DIMASH, Lara Fabian & Aida Garifullina - Ti Amo Cosi | Singer Songwriter REACTION

Fantastic performance of Ti Amo Cosi by Dimash Kudaibergen, Lara Fabian and Aida Garifullina. Wonderful performance! To hear more of my music, get contact info and links visit www.calebcoles.com
Instagram @calebcoles1
Facebook.com/calebcolesmusic
www.calebcoles.com
Original Video:
• Dimash Qudaibergen, La...

[@CalebColesMusic]

►► *My first Music Video has just been released! Check it out linked below!* ►► kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpTMiZhsrrOtZqs Thanks for all the support, hope you enjoy :)

[@MartellC.]

Caleb Coles Music Congratulations 🎊🎈

[@CalebColesMusic]

@@MartellC. Thank you so much! :)

[@user-rm4fu3sc2h]

@@CalebColesMusic congrats! Heres the raw fancam. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aoGsY4xnjciXj6c

[@CalebColesMusic]

@@user-rm4fu3sc2h Thanks!

[@Sapsan40k]

Ждём! :)

[@rutakudrjasova1121]

It's completely live and you can check out fan cam version, it's perfect! When come together Dimash,Lara and Aida(top 5 soprano in the world,also prima of the Vienna opera) ,then happen magick!💖

[@JustGotALife]

you can hear background noise in fancam version , he is right!

[@Anatoliy-Karpenko]

МОЛОДЕЦ. Самый радостный здесь Игорь Крутой, собрал кого хотел и представили как хотел.

[@user-hi3ig4hi2o]

Гармония голосов, великолепное трио, браво! Крутой гордится, мы тоже!

[@marinakardash3322]

Калеб, они вживую пели. Это потрясающий концерт и вряд ли это возможно повторить. Скоро ждем новую песню Димаша со словами Лары Фабиан.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Thanks. That will be great !!

[@1061611]

В студии они может и пели живьем, а здесь в лучшем случае, даблтрек, а так это фонограмма. Тем более речь идет о телесъёмке и исполнении на стадионе. Не будьте идиотками!

[@marinakardash3322]

@@1061611 Просмотрите фан записи этого выступления, я подозреваю для телеэфира бла конечно чистка звука, но не более.

[@user-yg6he5zo2w]

@@1061611 я видел любительские видео. Они пели в живую

[@user-uw4nr5ld4n]

@@1061611 те, кто не были на концертах, пишут про фонограмму, а те, кому посчастливилось побывать на них - уверены, что всё по-настоящему. Думаю, что есть смысл доверять свидетелям, а не просто рассуждающим. Была, видела, слышала - восхитительно.

[@verasavitskaya9918]

Thank you for your sincere reaction👌 It was a magical concert. Please see his other performances from this concert: "OLIMPICO", "KNOW", "ULISSE "and"PASSIONE". All videos are available on Dimash's official channel. On February 16, Dimash's world tour in Russia and Europe began. I was at his concert in Krasnodar (Russia). And I can say that Dimash is truly a miracle. I waited so long to hear and see him live, and it was worth it. The emotions are incredible. It's been a few days, and I'm still impressed. The concert was amazing and Dimash's voice touched to the core. I will remember this day for the rest of my life. His voice, upbringing and behavior on stage is something incredible. I advise you to go to his concert some day to see for yourself. It was at a concert in Krasnodar that Dimash performed "War and peace" and "Restart my love" for the first time in a long time. Greetings from Russia🇷🇺 Good luck👍

[@CalebColesMusic]

Thanks I will check them out!

[@n_prg]

@@CalebColesMusic the full version of this concert is available on Igor's official KZbin channel : kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKmpenykjdaUfc0 Enjoy! 👍👍👍👍👍

[@user-un9bn4tf9t]

Калеб, они так и звучали - великолепно! Это шоу было феноменальным!!! Пели все вживую ! на льду - самые титулованные фигуристы- чемпионы России,Европы, мира, Олимпийские чемпионы.... Это был самый крутой концерт!

[@user-uk3do6bs1x]

Я сама видела их репетицию. Днём они репетировали, а в 19- 00 начался уже концерт. Вам действительно нужно посмотреть в Ютюбе фрагменты их репетиций на канале у блогера Crazy Maks. Чтобы не было сомнений.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Yeah that makes sense! Thank for telling me.

[@user-ud3ui5ry1g]

Ооо порадовали!!! Спасибо!!! Трио божественное!!! Димаш как вишенька на торте!!! Браво всем!!! Позже ещё дополню, пока под впечатлением!!!!))))

