What is Secularism - Religion, Secularism & Pakistan

[@GadgetPulse69]

What an In Depth Analysis on Secularism. BTW congrats on 200K.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

👍😊

[@rashidfaisal6732]

​@@BookBuddyOfficial aap Jhoot kyu faila rhe ho . Discrimination nhi ha USA mei. USA mei humanism ha. really? India mei bhi secularism iska bhi comparison karleta 😅. Aap log kabhi khulafa ki kaamyab statehood aur philosophy ki baat nhi krenge. Muslim sirf 150 saal se abuse ho rhe hai Kyu ki deen ko chod diya ha. Isse phle sabhi khulafa ne kaamyabi se apne citizens ko muttahid , insaaf, haq pe rakhe hai. Biased and fake propaganda

[@tsports4390]

O bhai maaf kr hazrat Muhammad (p.b.u.h) na Zindagi ka hr tariqa or taraqi ka b hr tariqa sikha diya ha is liya bkwas bnd kr or allah sa hidayat mang

[@waqas_khan417]

5:18 Europe Ne Christianity Apna Rakhi Thi Aur Us time ko Europe ka dark age Kahate Hain aur musalmanon ne Islam ko Apna Rakha tha aur usko musalmanon ke golden age Kaha jata hai to isase aap andaza Laga sakte hain ki Hamare liye kaun sa Nizam behtar hai

[@om.rajput3732]

​@@waqas_khan417isilye Pakistan m religious riots Ho rhe h 😂😂😂😂

[@InspectorDirtyHarry]

I don't think secularism will change Pakistan because, secularism supports democracy & in Pakistan most of the people are conservatives & once they get to say their opinion they will bring back so called extreme & misinterpreted version of Islamic democracy....I think only think we can do is to educate new generation ( as they are comparatively tolerant) & clean the mess out of their minds...

[@MdAsif-r4b]

in the past 15 million people killed by this fu*king secularism

[@saraharslan1435]

I totally agree with you

[@MustafaAli-lb8dq]

It will change Pakistan if proper eductaion regarding secularism is given to people.

[@InspectorDirtyHarry]

@@MustafaAli-lb8dq There is mo field in Pakistan in which proper education is given , whether it's Relegion, politics, philosophy or science....

[@MustafaAli-lb8dq]

@@InspectorDirtyHarry Because of religious extremism and ignorance.

[@asimaziz3112]

We need more voices like him to save our homeland.

[@Voyager_space-mania]

Proud to be a secular Muslim ❤

[@comicsbysaif3017]

Secularism= kufr

[@nayanjyotidas7383]

Bhai mere Agar tum muslim ho toh quran Ke hisab se Seculer Nahi ho sakte. Quran Ke Hisab se La Ila ellela ka Matlab hi Allah ke alawa koi aur khuda nahi hain and Seculer hone liye dusre dharm Ke bazood Dena Parega jo quran nahi deta. Toh yah toh Tum Muslim ya fir Seculer dono ek sath Ho hi Nahi sakte. Quran tumhe v shirk Karne wala bol dega.

[@bobbyeditz765]

@@nayanjyotidas7383 Secularism means separation of church and state. Means government has not business in anyone's religion and will treat everyone same. You are completely wrong, Islam doesn't oppose secularism, just some extremist mullahs do. Don't act like you know quran better than us.

[@nayanjyotidas7383]

@@bobbyeditz765 we'll I don't know quran better then you . Thats true but why only church and State ? Who are Mulla ? Shia or Sunni ?

[@bobbyeditz765]

@@nayanjyotidas7383 "Church and state" is just a phrase. It means the laws of church (in an Islamic state means a mosque) wont define the laws of the state. Secularism is also much needed in Pakistan because there are many versions of Islam that people follow here. Shia, sunni etc. Also, what business do you have here? There are literally so many Indians on every other video about Pakistan. If you don't have anything good to say, then don't say anything at all. This is pakistan's internal matter, why do you give a shit whether Pakistan is secular or not ? Mind your own business.

[@ahindrakar6039]

Feel proud from India, thanks God people like you are in Pakistan. Plz spread knowledge to overruled ignorance. You are an intelligent soul.

[@amritsaha4034]

Bhai Salute to you kaise kaar lete ho ye Saab baate Pakistan Mai rehkar 🫡❤️.....love from India

[@SUPERNVA-gr4sr]

One of only hope in Pakistan 😢

[@AzanKhan-q3w]

see the disadvantage being not a fully secular, extremist has same mentality you hate pakistan

[@shubhamranjan-tf5bk]

All the developed countries are secular. Congratulations on 200k.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Thank You

[@bangbang6847]

Wrong. Rich middle eastern countries with more gdp per capita than europeans are totalitarian or authoritarian regime with no secular values.

[@redpanther9380]

The world most under developed countries are also secular 😂

[@unknown-vn6bq]

Most of seculars states are also poor Even many African States Riyasat ki ideology tabdeel kar Dana sa mulk taraqi nahi karta Mulk mahnat sa taraqi karta ha or durust aqal sa liya hova faslo sa karta ha

[@AmeerMuawiya-rc3gd]

But unfortunately the secular countries are more depressed 😞😞😞 according to western psychologists.

[@BookBuddyOfficial]

Follow BookBuddy on Insta on the following link instagram.com/bookbuddyofficial?igsh=MWlkOWdsNGgzYmYyNQ%3D%3D& ‎Follow the Book Buddy channel on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va80Cgj23n3ZTl5Gbq16 You can order my best selling book “Readistan” on the below link www.libertybooks.com/readistan-9786277626037

[@WaqarAhmad1.]

