Bystanders did nothing as woman was raped on Philadelphia train, police say

Authorities say other riders who witnessed an alleged sexual assault on a SEPTA train last week "should have intervened." Instead, police say some held up their phones in the direction of the attack. Fiston Ngoy, 35, has been charged with rape, aggravated indecent assault and related counts in the incident.
DETAILS: bit.ly/3lSdkaK
Philadelphia news, weather, traffic and sports from FOX 29, serving Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Delaware. Watch breaking news live or see the latest videos from programs like Good Day Philadelphia.
Subscribe to FOX 29: www.youtube.co...
Watch FOX 29 live: www.fox29.com/...
Watch more FOX 29 News on KZbin: • FOX 29 News (Archive)
Download the FOX 29 News app: fox29.onelink....
Download the FOX 29 Weather app: www.fox29.com/...
Follow FOX 29 on Facebook: / fox29philadelphia
Follow FOX 29 on Twitter: / fox29philly
Follow FOX 29 on Instagram: / fox29philly
Subscribe to FOX 29's newsletters: www.fox29.com/...

[@gaila.9852]

My mind can’t comprehend that NO ONE in the train helped this woman. This world gets more disappointing by the day.

[@Denniss7420]

They were afraid to be labeled as *RACIST*

[@Leahh823]

@@jamesrobinson2138 You just couldn’t wait to say something ignorant, could you? Congratulations

[@Leahh823]

@@jamesrobinson2138 I want people to think things out logically before they decide make an ignorant comment. Anyone could have and should have helped her, no matter the gender. If it was a woman you cared for, wouldn’t you want someone to help?

[@sadiadurrani9358]

@@Denniss7420 u know I would’ve jumped on him beside anything but what u said did happen to me when I try to save a chines girl and the ladies in the bus start yelling at me that why I told the cops…

[@virgochild8213]

@@jamesrobinson2138YOU ARE A CONQUERED BETA MALE.

[@dorianbedorian211]

That's crazy... ALL of Philadelphia should be embarrassed, appalled and disgusted by this blemish on the reputation of the so called "City of brotherly love."

[@valarmorghulis4801]

This isn't just Philadelphia. It's the world that is like this

[@ayalibra]

@@valarmorghulis4801 I totally agree

[@ayalibra]

That term became obsolete many decades ago. Philly is trash

[@queenjoy5111]

I agree 👍

[@kathleenking47]

@@ayalibra well, the name MEANS THAT we still call L.A. city of angels

[@naturelover2292]

Hopefully the guards will turn a blind eye when he gets the same treatment in jail.

[@vernonsanders371]

r u for real he will b right back on your streets in a new York second

[@lonelypigeon7562]

if Jeff Dahmer was still alive............

[@1maybeline]

@@vernonsanders371 Yep.. and you can blame the Democrats for that!

[@kimwarner1681]

There will be a crowd standing around him, doing nothing.

[@mrwhite77781]

Let the booty bandits have they way

[@caseys.manning8758]

There is SO much wrong with this story. It’s tragically heartbreaking. Prayers for the woman attacked.

[@OmarLopez-yr8bs]

There is SO much fake with this story.

[@crypticjim]

yeah, that'll fuckin help

[@Izziharassedbynycooficials]

your prayers are useless it's about to become even worse

[@theadventuresoftaco7306]

Walk into a divorce court and c how men get treated. Then maybe you'll understand why men no longer care what happens to female. Thank your sisters for that.

[@animaljustice7774]

@@Izziharassedbynycooficials shut up, you sound like you need to pray

[@dejamesola]

The fact that he had ABSOLUTELY no problem doing this in the presence of others! DIABOLICAL!!! AS IF HE KNEW THEY WOULDN'T DO ANYTHING!!! 😢😢😢

[@joebidens_touchyhands9477]

Media is lying like usually. All the facts are not out. Their was no penetration. They knew each other. Just groping.

[@ShanteRoxxane]

@@joebidens_touchyhands9477 Why are you literally commenting everywhere defending this!? You’ve been on every comment talking about the bad guy like he’s normal and a hood guy. You must be doing the same things.

[@shadow_alastor9829]

@@ShanteRoxxane what's a "hood guy"?

[@kosoul2k11]

@@shadow_alastor9829 Meant a good guy, use that education girl

[@kosoul2k11]

@@joebidens_touchyhands9477 You have a serious problem and need to be locked up with the rest of your Trump followers

[@kuriyahlahad9275]

The fact that people were there and did nothing to help is just sickening!!!

[@timksha2701]

@@dragonknightofamiraka3636 seek help. That thinking is not normal

[@tanicajackson5132]

FOR THE PEOPLE WHO DID NOT HELP THAT WOMAN IN NEED. YOUR KARMA IS COMING ................

[@lavender6500]

@MIDDLE east I bet you also mention that YOU built everything, right? YOU did? Your fathers? Such delusion.

[@shawnajoannalamb7116]

@@dragonknightofamiraka3636 I a lot of black women and men that would be sickened by your immaturity and mind.

[@TGrant-rl7fz]

@@dragonknightofamiraka3636 so in which nothing ever changes... and the cycle continues bc the perp will get his karma also.

[@thisisyoutubetv3235]

A man once helped by punching the aggressor and he got arrested for assault.

[@melissalovingit6872]

We are in a Upside Down 'Clown' World.

[@dab0331]

Because these are laws written by liberal WOMEN. Women created this mess with their soft on crime and anti-gun agendas

[@bullballsallday]

Just look at Daniel Perry, Daniel Penny, and Kyle Rittenhouse. Self defense and defense of others can be considered a crime.

[@pear-zq1uj]

exactly. stop arresting good samaritans. I would do nothing too because I'm not going to ruin my life because the justice system is corrupt

[@brianholloway6205]

lol once? When? What happened? Where?

[@bigstew9724]

When good guys get involved, they keep getting arrested. The criminals get a pass. Ironic.

[@NorthernAtlantic1980s]

That ex US marine who was jailed for being a Good Samaritan !

[@bigstew9724]

@@NorthernAtlantic1980s exactly

[@swires1]

@@bigstew9724 Also women constantly go on about being "strong & independent". Doesn't exactly help in a case like this.

[@swires1]

On top of that they're almost all pro-"diversity" ...... Well, that's what you get.

[@lexijs]

that has nothing to do with this weirdo@@swires1

[@user-uz2gc8rl6y]

The pain and hurt of crying for help when help is right there but won't answer, is on another level.

[@southernsoul152]

Beyond comprehension

[@elisabeth5087]

Fr I still can't imagine it 😔

[@ericalopez6152]

I was thinking the same thing just makes you more scared 😱

[@cliodhna2694]

@@mall29 😐 u think ur funny?

[@kenny6920]

@@mall29 tf is wrong with you bro seek help

[@peterclement8561]

So basically, you must be able to defend yourself for 3 minutes and expect no help from people sitting next to you. Nice work Philly.

[@libra7.063]

The 3 min he's talking about is from the time they called and when they caught him. The actual assault on the train was 6 min, according to other articles, and no one did anything. If the train was full, they all could have ganged up on him and save the victim. Shameful. Disgusting.

[@amresponsibilitytakernotli9613]

U can see lots of these kind of mentally ill peoples on porn site and their comments makes me feel complete mental illness ..after that i never see these dirty peoples

[@tonyaanderson1329]

Sounds like a scary movie 🎥. Too much enslavement of the mind with the end result of.......... NON-COMPLIANCE. 🤡👎 Boooooooo :ll

[@joebidens_touchyhands9477]

@@libra7.063 She should've saved herself.

[@vinnyv949]

The perps name is Fiston Nygaper

[@themessenger2455]

The fact that the man had the audacity to do it in public speaks volume of how this world is going. Jesus come quickly.

[@meferswift]

He know no body dared to intervene, or cared to. He is known to do lots of SA and get out scotch free.

[@zhaahn7869]

Maybe wish for free meal in the jail since it's hard to be homeless.. Well bad choice still.. Rape may lead to death in prison.. Well I don't know in Philadelphia but in my country it is.

[@DannyThomas-pm2ku]

What do you mean? You want to get involved with a black man? Get ready to be cancelled and lose your career.

[@meldrickedwards1464]

But overall it's quite confusing, because most videos/articles seem to claim the people watched and recorded what happened. An article by the New York Post claim that report is unconfirmed, or false and one passenger did help.

[@ElCapitanGames]

Jesus don’t have shit to do with this. Take that Babel-talk elsewhere.

