Prey vs. Prey [Total Spoilers]

This is a video critique and retrospective looking at Human Head's 2006 'Prey' and Arkane's 2017 'Prey'. It looks at how the game share some commonalities and tracks how it came to be that two such structurally divergent games ended up sharing the same name and franchise. SPOILERS FOR BOTH GAMES, INCLUDING THE ENDING.
===TIMESTAMPS===
Prey (2006) -- 00:12
Prey (2017) -- 17:35
If you enjoyed this video and want to contribute to the production of others like it, please consider supporting me on Patreon!
/ noahcaldwellgervais

[@JoeJently]

Arkanes ambition really deserves admiration for what it managed to do, the biggest shame is being forced to adopt the name of a franchise they had no involvement in, and no interest in replicating.

[@sizor3ds]

I can't remember who, but some other KZbinr proposed the name psychoshock as being a significantly more fitting name for the game, and tbh I agree

[@TheAssassin642]

@@sizor3ds that would be Errant Signal. He does good work

[@wormerine8029]

@@sizor3ds I believe Psychoshock name was mined from game’s files.

[@jacksonelh]

@@sizor3ds I feel like it's way too similar to bioshock, similar enough for a potential lawsuit

[@bobberhd9655]

@@jacksonelh bioshock is named after systemshock prey is considered part of this spiritual succession so no law suit and its named that close for a reason

[@lillyclarity9699]

I haven't fallen in love with a game like I have with Prey (2017) in over a decade, if ever. Truly an amazing game that really rekindled my love for the hobby.

[@forbidden_channelexe]

Prey really is a special game. How ironic that so many people seem to hate it for not being something much more generic and forgettable.

[@carlopanella5855]

@@forbidden_channelexe you are delusional if you think the original prey was generic and forgettable, allot of technologies like the portals originated from prey 2006, fuck outta here lmao....

[@InMaTeofDeath]

The Nerf gun _does_ actually have some combat value. I forget what the enemy is called but its the one that spawns the tiny black blobs that explode on impact. They're attracted to movement and blow up when they run into the bullet. Works best in zero g when your movement is restricted and you don't want to deal with them.

Crystoid and Crystoid nests. I would agree with you, but the Goo gun ammo is so plentyfull and cheap I just used that. Also you dont have to pick nerf bolts up after the fight.

[@123doomdoom]

STFU....this game has some interesting baddies

[@apictureoffunction]

@@123doomdoom Aesthetically, the Tyhpon aren't that great, and all look similar to one another. GAMEPLAY wise however, they are all unique threats that often require different strategies for approaching them in combat

[@jerrodshack7610]

Played through the entire fucking game and never thought to use it against Cystoids 😅

[@k0lpA]

@ it's actually more effective than goo

[@Zemonkoflol]

Arkane did a fucking fantastic job with Prey. Although I am sad we will never get to experience the original sequel, I'm very happy with what we got.

[@stolenname94]

@Bethesda sucks, but Zerglings still are cute. look it wasnt the sequel everyone wanted. However what we did get was a decent immersive sim. I wouldn't call it generic though like it did alot of things better than other games such as bioshock. Yes bioshock has a better story imo but gameplay and player choices are much better in prey. Its a very small evolution of that gener but its not perfect. I hated it when it first launched I just couldn't be bothered to play another system shock/ bioshock type of game. I gave it another chance on gamepass and its easily one of my favourite games atm.

[@duhmzdaih]

@Bethesda sucks, but Zerglings still are cute. your mom is boring and generic as hell.

[@duhmzdaih]

@I am tired of humanity ...and I couldn't care less if you did.

[@duhmzdaih]

@I am tired of humanity I never claimed that. Learn to read kid.

[@duhmzdaih]

@I am tired of humanity haha you're pathetic. I don't even know if he read that, I answered because I wanted to, if he cares or not that's his problem.

[@jowilson5581]

the 2017 Prey is one of the best games I've ever played (and the DLC is also excellent). the empathy simulator it portrays is one of the most original and exciting ideas I've ever seen in a game, and it's just got such love and attention to detail throughout. thanks for taking a look at these games, I always enjoy your style of commentary and analysis.