Why do you invite us to insta? That is an immoral application; is just waste of time. You see your own advantage only

[@HasnainIzhar10]

I loved this video too much. Obviously, Secularism is a great solution for Pakistan.

[@MdAsif-r4b]

in the past 15 million people killed by this fu*king secularism

[@rawasbhai123]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@MuhammadAsif-7788]

I have a straightforward question: If secularism is the solution for Pakistan, why did we seek independence from India? Remaining united with India might have made us stronger and more respected globally. At the time of independence, every Muslim aspired to a nation governed by Islamic principles. It would be a betrayal to those who sacrificed their lives for an Islamic state, not a secular one. Please reconsider your stance; secularism is not the solution for Pakistan.

[@viratkohli1906]

Do you really think Jinnah creates Pakistan as a muslim nation and only for muslims ❓

[@bobbyeditz765]

This is just like saying what's the difference between China, Japan, south korea, Phillipines etc. They can be so powerful together as well. They all look the same, but they are still different. They are all secular but have different identities. Just because you look the same doesn't mean you have no separate identity at all. We need to move on from religion. Also Pakistan was made so that the Muslims in India don't suffer unfair things. They all gave their lives for the then Muslims not an Islamic state. But now they are all gone we need to move on from the past. Just look at how we are treating our minorities in the country, Is this what Quaid wanted ? Is this what the people who sacrificed their lives wanted ? For people to be lynched in broad daylight etc? Pakistani people have the right to decide their fate. If secularism is what they want the country should be secular and it will be.

[@084abdulwahhab9]

​​​@@bobbyeditz765 A movement is mainly recognized by its slogan which was common among the people following the movement. Which was "Pakistan ka matlab kiya,لا الہ الااللہ" Today Pakistan is a secular state.Some islamic rules are present for satisfaction of islamic masses. Islam give rights to non muslim and mob lynching is forbidden in islam.

[@bobbyeditz765]

​@@084abdulwahhab9 Muslims see non muslims as INFERIOR to them. The first thing they do whenever they see a non muslim is try to convert them. Some even FORCE it down on them. Don't tell me these are the rights islam gives to non muslims. Just today I saw a christian woman got rejected from a job because of her religion. Also what slogan are you talking about ?? Most muslim parties at the time of partition were AGAINST THE CREATION OF PAKISTAN. So, quaid definitely didn't want pakistan to be Islamic and it wasn't until ZIA came along. I don't care what slogan were they chanting at those times, the modern world has changed. The world is much more than just kafir muslim. The world has advanced and we are still living in medieval times.

[@Docs_WanderLife]

Tumhaara future deal hi rahega…. Hope you awaken up one day 🫖

[@sardarsaqibjaved9556]

What an incredible video sir you are doing great job ❤

[@yasmeeniqbal7002]

Exactly 💯 agreed... secularism is the last refuge...

[@SyedShaheerIbnHussain]

Secularism is kufr. When you deny to implement the orders of Allah that are ment for thhe state level. And judge, [O Muḥammad], between them by what Allāh has revealed and do not follow their inclinations and beware of them, lest they tempt you away from some of what Allāh has revealed to you. (Quran 5:49 ka theme) And whoever does not judge by what Allāh has revealed - then it is those who are the disbelievers... (Quran 5:44 ka theme)

[@nowie4007]

Proud to be a Muslim who supports secularism in Pakistan ❤❤❤

[@muhammadashfaq1938]

Congratulations Sir, on reaching 200K Subscribers... 🤩

[@farahkhan5566]

Thnx Bhai 🙏 I'm from Parachinar and aj hamen ap jese logon ki boht zrort ha jo hamari awaz bn sken.Moula apko hamisha salamt rakhy ameen

[@MdAsif-r4b]

in the past 15 million people killed by this fu*king secularism

[@Dipikasingha-lo7fb]

parachinar kahapar hai,kya khasiyat hai woha ka,kal iskebare mein thoda bhut sunatha please batayen iske bare

[@saeedchamkani]

Hahaha acha ho raha hao ap lagwo ke sta 😅😂

[@Billybuks]

​@@saeedchamkaniPalestine Mai Sunnio k sath boht acha horha 😂😂😂 Thanks Israel ❤ Aur Palestine k ilawa China Barma Afghanistan har jaga Sunnio kee K0TAY jaisi halt hai 😂😂 Aaj sari Duniya Sunnio koo Terr0rist kehti hai 😂😂😂 Ye okat hai Tum Sunnio kee 😂😂😂

[@farahkhan5566]

Ye Pakistan ka ek tribal area ha kafi khobsorat ha lkn isky halat boht kharab rehty hen aksar.yahan ek particular community called shia ka genocide ho raha ha boht saalon se.​@@Dipikasingha-lo7fb

[@redhold1529]

Sir your more than half of the video was how Christians became civilized and came out of ignorance because of secularism, we all know it was the need for them at that time. Now if we take a look on the islamic civilization at that time we see they were pioneers in science, philosophy, art, literature, infrastructure etc. Here you gave the eg of Christian nations this is logical fallacy ( false equivalence). You also gave the eg of of speech of qaid e azam, these words are not against the fundamentals of islamic state. So why you misimpreted these words as foundations of only secular thought. I also know what peace and security security did secularism and mOrAl nAtIoN ( usa) brought to muslims.

