Budget Magic: Budget Magic: $99 (43 tix) Eminent Domain (Modern)

[@blakesickness666]

40:04 "Probably something that involves counters...which is obnoxious" - SaffronOlive, *Looks at Seth's decklist, stares into camera*

[@dragonxfilms]

32 rhinos for modern would be interesting

[@horsebones727]

Shoot, that feels like it was just yesterday! I wonder how long ago he actually played it, gonna have to go look.

[@firstandlast.1254]

wait, what's wrong with abzan rites?

[@cuddlequeen3225]

34 Rhinos would be even better

[@drakeconsumerofsoulsandche5761]

@@firstandlast.1254 feels like cheating. Might as well call it abzan reanimator

[@shwift8789]

The children are consuming

[@Sakkyun]

that game vs burn omg lol

[@redmetalpanda9051]

The luck on that one!

[@miraculeux9476]

OhMyFuckingGod

[@christianlawrence2714]

Ponza throws yer OP sub sandwich in the trash. Eminent Domain takes it and eats it in front of them.

[@truetbird1730]

I love this analogy

[@onlyRicky_x]

Yes! More of this. I'm looking forward to it extending to against the odds and seeing a comeback to the 37 rhinos deck.

[@Sam_Propoganda]

Yes. I love the revisit. Please do more!

[@enabors249]

I remember this episode, I hope you keep coming back to old episodes. It's a great walk down memory lane for us long time viewers and really cool decks for everyone.

[@jonathanshore5768]

SETH im gunna need to see me some RHINOS

[@PeteDoesGames]

Oh my god that game against burn was amazing

[@Borkybaby]

That burn match up game one...... in freaking mind blown hahaha wow. Wow.

[@anonymoususer69]

I had been drifting away from magic for a few months now, but your videos from the past week have pulled me back in. Thanks Seth

[@travislangert5978]

Thanks Steph I enjoy all budget magic decks my built mini on the past it's good to see how you're going over the old deck that I enjoyed so much

[@williamstocker8107]

Seth, I love your content so much. I don't even play anymore, and I still love watching you play.

[@gamerprettyboy]

This was fun. Please do this again. Budget magic I think is your best column and this adds to it.

[@sirvaleros7983]

This is the very first MTGGoldfish video I ever watched and eventually the first deck I built on MTGO

[@redwoolsocks]

I remember this!!! You need to do more of this. There were so many sweet decks from the past clips!!!

[@jessebrown1357]

Love revisiting old decks (across the board, all series!) Keep em coming!

[@ZiegIce]

Should absolutely do this more in the future. So happy to see eminent domain return. I actually played this back when it first came out on budget magic. 👍

[@wdonica]

Absolutely do updates. I frequently watch your old deck techs and see places where new cards would fit or cards have come down in price.

[@dantran3087]

It's worth revisiting if it makes you this happy with each deck. This is too fun to watch!

[@BastianHodapp]

I really like the idea of revisiting old Deck techs :) Keep up the awesome work, Seth!

[@michaelburt9888]

Yes! Update and or recap old budget magic games. I for one would enjoy a "bonus round" of these decks.

[@lessercrow]

I really like that you are going back and revamping old decks! Keep it up man

[@brendanerickson2363]

These games had me on edge...so awesome! Totally should do some updated old decks. Great content! Thanks Seth

[@nathandjohan1969]

Omg i still remember this deck from way back when, it was amazing

[@kellyantonio5106]

The laugh of a madman 18:30

[@turnipy88]

I like seeing old decks replayed. Not just Budget Magic. The games will go differently and revisiting what new cards can go in the decks is cool.

[@austinstewart783]

I would love for you to do this more, it's an interesting idea to see the old decks you've done updated for the newer meta

[@cannonspectacle5195]

This was one of the first decks I bought on MTGO, excited to see it brought back. Is it possible that Desolate Lighthouse is better than Mikokoro, since we don't want to draw our opponent out of their screw?

[@Atmapalazzo]

Honestly I'd suggest it over Mikokoro

[@BigNast]

Definitely revisit and update old budget decks. Love watching the matches and updates would be great!

