British guys try Girl Scout Cookies for the first time!

Today we try an American classic and see which is the best girl scout cookie! Get your JOLLY merch at getjolly.store
Click here to buy Josh's bestselling autobiography! amzn.eu/d/73xtwcy
Hit join and become a Jollybean member to join us in our members-only livestreams:
kzbin.infojoin
Special thanks to our Jollybean VIPs for supporting us in making this video!
Reilly Willoughby
Li Winslow
Yun Lim
유경Ella
AJ Villanueva
Nora yousef
Victor koh
Anthony Jefferson
cubit큐빗
Alex Kunis
Koral JollyBean
Jessica lodge
Uyen Ngo
Diana Woon
Madison Cho
Patricia Veronica
63angel
Julian Leung
Bada Choi
Nurse Laykan
heather owen
Laura Hipwell
CitrusQuill
Clare
Bettie Meier
Gloria Kwon
Michael Zambrano
lira12tan
Andi526

[@patriciajackson1457]

Ollie, the majority of Girl Scout cookies are eaten in a closet for two reasons 1) so no one else can have any. 2) because we don’t want anyone to know just how many we ate 😂❤

[@Samuel-I]

I’m a multi box annihilator and I won’t apologize for it ! 🤓🔥

[@Sommiel]

I have “accidentally” eaten an entire box of Samoas on more than one occasion.

[@LadyCyr]

Agreed lol

[@SuzanneBaruch]

Truth.

[@stephanielowe8035]

absolutely!!!

[@erjinson]

i always appreciate the effort that ollie puts into sourcing and wearing outfits that fit with the episode’s theme 😭

[@uncreative5766]

Seriously. Ollie is dressed so identically to a Boy Scout that I wouldn't be surprised if he had popcorn to sell around his neighborhood.

[@Inkio01]

Yeaa slightly disappointed that josh wasnt wearing one too

[@The0neAnd0nlyUnicorn]

Well, yeah. But it's still hurting my eyes, that he is not wearing the scarf properly... It needs to be rolled up

[@revinaque1342]

@@The0neAnd0nlyUnicorn that's exactly what I was thinking 😂

[@ramyahiriyur]

@@The0neAnd0nlyUnicorn and the woggle

[@mauraschatz5395]

From a former Girl Scout, three things: 1. Thin mints are better frozen 2. Samoas are better cold 3. The lemon cookies used to be DELICIOUS but they keep changing them (the best was when it was a plain cookie with lemon frosting in the shape of whatever the shortbread ones are called)

[@1ghostchaser]

They totally didn't even have any Oatmeal Peanut Butter Sandwiches.....what????

[@glo1005]

Gurl I thought I was trippin about the lemon cookie. It over lemony

[@iwishiwasthomasshelby]

@@hotboxedHemi300weirdo. Please remove yourself from society.

[@iwishiwasthomasshelby]

@@hotboxedHemi300no one likes you.

[@sarahm8657]

​@MMathis-cu7ewto this day, my dad still thinks about those cookies. Loved them when my sisters and I were in girl scouts in the 90s

[@L_Jay10]

Could you all do the girl scout cookies with the high schoolers. Their reactions would be priceless.

[@DravenGal]

Oh that's freaking BRILLIANT! Yes sir! I vote for this idea too!

[@cindyllax]

Yes!!!!!

[@suewolf3279]

Me too

[@kirstenr.6512]

Me too!

[@kathleenmiller516]

Please.

[@arnoldsherrill2585]

The thin mints are extraordinary when they're cold. And the Samoans are just sublime. The girl who broke the record during girl scout cookie season was selling her cookies outside of a marijuana dispensary.,

[@ivechang6720]

😂 Genius! She definitely knows how to pick a niche market.

[@kendallrichardson5639]

I feel like that Girl Scout has a bright future.

[@ambersmith459]

Yes gotta put thin mints and Samoas in the freezer...so much better

[@ivechang6720]

@@ambersmith459 Thin mints yes. Samoas nooooooo! We need the melty goodness of the caramel stretching between each bite. 😋

[@ambersmith459]

@@ivechang6720 I disagree I like the snap of the caramel when frozen

[@itsfqndave]

As a Samoan, I can confirm we definitely smell like caramel and coconut, and have a dark chocolate complexion. So yes, it makes sense that we'd make the ultimate cookie. What can I say? The Big Man upstairs did a great job 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@bodyofhope]

🤣🤣Great comment!

[@karmaoutlaw]

Hahaha! 😃 🇼🇸

[@ashleybroening6933]

I love this 😅

[@Olivia-xf4gy]

Lol this is the best comment 😂

[@kerrymorris3366]

Love this!!

[@finnmcool2]

I've always thought it was a crime that Dos Si Dos aren't more popular. They are my absolute favorite Girl Scout Cookie.

[@kittywetzel92]

I am with you! Do Si Dos are the best!

[@miragenesoi7026]

I agree

[@LarryGonzalez00]

Are you talking about the peanut butter sandwich cookie? If so, I totally agree with you.

[@axmajpayne]

Ya, they are one of my favorites as well. They should have tried those.

[@sushiroll3795]

Do Si Dos are insanely good, and I genuinely don't understand why they're so underrated.

[@lauracavanaugh7466]

I am a Girl Scout troop leader in Mississippi, USA. Our troop has 8-10 year old girls. We just finished our cookie season. The girls have so much fun and they end up learning a lot (money handling, planning, communication skills...) We are so excited to see yall enjoy these cookies!!

[@gsaw5008]

Brings back fond memories! I was a Girl Scout for years loved going camping making banana boats🤗

[@pamelaleannefreeland9025]

From an American: Samoas are definitely the best, though thin mints are the most popular. And since you guys liked the thin mints, I’ll give you a pro tip. Stick a sleeve of them in the freezer. Then they are at their best, in my opinion. Enjoy! 💜

[@josephdavid3081]

I'm American too and I also came here to recommend freezing the Thin Mints.

[@Liie37]

LOL same; I was waiting to see if someone posted about freezing them LOL they are so good that way. My fav though will always be Samoas :)

[@MzGFunk]

I put mine in the fridge! They’re so good nice and cold!