[@LilMissSmartyPants.922]

we dont have a racist problem we have a problem race

[@rod253]

😂😂😂 the irony of your comment

[@LilMissSmartyPants.922]

@@rod253 its also true

[@rod253]

@AtomicBlonde22 🤣 🤣 you are very correct. Oh the irony

[@MarioMario-vy4bi]

We have an iq problem

[@SlayedbySavagee]

This women is going to never trust a single person again… I’m traumatized for her I hope she’s okay 🥺❤️

[@meldrickedwards1464]

But overall it's quite confusing, because most videos/articles seem to claim the people watched and recorded what happened. An article by the New York Post claim that report is unconfirmed, or false and one passenger did help.

[@suchabadkitty1293]

@@meldrickedwards1464 SHHHH

[@chantsfiji]

😢 this is so heartbreaking

[@theultimate6542]

Is anyone surprised?

[@suchabadkitty1293]

@@theultimate6542 Yes.

[@sabineholthaus7961]

In Germany all the bystanders who did nothing would face jail. They have a law that if one doesn`t help a person in danger "Unterlassene Hilfeleistung" will be prosecuted.

[@mjnaz65]

Then Merkel should be arrested for allowing Germany to be invaded and doing nothing to stop it.

[@stellatan9485]

But this is America now? Just like in india

[@Izziharassedbynycooficials]

lol

[@messyangel1169]

No wonder Germany is such a sh*thole 😂

[@theadventuresoftaco7306]

I'd rather be prosecuted than buried after becoming a victim. Cause guess what? I can't even carry a small knife to protect myself. So keep it German comments to urself. U have plenty going on in Germany. Don't worry bout USA.

[@misspoliticallyincorrect2081]

He came here on a school visa and then refused to go back to his country and during the last eight years hes been arrested for theft, drug trafficking and now sexual assault. My question is why tf was he not sent back after the first charge!?

[@robbybarbey2713]

Because of black privilege...and no one wanted to be labeled a racist..

[@alexsaavedra644]

Because these scum are the backbone of the Democrat Party that contine to weaken Americans and prepare them for servicing and subjugation . Do yourself a favor and train to be strong like your ancestors because this is only the beginning of the Trials and Tribulations. As Shakespeare said " Hell is empty and all devils are here"

[@lavish_1717]

Because of BLM

[@erowry22]

@@robbybarbey2713 wtf are you talking about!!! Hatians get deported all the time! There is no wet foot dry foot policy for them lmao

[@erowry22]

Miss Marilyn i feel like you were asking this question from a criminal vs law abiding citizen stand point...but the racist people jumped on this like white on rice trying to seem important. Black privilege they say lmao wtf is black privilege????

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

As I recall, a white marine in New York DID intervene against an aggressive black man who was threatening people on the subway. With the assistance of two other citizens (black men), the aggressor was subdued and died in the process. The white marine has been charged with murder. Tell me again why people should not be afraid to intervene when Good Samaritans are arrested and charged with murder

[@Hahaha43332]

Lol trying to start a hate crime debate

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

@@Hahaha43332 there really is nothing to debate; the liberal woke D.A.s would rather punish people heroes who protect bystanders than punish criminals. Woke progressives and their liberal enablers poison society-that’s not debatable. But the You Tube censors probably won’t like my facts

[@RamonEspitia-vn4xn]

Yeah, you are so right, technically if you are black or an illegal immigrant, you have all the rights and immunity to commit crimes and don't be prosecuted in this country. And just to let everyone know before they start saying that I am a racist person, I am a half-black/latino male who was born here and did four deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan.

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

@@RamonEspitia-vn4xn Thank you for your service and your candor Sir!

[@dubsounds]

@@RamonEspitia-vn4xn Like your right side is black and your left white?? Cool

[@rockydeleon6629]

The people who ignored it are just as evil as the guy who rapped her period

[@DawnKellyMedia]

Yes!! Thank you for being a kind man.

[@iljenshumilin467]

Wow so I need to help a human that I don't even know help. I'm not gonna risk my life for one human

[@aoibheai8746]

@@iljenshumilin467 It’s called being a decent human being. Freak.

[@iljenshumilin467]

@@aoibheai8746so trashing the earth called being a decent human if humans can't fix big problems and don't care about it why should I care about other humans and there is nothing good for being a human

[@arthurramirez5665]

@@aoibheai8746 They say in debate, as soon as you start insulting, you lost. Learn to discuss respectfully and never be one of those who get emboldened to name call, just because you're behind a screen, kid.

[@Lil_Valor]

The people that did absolutely nothing to stop it should be charged as accomplices

[@chuckysmaria6466]

Lil valor Let me get this straight: (1) You want unarmed civilian to put themselves in harms way. (2) In a liberal city more tolerana towards criminal. Let that sink in. This kind of place have politicians and law enforcement that would penalize you for being a hero.

[@larrytate1657]

@@chuckysmaria6466 and videoing is like even sicker.

[@Lil_Valor]

@@chuckysmaria6466 You are so right. How could I be so wrong, I’m very sorry. Of course the best thing to do in that situation is to stand there and record her being raped.

[@disorderlyconduct6011]

@@chuckysmaria6466 you don't need to be armed to stop that.. A flying fist will get the point across.. And personally I wouldn't care.. I'd take a charge to stop a rape and fight it in court 0 f#&ks given.. But that's just me 🤷‍♂️

[@rfamily2112]

Agreed

[@selahjames1267]

That poor woman is going to need a whole lot of therapy. I wish they could charge the do nothing bystanders with a misdemeanor

[@Yodumeee]

The only other person who should be charged is the immigration judge that didn't deport the animal after multiple arrests including a sexual assault. The JUDGE is the one sworn to protect

[@feliciaboston6365]

If it becomes a crime to sit by and watch a crime I guarantee people will start doing something...so maybe they should get charged for just standing by and watching...

[@feliciaboston6365]

Unless ofcourse if the person has a weapon

[@AuroraColoradoUSA]

@@feliciaboston6365 The best legal minds over the centuries disagree with you... Forcing people to render aid turns into a quagmire. It's good for you fascists though. You can prosecute people for practically anything then.

[@feliciaboston6365]

@@AuroraColoradoUSA shut tf up... we know you just want to commit crimes and piece

[@asdfgggdjflzkjsdfoisjego-jr9vm]

The last few people who interrupted criminal attacks were sued and jailed. DUH

[@insertnamehere9154]

I would have emptied out my pepper spray. Bystanders, criminal... Everyone was gonna get a whiff that day.

[@flyfishing1776]

Blessings to you for being braver than any of the by standers🙏

[@rolexomegaspecialist9411]

Those people that stood by were the same people who looted and burned America down to the ground last year. The piece OS rapist WILL walk, as some liberal boot-licking white apologist on the jury finds him NOT GUILTY

[@503g2]

@@rolexomegaspecialist9411 People should have stepped in no doubt. You are on crack though if you think someone caught in the act and on video with a train full of witness is going to WALK. The rapist is for sure going to get the MAX sentence, what type of drugs are you on?

[@myramorrison2211]

Yes, indeed..

[@kariw.160]

They all would have deserved it!

[@DaveNanan]

I can't believe that no one did anything to help this lady 😢

[@DawnKellyMedia]

Thank you. You have a heart. There is so much hate in this comment section by men, saying they would never help a woman, for disgusting reasons. You are kind. 💓

[@iljenshumilin467]

@@DawnKellyMedia I wouldn't help because I wouldn't give a shit

[@As-qz5lr]

It’s their party who are open borders and support releasing criminals early whilst defunding the police. What do people expect?

[@DawnKellyMedia]

@Grace Awolesi yes!!! That's the thread I saw!! Some dude commented back to me "I wouldnt help because I wouldnt give a shit." Something tells me there are rap1sts in that thread. They hate women.

[@tryme9914]

@@As-qz5lr Stop shooting innocent minorities its all in camera now

[@TheAsianslovetechno]

They should also arrest the passengers sitting next to the emergency button.

[@krizyamz70]

Why?

[@AmorieAudrey]

All of them that watched need to be arrested.

[@clintonkildepsteen3982]

They need to arrest everyone that stood there and just filmed it

[@TheAsianslovetechno]

You can lift up your arm and record on your phone, but you can't press a fucking button? Fine maybe not jail maybe a ticket but something

[@kaylacarter8766]

@@TheAsianslovetechno no jail.

[@brendalaprince8605]

There are a lot of monsters walking amongst us. I don't understand why the people on the train didn't help her. What in the hell is wrong with people.