[@abhisrivastav7395]

Same thing happening in india .. we are secular but now we r heading towards hindu state .India must be secular for his future development !!

[@Tariq-ox8tc]

Bro I am from Pakistan our nation has been fundamentalized I know but astonished to know that you understand that your government has Brainwashed half of indian population and trying to use religion card in politics...bcz of most Indians orally abuse us and call us names on Social media but they don't understand their issues ... Thanks

[@cogito9350]

U can't become secular by preaching the word, u become secular based on how urs laws n policies are independent of religious influences

[@nycto0]

Being Secular doesn't mean leave your Religion and promote convertion to Islam. Secularism should come from all community, Including Muslims. Don't blame Hindus only.

[@nycto0]

Secularism should come from all community, Including Muslims. Don't blame Hindus only

[@King.khan.g892]

Yaar aap log b tu humaray bhai ho bus farq itna hai k aap Ameer bhai ho 😂😂😂

[@MoizAli-iy2wg]

"This man will change the" -----Education system------ If We support this man This channel is different 🔥🔥🔥 Do not blindly agree with all things Sir is saying Use your own mind . If you blindly follow then you are in the same loop. Great work 💯

[@Mooneypilot101]

The only way Pakistan will modernize is by adopting secular form of government. Secularism is not anti religion. Rather it gives citizens the freedom to choose their faith without discrimination or preferences. Pakistan is becoming more sectarian, dangerous and unstable. Without Secularism the country will be in continuous internal conflict.

[@MdAsif-r4b]

in the past 15 million people killed by this fu*king secularism

[@shivaputrappagarwad3890]

If Pakistan want to be secular country. It shall open Hindu university in Karachi and Islamabad .

[@abdullahraja8496]

😂

[@fsu3328]

What the f you on about

[@ISknowledge7299]

Liberalism, Secularism, Capitalism, Democracy, Feminism

[@HamzaAli-dh9xf]

❤

[@JareeBaba-lp4qt]

Great job شاید آپ یہ نہیں جانتے کہ جسے آپ سیکولرازم کہتے رہے اور جس پر یہ ویڈیو بنائی در حقیقت دین اسلام کی ہی تائید کرکے آپ نے اس معاشرے کے کفریہ عقائد اور مولویوں کے منہ توڑ دیا بہترین طریقہ ہے اور یہی حقیقت اسلام ہے. آزربائیجان کی بات کی ہے تو وہاں پر موجود اسلام ہی ہے جوکہ ایرانی اور سعودی ادیان کے مذاہب کے بت توڑ کر آرام سے ہے. Very impressive

[@Rev.S.Matthias]

Great job. Well done 🎉

[@hammadahmad2776]

Humans can't function without stories. religion, secularism, atheism and capitalism, they all are stories. unfortunately, in Pakistan, religious stories have hegemoniesed the public discourse. It's imperative to generate and proliferate the alternative discourse among the masses. We need to preach the soft form of secularism which is based on inclusivity, cosmopolitanism, and inter-faith and intra-faith harmony. You have taken a phenomenal initiative of enlightening the masses. Keep on producing such a productive content.

[@AbdulWahid-z5h]

میں مولویوں کے خاندان سے ہوں لیکن میں آپ سے متفق ہوں

[@unknown-vn6bq]

@@AbdulWahid-z5h Pakistan ka Secular ho jana masla ka hal nahi ha. Ya siraf manipulation bataye ha. Kon sa kaam riyasti level pa Islamic ho raha ha jis ki waja sa hum ya kaha ka Pakistan ko aik Islamic state hona ki waja sa nuksan ho raha ha or taraqi nahi ho rahi. Or ya haqeeqat ha ka Pakistan ka name Islamic republic of Pakistan ha lakin ya policy level or rules regulations level ma secular state hi ha or secular haqaato or qartooto ka galat result ko or apni na ahli ko ya kah kar side po ho jata ha ka religious state ki waia sa hum na kaam hova Hamari pasti ki waja ya interest pa liya hova qarza ha jo aaj hamara gala ki hadi bani hoi ha jis ki waja sa hum par kai trade ki pabandia lagti ha or hum khul ka kisi bi mulk sa trade karna ma azadi nahi. Kiya interest pa loan lana ya islam ma jayez ha? Ya ya aik secular policy ha jis ki waja sa hamari industry ka bura haal ha. 1)Kiya aaj sa Pakistan ka name change kar dana sa Industries lag jaye gi 2)Kiya schools ka number increase kar jaye ga 3)Kiya unemployment khatam ho jaye gi Ya siraf fictional bataye ha jo ki jati ha. Haqeeqatan koi asi cheez ya islami policy nahi jo hamara mulk ki taraqi ma rukawat ho. Or ya hamara mulk ki galat or kharab halat siraf secular policies ko waja sa ha

[@Mooneypilot101]

@@unknown-vn6bq Why are so afraid of change??? ONly those with weak faith will resist change. Pakistan is heading towards democracy and secularism no matter how much resistance you create. It is a matter of time.

[@unknown-vn6bq]

@@Mooneypilot101jab jawab na ho na baat ka to Tum jasa log fazol ki baatye karta ho. Or ya waqat bataye ga ka kiya ho ga inshallah. Lakin change sa hum nahi Tum dar rahe ho kio ka secular system or policies ha or hum Isa change kar ka islami system banaye ga jaha aik bahtar family system wala mashra or insaaf ho ga. Jaha log interest sa liya hova farsoda zulm pa mabni system sa azadi hasil kara ga .