[@bryantkeller9278]

THIS 💚

[@jenncutshall4624]

I freeze those, and Samoas yummm

[@pierogizkimchi]

Oh my god, all my life watching these American tv shows where they were talking about selling girl scout cookies, I was thinking that girl scout cookies are cookies actually made by girl scouts! I was so naive 😅

[@paulcalb]

I can see why you might think the girl scout cookies were made by girl scouts. I think many people think like you. They are actually made by various bakeries under the license from Girl Scouts of the USA, a non profit organization.

[@ayoayo1044]

I feel like maybe at some point they were before girls scouts became a big organization.

[@iac4357]

Originally they were; before becoming industrialized !

[@TomTomLo1]

I thought so too. Who wants to buy a factory cookie with girl scouts on the packet? I thought learning how to bake, package and market cookies was all part of the challenge for the girl scouts? America is just awful. Next you are going to tell me that lemonade stands are owned by Nestle.

[@SSEBBlue]

@@TomTomLo1 to be fair it acts as a fundraiser for their local Girl Scout’s council respectively. That money is used to then donate to local charities or animal shelters, used to take the girls on wilderness activities and such~ i wouldn’t shame it at all! As someone in music as a kid, we fundraised as well and all that money would go to buying new instruments, going to really nice 2 week vacation trips where we would preform in let’s say a Disney World Parade for example and such, new uniforms. I would imagine it’s the exact same use for them! ☺️ it doesn’t go to some big corporation or anything, it (raised funds) 100% stays with the local Girl Scout group :)

[@thesehandsart]

Try putting the thin mints into the freezer! It's a whole other experience!❤

[@Annie.747]

THIS🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 it goes thru metamorphosis into the best friggin cookies ever

[@askmeificare336]

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@m.-.-.]

Same with the lemon cookies

[@katemock8260]

That's what my husband does with his.

[@awildawallace5837]

Yeah awesome when you've had a tough day. Yummy 😋

[@aleece4]

“No wonder they’ve got an obesity problem!” 😂 Ollie’s got a point!

[@RRQueen1]

So does England.

[@mishka8180]

So rude of him to say even if he thinks it, should not say it. He can be very rude.

[@katiecarr6609]

Fun fact: thin mints have passed Oreos as the most sold cookie in America. When I was a Girl Scout I had so many friends and family members literally spend 50 dollars on a case (12 boxes of thin mints) to just keep and store in their freeze so they could enjoy it yearround.

[@TheAsmrAddict888]

I'm surprised since they suck now. They haven't been good in at least 10 years.

[@ebonywinters7658]

That's why I don't eat them anymore (except Samoas) had to many selling them

[@duncil85]

Walmart has their knock off brand of thin mints and samoas that are better than the girl scout cookies! There are a few others that Walmart does...like the tagalong...omg...yummy...I'll go with 3 bucks instead of 5 or whatever it is these days 😂

[@TheAsmrAddict888]

@@duncil85 Aldis has tagalong copys and they are so much better than the girl scout ones. Pretty much the way they use to be.

[@emmasurf8109]

I think I've reason they were so popular when I was a GS was they only had a few kinds, you had to sell them door to door (guess pedos didn't exist back then. You took the order then delivered them weeks later and that was it for the year. There was so much FOMO and people would buy a bunch and freeze them. Somewhere somehow it morphed into the sell on your website or get your parents to sell them, and also the weird flavors they keep trying.

[@caseyic9165]

One of the secrets of eating the most favorite type of cookie, the Thin Mint, is to freeze them first. When it's frozen, it snaps which makes it even more delicious. I hope you try it that way (if you have any left over). Enjoy!!

[@amandachilds5290]

Yes! I also like them in Bryers vanilla ice cream!!

[@raeannaroylance5401]

I concur. Cheers 🥛

[@lindiekeely7428]

Casey, you are correct.

[@allisonl3356]

Yes! My boss swears by frozen Thin Mints. Too bad they didn't have this tip before they ate.

[@Naomi-tj1qz]

My mom always got milk, bit a tiny bit from the top and the bottom of the thin min, then used the cookie like a straw. Looks ridiculous but it's so good!

[@sharonbetts7209]

I was a girl's gout 50 plus years ago. The thin mints we're the most popular at that time as well. It's common for people in the US to stock up on thin mints because you can't get them for another year, and put them in the freezer.

[@TheTEXMIKE]

you can buy the same thing in the store all year.

[@catherinewilson5441]

To be clear, the reason the shortbread are so popular is because they’ve been around forever and they’re the cookie of choice for the elderly. And no, they’re not eaten in front of your grandma, they are almost exclusively eaten, an entire box at a time, by oneself in absolute shame. But they’re sooooooo good!!!! Side note: Boy Scouts sell popcorn. It’s not nearly as good as the cookies, but it does exist.

[@HarmoniousHorse]

YES

[@chadsmith3363]

Helped my boys sell popcorn for YEARS. It's not bad, until you factor in the price. The smallest item is a box of microwave popcorn for $10, and it goes up from there to ridiculous levels for the flavored ready-to-eat canisters. At $4 a box, Girl Scout Cookies are a much better value.

[@BathersonMote]

I love shortbread and I was ready to disagree with you on your comment that it is the choice of the elderly. Then I remembered my age, and it was like, "Oh crap, she's right", To be fair though, I've loved shortbread long before I became a geezer.

[@Bunbur]

My cat has definitely stolen my snack bag of these and I found my ziploc bag of them with a hole in it under the couch. These were also the first girl scout cookies to be sold

[@srkh8966]

It’s too easy to eat a box by oneself-should be illegal

[@hankbug]

As a former Girl Scout, I can tell you that GSC season is a major deal. The money we made by selling cookies funded our yearly camping trips, national convention trips and yearly dues. The Caramel Delights and Samoas are the exact same cookie they just come from a different cookie distributor. Great looking uniform Ollie, I think you are well on your way to earning an "Ambassador Cookie Influencer Badge"....yes, that's a real thing. ☺

[@Shebeast3]

is it? wow

[@erin8575]

It's true, the money we made for our troop selling cookies was such a big deal. We took a summer camping trip every year to different places across the country and there were girls in my troop who couldn't have afforded to do that without us all working hard to sell cookies.