[@MTGGoldfish]

Another one is in the works!

[@BigNast]

@@MTGGoldfish Thanks for the response and great news! Happy New Year and best of luck! :)

[@DarknayseLyn]

Should have taken the dispels in the burn matchup.

[@naphackDT]

dispel covers instant speed threats, dream leash takes their lands if they play sorcery speed. I like the idea behind it.

[@DarknayseLyn]

@@naphackDT its burn. The voal of magic is to not die while killing the opponent. Dispel keeps him alive against a deck of mainly instants, while lash takes a land.

[@Sethsters]

Hindsight is 20-20, but yeah I cringed a little when he bottomed them.

[@bennaveaux]

I think updating old decks on occasion is a great idea. Excited to see this one in particular.

[@usethishere]

great video Seth. It is right up there with your green red land destruction video. I was looking for a deck to play around that time. I first found your videos through Land Destruction. keep up the good work.

[@Goddessofblundr]

I would enjoy seeing updates on the older decks. Been so long I have forgotten about a lot of these decks.

[@Gingerbreadley]

Hot damn it’s been 3 years?!? Thanks for all the content seth also revisits are a great idea!

[@BobardeZanzibar]

It's been another 3 for this comment.

[@Gingerbreadley]

@@BobardeZanzibar damn I feel old lol

[@Ashmanaiel]

Revisiting cool decks like this is great. The next best thing about this video was your choice of mountains. The ice cream sundae is one of the coolest arts, even if it does make me hungry.

[@Flickstro]

I'd love to revisit some more old budget decks, but I suppose that will rely on price changes and obsolescence as new sets come out. Also, 18:28 was hilarious!

[@dcmag2020]

I like the revisit idea, especially for decks that can get a real retooling with new cards.

[@rascalzard4217]

Definitely go back and update older decks. Really cool to see them again!

[@Alexhandre13]

This deck is SO SWEET! lol I hope you keep making updated versions of budget magic decks, and PLEASE make a new version of 34 rhinos!

[@dr4conic]

Loving the idea of revising old decks to play again!

[@Jude3333]

You should play a non budget version with blood moon on stream

[@Zolthux]

I second this

[@ezrabartsch1505]

Coming back to this 3 years later and thinking the same! Let’s see what this looks like in 2022!!

[@tiborgrun6963]

I played this deck in a budget modern tournament. I included one copy of Hanweir Watchkeep to have another finisher. It's cheap, survives your Wildfire, and closes out the game fast once your opponent can't cast spells anymore. Also Singing Bell Strike as additional removal in the sideboard. Sure you may pay 6 to untap your creature.

[@Tony9804]

I wanna see the Seance deck make another appearance

[@tiagosolano9728]

This was the best budget magic episode I ever saw!

[@mirtul1]

I would love to see some more old decks of yours make an updated return!!!!!!

[@TabbyLikeAKat]

Great video Seth, still love this deck! I would love to see you stream a nonbudget version as well, I honestly can't get enough of this deck

[@VGTIMEDBS]

Love the throw back. I would say somewhere in the 75 should be some number of copy enchantment. With dreamleash it gets around hexproof/ shround

[@damanstover2035]

I love the idea of updating older decks you have made!

[@ninjadave3281]

Yes! I would love to see more revisits to budget magic decks. It'd also be sweet if you could revisit old against the odds decks. Like see if any of the ones that did poorly or just so so are any better with new tools.

[@the_samwitch]

I'd love to see updated versions of older decks, whether they be Budget Magic or Against the Odds. That would be a bunch of fun to see how they changed with updates and meta changes.

[@doctordoctor7469]

This was one of your best episodes! Love the deck.

[@millie-max-moo]

20:00 ...should we tell him?

[@SlothMentality]

Ty Madey but maybe it was the nuts last year

[@Afrothoz]

That g1 burn match is why I love magic. At least when I'm in your seat!

[@abe10alpha]

34 Rhinos in modern. Make it happen seth!

[@rprat350]

Hey Seth, love the revisit! It would be cool if you also showed the old deck list (to see how things have changed) and maybe just mentioned how the deck performed originally (record).