[@unknown-vn6bq]

@@Mooneypilot101 or agar Tum apni baat ko change kahta ho to tumha ilm hi nahi ha or fazool baat kar rahe ho

[@Mooneypilot101]

@@unknown-vn6bq Your experiment with Islam has failed over the last 1500- years. There was never justice for all. Just because a few benefitted from the system means it was a good system.

[@farhad1509]

رياست کوئی بھی ہو وہ بس ماں ہوتی ہے انسان تو کلمہ پڑھ سکتا ہے مگر رياست کو آپ زبردستی نہيں پڑھا سکتے۔

[@mritunjaysharma573]

I support secularism. I am a liberal Hindu though I am proud of being a Hindu. ❤❤ Excellent video! Who else support secularism. Like here.

[@waseemahamad5209]

But India me tum log Musalmano ki lynching karte ho India me rahna hoga gay shree ram kahna hoga😂😂ye sab bolte ho

[@Issac_01]

I am Muslim and only believe in liberty and secularism

[@nnonymousone303]

Islam is a perfect ideology as far as politics is concerned. The only need is to get rid of Curse of Sectarianism and correct ourselves as nation and Muslims The Pre-Islam Arabia was divided into different tribes and each tribe considered themselves superior. But Prophet PBUH came and re-established the system of islam as was narrated by Hazart Ibrahim and Ishmaeel.

[@muhammadbilalmirajdin3764]

😒😒😒😒

[@rishijha4663]

Islam is perfect ideology for londiyabaazi

[@unknown-vn6bq]

@@rishijha4663 is Islam permote londybazi or not? This is harm and one of biggest sin in Islam Pahla research karo

[@rohand04]

Islam is perfect for Muslim.. not for any non Muslim minorities in the country.. history speak volumes on this

[@rohand04]

Islam is perfect for Muslim.. not others..

[@fidaali7818]

You play a leading role❤ wonderful

[@Aamirdhar457]

Islam is the system of justice, equality،freedom،liberty ۔

[@Mooneypilot101]

Islam allowed capture and ownership of slaves, sexual assault on female slaves, child marriages and the list is long. Calling it a systems of justice, equality،freedom،liberty, continues the lie we are taught from the moment we are born in a Muslim society.

[@wanderer2740]

Afghanistan mein rehne ja toh... Wahi pe freedom, equality and liberty milega😂

[@Mooneypilot101]

@Gazishahchak Islam is a drug and you are talking like a drugged up junkie extolling the benefits of Opium.

[@utpalbal6275]

Islam spreads hatred towards others .

[@Hashashinofallamut]

Pakistan to taba haa

[@omgupta9]

Your video is really knowledgeable... love form India.❤ watched whole content ❤

[@kamalarya6361]

Great job bro... U r well-wisher of Pak n humanity

[@amritpanthi0000]

Good Job stay safe love from Nepal 🇳🇵♥️

[@solutionshorts]

True Islamization is better then secularism

[@sirajtaj9636]

Usi taraf jarein hain tension ni leni .

[@Medhatullah]

Love your content

[@ShahidMalik-yr6ks]

Truthful analysis ❤❤keep it

[@ArfakqsedArfakqsed]

I love to watch you videos

[@AQkhan.student]

Secularism is not the solution of problems in Pakistan and now we need golden rules of Islam... secularism can't work more because we faced secularism since 1947 and didn't find any solution of our problems in secularism. Only the name of our country is Islamic Republic of Pakistan but it's the greatest joke with the world because when someone is named a wrestler and he is Too weak to walk then this is the insult of the name "wrestler"

[@sariahusain0622]

Thank you so much for highlighting this as people here are very proudly calling themselves secular or liberal muslims

[@sartajalikhan728]

Allam iqbal was critique of both secularism and demcoracy.جمہوریت اک طرز حکومت ہے کہ جس میں، بندوں کو گنا کرتے ہیں، تولا نہیں کرتے" and he said about secularism. جدا ہو دین سیاست سے تو رہ جاتی ہے چنگیزی"

[@SaifullahKhalid73]

He should learn about the constitutional or law-making system of Islam But he is referring again and again one point "Pakistani actions" His analysis shows it that Islamic rulings system will not establish a great nation. But he failed to provide evidence of its failure (Pakistan is not included in this, even if some parts is Islamic in legislation that's not implemented correctly) Afghanistan (may Allah protect it and retain it on Islamic values) can be an example for that how they are evolving and how the peaceful their environment is even after such destructions

[@talkie-nyc]

​@@SaifullahKhalid73The so-called Progression of Afghanistan is coming at the brutal cost of suppression of religious and individual freedom. Women's education is one of such many examples. They're making things far more worse for their people.

[@bobbyeditz765]

@@SaifullahKhalid73 What are you on about bro ?? Afghanistan is literally one of the poorest countries in the world. What peacefulness are you talking about ? Are you talking how women aren't allowed to study ? Are you talking about how non muslims are seen worse than animals ? Are you talking about how women are stoned to death for just not wearing burkah or hijab? You must be living in 16th century to even call this peaceful.

[@Salmanazadofficial]

Migrate to Aghanistan😂

[@fsu3328]

@@Salmanazadofficial you hate Islam you atheist

[@Infinitezindagi]

I am secularist Alhamdulilah ❤

[@GenuineJunaid]

*Alhamdulillah????? There are two types of secularism: 1. French secularism 2. American secularism If you're following French secularism, then you lose your Faith as a Muslim. But if you're following American secularism, you don't lose your faith, but you get closer to it Because secularism means that God's laws are lacking. Islam isn't only Faith, it's way of Life.