[@vault1021]

I’m just still upset that Bethesda decided to sacrifice the sequel to the original Prey in order to tack the IP’s name onto a game that was far more acclaimed in its own respect 😢

[@TellerGrim]

Great video, though I would argue that you are wrong about all the people on Talos I being complicit in the human experimentation; large sections of the staff didn't know the Typhon existed, and people like Mikhaila and Dr. Gallegos were trying to find out/expose what was going on. Danielle and Elazar are were also good people who did not know Transtars dark secrets.

[@VashdaCrash]

Miles I agree, this kind of thing are very little known even by people working within these kind of companies. It wouldn't work otherwise.

[@Jasonwolf1495]

YEah the employees were subject to neuromod removal which made them forget the things they worked on.

[@SamsButterscotch]

While I liked the old Prey, I absolutely loved the new Prey. Who would have thought that one of 2017's semi-underdogs would be a true spiritual successor to System Shock? And with zero crowd-funding, to boot.

[@slvrcobra1337]

That's cool, but ultimately unnecessary considering we're getting both a remake and a sequel to System Shock soon. I personally don't see a reason for this game to exist beyond Arkane paying tribute to a game they liked, which is nice, but I just would've preferred something more original.

[@SamsButterscotch]

Seeing as how this is the first true SS spiritual successor, I'd say it was pretty original. Even if it were the case, and the game wasn't original, I'd far rather play more games similar to System Shock than most triple A games shoveled out nowadays, to be honest. I enjoyed it far more than any of Arkane's previous games (even Arx Fatalis), and it's weird as I had almost zero expectations going into it, except for Chris Avellone's writing, which did not disappoint.

[@TheSoulHarvester]

Prey (2017) is System Shock 3. I'm all for more games to be made in this vein, but this is easily the best title of this year. So, that's a reason for the game to exist. I'd be very surprised if subsequent efforts to reboot/remake the SS will be as good as Prey.

[@frankaliberti]

Lmao clearly someone never played either System Shock 2 nor Prey 2017. Bioshock is only a “spiritual successor to System Shock 2” in the marketing that had that sentence to help sell the game. Plus, if Prey 2006 was so successful, they would have made Prey 2. Clearly no one wanted that. Fanboys always miss out on fun. So sad.

[@subjectdelta17]

@@slvrcobra1337 I never understood the argument of "there are plenty of other system shock like games out. So this one shouldn't exist" So fuck people that love games in that category? You can make a million JRPGs, or 3rd person adventure games, but God forbid there's another system shock like game. I know this is an older comment, but I've seen that argument plenty surrounding this game, and damn its annoying. Sorry we wanted a new game instead of a system shock fan remake.

[@GreyWolfLeaderTW]

Found a Limited Edition copy of Prey 2006, complete in box, with its tiny pewter figurines and everything inside it, in a Used Video Store and bought it for ~$15.00. Score!

[@kaliwhite6539]

Actually the last choice post credits also happens to be in a simulation, for a split second screen "glitches" when you're looking at monitors, and if you manage to catch it: you can see the previous scene before you were turned around in chair, but Alex is missing ^^

[@CountDoucheula]

Reminiscent of the glitch in the helicopter sequence at the beginning

[@SlyBeast]

I actually didn't suspect the sim within a sim thing until I was around 3/4 of the way through Prey 2017, but I NEVER expected that I was a Typhon. I thought that was really brilliant and one of the funnest twists in a game since KotOR. They kept calling me "it" and I looked down in the chair only to see that my hands were made of Typhon material and not flesh and bone. A real moment for me. I laughed out loud at myself. I'd been had and I loved it!

[@tastiGMmaster2099]

I saw the video made by the other YTer, Errant Signal, where he discusses the open-ended shooters like System Shock 2, Thief, Deus Ex, etc and naturally Prey 2017 came up. One thing he mentioned that the line you could draw between its heritage with System Shock and Bioshock was its name: "System Shock" being about computer systems, "Bioshock" being about altered biology and ecosystems, and "Prey" being about psychic abilities and altered psychology. A "psychoshock". ...and "Psychoshock" would have been x10 a cooler name then "Prey".