[@nicolawestwood38]

We need to get him a badge….anyone got insider links to Girl Scouts US?!

[@aussiebird14]

Yes! It really helped pre-sale season to be an older scout since you could sell to you classmates, but was definitely harder on location….people don’t feel as bad saying no to teenagers over elementary schoolers. and I know it’s gone up to $5(?) a box, but back when I sold them at $4, we only earned 60¢/box. Not many people realize how hard we worked for not much reward. Where I lived, it was cold and rainy all cookie season and we’re not allowed to set up our tables inside the shops (Girl Scout rule). We technically weren’t even supposed to wear jackets over our uniforms, which thankfully our guardians usually let slide. I know they’re expensive, but I always buy one when asked and give it to the girls. I remember feeling so nice getting cookies from a stranger after standing outside for 2 hours.

[@oaktree1628]

How many boxes of cookies did you sell as a personal record?

[@63angel]

When my daughters were younger, I was their girl scout leader. All of the girls in the troop sold over 2500 boxes each. I was surprised that the girls could sell that many boxes. Thin mints has been the biggest seller for years. This year a friend who has 2 daughters knew I would buy them. each box is now $5.00 each. Even though they are $5.00 each, people will pay it since it benefits the girls. I ended up spending $125.00 this year. My daughters are 40 yrs old now and they have children also and my grand-daughters now sell them.

[@LindaC616]

Some are $6, in my area

[@dreamer7770]

That went from cute to impressive to wholesome in such a short amount of time.

[@joeykiller]

at the top of that pyramid is quintessentially a guy playing cookie clicker

[@unknownguyindo4356]

You know what, the girl scouts cookies is actually a pretty savvy and clever business. They unintentionally _"use"_ young girls/kids to promote their products for them and it's succeed *MASSIVELY*

[@rachelcookie321]

When I was a girl guide I sold like 20 boxes a year… how much time do they spend selling cookies in America? That would take forever! And where do they go to manage to sell that much each? Do they not run out of people?

[@zeus136988]

I was hoping they would've had the "Do-si-dos" peanut butter sandwiches. One of my favorites with Samoas and Tagalongs.

[@kellywalker7127]

Very disappointed they didn't try Do-si-do's. They are one of my favorite. That and think mint. Surprised they were not mentioned. Guys, they are back and I hope you try Them this year.

[@crisceewillcutt7296]

Those are the only 3 that I ever get. I don't waste my time on any others lol.

[@sarah.s.flanagan]

​@@kellywalker7127 For real?? I thought they stopped making those, that's awesome

[@dfloriza]

As a Filipino, i had to laugh when they pronounced tagalongs like "tagalog" xD

[@christopherchen344]

EXACTLY!!! 😆😆😆 And this Chinese-American thought that it was pronounced in reverse “TAG-uh-long” until I met my first Filipino in my 20’s (and now life bestie). Also, I thought that famous Filipino language was named after the even more famous GS Cookie (or vice versa).🥴😳

[@lisalister8002]

My sister bought 200 boxes to send to her son who was serving in the Army in Iraq. When he got the boxes - he had great fun passing them out to other soldiers.

[@mdt1577]

When I was in and we got Girl Scout cookies they became a very valuable trading commodity ( especially Thin mints)😂

[@DubThaDetailer]

On one of my deployments many many years ago, some organization did the same thing for us. We were ecstatic.

[@4wheelliving132]

Wow that's a cool and great idea. My sister used to send my nephew stuff to share when he was in Iraq as well. His little sister was in about 3rd grade and they 'adopted' his group (whatever you call it) and would write individual letters to each man at Christmas and made little homemade cards for each one

[@christinap-c]

That’s brilliant.

[@TenTonNuke]

As an American, I'm required by law to say that Thin Mints are my favorite. But late at night, when no one else is around... ...I'm eating the Samoas.

[@KanadeChiaki]

Naughty kid we got here aren't we

[@andreac7261]

Naughty Brian! ... you must now go to girl scout court and atone for your crimes 😂😂😂

[@heylo757]

Yes, it is thee late night treat. "I'll just have one 😁 ...row 😫"

[@hutch3376]

Gotta pull them straight out of the freezer though!

[@neolithiumproduction]

I'm part of the 10% of Americans that don't like mint. Still required to vote by law for Thin Mints though. Can't deny they are king for those that do love mint.

[@SteveSwags]

I keep a few boxes of Thin Mints in my freezer at all times. They are so good when frozen! Also, a "sleeve" of cookies is a single serving size for me.

[@theConquerersMama]

Same. I was so upset when I found out our sitter was sneaking them and putting back empty boxes.

[@Northernsolstice]

Yes, need to eat them colddddd!

[@srkh8966]

It’s normal for everyone!

[@dammitqirong]

back in the late 90s ish there was an apple cinnamon cookie and i miss those so much, i dont even remember what they were called but they were the BEST. they also came out with what i think were called lemon smiles before the current lemon ones (they were like lemon tea cookies covered in powdered sugar) and they were so much better than the current lemon cookies.

[@TheAsmrAddict888]

The lemon ones were GOOD.! Such as shame I think all of them suck now. THey changed them so much in the last 10 years. I refuse to buy them now, besides the fact that the price is ridiculous now.

[@waterloohillpeace]

They were called apple cinnamons! And the lemon ones are called savannah smiles 💛☺

[@TraceyJean]

I loved those Savanah Smiles!

[@TheAsmrAddict888]

@@TraceyJean i forgot that's what those ones were called thanks. I was a Brownie a couple years, started Girl scouts then bailed. We weren't doing anything real fun. The boys were.

[@pureconception]

Righttttttttttt!!!! It’s like they don’t understand when they have a good thing going because when I was a girl scout (98-01) they had SO many classics on the lineup that even though they can’t compete over the Big 3, could definitely still stand their ground. In the past 10-15 years, the newer cookies they keep rotating and redeveloping have all been pretty weak imo

[@marsdoria189]

Josh: "I don't like taking risks." Also Josh: *Has a video where he skydives, eat nuclear fire noodles, and jumps off a mountain in New Zealand*

[@thenameisgsarci]

Unfortunately for all of us as well, not taking a risk is also a risk in itself.