[@Devilplayzz13]

​@@GenuineJunaid kuch nahi ho sakta 😅

[@GenuineJunaid]

@@Devilplayzz13Did Book Buddy does not show you the darker aspects of secularism. You are unacquainted.

[@Devilplayzz13]

@@GenuineJunaid baat bas itni si hai ki jab hum ye kahe ki hamara perspective hi sahi hai baki sab ka galat hai bas problem hi yaha par khadi hoti hai baki Aap samajdar honge to samaj jayenge . baki to jazakallah khair ❤️

[@Infinitezindagi]

@@GenuineJunaid My dear, I have never mixing both of things together. Like Islam and Science are two alien objective,if we merge both of them so their conclusion is Extremist theology rather than if we grasp both of them by emplace their own position so,we nor astray on the way of faith and believe and often learn both of them by feasibility. Thanks for this information ℹ️

[@Munirbusiness]

Amazing to watch this

[@aqsaali2670]

I think you should have added the example of Indonesia also, they are also secular despite being Muslim majority but look at the set of values their people are following, it is a great example of how does a practicing Muslim society looks.

[@aftabahmed9412]

Knowledgeable ❤

[@HasnainIzhar10]

As you have remembered that i had suggested a video for Pakistani Girls and their independence to you. Please upload that.

[@letslearnwithshahbaz6615]

Aagya sir Thanks ❤❤

[@osamaali5969]

My dear sir, let me quote George Holyoake the philosopher who coined the term secularism, and for your "Blind Followers" who are being proud secular Muslims down the comment section. In his book: "Principles of Secularism" George writes: "Secularism is a series of principles intended for the guidance of those who find Theology indefinite, or inadequate, or deem it unreliable." Now, while we have that much conviction about Secularism we must consider the origins of this vague thought and must gauge its wisdom through the consequentialism it bore for those who had embodied this thought with a "Dark History" known as the "Reign of Terror". Thats what make this idea rogue, bogus and anarchic... and for sure would inculcate "Anarchy" in the Pakistani society. Having said that, we truly need a system of governance that inclusively addresses a Mans's intellectual, spiritual, humanistic and emotional needs that also caters his desires through proper contracts and ISLAM is that system that incorporates all of this, if its jurisprudence is followed with its true essence, InshaAllah. LET US ALL CANCEL THIS VAGUE CULTURE OF "SECULARISM" together....

[@iam_r_k_t7593]

2_you've talked a lot about dark age and you've compared with today's Pakistan's situation. Why didn't you compare with Islamic golden age when the religion was at all and it was the best time of growth of humanity.

[@PakistanTallent]

that era was secular as well🤣, do your research on that

[@MohammadNuman938]

😂bhai agar Islamic golden age k baaray mein kuch pata ho toh ye bhi pata hona chahiye k vo ek lota medival region thha jajaa secularism ko follow Kiya jata thh 😂 khilafat e abbasia was the first international super power to established state secularism

[@muhammadfaiq9023]

Sorry to say that i disagree with that I personally really like secularism but it's not mean that. This is the right thing Because when i deeply studied about the ideology of islam I realized that there is no such thing like Liberal Muslim People those have secular mind are non.muslim Otherwise facts are facts no doubt

[@ItsMeS47]

O yes I was anxiously waiting for this video from such a great personality I am really thankful to you Sir ❤

[@NitinAhire-zu9ir]

Congratulations 200k🎉🎉🎉

[@DeepakSingh-hl3er]

I have pakistani collegues in UAE. They think me as a non-muslim will go hell as i am on wrong track & hell-bent on converting me. I am really shocked to see how much hatred they have for other religions. They have no nationalism & just call themselves muslim.

[@dr.k3598]

Secularism promotes athesim. Today in this world Atheism is itself a religion.

[@mustafa_unitydev]

The problem isn't with Islam; it lies with those who claim to follow it but have neither understood its essence nor shown a willingness to do so. The State of Madina, under the leadership of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W), was a beacon of justice, where fairness and compassion were paramount. There was no room for unjust bloodshed, and the principles of Islam were upheld in every aspect of governance. It was not a secular state; rather, it was a model of governance based on the teachings of the Qur'an. The problem with Muslim advocates of secularism is that they view Islam through the lens of European secular writers. For your information, these writers wrote against religion after observing a deformed version of Christianity, not the comprehensive and just Islamic system. Our only true role model is Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W), and the system he implemented in Madina is the blueprint for any Islamic society. To advocate for a secular system in an Islamic country is to disregard the wisdom and guidance of the Qur'an and the Prophet. The true solution lies in returning to the principles that were established in Madina, where justice, equality, and the fear of Allah were the foundations of governance.

[@manzar42]

Secularism is not a new idea. It was already a medieval concept when Pakistan was made in the name of religion. I wish it had been made in the name of human rights. I think we are doomed unless we can change our thinking. Well done for making a sincere effort.

[@UmarAli-qs4wb]

Instead of making the state secular, government should thwart such policies that solve these problems.

[@samabbas8519]

I respect you as my teacher and have learned a lot from your videos. However, I must say that you have failed to identify the main issue facing Pakistan, which is secularism. Pakistan is already a secular state, but its people have not accepted secularism because they originally demanded the establishment of a caliphate when Pakistan was created in 1947. They never achieved this because they were betrayed by secularists. Today, the elite in Pakistan are secular, so why haven't they solved the country's problems?