[@user-qs5fh1vl4u]

спасибо за реакцию. Димаш феномен 21 века. спасибо подписка от меня только из-за Димаша. (Новосибирск)

[@barrichase]

Stunning! So love this song by them. I want a whole album of this trio. Blown away!

[@ryli1860]

До чего красиво ,гармонично поют и великолепное трио из трёх прекрасных певцов .Это неповторимо , божественно .

[@rosangelaruza2550]

Dimash, Aida Garifullina e Lara Fabian fizeram uma apresentação magistral!! Dimash foi um cavalheiro nessa apresentação!! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏽👏🏼👏🏼👏🏿👏🏻🎶🎶🎶😍😍🇧🇷🇧🇷

[@magalissalazar]

beautiful song three great singers

[@raisakim2769]

КОНЕЧНО,200% ЖИВОЕ ИСПОЛНЕНИЕ!!! ПРОСТО ИСПОЛНЕНО НАСТОЛЬКО ИДЕАЛЬНО С ВЫСШЕЙ СТЕПЕНЬЮ ВОКАЛЬНОГО МАСТЕРСТВА,ЧТО У ВСЕХ СНОСИТ КРЫШУ ОТ ЭТОГО ВЕЛИКОЛЕПИЯ!!! А,ЧТО ГОВОРИТЬ О ПРОФИ,КОТОРЫЕ САМИ ПОЮТ И ЗНАЮТ О МУЗЫКЕ И ВОКАЛЕ НАМНОГО БОЛЬШЕ НАС !!!ОНИ,ВООБЩЕ,В ДИКОМ ВОСТОРГЕ!!!

[@CalebColesMusic]

They are great singers! So good live.

[@GS-cg9ig]

👍👍👍🌹

[@user-mb9kn7sw3e]

Игорь Крутой говорил, что это будет живое исполнение, я в интернете видела репетиции, по словам Игоря Крутого Димаш поет только в живую.

[@Yoyo-tk3rb]

Он врет.

[@ju1ietta]

@@Yoyo-tk3rb почему именно он, а не вы? 😆

[@Yoyo-tk3rb]

@@ju1ietta А какой у меня интерес врать? Димаш мой любимый исполнитель.

[@ju1ietta]

@@Yoyo-tk3rb ну да, «очень любимый» - утверждать, что Димаш поёт под фонограмму😆😆😆Какой-то вы неопытный тролль. Плохо у вас получается

[@user-qj3iz9zr8l]

@@Yoyo-tk3rb Крутой сказал, что артистов еле удалось собрать вместе из за плотного гастрольного графика каждого! Утром они отрепетировали, вечером великолепно выступили. Так что, времени на фонограммы точно не было, верю Крутому

[@user-ex2qc4mh1c]

There are no words to describe my feelings!!! Bravo!!!!!!!!

[@rachelvideo2663]

Боже это такие музыканты!!!! Для них исполнить вживую ничего не стоит!!! Это высший пилотаж, высокий уровень мастерства!!!! Здесь все прекрасно!!!!!

[@nacv01]

Este Concierto fue un Homenaje a DIMITRI HVOROSTOVSKY!!!!!!! IGOR KRUTOY hizo muchas composiciones para el Baritono!!! Esta Canción fue interpretada por Lara Fabián, la Soprano Aída Garífulina y Dimitri Hvorostovsky (Barítono). Es en honor a éste último....(fallecido el 22/11/17) que hacen esta canción. Por eso Dimash mantiene en todo el repertorio su voz de Barítono!!

[@jimkelly4573]

I have been watching and listening to you for the past year ever since you attempted to sing SOS as Dimash did. You were the best of the several singers that sang SOS and have an excellent voice with great range. I am an 86 year year old classically trained singer and am also impressed with your knowledge of the mechanics of singing. I also have noted you are taken with Dimash as everyone is including me. He has the best range of any male singer that, I have ever heard. However, I have also noted that no one has the courage to critique him for any weaknesses he has. I first heard Dimash two years ago when he sang SOS and I was blown away. However, in my opinion his artistry is often lacking because of his great range. SOS was written in 1978 by Michael Berger as a eulogy to his young friend that died too early and had a great singing voice with great range. It was deliberately written with enough range that the average singer could not sing it. It was a perfect vehicle to show case the voice of Dimash. However, he sings many songs that do not have such a range and that is the problem. In an attempt to show case his range he will often sing these songs three times once in his lower register, once in his middle register and lastly in his upper register. He does not understand that, high notes loose their wonder if they are all in the upper register. The value of a high note is the comparison with the middle range! This is my opinion and I would love to know yours. Jim Kelly

[@saulek.948]

BRAVO! Какое великолепие голосов! Прекрасное трио! 👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏

[@MegaLana555]

Ну вот и профи музыканты сомневаются это нормально к голосу Димаша невозможно пр и привыкнуть он нас всех удивляет. А в данном просмотре оперное пение. И оно восхитильно и это живой звук мы все восхищались этим не попоюсь сказать театрам высоким исскусивос всех людей которые нам погоовилм это предстовление и огромное всем спасибо запрекраснок наслаждение

[@apashkafromnytnt4475]

Igor Krutoy’s answer - “Dimash sings only live....”

