The Mysterious Story of a Missing Medieval Kingdom

[@celebalert5616]

I could easily locate this place if I put my mind to it.

[@Atollic]

All hail CELEB. Our mightly lord.

[@curtisheron8858]

You fail In life when you never put your mind to anything.

[@solarpenguin1]

Have you tried looking down the back of the sofa? That's where my lost things usually turn up.

[@helloworld-wy4vq]

Not if I can help it.

[@telebubba5527]

Wot mind?

[@JulianScotus]

*Scholars:* _"Hey where did Rheinwg go?"_ *King Offa with a conspicuously Rheinwg-shaped belly:* _"Erm, no clue"_

[@limolnar]

It's important to remember that kingdoms in antiquity often were named by not just land occupied, but also through vassalage. Rome, for example, was any land that came under the sway of the city of Rome. So Rheinwg could have overlapped several other kingdoms.

[@donwayne1357]

Just what the Illinois Enema Bandit would say, the one with the bag of hot soapy water and the twisty nozzle.

[@mondaysinsanity8193]

Yeah feudalism made borders VERY weird. The idea of nation states didnt exist yet

[@Slothface]

you need to explain it to historians like they are five years old

[@lolasdm6959]

@@mondaysinsanity8193 Nation states were rare but not absent in pre modern times.

[@mondaysinsanity8193]

@@lolasdm6959 name a nation state pre say 1600

[@celtofcanaanesurix2245]

honestly I thought this was going to be about that one mythical welsh kingdom that was supposedly where the irish sea is today, but good to hear of something I never knew about before

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you! Cantref Gwaelod is super interesting too, might be a topic for the future

[@eamonnclabby7067]

@@CambrianChronicles indeed Cardigan, Atlantis...

[@coalkingryan881]

I don’t know anything about this kingdom, but seeing as water levels were significantly low for a time, allowing these people to go to the British Isles which at the time were a part of mainland Europe, all these stories about sunken cities and kingdoms could well be true to the extent that when ocean levels rose it took these lands and people with it. Presumably this is why the Flood is a story in every religion. Global warming isn’t anything new, so the flood really could’ve just have been the ice caps melting and the oceans rising at an unprecedented level completely submerging “Atlantis” or “Enoch”

[@damenwhelan3236]

@@coalkingryan881 I'd be very cautious with applying this to the Irish myths. People died off in Ireland before settling again long after the sea levels rose. So ireland was always an island to the longest inhabitants. But grwat Britain has been inhabited longer and well into the times of doggerland.

[@pittsburghmcconnell]

Awesome. Almost didn't watch because I thought it was going to be about John's lost kingdom.

[@darkhorse505]

Honestly I just admire the dedication you put into finding the information and making this video of an obscure yet fascinating piece of Welsh history

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@ROBOHOLIC1]

Maybe the real Rheinwg were the friends we made along the way?

[@VODEnjoyer]

😮😮

[@LTPottenger]

Everyone asks where Rheinwg is, but no one asks how Rheinwg is.

[@DirtyDruid]

A little Rheinwg lives in all of us.

[@gildedpeahen876]

🖤😞🙏

[@realgsdontdie5095]

Everyone forgot about Rheinwg's younger brother Lemmiwinks.

[@hatac]

Your explanation is quite reasonable. Remember Holland was once part of the kingdom of Spain. Some French and German kingdoms moved hundreds of miles as the king moved their center of power to a new and more strategic location only to loose the land of their ancestors to other invaders. Poland is also a nation, people and culture that has moved greatly. Once it reached from Lithuania through Belarus to Ukraine on the black sea but controlled very little of what is now Poland today. That was Prussia at the time.

[@henkvandervossen6616]

Silesia was austrian until mid 18th century

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, those examples are excellent as well, especially Poland, I hadn't realised how much it had shifted over the centuries

[@studiumhistoriae]

I am reminded of the Duchy of Saxony which wound up being in a completely different place than its place of origin (now called Lower Saxony)

[@henkvandervossen6616]

@@studiumhistoriae The saxony you mention is still there, around Dresden.

