BTS - Permission To Dance (Live) - Musician's Reaction

[@imclara6575]

Jin voice is so high omg . It's more high than the studio version 😳

[@humna.9402]

That's our grammys acclaimed silver vocalist Kim Seokjin for y'all

[@tayjin2522]

Kim Seokjin our silver vocalist mostly sing the high part of their songs

[@evaindriati2500]

He is good in high tone .....

[@Zoe-lw2ur]

JINNNN❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💜

[@budahparticle5752]

I like the studio version but I love this live version 1000x better

[@melaniewigner3930]

1000000x better lol

[@alifc1082]

Yes, to hear the difference in their voices, the specific tone of every one of them, all of them sound so good. And that's the magic of Bts sound, different tones, the way they sing you cn feel their personality 💜Bts 💜Army and 💜Jacob

[@melaniewigner3930]

@@jeongukk06 lol

[@taequilasilver7183]

live versions are alwas better

[@butterbuttersbetter3689]

I agree. That studio version sounds great, because it’s a great song, but I was really disappointed by how much the production ironed out all the distinctions in their voices.

[@sadinaadhik2176]

Idk why I am in love with Jin live vocal. It is so much beautiful then studio even that danananana sound Same like studio amajin😍😊💜

[@jenjin9492]

For other ARMY complaining about the song being westernized listen: This is only their 3rd full english? Whatcha on about fam?? We have 100+ in korean. Last year the BE album songs was in korean.. come on... Us ARMY are always proud that BTS is not just 1 genre.. we always say they are THE GENRE so they are constantly branching out and trying different sounds thats why we love them for not sticking to one sound. They're bringing more and more non fans to our BTS universe and they will be discovering the great complex hard hitting past songs, is'nt that a good thing? Im sure they will be going back to singing korean songs. This is a birthday gift to ARMY, its in english so all the different races of ARMY can sing fully to it.. plus incorporating ASL sign language. Come on ARMY fam its okay not to like it.. but lets not knock out BTS like that. Borahae 💜

[@geovanadelapena157]

So truee

[@chrisc1184]

I think this song sucks, especially by Ed Sheeran's standards. It sounds too poppy and Disney-like. That's okay though, because they have like a million other great songs for fans to enjoy.

[@jenjin9492]

@@chrisc1184 its okay not to like it.

[@chrisc1184]

@@jenjin9492 Yup. Doesn't take away from BTS' greatness one bit. They've already built their legacy and broke all the records already. Every great artist has at least one or two flops (at least in my eyes).

[@tanvigawas472]

True

[@eddyricksadural3482]

Jin Butter- PTD is my BIAS!

[@TjolleBanan]

Jungkook's vocals and adlibs are topnotch! I also replayed that part because he makes it look effortless but he really is a talented singer. They all sound great and I like the live better. It shows their beautiful unique voices. All 7 of them have unique voices in my opinion so you instantly know it's them!

[@punamsingh050]

Absolutely true

[@aerasauce4655]

You can clearly tell the distinction of their vocal styles here. I am highly impressed with rap line's vocals and enamored with the vocal line's. Jimin and Jungkook's vocal runs were amazing!!!!

[@fannyhorville3687]

Jimin is always so impressive live. He adds so much flavour into the song. Just WOW!!! He really is on another level.

[@JacobRestituto]

😃

[@marissamcwhiter9381]

This live version is so good...I love how raw JK sounded in some parts and the Harmonies with Jimmin...so good. The rap line sounds so good!

[@huiyansun5977]

I like the live version more. And the last three dance moves are sign language, they want to share the positive vibes literally to everyone!

[@biella1879]

ikr

[@tabithadejong6365]

Jin did it also....but it was too fast too see...

