Is Henry McKenna Good When You Don't Know What It Is?

Dan pours me a sample of Henry Mckenna completely blind so what do I think about it without seeing a label?
Join us for Behind the Scenes, Barrel Picks, and Weekly Updates on Patreon:
/ bourbonjunkies
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @bourbonjunkies
25% off Liquid IV (Recovery and Hydration... Perfect for Tuesdays):
glnk.io/koyv/b...
Cheapest Sample Bottles:
glassbottleout...?p=rkuqLAgKv
Need Copyright Free Audio:
www.epidemicso...
Bourbon Junkies Merch:
www.bourbonjunk...
Follow us on instagram:
/ bourbonjunkies
Join us on Facebook:
/ 2040101716104283
Email us:
[e-mail]

[@0529mpb]

$57 at Costco. Heaven Hill BiB is $43. Both are regularly available.

[@travisjames1263]

Love that they have these at Costco. I found a Heaven Hill BIB in Costco for $32 on sale. What a deal

[@clydekimsey7503]

😮​@@travisjames1263

[@epegr1075]

I really enjoy blinds, but maybe don’t give so many hints next time. Felt like all of Dan’s comments decreased the “blind” environment. Hope to see more of these going forward

[@grcfan]

Would rather they both were blind

[@Wild_Danimal]

Would rather them be deaf and blind

[@chrispalozzi1602]

And dumb😂😂😂

[@HeffewiezenDudeGuy]

​@@Wild_Danimalthey just need to start reviewing moonshine

[@hyseptu1733]

If you’re asking Dan to keep quiet we might as well ask him to not be in the video! 😂

[@marcsingleton9430]

Recently had a drop at my local ABC Store, Everyone else was picking up Blantons and Eagle Rare. I seen this on the counter and quickly grabbed it. After getting home and having a pour, I was very satisfied with my purchase.

[@nopassenger2151]

I’ve moved away from bourbon in my life. Moving away from drinking in general actually but this is one of those bottles that in the beginning was very good to me. Cheers!

[@jeffreyspencer4005]

I paid $55.99 for one in Texas yesterday. It was $24 when I started buying it years ago (before Whiskey Advocate blew it up.) At that price, it's a good pour.

[@AdAce21]

My buds and I love this stuff; it's kind of our "go-to" share bottle. Being a person who never liked whiskey, this exact stuff is what got me into bourbon (my buddy had a bunch of these when they were 35 a pop). Here in NYC/Long Island, I find it pretty regularly for around $50-60. Just bear in mind, since they're single barrels, they do vary quite a bit.

[@namrocknamrock371]

In AZ they normally run 60-70$. Just saw them at Costco for 47.99!!!

[@C_GOODIES]

Got one in Gilbert for $40. They rang it up wrong and I ran out the store lol

[@willr.9903]

id pay that for it i would not pay 60

[@jkk4657]

I get it for $48 in Gilbert

[@FrankGastelum]

I still have 6 out of a case of 12 i bought, at $35/each. One of my first favorite bottles so I stocked up on it.

[@parkersmith711]

See this in GA around $59.99-64.99 pretty regularly. When I went to KY back in the fall, I found it at more than one store for $54.99 so I went ahead and grabbed a backup bottle 😬

[@stevenbell4623]

Just bought a bottle in Georgia for 58 :)

[@jamessocal8946]

I picked up a few more bottles last time I saw it at $60. The good ones are really good. I’d like to see you guys doing this format a couple of more times to see how it goes.

[@Brad-ic4bp]

I agree, when McKenna is a good barrel, it's really good - but I've had bad barrels/bottles too.

[@johnhicks8626]

I just bought this and my single barrel bottle is barreled in 2013 - two years newer. Still good. More baking spice, less fruit. Caramel. Oaky on the backend.

[@TheDrSpEd]

It was allocated around here for a long time but is now usually on the shelf. Good stuff! Keep doing the quick single sided blind videos.