[@ndahiya3730]

Nothing wrong with the people. They know from experience that the law and the enforcers stand against them when they intervene.

[@fatah496]

Why I should help? To get accused as accomplice?. No thanks, you can insult people like me, but hey we avoid jail with that simple decision

[@jimx45]

Only a healthy minded individual would do nothing about it. Someone that think someone should do something for no gain is the messed up one. You were sheltered to think people should help you for no gain.

[@jimx45]

@@fatah496 You are right in how you feel. One shouldn't help other unconditionally. The only people I can imagine doing something about it is someone that knows the full extent of the police is on his side and would apply as much violance as possible not to help the individual but for their own self-gratification and to have a chance on her body as well when eshe thanks him.

[@trailblazer1047]

Hate Crime.

[@meowmix8751]

And this is why I choose to stay and live in this one horse town. EVERYONE here would have helped her, made him disappear, and if questioned, “never saw him”.

[@buckrogers2546]

My kinda town😉

[@alkokenbalz4078]

Probably aren’t any joggers in your town so…. Dang you are lucky!

[@meowmix8751]

@@alkokenbalz4078 Idk what you mean by that, but I’m not lucky. Things aren’t just granted to us. We make it happen.

[@----.__]

@@meowmix8751 There was a "jogger" a few years back, who was actually just a non-white person going around robbing houses but he told the media he was out "jogging". He was cornered by some civies and the criminal tried to take their gun at which point he got shot. The media was full of "jogger gets shot" type gas-lighting headlines, completely ignoring the fact the guy was on video robbing houses, was miles upon miles from his own neighbourhood, and had committed a crime by trying to take someone's firearm. (had to use "non-white person" instead of the real colour or else this message gets deleted. youtube is trash)

[@spikejones2776]

Thats how a community should act.

[@caldaque7354]

3 min police response time is actually really good. The real question is why none of the bystanders allowed this to go on instead of beating the perp to a pulp.

[@TheWarriorLV]

Shows where our society is...this is scary

[@geebert23]

america is becoming a lawless country and no one care about other people

[@meferswift]

Can't risk getting stabbed or labelled as sexist. I guess, for the men.

[@elmacuelmo6434]

@@meferswift pretty accurate

[@freakjob0]

Probably because if another guy stepped in and beat his ass. The good samaritan would have been labeled a racist and tried as a hate crime. This is the situation our culture has created...welcome to teh shit!

[@araina5896]

The horror... That people could sit back and watch a rap transpire in front of them, just hurts my heart.

[@robbybarbey2713]

They didnt want to be labeled a racist for helping...

[@lavish_1717]

Atleast they’re not racist

[@memememememme5499]

@iris kamberi ????

[@theadventuresoftaco7306]

What f would u have done besides being another victim

[@j.ceasar]

@@theadventuresoftaco7306 ????

[@josephdidonato8973]

You mean like the Marine did in NYC and got arrested and spent over 100k proving his innocence. Nah

[@solesoulsorrow]

If I walked away without doing something, it would bother me for the rest of my life. I'd think about it when I was in the shower or when driving. It would fundamentally change my perception of myself as a person.

[@cyvonn]

Unless he was holding a gun on the people, I just can't understand why they wouldn't help. I just can't understand 🥺

[@meldrickedwards1464]

But overall it's quite confusing, because most videos/articles seem to claim the people watched and recorded what happened. And a few articles claim that report is unconfirmed, or false and one passenger did help.

[@theultimate6542]

You’d live

[@petscraftsandwonderfulthin1279]

Good. Means you still have a concious.

[@cyvonn]

@Hyrenapth Ok.

[@heartstrings7814]

I would have had to intervene even if that meant being physically hurt by the pervert. I am in my 50's and as a child of 5-7 was molested by an older neighbor. There is no damn way I could just sit there and watch or turn the other cheek. If Only 2 or maybe 3 people did something, this lady would have been spared a life of suffering and trauma. This is sick. None of those people should ever be allowed back on the train!!! Not ever!!

[@AuroraColoradoUSA]

Yep. If only women voters would stop rayping their male counterparts at the polls, maybe chivalry would still be alive.

[@idontgiveanf3713]

@@AuroraColoradoUSA to compare rape to someone not voting your way is disgusting

[@AuroraColoradoUSA]

​@@idontgiveanf3713 You are a liar and/or you lack reading comprehension. OBVIOUSLY "chivalry" is not referring to the perpetrator. You disempower and alienate your male counterparts, then you expect them to come to your rescue. What if the perpetrator had a gun? You believe in autonomy in marriage but you expect devotion from strangers.

[@j.ceasar]

@@AuroraColoradoUSA If you dont know what you're talking about, dont talk at all. Be quiet.

[@eddyvideostar]

@@AuroraColoradoUSA And psychologically raped in the call center offices, where all the cards are beheld by them to pull aces against the males, when the deck is *always stacked!*

[@samantham2204]

I’m in shock. I am a girl with zero upper body strength but I really think I would have tried my best to help. No way I just sit there while someone is attacked.

[@bigpumpkin49]

You don't need upper body strength to press a button. That's all anyone had to do....

[@thelastchristosever8910]

Hmm, ppl are satanists these days

[@bigmountain1970]

You accuse a Blk person then you’ll be called racist. We’ve seen ppl lose their jobs, friends and publicly smeared for calling the police.

[@bigpumpkin49]

@sqiudbilly thirteen intervention doesn't have to be confrontation though so you don't need to go to jail....who cares what color you are? You think ppl gonna hold that over your head for helping someone in need??? Damn I hope not smh...

[@bigpumpkin49]

@@bigmountain1970 yeah for BS! Come on sir, please don't use that excuse in this situation. It's all being recorded so there would be justification for you calling then. This is not an expired coupon scenario. We both know why some ppl ended up in those situations. No employer or otherwise could hold that against you....

[@TheDJFAA]

I don't believe it. People just watched. What kind of disgusting people where on the train,‽

[@장현우-c4w]

Yeah its disgusting

[@TheDJFAA]

@@CRAZYHORSE19682003 we know you would

[@joshgordon2484]

Dimocrap steeple watched.

[@aliengreeter]

democrats or just people afraid to help because what democrats will do to them

[@jacoburena1131]

Maybe because every time someone did intervene before they were arrested

[@MaMaTArtlife]

Everyone of the passengers that stood by should face charges, and the ones that video taped it should face harsher charges. How dare you as a human being just sit by and watch, let alone video tape it. Worthless excuses for human beings.

[@meferswift]

Help = accused , jail Not helping= charges, jail

[@sjoerdvelzen8255]

They should face charges for violating what law exactly? There is no such law in the US that forces someone to help during an emergency.

[@meferswift]

@@sjoerdvelzen8255 they will just ran away from trouble anyway.

[@MaMaTArtlife]

@@sjoerdvelzen8255 there is a law for filming violence and rape.

[@codimarie090]

It is extremely sad that ppl are so quick to pull out their phones when something goes wrong! Everyone is so concerned with being the one to film it and the potential to go viral. Maybe in this case they thought they wanted to have sex on the train not realizing they pair didn’t know each other... The more I think about it tho... if other ppl where in arms reach how could you not notice... the man stripping and trying to get her pants down... or her pushing him away? Maybe she wasn’t screaming that she didn’t know him? I dk I wasn’t there to know exactly what happened. If she was screaming and it was very visible that she didn’t know this person and ppl still watched... okay yes they are a special type of person not to step in.

[@eljay4k]

I can guarantee you that every passenger in that train had a phone in their hand during this whole incident and not one used it to even call for help. Wtf is wrong with this country

[@Ahopelessromantic]

They did ! It came out that they did

[@HelloThere-jr6gd]

Its the liberal way. You think that would have happened in a small country town?. Guy would have been shot on the spot and buried where no one could find him.

[@eljay4k]

@Anthony ridge You sound crazy bro. This woman was assaulted, simple as that

[@eljay4k]

@@HelloThere-jr6gd I don't believe this would happen in most small towns... Liberal or conservative.

[@eljay4k]

@@Ahopelessromantic Thank you for restoring a little of my faith in humanity 🙏🏽

[@tngardener231]

Please tell the whole story. He is also an illegal here on an Visa that expired in 2015, arrested on drug charges and on sexual assault charges and then let go ) The people on the train watching this are cowards and every news channel that doesn’t tell the whole story are also cowards.

[@Findaway2day]

It doesn't matter that he's illegal and on an expired Visa. What is important here is that human beings watched a woman being raped right in their space and did nothing. His status is no excuse for these dead souls behavior.

