Buying an M240i over the G87 M2?

Today we take a look at the G42 just days after driving the G87. I am considering both of these cars as my next purchase, and it's a tough pick between the two. They would serve two different purposes in my book. The G42 would be a really fun dig and roll race car. Throw a full frame turbo on this car with proper cooling and port injection, we would be MOVING OUT on the competition! The G87 would really be geared towards the corners and road track, I would buy that in manual as well while the G42 is only offered in Auto.
Now, I am aware that the supra and M240 are not actually the same cars. (I think we all know this!) However, both cars ARE utilizing the same power plant, the B58. The G42 weighs about 300 pounds more but you can shed weight in these cars quite easily. The AWD is the main attraction here, B58 + AWD is a great combo!
So, what do you guys think? Would you go G87 and pay a bit more? Would you go G42 and save a little cash? What type of build interests you? Comment below!
A special thank you to Deanna for allowing us to film her car today! You can follow Deanna here: nc_car_girl...
Huge thank you to Suvneer for sponsoring this video and helping Deanna out with a new carbon Lip, the exact lip can be purchased here: tinyurl.com/sf57hyac
Suvneer offers a wide variety of BMW carbon Fiber products, feel free to shop Suvneer Here: tinyurl.com/mtk83efb
BMW MODIFICATIONS FROM ALL OF MY BUILDS: www.thicwhips.com
All of my Wheel & Tire Setups: tinyurl.com/yyftysns
--------------------------------------------------------------
Discounts and Codes: tinyurl.com/5n92k9m8
10% Off The Veepeak Adapter Using Code: YTBDST10 OBD2 Adapter For Bimmercode: geni.us/W4ct
20% Off Variant Wheels (Use Code “thicwhips”): tinyurl.com/8thphmmt
$13.99 Off The OBDLink CX+ Adapter For Bimmercode: tinyurl.com/yyj924lw
5% off all parks car care detailing products: tinyurl.com/yckma39s
5% off of Valvetronic Designs Exhausts Here: valvetronic.com/?ref=-2nSk-CZ...
ThicWhips Merch, Apparels, Decals: tinyurl.com/yvpwrra7
FACEBOOK GROUP: tinyurl.com/m4r294c

[@ThicWhips]

What do you guys think, would you go with the m240 or would you go with the m2? Leave the comments down below!

[@madmax1631]

i like the m2 more better engine and has tons of more potential

[@ilgatto7327]

The M2 with 6MT

[@BTSyaya]

Personally would never even consider an m240 over the m2. My needs and uses would never need the awd from the 240 which in my opinion is the thing the 240 has that’s “better”

[@thrbcha]

M2

[@gabegonzales8618]

Exactly my thoughts don’t get me wrong it’s a beautiful car but in the back of my head I’d always think, “I coulda had an M2”

[@Anthony-bc2cw]

I ordered a M240i and had it delivered last month. I love it, super planted to the road and handles really well. The AWD is crucial for me as a DD living in the Midwest.

[@sa_power_1641]

This is the content we want !!!!💪keep doing what you doing bro

[@ryancaso]

Loving the recent videos with the car review and owner interviews!

[@michaelgarcia2821]

I got my M240i back in December. Also for me this is my first BMW and I'm not disappointed at all. To me its the perfect daily driver. Plenty of power to have fun on the streets, yet calm and comfortable when driving in heavy traffic. Just saving up the pennies now to do my first upgrade. Great Video!!

[@jks1311]

great video and beautiful car!

[@thepencilkidd]

Took delivery of one of these in July. The aftermarket support is lacking because they aren't that common, but it's the best thing I've ever bought!

[@speed817]

Just picked up my Thundernight Metallic M240i last week. Love it so far!

[@Ryan_Mooney]

FYI - The grills do not open every time you turn the car on like she says. From what I've experienced, they open up when the car reaches a certain temp. It's also believed that driving mode and AC level impacts this, but who knows.