[@TheAdarkerglow]

I'd say "But naming it the same as another game increases publicity to an extent', but I think 'Psychoshock' probably would've drawn comparison to Bioshock and Systemshock (if you're making them all one word, make them ALL one world) in the same way, possibly more so. But is it a truly proper successor to those games? What's the qualifier on that? Development team, studio, trademarks, structure, narrative, mechanics? Just curious, not trying to aggressively debate it, being that I think the outcome is that it'd be subjective (as art).

[@henryrice9263]

I personally like Neuroshock more, but there is a power in game called psychoshock

[@remembertotakeshowerspleas355]

@@TheAdarkerglow It's definitely a spiritual successor because of its gameplay and level design, basically a prettier and more casual friendly version of system shock. From what I remember Arkane has almost no former Looking Glass or Ion Storm developers though, if that's a consideration for you.

[@apictureoffunction]

@@remembertotakeshowerspleas355 what? Arkane ABSOLUTELY has Looking Glass and Ion Storm developers. Harvey Smith and Raph Colantonio both worked for Ion Storm during the development of Deus Ex and were tutored by Warren Specter himself. And there are other members on the Arkane teams who worked at Looking Glass

[@apictureoffunction]

Hell, the name Looking Glass being used so heavily in the main story of Prey is already a large indication of people on the team having previously worked there

[@Poki3]

Not saying the new Prey is a bad game, but I'm very disappointed we still don't have an actual sequel to Prey. The two games are completely different and I wish the new game had a different title, cause this one pretty much cements the future of the original.

[@Hal_142]

prey wasn't that successful though. not that it *wasn't* successful but it wasn't "famous"

[@Jetsetlemming]

I was disappointed to learn they dropped the Cherokee theming before release, because god knows (good) representations of Native peoples are rare enough as it is, but I'm not sure a "Prey 2" would have much of that anyway besides Tommy himself, given that he left the Earth behind.

[@raresmacovei8382]

I don't think we're ever going to get a more mainstream or talked about Cherokee game than Assassin's Creed 3.

[@Crystalwolf78]

You are right man I can sadly count on my hand the amount of games with good representations of Native people, it stinks that there is so little out there, it always upset me there was not enough of that. I have a cousin who is part Cherokee.

[@Poki3]

The first Prey didn't have a cliffhanger per se, but a very open ending that I was looking forward to checking out. I never said I wanted a rehash of the same story cause that would be super dumb, but I wanted a sequel to Prey not a sequel to System Shock.

[@The-Bloke]

Thanks for another thoughtful and interesting video. I've sunk over 75 hours into Prey 2017 and adored it for many of the reasons you mentioned. I felt it was by far the most detailed, evocative and believable environment I'd ever experienced in a game of this type (any other than a full RPG, basically). As you touched upon, the human stories and the rich details about their day-to-day lives worked superbly to create a truly believable, relatable place. I found it genuinely touching and moving to read and hear about D&D games and blossoming romances whilst walking amongst the subsequent carnage and corpses. And, luckily, I also greatly enjoyed the combat and 'grind'. I played on Nightmare difficulty and thus found myself constantly low on materials, making it a survival sim on top of everything else. And in combat I was delighted to find I had to very regularly combine multiple weapons and tactics in a single fire-fight. It was truly exciting, and unique to need to, for the majority of my playthrough, combine eg. Gloo with bullets with multiple Neuromod powers in order to survive. It resulted in periods of frantic, break-neck pace interspersed with longer, calmer periods of exploration, resource gathering (I all but stripped Talos-1 bare), crafting and of course reading, discovering and pondering. A great experience from a wonderful game, which I enjoyed far more than Bioshock 1, 2 and Infinite. (I've still somehow not played System Shock 1 or 2, and now think I really must do so.)

[@matthewc9947]

As a Native, thank you!

[@Don_Los]

Thanks for what? For gameplay? If so, thanks goes to the devs

[@katweasel4996]

you must be a skin walker

[@donniedarko2815]

You’re probably like 2% native.