[@ABC-qn7cn]

Jin's voice,he is slaying 💜 BTS 💜

[@Zoe-lw2ur]

❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@R.J01]

Jungkook is really the best vocalist in this generation hitting those high notes while dancing chefs kiss ,the emotion he convey in each of performance make him outstanding ! he has such a great voice he can sing absolutely anything ! the plus factor his natural charms when he performing those killer smile can tip my table up😂

[@angiesplaylist23]

Jungkook's live vocals are perfection! 🔥 Love his adlibs and runs! And his pronunciation is so clear, its crazy because you can't tell that he's not fluent in English

[@celinajimin586]

OMG, today, my heart is full loving by Jimin’s vocal, dancing. Jimin’s vocal is so insane, so sweet, so pure, Jimin’s dancing is so amazing, his bodyline make you can’t take your eyes off, his body roll is so perfect. Thank you so much your reaction today. And I’m so happy if you can react Jimin’s vocal, dancing and live solo performances more.

[@celinajimin586]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/mInchmCInMtqoJY kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z33XhIuuirNsnNk kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpqUpaSkmJaBb5I

[@celinajimin586]

▶️ kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZmtYZSwnaZ2ftE ▶️ kzbin.info/www/bejne/l4DSgnSJis2Kbpo ▶️ kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJS5ipRmbJyFnck

[@lindadini]

Yes

[@nanduchoudary2653]

JIMIN vocals and adlibs and hightnotes he always stood out 🔥

[@jkgoldenmaknae7325]

Jungkook vocal even better in live ver

[@punamsingh050]

True

[@JUJU-gl4jp]

Not gonna lie Jin easily owned PTD

[@user-pj8wd5kn1s]

As the main vocalist, JungKook uses his sweet and rocky tone and superb skills to lead the mood of the whole song and bring the song to a lofty state.

[@sel483]

Jimin's voice sounds amazing live, it is so exquisite and unique is my favorite singer and it surprises me more and more.

[@LisaMT1218]

I prefer this live version too, because I like hearing their voices with the natural tone and pronunciations.

[@luzcartagena6869]

I LOVE that they incorporated Int'l Sign Language into the choreography of the song. They really try to be so inclusive and I really appreciate that from them.

[@soniacruz8407]

Loved hearing the different texture of their voices and their accent. It's always impressive how they can dance and have stable vocals. Their timing in phrases, one finishing and the next starting or when they overlap is amazing in live performance.

[@punamsingh050]

Jungkook voice is angelic

[@ellensantiago6331]

I'm really glad that Jin got more verses. You can distinguish who's singing what! Love that the rap line was singing like they were vocalist not rappers. This song is so dope. Glad I ordered my CD! Can't wait!

[@diannetics18]

Ed wasnt the only songwriter though. There's more people credited.

[@heeseungsfeet9496]

Yup he co wrote the song

[@emilyl1094]

I noticed that many reactors were more excited about Ed Sheeran as one of the songwriters for PTD rather than it was sang and performed by BTS. The same for other BTS songs when they collaborated with any Western artist. A few reactors didn't even react and comment on BTS singing, dancing or overall music video. They were excited that this is Ed Sheeran's style of songwriting/music and he would be good playing PTD on his guitar. Ed is a good musician, songwriter and producer but some credits need to be given to BTS on their overall performances and MV which make the song worked too. This song brings joy, happiness, positive vibes, inspiration and as a gift to ARMY and all listeners during this pandemic and special day for ARMY. Sorry for my rambling here.

[@nl8404]

Precisely bc the writter is Ed sheeran and the producers are british+american, PTD has so many pros and crons. Some people don't like it bc it looks like Ed sheeran's stlye not BTS stlye. In butter RM still participated to write the rap but PTD just doesn't seem like BTS i guess? When you worked with western producers who have worked with so many western artists, you wound up with a song that sounds just like any other western songs. The lyrics are nothing to compare to their korean or even japanese songs (you know what i'm saying, their korean songs have more deep into your soul + good lyricism compare to PTD) maybe that's why some fans are dissapointed. maybe if BTS could make an English song written by themselves then the song would be even better. Especially this is a song for ARMY.