[@Jay_812]

I have a G42 and also feel it doesn’t get the respect it deserves. Especially when you lower and add an exhaust! You hit the nail on the head - the body roll is significantly reduced and the downpipe really opens this car up. I have a full exhaust and it sounds ridiculous. I vote you get one and build it for the channel!

[@morsinimicis3930]

My new loaded Melbourne Red M240i is in production now and arrives end of October. Adding the MPE and quad tips initially. Can’t wait to take delivery!

[@kylerhurlburt3206]

My G42 is currently in production. Can't wait to pick it up!

[@jaimehurtado356]

Every time I see these cars in person I think to my self, man that's a good looking car sporty but subtle and they have some awesome color options

[@Clockwork2004]

Picked up an aspen white 2023 M240i xDrive last month. Waiting to break the engine in before I let er rip, but so far I am enjoying it. A while back I had a 2021 Toyota GR Supra 3.0 Premium and I think that this will be a much better daily.

[@pool12390]

Great car! Just be prepared for a good chance of condensation developing in on the headlight units.

[@ryanlen2115]

Great video. Those roof light thingys were cool, unless I was seeing things

[@NC_Car_Girl_G42]

Nope you weren’t seeing things 😈 the starlights are one of my favorite mods on the car 🌌

[@ryanlen2115]

Thanks. Will have to see where I could get done around me

[@DevelDogg48]

I’ve seen a few 240is on the road and they look great. I have a G87 on order and I’m excited, granted I have yet to see one out there yet.

[@P1stolPete.]

Is there lighting on the roof liner? never seen that before, looks great!

[@benbustama3430]

M240Xis are great cars! I own a ‘19 & absolutely love it. It’s my DD. Never had a regret owning this over the M2! They really don’t compare. I chose the M240Xi over an M2 for two reasons. I need AWD (Midwest) & I need something more comfortable (softer suspension) as my DD. I honestly believe the M240Xi is the best sporty car value/DDriveable/quasi limited/quasi special/high performing car extant. I own two other real sports cars that scratch my M2 itch…

[@alexhentschel1080]

Id have the m240 all day. and i agree all you really need is a intake, down pipe, BM3 and XHP.. annnd some VS5RS wheels.. and lowering springs... and code out the fake engine noise... thats it! theres just so much you can do lol

[@HotRodM4]

VS-5RS gang 🫡

[@curtdragon]

Love these. I'd get that color too. But probably end up with a G87. Just wish they had AWD

[@mandikim682]

Hey! I was at Olive Garden when Usef stopped by to see us. I’m not sure if you were with him at that point, but sorry i missed you at MPact I have the Zandvoort G87 @M2mandi …loved your review of Chris’s!! M2 all the way!! 💙💙💙

[@Digiphex]

The display looks so much better in this car than the current M2 with that Samsung TV screen.

[@danieljordison0793]

All 2023 models have the big screen, this must be a 22

[@jdbsoccer100]

I hate the update.. they took the shifter knob away too lol

[@1Clean.E93]

im doing the same cant wait for my g42

[@brianmiller1977]

YES! The G42XD will soon be revered as the optimal tuners car.... Now there are driveline upgrades, with some basic mods its essentially a 1st gen GTR. Such a high value platform, and people will have them in the 8's very soon... An affordable high ceiling platform with quality after market support now. Once people catch on to their potential, I think many performance car enthusiast will op for the G42 over the G87..

[@bladejames8208]

BTW, there is a new 23 automatic, Black on Black M2 currently available at BMW of Lynchburg VA. I just passed on it this morning because I am still unsure if M2 or M3/M4 is right for me and the fact the car is Black on black. I love black exterior on the m2 but, need a bright interior to brighten up the car, Silverstone, Kayalama, Red or ivory. The new 23 M2 black on black was still available as of 11am this morning 8/31/23.