[@muntapede572]

Onya cobba

[@touheed6140]

@@donniedarko2815 why are y'all assuming lmaooo???? For all you know he could literally be 100% native American 🤨😬

[@qinlongfei]

"There is only one guarantee against mishandling inclusion of minority characters and that is speaking to and consulting with minority you are including." Bethesda take note. When they made Fallout 3's Anchorage DLC, the name they made for the Chinese stealth armor is no joke, how we say the N word in our native language. It was quite unexpectedly hilarious when I first saw it.

[@qinlongfei]

@Matt White You apparently cared enough to make a reply to a 2 years old post.

[@GreyTide]

I love internet archeology. Recent find, but this one belongs in a museum.

[@trashman8080]

@@qinlongfei i still dont get what the hell is wrong with this guy. Necro a comment just for a dumbass remark.

[@schnarfschnarf5886]

What now..I'm confused

[@slyfer60]

Crimson dragoon?

[@LIETUVIS10STUDIO1]

2017 Prey is great. It hits on head why scifi is great. It takes its characters seriously and gives everyone the benefit of the doubt. A good media produces multiple interpretations. I can't say my and Noah's match quite. But I can also see his reason. That's why it is great - multiple right ways, that tell us as much about ourselves, as the media's authors or the fictional world.

[@SaberRexZealot]

Prey-lien Vs. Prey-dator Preysona Prey-sident Evil Prey-us Ex Prey of Persia Tomb Prey-der Prey-onetta Dragon Prey-ge Metroid Prey-me Ninja Prey-den Vampire: The MasquePrey-ed

[@DeepInsideZettaiRyouiki]

Prey-Order

[@tibne2412]

The prey of us

[@lvkeyne]

SYSTEM PREY 3

[@gigamercer7874]

Fallout: New Preygas

[@Learned_English_Dog]

Why tho?

[@SteveJonesGamingGWO]

In 2017:The cabin in the executive suite was a Trippy moment once you figure out it and the adjacent placement of its hallway is exactly the same layout as the "earthbound" apartment just minor changes such as the elevator being behind you and the room next door being Alex's

[@NickHunter]

I wish there were more games like this. That let you take your time and read the emails and listen to the logs and learn the stories of what went on. That let you solve problems creatively. Where the plot keeps deepening and shifting and surprising you. I love the multiple iterations of your AI, snapshots of your personality from different stages of your journey all competing and contradicting one another leaving you in doubt about which version of yourself you can trust. The whole game was just so compelling. If it wasn't for the unnecessary difficulty ramp up in the final act it'd be the perfect game IMO

[@blakehorton8110]

Damn man if anyone ever deserved a donation on patreon you are the one , these are more like documentaries rather than reviews and very interesting almost can't stop watching and listening ......just wow

[@lewislewis3531]

Prey is better than Prey. It is a shame Prey never got the attention it deserved, that said Prey is now remembered fondly, and I pray Prey gets the recognition it deserves over the coming years.

[@KrazyK785]

What sucks is that Prey 2 had not only an interesting concept and call backs to the original, but several of the devs (said in a video by Eurogamer) stated they were going in a new direction with death /respawn mechanic and that in turn would influence one of the endings. They even had mechanics that we would see in later games like Titanfall (in what capacity idk), but we'll never really know thanks to Bethesda.

[@powervidsful]

KrazyK785 for all we know thatbgame might have been terrible there's no gamplay fortage and even if there was it would be a pre alpha version of it so stop complaining and get over it

[@RossardJames]

PowerVidsFul Well the game we got was really boring, so the mere idea of the open-world cyberpunk Prey 2 is much more exciting.

[@RossardJames]

PowerVidsFul also, we did get gameplay footage, so not sure what you're talking about.

[@powervidsful]

RossardJames prey alpha hell so no and just because you didn't enjoy it doesn't make prey 2017 a bad game i loved it

[@KrazyK785]

PowerVidsFul And for all we know it could have an amazing and revolutionary game instead of the bio/system-shock dishonored mash-up that we got, but as I said we'll never know! Sod off and have a nice day.

[@benmuzz]

I just finished Prey 2017 and absolutely loved it - it was the one immersive sim I hadn’t got to, and had heard good things, but I didn’t expect it to be so good. I thought the story was brilliant, and was impressed that the game engine and graphics kept up with every wild twist of the story (like the Apex Typhon). It really surprised and impressed me. Another impetus to finishing it was to then come back and listen to your review! Two treats in one!

