Can children be punished for sins of their parents?

Jew explains.
Sources:
"You shall not prostrate yourself before them, nor worship them, for I, the Lord your God, am a zealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the sons, upon the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me." (Deuteronomy 5:9).
"The soul that sins, it shall die; a son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, and a father shall not bear the iniquity of the son; the righteousness of the righteous shall be upon himself, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon himself." (Ezekiel 18:20).
"A bastard shall not enter the assembly of the Lord; even the tenth generation shall not enter the assembly of the Lord." (Deuteronomy 23:3).

[@iskandariacordoba]

I'm here to thank the Rabbi for the beautifully articulated words which he shared conserning the concept of HaShem and Allah in both belief systems... Thank You...

[@insaanietihad-MSB]

Thank you Brother for this video, and explaination for the law.

[@MirMahmud2003]

Thanks brother for such a crystal clear explanation.Salam from Bangladesh 🇧🇩.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

My pleasure brother!

[@Ahmad859]

You are my favourite Jewish Rabbai may Allah bless you in this world and after the world (day of judgment)

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Thank you, I'm not a rabbi though. Just a regular Jew.

[@aaronharun1394H]

And no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another. And if a heavily laden soul calls to its load, nothing of it will be carried, even if he should be a close relative. (Al-Quran 35: 18)

[@elfenomeno5498]

Could u do a video about the atonement of intentionally and unintentionally sins? Am I right that in the torah animal sacrfices were only for UNINTENTIONALLY SINS and for specific sins like sins against the temple? But for the majority of sins, intentionally sins, the only way for atonement was always to repent to God?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Yes. That is correct.

[@violetsho]

Ezekiel 18:20 - Only the one who sins will die. A child won't bear a parent's guilt, and a parent won't bear a child's guilt.

[@Aliabbashassan3402]

Watching u from Baghdad.. Greetings

[@SameerKhan-sn3hs]

Thank you Sir. Your cousin from Islam. Love and Respect for you. Salam Shalom

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Salam/Shalom cousin 💓

[@amberking1434]

How does this work for adopted children? Do we have to break the cycle of our parents that adopted us or a birth parents or both?

[@abc_6]

Every child is born sinless, the sins from the child’s forefathers will never be passed down the new generation unless he/she repeats what the forefathers did. Muslim theologians explain man’s nature at birth as fitrah: state of intrinsic goodness. Like Adam, people are born pure and sinless. They are Muslims by birth, and salvation is intact, but they must do all in their power to maintain this status. Everyone is “accountable for what he himself inscribes upon the unblemished Tabula Rasa or tablet of his nature.” - Robert W. Thomas, Islam: Aspects and Prospects a Critical Analysis, 41. Muslims reject the doctrine of original sin and cannot accept that death ensured; it was a natural process built into creation (23:14-16). They may even quote the Bible that people are responsible for their own deeds: “The person who sins will die. The son will not bear the punishment for the father’s iniquity, nor will the father bear the punishment for the son’s iniquity; the righteousness of the righteous will be upon himself, and the wickedness the wicked will be upon himself” (Ezekiel 18:20). They reason it would be unjust for God to punish all humanity because of Adam’s deed. Sin is not hereditary and no one born a sinner.

[@phenomenal17playz]

"Parents shall not die for the sins of children nor the children will not die for the sins of parents. Every man will die for their own sins." (Deuteronomy 24:16) "The father shall not suffer the iniquity of the son nor the son shall suffer the iniquity of the father. The righteousness of the righteous shall be upon himself and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon himself. If the wicked turns away from all sins which he had commited will surely live." (Ezekiel 18:20-22) Hashem loves us and he wants us to repent from all our bad deeds.

[@SyedMuhammadMoaz3634]

No 😨 in regards to Capital punishment but spiritually In Scripture, we are told that Abraham “took the ram and sacrificed it as a burnt offering instead of his son.” (Genesis 22:13) Is it not enough that God provided a ram? Rashi asks, “Why does Scripture also say, ‘instead of his son’?” These four words don’t have to be there. Or do they? Rashi, one of the most revered and often quoted Jewish sage explains why it’s important to know that the ram is offered instead of Isaac: "Over every sacrificial act that he [Abraham] performed, he prayed, ‘May it be [Your] will that this should be deemed as if it were being done to my son: as if my son were slaughtered, as if his blood were sprinkled, as if my son were flayed, as if he were burnt and reduced to ashes.” (Tan. Shelach 14] If Rashi is correct, then every time Abraham sacrificed a lamb or goat, he thought in his mind and heart that he were slaughtering his own son Isaac and sprinkling his blood over the altar.