[@vonfragyou]

Only difference is really the suspension bits. The horsepower can be obtained from the m240 easily. Since you always do your own suspension parts I would suggest the m240 so we can see all the goodies you add....i.e. new Thic Whip special!

[@FreeYSLM2]

There a definitely more differences than just the suspension but I understand your point though

[@BTSyaya]

S58’s are making over 700whp with a downpipe and an e40 tune. Sure the b58 sauce is good but it’s more in the realms of 500whp

[@liamsullivan8171]

Repping the IND shirt. Just made a whole bookmark folder in Chrome last week of stuff I eventually wanna buy from them.

[@svenhoeylaerts3249]

After 6 years it was time to let go a F87 m2 manual. On youtube the new m2 looked not good. So we went to the dealer to spec a m240. There was a m240 in stock a grey m240 but there was also a toronto red m2 in stock, i asked if it was possible to park them next to each other and than the m240 looked dull. It is way smaller than the m2. In real life the m2 is very wide and good looking something a photo will not show. We went for the M2!

[@SlavicPridee]

I own a G42 2023 m240 but the RWD not x drive. Reason why I didn’t go with a m2 was due to the wait time, price, gas mileage, insurance and the fact that M Car maintenance is always more expensive. B58 engines are amazing already and the S58 is beefed up however you can still have great power from these B58s. The 2023s do come with the idrive so the interior is different. I get the AWD hype however a “true” BMW in my eyes is RWD. This car is by far THE MOST fun car I’ve had. The M diff really makes the car slide around easily and the control of the car in a slide is incredible. A toddler could drift this thing really.

[@OFFROADandSTUFF]

You’re literally the first person who has shared an opinion of the 240i RWD, there’s no video about it in all KZbin. I’m also planning to get the RWD version, the only thing that makes me doubt it is that the launches may not be as powerful as the AWD, what do you think about that? Does the launch still feel savage?

[@jdbsoccer100]

Glad you went with the RWD! I had a 2016 340i for 6 years and have loved it. I drove both the m240i RWD and xdrive. I liked the RWD a little more but got a sweet deal on a 2022. I also prefer the pre face lift interior with the shifter knob. Not sure why they took it away

[@jdbsoccer100]

@@OFFROADandSTUFFlaunches are not as powerful but that’s not important. If that’s the only thing tempting you towards the x drive, go RWD I wanted the old interior with the shifter knob and also got a decent deal on a used one

[@yujie1973]

Great video. Just not too sure about the pricing. I got my 2023 M240i xdrive alpine white for MSRP $58k but now it's a little more. 2023 M2 starts at $63,200 currently. with options MSRP is probably $70k. So it's probably $12k difference instead of your estimate $30k difference. I am located in the States, not sure if it makes a difference.

[@andreagate542]

Sweet carbonfibre lip!!! I have an E82 135i with the M sport bumper, does the company that made the carbon fibre live in this video so one for my car? 🍺🙏🏽

[@SsTR-th2wv]

loving the way that paint color is matching her hair color

[@MyDuffy33]

the look on her face when you put your foot down she just loved it and what a great car it is.

[@micraw714]

I would totally snatch one of these if you could flash the dme without sending it off 😢 B58 plus x drive is dope 🔥

[@dnice362]

Wow cannot beat that for the price either

[@TheSiege2]

I just ordered my 2024 240i xDrive in purple with red interior and shadowline package! Cannot wait!

[@Fat_Catt]

How long did it take to get delivery?

[@TheSiege2]

@@Fat_Catt ordered in late October and took delivery at the end of November

[@redsiricer]

M240 and M2 are both fantastic value at different price points. Honestly can't go wrong either way!

[@viperx100]

0-60 has been documented as low as 3.6 stock with launch control. BMW underrated the engine as per usual.

[@chadleutscher9971]

Absolutely love m240ixdrive!!

[@nathankeller2870]

I have a 23 m240 and i plan on getting 650hp out of it. Super nice car!!