[@JovaGoose]

@roberta legeee, it is important actually, those bystanders are surely scum but these sanctuary cities keeping worthless humans like this in the country despite repeated offenses is awful. Should have been deported long ago, if you come here illegally and can’t abide by laws send them back!!

[@sauljahboi5965]

@@Findaway2day it absolutely matters. How can authorities bitch about the social contract and people protecting each other? When they greenlight and enforce policies that can't reliably keep proven dangerous people behind bars or out of the country?

[@carlisawilliams5284]

@@JovaGoose Even If He Was Not An Illegal It Would Still Be A Rape. You Have Another Agenda That You Need to take up at another time this was a rape regardless that's what needs to be addressed. He may be an Illegal but he is first a low down dirty individual. And the fact is: all of those aren't Illegal.

[@carlisawilliams5284]

@@sauljahboi5965 You Too Sir Have Another Agenda. Had This Guy Been An American. He would still be a low down dirty individual whom raped a woman on a train. And that is the first matter at hand. And other people watched is the second matter.

[@imageno2293]

Absolutely disgusting

[@tonyahenry5198]

It’s sad that people will record everything but won’t help no one 💔💔💔💔

[@pennyck9468]

I am disgusted by that. Then post it with some fake empathy! The are the same as the guy that committed the crime.

[@elmacuelmo6434]

@@pennyck9468 NO,why would you even consider labeling them as bad as the man who committed the crime what is wrong with you

[@pennyck9468]

@@elmacuelmo6434 How do you sit there and watch a woman scream for help for atleast 8 minutes and do nothing instead pick up a phone and record? Sounds like human of the year to you? You see nothing wrong with that picture?

[@elmacuelmo6434]

@@pennyck9468 YES I see nothing wrong with this picture Penny, because 1.) Look at the update on the case Penny people actually helped so the whole everyone sat there case is utter bs, and 2.) Why tf would I risk my life for a person I ain't even cool with. Have you seen the recent allegations that has dropped over recent years?! People literally getting accused for HELPING women nowadays. Most you getting out of me is a phone call to the police(which btw also happened) and imma sit my ass down and play pokemon unite on my phone. You got me messed up if you think imma play superman and beat a man's ass for her. Like wtf

[@shreer.6901]

@@elmacuelmo6434 What about calling 911? What if it's someone from your family or friends or you yourself i'm pretty sure your response at that time 'll not be the same. Sitting behind a screen and writing this BS is so easy but when reality comes to knock on your door step then the same you'll be calling for help from strangers.

[@shirleyg9225]

These people who did nothing are not even human anymore. They belong to the enemy!

[@vernonsanders371]

exactly 💯

[@Gay.Muhammad]

kzbin.info42_ixyBIMuI?feature=share wanna get sued for helping vvoman? I certainly dont want to. Also they are strong and independent "Men are trash" "men are pigs" So you want to call me all that and then expect me to help you? NO Also nobody is obligated to help anyone

[@crystalhelton6726]

@@Gay.Muhammad hey genius no one's saying that someone had to put their self in physical harm to help her but what's the excuse for nobody calling 911 or septa security for 40 minutes and instead just pulling out their phones and recording it instead for views. That's what's unacceptable and effed up about all the people who did nothing.

[@Gay.Muhammad]

@@crystalhelton6726 its complete on their choice tho Their body their choice They chose not to call respect it Recording it was bad i can agree but i don't think not calling 911 was bad

[@crystalhelton6726]

@@Gay.Muhammad if you think calling the cops when a crime is being committed should be a personal choice then you are mentally unstable. In America if a crime is being committed and you just stand there watching and recording it and then do not call 911 and report it, you can be charged with conspiracy. You do not have the freedom to choose to not call the police. If the cops wanted to they could charge all those people on the train who just sat there watching and recording it, and that's the law. Feel free to look it up, and get some help.

[@thelightofthebodyispineal7137]

They watched because they were glad it wasn’t them, and didn’t care.

[@louellarobertson8074]

It could well be 1 of them next because it will be someone...There's something about this type of vile behavior that set off chain reactions...I feel so bad for her...I pray she gets the help she need to get through this...Peace and Blessings to everyone...

[@90210Skye]

They were afraid he may be armed or something.

[@NewYorkFloridaMan]

They were just a bunch of chumps and scumbags.

[@supersonic1920]

They cared, but they were afraid they were worried that they'd be called toxic masculine

[@w4r7h0g8]

so they didnt even called the police?

[@getsome4363]

Why should anyone help when you had AUS marine veteran? Help everybody on a train car from a crazy. Individual threatening passengers daily and throughout the trip that US veteran marine took matters into his own hands to protect others. And now he's in jail. That's why nobody wants to help. The system is for the criminals, not the law-abiding citizens.

[@bullballsallday]

You're referring to Daniel Penny. Poor guy. Did the right thing, and now he's on trial.

[@ncredbird3998]

This sickens me beyond words. She needed help not to be ignored. To the victim, I am so sorry all those around you failed to help and protect you...I also pray for you, be strong, stay strong.

[@ManwithThemoon542]

75% of all convicted rapist, grew up in a fatherless home. So the left and BLM encouraging destroying the nuclear family... not good

[@scottandrews947]

Sounds like the lady was drinking.

[@scottandrews947]

@K It does. She should have been more careful. These kinds of things happen all the time to those who are not paying attention to their surroundings.

[@CanadaBoyRocks66]

This who didn't help should die

[@kaylee3867]

That why it's important for females to carry weapons of any form cause these f up folks ain't gonna protect you

[@michaelcritchlow4373]

The fact that we have to emphasize helping people in need has shown how far down the drain Philadelphia his come.

[@shon7425]

It's not just Philly. It's nation wide

[@Darth_Vader.731]

I mean, Philly was already a trashy wasteland before.

[@lisabradford8180]

@@shon7425 nation wide, world wide, every fucking where. disgusting doesn't begin to describe this world we live in🤬🤬🤢🤢

[@philadelphian7814]

Society as a whole

[@jimcook2715]

Lived in Philadelphia 2 years and have returned often I just visited 10/21 I'll never return

[@chocodogz1324]

This gets me so angry, a guy having the audacity to even touch a woman without their permission. I'm pissed that whenever I get older I'm going to have to protect myself from these kind of people in this cruel world.

[@Gay.Muhammad]

kzbin.info42_ixyBIMuI?feature=share wanna get sued for helping vvoman? I certainly dont want to. Also they are strong and independent "Men are trash" "men are pigs" So you want to call me all that and then expect me to help you? NO Also nobody is obligated to help anyone

[@mgtowproperties]

@@Gay.Muhammad And let’s not forget they have women’s intuition Apparently it didn’t work so to tell her not to get on the train

[@hanahduriyah]

@@Gay.Muhammad 1. Different ways to help women u don’t have to fight:) 2. When women say they are independent they are talking about Providing for they selfs 3. Women say that to men that acted and think like you so your not making it any better 4. if you sit and just watch you are also a part of the problem that's like sitting and watching someone getting murdered and not getting help 5. YOU ARE A COWARD. AND MEN LIKE YOU NEED TO LEAVE FROM THIS EARTH :) The fact that there are so many men out there that agree sickens me. Y'all don't protect women, y'all watch, don't get help, and make rape jokes and then attacked women and hurt them like ew this generation of men suck I bet you GENZ?

[@Gay.Muhammad]

@@hanahduriyahtalk shit idc i aint helping a random vvoman ill for sure help a man The only woman i care about is my mom and she's always home whenever she goes out its either with me or my dad so if this happens when we are out im 6'5 and 214 lbs so yeah its either me or the abusers alive at the end of the day Idc about any other vvoman and you cant change it with yo shaming tactics

[@hanahduriyah]

@@Gay.Muhammad wait so u will help a Random Man tho?

[@GP-nr2fm]

Why would anyone intervene? The NYC DA charged the marine Daniel Penny who took action when Neely was harassing passengers. No one else would be themselves into trouble after Daniel Penny. Sad!

[@kiki5176]

As a girl myself, when I try to imagine myself being there, I'll honestly say that I'd be really scared to directly touch/push him with my bare hands BUT I wouldn't be able to stand there and let him continue harming the woman. I'd AT LEAST find an object or something to push him off with and use to defend us! Maybe these witnesses were scared like I'm imagining I would be, but it's really NO EXCUSE to be present during the act and not step in. Especially when there were multiple witnesses. And some were even at arms length away from him??