[@malfon12]

I love how Josh says, "proper American cookie territory," and the both proceed to dunk a cookie that is impenetrable by milk without biting it first. 💀

[@jenniferpearce1052]

They have that British "all biscuits are hard and must be dunked" training.

[@gigi9301]

Exactly!! That bugged me!!!

[@user-sf1js1nq7e]

I thought the same thing. You only dunk cookies that can absorb the milk. That was a definite faux pas!

[@isabellegt9826]

Olive is the true first wife, playing dress up, adventurous, loving and supportive. Thank you for always giving us a laugh 😅

[@lynnjepson8218]

I love how Ollie always looks heavenward! LOL....

[@sherriandwaynejohnson3185]

By the way, your comment about the thin mints is spot on. When you eat thin mints, you are literally plowing through the entire box.

[@englishatheart]

Literally? More like figuratively.

[@havenbastion]

Some of us with exceptional self control eat a row and save the rest for an hour later.

[@brycedecker7142]

@@havenbastion impossible. How is it done?

[@havenbastion]

@@brycedecker7142 You have to be enlightened first.

[@alisasanders3]

It’s true and sad lol

[@nhazex3]

Who else would really like to see Juno review these cookies!? 🙋‍♀

[@artifex4853]

Literally the first that came to mind when I read the title!

[@personontheinternet304]

Bet she would like the pida butta! (peanut butter lol)

[@jjgarrett8225]

And the high schoolers!!!

[@andreac7261]

Pretty much everyone needs to review them. Rev Chris .. Juno ... Ollie's dad ... etc

[@kpop2395]

Juno hasn't been on the channel in a while! I wonder if Ollie is trying to keep her life a little more private 🤔

[@dawnbabcock3775]

I love Josh's laugh and Ollie's facial expressions. 😅

[@thatawkwardnerd8998]

My college roommate and best friend was a Girl Scout for seven years. She was counting down the days until Cookie Season this year! She went home for a weekend and came back with a box of Samoas, S'mores (which are her favorites), and Lemon-Ups. I was warned not to touch them, which was fine by me because I only like Tagalongs and Thin Mints 😂

[@ventrueb]

Girl Scout cookies are amazing Frozen. These are “seasonal” because they’re an annual fundraising event. It’s amazing marketing because they’re limited time! The different names are because the cookies are a National treasure and some names are regional. Also, try the shortbread with hot cocoa! Brownie, lemon and s’mores are new. There is usually some kind of lemon one. They add new ones per year to see what people like.

[@LindaC616]

Smores are a couple of years old

[@ventrueb]

@@LindaC616 ah! You’re right. I think this is just the first year we bought them. Thanks for the correction!

[@emmaponymous]

I bought a box of the "lemonades" (round with glaze on the bottom, but no messages) and they didn't last a week. The bakery changed the following year and I ended up getting "Savannah smiles" lemon slice shaped with powdered sugar... They didn't survive the ride home. 😅🤤

[@LindaC616]

@@ventrueb maybe they're at dollar stores, too. I try to avoid them--I live alone. Danger, Will Robinson! 😆

[@sallymcquaid6392]

Thin mints frozen are THE BEST

[@liv.contgeth]

Omg, Ollie's outfit is so cute and it really suit him. Beside that the cookies looks so good, I haven't tried a girl scout cookies in my life and now I'm craving cookies.

[@faithong451]

I only chose to watch this video because I saw Ollie's outfit haha

[@lillithveil]

Girl guide cookies are very big in Canada too. I love them! They sell thousands of boxes a year just in my province alone. It is worth checking them out and trying them if you ever get around to it :)

[@victoriavo135]

yesss he looks so adorable🥺🥺

[@liv.contgeth]

@@lillithveil Of course, they look so good but sadly I'm from the other side of the world but if I get a chance to taste it I will not decline the offer.

[@lillithveil]

@@liv.contgeth oh I see! That’s unfortunate. Maybe one day :) or if someone travels abroad that you know, they could pick you up a box :)

[@bonnieplastow7018]

The thin mints don't taste the same. I was a Girl Scout in the 70's and my grandmother was my best customer. She'd fill her freezer with them. Thank you Grandma ❤

[@SSwann-sj8we]

Hands down, Samoas as the best! Your reaction was exactly what I was hoping for!

[@Eontologist]

As an ex-girl scout, Tagalongs and Thin Mints are my favorites. 🤤 A great place to sell cookies is near a university because college kids go HAM! (Can confirm as a university student - my housemates and I bought 20 boxes of Thin Mints in one go and bought more when we saw another girl selling cookies a week and a half later) 😅

[@newaccount6414]

Behold the power of an Adult!

[@ingothitrust5248]

My sophomore year roommate was kind enough to share these with me before finals. There was a troop that would come to our campus in April and I'm sure they made plenty of bank off of us. I never bought them personally since I was on scholarship and I was broke as hell, considering how expensive they were compared to the stuff you could buy from Walmart or Dollar General.....

[@XSemperIdem5]

Ok that's smart. All that cookie stress eating during midterms and finals when you don't even have time to get real food makes for a good cookie selling market.

[@yayturray4321]

Ive never bought more girl scout cookies in my life than when i was in college

[@thetwizzler8096]

this is so accurate cuz im a college sophomore and i saw this girl selling and freaking sped over to her and her mom but when I checked my wallet i didn’t have any cash. tell me why i was stood there having this girl gimme her damn cashapp so I could buy like four boxes of cookies 😭😭😭

[@cherylanderson1462]

Helpful tip: Thin mints are better chilled, for the full(better) experience put them in the freezer or refrigerator for a bit. Also note there is no point in dipping a chocolate covered cookie, the chocolate shell protects the cookie from moisture. Loved the video "peanut butta" made me laugh 😂

[@jimmywoo3885]

Yes but: 1) One dips after the first bite. Or 2) hold the entire cookie beneath the milk until the bubbles stop rising. Don't squeeze too hard or it will squish and fall off. The milk must be constantly filled to the brim and the two delicate fingers holding them get a bit wet. Tum. Great with the old Mystic Mints and Oreos of course.

[@megancash3990]

Thin Mints are my favorite. They're best taken straight from the freezer. Love it.