[@keizoxd5623]

@@studiumhistoriae Duchy of Saxony never moved. It was still there until 1871 when the 2nd Reich was formed. Lower Saxony or Niedersachsen is a completely different state

[@lordsiomai]

I kinda like the idea of "Rheinwg" as the name of a region rather than a specific kingdom. It would better explain the weird variety of it's criteria. Remember back when "Asia" was just used to refer to Turkey or something? Now "Asia" refers to the entire continent. Region names are much more flexible than the names of actual kingdoms/places and thus it makes sense to look at Rheinwg that way.

[@trodat07]

In Spanish, king is ‘rey’ and kingdom is ‘reino’, both sound weirdly familiar to ‘rheinwg’.

[@lordsiomai]

@@trodat07 doesn't tell us much since these two languages developed so far apart from each other. Still, a very interesting coincidence indeed

[@kweejibodali3078]

I think Asia Minor referenced Turkey, not Asia

[@lordsiomai]

@@kweejibodali3078 oh yes that one thank you for reminding! Forgot the minor part

[@tomcole5118]

@@kweejibodali3078 The Geographical region of Asia minor is referred to today as Anatolia. Turkey occupies land beyond Anatolia, Anatolia is generally defined to end to the east at the Armenian Highlands and to the west at the Dardanelles and Bosporus straits. Many different peoples aside from the Turks lived in Anatolia and to describe the region simply as Turkey does a disservice to it's history.

[@starhalv2427]

My theory is that it was considered to be most or the entire of southern Wales, and many lesser lords called themselves kings of Rheinwg as a form of laying claims to many more territories than they actually controlled.

[@CambrianChronicles]

That does make a lot of sense!

[@lolasdm6959]

Just like people calling themselves the "Roman emporer"

[@lolasdm6959]

It could also be that they all descended from a king named Rhein, which rule over the original Rheinwg. Just like all kings of the ptolemaic dynasty are named Ptoleme

[@HipixOFFICIAL]

I was thinking maybe the authors of these records were mistakenly referring to vassals as kingdoms and as such, referring to counts and dukes as kings.

[@raypurchase801]

@@CambrianChronicles Is this the location of Castle Anthrax?

[@CineMiamParis]

« Kidneys : 14 » I love that you take the trouble of hiding hilarious Easter eggs within a engaging and well-written story. Very nice job.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Haha thank you

[@kitstorm7637]

Great work again, especially the way historiography is portrayed. A lot of this vague "we're not 100% sure" sort of history often comes down to Occam's razor, doesn't it? Can't wait for what comes next!

[@CambrianChronicles]

It definitely does to a certain degree haha, sometimes it seems like it becomes too easy to just ignore any contradicting evidence

[@stevie-ray2020]

As History is usually written by the victors or usurpers, much of the truth has inconveniently disappeared from the records of the past!

[@user-wr6dj4ib9o]

as rheinwgian i confirm not even we remember where we are

[@JapicaIsSus]

Wow, I didn’t know a thousand-year old person could use the internet

[@swaffelkonijn5166]

Can I just say that for me, as someone with an MA in history, it's so nice to see someone doing some actual historical research on YT, someone actually explaining a method and reasoning rather than the usual "15 things wrong with Braveheart that you didn't know about" type of nonsense. Perhaps I would have liked to have seen a bit more background about the sources and their authors (if at all possible, which, let's be fair, it probably won't be). All-round top effort!

[@LukeGood1018]

As a proud Welshman I am soo grateful for this channel. Thank you for shedding some light on my ancestors' amazing history.

[@RR-ut3xl]

WAAAAALES

[@LukeGood1018]

@@RR-ut3xl CYMRUUUUU. Happy New Year

[@LukeGood1018]

@kprop Amen, gyfaill.

[@vikttor_6495]

Welsh is really wierd but also interesting language. Like sometimes when I see something in welsh it looks like somebody's head has fallen on keyboard

[@LukeGood1018]

@@vikttor_6495 LOL, very funny. Yes I suppose it would look strange to a non-Welsh speaker, but to me and other Cymry (the Welsh people), it is a beautifully poetic language. The poetic and prose literature, ranging from the work of the ancient bards to the authors and poets of today is a truly magical art form and unique to Cymraeg (the Welsh language). Cymru am Byth

[@Leppi_Lugh]

I have never been so fascinated with a story/history with names I can't even begin to pronounce correctly 😅. Well done!

