Brendon Urie Vs. Patrick Stump - Best Live Vocals

[@margot6896]

Theory: Patrick hides a forehead under his fedora, and Brendon hides a fedora in his forehead

[@myrtlegoesgaming6754]

my mind has exploded

[@xxxalex6726]

Frickin true!

[@pineapplejester7191]

I love you and I'm quoting this

[@cometthestar6575]

👏greatness

[@shirazens]

Margot l-/ HOLD THE FUCK UP-

[@steffbat1468]

PS: Lets be real we need an FOB & P!ATD Song with an extra extra long Song title

[@elisecode2212]

20 dollar nose bleed isn't quite there. (the song itself sure is, though.)

[@steffbat1468]

Yeah I know ha, but I mean longer

[@danasultan137]

Jesus yes

[@Strobobel]

My songs write sins not tragedies in the dark

[@krisw1852]

I write arms races but all I got was a song written about building god then we talk about sins and gospel.

[@l.1934]

"oh my God that sounds like soul!1!"

[@lonelycreamsickle4943]

Lauren OMG

[@koutsodip]

What the fuck you took my beer away

[@La_pilu]

And brendon urie had nothing to do with the entire record :(

[@balazskozma8409]

"Yo. I know more about music!"

[@petrichorrrr]

*holds up hand* aaaaaaaAAAAaaaAaAAAAAAAAa

[@mr.t1389]

I like Patricks articulation and vibrato more than Brendon's, but Brendons range is one of the best of our generation hands down

[@pizzaboy1250]

All great points that I agree with...

[@emilyweaver3005]

Mr. T I see funny joking comments then I find this

[@MichaelRockfez]

I think Patrick has more control and sings a lot more in tune. Overall, I still can’t really decide.

[@pizzaboy1250]

Michael Chan no offense but... Brendon definitely doesn’t sing out of tune... Almost never. Every vocalist has bad moments but Brendon Urie is a master of the voice as far as pitch, tone, and technique goes. I’ve never heard him sing out of tune.

[@josievarisco3266]

I like Patrick’s articulation but I think Brendon’s vibrato better in my opinion

[@miau2499]

I fucking love Patrick, but Brendon is insane.

[@reee2420]

there are some things patrick does but Brendon cant and vice versa Both amazing

[@erlineandrews]

I don't know if it's that they can't or that they choose not to do certain things with their voices. Patrick does this soul melisma thing and sometimes allows his voice to sound broken and vulnerable. Brendon does the strident high pitched Freddie Mercury thing and the big band lounge singer thing. It's a reflection of their personalities. I prefer Patrick's voice even while acknowledging that Brendon is the better showman.

[@Melanie-wy6eg]

Nice pp

[@brokenheart4099]

Brenden can do low and classic like he did in death of the bachelor

[@lilyrobson9103]

babysnake honestly there is nothing b can't do

[@the_brallon]

+Broken Heart it’s more hard for him to do that with the training he did, Patrick can hit low notes better and high notes well, but not as high as brendon. It’s weird I know

[@catluvsdnp]

I am not picking.. BOTH AMAZING

[@lindalopez8737]

Dil Same

[@agentsofshieldilovedaisy2197]

Dil same

[@garrettmoore7902]

I think Brendon Urie has better control over his voice, so I'd have to vote him. I love the sound of Patrick's voice overall more though (at it's best)

[@L4UR4RU4L]