[@tonytran9538]

@@nl8404 I enjoy the song and you can see different side of BTS. They don’t need to produce their music and sing their songs all time. Ed Sheehan used to write “Make it right” for BTS so this is not the first time. Also, BTS experienced a lot of types of music and they have different vibes. Not many people will like all their songs…so just thinking simply, this song is just another happy song of BTS. English song is hard to write because they don’t speak English fluently (except RM). This song showed their great vocals so not bad. It also showed BTS style that is happy and positive. Of course I know BTS had many great songs in Korean and Japanese, so just take it easy to wait for other songs from them. They usually have better B sides than main songs tho

[@ymhktravel]

@@nl8404 I think V's Sweet Night (a short song in English) for a Korean OST written by him is quite poetic and touching. "....we are ships in the night, passing each other"....English songs just don't have the deep and poetic feel to it unless it's written by an Eng Lit major, compared to say Chinese, Korean or Japanese songs. Any of these east asian songs translated to English would have lose the poetic essence not found in the English Language.

[@CreativaArtly]

Man! I love this song so much. I’ve listened to it 10+ times already and honestly can’t help but dance along.

[@luiloves9517]

What’s so special about BTS is they can actually SING LIVE and DANCE at the same time like it is no big deal! I enjoy watching this review. You’re good at this! Keep making them! 👍🏻 I subscribed!

[@poporabbitqueen]

JungKo.ok’s sweet and rock-and-roll singing adds to the artistry of this pop song

[@jesskb]

I always love their live vocals more than the studio version.

[@triana3679]

17:42 lol can you believe fans from other groups once criticized BTS for this?! in a year-end festival 5 songs 2 and a half costume change totally live with band there on the stage and the last two with heavy choreography, they said they prefer their groups lip-synched to sing live so they don't have to listen to their breathing 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

[@user-qd5gr8ql2w]

They were talking about which performance ? Mma 2019 ? Or golden disc award 2020?

[@sissyfart]

Another co ceo sajd lip synching was a genre. i cant even.

[@triana3679]

@@sissyfart ooh yes I remember that 😬

[@punamsingh050]

Jungkook highnotes Looks effortless

[@msrirung]

Yesssss…I soooooo agree with you on the overproduced vocals. This song is the nearest to be the most perfect song for summer, just that they need to turn down those autotunes. I love yr reaction so much bc you tell it as it is without hurting anyone 😉😏& promise to be yr fan from now on🤟🏼

[@lindadini]

Wow jimin vocal

[@thv2165]

Bts rap line vocals not joke!!!

[@tinanoona]

That's high. That's Jungkook.

[@notnaqueeb1890]

Btw if you were wondering....a lot of the steps in choreography were sign language for "walk" "talk" and "dance". Which i think is pretty cool

[@bmb1824]

I was hoping for this!!!! I really wish they didn't "over produce" their voices so much these past 4 releases especially!! I get it stylistically for the radio, but I really wish they would at the very least turn it down some!! 💜

[@pinkyrivas1070]

Jungkook vocal and adlibs amazing

[@punamsingh050]

His live vocals always amazed me

[@jimba5358]

I love this song so much. Uplifted my depressed mood. I am using my free time to learn the dance. Its simple for others but complicated for me. 😅So good..

[@twinkleeyes8905]

I really loved Jimin's voice in this live performance

[@JacobRestituto]

:)

[@user-pq5do1yk4s]

You're quick at reacting and upload! Appreciate that 👍✨ and I still cant believe they get all the rappers to sing tho 😂 im most surprised at suga (blue hair)bcs he's the one who doing least vocalizing in their song (as far as i know).