[@cindylee1499]

Woman to woman never leave your house again unless you have something that you can defend yourself with. Your life is valuable protect it no matter what. You see others may not help you. Stay safe out there ❣️

[@Arya-pe1dr]

I get what u r saying but the reporter says that emergency call buttons r there that r on all subway cars that alerts driver to contact police. So, no one did that which is inexcusable. Secondly, those standing near by were recording the attack with their phones for entertainment purposes, again is inexcusable!

[@sweettee6827]

I hear you sweetie and commend you for your honesty. That being said, those folks who whipped out their phones to record this crime when they literally could have pushed a button on a call box is absolutely ridiculous and sad. They weren't scared... they stood by and recorded it. Disgusting.

[@eddyvideostar]

@@Arya-pe1dr: This is true; however, the fear of the situation is understandable -- but the recording on the cell phones is diabolical -- bad.

[@PsychoKillertheGame]

Ah but the issue is she is white i would guess..it wud be racism to stop him.

[@howieharding344]

Everyone on that train should feel less of a human for standing there and doing nothing

[@dragon5568]

LESS THAN HUMAN! I'm pissed!

[@Labyrinth6000]

Nope, they don’t have to do anything. That city voted for less police and there’s nothing for men to gain. He could be accused of racism if he stopped the “grapist” or the victim could sue him. That’s the society you wanted, you reaped what you sowed. This will be happening more often.

[@blacklyfe5543]

I heard they recorded her that's even worse

[@usa4ever711]

Remember Democrats, YOU BUILT THIS!!! YOU, YOUR "LEADERS" WANTED TO DEFUND THE POLICE AND RELEASE CRIMINALS ONTO THE STREETS WHILE VILIFYING THE POLICE AND CALLING CRIMINALS HEROS! Get ready for more crazy stuff to happen in your new woke reality!!! OH and your forced vaccinations causing police resignations en-mass along with resignations of many other public servants will only exacerbate things!

[@zerubbabelsbridge]

Where was the sisterhood and united phemonists when you need them?

[@gigi-dh9im]

The trauma of the attack is devastating - and imagining how it would feel to watch other people watch you get attacked and do nothing

[@mrjones4249]

That would multiply one's trauma, anger, and disgust. That was an excellent point.

[@infinidominion]

Or fight back

[@joebidens_touchyhands9477]

Awww maybe females need to take defense and their safety more seriously. Instead of being glued to the tv watching bachelorette AND love n hiphop AND dancing with the stars. And on youtube twerking and doing make-up tutorials.

[@gigi-dh9im]

@@joebidens_touchyhands9477 u seem thoughtful

[@joebidens_touchyhands9477]

@@gigi-dh9im Thanks ✌😺😸

[@rafaelchiclana4716]

It sad people don't care for each other. Lord have mercy on us

[@leehines1260]

This is beyond sad!! People watched this shit show. And did nothing to stop it!! My prayer of healing is with the lady.

[@Wooley689]

Because to many times now it is the norm for the people who step up get arrested and more trouble than the perpetrator does.

[@pp3k3jamail]

💥Well modern day women always say they can take care of themselves 🤷🏿‍♂️

[@----.__]

The people that help are the ones who end up in trouble. Moreover, I've been told time and time again that violence is toxic, and I shouldn't interfere with "black culture" otherwise it's racist. So what do you want? To be treated like the fragile beings you are, and acknowledge that men are needed in this world? Or are you the sort who thinks women can do anything a man can, and men are no longer needed? Because if you look at the media, if you look at the news, if you look at social media, there's a VERY loud message that men need to sit down and shut up and let women go about their business. See what the latest wave of feminism has created? Probably about time for YOU to tell those types of people to sit down and shut up, unless they represent you?

[@TheRock2004]

@@----.__ this isn’t black culture, this was probably some foreign African or Caribbean.

[@----.__]

@@TheRock2004 Is the Caribbean and Africa not black? I'm not saying all blacks are like this, I'm just playing on the ridiculousness of today's media and social justice warriors where if you even point out a black person committing a crime you're accused of racism. Seen any joggers lately..... lol Peace m8

[@alimay8344]

I would rather face the consequences of trying to help than live with the knowledge I did nothing. Sounds like the 'bystander effect'. The more people who witness, the less personal responsibility we each feel.

[@meferswift]

You do you. Maybe u are one of the more kind person.

[@goldmanbobby9039]

Sounds like she cooperated!

[@Drexxaal]

Same n do! I know no1 would stand up 4 me but that won't make me act like most people. People r assholes, no excuse, bystander effect, more like worthless piece of shit in effect!

[@lordofdarkness457]

Wow a bunch of EMO bois trying to wear the tough guy mask.

[@bentonrp]

There are certain things I can't stand, and I would have stepped in too, knowing I could be falsely accused of assault, or prejudice, or whatever lies. Because trauma is the biggest thing here, and I unfortunately have enough experience to know that allowing that to happen would be reliving the worst of it all over again. Just speaking for me, it's better for me at this point in life, to pay for an awful crime that I didn't commit than not pay for one that I had allowed.

[@Ann-kg1zd]

Nobody does anything anymore but pull phones out and record. Glad I left that city years ago. People should be ashamed

Just like the European train station bombing no one wanted to be called a racist for calling someone out

[@envy1rDowney]

Blame modern feminism. Biological sex means nothing in 2021.

[@Oahspe]

Same here man. I escaped Philly about 6 years ago. Good riddance to bad rubbish.

[@Oahspe]

@ eh, as someone who took that train 5 days a week for years, I can tell you that's not the issue, because 98% of the people on that train were... melanin-rich.

[@Ann-kg1zd]

@Brendan Sullivan So what's your point

[@mikeifyouplease]

In California, if you interrupt an individual committing an illegal act, the odds are very good that it will be YOU, who gets arrested. and charged. So honestly, why risk it?

[@fhxs]

“Call the police” “We’re talking about less than 3 minutes” Doesn’t matter this woman will be mentally scared for life. Rape alone makes people want to commit suicide. Imagine in front of people while they’re recording & not even attempting to help..

[@theprofessionalunprofessio7883]

So traumatic to know you cant trust people to help

[@ibjayb9785]

Exactly! I'm mortified!

[@DMONEY7720]

3 mi.n response time after Septa was notified the rape was 6-8 minutes while a bunch of cowards recorded it and did absolutely nothing. They will be charged as accomplices.

[@alexsaavedra644]

Just typical Democrat city. Time to purge the unclean

[@DMONEY7720]

@@alexsaavedra644 you really don't know what you are talking about been a Dem city for decades but now people are trained to ignore other citizens in danger. Thank 9/11, before that someone would have stopped it and dropped that guy in between the cars while the train was moving. Too many pussies these days what you get when you rasie kids to become adults who stand for nothing. That"s what kind of population participant awards get you.

[@missuptonogood3655]

America is getting weirder and scarier by the day, some days it almost seems to me like it’s a different planet.

[@clarenceeugene9692]

We've been in steady decline for at least four or five decades. It's just now that people are looking around and asking "What the hell happened?" Personally, I believe most of the blame lies with the Democrat Party. They are so motivated by their hate and resentment for this country, its traditions, and its people that they will do whatever it takes to destroy it. They are the ones creating the environment that embraces criminality and that allows negative behavior.

[@hi-sj1gh]

lol

[@MurakamiTenshi]

Don't live near big cities... it's getting bad

[@OGDelulu]

​​@@MurakamiTenshiThere's a reason I left detroit with only the clothes on my back. I left everything and fled.

[@ginaj617]

I know you can almost feel it

[@sweetnaomi56]

The scariest thing is how people behave when they're part of a crowd...

[@friscofe]

Whew. Scary, but true. Humans still are coming up with ways to baffle me 😔

[@eduardochavacano]

social media! They probably live stream the incident or try to tale a good video for Instagram or Tictoc.

[@simpbeforeusleep]

I’m not helping anyone I don’t know, I could be the only one on a train and if I see shit going I’m moving to the other end and calling the police assuming I have a signal

[@davidcabreonmunoz6258]

Tell me, why risk my life for someone who wouldn't do the same for me?

[@jonathanjohnson9611]

@@eduardochavacano Show me where social media touched you

[@spiritualinsiderr]

I hope she’s healing

[@joeyzasa7383]

Welcome to our society where nobody bothers to intervene and would rather record it or Livestream it. 🤬🤬🤬

[@dtaylor2647]

This is what comes from proper programming.

[@merkcityboy834]

Sick ppl out here what happened to this country..

