Calling Non-Muslims Bro or Sis┇Shaykh Muhammad Salih Al-Uthaymeen

[@thepillar1164]

Watch: Heart Melting Story of Ka'b ibn Malik رضي الله عنه kzbin.info/www/bejne/qJnZhXl8rM1-iMk

[@RiyazMS0]

The deep understanding that ALLAH taala bestows to his pious slaves is beyond praise Subhanallah

[@petergreen5337]

ALHAMDULILAH..

[@KIZILELMAFATIHI]

May Allah reward you immensely for posting vids like these. Your channel is a gem especcially for those who dont understand Arabic and want to learn from the real scholars.

[@AbdurahiimRoberts]

It is also a gem for those who are learning Arabic because these active translations while listening to the speech in Arabic help a great deal in developing listening skills which (I have found anyway) need to be developed in parallel with speaking, reading and writing in Arabic too. BaarakAllahu feekum

[@crnojaje9288]

Brother leqrn Arabic. There are Madina books playlists for all three books that you can study from. Everything is free

[@petergreen5337]

Ameen

[@abdouahamada8122]

@@crnojaje9288 where can we get them please

[@CordobaGeneral1234]

Ameen

[@PathToXP]

Such an old video that is so relevant in such new times

[@akongvlogg9737]

This is the real Fatwa.May Allah reward you Shiekh

[@petergreen5337]

Aameen

[@AbdurahiimRoberts]

I may have accidentally pressed the "dislike" button. It was a mistake. I apologise for the inconvenience. There is nothing except "like" for this beautiful kalam from the Shaykh رحيمه الله

[@pearlsofadaab]

رحمه الله*

[@adetayoadebajo1756]

This happened to me too and then I saw your comment after 😅... May Allah continue to guide us 🙏🏽

[@hypermangi8265]

Brother, Allaah knows ur intention. You can delete this comment. It's ok, because u made mistake and corrected it. Keep this between Allah 🗿

[@stefanie9157]

Press ist again, that deletes the first pressing!

[@_purplelion_]

You can undo it by pressing on the button again and click like

[@petergreen5337]

May Allah reward the sheikh ameen.May Allah forgive and accept us ameen.

[@jonathancharles3719]

I shall stop then although its a habit barakallah feek sheikh

[@mdkhan3928]

Very diplomatic.🥇🏆🌹

[@maazmustafa2322]

Extremely beneficial. Your avg muslim incl myself wouldn't know this.

[@نُتَفٌمِنْكِتَابِالْوَابِلال]

رحمه الله تعالى ووفقكم لما يحبه ويرضاه

[@ahmedabdulhamid5656]

جزاك الله خيراََ

[@petergreen5337]

Aameen

[@idreesabdallah.2664]

بارك الله فيكم May Allah bless you

[@petergreen5337]

Aameen

[@ProLookout]

Its a hard thing to fight your nafs

[@regidon6816]

that wisdom right thre guys (mashallah) and today u see many milk shakes say "my brother in humanity" or "my brother that has not yt come to islam" I been saying for decades the kuffar are not our brothers. listen right here thats a don scholar right there i still today remeber his passing man and where i was. Allah have mercy on all them top dons mashallah.

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

Stop using the inventions of the kuf far as well, stop using mobile phones from now on...

[@SalafiDawahNZ]

It seems that some brothers may not have paid enough attention and have misunderstood. 1) The shaykh has said that it is wrong to say they are your brothers in humanity. This concept is false. 2) You are not allowed to say "MY brother". In arabic "akhi". As for "akh" without the kasrah then this has a different meaning. The shaykh said this is fine. Hence saying "brother" and "bro" is fine according to the shaykh provided this is not intended to mean "brother in humanity". People commonly say "bro" in the West at it does not carry the same meaning as "akhi". What would be haraam is to say "my brother" or "my bro".

[@canyouhandlethetruth8682]

Beautifully calarified, barek Allaahu feek

[@AymanTravelTransport]

Easy way to rebut the whole "brother in humanity" concept is to ask yourself, did the Prophet (peace be upon him) or his Companions ever use this kind of terminology with those who haven't yet accepted Islam (outside of their family members that is)?