[@mth469]

I am not even Jewish yet I'm subscribed to this channel. Please keep making videos rabbi and consider making more generic videos for non-Jews as well please. Your audience will grow.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Thank you for your comment. I'm not a rabbi. Just a regular Jew. What religion do you follow (if you don't mind sharing)?

[@mth469]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 Shalom. I'm an "idol worshipper" the good book warns you against associating. However I find our communities have much in common. We are also family based, have high regards for academic education, save money for the future, celebrate joyous festivals, and earn our living honestly. Just like Jews we have been killed by the millions by marauders and robbers throughout history because of the general belief in non-violence. But just like Jews we are becoming strong and have put a stop to it. There are areas of differences, but few.

[@abc_6]

@@mth469 not only his book, my book is even tougher 💊 to swallow in regards to associating partners with god. Please brother, avoid idolatry as much as u can otherwise you will be off the straight path. God bless 🤲

[@anastasiesasmr9805]

@@mth469 Are u a hindu?

[@AquaBird-FCM02]

Jesus is true! ✝️ I pray y’all find the truth. God bless 👍

[@onmycaballo2628]

1:05 that would be a explanation for the secret meaning of "A Serious Man"

[@محمد-م9د3ش]

I have a question: Are there Jewish sects that allow the division of inheritance and the work of a woman in a Halal Judaism and a halal travel because Islam Death insulted a woman explicitly, and my sister refused to come to have a son, and he must have a brother to take inheritance. Is there a solution that takes equal inheritance or sects that can be answered because it is a Jewish nation, my sister is apostate of Islam?

[@samphonnetgamgee5625]

How to counter "pagan blessings" of loving but unchangeable parents? Is it enough to just not thank?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Sorry I didn't understand the question.

[@aishamuhammad7094]

Shalom Brother (was it snowing? feel cold watching the video). I hope you (family) had great Hanukkah. How did you celebrate Hanukkah? How do people around the world/different traditions celebrate Hanukkah? Happy holidays to you and your family.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Thank you sister. I don't remember. It may have snowed a little. The way we celebrate it is by lighting candles for 8 days to commemorate the miracle G-d did for our ancestors.

[@mousamuneebexplorer]

I think there are great similarities between the Muslims, Christians and Jews

[@Ari114]

Good points about punishment and consequences. There is a difference. A great topic to ponder about. Shabbat Shalom!

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Shabbat Shalom akhi.

[@Ari114]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 Thanks Bro. Hanukkah Sameach to You and your Family.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

@@Ari114 chanukah Sameach to you and your family akhi.

[@hashemahmed1402]

Shalom Brother , thanks for explanation . I have a question , what is the point that eating pork not allowed in Judaism? Also for other animals, In Islam adopting dogs or pigs is not allowed , is it the same in Judaism?

[@abc_6]

Actually adopting dogs in ur garden for security is permissible in Islam so long that u don’t bring the dog inside ur home. My grandad kept a dog in his garden for security incase someone broke in

[@FarhanShaikh-ru7ri]

With who you was discussing he was jew Christian or muslim?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

I think Christian but not sure.

[@vykintasjocys6401]

I like your 1900's Ashkenazi style.

[@lipazdotan4021]

Jeremiah 31:28 Also, We can see it's snowing where you are, hoping you keep yourself warm. Here in Eretz HaKodesh there is non stop raining, Baruch Hashem. Take care.