[@pamologyfriday]

Yes there are lots of fancams of this one. Its beautiful. A special Ice dance and opera score all for Igors tribute tv special for Russia. it looks totally spectacular. Di got his dream to sing with Lara. His idol. He said this in a touching afterparty. where he says it was his dream. and Lara is lovely ,says they will do it again. He gives her a sweet hug. Very lovely.

[@gulnarkuz8626]

Bravo, TRIO! Bravo, Caleb! 👏👏👏🔥🔥🔥😍💖🙋🏻‍♀️🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿

[@Samara.3d]

Красивая песня, она услаждает душу, браво!!!!

[@user-sy3sj9tn2b]

Мало кто сейчас уже сомневается в способностях Димаша, но если кто-нибудь всё-таки сомневается, посмотрите конкурс ,,Большая опера,, там Димаш и Сундет Байгожин, исполняют ,, Нотердам Депари,,. Выступления на конкурсах только вживую, нет автотюнов, и.т.д.

[@user-im4jn9rt9n]

Ну почему???????? вас посещают сомнения...почему не верите????????.......думаю вам нужно найти видео с репетициями.....или более правильно будет,это приехать на любой концерт Димаша...его фантастический вокал поразит и вернет вам веру в прекрасное....вы молоды и не нужно подвергать сомнению свио собственные восприятия прекрасного....верьте тому что слышите ... вы же профессионал...неразачаровывайте нас...любим вас и ваши реакции...

[@CalebColesMusic]

Thank you, I only wanted to say what the options were given what I was hearing. I know that Dimash and all 3 singers sing live and are amazing.

[@marinakardash3322]

Потому что профессионалам , знающим как трудно такого достичь, сложно поверить в такое. Но он категорически ничего не говорил, просто ему сложно представить что так гармонично и идеально можно петь, и он знает, что на подобных шоу есть разные варианты исполнения. Тем интереснее наблюдать, когда профессионал понимает, что это исполнение -вживую.

[@Anastasiya-Shtern]

@Chernobyl was Nothing not only in Russia. Half of the performances in the past The American Music Awards was performed to a prerecord. In Chinese TV shows, a prerecord is often used. Some of the world's pop-stars generally perform under the prerecord at their own concerts completely. For Example, Madonna. So this is a common practice all over the world. And in Russia sometimes use playback, but not always. For example, at the last music awards "Victoria" (similar to the American Grammy), all the singers performed their songs live, including Dimash. I didn't expect this. Or in the TV show "Evening Urgant", singers often sing live. So it happens in different ways.

[@user-wk7sn3kl7j]

@@marinakardash3322 Оперные певцы всю жизнь поют В ЖИВУЮ! - это норма! А в отношении эстрадного певца кое кого гложат сомнения?! Димаш имеет классическое образование по классу ОПЕРНОЕ ПЕНИЕ ! Так в чём проблема?

[@marinakardash3322]

@@user-wk7sn3kl7j Про оперных певцов Вы правы, и у Димаша есть классическое образование. На эстраде, увы не всегда поют вживую, а некоторые певцы по собственной инициативе часто используют фонограмму. Надеюсь с приходом Димаша на эстраду эта ситуация измениться в лучшую сторону. Также некоторые не могут поверить, что так хорошо можно петь без искусственной обработки. Хотя, если честно, то и с искусственной обработкой никто до Димаша так петь не мог, и сейчас не может. Что касается самого Димаша, то для него хорошо вживую петь не проблема, а удовольствие. В интервью он говорил что любит петь, а не съемки, клипы. Учитель Димаша сказал, что обладая хорошей техникой можно петь долгие годы совершенствуя вокал, сохранив голос.

[@spartak343]

Angels 🎶

[@barbaraelliott3510]

You should also enjoy Dimash and Aida perform Ulisse at the same Igor Krutoy concert. It is on Dimash's channel.

[@CalebColesMusic]

I'll watch it :)

[@user-tu6dr5sb8z]

@@CalebColesMusic By the way in this song (Dimash and Aida) Dimash sang with the baritone voice as well except his last note (could not keep a style? :))

[@JasminGardenia]

@@CalebColesMusic Please react to it 😊❤

[@Tricia_K]

Please, please react to it! Very few reactors have, and it's a real pity...