brendon's four octave range is outstanding and his technique is flawless - especially when it comes to belting. the latter allows him to sing these skyhigh notes with this incredible ease without sounding tired or cracking. i LOVE his belts and never get tired of them!! he's even able to do (vocal fry) screams with a healthy technique. his color of voice and top-notch phrasing allows him to be an incredible emoter. i also appreciate his vocal creativity a lot. favorite vocal performance(s): climax of 'casual affair', that whole acoustic set back in 2011(?) with spencer, girar con me questta note (rare footage flying around here on yt), dream on, emperor's new clothes acoustic/studio, bohemian rhapsody, golden days, singerview 2016... what i love about patrick's vocals is his timbre (especially in the verses of 'thnks fr th mmrs' and 'mskwyditd'), i also like how his voice has this rasp at times, mostly present in the srar and soul punk eras. but the biggest reason is that, to me, there's so much comfort and emotion in general in his voice, like everytime i'm feeling low it lifts me up as if things definitely ARE gonna get better. to me, he sounds more soulful. when he sings he's like 'yo, i got a soul voice'. favorite vocal performance(s): basically every performance where he really gets to show off his soul voice e.g. climax of young & menace, stand by me, that 'what a catch, donnie'-performance where he sings the run in front of the bridge in head voice(if you're deep in, you'll know which one i mean lol) etc. due to the both of them being lyrical tenors, the both of them can really sound identical at times. just listen to the studio version of '20 dollar nose bleed' and try to find out who is who when they are singing at the same time. also, patrick aswell as brendon are able to sing in multiple genres which speaks for their versatility. their vocal stamina is on fleek and allows them to sustain notes for about 10-15 seconds. to conclude, i'd say brendon is the better singer technically and when it comes to vocal creativity. patrick's vocals are better when it comes to emotions and soul in general, but that isn't meant to neglect brendon's ability to emote, it's just that patrick's vocals touch me more, just a personal choice. i love both of them equally and they have a special place in my heart. ♡

[@dontso]

laura wtf

[@L4UR4RU4L]

flore wtf

[@dontso]

laura klausur 1+

[@yes-wo7qn]

Can u dumb it down for us pal Jk i agree 100%%%

[@lucyskyler21]

hello pls link the what a catch performance thank u

[@phyto6183]

We all know that the winner is Brendon Stump

[@nyquill8161]

I vote Pete Wentz's screamo parts

[@juanguillen6855]

Pete sxcks lmao...

[@nyquill8161]

@@juanguillen6855 your opinion is valid Ig 🦧 also this was three years ago omg

[@frostchaotic3691]

IT WAS ICE CREAM HEADACHES AND SWEET AVALAAAAAAAAAANCHE WHEN THE PEARLS IN PUR SHELLS GOT UP TO DAAAAAANCE YOU CALL ME A BAD TIPPER OF THE CRAAAAAAAADLE TIRED YAWNS FOR FAWNS IN HUNTERS LAAAAAAWNS WE'RE THE HAS-BEENS OF HUSBAAAAAAANDS SHARPENING THE KNIVES OF YOUNG WIIIIIIIIIIVES TAKE 2 YEARS AND CALL ME WHEN YOU'RE BETTEEEEEEEEER TAKE TEARDROPS OF MINE FIND YOURSELF WETTEEEEEEEEEER AAAAAAAAAAAAARGH

[@okruszeklukeya2806]

of course both of them

[@hannahtheawkwardkid1780]

Okruszek Lukeya ikr

[@stopgerardthatswaytoofar8286]

Yas

[@kimpatton1159]

Luv your profile pic

[@kaitlynv2769]

I REFUSE TO CHOSE CAUSE BOTH ARE MY FAVORITES

[@Emily-bp9he]

same

[@loriwilson9148]

That Insane Fangirl I am 100% with you

[@crispysalads]

Okay, I’ll choose for you. Beebo won :)

[@smoky7451]

8:29 JOE WINS

[@chaoticsunny6175]

Smoky - hONEsTly tHo

[@Olix466]

5:99 Beebo wins

[@tirzahvision]

They are both my favourite male vocalists ever, but I think generally Brendon does have a better range and control over his voice. Brendon is comparable to Elton john and many famous broadway stars in the way he sings, probably why he did kinky boots. Patrick however has one of the most unique and distinguishable voices ever. He truly does have a soul voice and an amazing edge and power in it. They are just both so different that it's kinda hard to compare. Basically Brendon=Professional Broadway Singer, Patrick=Soulful Rocker. Love them both but I think Brendon is the winner based on his technical abilities.

[@ilana6256]

Brendon wins every time against everyone but... I love Patrick more

[@tillyzilla36]

Classic.Patrick I agree

[@leohknee]

Classic.Patrick I love Patrick

[@leohknee]

Classic.Patrick at least Patrick knows how to keep a shirt on

[@cloudyrowan]

I agree

[@kelseyguilliams9964]

Good boy

[@erlineandrews]

I guessed the person who compiled this was a Brendon Urie fan because there was some bias in the selection of the clips. I need to hear Brendon sing the US national anthem before I decide who's the better singer.