[@DeMonotheist]

​@@AymanTravelTransportindeed. Stick to the salaf. Shaykh ibn uthaymeen is a respected scholar but his "akh" opinion isnt referred to manhaj salaf. Its his ijtihad. There is absolutely no need to call a kaafir "akh" or "bro" without intending insaniyya or religious brotherhood.

[@mukhtarali1974]

Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Amr: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "A Muslim is the one who avoids harming Muslims with his tongue and hands. And a Muhajir (emigrant) is the one who gives up (abandons) all what Allah has forbidden." Sahih Al Bukhari

[@amadousagna7053]

JazakAllah Khairan

[@hasanfaisal6029]

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa baraakatuh Need English subtitles Please zajakAllahu khayran

[@SultanaNdoye]

There is

[@محمد-س3ك9ج]

is that thumbnail picture an actual picture of the shaykh when he was young???

[@thepillar1164]

Yes, from perhaps the 70s

[@aymenashraf4183]

@@thepillar1164 رحمه الله

[@Future_1400]

Akkahu Akbar!

[@petergreen5337]

Allahu akbar

[@WeEducateAndTutor]

Yep. Here in the Emriates I’m faced with this issue a lot. I don’t know what to call the helpers at the grocery shops or at the small markets who are mostly from India or Pakistan so I just refer to them as ‘brother’ أخ. (e.g. brother, can I please have a bottle of water?).

[@WeEducateAndTutor]

But I know someone who refers to them as ‘sir’, and now I see why it makes more sense to refer to someone (a man) as ‘sir’.

[@lostsouls5885]

people from Pakistan are Muslims

[@mohammedkhan2303]

My friend most of those people might be Muslims especially from Pakistan

[@khayr1]

Pakistanis are overwhelming Muslims and India has more Muslims than UAE So what issue do you face?

[@deislampagina]

Pakistanis are mostly muslim. Isn't it?

[@misteryolo7248]

That's actually genius

[@carbonlodi1527]

I don't know what is preferable 😅

[@hypermangi8265]

I only began saying "brother in humanity" because The Muslim Lantern says... Shaykh just repeated himself.

[@umermohiuddin2061]

im honestly still confused in this matter.

[@cushconsultinggroup]

yes I understand why because it’s kind of a deep topic and the question in the end about being Banu Adam, but the answer is clear, they are either your brother through lineage or your brother through iman.

[@Reed0069]

When in doubt, my beloved brother, refrain from doing the action or making the statement. As the hadeeth goes, “leave that which makes you doubt for that which does not make you doubt”. Narrated by at-Tirmidhi (2442), Ahmad (1630) and Ibn Hibbaan (722)

[@SalafiDawahNZ]

Refer to my earlier comment where I summarized the video. InshaaAllah that clarifies the issue for you.

[@faizannazrawi2657]

✌😇🧘‍♂️

[@Thrawnio]

Is this opinion a matter of consensus for the Ulama?

[@DeMonotheist]

He used a verse from the Quran as proof. Where do you see an opinion?

[@thehourglassfan3515]

Why do you always say infidels? They haven’t even heard about the religion yet so why putting them in that box, first preach the message to them instead of criticizing them? They can be our brothers in humanity. Hate mongering is so disgusting.

[@DeMonotheist]

Your ignorance is disgusting. Islam is based on confirmations. If someone doesnt confirm his Islam he is a non muslim or infidel towards Islam. This isnt insulting the individual at all. Youre too emotional, deal with them.

[@user-user-user-user.]

With all due respect to the Sheyk, his opinion fails to take into account other cultures, the type of language that other cultures employ, colloquialisms, slang, and other culture-specific linguistic patterns. For example the informal use of the word “bro” in both Muslim and non Muslim culture. The term “bro” can be identified as a noun (although it can be turned into a verb) and generally translates as “a comrade, a friend.” It would be misleading to suggest it means anything else (just as the term “habibi” is not a formal declaration of romantic love between males in the Arabic speaking world).

[@aqibkhwaja6106]

What? You can say bro, etc. Just don't say MY bro while having conversation as sheikh said with reference of the Quran.

[@applez3015]

It's not his opinion he gave you ayat from the Quran

[@EV-EV-EV]

Islam does not care about Kuffar cultures

[@siyarjoya9655]

Even if it meant comrade or friend: can you have friendship with non muslims?

[@mohamedmuienudeen8992]

What are you trying to say?