[@ThicWhips]

Very nice!

[@Ruebz_f30]

when he swicthed to paddles, she heard sounds she never heard that car make haha

[@NC_Car_Girl_G42]

Very true!! Gotta learn how to use paddles now 😂

[@dylanhall6136]

I'd pay for the M2 with a manual transmission (and I did lol). Especially if you plan on taking either cars to the track. You'll be happy you purchased the M2.

[@thev8744]

Thick whips goes hard, unlike other tubers

[@kaiichinose9590]

It really depends, I prefer manual transmissions but if I could have it my way it would be the m240i xdrive, with 6speed manual. No reason BMW couldn’t offer the manual on the m240i. The b58 is just so damn stellar. But then again I don’t really like the g series looks at all. I’d probably just go with an f series m2 og. Man the n55b is legit but if the og m2 had the b58 it would be perfect.

[@Sprout4k]

Why not get the m340? already had the two door supra but the 4 door would be a little different. Especially with the 21-22 that have the mild hybrid in it. Not enough people are modding the mild hybrids. (I also don't know if the m240's have the mild hybrid so don't roast me)

[@thrbcha]

Funny how when the leaks first came out I thought it was hideous. Next thing u know I seen it in person and am itching to get one 😂

[@MALIK-fk1rz]

like every other bmw hater

[@thrbcha]

@@MALIK-fk1rz I have a g80 not a hater

[@AJUSA1]

M240s are definitely under appreciated by the car community… awd supra… and nobody really talks about it…

[@PlayafromtheHimalayas]

The 240 and 340 are the best bang for your buck in the bmw lineup.

[@domostructor147]

M240i for sure

[@bladejames8208]

Johnathan, do you have any pull with Hendrick BMW Charlotte (not Northlake). Hook up a follower, a fan, lol. Nick (Parks) took care of me thanks to you. Thank you again for that. I went to Hendrick BMW today 8/31/23. They had 1 new 24 M4 Competition XDrive Aisle of Man Green, Kayalama extended interior, carbon buckets, carbon interior package and the full carbon exterior package. Absolutely beautiful car but, not one other option selected 🥵🤧😪😤🤯...... customer spec'd the car, late on delivering paperwork to purchase. Was told , had a very good shot at purchase but, even as beautiful as it was, no tech/comfort options (I am old, need that stuff). They had 3 new convertibles M4 Competition XDrive cars. I am not a convertible guy but the Dravit Grey with Silverstone interior and fully optioned down to neck warmers........ Damn we were close.... last day of the month. I was wanting them to beat Colorado BMW offering 3k off MSRP and they just wouldn't do it. They came down $1,800 but, $1,200 was their markup for tinted windows, nitrogen in the tires and 3M door edge trim.

[@parkvoranaparit1873]

RS3 is faster, but the interior is boring as hell. I personally prefer the M240i xDrive over the RS3 and the M2 (you pay extra for the wheels spin, unless you like drifting lol)

[@mkvB58KING]

240 will leave a ton of extra money for mods, you should do a top mount turbo build 👀

[@CullyColantino]

Bro, top mount 6466 240 with xdrive would be silly fast.

[@chrisginoc]

This exactly! The money you would save and apply towards mods would make those car with xdrive insanely fast.

[@AcousticheroM]

Been looking into the m240 over the m340, m3 and m4. For what the motor offers with the Drivability it might just take the cake. Stock to stock yes it will lose but mod to mod after awhile it will take the cake.

[@nell9956]

You do know that the m340 and m240 share the same b58,

[@BTSyaya]

Mod for mod the b58 doesn’t even come close to an s58.

[@icebruner]

Best G42 to Get is the 230i, Better Looking than M2 and 240, Manual And RWD‼️ Upgraded Turbo and Ur Set 👌🏾

[@BigBrotherMotown]

Just bought a 230i xdrive. 9 grand cheaper than the 240i and a 4 cylinder twin turbo is PLENTY of power for me. My car will never see a track or a youtube video. 😂

[@curtdragon]

Bro sweating out his tee-shirt and she's got on a hoodie lol

[@kevincoy6969]

Beautiful car! not sure she can make any comments on reliability having had a brand new car for less than a year lol.