[@RafaelSolMaker]

This is a brilliant analysis. I got several spoilers for Prey 2006, but I absolutely loved both parts of the video. Subscribed instantly! Instead of preferring one to another and trying to discover which one is best, I see that both are amazing games, for completely different reasons, like Half-Life and Deus Ex were back in time.

[@baultista]

I love Prey, Art Bell, and your videos. excellent work and great coverage of id games!!

[@kirktown2046]

Man, it's a real pleasure to listen to/watch your work.

[@adammercysystem6450]

This channel is fast becoming my absolute favourite. Thank you so much for your work, keep going.

[@TheOneTrueStAN]

This video is absolutely fantastic in describing why I adore both of these games and why they stand out for entirely different reasons.

[@Moonlightatnight2]

"We couldn't make a shooter from that era, so we made a shooter modeled after a game from roughly 10 years before that era."

[@johnstark7850]

FrenchDipp and it's way better than that garbage linear fps from 2006

[@gabrielpadro5589]

Dude come down. If you did not like the new Prey than that's fine. But you do not have to go on a screaming fit and just write this really ranty comment on how the original Prey was just so much better than the original and that's all Bethesda's fault on why the original Prey 2 was cancelled(Even though it probably is, but still please dont's be a dick about it) Remember that we play video games to have fun and to immerse ourselfs in a crazy new world so please come down and be a little more calm when you express your opinions.

[@cjrichards4342]

EA sucks, but Zerglings still are cute. Shut the fuck up lmao. You're insufferable.

[@banana1231234]

John Stark "linear fps" somebody didn't play the gaaaaame

[@jerrodshack7610]

@Bethesda sucks, but Zerglings still are cute. you are so butthurt dude it's so funny

[@iplaygunz1]

Glad that you made the Black Mirror comparison because I felt that this felt like a video game version of an episode.

[@BadHouses]

I liked the faster paced ending. With the station overrun with Typhon minions and entangled by coral, with the terrifying Apex Typhon ready to consume Talos 1 at any moment, with dozens of lives hanging in the balance (I used the nullwave), I found it incredibly exhilarating to dash through the station with which I'd become so familiar. It really felt like all that exploration had paid off and I was able to careen through the hallways, ducking here and there behind this or that to avoid lasers and all sorts of Typhon projectiles. I had completed all the side-quests by this point (Except the treasure map, 25% of the drop points, and finding out about Mikhaila's dad) so I think this complete focus on the final catastrophe was made mush easier. The even scarcer ammo and the high number of enemies also made the mad rush totally invigorating, as some fights seemed simply unwinnable. On an unrelated side-note: The EVA sequences were awesome. Whenever I watch real shuttle EVAs or see it in movies, I'm almost never struck by the endless frigid void that could so easily swallow you up should you lose power or make a mistake. This game did it and then some.

[@heyitsmort7744]

The ghosts being like that is so sad - Cherokee culture has a huge respect for evil and even just scary spirits. I’d love to see a game that actually embraces those myths.

[@runnerup15]

What a fantastic video. I might never have heard of this franchise (I've been out of the loop on gaming for some time now) if I hadn't looked you up to see what you're currently up to. I appreciate your in depth analytical style and I'm glad that I can come back after all this time of being out of the gaming world and see that your are still here making incredible content. Thank you for being amazing

[@gtabro1337]

Both Preys are some of the more interesting games I have played in their time.

[@wormerine8029]

I actually found crosbow toy useful for dealing with those radioactive blobs. Crosbow dart is a moving object and the readioactive buggers will chase it and explode on contact. Far more efficient, then shooting them down one by one, if no object to throw is available.

[@rhrabar0004]

Hey Noah. Starting my morning with coffee and one of your videos. I live south of Seattle and I really appreciate you and your contents. Thanks.