[@Vextonomy]

This has given me an existential crisis about being forgotten and not making a difference in history enough not to be thought of and that I will eventually fade away like I never existed. On a serious note great video lmao

[@jahmanhosking5153]

I have already forgotten you exist.

[@realmoodle]

Who are you?

[@Relies-t5v]

sometimes its not bad to be forgotten, your name is in peace and you stay out of controversies (your close family will always know you), and when we are out of this world we meet our people (relatives, friends etc ) again

[@realmoodle]

@@Relies-t5v all of this is for nothing, everyone will die, nobody will remember you.

[@billychops1280]

I was planning on doing a Welsh campaign in ck3 but I couldn’t decide who to start as so I came here hoping to see which region had the coolest history lol

[@CambrianChronicles]

Hopefully I helped!

[@ibiGamer]

ck2 better

[@TY-km8hj]

@@ibiGamer could u explain why? I've only ever played ck2 and love it but it seems as tho everything in 3 is made better, I don't have a strong enough laptop or pc to run ck3 so I'm waiting for the day lol

[@saltgamer7895]

@@TY-km8hj Probably because of nostalgia value.

[@user-wr6dj4ib9o]

ck3?

[@Ulfcytel]

An example of different geographical areas which came under the same name (or the designation moved) later in the medieval period is Burgundy. Not only was there a separate County and Dutchy of Burgundy, but the lands were both in what is now eastern and south-eastern France *and* also areas of modern Belgium. The location could vary by hundreds of miles depending upon when and whom you asked. Very much enjoy your videos.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Another excellent example, thank you for sharing!

[@Enleuk]

The name of Burgundy came from the Burgundians who lived in Poland around the 3rd century. Their name in turn came from or with people who lived in Scandinavia e.g. on the island of Bornholm.

[@vanyadolly]

A puzzle for future historians!

[@studiumhistoriae]

What a great and interesting video! I think it should also be kept in mind that the titles of kingdoms in the middle ages (especially the earlier middle ages) were not necessarily as set in stone as many people think. I imagine Rheinwg could have been one term used specifically for the kingdom as ruled by the descendants of Rhain until that dynastic connection ceased to be significant, though I admit medieval Wales is far from my specialty so I could be completely off the ball here.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you! That's certainly a good point, it's definitely possible that it was a term for the dynasty descending from Rhain, perhaps until its eventual conquest by Gwynedd from the north

[@frenchfriar]

Honestly, I think it's amazing we know enough to even have conjecture about these vague one time mentions in documents over a thousand years old. Fascinating, though.

[@CambrianChronicles]

I couldn't agree more, the amount of theorising that historians can do with only a few scant mentions is incredible

[@bostonrailfan2427]

i thought it would be about Arthur and the whole knights of the round table, but a weird bit of local history that sprung out of a very brief period of time that unintentionally got recorded in records and baffled educated people for centuries is simply much better! it makes sense, it was lost due to the changes in how places are referred to and took a lot of investigation into other things not considered for you to expose the truth and give the place its due…you brought out a unique piece of Welsh history that deserved to be known

[@aronaax]

I mean, king Arthur didn't even exist, probably, since there is no evidence of him existing

[@bostonrailfan2427]

@@aronaax there’s theories of him being a Cornish man of great power and wealth but not a king…evidence is there of his existence as a normal man but notbas a king

[@aronaax]

@@bostonrailfan2427 there is *no* evidence of an Arthur existing in the alleged time in the said place, being a king on top of all the other stuff. Sure, the legends of him written long after his alleged existence might have could have used other existing persons from around that time, to build the story around some "solid" base, but it's highly debatable that there is any actual proof of any of those inspiration-persons being in the picture to say the least

[@bostonrailfan2427]

@@aronaax you’re spouting off crap without any evidence, but i doubt you care: you’re just trying to make yourself feel better by appearing to be smart. i never said the king was real, just that the story had roots in reality that huge shock: English people try to believe isn’t true. their biggest hero being based on a Cornish rich person? that can’t be allowed! no, he must be fake! even though there is actual evidence into the story that points to local tales based on the descriptions in the stories. he wasn’t a king, but a very rich person of blood.