[@tolgaayazseven9139]

I wanted a manual M2, ordered one. Then realized manual M2 exists in 2021. So I found a mint condition manual m240 (they are very rare!). Really happy with the decision

[@nickmarsden8129]

B58 is the best bang for the buck no doubt. But S58 is truly the next level. A basic stage 1 tune with zero mods on a S58 engine puts it around 650HP. That’s already way more than FBO on a B58 (unless you’re doing big turbo but at that point it’s over 10k worth of mods along with other headaches). Point being the M cars are truly special and yes it’s a steep price increase, but 100% worth it if you can afford it

[@scuddryvr8784]

A purple M240i looks like the perfect car…..for my wife too.

[@guclugozen]

M2 looks priceless..

[@ababbington1]

Don’t bother messing with the gearbox. The ZF gearbox has been used in many cars including Bentley and Aston Martin. Any change you make will be hardly noticeable but might bugger the gearbox up.

[@naudi0101]

my m340i blew the transmission with a stage 2 mhd tune after I unlocked and tuned it only lasted a month 😭. It might have needed xhp but 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@ThicWhips]

That’s crazy

[@naudi0101]

@@ThicWhips yeah when i took it to the shop they have no idea how it happened. I launched it less then 3 times too but looks like the transmission couldn’t handle it. The g87 auto comes with the way stronger zf8 speed. B58 cars have the zf51

[@arlok789]

I debated this endlessly with myself and then I bought a certified G20 330i xdrive and a super low mileage manual 987 Boxster S. Problem solved. Better utility from the 330 and better handling and driving feel from the porsche for the same money as an m2. Both are plenty fast for public roads. I've had 500 plus horsepower cars and they are just trouble. Not fun unless you are breaking the law. Cant rev them out.

[@huntermckim]

i say m240 because for track and backroads u have the m3

[@stephenemmonds]

ĎO IT! This will 100% be my next car if you do. I'm already looking at them to replace my F32. They are a great looking performance car at a reasonable price point. Plus you don't see many around. My favourite colour is the purple too.

[@cjameson]

Do this with my car 😂 I have a ‘17 m240. putting on my ARM DP tomorrow with the help of KZbin University!

[@richardwelch8593]

Coming from the m240, I'll take the new m2 any day. I want a manual transmission, rear wheel drive car. The difference in performance and handling is palpable...

[@seethruhead7119]

current gen m2 is now an m3. i'ts big and heavy almost feels like the supra is closer to the m2 of old than the real m2

[@unexpiredbleach9236]

was in the same boat about the lci m340 and m3, bought the 340 but regret not getting the m3. trading it in sometime next year

[@bladejames8208]

John/Community, This video could not have come out at a better time. I am currently shopping new 23/24 M2s and new 24 M3/M4s Xdrive. I am either looking for a daily driver vehicle and keeping my 21 Porsche 911 C4S or buying 1 vehicle to be both a daily and a performance monster. Keeping in mind I only drive 5,000 miles a year maximum. I truly can not decide between the M2,M3/M4, as dealerships do not allow test drives of M2s or M3/M4s I don't want to purchase a car and regret it only to swap out soon for another, loosing money. Given the situation I stated above, given you could buy either of the 3, keeping in mind with the M2 I would keep my Porsche and with M3/M4 xdrive it would be a replacement for the Porsche 911 C4S (if you will). Which would you have? Need advice from owners of the new 23 M2 , New 24 M3/M4 who perhaps ideally have had new (2020-2023) Porsche 911 C2S, C4S, GTS. Thank you for anyone who leaves input, advice, opinions 🙏🏻

[@InclineDumbbell]

I have the new M2 in a manual and love it! Haven't driven a 911 though so can't really compare.