[@alfonsorodriguez7671]

Noah, you justo did a perfect lecture of Prey (2017). What an absolute brilliant annalysis of a game

[@LateNiteGibberish]

Thank you for doing this. I really enjoy your style, pace and thoughtfulness. I've been very divided on Prey '17. It's difficult for me to truly make up my mind about how I feel about the game. But in a way that division is interesting in itself. There is a lot to think about. A lot to process. You have an astute awareness of things I never paid any attention to.

[@hyperbomb180]

Finally someone gives Prey the time and attention that it deserves. So many people bash Prey 2017 simply because they wanted Prey 2 or because they are so used to the way FPS games are now that they don't want to give the game any time or attention. I found the latter out when a youtuber I used to watch, was playing Prey while talking about games on a podcast. You simply cannot play Prey while doing something else. It requires the full attention from a player in a world where asking that may be considered too much to ask for. Prey is a throwback.

[@Grimbop]

Great game, and likely Prey 2 wouldnt have been as great as people thought. How many times has a game come out with new and exciting features and than actually manages to be the exact game it hyped itself up to be. Its not even like we will never get a si fi 80's inspired RPG now. Any developer could do that. In fact thats what CDPR is doing with Cyberpunk 2077 and that will probably be way better than what Prey 2 will be based on budget alone.

[@johnstark7850]

Well said, those people's dumbass opinions are why we don't have more game's like system shock 1 and 2, and deus ex 1, everyone wants streamlined shooter's now, well...........fuck them!!

[@DarkusRelling]

Oh gee, I wonder why people are whining like babies when they haven't even played the game. I don't bash Prey 2006, so don't bash Prey 2017.

[@TheMightyShell]

I just have to comment that I appreciate that you keep your little mistakes and "ahems" in the audio -- it makes speech feel so much more natural and enjoyable to listen to.

[@linguisticallyoversight8685]

actually it's my understanding as I live in the four corners area and involved in a lot of archaeological digs that for the most part the group referred to as the Anasazi the ancient ones we're more than likely a combination of vassal States control by the Maya or Aztec one of the Central or South American powers and as it being a vassal State and holy dependent on the strength of an Empire when the Empire crumbled they lost trade routes and the ability to keep their Community is thriving because of it

[@TheCrimsonSeven]

Another great video, thanks for doing what you do.

[@TheKatamariguy]

Thank god! Are there even any "0451" games left to cover?

[@AmbientMalice]

Mafia III makes reference to it.

[@Gheringerbob12345]

He covered the Mafia series

[@slvrcobra1337]

Ambient Malice Really? Where? I'm actually playing through that now

[@AmbientMalice]

It's mentioned in dialogue as an elevator keycode. During the heist, I think.

[@zerodollarbird]

Deus Ex, the original. He hasn't covered that one.

[@BlackLegion12621]

This is just what I needed for my Finals-induced insomnia.

[@slendy9600]

Peter Hanson good luck with finals dude

[@SepSyn]

Just finished the 2017 title after having watched and having subsequently largely forgotten this review from a year or two before. I appreciate your examination of the game play and themes. I was intrigued by this review and remain intrigued by the game's themes after having completed it. Thanks for the heads up Noah. Worth the ride. Shame you couldn't have stopped what happened, but the exploration of what comes after the major mistake is engrossing nonetheless

[@Gheringerbob12345]

Terrific video as usual. I doubt you're lacking in ideas for videos to do, but if you are I think maybe the Metro games or the Max Payne games would be some interesting topics for you to cover. I think they're both interesting takes on first and third person shooters respectively and think they're good examples of the imaginative/original use of game play, genre, and story that you usually cover.

[@thescroot]

Gheringerbob12345 You got your wish!

[@markmullan73]

Yet another fantastic video! Totally agree with the combat focus shifting towards the end game, but I really found my stride with the upgraded movement mechanics and neuromods and had a blast ripping through aliens like a bouncing mad space ninja. Great game and I won't forget it.

[@thomashalkes4699]

Great video as always, of course. I'd just like to note(even though it's several months on now and totally doesn't matter) that the disruptor is incredibly powerful against anything robotic once it's upgraded and that the huntress is pretty effective against cystoids. So they have even more use beyond what Noah pointed out.

[@Pajalfonso]

Another amazing video. Thank you!