[@alexsaavedra644]

This is typical Democrat city. Full of degenerates and the unclean

[@DJCrisisUK]

In America yea, you guys live in a strange bubble.

[@joshuasmith6346]

Surprised i didnt hear world star!!!

[@justmyopinion7764]

"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."

[@Chrizpl]

Edmund Burke ,one of my favorite quotes

[@DigitalDirigibles]

There were no good men there.

[@steelhere5519]

There are no good men.

[@she4136]

Indeed. Our men, across the board, MUST step up.

[@bellavampirella]

There are no good men.

[@unapologeticallyBlack414]

I have officially lost all hope in humanity.

[@theultimate6542]

Just now?

[@yashaikha7324]

I’m sorry but all of the world is not like this it’s mainly America whose people have become atheistic individualists strung out on drugs who give guns to their civilians without any moral agreement or guidance n care more abt their criminals then the victims

[@seanstoner8900]

Trust me I have seen worse from humans not just in America but around the world

[@yashaikha7324]

@@seanstoner8900 I don’t trust you if bad stuff happens around the world it’s mostly isolated The society in America is weird and selfish almost sadist too

[@seanstoner8900]

@@yashaikha7324 lol you have never been around the world you live in a bubble I have seen worse stuff than this trust me

[@ExposeFlyersDotCom]

This why girls should support the 2nd ammendment

[@hellogoodbye1309]

Tf this has to do with the second amendment

[@pimpinace_175]

@@hellogoodbye1309 ok libturd get grape then

[@brandi17able]

The very least these people could have done is called the police. The septa employee did it smh

[@exitscreaming]

Do we know if this was a Hate Crime ?

[@bellojune]

Fuck calling the police we jumping his ass idc how big he is see this is why I am licensed to carry because you can't trust others to help you gotta help yourself they would rather take out a phone & record for social media than actual step up & help but let it had been them or one of their loved ones they would be outraged if no one helped them

[@kingcosworth2643]

People get attacked (not necessarily physically) often for calling the police on somebody Black, regardless if they are in the middle of a crime, they see it as racist. And I imagine this 'code' would be strong in Philly.

[@sircasm6578]

This is the world we live in. When the 5:00 news people have to tell you you should probably intervene. Grotesque

[@wardaddy6002]

Hey I mind my own business.

[@animeslayer6817]

Well minding your own business isn't the right thing to do in that situation.

[@NewYorkFloridaMan]

@@wardaddy6002 spoken like a true chump

[@rasheemthebestfirstone3274]

@@wardaddy6002 so if your mother or daughter were in that position what would you do

[@wardaddy6002]

@@rasheemthebestfirstone3274 That would be the definition of my own business.

[@ms.ferretmanthing2404]

I see a lot of Americans in related stories say stuff like "I cant intervene, what if I get hurt myself.", It's honestly the most selfish response one can come up with and to see that people apply that mindset to seeing someone getting r*ped right infront of them.. it's mind blowing

[@Han-Solo459]

In Rome... they would put Men, Women and children in the arena with wild beasts and professional gladiators. As they were being slaughtered... orgy would break out in the stands. The world is doomed. The Lord of Israel is blessed forever.

[@aquarose9053]

@carnage wow I agree and I even see some comments blaming this animal's assault on feminism, as if women weren't sexually assaulted before the feminist movements. They forget that one of the catalysts for the movements were heinous crimes such as this one being done to women while no one interfered.

[@india6299]

Honestly it’s like if you are a coward just say that.

[@Gay.Muhammad]

kzbin.info42_ixyBIMuI?feature=share wanna get sued for helping vvoman? I certainly dont want to. Also they are strong and independent "Men are trash" "men are pigs" So you want to call me all that and then expect me to help you? NO Also nobody is obligated to help anyone

[@daikon267]

i think the arguement works well, unfortunately im not one to talk, i deal with social anxiety and no matter what situation im in, i wont be able to speak

[@auralightrom7022]

Bet $10 that if it was a dude, it wouldn't even be acknowledged let alone making headlines.

[@aucklandsadventures]

But But, “Wait for Police” and “don’t intervene” and “You Don’t Need A Gun”….

[@phillygrunt2154]

What is, brainwashing sheep thinking deepstated into the voter community via democrats?

[@socalraie]

Police need to make up their mind do they want people to step in possibly get arrested or sued or call and wait for police

[@LL-vj5yp]

Bingo.. the public has been beaten with accusations of racism. They won’t do a thing.

[@severetruth4063]

No, wait for a "social worker". Maybe he'll do the same to them onsite. Smh. 🙄

[@shanicehagert]

I rather get caught with my gun than caught without its😷

[@preciselyd]

This is disturbing, troubling and my heart goes to this lady who experienced this horrific vile attack. I am sickened just hearing no one did nothing.

[@maxf223]

As a white guy yeah I woulda just watched or moved seats too We all know what happens, I step in, save this girl's life. Everyone thanks me for about 5-10 minutes. And then the next day I wake up to an angry mob outside my house calling me racist, and how I should have waited for the police and how it was racist to punch him in the face and how it was practically a public lynching, oh and now I lost my job, and now I'm blacklisted from working in my industry again, my life, my career, and my family is ruined all because I tried to do the right thing. Nah, I'm good on all that. Moving seats it is.

[@preciselyd]

@@maxf223 Your comment is one great sadness. But it is the reality of how many think. I have heard a statement similar to yours from people of different backgrounds. It is worry that not one person alerted the law enforcement especially if uncomfortable and the reasons are similar like the ones you have mentioned. My conscious could not let me sit, move or watch this dramatic ordeal. I would intervene whether it was a White person, Asian person, Black person, Mixed person, any person irrespective of background. It is a huge concern the Public have reacted this way and feel they can't intervene similar to the reasons you have given. Anyway thank you for your honesty.

[@preciselyd]

@Colonel Cracker what a statement 🧐🤔

[@preciselyd]

@Uncle Jasper This is very disturbing comment. Sorry to read in accordance to what you have written people have been sabotaging your progress. But "enjoy it" I have a huge problem with this part of your statement. My hope is that whenever a person is in need or encounters an ordeal that you are not in the same environment. Your comment is troubling and how I have processed what you have written is that you enjoy others pain and misery. I may have misconstrued what you have stated. But your message radiates red flags all over.

[@Moodboard39]

Lol would you ??

[@sully7597]

Diversity is our strength

[@ilove_dr.pepper.]

All I can think of is her begging everyone for help and her thought process knowing she was not getting saved. I cannot imagine.

[@Gay.Muhammad]

kzbin.info42_ixyBIMuI?feature=share wanna get sued for helping vvoman? I certainly dont want to. Also they are strong and independent "Men are trash" "men are pigs" So you want to call me all that and then expect me to help you? NO Also nobody is obligated to help anyone

[@jaycensangel.304]

@@Gay.Muhammad No one said a man specifically had to help, any person in general could have helped. I swear ppl like you are obsessed with being victims, yall stay trying to make ish about yourselves stfu.

[@Gay.Muhammad]

@@jaycensangel.304 how am i being a victim? Lmfao, i dont care about women and what happens to them,doesnt matter if it's rap3 ,i only care about my mom and she's always home but if this happens when we're out im sending the abusers to coma since im 6'5 and 214 pounds they really stand no chance until they have a weapon idc im ready to die to for my mom ,any other women idc Im just saying every man should stop helping random stranger women

[@jaycensangel.304]

@@Gay.Muhammad Why are you sitting here compla*ning about men helping women when no MAN or WOMAN helped her. No one is saying that a man should have helped her but your acting like someone did, you just want to start stuff for no reason. No one cares if you don't care for protecting other women except your mom, that's great for you. Your in random ppl's comments typing your garb*ge. Do not expect women to help men either then. Men cause the most cr*me and are stronger than women and your really gonna be an a*s and not help just cause she's a woman...smh. Your petty dude, I don't think any woman would feel protected by you anyways.

[@jaycensangel.304]

@@Gay.Muhammad Also...how would you get sued for helping out a woman in danger??? Your being dramatic, just say you h*te women and move on.

[@cawilson5357]

There comes a point when we will have to hold JUDGES, AND PROCESUTERS responsible for not fulling their duties. This man should have never committed this crime.

[@myapologiesmissgurl5069]

Yep. Should have deported his ass back in 2017 smh

[@icebergslim4661]

FULFILLING NOT FULLING DUNCE.

[@dtaylor2647]

You are sooooooo right!!!

[@theadventuresoftaco7306]

Wtf is he doing in the country

[@Arbysroastbeefjuice]

@@theadventuresoftaco7306 Democrats are why he's here. Now someone's life is completely ruined because of it.