[@mohdshoaib1803]

Hello god pray

[@awatefeid792]

Hi...I have just a question...in the Jews book, God was very upset that Adam ate from the tree, so Eve was punished by labour, and man will rule over her...etc. If you look at the story in the Muslim book, it is different. God decides to create a representative on Earth so Adam is created and when Adam made a slip, it is just a slip not a Major error, God forgave him, then they had come down to the Earth because Life is not punishment, Already God created them to be on Earth and such a slip Adam committed signaled his earthly life. Then God tells them Follow my guidance and you will never have fear or regret....In. Fact, The book of Muslims is so marvellous. It connects Reason with Faith. It touches the heart....well, can Joseph brothers use a donkey to travel to Egypt...how come...in the Qur'an they used the camals which shows that

[@awatefeid792]

In the Qur'an, stories of the prophets differs from that in the Jews and Christians book...gives accurate narration which does not contradict with scientific facts. You can read books for Dr. Jeffrey Lang, an American Mathematical professor at the university of Cansas, entitled: Surrender to Faith. Even the Angels ask. The prophet life is not mentioned in the Qur'an, while the Book tackles the nature of the Human Being, our heart, our fears... everything... The purpose of life... How many Jews or even Christians memorize their holy book verse by verse, letter by letter... I know that Torah and Bible contain right things to some extent but what is more obvious is that they contain false thing written by people. When God gave them the book, they distorted it. So God told his prophet Muhammad that He (God) will save the Book. Actually, this happens nothing can be changed in the Qur'an ... It is in the hearts even of the children. We even love death more than life ... Why because we love God, truly love the most merciful, the most compassionate and our prophet told us that we will see God in the hereafter.... Yeah, we do not fear death... Simply, because we love our Lord more than anything else and Jerusalem will be entered by us for the second time...

[@mysticsmith4067]

Do you have a discord in which we could chat through, if not I highly suggest getting one in general.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Sorry I don't. You can search for my channel name on Facebook.

[@amirulafiq4371]

Hello sir can you explain the purpose of the guilt offering? Is it meant to atone for specific sins?

[@jasonssavitt5297]

The Guilt offerings or (Asham) was usually for the destruction of property, desecration of holy items, and perjury. It was also used as atonement for sins that a person committed in ignorance but then came to aware of his error. Money had to be given to the offended party before the offender made the Asham , as according to Jewish beliefs a person cannot atone for his sins unless he had made things right as God would not accept his offering.

[@amirulafiq4371]

@@jasonssavitt5297 What's the difference between committing a sin in ignorance and unintentionally? I understand that the latter was to be atoned through the sin offering.

[@sahin.Tunc.]

Quran 2:133Is it that you were present when death approached Ya‘qūb, when he said to his sons: “What will you worship after me”? They said, “We will worship your God and the God of your fathers, Ibrāhīm, Ismā‘īl (Ishmael) and IsHāq (Isaac), the one God, and to Him we submit ourselves.” Quran 3:95 Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “Allah has declared the truth. So follow the Way of Abraham, the upright-who was not a polytheist.”

[@محمد-م9د3ش]

I have a question whether I can convert to Judaism without a Jewish mother and whether Judaism allows equal inheritance and equal between male and female.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Yes, one can convert even if one has no Jewish parents. The inheritance is not equal. First born boy gets double portion. Daughters only inherit if there are no sons.

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 there seems to be a misconception regarding that one must have a Jewish mother in order to convert to Judaism, why rabbis in the past suggested this and is there any evidence to support their claim that one must have a Jewish mother to convert to Judaism?

[@aramaicjew3212]

@@abc_6the main reason was to avoid pagans from joining judaism

[@abc_6]

@@aramaicjew3212 I highly doubt that since anyone can convert as long as he/she is dedicated to the faith, being a former pagan shouldn’t prevent one from converting since he/she is seeking the straight path

[@alurusandeep5574]

I heard in Talmud it stated rabis argued with God and God admits he is wrong is it true?????

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Not true. It's misinterpreted.

[@alurusandeep5574]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 Ok thanks for giving clarity assalamualaikum

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

@@deen6008 watched small part of it. Sadly, many Muslims have also assimilated. They now have reform Muslims where the Imam is a woman without a hijab.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

@@deen6008 sometimes I'm amazed that there are Orthodox Jews who lived in USA for 10 generations and yet they didn't assimilate. I know some families that are here from the civil war, and yet they've kept their Jewish religious identity. One thing Jews are good at is (at least some of them), is resisting assimilation. I can't think of any other group of people that lived as minority scattered among others for 2000 years and yet still kept their identity and religion. Ishtabach Shmo Laad!