[@tariqghuary7848]

simply amazing

[@Dipikasingha-lo7fb]

Sir apka 4 video lagatar dekhraha hu bhut ache6a hai aur knowledgeable hai❤❤

[@billonairequotes1233]

bhai what a job brilliant

[@hamzazaman18]

I am conservative, but i agree ke secularism is a solution for Pakistan. Instead of having so called 'Islamic Democracy', people need to know ke there us no such Islakic thing. Democracy is against Islam. This social laziness is slowly killing our nation, we need to switch completely and lean on one side instead of hanging on such ideologies.

[@javeria_siddiqa]

Congrats on 200K❤️

[@krishnakantvijay824]

Thankyou very much brother. I from India selute you. We all have equal identity.

[@NgonlyemKonyak]

Well said absolutely correct information and explanation ❤ from india

[@samabbas8519]

Thirdly, you mentioned that secularism is a part of Islam, which is completely misleading. Secularism involves separating the state from religion, but in reality, Islam integrates politics and state governance because it is a political system in itself. The foundations of science were laid by Muslims during the caliphate when Europe was in the Dark Ages. Muhammad Ali Jinnah and Javed Iqbal are not the final authorities for us; our ultimate authority is Allah and His Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). Therefore, we do not care about the opinions of Jinnah and Javed Iqbal on this matter

[@Docs_WanderLife]

Bro you are doing such a great service of Pakistan by opening up their orthodox view about religion and humanity…

[@mirfa5069]

Good analysis

[@Tariq-ox8tc]

Congratulations on 200k

[@malikhassamzahid6301]

You shall read State under leadership of Hazrat Umer R.A where religion was the only constitution of state and present that narrative also , don't misguide people

[@MustafaAli-lb8dq]

Those were midevil times. Besides the second caliph was an intolerant person who destroyed libraries and other stuff that contradicted Islam. Secularism is the only way forward. Most Muslims are happy in secular countries than their own.

[@worldexplorer45]

दुख की बात यह है कि इसे कोई पाकिस्तानी मुस्लिम नहीं देख रहा होगा सब के सब इंडियन होंगे 😂

[@MaazAkhtar-m2g]

200K congrats

[@SaidulAlom-pt5uv]

I'm Indian Muslim but I believe secularism

[@viratpatidar9152]

Because you are less in numbers 😂 go and make more babies to increase population then you will say same or not 😂

[@sayanhazra7521]

You have to.

[@WaseemAyyan]

Pakistan Can be developed but never be Secular because our Politicians Use Islam as a Play Card 😢😢

[@Issac_01]

Proud to be a Secular and liberal Muslim 🇮🇳

[@sumeetkumar-se4qs]

Great❤❤❤

[@majeedanwar6337]

You are really right

[@AhsanAzhar]

5:40 یورپ کے زوال کی وجہ عیسائیت اس لیے تھی کہ اجک عرصے تک وہاں نہانے کو گناہ سمجھا جاتا تھا۔ اور لوگ علم بھی نہیں سیکھتے تھے وہ سمجھتے تھے کہ سارے علوم ہمیں کتاب کی شکل میں دے دیئے گئے۔ جبکہ اسلام ہمیں علم سیکھنے اور تحقیق کرنے کی تلقین کرتا ہے ایک عرصے تک مسلمان سائنسی دنیا میں نمایاں رہے۔ ہمیں اسلامی نظام کو اپنانے کی ضرورت ہے ناکہ سیکولرزم کو۔

[@asan506]

Good work by you... But there is no easy way out of this mess 😔

[@DeepakSingh-hl3er]

I have pakistani collegues in UAE. They think me as a non-muslim, I will go hell as i am on wrong track & hell-bent on converting me. I am really shocked to see how much hatred they have for other religions (esp Hindu, Jews & Christans ). They have no nationalism & just call themselves muslim.

[@dimijahu]

Islam is the complete code of life. We need islam as a system that is not even installed on 1 inch land currently anywhere on planet earth. Islam Political, Social & Econmic system shall be installed.

[@shehryarbaig8947]

same views

[@utpalbal6275]

You are already a blind Muslim. Keep it up.😅

[@mustansarhussain6650]

Nice

[@Izzah-k3r]

Even More than 200 times in Quran Allah SWT emphasizes on intellect. If you want to be a Muslim then stay away from such extremism. Islam does not reflect such person alities. May Allah show us the righteous path.

[@MustafaAli-lb8dq]

Proud to be Soft Liberal Muslim! We need American secularism in our country.

[@Jbsilver007]

Very nice

[@sabatariq2892]

Totally agree with the whole video! A high time Pakistan needs to reconsider its ideology.

[@mosaviryousufzai8453]

We say that the understanding of these secularists regarding Islam is incomplete and incorrect. Islam is not merely about believing in the existence of Allah and performing acts of worship, but it is comprehensive and encompasses all aspects of life, such that all forms of human activities are conducted in accordance with the laws of Allah. It is a complete way of life. Just as there are commands for prayer, zakat, fasting, and Hajj, there are also commands to judge by the law of Allah, to submit to the rulings of the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him), to strive in the path of Allah, and to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong. Just as there are prohibitions against polytheism, disobedience to parents, lying, and sorcery, there are also prohibitions against usury, adultery, alcohol, bribery, and unjustly consuming people's wealth. Secularists want to confine Islam to acts of worship, but Islam is a comprehensive system of life that encompasses beliefs, acts of worship, ethics, transactions, economics, politics, governance, as well as arts and culture, and all other fields of life. Islam does not accept any other system to share with it in organizing the lives of Muslims. Rather, it seeks for society to derive its laws, regulations, and systems from divine revelation, represented by the Qur’an and the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him), so that it may be a godly society, not an ignorant one.