[@BrendonUrieContent]

Erline Andrews I took most of Patrick's clips directly from "Patrick's best vocals" videos to avoid bias. Although there still may be some, i tried to avoid it.

[@erlineandrews]

The audio quality most of Patrick's clips was bad. :(

[@onehoursongsemma2820]

Erline Andrews no they weren't they were both equally good both of the clips come from the vids on popcrush's yt channel

[@lucaguccione-jimenez346]

Erline Andrews Where'd you get the bias idea from? IT'S NOT LIKE THE CHANNEL IS CALLED BRENDON URIE COMPILATION OR ANYTHING, RIGHT?!?!

[@caitlinsaxinger1590]

Well i feel like it would be hard to compare them based off of one song because of their different singing prefrences and the song would have to be slightly easier for one of the singers. And I know that I might be biased, but i would say Brendon's better. But they're both amazing. And i feel like has a better vocal range. But just my opinion

[@lonelycreamsickle4943]

Patrick has a soul voice and is super fedorable. Don't get me wrong, I love Brendon but Patrick is my #1 so Patrick wins.

[@theberserkturk6059]

Brendon Urie definitely has the bigger range, but in my opinion, Patrick Stump has a more interesting voice.

[@marissachetcuti6321]

Sam 25 I think they are equally as talented because they sing quite differently

[@katej2284]

Patrick's is my fave voice of all time. Sure Brendon can belt but I literally just think of him as Not Patrick :D

[@sleepyjayjay]

I'm not choosing, both have amazing voices!! I love Brendon and Patrick so much, I can't choose.

[@ritukashyap9704]

Not to be that salty person but you didn't really use good videos for Patrick like you cut off the great vocal parts of This Ain't A Scene and SRAR and there are so many more amazing videos of him singing like the life on mars cover and you didn't really showcase his range but whatever nice video I'm just that one cranky person

[@BrendonUrieContent]

I see what you're saying but many of these clips were taken directly from "Patrick's best vocals" videos so i figured they were alright to use. Appreciate the comment though :)

[@athenaperry5081]

Ritu Kashyap I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING THE WHOLE TIME. WHERES THE LIFE ON MARS VIDEOOO

[@verysquishy3904]

If you want great vocals from pat, gym class heroes billionaire, clothes off, stereo heroes live

[@lonelycreamsickle4943]

i get it.

[@stopgerardthatswaytoofar8286]

That is true but Patrick sounds good anyway

[@josephsuarez9594]

Range does not equal better... anyway I prefer Patrick because his tone and intonation are magnificent.

[@manofsteele1044]

I watch a bunch of videos of some artist against brendon urie, all comments love brendon. Watch this video, they don't want to choose

[@buriedlittlelove]

AHHHHH!!! I LOVE BOTH....They are both my babies!

[@Marcel-wo3yy]

I love you Brendon with my whole heart But i love pattycakes more, he is the winner.

[@graceb1628]

*DID YOU JUST PLAY WHAT A CATCH DONNIE* **EXCUSE ME**

[@Trashmanstrashcan]

This is more than I bargained for

[@v4mpiref4ng]

Aaaaand now there's gonna be a war in the comments

[@myahsoggy3122]

Sorry guys but Patrick for sure. I have an emotional attachment to the sound of his voice

[@Leo-gv8hz]

myah soggy same except me with beebo

[@crispysalads]

That’s a weird way to say brendon.

[@josievarisco3266]

myah soggy I disagree but go off sis

[@josievarisco3266]

Not trynna be rude just so you know

[@FloreMar-yp3iz]

@@crispysalads Sorry but that's a weird way to say "I respect your opinion"

[@greentea5095]

I love both but i have to pick Brendon.