[@mariusweber4990]

This is probably one of the best video game critiques i have ever seen. I really want to play the original Prey now.

[@alanfennell4833]

I was about yo go to bed, but I can't help it! Love your channel =)

[@CaptainComicbook]

Damn sir, you're one hell of a wordsmith. It's a pleasure hearing you speak.

[@iopohable]

monotonous is not bad. i for one love your monotone voice.

[@antonstozhko665]

Great viedos! Applause to Noah

[@f1r3hydr4nt]

another great video, keep it up!

[@silassnell1815]

I love Noah's voice.

[@BillBilliamson]

Great video, your analysis made me think more about my ending of the game and reconsider the final choice at the end. Prey 2017 really feels like an unsung game of this year but it's sunken it's teeth into me more than some of the game's it tries to imitate.

[@yorshka6955]

3:36 It looks like the looking glass from prey 2017

[@alexspogonz]

Fantastic video as always friend

[@D3w10n]

The only thing I remember about 2006 Prey is finding a secret room where wall vagina told me to "Behold"

[@quiddd]

I have a great appreciation for your work and your commitment to long form analysis. I hope you find what you need on your journey.

[@MasterFGH]

Great as always!

[@StillGotShit4Brains]

HOW GOOD WAS THAT PREY 2 GAME THO.

[@powervidsful]

StillGotShit4Brains well since it never game out and theres no gamplay of any kind worth a damn ...

[@OmegaEnvych]

The Human Head one? Who knows. It could have been amazing, but at the same time it could be utter shit. No one will tell now. Sadly, these things can happen, but at least I'm glad that Prey, the new one, became me personal favorite game of this year.

[@hairy_cornflake]

But how real was that Megaman? We all remember the lies behind Aliens Colonial Marines and the fake demos.

[@johnstark7850]

Google+ Sucks! Now looks like a shitty FPS, while prey 2017 is a spiritual successor to the legendary system shock!

[@Tycholarfero]

John Stark why does that give it a pass, it's not even a good spiritual successor it's a great game, but the game loses it's luster WAY hard during the second half

[@SirBigWater]

So Doom 3, Quake 4, and Prey all have you fight allies turned into enemy hybrids.

[@timothymclean]

Both Preys turned out pretty well for games with such long and convoluted development cycles.

[@guanyu8539]

Listening to Art Bell at 1am while driving the 6 hours back home down I-80 after visiting my girlfriend at the time who was away at college. Thank you for reminding me of that fond memory!

[@c.jarmstrong3111]

It's unfortunate that the original Prey is a forgotten game, it was really unique and quite good overall

[@furchtegottgellert4865]

Good video. Thank you Noah.

[@nikibest23]

The purpose of the universe is a GTA retrospective appearing on this channel some day. I will die hoping probably. Love your stuff! Keep it up!

[@HydraKittten]

I love Prey, Which One, You ask? Yes

[@DANRYX]

What may sound silly is that to this day, Prey xbox 360 still feels next gen over most games and it is down to the simplistic beginning where you can interact with the sink, soap dispenser and toilet handle WITHOUT a button prompt. Alien isolation at first felt truly next gen until, no matter the settings or difficulty, forces button prompts and glowing orange item pick ups that all break the immersive atmosphere that the game rendered so well.

[@NoExplosionsMcgee]

The loss of Human Head's Prey 2 and its planned expansion pack still hurts like hell

[@___.51]

I wish that 2017 Prey had a different name. The two games had nothing to do with each other.

[@themechanic3352]

Can you talk about the Star Control series next?

[@xdearlifex]

I loved Prey 2017, especially the ending. It actually goes for the "it was all a dream" ending and doesn't half ass it. That's goddamn impressive, making an ending THAT CLICHE fascinating. It recontextualizes the entire game in a good way, making everything more complex, not less.

[@jerrodshack7610]

Yeah I think it's pretty impressive they managed to do what is usually considered an insulting cliche, but tie it to the world and story to actually improve it.

[@captainsargas1606]

@@jerrodshack7610 Also the ending wasn‘t completely a dream since your expieriences where based on the memorys of Morgan

[@theespatier4456]

I replayed this a few months ago (thanks!)... best FPS of 2006!