[@honey23b2]

This is a history mystery. Thank you. Highly recommended. Great comments too. Very thought provoking. So nice to find a real interesting history channel without robot talking and silly scaremongering. 😂. Thank you again. 🎉Happy new Year Everyone.

[@Gortius-VIII]

Incredible video as always. In fact, your whole channel inspired me to start leaning Welsh!

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, that is amazing to hear!

[@philiphawley1319]

Tremendous research, I one had a friend from London who moved to Swansea. She spent a very long Sunday driving around, trying to find a place called Abertawe, as it sounded so nice....!! lol. With the confusion like this, plus the sparse records, and the passage of over a thousand years it is a miracle that you could draw any credible conclusions. Well done.

[@eardwulf785]

Nothing like a bit of medieval detective work to start the day, super interesting video; subscribed! Just a little North of where i live is an interesting place called Sherburn-in-Elmut. Sherburn is Anglo Saxon in origin but Elmut is much more mysterious. It was a post Roman Brythonic Kingdom with not that much known about it. I think it's amazing that it still exists today, how the place name survived the Anglisc and Danish expansions is what fascinates me.

[@beth7935]

I remember hearing something about a mysterious Brythonic kingdom called Elmet, & that's what I thought of when I saw this video title.

[@eardwulf785]

Well it did border onto Mercia but that's all I can think of to make it a contender. In fact rather than Elmut warring with Mercia they became allies against the Northumbrians.

[@beth7935]

@@eardwulf785 Oh gosh no, I didn't think Rheinwg WAS Elmet! It's clearly in a totally different place! Nor do I know enough to propose an alternative theory- & this seems correct anyway. It just reminded me of it cos it's another "mysterious" kingdom in Britain. I didn't know Elmet allied with Mercia against Northumbria, that's interesting! But then it certainly wasn't "all Celts vs. all Anglo-Saxons". I only really remember that Elmet was a Brythonic kingdom in the north of England tho; it was ages ago that I heard of it.

[@WK-47]

Place names seem to survive better than personal ones, even if they can still become corrupted with time as with any words. I mean, personal names can be synonymous or interchangeable with titles, and at least parts of the world once practised the ritual removal of names of former rulers if the new regime really wanted to supersede the previous one (Akhenaten is a good example, even if Ancient Egypt is pretty distant in place and time to pre-medieval Britain). In contrast, and maybe I'm comparing apples and pears here, in south-east Scotland you'll find a strange mix of linguistic roots for the place names. There are more English-influenced Scots ones than almost anywhere else in the country (one reason it's the 'least Scottish' corner of Scotland), such as '-burgh'. Then you find very little Gaelic (one way to tell how deep into Scotland you are is by how many places have 'aber-' in them), again due to the cultural and geographical proximity to England, in part thanks to the old Roman road now mostly covered by the A1 motorway. The other one, definitely the strangest and what your comment reminded me of, is Old Welsh. Seems like a fluke, one of those linguistic oddities that's hard to explain, but according to historian Alistair Moffat (I strongly recommend his work, especially The Faded Map, which is actually about 'lost' kingdoms) is due to a considerable wave of settlers from Wales a long, long time ago. The village I grew up in, for instance, has an entirely Old Brythonic (okay, not Old Welsh in this case but still pre-Gaelic Celtic) name that's uncorrupted enough for a layman like me to understand the etymology of. Anyway, I'm rambling. Point is, history and linguistics are fascinating, but (especially ancient) Britain just takes them to another level.

[@simonpentwyn]

Great vid. Me and my family have lived in Dyfed, forever. Congrats on the prononciation, wish the BBC took as much care.

[@heathfairbairn2460]

Thank you for your great work, I live in pembrokeshire and fascinated by the ancient history of my land, keep up the good work

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm glad you liked it!

[@irenejohnston6802]

My son lived in Hook on the western Cleddau. Interested to learn that Milford Haven doesnt mean a Mill on a Ford. Is Viking melr sandbank and fjordr inlet. Sandyinlet. Hubba overwintered there with 23 ships in 854. Lent his name to Hubberstone.