[@MTGGoldfish]

Good idea!

[@NastierNate]

I love the idea of revisiting old Budget Magic lists. It’s like a Greatest Hits Remastered album.

[@adrianchupp]

Yes, updated to the best Budget Magic decks is a great idea. I love this!

[@swiftmage]

That burn game was one of the best things I have ever seen. I can't believe he didn't find any burn and only creatures!

[@benjiboy1337]

I like doing deck updates maybe once a month or so. A lot of the older shells are solid, but have some new and cheaper tools that we can slot into them today.

[@MTGGoldfish]

That's what I was thinking, especially during slower times (like now, when we are waiting for a set release).

[@dabbingpoliwhirl8567]

It should be nice to see more old list getting updates, sure go ahead. PD: the third game against burn... You teached me that i should keep cards that I side board in, yet you throw both dispels, that could have give you more time to get to the Titan along the mikokoro.

[@vesok]

Great idea! I think that you could even do a mini series, where you go over some old decks to see how are they affected by new sets and meta.

[@vesok]

Also a deck doctor episode on upgrading old decks would be awesome!

[@paolorumi9882]

Old Deks updated are very very cool :) Never saw this one and it is so so so so so so good!

[@shogostarr6218]

That game 1 against affinity made me want to take a shower afterwards... Good job, Seth.

[@HoneyCultured]

that match was hilarious first game

[@miketate3445]

I have no problem at all with revisiting old decks. Go for it!

[@Sabortooftigar]

Yes you might as well revisit decks as you choose. When they're still viable, get updates, etc I dont see why not

[@DropkickGoose]

I'm so down for some of the old budget decks, possibly even taking some of the budget standard decks that have rotated and updating them for modern (for instance, I have the WB aristocrats deck from a couple years ago that slowly got updated into abzan tokens right after ixalan. All of that deck is rotating basically, so having a route to update into modern would be interesting).

[@noahjaffe3094]

"Maybe this deck is just the nuts in 2017" nailed it

[@maestergallen]

Ever since I tried you haphazard ponza deck, I can no longer stop blowing up lands seth. This deck looks so sweet, though I'm not sure what advantage this has over classic G/R Ponza. Also, I would definitely love to see you updating old decks, especially so if it involves adding newly printed cards.

[@nomoarhamburgertime]

Hey Seth this was my first deck in mtgo and its always been super fun to play. There is nothing better then assembling an opponents tron. If you do any retro against the odds you have to do a remake of the psychogenic probe deck!

[@devcycler]

I really like the idea of adding another "Budget Magic:" every time a deck is revisited

[@glorybringer1545]

This deck is sooo sweet! A non budget version video would be much appreciated

[@mysticswaypointadvocate]

If rewatching my old favorite content is the only fee to watch seth have so much fun he's nearly crying from laughter, count me in. P.S. It's not a fee

[@CantusTropus]

I also love the legal reference in this deck's name.

[@francescogulisano2917]

First match opponent was such a good sport, props to them!

[@Snowjiggles]

I love this idea of updating older budget decks to be budget decks in today's world. I would also like, if it's at all possible, to see some budget decks with competitive updates. Imagine how consistent and good this deck would be with Steam Vents, Scalding Tarns, and Spirebluff Canals.

[@Snowjiggles]

Also, could you not fit Spell Pierce under the budget if you replaced the Negates with them? Leaving them no lands means they likely won't be able to pay the 2 mana.

[@tylerensor2591]

Consider greater gargadon in our deck here?? Like you can sac. Lands to him for value when you wildfire. Also you can sac annexed lands in response to any kind of enchantment hate from opponent trying to get their lands back to gargadon. In addition to having just another one drop that you can play like turn 2 where we would normally have nothing if we arnt double mana rocking.

[@tylerensor2591]

I guess that would be turn 3 my bad

[@bryantan4228]

This Land is My Land would be a meme name.

[@freddekar93]

I don´t think I have ever seen Seth have so much fun with a deck

[@MTGGoldfish]

I really love making opponents unable to play Magic.

