafat in a manner that no other historian has been able to match, be it Muslim or non-Muslim; all this is done in an an eloquent, academic, yet simple manner, in the form of an interesting narrative. www.alislam.org/book/outset-dissension-islam/ Use vpn if there is problem, thanks

[@hinafatima1297]

I'm strongly agree to ur conclusion Mr book buddy

[@Gulamqambar]

Jazakallah. It is extremely important to watch this clip up to the end. We are told that the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him and his holy progeny) died without appointing anyone as his successor. If this is true then it means that there was no need for him to appoint anyone as his successor and he didn't. In that case why did the so called grand sahabas abandoned the blessed body of the Holy Prophet and gathered together in Saqifa to sort out the issue of khilafat? Were they trying to be smarter and cleverer than the Holy Prophet himself? Abu Bakr became the first caliph as a result of the so called "election" When Abu Bakr was on his death bed, he nominated Umar as his successor. And when Umar was on his death bed, he appointed a committee of six people amongst who Uthman was selected as the third caliph. Abu Bakr and Umar were very smart and clever that they made sure that they did not leave this world without making provision for their successors but the Holy Prophet himself died without thinking of appointing anyone as his successor. This is a very big insult to Islam and the Holy Prophet himself. Yes, the holy Prophet did appoint his cousin and his son~in~law as his successor after performing Hajj in a place called Ghadeer Khum. Muslims need to study the history of Islam (not the history of the Muslims) academically, with an open mind and free of prejudice. www.imamali.net/?id=2390

[@kumail9090]

Logical and intellectual points raised by you. In fact scholars have been asking these questions for centuries. But block headed people dont bother to think objectively without prejudice. They think that facts are different from ideals.

[@KapilDev-fo2jt]

Issue of necklace happend first or hijat al wida happened? Anyone tell me chronology

[@mohdrizwan7691]

Assalamuaalekum w. W. Bhayijaan , jo aapka nazarya h wo mera question h poori qaynat k nabi n ek e fesla q nahi kiya agar kiya tha to wo fesla samne q nahi aaya. Aap plzzzz detail m video ke throw btay

[@shahidraza7467]

Wafat se pehly Rasoly Pak S.A.W ne sahaba se farmaya k "Lao Qalam aur Dawat mein aisi cheez lek don take Qiyamat tak tum log Gomrah na ho" toh Hazrat Umer ne kaha k hamare liye Quran kafi hi aur Rasoly Pak ko Hazarat Ali .a.s ki welayat nahi lekne di. Ye haqeekat sab tareekhi kitabon mein leki hi

[@Human_boy_91]

Abu Bakr Siddique, umar bin khattab, Usman bin affan, Ali ibn Talib is our khalifa Is our Amir ul mumineen And ammi Ayesha is our ummul mumineen

[@goworldly233]

Very nicely presented

[@birdebojit]

Hello Sir, I listened deeply to your video and tried to understand your review. Book review is nice. But I want few evidence (written by different scholar). Can you provide few references where it is written that the Prophet had three sons and they all died before the Prophet. Please answer soon. Thank you.

[@nasirshah2646]

Very injustice,accept last 4 line there he forgated that when holy prophet p.b.u.h asked the peoples before the 3 days ago of his hiden,for the pen and paper to make them a heirship document for his assistance but peoples loudly crying to each other's. Allama shibly noumani accept the hadith of qirtas in his book.this hadith was expressed hazrat Abdullah ibn Abbas You also forgets surah tahreem first 6 verses.what is Allah shanahu says.Ali a.s says only that verses.u divers these on ali a.s. You also forgets that fire which bring on the door of that ali a,s.that is written in so many books. You do not calculate the age of umme kalsoom it my request,pls firstly calculate and then make the relation ship. Finally you are hiden so many realities according as well as your faith.

[@frictionforce2526]

you are right

[@syedazharabbas5677]

True

[@AliShah-im3rn]

Right Ume kalsoom ko Hazrat Omar ki wife bana dia without knowing the facts. Aisi kafi hadees maujood hein yahan Nabi SAW ne clearly kaha Logun pori duniya chor dena magar Hazrat Ali ko nah chorna. Kya ye sab ap SAW ne nayuzbillah apny ap se kaha nhi. Ap ko Allah ka Hukam tha

[@nasirshah2646]

@@AliShah-im3rn برادر میرا بھی بیٹا آپ کا ہمنام ھے اچھا لگا ۔ رہی بات عقد بیبی ام کلثوم علیہ سلام کی تو موصوف جناب بی بی پاک دختر نبی صلی اللہ علیہ و آلہ وسلم کی خواستگاری کر چکے تھے جیسے آپ صل اللہ علیہ و آلہ وسلم نے رد کر دیا تھا اب یہ کیسے ممکن ھے کہ مولا علیہ السلام انہیں رشتہ دیتے۔نہ جانے در بتول علیہ السلام جلانے والے کیوں ایسی من گھڑت باتیں کرتے ھے۔

[@AliShah-im3rn]

@@nasirshah2646 yes. Hazrat Ume Kulsum married with Awn Ibne Jaffar ibne Abu Talib. We should not change facts.

[@markazewilayaturdu9727]

Damn your conclusion was very rational... You rock bro.

[@abhyder6937]

The book as i understood is the work done to widen the ditch of differences between the two school of thoughts. The writers commentry and the inference she has drawn in his analysis regarding some of the holy personalities can not be said to have been done justly in a fair way. The narration of events in a sequential way is impressive yet the lasley Hezleton's inferences and her appreciation of the historical facts required to be looked into in a more critical way felt lacking.

[@hidaabro9037]

Main zaror read Karon gi yea. Insha Allah.

[@munsifali7985]

Brave effort! Such a sensitive topic so delicately explained... thanks

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thanks Munsif

[@houseofwisdom7860]

How do we can believe that the author of the book (which you are using as reference) is not biased and his book is accurate

[@syedrizvi696]

too many things missing,like who participated in namaz e janaza of holy profit.etc

[@umairjavaid83]

5:41 These verses are clarifying Maryam's Character. Hazrat Maryam per Bohaat laga aur.uski ka Jawab Ayaton me.likha hai.

[@dilawerhussain3639]

Good conclusion. But we have strongest source for review of history of islam. Hadiees n quran. .. Allah hum sub ko hadayat dayyy... ameen

[@AliHassan-ey4ph]

Ume kalsoom ka nikah umer sy nahin huwa umer to ume kalsoom ki walida k nana lagy to nikah kesy ho gay Tum loog noker ko apni beti dety ho

[@syedalihaider4053]

Review was fantastic

[@askarirecords8200]

Your opinion is great Salam hai ap per