[@dkr7517]

Yes he should!!!

[@dnn32]

I believe they were singing live. My reasoning is that at the end the three kept going at that last note and even the choir conductor reacted to it, Igor even raised his eyebrow as "keep the melody on".

[@JerryEmanuelson]

This concert was at the VTB Ice Arena in Moscow on November 3, 2019. It was not televised on Channel One Russia until January 2. That song was written by the same songwriting team that wrote Olimpico (Ogni Pietra). Igor Krutoy wrote the music and Lilia Vinogradova wrote the lyrics. This song was written at least ten years ago. The male part was was originally sung by Dmitri Hvorostovsky, who died of a brain tumor two years before this concert. Earlier in the concert, however, Lara does a duet with a quasi-holographic image of Dmitri, who appears to be standing on a platform above the orchestra. The video and audio quality on the Channel One Russia broadcast (as released on KZbin in January) was not as good as the video and audio quality on the subsequent KZbin videos (released shortly after the January television broadcast) by Dimash and by Igor Krutoy.

[@JerryEmanuelson]

Igor Krutoy's KZbin video of the complete 2 hour concert is at kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKmpenykjdaUfc0 The Lara/Dmitri duet starts at 51 minutes into the concert. That duet also features an ice skater who is not there, but who still casts shadows from each of the 4 spotlights shining on him. I believe that this is supposed to be a tribute to Dimash's late friend, ice skater Denis Ten.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Thanks for that info, I didn't know any of that. Really cool to hear about who wrote the song and more about the concert. Thank you!

[@MsLucy4ever]

@@JerryEmanuelson Thank you! I had not watched the whole show before, it was a wonderful spectacle, high quality music and visuals. I did not know that Mr. Krutoy also sings 😃, I loved his duet with Lara performing "Les feuilles mortes"👍💐🎼

[@user-mr7mr9xb4o]

It was a concert in honour of Igor Krutoy's annivesary. He is 65. Actually, his birthday is in July, but the concert was shown on January 2, 2020 on Russian TV.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Oh that makes a lot of sense. Thanks for letting me know :)

[@kitty4536]

The actual concert was held in November

[@ecilaeniarol9863]

There are a lot of fan cams of this performance if you want to hear it raw. They were pretty amazing! Looking forward to your premiere!

[@CalebColesMusic]

I will check one of them out. Thanks so much see you then!

[@arteymoda4662]

Yes!!! There is a fan cam very close and is super amazing. You can see them better and all the time

[@BexREB]

It sounds like they've messed with the levels pretty heavily from the fan cam to this. So much so that I feel kind of detached from the TV version, on the fan cam version Dimash especially is much fuller and louder and in the TV version sounds oddly hollow I feel and almost drowned out. Same for Ulisse. The fan cam I watched for a month and a bit before it came out and it was amazing then saw tv version and it just kind of fell flat. Weird!

[@MsLucy4ever]

@@CalebColesMusic kzbin.info/www/bejne/ooeoiYenitqtjcU

[@user-wt8jq8yj1c]

Димаш поет только вживую ! Не путайте его другими певцами !

[@olgasi7060]

Thank's for your reaction, I like this trio so much. I think it's not lip-sync, raw sound on fancams prove it.

[@d.s5170]

Красивое исполнение! Трио супер! Браво!!!

[@grahamehadwen]

That was sublime. Best singers, best orchestration, flawless production. Those Russians have still got it.

[@ssshadowwolf6762]

Beautiful! Sigh ... ❤️💯🌹 Igor certainly looked pleased !

[@CalebColesMusic]

He did :) Quite a celebration!

[@wrightgregson9761]

Igor looks blissed out from sheer joy. good luck, Caleb

[@shanialover]

Dear Caleb, this was the edition of Igor's 65th birthday celebration in Moscow. Dimash sang solo at least Ogni Pietra and Passione and a duet with Aida to Ulisse and Andrea Bocelli was also there. By the way, there is a new reactor to Dimash named Tina from Rise Academy Of Music from Sydney who after watching SOS said she would like to hear an English version so I told her to use yours. I was amazed at the coincidence.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Wow that is really a crazy coincidence. I'll have to look her up :)

[@unknownandmystical]

@@CalebColesMusic LOL Yeah I've seen her reaction and I found it to be a strange coincidence too. I've told her to react to your version too.

[@hellotomka]

Beautiful , I love it

[@user-vm3kj2pw3i]

Они Прикрсны! Спосибо за реакцию. Удачи!

[@maritighe5674]

This is so epic I love it.... does anyone else notice the sheer joy on Igors face? He is in heaven....