[@GirlDad_cards]

Completely right on the variation between bottles. My first and second bottles of it were incredible, my third bottle was awful. Jury is still out on my current bottle

[@highwayman1224]

I bought a bottle of this from Costco out here in Arizona several months ago and I really like it.

[@NateRay]

ya know, instead of Celsius, there's always coffee. ☕ Cheers!

[@BourbonJunkies]

Yea my normal day has a couple shots throughout

[@clydekimsey7503]

About 5 years ago, i bought it without knowing a thing about it. In san Antonio, i paid about $28. I was really impressed with it. Its now about 60 to 80😮

[@onslaughtofterrorJW]

this is my go to, I love it

[@RocketSauce666]

This is the bottle that got me into neat whiskey. My cousin had a few bottles squirreled away behind the bar at their wedding and gave me the green light to ask for it. Prior to that it was all Old Fashioneds and Manhattans. Obvs it had the big win at the SF spirits contest back in 2019 which raised its profile and then price, but I think this is better than solid whiskey at retail. I always want to have one around.

[@TheWhiskeyChannel]

Good callout from Sean at the end. We've had a couple of stinker SiB HM10s. We've also had one that was next level awesome. We compared 3 HM10s side by side by side a few months ago (from all different years) and the 2010 was very different from (i.e. much better than) the 2011 and the 2012. XOXO

[@gingergeezer3685]

Cookie's here! Have an unopened one of these from 2020. Make have to crack it open soon...

[@Bdale478]

It's good when you know what it is!

[@SayWhenBourbon]

McKenna 10 year is a great pour! Especially when you get it for around 50 bucks!

[@twocupstwodrams7535]

This bourbon was my reintroduction to whiskey after a 40 year hiatus. On the shelf outside of the Midwest, Eastern Indiana? Not so much. Thanks for sharing.

[@Hal-Larson]

We need more of these blinds!

[@croaker4747]

I think it is around $45 in VA when you can get it in a drop.

[@nicksanchez6667]

Love the review. I just got around to buying one of these about a month ago.

[@kevingalloway1684]

Love Henry McKenna and love the format!

[@robertlee6781]

I have half of a bottle from 2021 also. It is really good. Paid a whopping $38. I have seen some at $54 around my place.

[@RunFreeRyan]

I bought a Bevmo pick and it is FANTASTIC back when it was $35. Then I bought another from a grocery store and it was horrible lol

[@FaceIntoKeyboard]

I've only had a few bottles, but they were pretty good. Not worth over $50, but at or below, it's worth a pickup.

[@drgallup]

Was a huge fan when these were $35. I've got a couple, need to crack one soon.

[@johnthallcpa]

59.99 in Virginia and I got my hands on a bottle last allocated drop day. I put it through a 100 proof blind Saturday night and it came in 5th behind, Heaven Hill BIB, Heavens Door Revelation, Benchmark Bonded and Coopers Craft. Tater card punched.

[@stephencornicelli3194]

Mine was pretty complex. Super Okay with the stone fruits. It kept changing as I went back to it. Didn't like it then I did like it...I'd buy another one. Single barrels are all diff a lil bit

[@00DUCK]

This was a great buy around the $40 mark but I refuse to pay current pricing for it. I still have 95% of a bottle I was able to grab before the price escalated.

[@nathanwillems7214]

$45 to $50 now at Total Wine in NorCal. One of my faves.

[@Crateria]

great format!

[@Valath]

This was cool Id love seeing more!

[@dirtydan1392]

Was very excited for the blind video and then Dan wouldn't shut up and gave a dozen hints for absolutely no reason except to completely nullify the blind concept. Nice job, guys. Almost 👍

[@sapefley]

I don't even mind hints, but they were WAYYYYY too quick lol

[@jzzsxm]

Like the format! More! Revisiting videos are solid. So many KZbin channels run through all of the "normal" content and then start focusing on the crazy and ridiculous, quickly losing touch with their audience. I'm thinking specifically Guga, who used to just cook normal cuts of meat in different ways and it was awesome, but now it's all ridiculous experiments and expensive meat and he's lost a core part of what made his channel good. I love the idea of going back and re-experiencing the staples that anybody can find.