[@realtalk6162]

this commentary was amazing.

[@DracoRulezU]

I was wondering if you would do this. I've already beaten Prey 2017, but definitely looking forward to hear you're opinions.

[@nickgivent3157]

I like the mind bending elements of navigating through the first prey game

[@DeepInsideZettaiRyouiki]

Bethesda - Like Ubisoft learned the best moves from EA First they fucked Interplay, Obsydian...now this... "High Standards" of Bethesda: Best animations in the world... ...when ragdoll kicks in.

[@Bigdaddymittens]

Pro Toss Stay mad. Obsidian can't make good games.

[@Drako1777]

Pro Toss I think you meant to say Zenimax. They own Bethesda Studios (and softworks) and like to hide behind Bethesda quiet a bit.

[@DeepInsideZettaiRyouiki]

+Brady Benedict ...intersting, thanks. Still is quite hard to tell on which step directors make those terrible terrible decisions.

[@packrunnernes]

Prey 2017 is an absolute masterpiece

[@Finalblue1234]

I remember the intro to OG Prey giving me legit nightmares back in the day. seeing innocent people getting butchered by disgusting and terrifying alien stuff while you couldn't do shit about, all the while hearing their screams and cries for help.

[@MinooMinou]

Superb video.

[@george867]

Two Noah Gervais videos in one day? Is it christmas *and* my birthday?

[@rhysdoyle5092]

YASSS another video!!!

[@hsapin]

Excellent video. More people need to play the new Prey!

[@maddude7161]

I need to get to sleep. Work in 4 ho- *sees vid* Who needs sleep? Sleep is for nerds.

[@1300l]

I guess you never asked for this

[@ranakin9000]

"rolls eyes"

[@RafaelSolMaker]

Saying this and here it's actually 4am now. Wow!

[@ssosso79]

exactly!

[@Killian_sawyer]

This is 1 of my fave games of all time

[@ratheonhudson3311]

I loved so much from the intial Prey game and the rumours and teaser trailer for the sequel, which was unfortunately shelved, had me wanting more. Prey was so dramatic, especially the horrible death of Old Man Enisi. The pacing between events was good too. Although slightly faster than Half Life 2 did. The idea of having an additional layer on top of the world, namely the spirit world layer, is very incredible. Puzzles on 2 levels.

Hey noah, I'm really curious. I've noticed in the last fight before the shuttle, you did not have researched even the names of same basic typhons like the voltaic. Did you ignore the research mechanic on purpose?

[@artmanxp]

Noah Caldwell-Gervais just wondering if the footage you use is your final playthught or just to get b-roll. i ask because the chooses your make in the game are interesting conparted to mind like killing the prisoner instand of freeing him

[@AmbientMalice]

Great video, Noah. Keep up the good work. Just a small note, though -- I believe the Neuromod needles go PAST the eyeball into the brain. And you have to hold them there for five minutes or something like that.

hey, lovely vid

[@crystalhydra4779]

Noah will you cover the Dead Space Games?

[@OrbitalShell]

CrystalWing Ghirarga THIS!!!!

[@powervidsful]

yes yes yes thank you noah

[@BalgaBear]

Almost think I wanted the Prey 201x where you were a bounty hunter in a sci-fi neo-punk setting. But I'm glad it turned out to be a psych-horroresque D&D every weapon is a utility item kind of game.

[@stevelarry3870]

EA sucks, but Zerglings still are cute. Seems you are still around. I can hope you have found something better to do with your life than raving about Indian ink blots.

[@Ditocoaf]

I would have liked to see Prey 2 also, but it isn't this game's fault that it was cancelled. This game was only given the name "Prey" after Prey 2 was killed in a completely separate decision. This game is good on its own terms. Call it Neuroshock, and mourn Prey 2 as a separate issue.

[@DIEGhostfish]

I want to watch this, but I also sorta want to try out the Preys at some point.

[@iainengland8058]

This was amazing

[@RomeoCo]

I've heard such mixed reviews of the first Prey game from other Native people, but I really do need to check it out at some point

[@cortedemico]

oh. boy did i love this game (the first prey that is)! thanks for the nostalgia.