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 Imam women without hijab? interesting 🤔

[@FreeDom4Us1]

Brorher Aaron pls would u tell us how one can stop the sins of their parents?

[@fullstop.1407]

Rabbi mousques are built facing the kabba so if a Jew prays in a mosque is it considered as idol worship?

[@mysticsmith4067]

The Kaaba is just a direction of worship so that Muslims pray unified, nothing to do with idol worship.

[@fullstop.1407]

@@mysticsmith4067 why then u kiss the black stone? And kising any type of stone is prohibited in the hewish bible

[@mysticsmith4067]

@@fullstop.1407 Because it is something sacred and holy as we believe it was originally built by Adam AS then rebuilt by Abraham AS and Ismail AS so we respect it, I'll give u a hadith that will answer your doubts about it being an object of worship. ‘Abis ibn Rabi’ah reported: Umar ibn al-Khattab, may Allah be pleased with him, came to the black stone and he kissed it. Umar said, “Verily, I know you are only a stone with no power to harm or benefit me. Were it not that I saw the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, kiss you, I would not have kissed you.” This should end any speculation regarding the common Kaaba worship myth that has been debunked 1000+ times.

[@fullstop.1407]

You shall not make idols for yourselves or erect an image or pillar, and you shall not set up a figured stone in your land to bow down to it, for I am the Lord your God. -Leviticus 26:1

[@fullstop.1407]

@@mysticsmith4067 How can lifeless stone be sacred?

[@Mindovermatter0001]

Our father (Hashem) who art in heaven Hallowed be you're name. Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven. Give us this day our daily bread and forgive us our trespasses. As we forgive those who trust pass against us. And lead us not into temptation. But deliver us from evil. For thine is the kingdom and power and the glory for ever and ever. Amen

[@abc_6]

It’s Alaha for god in Aramaic = ܐܠܗܐ

[@abc_6]

This proves that Moses, Jesus and Muhammad peace be upon them all worshipped the exact same god.💯

[@abc_6]

No idol nothing like that

[@Mindovermatter0001]

@@abc_6 ✝️💪🔥Jesus > muhammad

[@Mindovermatter0001]

@@abc_6 True Alaha is aramaic. Generic title for God just like for God in arabic Allah. Jesus spoke aramaic but more like a galilean dialect. And I don't worship idols btw

[@jupiter9048]

Adam (peace be upon him) was the first man in the world and the first prophet - those who did not believe in him - actually benefited from religion

[@kurdishman7819]

Shalom aleicm bro I was going to ask something. We Muslims say that God is only one. and we say that jesus christ is not god. God is invisible, unmatched, God is everywhere. but Christians say that Jesus Christ is god. Do all Jews think the same as Muslims?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Aleichem Shalom. Yes. All Jews who follow Judaism think that. There is a question whether G-d is within this universe or outside of this universe but that's a whole different discussion.

[@kurdishman7819]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 Jews and Muslims think right. But Christians are wrong. because God is one. and stronger than anything. Jesus Christ is only a prophet. but Jesus is not god. Christians eat pork. but god doesn't want us to eat pork the only true religions is Islam and Judaism 🌹

[@abc_6]

@@kurdishman7819 u Kurdish like me?, chonit bashit bra

[@abc_6]

@@kurdishman7819 which part u from

[@kurdishman7819]

@@abc_6 başım te çavani bra. İm from north Kurdistan ( Anatolia)

[@josephbenadam]

Hashem is an invented word. It's Elohim not Hashem

[@anastasiesasmr9805]

Hello my jewish brothers and sisters!A very happy chanukkah/hanukkah to y'all!I am an Atheist ex-muslim from India.And I admire the jewish spirit of preserving their cultures,traditions and religion from opressive christian and muslim rulers.Especially muslim rulers.I left Islam and became an Atheist when i was 16.I wish i had become one when I was 10 and had maturity back then.But what is done is done,and there is no changing it.Better look forward to the future!Many of my ancestors were also hindu who were forcefully subjugated and made muslims against their will.Now I am re-honoring their history by being an Atheist (sanatam dharma is compatible and ok with atheism.Hinduism has it's own form of atheism,whereby u can be a hindu and an atheist at the same time.But still,I am happy with just being a modern secular humanist atheist).Even in modern-day Afghanistan,Jews are being subjugated and being converted into islam.In fact,I saw a video somewhere of a only a single jewish man being alive.I thinkn he was also killed by the taliban recently i am not sure.I light candles for hanukkah everyday!Even tho my fascist,islamist,authotitarian father is against it.And i will continue to do so every year ;D I celebrate it in a secular manner,without reciting the blessings while lighting candles.For me,hanukkah is a celebration about bringing family together and having fun time that u can reminisce about in the future!With that being said,Happy Hanukkah to you!And stay away from islam!