[@elipost1703]

I love them both but Brendon definitely wins

[@bj_emlilys3284]

I say brendon urie

[@Leo-gv8hz]

I say Jimin wins

[@xd_dat.one.boi_xd2285]

Don't make me choose, Both of them are great to me because I'm literally there baby because I look like if both of them had a baby

[@PureEpicnessXDC0RE]

I don't honestly think it's a fair comparison like basically all of the Patrick examples are given shit audio in a concert from some random kid's iPhone and Brendon's got these professionally recorded videos (also, there are professional recordings of some of the Patrick clips that were shown, I just think it's a little biased towards Brendon I mean look at the name of the channel.)

[@onehoursongsemma2820]

PureEpicnessXD they're both from the same vids on the same YT channel

[@BrendonUrieContent]

I took them from compilations of patrick's best vocals so not my fault those people also chose bad clips

[@averyryder8080]

patricks vocal range is incredibly rare,,,, especially as of 2015 onwards

[@leoapps2076]

O well Brendon is better and always will be he has the voice of an angle

[@1emonboyy19]

@@leoapps2076 Yup the voice of an angle.

[@damarisresto7848]

Brendon Urie Wins

[@tsporte405]

Patrick is incredible, but Brendon is better.

[@percabethisawesome1163]

I love both so much but brendon, he just has more range & control & can hit notes better, occasionally patrick doesn't hit high notes though he has a beautiful soul voice & is very strong due to his many stolen lungs

[@adrianoines521]

brendon has a larger range however patrick can belt way higher. He is also able to sing really softly and gently in a way that brendon cant. Brendon can hit his whistle tones really easily but patricks belt is stronger.

[@imtryingimtryingtosleep6124]

N o Don't make me choose-

[@twinny_mi]

Luv your name and your pic

[@astridway4240]

Beebo obviously

[@keelystricker4656]

What no

[@yes-wo7qn]

ryan is the sun na bro range isnt everything

[@astridway4240]

yung menace but beeb's still better

[@astridway4240]

In my opinion

[@yes-wo7qn]

ryan is the sun and also people whomstdve call brendon "beebo" must be excuted

[@minazuban2118]

Patrick wins for me, always, I love Beebo so much, and he might have better voice, but there's something special in Patricks voice, that makes me happy no matter what, he just has the most beautiful and unique voice that I've ever heard 😊❤

[@aileen4257]

I really love both,but the vocal range of Brendon is better

[@aileen4257]

What?

[@Olix466]

@@aileen4257 yes, Brendon is better

[@iakiria]

I love how panic!/FoB community is like "fuck you, I ain't gonna choose", best fan base ever

[@thereyvan]

I thought it’d be closer in the comments. Y’all really love Brendon. Personally, I go for Patrick, but I’m not one to control your lives. Gotta blast!

[@Ender_boo]

This is like making a parent choose a favorite child

[@ajg2004-]

I have more of an emotional attachment to Patrick, though obviously I adore both of them, but Brendon definitely has the better voice as far as technique and range, though Patrick just really has that butterfly causing emotion to it

[@kaylaclark4409]

Beebo forever 💗

[@charizdead1365]

When all you want for Christmas is Dallon Weekes.... Ik this was completely unrelated

[@endofinfinity4131]

Unrelated but appreciated. I love Dallon so much.

[@shirazens]

I want Dallon and Ryan. Two basses are better than none. *cri*

[@reb8017]

I relate to this comment on a spiritual level

[@Andrew_Germain]

Sorry Patrick, I love you a lot but Brendon wins

[@mlekuwu4493]

Patrick is the best singer ever. I love him and FOB.

[@torimote2519]

Also, Patrick never took singing lessons. He actually was going to be the drummer. Now let that sink in..

[@brantleyt05]

HOW CAN I CHOOSE THEY ARE BOTH MY ANGELS?!

[@niceclashroyale9381]

Brendon is better❤his voice is like a angelvoice nobody can hit his beautiful voice😍❤

[@bonniedaviess]

Patrick's voice is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING, but, I gotta admit, Brendon's voice is probably one of the best of this generation. He has such great control and his vocal range is even bigger than his forehead. It's just so amazing. However, Patrick's voice is so beautiful. Still, I gotta choose Brendon. 💕

[@_young_blood_0004]

I love Patricks voice. Its like the voice he has came from heaven. Angels gve it to him. I LOVE PATRICK SO MUCH.