[@Riplae420]

I would’ve been trying to fight for myself knowing that nobody else tried to help me .. I feel so bad for her, prayers up for her 🥺

[@AuroraColoradoUSA]

I pray for people who have never even opened the New Testament...

[@valarmorghulis4801]

@@AuroraColoradoUSA or the old testament. The whole bible is predicting the times we are in now

[@В.Т-з2г]

Well, the news is terrible. By the way, you are a very beautiful girl. Greetings from Moscow

[@tomarasmith4459]

Exactly... only 1 of us would have got off that train alive.

[@tomarasmith4459]

@MIDDLE east I wouldn't want someone with your attitude to help me.

[@DarkWinter48]

Ladies, please always carry some sort of protection on public transportation. Carry mace, or a taser, or look into getting a licence to carry but research the laws in your state first. These violent degenerates are getting out of hand.

[@yukikowu5695]

I guess those folks would have failed the “What Would You Do” experiment on NBC…..

[@glorymosbyfloyd3878]

Definitely

[@queque5williams748]

Terribly sad

[@vernamorales2064]

This happened in New York last year but was stopped and the people was furious!!So glad she was helped

[@NewYorkFloridaMan]

Because New Yorkers aren't chumps. Even the softest punks in NY wouldn't sit back and watch something like that. Even the old ladies in NY have balls the size of the liberty bell.

[@A__Mina]

When the dude tried to drag her out? I remember that

[@jimcook2715]

I noticed the kindness empathy and attitude of New Yorkers has changed for the better since 9/11

[@jimcook2715]

@@NewYorkFloridaMan not my point but ok

[@Love-ku6yc]

Wow nobody try to help that woman how could you just sit there in do nothing

[@patimrider]

This totally disgusts me. The "bystanders " should be charged with aiding & abetting. Shameful!

[@anointed913]

Agreed!

[@marquis-_5501]

🥱

[@avatarwarmech]

It's unfortunate what happened to the woman but that's not aiding in abetting the criminal when they had nothing to do with it there's no law in the US they save his crime going on that you have to intervene or call the police

[@MrNote-lz7lh]

@@AuroraColoradoUSA What's funny is that I bet every bystander in that train would have said they'd help an hour before the incident. But yes. There's no way I'd have helped in a far left city like Philly. I'd probably be locked up for a very long time if I did.

[@AuroraColoradoUSA]

You holier-than-thou keyboard white knights are so brave! Just a day late, and of course not there...

But ifyou stopped him you would be arrested and called racist

[@bullballsallday]

Just like Daniel Penny (unfortunately).

[@adrxxanna]

absolutely DISGUSTING. what has this world come to.

[@seanstoner8900]

The world has always been cold and heartless

[@Jademoonx]

@Carol Stop it please, read up on history. Then come back and make logical claims...✌

[@Yoongiswife7]

The crazy thing is a worker that wasn’t even on the train seen it as the train passed by had to call the cops

[@lauriec9183]

The more important issue here is this violent criminal had no fear of consequences for his crime! He knows he will get out of jail with in hours or days to continue his crimes on innocent victims.

[@speedtrap420]

@Laurie Channell You are absolutely wrong. The, single most important issue, other than the rape itself, is the fact that the rapist is from an African nation here on an expired student visa. He has a prior sex crime that was not deemed serious enough to deport him. Tell me something, did you vote for this?

[@briankooker2627]

@@speedtrap420 thank you. if you voted for dems who push sanctuary cities, you are responsible for this woman's rape. every single d voter. every single one.

[@speedtrap420]

@@briankooker2627 I read your comment wrong the first time, sorry.

[@MarsOneBeatz]

You are all wrong & what tf is wrong with all of you? The most important issue here is that a woman who was unable to defend herself was being raped by a man in front of other people and none of those other people did a thing to stop it. Another report even said that some of the bystanders actually took our their phones to record this despicable, felonious act. Screw waiting for the police, these bystanders should have physically stopped this rape as soon as they saw what was occurring. This is not about politics, or race, or immigrants. This is about doing what is right. This is shameful.

[@speedtrap420]

@@MarsOneBeatz No, you are 100% wrong. The rapist should have been deported after his first sexual assault. Get a grip and stop voting the way you do...

[@monforttransport]

She's s strong independent woman, she should have been able to fight him off. After all, men and women are equal in all things. Also who wants to go to jail for potentially killing the perp? We are not super heroes. Im not putting my self in danger for a woman who wouldn't appreciate my efforts anyway.

[@hi-sj1gh]

She never said she was strong, independent, and capable of fighting the criminal. You wouldn't say this if the victim's gender changed. I don't mean men should help her. But it's disgusting to blame the victim this way.

[@YanimariOrtiz]

Your assuming that she is a feminist. It’s like if I assumed your a rapist and all you care is to have sex with any female. Not every female believes what you say. Not everyone is the same. Just like not all men are the same.

[@OGDelulu]

​@@YanimariOrtizAll women assume men are rapists. All women are like that. Women are no longer to be trusted. You abused the system and weaponized sexuality against men. You are the enemy, remember that

[@Wilbur-em1hw]

@@YanimariOrtiz Men are seen as r@pists by society. Women don’t have nice opinions on us and society is quick to kick us while we are down. Men decided it not worth the effort. They can handle themselves and if they can’t too bad.

[@EirikOlsenOfdr]

​​@@hi-sj1ghthe reason why the bystanders didn't help was because, if the bystanders did help the women, you'll be labelled as a racist by the BLM, and you will be jailed for fighting off the criminal, while also being labelled as a creep due to feminism. It is sad, but it's the reality. This has happened before where the man who was a hero gets jailed, I'm not justifying the r*** that has taken place, neither am I supporting it. But that's the reason why the bystanders failed to initiate any action, to avoid getting involved and being arrested by law enforcement agencies and getting locked up behind bars. The justice system, is a joke like all other things.

[@bernicealmonte5149]

They all could have overpowered him…this is Earth…but there are no humans here only monsters.

[@AlmondJoie]

Right?! The monsters are quite literally taking over. This is exactly how the Book of Revelation said it would be. God help us!

[@lovelyblac5481]

Its that shot! Being control probably

[@theultimate6542]

Yep

[@tiathomas395]

Exactly there's no excuse anyways there shouldn't have been only one person thinking to stop him it should be second nature for everyone to intervene and get that man straight off her

[@fatcheeseburger100]

@@tiathomas395 so why all the women ain’t help her then.. stop blaming men y’all did dis to yourselves 😂😂😂 y’all independent and strong right oh ok

[@KurosakiLuvar01]

Just like how everyone stood around as that kid Junior in BX NY was murdered while everyone stood around and watched him bleed to death. I hate people. This is why I don’t care to have kids if these are the people they have to walk by everyday as soon as they get school-age. No thanks.

[@hfrt29]

I never heard that story

[@alexventura544]

Welcome to the real world

[@brianburnett118]

What was anybody going to do with a violent gang chasing junior in that store in the Bronx? There is no comparison of one predator raping a women on a train with people on the train.

[@Killasim1]

This is the most f'd up thing that could ever, someone being harmed in that way and these mfrs watched and did noth'n, I heard some even pulled their phones out to record...I hope he gets what's coming to him, and he suffers in the process.

[@anointed913]

Those that recorded him should be charged as well

[@adriand817]

How you know they watched? They could have been not watching, maybe sleeping or watching a movie on their phone.

[@MrStringpicker]

The DA probably let him go already

[@gracedicken8708]

@@adriand817 yes because I am sure every single person on the train was sleeping. Rape is not a subtle or quiet thing. People would have seen or heard something. You can’t rip off someone’s clothes without other people noticing and you sure as hell can’t subtly rape someone. There is no way no one saw anything

[@FloridaGirl-]

Yah recording it 🤦‍♀️ PLEASE!

[@BeckJoseR]

Be careful, helping could get you in trouble. When people are not criminalized for being good citizens, then maybe people will help. That, and if the good people have the correct "tools" to help.

[@howdyfucker443]

Me personally sir I’m staying out of it. Not worth getting attacked 👍🏻

[@insideout8814]

Ladies, we have got to take self defense, carry a legal weapon like bear spray and even get guard dogs

[@reesejohnson2788]

Facts! Also, get in shape too so they can run. The best defense; is the fight avoided.