[@jonathanwilliams1974]

I remember buying a bottle for $39 when it was highly allocated at that price and I thought it was just OK. I still have some...perhaps I'll give it another try.

[@jondilly1974]

I’ve only ever opened one of these and it was boring so I wrote the brand off. Guess I should snag another and give them another shot.

[@chrisbfd]

I remember y'all did a tier rating of the heaven hill line. I think Henry McKenna rated around a C or C+. As long as it stays around the current price, I'll keep one around.

[@coltonr5741]

$55-65 here in Mn. Not a great price but the juice is damn good to me

[@Dafoodmaster]

i like the format

[@SeanFinnz]

Love this bottle

[@Rob80132]

Bl-iiiiiii-nd Guesses!!!

[@curtboxley7678]

I stashed a few bottles of this away a few years ago...when I could get it for around $45.00

[@bryanmyers2110]

Looking for some recommendations. I’m driving down to Nashville next week and plan on doing some bourbon hunting on the way down. I’m going to be driving from central IL and trying to decide which route will produce better results. Going down 24 through Paducah or going down 69 (nice) through Evansville and heading over to Bowling Green. Any KY only bottles I should be looking out for? TIA

[@BRBNWolf]

Having to write this twice this week 😂 Less cat 🐈‍⬛ , wrote this this week on a Hooves garage good morning KZbin

[@pouringwhiskey9203]

Love this bottle. Cheers my friends

[@RingerDaClown]

I just got a hold of a McKenna for $50. It's amazing. Didn't they discontinue this product? I heard it will no longer be a 10 year statement or BiB.

[@clemonsjoey]

Picked up a backup bottle this weekend for $53

[@jkill1981]

I live in Fort Wayne Indiana. How far into Michigan do I have to go to get Eagle rare.

[@dustincannarella8077]

That cat gave us the angry eye for like a full 2 seconds.

[@Ch0ng0B0ng0]

Do more like these

[@goldenboy912]

I regularly see these for around $59 but would be more of a McKenna fan at around $30-$35. In my opinion there's much better bottles out there for less but I accept that my taste is different from a lot of other folks on this bottle.

[@dreamweaver32487]

Great video , keep it up

[@frankfraga295]

I believe I have this same barrel number sitting at home.

[@NFSox]

I hadn't seen a bottle three years. Now, I've seen four at around $55 in the last six months. Maybe a sign of things to come?

[@dannyfannyfoodle]

Dig it! Keep doing these.

[@Condor987]

Saw it for $59.99 in a store the other day and turned it down because the only 2 I’ve bought have been crap. Not worth the risk for me to keep hoping for a good barrel.

[@hhbuckeye5hhbuckeye585]

I always keep a backup. But if it was 35 stones, I'd have a case. It's $64 in Ohio.

[@yanksrule311]

I like this bottle a lot and have no problem paying $60.

[@TLS2005]

I drank some james e pepper rye today very good

[@adityasane]

One thing to keep in mind is that HMK10 is a single barrel product. IME, Heaven Hill's quality control on this line is poor. 90%+ barrels on the market are sub-par. Might as well spend the money to buy ECBP or Larceny BP.

[@_prkchpsndwiches]

I've had three different ones and they were all terrible. I like HH6 (RIP) and EW Sib and 12Yr, but I just cant get behind this bottle. Guessing high variance single barrels but I wont spend my money on them anymore.

[@teofilstevenson]

Fellas, what is the Magnus with the blue label? Thx

[@arttrejo8109]

Love the format! However, it would be much better if both Dan and Sean were blind. Feels like Sean was influenced by Dan's comments too much. This way we get an honest review of what is inside the bottle.

[@marcremington7375]

I hear people are all over the place with their bottles. I love mine. But haven’t dipped into any others bc of the insane markups. This bottle should not be over $50-60 tops.