[@KyreDevotional]

I'm a bigger fan of Brendon actually. But Patrick is also a great singer. I'd probably prefer Brendon's vocals since he encouraged me to bust my vocal range, but I love Patrick's voice as well. Do not ever ask me a question "who is better" ever please.

[@brookehansen6181]

I mean Brendon wins for everything but Patrick was awesome.

[@megan6796]

Brendon wins cause you can understand him more of the time

[@tessadunn7157]

Brendon has a larger vocal range but they're both incredibly talented and Patrick is still amazing

[@aaaa6666-s1l]

Brendon Urie ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@lunastump3825]

Can't we just appreciate both of their beautiful amazing voices?

[@floriansis400]

This question is harder than the ones on national tests..............but my answer is A ...... beebo

[@zosiawiackiewicz5152]

Am crying! whyyy? I love them and their vocals the same! The are both so talented! Brendon and Patrick are both LIFE. ~

[@saphydoesstuff6414]

Had to show this to my brother because the thought Brendon and Patrick sounded exactly the same :/

[@shadowthefurry115]

XStarlight HowlsX XDDDDD

[@agro2598]

In my opinion Patrick is better. He doesn't rely on his falsetto as much as Brendon does. He uses very well supported high belts. His chest voice on a good night can fly into the 5th octave with ease. I like his style better. Brendon has a very limited rock style to his voice, I love his voice but *IN MY OWN OPINION* Patrick is better. Also Brendon smokes cigarettes and weed all the time making his voice sound tired and pinched. Again my opinion. Edit: I noticed you used half of the Brendon clips from that live acoustic session from 2011 when his voice was at its best (in my opinion). It seems very biased and you didn't pick the best clips for Patrick.

[@itzzsevn9660]

AgroGaming Brendon doesn't smoke cigarettes

[@straightchlorine2434]

AgroGaming his voice in PFTW is better than ever.

[@kayleyhaflich3289]

Excuse me wtf

[@1emonboyy19]

I do love Patrick's voice more too.

[@tok33n14]

@It's the summer of 2004 we can clearly tell from the main comment who is the one that smokes weed

[@blackbird3847]

Thank you so much for including that performance of Headfirst Slide into Cooperstown on a Bad Bet because I worship that video like nothing else and was hoping so much that it would be included

[@katiesrw]

Brendon wins. ALWAYS

[@kimberleyalcorta7139]

Brendon has a stronger vibrato and belt. But patrick has a more soothing and more of a soul voice. This makes both of them very great🥰

[@boredlyaesthetic4111]

I CAN'T CHOOOOOOOSEEEEEEE THEY ARE BOTH SO AMAZING

[@maggie12md18]

I love C’mon! It has Nate Ruess from Fun! The Some Nights Album was lit

[@lynn6579]

BEEBO! Hes got the looks 💞 He's got the voice 🎤 He's got the kindness 😘 He's got the maturity 🙏 He's got a outstanding control over his voice 🎶 He's got good song styles 💁 He's very relatable 😍 He's amazing with instruments 🎹 Overall he's perfect 💙👑😘 (Just my opinions though I respect everyone else's thoughts about him.)

[@shad0whawk947]

I can see most of the comments section has never taken a chorus class or voice lessons. The closest thing most of them speak about regarding technique is range smh.

[@Tommy1337-]

Objectively, Brendon has the most well rounded and pleasant sounding voice.

[@calebcarter9339]

I love both voices, Brendon wins in my book. He can literally sing anything, I feel like he has the perfect tone in his voice for any genre if that makes sense.

[@Olix466]

yes, Beebo always win :)

[@davidkushal461]

can't choose! love em both!!! its like comparing your two nuts

[@ThatGirlAtTheConcert]

Range - Brendon. Literally everything else - Patrick Lil boy can sing

[@tasia3236]

Beebo all day even tho i love both and both are extremely talented

[@mckayla1609]

Oh great, two people I've sold my soul to.