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Have you thought about becoming a Noahide? This is the oldest religion. It simply states that all humans who are descendants of Noah PBUH are to observe 7 commandments that G-d gave to Noah.

[@anastasiesasmr9805]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 well as an atheist,I believe there isn't enough compelling evidence for the existence of god to make believe in one

[@abc_6]

@@anastasiesasmr9805 Quran clearly condems forcefully converting anyone here’s ur proof, “Let there be no compulsion in religion, for the truth stands out clearly from falsehood. So whoever renounces false gods and believes in Allah has certainly grasped the firmest, unfailing hand-hold. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing”. Quran ch2 v256

[@Ari114]

Agreed. Unfortunately, history is filled with too many instances of Islamic persecution towards Jewish, Samaritan, Christian and other Levantine communities. As the Brother stated, you should look into the Noahide Laws. There maybe some points that you can begin to implement in your life.

[@kurdishman7819]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 bro rapea rapay is an atheist. This person does not believe in god. He who does not accept God is foolish. The god of Abraham Isaac and Jacob is the true god. blessed is he who believes in god 🌹

[@Bisamkhanz8]

I am really impressed to listening you. I really want to read Talmud Urdu version.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

I doubt they have it in Urdu.

[@abc_6]

You should try reading תורה first otherwise your skipping.

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 🇸🇦 translated the Quran into Hebrew language, however it was taken down since it contained over 300 errors, many were mistranslated due to human error I guess it’s not that simple to translate every vowel, letter and story from Classical Arabic to Hebrew😒

[@abc_6]

Inshallah one day they will

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

@@abc_6 most Israelis freely speak English anyways

[@maimohamed7065]

I hope that you have read the Quran.

[@Bhatbarkat7]

Why don't you make any video about dajjal.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

We don't have such a concept in Judaism

[@Bhatbarkat7]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 But we do.

[@Bhatbarkat7]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 U need to know him

[@aramaicjew3212]

@@Bhatbarkat7 dont beleive on dajjal and saithan only god exits its created in bible its fake. only prophets exists neither a fake anti god and anti prophet i hope u seperate quran from bible just free it and u will be a jew a true follower of avraham mosche and elohim

[@Bhatbarkat7]

@@aramaicjew3212 u will never accept the truth

[@FreeDom4Us1]

Assalamu alaykum all... Allow me to deconstruct all points brother Aaron brought here, while he won't reply, but hope he does learn... 😊❤️🤲 First of all, instead of focus on one topics to answer his friend's question "Can children be punished for the sins of their parents?" Aaron kept hopping on many topics in fallacious ways, and unknowingly he answered his abrogation topic question of the last video. Since there is a verse that says children would be punished, and another verse says the converse, therefore, this looks like a clear contradiction or an abrogated law depends on which verse claimed to be written first. 2nd, we know all resolutions in Talmud are just rabbis own conclusions & self exciggeses based on their understanding & agendas.

[@Mafia_マフィア]

so in Judaism & islam it's Ḥawwāh, and in Christianity is Eve?

[@abc_6]

Hawwa in Islam and Judaism is Eve in English

[@johannernold1000]

Eve /iːv/ is an English given name for a female, derived from the Latin name Eva, in turn originating with the Hebrew חַוָּה (Chavah/Havah - chavah, to breathe, and chayah, to live, or to give life). The traditional meaning of Eve is life or "living". It can also mean full of life and mother of life.

[@abc_6]

@@johannernold1000 good one!

[@maimohamed7065]

You believe in only one god , do you believe that Muhammed is the last prophet ?