[@shirleywilhelm1495]

Ollie's blinking eyes are soo 🤣 funny!

[@Sommiel]

The reason we buy them in such volume, is that you can only get them for one season during the year, and the little Girl Scouts are so adorable. They are some hard sellers. You just cannot resist them.

[@steveaustin2686]

Yeah, the Boy Scouts have popcorn and it just isn't the same. The young Girl Scouts selling for the first time can be soo earnest. It's adorable.

[@naff_tm]

Ollie making fun of Josh by saying peanut**buttah** after Josh's tagalongs dilemma has me wheezing hahaha

[@nefertariwinchester3177]

Me too!😂😂😂😂

[@mumbii_sun]

Same here I was literally on the floor 😂😂

[@imari2305]

I was a cadet back in 1982 and I can tell you being a Girl Scout was absolutely amazing. Thin Mints are best frozen, Samosas are best cold, Trefoil shortbread cookies are best warmed and served with a fruit jam or I use them as a base for my cheese cakes. Tagalongs were not my favorite but if you really want a true peanut butter cookie you need to try dos-si-dos; hands down one of the best peanut butter cookies of all time.

[@sunnydaze3131]

Samoas. No "s."

[@countrygirl7402]

FYI Adventurefuls and The Smores are newer. Thin Mints and Samaos are where it's at in Girl Scout cookies. The Shortbreads go great with ice cream. Thin mints are my favorite, since I was a child. My girls sold Girl Scout cookies. We racked up the $$ on it. People love them.

[@shepshape2585]

They didn't really try thin mints. You have to put them in the fridge or freezer first, THEN they're able to reach the pinnacle of thin mintiness.

[@PyrantsWRLD]

This^

[@sammyc9617]

💯

[@theConquerersMama]

I always save a box in the back of the freezer to have a sleeve on my birthday in June. And the 4th of July.

[@bethwebster5159]

Frozen thin mints and egg nog are a perfect holiday snack. As long as they stay frozen they are still good at the holidays.

[@colettemiller7531]

THATS WHAT I SAID

[@lilmelodie]

We aren't eating these with our grandparents. We're binging them late at night and then feeling guilty about it. Everyone has their favorites. The Samoas/Caramel Delights are mine, but thin mints are a close second. I've heard that the girls who sell cookies outside of dispensaries do quite well. The cookies are kind of expensive, but they are for a good cause and they are delicious.

[@LindaC616]

Samoas are awesome

[@bodyofhope]

Exactly! We are stocking up, hiding them from our families, and then binging them alone with great pleasure. Thank goodness they're only seasonal 🤣

[@nicholasjh1]

Love frozen samoas

[@MsCrazylady71]

I agree the samosas are my favorite and thin mints are second. Which confuses me because I dispies coconut and don't care for dark chocolate. But I can't get enough of these cookies.

[@allieren]

Oooo I never thought of that-selling outside of dispensaries is genius!

[@mutteringcrone1210]

Samoas and Tagalongs are my family's favorites, but my mom was all about the thin mints. Some flavors change year to year. And there are two cookie regions with differing factories, thus the names that are different but the cookies that are the same.

[@beteeho]

Just when I thought Ollie could not be any more adorable

[@MusicxxRose]

The least favorite ones are also the newest flavors. The most popular ones were the cookie flavors that have been around for decades. They're well known established favorites not just for nostalgia but just being really good.

[@sarahanley7142]

You forget (and so did they) Do-si-dos, every scout troop was left with a stack of those at the end of cookie season

[@rachelk4805]

It makes sense, right? If an older flavor was unsuccessful they wouldn't keep it.

[@sarahanley7142]

@@rachelk4805 but do-si-do is a flavor that is not allowed to be discontinued

[@indigowendigo8165]

Honestly, I feel like the newer flavors of Poptarts seem pretty weird too compared to the classics. :p

[@poogie_]

I really wish they had gone from least popular to most when they ate them.

[@kristirobinson17]

They missed giving you guys a box of Do-si-dos. They are an oatmeal cookie with a peanut butter cream between the two oatmeal layers. Soooooo good!

[@racheldavin7763]

Yes...Do-Si-Dos are my personal favorite! You can eat them for breakfast with very little guilt. (Not that I've ever done that.)

[@deathwish1085]

Ollie, your faces when you don’t like stuff brings me so much laughter. Thank you for your expression. 😊

[@LadyT2g]

Me too😂. It's the thousand of blinks with the frown that does it for me each time. I love it 😂

[@marywalker6043]

The S mores 😂😂😂

[@shortyangel2010]

When I was young we would always buy 2-3boxes of coconut dreams and save them/savor for a while ❤

[@heatherhaloupek4407]

Definitely not just for grandparents. Everyone gets excited about Girlscout Cookie season. I bought two boxes just for myself (one Thin Mint and one Tagalong) and ate both boxes in a week.... Worth it.

[@lolitajimenez668]

Freezing them makes a difference

[@cassidyho939]

@@lolitajimenez668 Does it taste better?

[@kariwilson6588]

Wait... You only purchased 2 boxes!?!?!? How do you get away with that? LOL

[@lolitajimenez668]

@@cassidyho939 yes ... especially the mint and tagalongs Oh my god . Everytime i sell it i tell them and when they try they keep coming for more.

[@PR_311]

I'm curios: how expensive are these cookies? And how many are in a box? Two boxes of something that just seems to be avaible few months a year doesn't sound like too much tough

[@sharonbonser6631]

Thin mints in the freezer and then eaten in the summer are the bomb.

[@yarnangel52]

only IF they can last until summer!

[@girty6]

Thin mints blended into a milkshake

[@TheAsmrAddict888]

They suck now, just like many of them. athin mints were my favorite. Ever since they changed the names of them like tagalongs samaoas do si dos etc. They all are terrible now. Someone somewhere got offended on the behalf of other unoffended people and decided they were offensive names, then i guess the ingridients were offensive too since they are def not made the same anymore. ITs 2023 and they havent been good since maybe 2009

[@MichaelHampton-Whitney]

The expression after the s'mores! Priceless!