[@WhiskeyAndReading]

Locally, when available, these have dropped back down to 48.95 a bottle.

[@ghostunit9]

I enjoy this BiB much more than old forester BiB

[@Sladvan]

Look at all them Schmoo Shrun bottles in the background.

[@dadkicks]

Yes yes it is

[@gstillings5140]

My bottle was like drinking paint thinner. Bitter, ethanol forward, no typical bourbon flavors at all. It was awful.

[@randc47]

Mine is pretty bad too.

[@curtboxley7678]

Some bottles are better than others....not sure what happens with these. I prefer the Four Roses single barrell at 100 proof

[@stevepayne3076]

Maybe I got a skunky bottle (not likely being BIB), but it just didn't taste good. A friend that likes HMcK tasted it and said it tasted normal to him, so he got an early birthday bottle.

[@mhard126]

I'd love to see this 2021 bottle vs 2024 bottle. Think it has gone backwards

[@davidvoller726]

While it is a $46 bourbon you should not pay more than $50. One of my absolute favorites and while these are a single barrel they seem to be pretty consistent for me.

[@spencerjcolling]

I understand that every barrel will be different from the next but my bottle of this stuff is terrible. So disappointing. That being said my friend has a bottle and I was completely blown away.

[@gmbsantabarbara]

just bought one at my local costco- $55

[@stevefromchicago8277]

What always seems to get lost in discussion- these are Single Barrels, I’ve had some really good ones and some mediocre ones.

[@Abby_Normal_1969]

I did not get fruit medley on my bottle. Good, but I would be disappointed at $70, which is $85+ with Washington's grab-your-ankles tax.

[@jheffernan13]

I bought 8 of em at $35 and then they won an award and poof they disappeared and come back at a 80% price increase. It’s good, but I feel burned and refuse to buy ever again. I have 1 bottle left at my parents house. Obviously just my personal opinion and choices. No judgement from me what folks choose to consume.

[@spencerjcolling]

My bottle of McKenna10 is below mediocre. I have no intention of ever buying another unless I get to try it first.

[@kylewipert11]

“Power bottom, dude” - Dan

[@BB-kr7ep]

Team Cookie!

[@RobertFair-s4p]

I have a bottle of H McKenna and it might be the worst bottle I own. I pour a once every few months. And it’s awful. Everyone one that’s into bourbon says I must have got a bad bottle since it’s SB. Not gonna risk buying another when there is so much good bourbon readily available

[@MrIkesimba]

It was great when it was $25 a bottle and always on the shelf. Now, as an $80 unicorn? Not so much.

[@TheBigJankowski]

$54 Costco Los Angeles. Van Nuys

[@M6transam]

Recently picked up a bottle of this. I can’t pull any tasting notes at all from it. It’s just spicy. Not pleasant. Wasted 80 dollars 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@SingleMaltMac]

Totally saw it. I call alcohol abuse!

[@paulg.5997]

One of my few bottles I avoid....never cared for it from the moment I opened it.

[@100puremustard5]

I've had 2 different SiB's and they were both forgettable 😂\ At $60 now I'm reaching for Russell's SiB

[@tdietlein]

This is the only Heaven Hill product I’ve liked. I haven’t liked an ECBP and I really don’t like Elijah Craig toasted

[@SirOttis]

Dan wants to remove all bias from Sean to see if HM10 is still good. Then Dan continues to talk so much Sean can’t get a word in, while dropping so many clues the biases Dan was trying to avoid became front and center.

[@wc1533]

My bottle is terrible. Just bitter oak. I don’t like when things are very hit or miss. Won’t risk it buying another

[@andrewvermeire6125]

When when they're at Costco they're only $48

[@lukstephens1]

Blinds always turn out interesting.....great fun that everyone can do!

[@bretthanna7194]

And it still should be 35-40 doll hairs.

[@Longenecker1776]

I wish more Bourbons would have age statements, but that’s just me.