[@dalairem]

Thank you for this great reaction and analysis! Like I'd said in your last offering, I adore this live version of PTD - even more on repeat listening. I can discern their beautiful voices and expressiveness (despite it being in English) so much better than in the studio version. I really don't think production had any good reason to homogenize the vocals in the studio version. Most BTS songs have switched between all of the members throughout its history, and listeners have ever been happily along for the ride, appreciating their uniqueness and personalities shining through. Again, I'm looking forward to hearing PTD develop over their many stages in the coming weeks and so on. 💜

[@sarah311979]

I'm an Army and was annoyed at the over processing of their vocals.... I don't know why the producer did that.... live is so much better

[@user-qd5gr8ql2w]

I'd like to see reaction to one of their elder songs called "DANGER" it's their title track for their album "dark and wild" , it's kinda like a rock song , i want to see your reaction to "Ma city" live performance as well it's a banger and a rock song too ✌️

[@senu.]

you guys always talk but those type of songs get the least hype nowadays. some of you need to start actually listening to it

[@smeraldo3151]

Been waiting for someone in the industry to comment on the dampening of their vocal differences in the music video version. I dislike it. But I wondered what the reasons might have been. I prefer this live version precisely because I could hear each of their vocal characteristics. More choreo here not withstanding. I’ve also been thinking about their accents and such given that they don’t really speak English although they understand passively I think (most language learning starts with passive before active anyway). Love your commentaries as always. This song is REALLY GROWING on me, because of its much needed sentiment 🦋 Thank you!

[@JacobRestituto]

thanks so much! glad you learned something!

[@worldofivy8816]

This is definetly one of their best vocal performances, it was so so good, and they just keep getting better and better!!!!

[@JacobRestituto]

Nice!!

[@csaulpaugh89]

I like this version so much more. I'm not a huge fan of heavily produced vocals, especially when you have voices as good as these. I'm also LOVING the sign language. I can't wait to show the dance to my neighbor's daughter. 😃💜

[@amandacrozier5368]

Much prefer this live version😀

[@niccolopaganini4082]

I agree, the studio version production changed the timbre of their vocals a lot, like that one part of JK singing in the laundromat doing a twirl, if I didn't know any better I would think that part was Jimin. The first time I heard it I knew people are gonna complain about the autotune too, but it doesn't take away the fact that this is a feel good song which touched a million hearts of those who have listened to it and watched the MV. The flaws aside, I would still pick this as my favorite BTS english song, because of how it makes me feel whenever I listen to it. Isn't that the greatest purpose of music after all?

[@llt3973]

Agree. I preferred the live version.

[@esterpasaribu]

I agree with you, I just a listener without a music background. I love this live version.

[@JacobRestituto]

🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@chloecham3908]

I like both studio version and live version

[@cuttestpomeraniansimbafrie2600]

How can they dance hard and sing at the same time like that...... that is a pure talent and a million hours of practice and hardwork.

[@heydyan17]

I love how I'm always learning about music and production whenever I watch your reaction videos haha. Thanks for sharing your knowledge with us. You help us understand things we wouldn't normally notice in their videos and song production. Great job man!

[@selenavirruetafigueroa3806]

I listen and listenig this song. I love this song!

[@naglayusuf6991]

They are awesome live great reaction as always 🙂

[@namjooning3779]

Thanks u for this reaction 💜

[@xsweetcupcakekagome]

It’s cause it’s not auto tuned and that’s why I love live versions better 💜

[@christinevinzon6379]

Don't sleep on V's voice his studio and live version sounds the same it proves how stable his voice

[@stevenjo6046]

Wow..this song is not easy to sining....but they do it very well. Vary catching.!

[@JacobRestituto]

True!

[@coolypetzz]

My fav is during jhope and suga parts

[@KimmyGibson]

Thanks! Question....which 'recording' of the song would they use for radio play...the mv version or a live version like this? I get what you're saying about the blending of voices, but then they just sound like any other (western) boy band. It's their unique voices and how they blend and harmonize that I love so much, so I hope a live version is the radio song.

[@btsforever9803]

I always like live ver They have different vocals and this enjoy to listen

[@renaustin9564]

It is Live!