[@DREAMCHASER27th]

Why not try Islamic system of life instead of secularism. The purpose of Pakistan was to implement Islamic system here but unfortunately it is still a dream. If you talk about religious extremism is has nothing to do with Islam. The main obligation upon a Muslim is to implement the Islamic system where sovereignity belongs only to Allah.

[@Ijaz_Ul_Haq]

Islamic system possible hi nai ha, es lye tu secular Hona chye

[@DREAMCHASER27th]

@@Ijaz_Ul_Haq Why not possible still having more chances than secularism. If you think secularism will lead us to prosperity then you are looking at only developed countries while ignoring countries like Nigeria and Sudan they are also secular. Secularism is not the only solution.

[@bobbyeditz765]

@@DREAMCHASER27th Nigeria and sudan have internal conflicts, corruption and unproductive people. That is why they are poor. If you look at religious governments, there are not more than 4 countries which are prospering. Israel, Saudi and UAE(Oil reserves), Vatican City (donations from catholic believes + tourism and very small population). But when you look at religious governments countries that are prospering are not because they have a religious government but other things. But that's not true for secularism. In a secular state everyone is equal, state has not business in your religion.

[@DREAMCHASER27th]

@@bobbyeditz765 The things you said about Nigeria and Sudan is found in abundance and more then them in Pakistan so how can secularism be a solution for us.

[@sariahusain0622]

Thank you so much for highlighting this as people here are very proudly calling themselves secular or liberal muslims

[@MuhammadAbdullah-lr7sd]

The problem is we are having some soo called speakers like QAR, Sahil Adeem etc, who criticise every thing except religious narratives, every intellectual, thinker, and philosopher. People are blindly following such speakers and they don't even try to listen arguments from other side. Muslims from Pakistan (Sunni) want religion as a state while Muslims (All sects) from India want secularism. End result would be that our generations would lead to agnosticism in few decades . Hamari qoum bht khushdilli aor aitmaad k sath Allah ki ayaton ka inkaar karty hain. Quran me hukm ha, Tum shaur/aqal se kaam q nahi lete. Han lete to hain lekin dosre ki aqal se.. apni aqal istemal ki to muntashir ho jainge "aksariyat" se. Aor aksariyat...

[@OfficialTheVirus]

No it is not...Ap bt kr layen Live Qasiar bhai se

[@MuhammadAbdullah-lr7sd]

@@OfficialTheVirus I already watched his videos. Mas'alon ka hal unke pas bhi nahi hai. Khilafat ki baat karty hain jo mushkil se 1400 saal me 30 bhi pure nahi kar saki. Modern problems require modern solutions. Wo English bolne wale desi molvi hi hain. Ghamidi sb, syed muzamil, dr taimur, engineer ali, pervaiz hoodboy. In sab k khilaaf bolte hain ye nahi kehty logon ko k in sab k narratives suno. Clips kaat kar laga k response karna kon c bahaduri ha. In simple terms, andhon me kana raja ki misaal baron ne durust hi daali..

[@taetae......]

Secularism is not what you have described. Secularism is making laws of the system other than religion. And Islam is "making laws of the System from Islam" . So you can either be a Secular or Muslim. And Islam is not a religion (mazhab). It is a deen (system), that is Socio Political and Economical system compromising worshipping and faith as a center.

[@afzalsaifi1582]

TUMHARE COUNTRY KA BEDAGARQ TUMHARI MILLITARY OR POLITICIANS NE KIYA HAI. NA KO RELIGION NE, TUM SECULAR BHI BAN JAO GE TAB BHI TUM WAHIN KE WAHIN RAHOGE

[@Tariq-ox8tc]

Proud liberal Muslim ❤

[@Smbv-n6r]

Yes brother religious hona no problem but radical or extremist main problem mind set change hona chahiye

[@GenuineJunaid]

I'm also a Liberal but Halal one.

[@Tariq-ox8tc]

@@Smbv-n6r obviously your religion may not harm anyone

[@Tariq-ox8tc]

@@GenuineJunaid If you don't harm anyone welcome jana by your thoughts 😃

[@WaseemAyyan]

Mee tooo

[@shakatsiddiqui2469]

You are amazing

[@Salmanazadofficial]

Secularism is the only way out for the world to reckon with peace, prosperity and progress. These three P's needs another P of pluralism and secularism.

[@qaisera6282]

A strong narrative giving vision to see truth and enlighten ourselves, a much needed commodity for us.Islam was the first religion that emerged totally free of priesthood. But unfortunately, we allowed it to creep in. Today we are in its stranglehold.