[@asia394]

Калеб сообщил всем, что завтра выйдет его первый сольный альбом. /////////////// Он с большим удовольствием слушал наше трио и сказал: «Я должен сказать, что это звучит совершенно идеально, в Абсолютном смысле». Потом, мне показалось, что Калеб усомнился, что так звучать совершенно идеально в зале НЕ может. А высказал он вот такое свое мнение (записала с автопереводчика): «Так есть один из двух вариантов. Либо они действительно сильно отредактировали прямую трансляцию. Другими словами, удалили звуки дыхания, фоновые шумы, действительно специфическое сжатие, чтобы получить эти голоса полностью такими. Так что это либо действительно высокое качество пост-редактирования, или они предварительно записали его в студии, и они сейчас исполняют живую версию. Это может быть правдой, но я знаю особенно на таких мероприятиях, где у вас есть оркестр и люди катаются на коньках на стадионе, то там очень трудно контролировать звук. И я знаю, иногда организаторы мероприятия еще много чего на самом деле предусматривают для художника, что, слушай, просто петь минусовку, петь, как вы знаете, просто выступать над треком. Я знаю, что ни один из этих певцов не будет синхронизировать губы на своих собственных концертах, но это специальное мероприятие, поэтому я не уверен, какой это может быть, но что может быть вы не слышите, что это грубый живой звук трех из них, когда они поют, как бы это звучало, если бы они пели вживую. Потому что, когда ты поешь вживую в микрофон, вы просто слышите сырой канал или даже немного отредактированный канал, вы все еще получаете все те недостатки, которые вы не (должны) слышать вообще в этом. Я просто говорю это, потому что я имею в виду, что вы можете услышать. Похоже, вы слушаете альбом. Это феноменально, и снова я просто хочу, чтобы это было действительно ясно, все трое из этих вокалистов звучат так хорошо вживую - так что это не вопрос. Это больше о том, что сторона редактирования звука этой вещи заставляет меня поверить, что они сильно отредактированы, или они выступают над треком, но это совсем не отнимает у песни. Это прекрасная песня, прекрасные гармонии…» и т.д. /////////////// Я не музыкально образованный человек, и не все поняла из того, что сказал Калеб, но меня это как-то задело. Мое мнение, что певцы в данном случае пели вживую. Мне кажется, выпуская официальное видео, неужели выпустят его с посторонними шумами и дефектами? Естественно, музыкальные специалисты по звуку должны подчистить, привести, как говорят, в божеский вид ОФИЦИАЛЬНОЕ ВИДЕО - что в этом удивительного или необычного? Разве не всегда, не везде и не у всех так делают? Я люблю реакции Калеба, но в данном случае пришла на ум поговорка "наводить тень на плетень".

[@allusikv3778]

у этого выступления еще как минимум 5 записей фанатских камер в сети бродят. не было даже сомнений, что это живая запись.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Thank you for translating that!!

[@ju1ietta]

Надо просто скинуть ему ссылки на фан-камеры. Спасибо за перевод

[@marinakardash3322]

Калеб честно говорит о чем думает. Он профессионал, и ему очень сложно поверить, что можно так идеально петь, ибо он представляет, что такого добиться практически нереально. Порекомендуем Калебу посмотреть фан записи, и все будет ясно. Ломать привычные стереотипы не просто. Димаш делает революцию в мире музыки и показывает что невозможное -возможно.

[@sonialoizou9440]

Благодаря ти за превода 😍😍😍

[@user-xu7ks2lq9m]

Димаш, как настоящий джентльмен, смог примирить и совместить ,вообще то , очень разные голоса Аиды и Лары. Он не выпятил себя, да и зачем ему это? Он вел их вслед за собой , и привел в одно целое. Настоящий талант и мужчина. А Игорь Крутой, по моему , просто , упивается его голосом и , истинно, мужским поведением.

[@user-sq7cb8cn5m]

Ура, първа съм! 😄 🤗 ❤️ DIMASH is music 🎶 😫 😠 🧐

[@kabe13348]

Even Igor had to brake a smile!!!!!

[@eliezerhernandez8009]

Lara Fabian is a inspiration for Dimash, is great ear this collaboration. Is Magic and so beautiful...

[@brittag.pedersen5340]

🙂👍👍👍...looove Classical music..and this performance is super amazing!! Love it!💕💕💕

[@CalebColesMusic]

It is!

[@brittag.pedersen5340]

@@CalebColesMusic 🙂🕊️

[@hridayaone]

Well, if I may ... They are extraordinary singers ! I don't know the lady in white, but she sure has a beautiful voice. Dimash has this range of notes I don't think I ever heard in my life. We can feel Lara's heart vibrating in most of her songs (I live in France) . But do we really need the skating and ... ?