[@azuraflame1]

I love the idea I hope it isn’t just budget decks though. I’d love to see an updated mono blue deck and at some point mono blue Fairies as well

[@user-vi4sn9eh5l]

I really do think you should revisit old budget MTG Decks because its a less work lode and it gives other people the chance to experience extremily old decks that they didn't see, and plus your also updating the deck wich is great.

[@ahunter7563]

I don't want to sound mean,but I love your "work lode" x)

[@jjconway8946]

Keep the flashbacks coming!! Thanks Saffronolive

[@matthewlohmeier2056]

I think you need aether wall and another finisher to make the deck amazing. Watching you dig for one finisher was just brutal for me. But I want this deck!

[@aaronr.k.9707]

I have to admit that I've never laughed so hard in any against the odds or budget modern deck ever before that Hardened Scales Affinity game 1. Loving the deck after that

[@alayoncito001]

I've seen all your videos but I still like the idea the meta changes

[@videorelaxants6495]

I like this idea. Maybe you can make a new series called Fishbowl Flashback where you visit old Budget Magic, Much Abrew, Against the Odds, and maybe even Playing Pauper lists? I would love to see some old much abrew decks updated.

[@johnporter9833]

18:45 " living the dream! Living the dream!" That laugh😂😂😂

[@NeoDeathrose13]

The Non-Budget version would be awesome to see on stream!

[@oliviergermain3106]

Sweet video, love to see Seth having so much fun!

[@Molly-ml1wn]

Love the idea of revisiting older decks! What if you didn't limit it to Budget Magic, and instead had weekly/biweekly/monthly/when-I-feel-like-it program where you update an older Budget/Odds/Abrew deck? With a viewer poll for the next old deck to get a rework. You could call it... Return to Goldfish? Or, depending on the deck varient being reworked that week, Shadows over Budget Magic? Improve the Odds? More Abrew About Nothing? While we're at it, I cast my first vote for Budget Magic Origins UR Thopters!

[@mrs4turn]

I've been hoping for budget deck updates for a long time. Rhinos and Troll Worship !

[@johnmichaelbushman]

This was in my recommended for some reason. Is it a sign that Seth should revisit this deck?

[@anthonyolimpio3545]

Seth's laugh at 18:30 is now my ringtone.

[@Amadrine]

Re-hashing is a great thing to do every couple of years in a game like magic. I'd love to see updated versions of against the odds decks that you personally believe have been improved or are worth a second chance for glory because of newer cards being released. I'm sure you'll figure out a way to shoehorn panharmonicon into something. lol

[@danielbridges9436]

Ravenor showing no mercy as befits a member of the holy inquisition. Makes Sign of Aquila “The emperor protects”

[@luliby2309]

Looks like Budget Magic has a new subseries called "Budget Magic". That game against Burn though was insane.

[@leesalt]

55:00 Should have wild fired the bridge vine deck one turn sooner. They would have only made one zombie that you said would be a million. You gave them the chance to build up a massive board state the very next turn. If they didn't have lands, they wouldn't have been able to get their vengvines out of the graveyard.

[@MTGGoldfish]

They have annoying free creatures to get things back, but you might be right. Waiting didn't work out.

[@leesalt]

@@MTGGoldfish in this particular case, had you done it earlier, they would have had one zombie, then, next turn they got two vengevines and two zombies with their two xx creatures. The very next turn anger would have exiled their recursive vengevines. I'm not saying it was winnable considering they were drawing lands at a freakish rate despite only having 17 but it would have given a few more draws than you got. The amazing ability of hindsight from your viewers is great, don't you think? I should have started my original comment with: Great stuff as always. Updating these old decks with new and reprinted cards is a very cool idea for your fans.

[@ryanmorfei6325]

I really like remaking old decks. Not all of them though. Maybe once a month do a vote for which deck to bring back just like how we sometimes vote for against the odds. I think bringing back favorite decks is a really great idea

[@Drakksy]

I fell asleep last night watching this so I'm glad I get to support you with a view twice 😂😂

[@outshimed]

That game against burn is one of the craziest games of Magic I've ever seen.

[@MTGGoldfish]

Yeah, that was absurd.