[@debhouckscraftycottage9288]

Have you reacted to ON: Kinetic Manifesto Come Prima yet? There is a solo about midway through where Jungkook apparently hits an F5 (per another reactor - vocal coach). It's worth a watch - either the MV or the Live on Jimmy Fallon show done at Grand Central Station.

[@JacobRestituto]

Cool thanks!

[@somyasingh8193]

You so right about the distraction thing, I read from two other music students they also said the same thing. They tuned the vocals yo give members kind off similar sound so the focus is more on the lyrics and the vibe cool!

[@jacquereid9958]

Enjoyed it! Thanks💜

[@joymakk1932]

JUNGKOOK💜💯🔥

[@marisolcentella6623]

I did hear what you said about the production in their voices. It's not a bad thing but it did cause me a shok because it's not usual for them, but I listened to the live performance and love it

[@coolypetzz]

Live >> mv

[@MM-et2jr]

It's funny, because I've seen some other reactors saying they can definitely hear the Ed Sheeran influence. I guess I'm split. Parts of it reminds of some of his work, other parts not as much. But since there was multiple writers, such as Steve Mac (who did a lot of Westlife, if I'm not mistaken), which I can definitely hear too. I hear a lot of influences in this song, like the disco pop ABBA-vibe (would go well with the Mama Mia song list). I love that they keep challenging themselves and do all kinds of genres. I love that they still surprise us. I love that nothing is off limits for them. I love that they'll do whatever they want to do - otherwise it would end up like "Fake Love", right? And they understood what was needed in this world once again - we needed a feel-good, wholesome song that everyone could sing along to, like Pharrell's "Happy". PS. Ed Sheeran said in a recent interview that he often/(always?) runs his music by Elton John and values his music. And I can kind of hear some Elton John-like influence in the song, so I wouldn't wonder if he had heard it prior to the release.

[@ndale0t780]

Not related to the reaction Not to be that person but I don't think there's anything wrong with the vocal production honestly...I only noticed about the vocal production when people started talking about it saying its 'overproduced'??? I don't know man, we're being given a gift and when it comes people are just analysing it like it's some experiment, army, are u not going to enjoy wat u get for once,,, I'd say majority of the 'army' actually messed up the comeback more than 'antis'. Stop getting caught up in people's opinions. And of course if u didn't like it or think it's 'overproduced, generic , another English song' it's cool but keep ur opinions to urself and don't spread the negativity. And of course I totally enjoy this live version because it's the raw voices of the members but I don't think there's anything wrong with the studio version. Please let people enjoy this gift cause people are loving it.

[@chiragpatil316]

Cant I just enjoy 1 comeback in peace I mean now this multis spread there opinions about bts saying that they are not in touch with roots But ppl are forgetting bts released BE between dynamite and butter

[@ndale0t780]

@@chiragpatil316 there's nothing wrong with whatever music BTS has put out, it's actually this so called army who are loosing their roots and boundaries as fans of music

[@geovanadelapena157]

I loveeeeeeeeeeeee it

[@sygynri3735]

Omg, I didn't know Yoongi did the last one. I couldn't actually point out who sang who on the studio ver. like on Sope where they sang right after the other and RM on the first talk the talk where he sounded a bit like Kook

[@vivivante8125]

This song was made for radio, they are always impeccable at blending their tones if necessary. Surely there is more blending going on especially on Tae who sounds way brighter. Also heads up Naver Now is not that forgiving with content uploads usually 🥴

[@erikoenglish1651]

Ed Sheeran said he wrote this song long time ago on the twitter

[@JacobRestituto]

Nice!

[@lalazee8818]

Thank you!