[@wandalovejoy4314]

The tag alongs are my favorite!! People here buy tons of boxes and keep them in the freezer, so they have them for a while. If they don't eat them all😂

[@marilynalvarez9951]

Girl Scout cookies were originally made by the girls and their moms at the beginning, then they grew so much that now they have specific bakeries licensed for regulation purposes and quality/quantity control. (minus the child labor...😁)

[@SRose-vp6ew]

Unpopular opinion, but children need how to learn how to work again. Keeping children and adults in school and entertaining themselves until they’re 22 or older is not making much for an able-bodied workforce capable of real life application and delayed gratification.

[@SRose-vp6ew]

And before some rich fool says pay your children to do chores, not everyone has the money for that, and some of us were actually working to help support our parents even in the early 2000s as minors. No one is saying make them literal mine workers, but no one hires under 16 in my area and there are so few of those types of jobs now that they all pay so much they expect adult ability and fun minimum wage summer training jobs are no more for 12+ The whole culture has changed and even 16 year olds that won’t clean a table expect a “livable wage.” No, the minimum is literally the lowest amount you can except for any amount of work no matter how poorly done it is. You don’t get mercy when you’re making enough to support a household, and you don’t get hired at 13 when that’s the pay.

[@theCourty140]

This episode is fantastic. As a Girl Scout my record was 32 boxes, so those California kids are really carrying the burden. Also, next we need Juno’s opinion 😋

[@keshaartis8365]

32?! Did you miss a number? 😅 I remember getting that off of just the order form my MOM took to work. 😅😅😅

[@imastatistic8347]

I did 325 boxes one year just going around my neighborhood 😅 omg it took me FOREVER to deliver

[@karenhamrick9210]

Don't those California and Colorado Girl Scouts set up stands in front of the marijuana dispensaries to get their large sales numbers?

[@babybones2725]

Okay thats very true dude i see girls selling cookies litterally everywhere so i have to buy atleaste 3 boxes

[@XSemperIdem5]

I'm in Southern California and the local girl scout group would set a table up in front of a bank.

[@charise773]

Jolly is so hilarious together!!!

[@amyroberts7248]

I love watching you both. You crack me up.

[@Ellis_d_w]

I love that at the end Ollie is dissapointed and Josh just kind of rewards him with more of the shortbread cookies 😂😂

[@maryohmaryoh]

One summer I worked as a counselor at a girl scout sleepaway camp. Usually, we were provided with a healthy daily snack for the girls but some days if snack supplies were low or something we had clearance to get snack from the "cookie bunker," this secret stone fortress of girl scout cookies on camp premises. However, we were forbidden to take out Thin Mints. That stuff is chocolate gold.

[@bfallingstar]

“The Cookie Bunker” and “Secret Stone Fortress” just killed me!

[@NoThankUBeQuiet]

They are like crack.

[@hummingbirdspark3998]

That sounds like a camp I went to! Is it Camp River Ranch?

[@redhead8777]

Half of the cookies never made it to the intended lol!

[@utbusr1]

Chocolate gold, LOL

[@danikasilva9906]

Back in the early 90s, at the dawn of the internet, the first time a girl scout used the internet (at the time called "worldwide web") she got in trouble with her local chapter...it's been wiped from the news, but they took her badge away and disqualified her sales saying she was using an unfair advantage...

[@briannarichardson9511]

Tag alongs are my favorite!

[@gigiflipp]

We don’t talk about the amount of Girl Scout cookies we eat, it’s very personal 😂

[@Liam69400]

There is a Congressional law that prohibits discussing the amount of girl scout cookies you eat! It is for our own protection!

[@debrapayne461]

No Do-si-do cookies? They're a peanut butter sandwich cookie and they're delicious! I hope they didn't stop making them. Fond memories of selling these cookies and eating them!

[@marissatennyson3728]

They're my favorites, too!

[@michaelgabriel7919]

Me too!

[@arithefierysecretary6411]

Maybe because of the peanuts?

[@marywenzel3199]

Definitely an oversight to leave off the Do-Si-Dos. Two flavors are must-haves for me: Thin Mint and Do-Si-Dos which I dunk in my coffee. Nom nom.

[@kagato3]

@@arithefierysecretary6411 given they had the tagalongs which have more peanut butter in them that is unlikely.

[@extranoodles]

The lemon ups were also a pleasant surprise! It works!

[@wickedpissa25]

I'm an American, and I go through about 30 to 40 boxes of Girl Scout Cookies each season. Mostly Thin Mints and Samoas.

[@amandaw7862]

You will need to try freezing the Thin Mints :) Brings it up a notch!

[@Zelmel]

Yes! Thin Mints are best frozen! Also, looks like at least some of those cookies were from the lesser (IMO) of the two GS bakeries. Little Brownie Bakers forever!

[@Kaylierae44]

100%

[@jadedseoul76]

I put mine in the fridge but I've never tried them frozen. I'll do that next time!

[@hellsbells012]

Totally agree. Crush it and eat it with Vanilla ice cream!

[@lisaaronin7606]

Was just going to say the same thing! And then dip in milk after you bite into them.

[@emonroe26]

When I was growing up, a girl in my troop's grandmother owned an ice cream shop and would buy enough thin mints to have as a topping for the full year and honestly single-handedly funded our troop for many years 😂

[@susanarroyo455]

I absolutely love watching you guys ❤ love from America

[@sarah.s.flanagan]

There's always a couple temporary flavors; Adventurefuls in a year or so will be replaced with something different. The previous one was a cinnamon-glaze shortbread "french toast" cookie and that one was awesome.

[@brisblondie]

Also, in case those outside the US are not aware, these cookies are not sold in stores! They are only sold by Girl Scouts, door to door, or on tables in front of stores, or sometimes a parent will bring an order form to the office and you bet everyone fills that thing out. 😅

[@kikihappy54]

You can also order them online, and choose which troop benefits from your purchase.

[@themontecristo1985]

Yeah, but cookie companies have dupes for most.

[@Appaddict01]

More like on Facebook and at their parents work.

[@gutturf]

@@themontecristo1985 True, and they are dirt cheap at Walmart. But I still buy 10 boxes from Girl Scouts when they are selling them.