[@heathfairbairn2460]

@@irenejohnston6802 yes and the vikings stayed longer than that, naming the islands of Skokholm and Skoma and taking all the trees to make more longships from them, my ancestry is viking so maybe some of them stayed

[@campfiresnlasguns]

By confusing their foes of their kingdom's true whereabouts, it is certainly an interesting way of defending oneself.

[@EternalShadow1667]

Ahh, this is such a lovely and entertaining video! Thank you for it! Amazing what we’d know if people didn’t keep destroying heritage. And how much we can extract from the scraps that survived WW2 and whatnot. The British Isles are so amazing to have escaped the worst of it. And thank you for monitoring comments and answering questions!

[@MsLukinhas29]

Pretty awesome video! Well summarized and i loved that he quotes and lists his bibliography! Keep going! 👏🏼👏🏼

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@VulnerableBede1]

Yet another banger video! Thanks so much

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@evert3971]

I just went through a binge watch of your entire channel, definetly my new favorite youtube channel, keep up the great videos!!

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you so much, I really appreciate that and I'm glad you're enjoying my videos

[@richardharries5551]

Don't know if it helps but one of my Uncles lived on a farm called Cadwgan, on the north side of the hamlet Rhoshill. My family tree goes back to the 10th century as we've always been farmers. Another Uncle farmed ten miles north on the road to Cardigan whilst Another Uncle ten miles to the South farmed near Clynderwen. My Dad farmed near Glogue and Llanfyrnach. The latter not to be mixed with the other village of Llanfrynach. There's a document of Farmers in this area in both the British museum and the National Library of Wales in Aberystwyth. Good luck and thanks for the video of useful information.

[@uglymeez236]

Interesting video, my dnd homebrew setting is supposed to be in a faded and forgotten kingdom and I was looking for inspiration just like this! Thank you and I'll check out more

[@CambrianChronicles]

I'm glad to have helped, thanks for watching!

[@karililjendal]

Been watching a lot of your previous videos after finding this one! Welsh history is very interesting and I look forward to learning more from you :)

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm glad you like them!

[@OldnGold]

The key to finding a missing medieval kingdom is the same as finding anything else. It's always in the last place you look.

[@CalvinNoire]

Is this kingdom possibly located in America? That's my theory /j

[@raypurchase801]

@@CalvinNoire I suspect Castle Anthrax is in this kingdom.

[@leadingauctions8440]

Now this is a fascinating mystery.

[@donwayne1357]

Long live The Bangles.

[@mtth6758]

Excellent video 👏🏻 A lot of respect and attention to detail towards Welsh history here. Very interesting topic as well.

[@mtth6758]

Subscribed, as I’ve only just discovered your channel and I feel a lot of channel’s coverage medieval history glosses over a lot of Welsh and Brythonic history. Looking forward to watching more of these videos!

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@prettyjavivu2836]

Great work to show the research and effort thrown into history!!! This gives me motivation to go out and discover more about history, our past, all details and other curiosities. Magnificent video

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you so much, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@Shwabadi]

i love the way these videos are structured and how you tell the story

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm really glad!

[@m.w.wollacott8179]

An interesting mystery. My first thought, after you revealed the name but not the evidence, was that Rheinwg was a different Welsh form of the old kingdom of Rheged. It could have been invaded by Offa, but would not explain anything else. As someone who went to university in Ceredigion this was a fascinating video, thanks for sharing it. I'd never heard of Rheinwg before.

[@HarpsichordHymnsTimRemington]

Fascinating information! Thank you for all the research and interesting presentation.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@MrExtraordinaire16]

This video is entertaining as expected from your channel.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@MrExtraordinaire16]

@@CambrianChronicles can't tell a lie when your speaking the truth 😊

[@angusmurray3767]

Well explained, with good sound, no ums and ahs and informative. 10/10.

[@nozoto]

Also, one has to keep in mind that Antique kingdoms are not necessarily entities geographically fixed. Sometimes, an exceptional king guides the kingdom towards an era of conquest and sometimes the momentum is so low the ruler must sacrifice lands and shift the center of gravity of the kingdom elsewhere... Preferably on a more defendable location or one making administration simpler and quicker.

[@BacchusAdoneus]

Another great video about something (or even somewhere) that, as a Welshman, I knew nothing about. Diolch yn fawr!