[@acat6291]

Also learn to be loud and make a seen no matter how scared acting crazy will give you an advantage

[@p.a.681]

@Hello There You don't seem to have a good head on yours. Women can do all that, but some of them might still freeze and go into shock like the lady attacked here did. And attackers are often armed themselves. Decent people don't stand by and watch while others get hurt. It's everyone's responsibility to not be a selfish pos, but instead help each other. Let's hope YOU don't get brutalized one day while everyone around you doesn't bother to lift a finger.

[@p.a.681]

@@reesejohnson2788 Where would she have run on the train? And the video says that she tried to push her attacker off then went into shock. Being in shape doesn't matter if your attacker is bigger and stronger or if your body betrays you by freezing up.

[@reesejohnson2788]

@@p.a.681 increases chances of survival for the GENERAL person(not her specifically). That’s all I’m saying.

[@sabineholthaus7961]

Another case and example of the mind set: "Lives of others don`t matter."

[@theadventuresoftaco7306]

That's right Not my job I can't carry weapons to protect myself or others. Wtf would you have done besides being a victim too

[@j.ceasar]

@@theadventuresoftaco7306 Then call the cops or press the fucking emergency button.

[@mariaguild2024]

@@theadventuresoftaco7306 You can carry a rock, or some mace, a baseball bat, a lead pipe, a pocket knife.or if nothing else just the two good fists the lord has given you, or take your fingers and poke the guys eyes out..while he is busy.

[@Yt_ShadowBannedme]

@@theadventuresoftaco7306 facts

[@wsosoI]

@@j.ceasar truth

[@rahman3780]

How can you not do anything, are people really that scared???

[@RaKenobi]

Zombies.

[@wmeiggs]

Yes they are. I took the subways every day for years, and people might indeed be paralyzed under those circumstances. Saw some outrageous things on the trains, but one thing I never saw was a good samaritan - not once do I remember ever seeing anyone stand up for anyone else or protect someone else.

[@retsukaioh4571]

10 years ago i helped some woman that was getting mugged, i end with a puntured eye, i almost lose that eye, lose my job cause i have to be on bed 6 months, she dint even say thank to me, dont call ambulance or call a cab, nothing she just left, so in the end, that was really bad for me and could be worse, a lot worse, everybody is a lion on YT, saying how they shoulda have help the woman, i dont shoulda cause i learn the hard way.That plp on the tarin they were smart.

[@meowmix8751]

@@retsukaioh4571 You also let them steal your character if you’re going to let it stop you from helping someone else.

[@zilalibayan6030]

@@retsukaioh4571 helping doesn't need a Rewards that's what it means If someone's needs help and I'm there I'll do sometimes even if the Criminal have Guns

[@lewistorres593]

This is sickening how could you just sit back and do nothing while someone is being raped. Heartless people…..

[@haristhebosniaklion8584]

It breaks my heart that many girls told me i am ugly and that is not even my fault to begin with,trust me i am desperate and wanting some xxx........i CAN understand GUYS who FORCE it with a girl i can and i do but......i do not have the heart to do that.

[@DrGregoryHouseIT]

This is horrifying. It's as if people heard the Kitty Genovese story was debunked and decided to make it true.

[@AlethiaHines]

I'm 59 years old and remember that story very well.

[@mdeborah827]

Was thinking the same thing.

[@dblack8141]

the family should be sentenced

[@merkcityboy834]

Was she related to Vito genovese?

[@WithoutRemorse12]

Some people did call the police and yelled at her attacker in kitty case

[@hybridflu6-810]

I was threatened with arrest and almost shot for calling the cops. The system don't make it easy.

[@HoneyRowland]

The system is messed up. We need to fix it. Thank you for doing something about it.

[@thesanfranciscoseahorse473]

It's all situation dependent. "Just walking away" shouldn't be an option in some situations. The laws should fine people for walking away. Create incentives for people to take action. Something.

[@cgbdfb52]

A concealed carrier could have fixed this.

[@CIVILDEFENSEBUNKER]

And then deal with blm because of "racist" better have a good lawyer.

[@joebidens_touchyhands9477]

Joe Biden says no citizen can arm themselves. Sorry Hall & Oates... No can do. Just call 911, pray, duck. 🤷

[@AlyciaRomeo]

@@CIVILDEFENSEBUNKER you clearly don't understand the stance of BLM. Try researching for yourself, it's not to promote racism. It's to demand equal treatment in spite of race.

[@danbiss87]

Or anyone with a moral compass and a clenched fist

[@joebidens_touchyhands9477]

@@danbiss87 Anyone except you right??? All these I-WOULDVE-DID-THIS's are always in the comment sections. Never out in real life.

[@carylynne6574]

You can hear her scream "NO!" over the intercom call 😢 Yet no one intervened

[@Jason_The_Man]

I’d rather be dead than have to try and live with myself if I’d just sat back and did nothing.

[@philipchampion]

The entire city of Philadelphia just became scum bags in my eyes.

[@mrsx7944]

they always have been

[@mcale8384]

Whenever i see something about or reminds of Philadelphia, this vid will be the first thing that pops in my head

[@philipchampion]

@@mcale8384 yupp me too. I love overgeneralizing. It saves me time.

[@robynvann735]

That fact that people need to be asked to help is beyond my comprehension. Just more proof that humanity is lost!!

[@juliefincham4636]

@MIDDLE east that is BS! You are not a real man!!!

[@TestTest-ei4gi]

The guy was black. There are hate laws in place so the Good Samaritan would have been surely charged. Democrats wanted this, this is the result

[@shad118]

I swear its always the same type of people

[@jeffsharpe5048]

You are so spot on.

[@Secondliferacquet]

Right

[@Christmas_tree90238]

People with mental illnesses?

[@Christmas_tree90238]

Oh Americans?

[@aliengreeter]

@@Christmas_tree90238 Americans? Have you been to France lately? What a stupid comment.

[@tanequagray]

This is so heartbreaking to hear, I'm 43years old and I live in New York, I've been afraid of riding the trains since I was a teenager. Me and my best friend was followed once, and till this day I never take the trains alone. So sad that everyone took videos instead of helping😔😔😔😔

[@glorymosbyfloyd3878]

When I first heard this story, I couldn't believe that happened My thought was that maybe no one noticed or she didn't say anything but to know that people knew what was happening and chose not to do something, anything is heartbreaking 💔 I'm praying for that lady's well being

[@columbusohio72]

You need to wake up if you were suprised

[@glorymosbyfloyd3878]

@Carol Sad truth

[@glorymosbyfloyd3878]

@@columbusohio72 I'm already awake I'm disappointed and sad that something like that happened and some people were aware and just did absolutely nothing

[@jackiepanuco7032]

This reminds me of a time when I was 19 and going home from work. I had just gotten off the train and was walking home. This man who was on the train with me got off and began following me. My gut told me that this man was following me so I began to pick up the pace and eventually sprinted back to the train station because not only was it dark but I figured that if this man tried to do something to me, there would be at least someone in the train station to help me. Boy was I wrong. There was only one man waiting for the train and I tried to stay close to him as possible. As soon as the man chasing me began to get closer to me, I yelled at him to stop following me. The man chasing me was in shock because I yelled and responded “I’m not following you”. The bystander saw and heard this and slowly began to walk away from both me and him. Almost in the verge of tears, I saw the bystander avoid me and it hurt me because I knew that if this man following me did something to me, I was on my own. Thank God there was a bystander in a bike who had seen the man chasing me earlier and came to the train station and asked me if I was okay and even stayed for a couple of minutes until the man chasing me got in the next train and left.

[@phillytwo1five]

So glad the guy on the bike was there! Sad that the other bystander couldn’t be bothered. Just like the Parable of the Good Samaritan, many will not help. But it’s fortunate when the few that do are there when you are in need

[@blueweirdo719]

The fact they just walked away is just fucked up. I’m so sorry that happened to you luckily the guy on the bike was there.

[@ray.4k44]

@@blueweirdo719 hes not obligated to help her sorry if we dont have to do smth we wont

[@stielimusterman3066]

Moral of the story: Don‘t chase women lol

[@Head-or-Dead]

​@@blueweirdo719 It's not fu cked up at all. For over a hundred years we have been told women are strong and independent and don't need a man so these brave men were giving the OP exactly what women say they want. She had a chance to show all these men that women really are brave and empowered and what did she do? Cower behind the nearest man seeking protection. Pathetic.

[@jimx45]

You do not have to take responsibility for a woman that is not obedient to you. Police should do nothing either if those women aren't their property.

[@howdyfucker443]

Yes sir if they are t my property im not getting involved

[@spicypecan]

I want to know who was on that train. We should know who the cowards were!