[@AliciaRainbow]

When I worked at a hospital one of the doctor's had a Girl Scout daughter, so they loaded up a little red wagon with cookies and wheeled that thing around the hospital selling cookies to anyone that wanted some. Absolute genius.

[@RebeccaEWebber]

This is cute! One year I volunteered to be the "cookie manager" for my town which meant I got to go to "cookie college" for training and every box sold in my town was in the warehouse I managed first. Man, those girls were strong little business people.

[@kaldo_kaldo]

Turning children into business people is the American way

[@maryhall1976]

I love love love these cookies

[@saltydawghailstate8936]

I just about popped a gasket laughing at the faces pulled on the S’mores cookies. 😂

[@mindicity3874]

Pro-tip! Chuck the box of Thin Mints into the freezer. They're amazing when they're cold! You briefly mentioned in the video, but all Girl Scout cookies are made by two different bakeries, and the recipes are actually different! Samoas have more coconut, while Caramel DeLites have more biscuit. The most dramatic difference is in the S'mores - there's the version you got, and then the other bakery basically covered a graham cracker in marshmallow and chocolate instead of putting it between two cookies. Wish you could have had a taste test between those two!

[@elizabethyost611]

The other smore cookie isn't offered any more.

[@lizj7028]

Fun facts: there are indeed two different bakers that are licensed to sell Girl Scout Cookies- ABC and Little Brownie Baker (subsidiary of Keebler). Each baker use the same ingredients, but have their own version of the cookie recipe. Our troop did a side-by-side comparison and can confirm the taste difference. Each council sets their own price per box and can decide which baker to use, but contracts are usually 3 years in length. The classic 5 Girl Scout cookies and 1 gluten-free option must be produced by each baker. The other cookie options can be on the chopping block like the recently departed Thanks-A-Lot and chocolate covered S'mores. LBB Lemonups replaced Savannah Smiles to compete with the more popular Lemonades from ABC. Adventurefuls is the newest cookie... basically a thin mint without the mint flavor and a weird glob of caramel in the center lol...

[@dan13ljks0n]

So that's why Keebler can make and sell cookies that taste quite a bit like Thin Mints! I thought that may be the case!

[@hummingbirdspark3998]

No one remembers ra ra raisins

[@andreajones5728]

@@NefelibataCat ABC has 8 normal, 1 GF, and the new online only cookie. Thin mints, caramel delights, peanut butter patties, peanut butter sandwich, trefoil (previously known as shortbreads-name change this year), lemonades, adventurfules, toast-yays!, and GF caramel chocolate chip. Online only - raspberry rally.

[@Appaddict01]

Man I love the adventurefuls.

[@meghanyoungren809]

here’s a terrible trick with thin mints: stick one between two oreos (taking off one cookie from each oreo so the crème sticks to the thin mint). its oscenely good

[@girrl88]

OMG that sounds amazing

[@jerryloufretz1797]

I love these guys,they are hilarious

[@sabirusa]

Girl scout cookies are like a staple of life in the us! Even on my college campus, there are troops who will sell at the campus bus stops and in the parking lots. There are even some who use qr codes to pay through venmo! It’s so different from when I was a scout as a kid lol

[@neolithiumproduction]

Same. I remember as a kid we were expected to go door to door, and it was frowned on to buy a bunch and then sell them at a table outside establishments. Now its the other way around.

[@GenieGin13]

yes, it was the same for me. for my troop , we definitely could not order a bunch ahead of time. my mom was able to get her co-workers to preorder and some of my neighbors liked to buy from me and sister but other than that, my mom would place a few extra orders for us to hand out boxes to family. therefore our biggest buyer was actually our parents buying in bulk to get us over the sales quota on the orders. so i did not understand how other troops got thousands of boxes sold or how some girls were able to set up tables outside grocery stores.

[@emmathompson2240]

two things: 1) you missed a Girl Scout cookie called Thanks-a-lots, they are a circular shortbread cookie, with a chocolate fudge base, and like the lemon ups they have varying messages on the top, but instead they read "thank you" in different languages. (they are my personal favorite) 2) back in high school, my sister and I used to sell cookies from tote bags and out of our lockers. Since there were multiple troops at our school, the school board didn't want to pick a favorite to be allowed to set up their own booth, so instead, the two of us would set up shop by one of the busy hallway corners during the morning as people were arriving to school, and students and teachers would buy boxes for their breakfast and as snacks for later. Then, whatever we'd have left from that morning we'd sell by the end of the school day. Combined between the two of us we did that for 6 cookie seasons straight and is a fun memory of our peers all groggy eyed from the early morning trying to get to us in time to buy their favorite cookies.

[@xmushromx8736]

Didn't try them because they discontinued them that's not a cookie anymore

[@keshaartis8365]

Similar story except from the trunk of my mom’s van after school by myself. 😅😂 Amazing how many kids have $ in 6th grade for cookies (then again they were half the cost they are now at that point)!

[@theusher2893]

Thanks a lots were my favorite :(

[@bethtrumm9784]

I did the same thing lmao, and they still sell thanks a lots in Texas last I checked idk, may be baker dependent?

[@hersh511]

Unfortunately they discontinued them in 2020. :( They were my favorite too.

[@ceostudio]

My friends kid had an online cookie shop and I could see that making it so much easier to spend even more. They deliver them to your door a few weeks later

[@clairenevins9945]

American here - Thin mints frozen is the best ever! Haven't bought them ever since they raised the price a few years ago to a ridiculous $5. (and yes, I'm a grandma LOL) Great reaction vid, guys! Keep up the good work!

[@joannescott3461]

I totally agree about the pricing... I was a girl scout in the 70's and I remember being able to sell cases; not a few boxes but actual cases to my regulars. I can't imagine anyone being able (or wanting) to do that now. With 30 boxes a case, that's $150 a case. My best seller bought 3 cases of thin mints, 3 cases of Samoas, 2 cases of tagalongs & one case of shortbread a year. That would be $900 today, I was always blown away that he spent the $150 back then.

[@fordimension]

@@joannescott3461 It's funny your story about the customer who would spend 150 dollars in 1970s. If you adjusted for inflation from the early 70s, that would be worth about 900 dollars in 2022! 🤑

[@joannescott3461]

@@fordimension not quite but it was a lot of money. I promise you I understood how huge an order it was. Luckily he was a business owner who gifted his customers with girl scout cookies.