[@CambrianChronicles]

Croeso! I'm glad you enjoyed it

[@glenchapman3899]

Thanks for this video, I love a good historical mystery!!! And by the way the paintings you used as the background to your presentation were simply gorgeous. I adore a good landscape, and stick some ruins in it - and I am all in lol

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it, and that you liked the paintings too! The Yale Centre for British Art has a bunch of public domain ones of Wales so I thought I'd change the background up rather than just showing a map all the time

[@dylanjones7485]

Being a north Powys guy I am so happy there is Welsh spreading around the world

[@newyorkshireman]

Extremely interesting good sir! Keep up the fantastic work.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@TY-km8hj]

Never heard about this or even really know much bout Welsh history but this was really interesting. U gained a subscriber, looking forward to more vids

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you! There's more to come

[@codywaller2840]

Ahh, an ending any seasoned CK3 player should have seen coming! Great video as always, keep up the great work!

[@ScrubbaDubDub]

Hello fellow CK3 gamer

[@Nommicus]

You did have folks living in different places with the same name, in this time Alliance Marriages were common. So you could have a King of a certain name in one place and their 3 Rd son could have the same name.

[@tvela595]

I greatly appreciate your listing of sources in the description!

[@alix9751]

That is a very interesting story and you presented it very well as well. I'm looking forward to what you will do next ^^

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@Ravie3]

Stuff like this makes me really appreciate the work historians do.

[@jago5193]

This was fascinating! Thanks for the video :)

[@CambrianChronicles]

You're welcome, thank you for watching!

[@Ennio444]

Fantastic and very satisfying presentation of the documentation. You make historiography thrilling.

[@RwandaBob]

medieval manuscripts are one of my favorite things because they capture the human imagination like nothing else we’re living in an age where information is so easy to find, but back in the middle ages and the dark ages it wasn’t like that. people had to fill in so many gaps of knowledge that so much interesting art and information emerged

[@lamename2010]

Please don't use the term "dark ages", that is enlightenment era word to try and put those who came before as simpletons and that in this new era of "enlightenment", they have moved past those "simple times". Modern-day historians are constantly lamenting about how pop-culture has embedded this term into the social subconscious, despite it being a falsehood.

[@Arcenus237J]

Damn this channel seems awesome. The video was informative and well produced about a niche topic explored academically and garnered a wide audience. Congrats!

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you so much!

[@_Dovar_]

Isn't it interesting, that if I was forced to learn about this in a public school, this would be unbearably boring. On KZbin, a short video made by a private scholar, someone who actually cares about subjects he teaches about - the same topic is made fascinating.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you so much, that's very kind of you and I'm really happy that I made it interesting

[@michellebell5092]

I find the beauty and fascination with History is that it’s always evolving. It’s not stuck in the past, History is really a present day phenomenon

[@Ksescel]

0:05 BIG SNAIL

[@awhite2501]

You just gave me so many missing peaces to the puzzle 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾 wow!

[@watermenlon3617]

someday people will think that Disneyland is a country where it is ruled by a giant mouse with talking animals

[@ebrim5013]

Never heard of this but fascinating video, thank you.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@theodorebear6714]

Very good work. I would ask Welsh people in the area and maybe take a trip to try to confirm landmarks like the roman settlement or something like that.

[@СолнечныйПарус-р7щ]

Thank you very STRONG for the intriguing presentation, interesting history and inquisitive coverage of the historical curiosity-paradox !!🤩🤩🤩😍🤗

[@joshpullman1690]

Loved the presentation, level attention to detail and the content. Great video 👍

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you so much, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@MKultraultimate]

your channel is growing a lot, congratulations I've been following since the beginning haha

[@RatelHBadger]

6:50 Who has 14 kidneys? Except a sheep farmer...

[@Sybil_Detard]

Thank you for the closed captioning.

[@WelshWing98]

Always thought Seisyllwg was North Ystrad Tywi (Llandeilo, Llandovery etc) and Rheinwg was South Ystrad Tywi (Kidwelly, Llanelli etc) Your theories are excellent though in terms of Dyfed and Brycheiniog.

[@BryantR372]

This is a very interesting topic and I’m glad that I watched.