[@petercauter9691]

Just in case you're interested: Aida (the female singer in thr white dress) is the prima soprano of the Vienense opera and said to be one of the best operatic sopranos in the world

[@hridayaone]

@@petercauter9691 Thank you for the info. That's very kind of you.

[@evilofeldstein4449]

Excellent collaborative with DIMASH, Lara Fabian & Aida Garifullina, Marvelous one of a life time event should not missed. The Geniuses of the Entertaiment Arena, Igor krutoy is quite please as he play the piano the maestro smiled...Thanks Caleb for this reaction!.

[@bettycogswell9851]

This was beautiful. This was also Dimash's dream to sing with Lara. Thanks Caleb.....Looking forward to your video...

[@billizetti]

An absolutely beautiful performance! The harmony was stunning!

[@laura_t_kz2754]

Caleb, спасибо за реакции, на Вас всегда очень приятно смотреть 👍👍👍👍👍

[@yamato19621302]

Невероятное трио! Каждый из них - супер. И все они прекрасны

[@nataliyakolesnik1671]

They all are sining live.. and they do sound phenomenal.

[@EllanaTs]

Such beautiful voices!!! All three of them! Thank you for your reaction!

[@fidimash5810]

It was %100 LİVE

[@JustGotALife]

you can hear background noise in fancam version , he is right, it is edited.

[@user-of7by1ih7d]

Спасибо за реакцию! Димаш!👑💎😍👍👍

[@user-eb6un3ih8r]

🙏🙏🙏КРАСОТА НЕОПИСУЕМАЯ🥰🥰🥰👌👌👌❣

[@giuseppecefali9302]

FANTASTICI DIMASH SEI UNICO 👑👑👑👑❤❤

[@hansderuiter2290]

Nice reaction to Dimash singing Ti Amo Cosi with Aida and Lara. Great performance by all three. Greetings from Amsterdam.

[@sarahcity9220]

Beautiful scenery 🌹 The ice skating, the singing, the piano..Dimash, Aida, Lara, Igor..oh my God..my heart can barely take this 💖☺️ I could listen to it a thousand times..Thank you for the reaction Caleb! 😁

[@bethwolford3652]

This is an extravaganza! I wish Igor would come over to the States and show them how it’s done! This is so beautiful in every way! Lara was I’ll and refused to do anything but live!

[@alcalaalcala5125]

Espectacular👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@user-hv1sh9mo3o]

Все просили низкий голос у Димаша, без верхов, вот пожалуйста, хотя мне кажется что он спокойно способен спеть 3 партии, и от этого песня не чуть не потеряла бы, а стало бы космической. Ни в кое случае не приуменшая заслуги ни Лары, ни Аиды. А из за того знаю какой голос у Димаша. Просто без головного голоса Димаша песня на много стала скормнее🤔😁Аида была там великолепная. Лара шикарной, а Димаш мужественным . Любым эксперементам Димаша мы только рады и ждём!!!

[@user-rc8wp6or1b]

Калеб! Спасибо за реакцию! Сделайте пожалуйста реакцию на Uliss, тоже с этого концерта, ВТБ арена 03.11.2019 в Москве, в исполнении Димаша и Аиды Гарифуллиной! Ждём!

[@isabellesurf]

💕💕💕👏👏👏Hi Caleb, you could listen to « Ulysse » with Dimash and Aida Garifullina at the same concert 💕💕💕

[@galinakrasteva6638]

Caleb,this performance was live100%-you reacted to official version-of course it is cleared of all annoying sounds-if it is so important for you if they are singing live -simply watch fan cam versions !Yes they were so amazingly perfect that is so hard to believe that this is live performance!Aida is one of the best sopranos in the world,prima of Vienna opera house,Lara never used lipsynking in her concerts,Dimash told in his interview once that it is an offence for him and his audience to lipsynk!I respect you very much ,but please leave this comments for live or prerecorded away,simply enjoy yourself!

[@Yoyo-tk3rb]

Dimash never said that, I don't know where people are taking this information from, and he has to use prerecord sometimes, especially in Russia. No need to make a big deal out of it, that's how such events are organized.

[@Yoyo-tk3rb]

@Chernobyl was Nothing He never said that he never uses prerecord. It's something some of his fans invented and firmly believe in it themselves, as if it is some kind of religion. This is very silly, he is a great live performer, he doesn't need this kind of defense. People create unrealistic expectations and then are disappointed and angry when they are not met. Dimash doesn't deserve this kind of attitude.