[@followerofg-d851]

They will not believe in Muhammad because if they believe him they also have to believe in Jesus which they are not gonna do

[@furkan1139]

Shalom bro. Do you think the story of Adam and Eve in Islam is true or is the story of Adam and Eve in Judaism true? please can you answer? You what the believe is story bro

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

I believe the story in the Torah is true. I don't know the story in the Quran.

[@furkan1139]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397In the Qur'an, it says that the devil is a very powerful person, the devil is the commander of the jinn. punishing the unbelievers. Then he came to heaven and saw that Adam and Eve were created on earth. He saw that Adam and Eve were great. He didn't want God to make Adam and Eve great. heard the story of the god's forbidden tree. Then she got jealous of Adam and Eve and asked her to eat the fruit of the forbidden tree. so it happened. Then he said to God that I am superior, created from fire, but Adam and Eve were created from dust. He said he was lower than me. Then God punished the devil and two people. The devil is cursed. and Adam and Eve were also expelled from paradise. Adam and Eve prayed to God. He said, Lord forgive us. God said then that you and your descendants in the world should worship me until I die. let them be on my right path so that I can give heaven

[@furkan1139]

Satan was jealous of Adam and Eve. he said to god I tricked them into the forbidden tree. give me time Let me deceive the whole family of Adam and Eve. let me and test all people so that they will all worship you or not. God accepted the deal. sent to the world

[@furkan1139]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 bro, read the quran too. search for god. I search for God every day. I read the Torah, I read the psalms and the Bible. People have changed the scriptures over time, but there are similarities. I think you should read the holy books every day. with love and reverence the god of the prophet Abraham hashem, Allah, Eloh the only creator ❤️🌹

[@GarmentofEsau]

The Zohar YITRO 518. It is written, "Punishing the iniquity of the fathers upon the children to the third and fourth generation" (Shemot 20:5). HE WAS PRESENTED WITH THE DIFFICULTY OF THE WORDS, "NOR THE CHILDREN BE PUT TO DEATH FOR THE FATHERS" (II MELACHIM 14:6). AND HE ANSWERS THAT this is the same tree, THE SAME SOUL coming once, twice, thrice, four times, WHICH MEANS IT HAD BEEN INCARNATED AND COME IN FOUR BODIES, being punished for the first sins IN THE FOURTH REINCARNATION. For the father, the son, the third and fourth generations, NAMELY THESE FOUR INCARNATIONS, are one, BEING ONE SOUL that has not done its correction or cared to attend to it. IT IS THEREFORE PUNISHED FOR THE SINS IN THE FIRST INCARNATIONS. The reverse is also true. A tree well established THROUGH INCARNATIONS stands firm, AND OF IT, IT IS WRITTEN, "But showing mercy..." (Shemot 20:5).

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

I heard this explanation too.

[@GarmentofEsau]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 This is the SOD of the matter. As it is written..... JEREMIAH 31 In those days they shall say no more, The fathers have eaten a sour grape, and the children's teeth are set on edge. But every one shall die for his own iniquity: every man that eateth the sour grape, his teeth shall be set on edge. Behold, the days come, saith the LORD, that I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel, and with the house of Judah:

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

I think on the Pshat level it's still talking about regular (biological) children, not the gilgul of the neshama. What do you think?

[@GarmentofEsau]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 I don't think is possible to be Just the biological children, it has to be the Soul of the person who sinned. Or else justice would not be upheld. For it is written the sons cannot pay for the fathers sins, nor the fathers pay for the sins of the children, each man must atone for his own sin. Deuteronomy 24:16) “Fathers shall not be put to death for their sons, nor shall sons be put to death for their fathers; everyone shall be put to death for his own sin. (JOB 21:19) It is said, ‘God stores up the punishment of the wicked for their children.’ Let him repay the wicked, so that they themselves will experience it!

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

@@GarmentofEsau but Rashi says it's only when children are not repeating the sins of parents. Otherwise, they would get punished. What is wrong with that logic?

[@musaschannel8868]

The consequence of sin and not the punishment theory is more of playing vid words. Brother u call it punishment or consequence, it has adverse effects in the shape of suffering. Is it Divinely just to make suffer the children of parents who committed a sin ? whether u call it punishment or consequence. Common sense says NO. Unfortunately this discriminate theory is in line vid human attributes thus created by them. Allah’s justice is very very clear, everyone is responsible for his/her own deeds n not anyone else may b parents. In Islam all humans are equal n all Muslims whether converts or other can marry each other.?Even Muslim men can marry Jewish n Christian ladies.