[@angelahackman2522]

Great work, and Wales is very rarely mentioned in historic terms. The Cambrian Chronicle's tell of early Welsh history, sometimes known as Harlean. The actual name Wales apparently means foreigner, or stranger, which is an insult really. Cymru is the true name, with variants it can change, Khumry, Cimmeroi, and Cimmerian, as mentioned in the Odyssey. Scotland has Cumbria, Ireland was known as Hibernia. Yes lot's of Wales has disappeared, and the language is hanging on by a thread. There were 2 King Arthur's (allegedly) One from the 2nd or 3rd century, and the most famous one from the 5th century, but also hidden, like the disappearing lands.

[@Perceptious37]

This was a great video/format for mysteries in history. Would be cool to see this expanded to other stories throughout the past.

[@wintersking4290]

Is it possible some rulers were kings of Dafyd and Bracheniog, and that Rhainwg was the name for the unified kingdom of those two regions, which was formed sporadically when kings conquered one or the other?

[@drychaf]

Dyfed and Brycheiniog

[@KevinWarburton-tv2iy]

Very likely ...but not necessarily just all about conquest ...but could also be about lineage/inheritance. Sons of the High King could rule over sub-Kingdoms during their father's life/overlordship & seat of the High Kingship would shift depending on where the eldest son had his reign as sub-King with the sub-kingdom becoming the new centre of power.

[@ImKentos]

This is so interesting. Thank you for all the research, presentation and visualisation

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@resinks2269]

Rhein-wg meaning Rheinsland is for me as a german quite funny, since the region of germany Iam living in is called the Rheinland (the area around the river Rhein). Tho it has certainly nothing to do with the Rheinwg from the annales, since I doubt it was called this way in the 8th century, or that any King of Mercia could have had much interest in it.

[@CambrianChronicles]

That is very interesting, thank you for sharing! Hopefully we don't find evidence that they're connected, otherwise we'll have to re-theorise everything all over again haha

[@simonpentwyn]

Oh and again thanks for the prononciation. I assume you had coaching from a Welsh speaker ?

[@gaz8891]

The borders were never really secure in those days, and maybe that's why King Offa eventually built his famous wall separating Wales and England. The Anglo-Saxons (eg. Offa, King of Mercia) had conquered their English lands from the British, who had previously ruled the land for 2000 years and were then reduced to just controlling Wales. For a long time, the Welsh/British nobility regretted the loss of their ancient lands in England and would have taken the land back if they could. So the Anglo-Saxons always had a question over how much land to take from the British and a need to consider the threat from the remaining British in Wales.

[@rjdcarroll]

Great job! Lovely content mate!

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@takdangkasaysayan9098]

Well, I do wonder that lost kingdoms are actually very magical

[@donwayne1357]

Long live The Bangles.

[@gaz8891]

Yes, I can imagine. The idea of two parallel worlds separated by a wall, with an enchanted ancient Britain/Wales on one side and Anglo-Saxon England on the other is wonderfully captured in the film "Stardust." Sienna Miller plays the class-conscious English girl very well.

[@m.g.3013]

Love this channel! Do Strongbow next 😅

[@peterwindhorst5775]

There is another Rhain in the same area. Unfortunately, he is probably legendary than real. He is proposed as an ancestor of Merlin (yes, that one). Rhain - father of - > Maredydd -father of-> Meruig - father of -> Aldan - mother of -> Merlin (yes, that one). If this Rhain ever existed, he probably was a Déisi (or Irish pirate, using the term loosely) that was exiled from Ireland and set up a sub-kingdom inside Dyfed that was absorbed later.

[@jamth118]

Great video I’ve subscribed look forward to more of your videos

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you so much!

[@customfighter8575]

Something about this video is just so eerie

[@CambrianChronicles]

I find lost history to be inherently eerie personally, just the concept of something vanishing from everybody's collective memory is so unusual

[@gaz8891]

It's because we are not encouraged to know anything about Welsh history, a country which continued the heritage and culture of Ancient Britain into the medieval ages. The English spent a long time destroying the libraries of the Welsh princes, to try to make the Welsh/British submissive and make us all forget that there ever were kings such as King Arthur.