[@galinakrasteva6638]

Yoyo 300 -read Kazakhstan interviews-all which Dimash gave through the years -no need to argue at all with you!

[@Yoyo-tk3rb]

@@galinakrasteva6638 He said he doesn't like it, he never said he never ever uses it because that would be a lie.

[@Yoyo-tk3rb]

@Chernobyl was Nothing Of course, every person with eyes and ears clearly sees that. That's the norm there and there is nothing Dimash can do about it.

[@anthonylamb5113]

I watched a fan cam of this a while back. I could definitely hear all that pollution that's edited out here. Thanks and congrats on the EP release. I look forward to it.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Thanks so much Anthony!

[@hallymariah45]

Dimash, has such a beautiful voice that it captures your eyes, your spirit....I did not feel that with AGT and Marceleto....I thought he was good but only that he had the female/male voice....Dimash is an Olympic STAR with his voice....And again...It floors me that Angelina Jordin did not get voted in, she's so velvety and and soothing....Enough of me.....

[@chandadas304]

Yes, this concert was held in Moscow on occasion of 65th birthday celebrations of Igor Krutoy on 3rd Nov 2019. Dimash performed 5 songs. And this was the last song of the evening All the performances of Dimash uploaded on Dimash channel. 👍. I think it's post editing because I have watched many fancams😊

[@CalebColesMusic]

Makes sense! Thank you.

[@user-hc2fy3mn5z]

thanks caleb 👍😊the amazing Dimash 🥰❤😘

[@luzjimenamirandadavila6551]

Caleb ya no me salen videos recientes,nos guataria que siga con sus reacciones,Dimash ya tiene muchas canciones compuestas y varios conciertos.Un abrazo y siempre es grato escucharle.Saludos desde Bolivia.

[@quinchin6200]

Perfection personified !! WOW what a performance ! Thanks for your reaction Caleb.

[@percanta1]

They are all equally excellent but the warmth in Lara's voice makes her special. Anyway, it's absolutely wonderful to listen to those voices in a kind of ballet of sounds. Thank you

[@aquariusmarika]

I know where you are coming from, Caleb, but I have listened to the livestream when this was happening back in November and it is definitely live. Dimash sang more songs and he changed some parts (especially when he sang KNOW - ZNAJ) so you could hear it´s not the studio version. Also you could hear Lara´s voice was a bit delicate - she was ill that time.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Yeah that makes sense! :)

[@yannickmauget4321]

Not only your analysis is great but you also are so passionate about music and how you react to it that you take us with you in your journey. Thanks a lot for that !

[@walkiriasaldana3669]

Lara the best una voz hermosa y super afinada muy buen control de su voz con excelente armonía.

[@Elizabet38]

Hi, Caleb! Thanks!!! I watch everyone day this concert and this trio, i love it! And frome you!☺️

[@CalebColesMusic]

It is an incredible blend of talent.

[@andreasimonetti7635]

Lara Fabian is of our Earth; DIMASH is from another planet!

[@frankbirch3877]

They are both from another planet. It is well known that her name comes from her own planet in another galaxy, the planet Lara...

[@terrymayling5764]

Beautiful. Igor looks like he;s in 7th heaven.

[@Danydanielballet]

Lara Fabian best diva word

[@RogerAkesson]

I haven't heard this one before, so I can't say that this was live, but "Know" had some unique improvisations and there were some unique details in "Ogni Petra" that I would say that they sang it live. This is the official version of the concert and I am sure that they have cleaned up and edited it for the best result. Direct Russian telecast do use lipsinc as a choice, but this was concert from the start, that is different, in my opinion.

[@CalebColesMusic]

Yeah, I am unsure what they did. It just does sound unusually perfect. But with the calibre of these singers and some great post editing it is possible it is just a really well done live version.

[@DrumL3000]

@@CalebColesMusic Yes, you are right. As a sound engineer i can tell you a bit about it in general. keep in mind it could be done in various ways. So one of the times that artists may appear to not be performing live is when they use a performance track, which includes the instruments, backing vocals and hook vocals pre-recorded and playing in the background during a live show. The fact they use in ear monitoring and band is actually playing could most likely state that when they go to perform it, singers have the support of the stacks they recorded. They have the effects on the background vocals. They're singing it on top. It's kind of like karaoke, in a way. When it comes to broadcast shows, like the Grammys and the American Music Awards, and the time schedule is so precise. It's physically not possible to mic an entire band for every segment that comes up. During such performances, the singer's microphone is still on. On the parts they're not confident on or if the performance is physically demanding, the artist will sing quieter, and more of the performance track vocals can be heard. These are some of the examples that can be used. They also maybe times when only some parts are pre recorded. Or completely dubbed and the audience at home is not hearing what the live audience can hear. In the end at broadcast shows I.E. its not the artist choice what will be used or done. And we all know Lara and Dimash are Gods at singing.