[@davimoraes3731]

This song grew in me like Film out

[@nilofarmalik4118]

thank u for ur reaction

[@selg6618]

wooow joonie 🔥

[@xeniaoconnor1782]

I love thissssssss! If you want high notes….. hear me out, Astro! (One of bts’s besties)

[@nosaibaissa7051]

Did u know that bts actually included sign language in their choreo

[@kaylaneprado]

💜💜💜

[@kc_fl_usa]

Live is a lot better than MV

[@silvermoon4670]

Live version is so cool I love it Thanks for reaction Please react to Umbrella cover by RM live

[@morganmomo101]

The kings of "lipsyncing? Don't know her" 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@user-vf5rn8hf5r]

bts video her 경기도

[@rain7705]

Kim Taehyung slayin' this PTD era💜🔥

[@anidii5719]

imo the way to maintain flow isn't to drown the vocals in unnecessary autotune, but to sing the song the same way/with the same vibe, ykwim? same emphasis, mood, & pronunciation, etc. whoever's in the booth with them should be guiding them with this. idk if that made sense; i'm just tired of robot bts.

[@JacobRestituto]

I agree to some point, I don't personally love the way they did it, however, I can see how it created continuity

[@user-bo8eo5nl8g]

슈발 뮤직비디오에서 나오는 댄스는 쉽더만... 라이브 버전 댄스 -0- 사기!!! 그 와중에 생라이브내.. 극혐이다!!!

[@junebugot7496]

Admit it - you are whipped for JK!

[@user-qd5gr8ql2w]

He don't know any member except for RM and probably Suga when he starts rapping , there was a time when he was reacting to jk and V's solo songs he was so whipped for them and now idk if he can recognize them or not

[@sontrinh3788]

Only anti agree with you

[@alexisgblack395]

I love how effortless Jungkook’s voice sounds as always. V is also stronger than ever. Rap line did beyond my expectation especially JHope and Suga’s part!!! ! I hate to say this but as much as I love Jin ( our WWH), I don’t like the sound of his voice in this song.. I don’t know how to put it but it sounds like he is squeezing it out from his throat.. very exhausting!!! this upbeat/ pop type of song is not for Jin or jimin.. jimin’s voice is too unique for this type of song! Having said that BTS wouldn’t be without a single one of them.. I wish fair distribution but not at the expense of the song!! Forgive me for being harsh and I am not saying this is the truth but it’s my truth! And honest to God, Jin is my second most beloved member! Again I am sorry but I must say this!

[@2_the_moon_and_back]

it's your biased opinion. if Jin was your 'second most beloved member' you would never have wrote this. Jin slayed. you sound very bitter. Jimin and Jin can suit any song. What you really mean is 'I wish fair distribution but not at the expense of TaeKook' right. You don't need to trash Jin to praise others.

[@user-pc1ow5mh9i]

you're so mean and bitter for jin…

[@2_the_moon_and_back]

@@user-pc1ow5mh9i how so? all the boys were great. you don’t need to tear someone down to praise someone else.

[@alexisgblack395]

I love Jin’s personality and I find him funny and handsome. I also find him a good leader in the way he is taking care of the members.. I love some of his solo songs but I don’t like his voice in this type of song! It’s straining and it’s exhausting to hear it.. Do not twist my words and put words in my mouth. I meant it when I say I wish for fair distribution but not at the expense of the song nothing to do with V or JK!!! You can like a person and not like their voice.. it’s as simple as that. With respect to Jimin, he has the most beautiful voice but not for upbeat songs such as this.. It’s not to MY taste.. is all!!!

[@alexisgblack395]

Also this is not called ‘tearing someone down’ it’s called giving opinions, sharing your likes and dislikes about certain people….. and I also don’t need to bring someone up either because they don’t need me to do that.. they are doing awesome on their own.. all of them for that matter! Unlike you I can voice out if I don’t like certain things even if it’s for my bias.. I don’t blindly like them and that doesn’t mean I don’t like them either! Wake up!!!!

[@justajakefanboy5409]

"I'm looking forward to see the live vocals" yet you practically say nothing to Jimin and Jungkook's spotless vocal runs in 4:27 and 5:29 . Watching this was a waste of time. Smh