[@slowm240]

f22 gang but these g series are growing on me with aftermarket stuff

[@BTSyaya]

M2 all day. Unless it snows and you need awd. Other than that give me the tuned s58 over a tuned b58 any day.

[@zcmdzpp127]

Best part is the screen before they updated it..

[@lks6825]

M240i is the move just not feeling the new m2

[@dnice362]

I would this over this generation M2 easily

[@daddaIT]

niiiiice

[@xtnuser5338]

I got the 4-door M240i Xdrive. Ooops sorry. I mean the RS3.

[@daringries]

As a guy who owns an m440i with a tune/exhaust/downpipe- I wouldn’t own an m240i without a downpipe and a tune and a set of Rohana wheels. Forget the intake- makes minimal difference

[@jdbsoccer100]

I’m swapping in my 2016 340in for a 2022 m240i. I have the resonators deleted and it sounds so good.. will definitely need to put a down pipe and ecu tune on the m240i

[@bsmoove69]

She said reliable lol reliable compared to what other models?

[@alane1000]

If isn't manual than it's not worth it. A lazy automatic isn't the way

[@marniionmee2140]

240i all day.

[@nickbrunisch3101]

The m240i is probably faster to 60 than the m2 and it has more practicality with being all wheel drive so the m240i wins especially being so much cheaper.

[@hondaman8648]

M2 comes in manual. Altho my 18 m240i is manual, but they did away with it in the gen 2. Dumb decision

[@derianc3]

B58 over the s58 ???

[@BTSyaya]

I swear all the people in comments haven’t seen a tuned s58. It’s mind blowing. Sure the b58 deserves respect but the s58 makes sooo much more horsepower mod for mod.

[@lukeperry8755]

@@BTSyayaspot on here ! Both great engines but s58 is an animal

[@vagueorigin7320]

The ONLY reason im considering the m2 g87 over the m240ig42 is because you cant get it in manual 🤦🏿...

[@souljayt8411]

Get a z4m40i more rare and same Supra chassis :)

[@2bootsman2]

The m240 certainly looks a lot better than the M2 for this new generation, and how can you go wrong with the B58?

[@Miles0370]

M550i is best to get

[@swift__]

For the price of the M2, I’d just save n go M3/M4… the actual cluster and the awd is 👌🏻👌🏻 ( stupid college computer screen is 🤢 I’d pick fighter jet > computer screen any day ) but everyone has their preferences so get what you like and can afford , it’s about whatever makes you happy .

[@dfischer1980]

Standard suspension, standard brakes, much more civilian look. And it's not an M.

[@Asiqowoodbbxirbd]

I’ll buy it from you for 32k cash rn because that’s what it’s worth

[@Asiqowoodbbxirbd]

My bad I thought this was marketplace

[@GerardoHernandezF87M2]

Looks great, but I would rather pay the extra $15k for the fat boy

[@omarrahman5532]

I could never pick this over an actual M car

[@rcouchh]

G42 can't really compare unless you need xDrive, just comes down to budget and use case. B58 is a good motor it's just in so many cars. G87 will always be a huge step up and much more capable all around. The G42 interior already looks so outdated compared to iDrive 8 also

[@Dhime]

No.

[@kratos9223]

If you're going to rip out all of the M division's R&D and hard work anyway then go for the M240i else just get a proper M car.

[@999isco]

Clean🥹🔥

[@cinorikese5890]

The simple fact that you get this car from Germany for like 20.000 dollars less in the USA than in the EU makes me wanna call Van der Leyen and tell her to kick BMW out of the EU. What's wrong with the fucking world?

[@jc74435]

Its all about taxes

[@bubbablack9595]

All depends on your budget 😂 have a lot of dough get a real M car, on a budget meh.. get m240 then list your justifications to make your self feel good. At the end of the day don’t kid yourself. 😅