[@JasminGardenia]

Yes, Dimash's Know and Ogni Pietra were definitely live, but I have never been really sure about the others. Fans of Lara say she had a cold that day (and praise her for still singing in this live performance). And she obviously had.. and there's also a video if the day before of Lara, Dimash and Igor chatting in which she says that she'll need stronger medication) Hard to tell... it could be live with a lot of post production, it could e.g. have been pre-recorded due to the setting or due to Lara's sickness (but that would have been spontaneous and they don't even necessarily already had a high-quality studio revording of it if a live performance had been planned... on the other hand, the song is supposed to be on the Igor Krutoy-Dimash collab album anyway hmm so I really hard to tell 🤷‍♀️)

[@tonipenkova4325]

Have a fan cameras of all performances . It's live. With love from Bulgaria ♥️🇧🇬♥️

[@tatyanakim407]

yotaplaysgames hi. There are fan cams of this performance. Check it out. Interesting what you think.

[@miramir8161]

А мне все равно,поет он вживую всегда. Я бы слушала и под фонограммы. Он живой человек. Ему беречь надо голос. Мне приятно даже смотреть на него. Пусть он даже молчит. На него просто смотреть и получить море удовольствия можно. Он такой один

[@davidbangtson3109]

Delighted to hear how much you enjoyed this, as it's one of my favorites as well.

[@emmanuelguadalupe9649]

Grasia Caleb ! Eres muy preciso en tus comentarios ! 😃 Dimash es muy talentoso ! 🙏sigue reaccionando mas a Dimash por favor ! Mas mas mas

[@ubervocal8777]

There were a series of Igor Krutoy 65th birthday concerts last year in different countries (I attend New York City). He engaged many of the big stars of the Russian pop music scene to participate with this one being the grandest. It was held in the Moscow Ice Palace, featured ice skating throughout and was the only one to include Garifullina and Fabian, Andrea Bocelli and other classical artists. Garifullina won the opera contest founded by Placido Domingo and, fittingly, she is named after Verdi's opera about an Ethiopian princess named Aida (pronounced eye-ee-duh' ).

[@CalebColesMusic]

Thanks for that info, I do remember seeing some fan-cams from the New York show. Pretty amazing to have all that going on for your birthday! Big stars, ice skating - the works.

[@ubervocal8777]

@@CalebColesMusic Lara caught a cold not long before the performance so that may have been why they went with a recording. Dimash's "Know" from this concert was live and superb.

[@Snarky_Tart]

Aida is a principal soprano with the Vienna Opera House. Other than Dimash and Lara Fabian, the performers for this event were all luminaries of the classical genre. This included Andrea Bocelli, Anna Netrebko, Brio Sonores and violinist Yuri Bashmet They were accompanied by Olympic and world champion ice skaters. The Russian pop stars weren't included in this one, though some did watch from the audience. Lara Fabian performed 5 songs; because of her illness, Igor Krutoy asked her if she would rather lip sync, but she refused.

[@ubervocal8777]

@@Snarky_Tart Thanks for the correction!

[@ubervocal8777]

@@Snarky_Tart I should have known this because of the backstage duet between Dimash and Bocelli.

[@brasil1604]

It‘s so BEAUTIFUL 👏👏❤️😍❤️😍❤️

[@michelinecharron2477]

J'aime beaucoup Lara et Dimash❤️❤️❤️🎶🎶🎶👍👍👍

[@user-ex1lc5yk6c]

Рахмет сізге досым, көңілді жүзі жарқын адам екенсіз. 👍👍👍👍

[@joanadarcpereira3554]

Este momento único com certeza ficará para a história pois são muito talentos juntos incrível ❤❤❤

[@PhilosophizingmeansdoubtingMdM]

Thanks for your honest reaction, Caleb.

[@aidasdin1777]

Hi Caleb. They sang live. A lot of fancam showing that. This video is the edited version. Good luck on your new song.

[@user-vt8lp7kz6r]

Спасибо, Калеб, за реакции

[@user-ls7nf9cf5u]

Это божественно! Спасибо!)

[@user-fi1ie1ii7r]

ДИМАШ 😙😚😙😚😙💜💛❤💚💙💖👍👍👍👍👍

[@teresasebastianmore6135]

Tremendo trío ! 💝💝💝 Nuestro príncipe kazajo cumplió uno de sus sueños, cantar con Lara Fabián, una de sus cantantes favoritas. Abrazos desde Barcelona😘

[@gemmaogayan1188]

What an amazing composition....love it....