[@gaz8891]

@@CambrianChronicles You've described the feeling so well, thanks for that! Ancient British history is amazing, like opening lost doors to rooms in your house that you didn't know existed!

[@34Thel]

My name is Thélio, alternative spelling of Teilio, first time in my whole life that I hear my name spoken by a stranger, and even more strange that I heard it in a random video suggested by the algorithm while I try to sleep at 1am. Very good video tough, I subscribed

[@j.murphy4884]

I think the theory that this is a Lotheringa/Lorraine situation is the best one

[@JozefLucifugeKorzeniowski]

the process on display in this video is one of the crucial pillars of building a reasonably accurate history. through painstaking comparisons, morphing, and flexing the terms and names in seemingly disparate accounts. all built on a bedrock of previous knowledge acquired by this means. it's a grand Gordian knot and maybe will sort it out someday.

[@loke6664]

Well, that is history for you. We probably have solved this one but new evidence could pop up that changes everything at any time. The problem with the British isles during the dark ages is that there are so few written records from the time that we have to look to archaeological finds and folk lore, but folk lore isn't very reliable and unless the archaeologists find something rare with writing on it, they can't really tell us what something was called. And of course, archaeologists only have the funding to make so many digs over the entire British isles that most finds are found by accident when someone is building something like a highway and are being forced to pay for a survey before. Cymru is still a land filled with ancient mysteries but sometimes we get lucky and solve one of them. :)

[@levi9193]

This was such a delight to watch.

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@garyfrancis6193]

This is going to keep me awake at night. My ancestors come from there. Am I Rheinuchian? I’m already feeling the prejudice. I demand reparations.

[@CambrianChronicles]

I'm not sure what the demonym would've been, the Welsh took their names from their kingdoms rather than the other way around, "Rheinwyr" possibly?

[@Nawaz-Tahir]

Really well done. Especially the maps

[@brianmccarthy5557]

The southern Irish kingdom of Desmond was larger than the one you describe, was rather wealthy and it had relations with Continental powers. It was long ruled by my family in our traditional territories where many of us still live (personally I'm a native Southern Californian). Yet it's almosr entirely unknown to outsiders and some historians of southern Ireland.

[@orchunter8388]

The irish are known for uhhhm .. embellishments.

[@SportyMabamba]

Another plastic paddy, sad.

[@dariusgreysun]

Lies

[@beth7935]

@@aduantas Yeah, I've heard of Desmond, & I'm absolutely not an expert on Irish history, or Irish myself.

[@chernetsovdidnothingwrong565]

Native californians is native americans nations lol

[@annabelle_xoxx]

Comparing Old World architecture to the buildings we have today, I believe it wouldn't be far-fetched to say that perhaps we're not the most advanced civilization to inhabit the planet. If we take that into consideration, it would make sense that some of the kings were able to travel great distances.

[@avus-kw2f213]

It’s amazing how little we know about the past

[@drychaf]

Also, how much we do know.

[@avus-kw2f213]

@@drychaf that writing is a recent invention

[@welshed]

Awesome as always

[@CambrianChronicles]

Thank you!

[@supercooloz13]

Never knew Shaggy had his own kingdom!

[@GetRidOfCivilAssetForfeiture]

ZOINKS!!!!!

[@AndyZach]

Well done! Another medieval mystery solved.

[@wintersking4290]

Yep looks like you may have figured it out, it seems like the name of the personal union of those two other smaller kingdoms.

[@WhoIsCalli]

Great stuff, thanks for this

[@trulsdirio]

I grew up next to the river Rhine (wich is spelled Rhein in German). So this is doubly weird to me lol.

[@GeraldM_inNC]

Did you ever see any Rhine-maidens?

[@promontorium]

The Rhine was named by the Celts, and then that name was modified by Roman and German language influences. The Welsh experienced the same, Celtic named modified by Roman then German language influences. So their similarity might in part be because of the linguistic similarity in their history. Or maybe just a coincidence with a sprinkle of linguistic origin similarity.

[@GeraldM_inNC]

@@promontorium thanks, I wasn't aware of that.

[@through-faith-alone]

@@promontoriumit's not that deep, alternate spellings of the same thing in multiple languages isn't that deep