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Brother, So tell me can a child be punished for the sin of the parents?

[@ginarios9442]

The Messiah (Genesis/BRASHYT) came and spoke with ABRaHM, after ABRaHM won the war and rejected the offer from King Sodom . ABRaHM would not take except that which the warriors earned in the warfare and he would not allow King Sodom to have the people. Then ABRaHM was met by MLK TSDQ (King Righteous). MLK TSDQ is the Messiah and He told ABRaHM, speaking about the Father, Creator, "AL GLYUN. QNaH SHMYM UARTS" (Most High. Maker of heavens and earth.) The Messiah also came (Book of Joshua/Yahushua), as the Captain of Yah's Army. Yahushua asked if He is for or against them and the Captain of Yah's Army said neither, that He is for Hayah. He came in the latter writings as the PSH Lamb, and rose from death to life, and presented Himself as the First Fruits, to the Father, telling Myriam (not His mom, but another), that He must not delay, but present Himself to the Father. He is our Kinsman Redeemer. ANY M SHBTe SHL GD, BNY YSHRAL (I am from tribe of GD, BNY YSHRAL). Please ask the Messiah to be your personal Savior. He is the ONLY way to Everlasting Life.

[@AnonymousFreek]

My dear Best Jewish rabbi I bet And mark my words my Dua is u and your whole family becomes Muslim and your life being a muslim will be alot tough mark my words because this world is like hell for believers and believe me it is 🙂 but you will be a muslim 🙂

[@maimohamed7065]

And whoever desires a religion other than Islam, it shall not be accepted from him, and in the hereafter he shall be one of the losers.quran Al imran chapter verse 85

[@towards_submission]

Man...!!! Your Ideas are more Islamic than the Jewish... While the Both the Verses Differ each other But you Explained in a way it what Islam TOLD us... We Believe that G-D cannot contradict... it clearly shows that these Books are No more Reliable Except Quran which is the ONLY Reliable Authentic Words of ALLAH....

[@FreeDom4Us1]

God Almighty sw would never says what's in Deu 23:3, He is the most wise and merciful and never would burden innocents for others' sins? Aaron see how.jews / judaism describe God Almighty, while they claim they fear Him... think about it.

[@AnonymousFreek]

My dear Best Jewish rabbi I bet And mark my words my Dus is u and your whole family becomes Muslim and your life being a muslim will be alot tough mark my words because this world is like hell for believers and believe me it is 🙂 but you will be a muslim 🙂

[@abc_6]

שלום עליכם אהרן

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

עליכם שלום

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 אהרן, I’ve heard you before say that ur not allowed to say gods name, if that’s true then how come ur الله אלהallowed to say.

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 for that too is gods holy name

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

@@abc_6 we are allowed to say God's name just not in vain. So whenever we teach,learn Torah, or pray we can pronounce his name. The Only name we never pronounce is the holiest one (tetragrammaton).

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 😳

[@bobbyc465]

Keep your Adam and Eve with you. Don’t apply to the entire world. People are different and they don’t believe you’re fairytale stories

[@FreeDom4Us1]

The book written in the name of Ezekiel pbuh, is full of examples that answer ur question... Aaron brought false analogy to prove his saying that one should differ between consequence and punishment, while the first thing one should do, is Define words accordingly to know what u're talking about. Punishment & consequence aren't and don't mean same things... Gentiles would never be counted as Jews even if converted/adopted judaism following all Orthodox as well as Definition & rulings of rabbis from other sects too. Many Falasha (Ethiopian Jews by lineage/blood) as they describe themselves are still suffering racism & injustice in colonial Israel)... Judaism failed coz of the racist men made-up rabbinical decisions, while hiding behind Noahide laws that they've got no evidences / clues about...

[@furkan1139]

God of name = İslam; Allah, ellah, el-ilah, elah, yahuwellah Jewish; Elah, Eloh, yahweheloh İslam; one god ❤️🌹 Jewish; one god❤️🌹