[@jsmith5509]

Black people in the USA refer to other Blacks as brother or sister regardless of their religious affiliation. Our Blackness and African origins unite us as family.

[@thepillar1164]

Those of them who are Muslim are our brothers and sisters. You can have the rest.

[@applez3015]

What's up with this we are black or we are white or we are Arabs. True Muslims don't care , the sahabas were from all different kind of backgrounds but I love them more than my own people or blood relations.

[@EV-EV-EV]

The kuffar are not our brothers and they can never be our brothers.

[@Abu_Abdullah790]

If a black person insults our Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), will he still be from your family? What about these disbelievers who ascribe a son to Allah! Reflect on your words.

[@sheroo1000]

The colour of our skin and our ethnic backgrounds do not unite us. Our upright faith and religion of Islam unite us, regardless of our skin and ethnic backgrounds.

[@MODEST500]

I have a question why their is no difference being made between non muslims who are ignorant of Islam vs non muslims who had witnessed the message and yet turned away . Are both non muslims alike ? If not why their is no distinction . Also how is the example of Muslims being brothers to each other is a proof against that Non Muslim and Muslim aren't brothers in humanity ? . The verse never mentions that Believers are but brothers to each other and not to non muslims etc. Another is how is the example of Nuh AS son befitting non muslims who have no experience of Islam ? . Jazakallah

[@thepillar1164]

Because the difference is moot in this regard. Whether they are ignorant nonmuslims or educated nonmuslims, they are still nonmuslims and that is what the Shaykh is addressing. wa iyyak beloved brother

[@MODEST500]

@@thepillar1164 jazakallah khair bro

[@G_1allah]

They might not be our brothers in deen yet however they are our brothers and sisters because our father is Adam . So I don’t see any harm in callin them my brother or sister . I think the sheikh was not practicing compassion at all . The Quran verse he cited was just saying the believers are one brotherhood .

[@thepillar1164]

Our dear brother, disbelievers are not closer to us than the son of Nuh was to Nuh and yet Allah forbade him from referring to him as family due to his kufr. And refrain from statements such as "I don't see any harm in..." It is a matter of Aqeedah from which this prohibition of ascribing brotherhood to disbelievers comprises. This is not a matter of opinion Yes, the Shaykh mentioned the verse of only the Believers are brothers, though this is more than sufficient as proof - recall the other verses the Shaykh cited. The prophet sal'Allahu alayhi wa sallam and the companions were more keen upon compassion than anyone after them yet they never uttered such words to the kuffar. They, in fact, fought their own blood brothers and fathers in battle, let alone those unrelated to them. Compassion is giving them dawah, being at their service, doing well by them, fulfilling their needs, speaking a kind word, etc. All of this is good that Allah enjoins. However, calling them our brothers or our sisters is not compassion in the least, it is misguidance. Disbelievers are not our brothers and sisters, dear brother. So long as they are upon kufr, they'll never be referred by us with same words that we refer to you. Our brotherhood in Islam is precious and the amount and intensity of love we give to you, we will never give them because you have submitted to Allah in Islam. There is nothing to rival that. May Allah bless you dear brother and elevate your rank.

[@humanaccount2754]

@@thepillar1164 aameen جزاك الله خيرا

[@SalafiDawahNZ]

The shaykh provided daleel. You have not. So do as you please then. Clearly you know better....

[@canyouhandlethetruth8682]

@@SalafiDawahNZ You can but provide the truth, guidance is in the Hands of Allaah! Allaah ul musta'aan

[@ahmedabdulhamid5656]

@@thepillar1164 ''disbelievers are not closer to us than the son of Nuh was to Nuh and yet Allah forbade him from referring to him as family due to his kufr.'' you put it very eloquently. you should pin that comment, and Shiek provided a good solution to the matter, Subhan Allah there is nothing that our deen left out.. everything is addressed alhamdullilah.

[@mukhtarali1974]

Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Amr: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "A Muslim is the one who avoids harming Muslims with his tongue and hands. And a Muhajir (emigrant) is the one who gives up (abandons) all what Allah has forbidden." Sahih Al Bukhari

[@abthulbasith4346]

Assalamu alaikum akhi can you please give me the reference to refer?

[@muhammadmusab6334]

​@@abthulbasith4346 Sahih Al-Bukhari 10 Book 2, Hadith 3

[@petergreen5337]

May Allah reward you ameen