[@Reel2Fun]

Mujhe ye samaj nhi arha k pakistan main religion Islam kahan per interrupt karta hai. Pakistani k law main Islam just as a shield use howa hai "Pakistan ka matlab La ilaha illallah" is k ilawa to mujhe islam sirf masjid main namaz tak hai. Han ye keh sakte hai k Pakistan ko chalane wali community apne maffad k leyi kabi religion k name per kabi cast air kabi patriotism k name per. Agar Pakistan main islamic law functional hota to Pakistan main crim kar k wo abroad jane k leyi na visa pate aur na hi wo travel kar pate. Agar waqi Islamic law functional hoti to ye kabi nhi hota k apke Karnals and majors ko pensions dollar main aur apke baqi sectors ki pension PKR main even decreasing day-by-day nhi hota. Agar waqi Islamic law implemented hota to apki mulk main mujrim baher aur mulzim jail main nhi hote. So jab ap baat clear nhi kehe sakte k asal masla kis ki wakha se hai to kindly ye religion ko blame na karen

[@ridakhan1749]

If you have not listened to his complete video, he is not arguing about whether Islamic law is good or bad. His argument is more related to the wrongful use of religion in controlling masses which keeps happening in Pakistan as so-called religious scholars have a LOT of street power and brainwashed a common man.

[@nobodycares2025]

pakistan is already a secular state. there is not 10 percent sharia law implented in pak so how can it be islamic country🐒 more than half of pakistani people go to school college and university......and what they do their that is another topic....Mujre🤣 and in comparision what usa and europe have.....you only showing good things what about bad things happening there like gun violence drug abuse onlyfans their family system have destroyed etc.....and they are not happy in their life yet they have good economy.....money is everything? do full comparison you are biased in that..... natural resources geopolitical location, population is also a big factor too. . . . many so called pseudo intellectual pakistani youtuber are doing this...Quiad azam tk chale gae hai🤣 kabhi zia kabhi mushraf kabhi islamic mulk hai isliye ham aise hai kehte huwe dekho ge unko.....jab k shuru se hi yeh mulk Munafiq Republic of mujrebaaz hi raha hai🤣 they wants views so they are doing this propaganda also they want and need indian audience.............its all business most people are naive. . and there is a thing k jitni burai kroge utna log tumhe intellectual samjhe ge.....kyu k unko lagta hai shyd yehi tarika hai attention pane ka.....they will never do full comparison 30 percent jisse inka apna motive ajae wohi bata kr logon ko bewaquf bana dengy.

[@afzalsaifi1582]

​@@ridakhan1749 Sister tumhari country tumhari army or politicians ki wajah se barbaad hai, na religious scholars ki wajah se. Tum koi bhi ideology follow krlo tum wahin rahoge. Jis country ki space agency ka head bhi sciencetist na hokr army general ho wo country ghanta trakki karegi. Aur fir tum log sara dosh islam or scholars pr laga dete ho

[@sariahusain0622]

Thank you so much for highlighting this as people here are very proudly calling themselves secular or liberal muslims

[@biswajitsahoo2791]

I am from India ,love you brother,not for support and reality,I salute your niece,I am reading all your comments most of all are agree with you,where is the controversy create and who created it we have to find out and solve it , let's reform world

[@Imranist2024]

Solution is not secularism but the true implementation of islamism

[@ashesfreefire3109]

Yup you said right. These liberal are saying that Pakistan is not secular but in reality Pakistan is secular from 1947 but it only have Islamic name. Secularism destroys family system,social system just only to make statehood.

[@muzammilmahaar4899]

Can you define what is true Islamism? Brelvis? Salfis? Ahlehadees? Shias? Deobandis Islam?

[@sananasir2436]

These are the sects and Islam is against sectarianism.

[@solutionshorts]

​@@muzammilmahaar4899muslim

[@MohammadNuman938]

Yes like Afghanistan 😂😂

[@uziplayzroblox9150]

Dear Shahrukh bhai, couple of points for further pondering: - before freedom in Aug 1947, what was the most poweful slogun? 'PAKISTAN KA MATLIB KEYA... LA ILLA-HA ILL-ALLAH'. - there are couple of hundred countries in the world, there is not a single islamic state. There are many muslim states. If we make Pakistan a secular state then it what will be new and big about this? - Let us visualize a state which follows principles of Islam particularly EQUALITY - LAST SERMEN OF THE HOLY PROPHET... - LET us also visualize a state where instead of Capitalism / Rich becomes richer and the poor becomes poorer, we have state prociding equal opportunities to citizens and system of justice. And the state where leaders are servents not masters. And they are worried about accountability after death in front of Allah not worried about building personal empires and wealths. - sorry to say, we have been charmed with the name of Allah by our leaders excepts the founders (although this is also being made contraversial). - have we ever tried islamic economic and social justice system ever in last 75 years... - Pakistan is an opportunity to test and prove to ourselves and all humanity that Islamic System of Social Justice / Equality and Economy has the capacity n capability to make this world the best place to live!

[@shehryarbaig8947]

100%

[@Mooneypilot101]

Secularism allows all religions to co-exist without one imposing itself over another, Religion is a combination of human experiences and abstract mythology (flying horses - Burraq and Pegasus) conflating them to ideological and spiritual levels to favor the rulers. The earliest religions were more spiritual in nature. As humans started farming and settling down, they evolved the spiritual mythology into a control mechanism to benefit the powerful leaders. The early concept of God were the actual rulers. Mesopotamian kings to Egyptian Pharos acquired God status. Over time higher figures, like the sun and moon were included eventually evolving into a singular war God Yaweh who later became the Allah of Muslims.

[@samabbas8519]

Secondly, you mentioned Azerbaijan and America as examples of nations at the height of humanity, but this is another area where you have failed. Both countries are among the biggest supporters of Israel's genocude, providing logistical and military support for the genocide of Palestinian people. Additionally, America has destroyed countries like Iraq, Libya, and Afghanistan. To claim they are examples of humanity is truly shameful.

[@PoliticsWithPeak]

Only people like you can change the world Love from India