[@vanina_c1165]

@@joannescott3461 there're currently 12 boxes per case, not 30.

[@songbird6991]

I actually used to be a Girl Scout and I remember there were these two cookies I loved that they got rid of Savanna Smiles, which were a lemon flavored cookie wedge with this kind of powder sugar And Thanks a lots, which were a short bread cookie with a chocolate layer on the bottom and it had thanks written on them in different languages They were great and I’m very sad because they were my favorites but now it Tagalongs

[@xXSnoozySnoopyXx]

omg SAVANNA SMILES! You unlocked a memory! I LOVED those. I could never remember the name but I remembered eating them. I also used to be a girl scout & my aunt was a troop leader. In our area we didn't actually get the Savanna Smiles, but my aunt was able to get a few boxes from some other troop leader & she let us try them and I remember loving them and being upset we never got to sell them. I thought I just made those cookies up cause I could never find a picture for reference but I remember the taste and the powdered sugar lol

[@rachelzapata9819]

I remember both of those and they were some of my favorites too! I was also a Girl Scout back in the day 😊

[@sofiamatos2660]

OMG YES THEY WERE THE BEST. im so mad they got rid of them. the lemon ups are delicious too but doesnt compare to the savannah smiles😔

[@GlennaAdele]

I'm also a former Girl Scout and YES Savanna Smiles were the absolute best! I miss them so much and hope they bring them back one day 😩🤞

[@XSemperIdem5]

It was all about the thin mints and those lemon ones for me. I do love a good lemon cookie or pastry.

[@MissMTriana21]

Love me the s'mores! My all time favorite!!

[@brandylee7871]

My absolute favorites are the thin mints. If you put them in the freezer they are soooo good. Like they don’t freeze or anything but it adds to the flavor

[@SherioCheers]

The 2 different names are because Girl Scout cookies are made in 2 diff factories and the names are regional. Whenever I see the girls out selling I always buy a couple boxes of Thin Mints (husband's favorite) and a couple boxes of Tagalongs (my favorite). The brownie ones look like a new flavor (they often release a new limited flavor every year). The new flavors are often hit or miss. The S'mores was a new flavor they brought into the rotation but I'm not a big fan of that one either. I prefer the spiced cookie flavors they bring in every so often.

[@danceluver2090]

Your husband should put some thin mints in the freezer if he hasn’t done that before. I think they’re even better frozen :)

[@erin8575]

You and your husband are objectively correct. Thin Mints and Tagalongs are the absolute best. :)

[@laurel1800]

I liked the smores from the other bakery but unfortunately they stopped making it :(

[@jeg1353]

@@laurel1800 Do you mean the ones coated in chocolate? I tried the ones with two cookies and filling and they were "meh", eat them if starving but not buy them again.

[@laurel1800]

@@jeg1353 Yeah, to my knowledge they dont make them anymore though. They were pretty good, i'd munch on them often

[@3bellam]

To be fair, the s'mores cookies are kind of iconic, because the Girl Scouts of America are actually credited with inventing the original s'mores, so it's kind of like a reboot of their own idea lol

[@Ash-Ketchum702]

I love the face Ollie makes when he doesn’t like something lol

[@christiengelberg444]

I thought the same thing about adventurefuls. But I tried them again knowing they are crunchy. They are now one of my favorites !

[@TakenTook]

In addition to grandparents, parents, and the neighbors and coworkers of parents and grandparents being the main purchasers of these cookies, another reason that the thin mints are so popular is that they freeze really well. So you can just take out a box here and there throughout the entire year while you wait for the next Girl Scout cookie season

[@jamyeryan5568]

There's no way frozen thin mints would last until summer in my freezer. 😊

[@SchoeneTante]

Fifty and more years ago when I sold Girl Scout cookies, the shortbread cookies were called Trefoils. They looked different, and they tasted much better than they do now. They were one of my top favorite flavors then. I've never even heard of Adventurefulls. My favorites now are the Samoas.

[@hummingbirdspark3998]

Its about place not time. Trefoils are still sold, mostly on the west coast. There are two different girl scout cookie bakers: Little Brownie Bakers and ABC Bakers

[@SchoeneTante]

@@hummingbirdspark3998 well, I haven't moved. Lol.

[@hummingbirdspark3998]

@@SchoeneTante maybe your area changed to ABC bakers

[@SchoeneTante]

@@hummingbirdspark3998 Perhaps, I don't know. I do know the cookie flavor changed long before the name ever changed.

[@kathyoconnor]

ABC Bakery is calling them Trefoils again. They were Shortbread for years.

[@dorothypalmer7668]

Adventururefuls and Tagalongs are my all Time favorites

[@Susanimal82]

First time watcher. I love yalls chemistry. Felt like I was like snacking with friends.

[@laurel1800]

I was in girl scouts all the way through aging out and earned my gold award (the highest award). I can tell you that everyone loves thin mints, young or old, the shortbread are what older people buy, and the smores and adventurfuls are pretty new. They stopped making the smores at one of the bakeries and adventurefuls are new this year. I have not met a single person who doesn't like girl scout cookies and they're good entreprenuerial experience for young girls.

[@bunnymcfoo8650]

oh NO, they stopped making the Good s'mores???? i am devastated

[@Melissa-sy9lk]

Initially read Samoas as Samosas and thought, "Wow, the girl scouts are getting into international flavours"... :D

[@Shebeast3]

me too ✋

[@rachelcookie321]

That’s what I thought they said and I was so confused lol

[@nadeeshaperera6597]

They are cus... Samoa 😂

[@rachelleyeung]

but can you imagine a samosa flavoured COOKIE?!

[@TheDizzy1964]

As an American I love Girl Scout cookies. Can’t wait every year when they come out.

[@lyndabegay4023]

I truly enjoy your show and thank you both taken time to try our food in USA.

[@LadyCyr]

My faves ate the thin mints and peanut butter ones. The reason these sell like crazy is because of limited time and availability and people try buying a year supply all at once. Also we can power though a box in a sitting so there is that. I try to limit myself to 2 boxes