Brenard vs Go-Shintai vs Chatterfang vs Éowyn EDH / CMDR game play for Magic: The Gathering

[@csimons]

7:39 It's a strange interaction but Micah wouldn't have Domain here. While there is a Humility on board, Magus's land altering ability occurs on layer 4, while Humility occurs on layer 6, so Magus'a bility is effectively still in effect, turning all non-basic lands into mountains. This interaction would also impact the game for a while after.

[@TCG9777]

This confusing interaction is what made me quit viewing this game

[@romeesio]

Tokens that are copies of cards have the CMC of the card they're copying, not zero; wouldn't your Muldrifter and Wavesifter survive?

[@derekgunnels4856]

This is a relatively new ruling I believe but yes you're correct. Copy tokens of cards now maintain their *ahem* mana value.

[@DarkEinherjar]

@@derekgunnels4856 They've always kept their mana values unless the effect that created them said otherwise, like in Embalm and Eternalize.

[@DarkEinherjar]

Saddest Damnation ever.

[@arymland01]

Just so Micah is aware path of ancestry is just a 5c tapped land in the shrines deck it won't provide any scry. Shine is an enchantment type not a creature type. The shrines do not have a creature type and therefore will never trigger the scry from path.

[@moedark4390]

Jesus, the coutnterspells

[@thehermit196]

o p p r e s s i o n

[@DarkEinherjar]

Culling Ritual wasn't going to hit your cookie army. They have the same mana cost as the original creatures.

[@frozentyphoon2049]

I was so confused on how go shintai died. Didn't realize grist was down ticked to kill him 5:17

[@bradsworth13]

Loved the game, especially because Brenard was there. Heads up Magus of the moon would have prevented the cracking of the marsh flats not that it massively affected the game.

[@dave_eagle2787]

At that moment magus has no abilities, cause of humility

[@Magnusovich]

​@@dave_eagle2787 @bradsworth13 is right in this case because of LAYERS. It's a super complicated, but basically when there are multiple continuous effects on a battlefield there's a list of Layers which dictate which one applies first, starting at 1 and going down to 7. Magus of the Moon is at Layer 4 whereas Humility is on Layer 6, so the Magus' ability is applied even though Humility removes that ability on a lower layer. So from 07:29 until 08:29 all nonbasic lands were Mountains, even though Magus of the Moon was a 1/1 with no abilities. All because of Layers.

[@dave_eagle2787]

@@Magnusovich forgot about layers, the bane of my knowledge of mtg rules

[@MTGMuddstah]

Oof that's complicated, haha!

[@rexone9564]

Great episode! Looking forward to that decklist

[@Anaki99DK]

Brenard list seems sweet. Any idea when you will have a list up?

[@TCG9777]

How does one skip combat before the draw step?

[@lokumo13]

Great showing of Brenard.

[@anthonybalista7421]

Definitely interested in that Brenard list, that was pretty damn spicy!

[@TK-zd7ym]

Damn 9 turns and nothing really happened. The greatest showing of Battlecruiser EDH I've seen on this channel

[@sushimahjongfc]

Great deck Andrew! Love the match.

[@adengroombaigent3258]

Where’s the brenard list?? I need it please

[@theultimatelifeform7077]

Haven't even seen the game yet, but based on the commanders, I'm expecting some cluttered board states.

[@mtgspecs]

Ah, Brenard! We have similar cards in our lists - Displaced Dinosaurs is hysterical!

[@nicholasfarrell5981]

It's pretty hilarious with Tommy B as well.

[@mtgspecs]

@@nicholasfarrell5981 Oh, it's in that deck as well! Dinosaurs telling tales as old as they are - Sagasaurus!

[@MedievalWerewolf]

Dino nuggies!

[@jeffwong2002]

why did go shintai suddenly disappear?

[@Carlk7777]

Its nice seeing someone run alot of the same cards in their brenard deack as me

[@PLB97]

Hey, nice work, keep up. is it possible to have a link for Eowin, please ?

[@sofer2230]

8:24 Would've been nice to know *how* Fred destroyed the humility. Can't parse what's on top of his graveyard from that camera angle.

[@MTGMuddstah]

I think it was a Disenchant. The audio of what he cast was mumbled sadly, sorry!

[@sofer2230]

@@MTGMuddstah All good, thanks for the update!

[@squalami2]

I think Corwin was forgetting to mill from Grist

[@TripleGMS]

Looking forward to the Brenard list

[@bidont]

Please let me know when the Eowyn deck list is rdy! I want to see it.

[@peytoncampbell1636]

Did Corwin ever mill when he used Grist's plus one ability?

[@FaustTheThird]

why tutor for magus and not immediately drop it? That was real odd, specially cause fatespinner didnt really matter early.

[@mdsw9300]

Great game, I believe magus of the moon works through humility due to when their abilities are applied layers wise. Luckily this didn't really affect the game

[@MG-yl6xo]

Need the Eowyn deck list 🔥

[@maxbodifee3263]

That Magus should have been played on t4..

[@Jay4Prez]

Grist's first ability should have made Corwin mill at least one card per activation.

[@Jay4Prez]

Also, 8:19 shouldn't be able to crack that fetch because of Magus of the Moon

[@trueHeBrew]

did you pay for Pact of Negation?

[@joebob7483]

It got countered.

[@trueHeBrew]

missed that. thanks@@joebob7483

[@Muhd_Akmal]

Cyberdrive awakener and rise and shine babyyy

[@astonrichardson5288]

God I REALLY wanna build Brenard ❤

[@bigxcon]

Why do you tell us about the combat phase, before the combat phase?

[@carlosaviles3435]

We need list pleeaaasse

[@Nero-yy4cy]

Brenard content. 👀

[@DarthTUK]

Go-Shintai decks are bullshit. I'm surprised you had enough enchantment removal to keep it in check.

[@foxykeep1]

Wrath of god should kill ojer taq and it becomes a land but you should still ahve a copy from brenard

[@legionnaire27]

Brenard says to exile the card after dying. If that happens, Ojer can't return to the battlefield since it's exiled. You have to choose not to exile so it comes back as a land.

[@DarkEinherjar]

The act of creating the token is tied to exiling the card after it dies. If he does that, he can't bring Ojer Taq back as a land.

[@foxykeep1]

@@DarkEinherjar oh right correct... I'd take the ojer taq token then I think :)

[@charles3839]

Ohhh didn't pay for that pact of negation. For shame 😢

[@MTGMuddstah]

It was countered

[@DarkEinherjar]

He only has to pay if the Pact resolves.

[@SirFrancisBaconn]

Learn the rules, chump. The pact was countered, so of course he didn't have to pay, it didn't resolve.