[@cayleecat5948]

Brendon clearly

[@keelystricker4656]

Smh

[@akakkajsjsjsj2649]

cayleecat101 both

[@akakkajsjsjsj2649]

cayleecat101 :3

[@stopgerardthatswaytoofar8286]

I love your profile pic

[@floriansis400]

cayleecat101 dude ..... your profile pic is fucking awesome

[@whydidannahavetokillsam1705]

Brendon defiantly sings really high and holds them a lot and it's really impressive and proves he's not bad at all with the low notes which proves he's an incredible singer in a lot of ways. But then again so is Patrick, he doesn't do extreme high notes like Brendon, but when their is high notes he hits them almost perfectly every time. Folie live always show his talent so much cause it gives a good middle ground for the notes. I'd say Brendon because of the notes Brendon can hit and hold on the scale low or high

[@EternaISouI]

Stump duh

[@hyperinsomniaparacondrioid]

pfft seriously? obviously, it's gerard way

[@pujibur8038]

duh

[@Marcel-wo3yy]

1. Patrick and Gerard 2. Brendon

[@papayaanimations1277]

It's the summer of 2004 i know

[@lesfrog649]

Who?

[@moth6966]

YES

[@natashaxv]

i love both but: (It's like brendon is patrick's father) Singing King : Brendon Singing Prince: Patrick

[@manofsteele1044]

Natasha Fall out ! At The Pilots it's funny that fall out boy is a lot older than panic at the disco

[@natashaxv]

Steelium lol

[@readyaimfire3454]

Fall Out Boy basically mentored Panic tho 😭😭 this is v backwards

[@evelynnwinter6765]

hmm they're both amazing but beebo always wins in my mind no matter what

[@pizzaboy1250]

I prefer Patrick's tone and vocal style. Brendon has an absurd range and is a five star performer. They both have incredible control and really could sing any kind of music or make any style choice and pull it off with perfection. 2 of the greats.....

[@haleigh6089]

brendon is like the video game character that beats everyone but patrick is the boss after the final boss that nobody can beat.

[@friedpebbles]

Dont let me choose between the lead singers of my two favorite bands I cant do this

[@kerignn]

8:44 I thought the sideburns were back

[@beomgyu1311]

Dont make me pick!

[@iam._.lou7877]

Both have voices of angels so they both win.... Because they're both so equally phenomenally amazing and talented

[@chaoticsunny6175]

im sorry but i love them both equally. brendon has excellent control and range. like seriously- 8 oCtaVes???!!! and his high notes are so powerful, as well as his lower notes. theres something about his voice thats so strong yet so vulnerable and sweet. and with as much dancing/moving around as he does, id consider it godly. same with patrick. the way he displays his vocals is honestly so admirable. “ yo, i got a soul voice “ even drunk, brendon knows whats up XD his vocals are messy which is comforting and real in a way i dont know how to explain. ive never met such a voice from the punk/alternative rock genre that flexible. he displays his emotes so incredibly. in summary, pete wentz looks good here.

[@Minifliek]

Even Though Brendon's range is better, Patrick's gives me goosebumps. So easy win for Patrick. Fun story: I didn't know hé was such an amazing singer till i finally saw FOB live last year.

[@pamsalfarizi]

They can exchange positions with each other

[@pikachuu9910]

It’s literally impossible to pick, they’re both amazing omg

[@axqua8593]

I LOVE THEM SO MUCH! I CAN'T PICK! BOTH OF THEM ARE SO GOOD!

[@domatm]

Patrick won for me, but Brendon's vocal range is killing me

[@cowboybat]

They're both so amazing wot the heck i love them aH

[@ilikedogs1504]

I mean let’s just take a moment to know that Patrick never had vocal lessons 🤷‍♀️

[@pineapplejester7191]

I like dogs that soul voice comes naturally

[@twinny_mi]

Pete encouraged him to sing. For all those people dissing Patrick, BEEBO YOU WOULDNT EXIST WITHOUT FOB, PETE SIGNED YOU! Now that I've ranted... Not trying to dis BEEBO at all, tho, just those people that are critical to Patrick. Everyone forgets that FOB and Panic! Are basically Best Buds! They have played pranks on each other, been in each other's songs, went on tour together!!!! Stop dissing each other!

[@partypoison2374]

Best part of the video is 0:00 to 6:35❤️

[@daguydatluvspanicatthedisc6569]

50% for pat 50for beebo Cant choose But im gon go to beebo