Can I Solve 'Batman The Long Halloween' Before The Reveal?

[@chasebridges]

I tried out something new for this one. Not sure how I feel about the green screen 😂😂 Let me know what you guys prefer

[@jazz7903]

I think i like the actual detective wall better 😭😭

[@heyspeckle8782]

I prefer the detective wall over the green screen

[@maxmfpayne]

I like the detective wall, kinda adds to the whole thing ya got going on. Maybe you could get one of the ones that roll around and keep the green screen in the background.

[@zeroisnine]

I like both

[@daniphea]

@@maxmfpayne that's very detective coded 💯

[@maggiegermann1724]

"Who commits crimes on holidays? Someone who doesn't already have plans" is an extremely raw line

[@presicionn962]

I heard the vine boom in my head

[@kiwi_arms]

sounds like something adam west batman would say fr

[@ottorasanen1575]

This one is too easy. The Holiday Killer is clearly Andy the Crying Cop!

[@chasebridges]

ON GOD

[@Nghtcrawlr-ts4mh]

WTH why’d you have to spoil it?!?🤦

[@sarahndipity_7]

my favorite running gag on this channel

[@darklighter66]

Rewatching Twin Peaks and as soon as Andy showed up......

[@Collector557]

He didn't spoil it. He's joking.​@@Nghtcrawlr-ts4mh

[@bort6459]

To answer a question you had at the end: The reason Calendar Man is involved is as a narrative device. He's basically a greek chorus to provide exposition and remind the stakes/emotion of the situation. Remember the original work was a 13 part comic series. Having Calendar Man show up every few issues to recap the mystery and occasionally add a ticking clock is more entertaining than having Batman talk to the bad computer every act break.

[@covereye5731]

Wasn't he also jealous of Holiday in the comics for stealing his thing and tried to kill them? That would explain why Two-Face didn't break him out, because maybe Two Face figured out who Holiday was and didn't want Calendar coming after them?

[@mangaman70]

He's also extremely important in the sequel story

[@funkyreapercat5280]

​@@mangaman70What is the sequel story called?

[@ItsButterBean1020]

It’s also a clear homage to Silence of the Lambs and works as worldbuilding, implying a hidden history between Calendar Man and Batman

[@GarrettTheViking]

​@funkyreapercat5280 Dark Victory is the sequel. It's really good. Worth a read.

[@pedrogarcia8706]

I think the fact that the gun silencers are baby bottle tops is a very deliberate choice. She keeps saying she can't have a baby so that makes the baby bottle silencers very meaningful

[@Means_Of_Production]

Wait Bruce wayne, the billionare playboy, is the Batman? Fat chance.

[@AlaricXIII]

THE BUTTS MATCH!!!

[@NyctoPhobia197]

If Bruce Wayne is Batman, then im the king of England !!

[@Cortex28]

Next you’ll say that Clark Kent is Superman

[@error-err-1016]

​@@Cortex28 imagine if people said that Oliver Queen was Green Arrow next 😂

[@justadude450]

​@Bio_Vortex Nah, Bruce Wayne is Superman. They practically look exactly the same

[@BearlyAwake13]

I feel like falling for the red herring should be less of a letdown when Batman himself did too tbh

[@jobhunter5090]

TBF batman is far more Watson than Sherlock in this story. There are clear problems with the logic that Alberto is the holiday killer or at least the only holiday killer.

[@jasongreen6826]

@@jobhunter5090I feel like your only saying that because you know the actual answer in hindsight

[@jobhunter5090]

@@jasongreen6826 I mean i do know the answer, but no i was referring to Watson's use as a literary device for keeping the audience on track. But had batman been acting in a sherlock role he'd have made a flawless deduction and there would be no ambiguity

[@somenerd7046]

This is another solid one, I personally like the red thread wall photo sections more than the green screen, but the presentation looks solid as always, keep it up chase!

[@ProXyZomBiE69]

Same here, it would be interesting if he used to green to simulate that having the characters on the board instead of having that background with random papers and the images of the characters. It would be more legible

[@aaronlutz5560]

In the original, Alberto was one of the holiday killer(s) and faked his own death, so the “twist” in part 1 was to throw off fans who had read the comic when watching the movie. Don’t feel bad about the red herring!

[@josephfox7068]

So kind of like the book "And Then There Were None"

[@sarafontanini7051]

does mean we lose the scene of alberto and calender man shouting at each other though

[@kalkuttadrop6371]

In the original comic it's intentional vague, with Alberto, Harvey, and Gilda all suspected to have been at least partially involved

[@donniejefferson9554]

Its vague but there is definitely am answer to exactly who was behind it. It does still involve all three of them to some extent though

[@oliverthedum2129]

@@donniejefferson9554I think that gilda commited the first or the first few holiday murders, Alberto took over for the majority of the murders, and Harvey unintentionally finished the job by killing falcone.

[@donniejefferson9554]

@oliverthedum2129 Yeah exactly. Happen on New Year's Eve. There's a pattern break (2 killings in December) and then Harvey comes home with wet hair right after a killing on a boat. Gilda thinks Harvey did it and just leaves the killing to "him" after that point.

[@fedweezy4976]

​​@@oliverthedum2129 Gilda did Halloween (one falcone to start it), Thanksgiving (revenge for the murder attempt), Christmas (again, weakening the falcones). Dent does New Years (picks up where Gilda left off) this is all explicitly stated by Gilda (although she could've misattributed the new years eve murder to Dent just bc of the hair. After new years and starting on Valentine's Day (Alberto's Birthday) the killings shift to the Maronis because Alberto takes up the identity of Holiday. Then all the killings after (except maybe April fools bc the silhouette looks like a woman's) are Alberto either killing Maroni's men or covering his tracks (coroner and Carla). Though everything after the arms dealer is ambiguous imo. Yes Alberto had motive to kill the coroner, but they mention that Holiday had to be someone who the coroner knew in order to get that close, and Dent is the only one who fits that description. Same with the arms dealer, he mentioned he got one order every month, any one of them could've killed him. Carla might've been killed by Alberto to cover his tracks, or it could've been Dent or Gilda just killing her because she's a Falcone.

[@Coconut_Prrson]

it's Alberto and Gilda. There are two Holiday killers

[@taylynhopkins]

You cracking the comic book to a T vs the movie is so heart wrenching to watch. Talking about someone’s motives and it was on the head just for a different iteration of the story

[@guywiththeweirdspellingoflogen]

Alberto was there entirely to trigger your ‘accuse that guy everyone overlooks/underestimates(Andy the crying cop)’ instincts, don’t feel bad about following them lol

[@MichaelHeide]

In the comic book, it WAS Alberto!

[@creed8712]

@@MichaelHeideit was for some

[@MichaelHeide]

@@creed8712 Yeah, but I didn't want to get into the details. It's spoilerish enough (for an over 25 year old story) as it is.

[@creed8712]

@ that does make me wonder if he could figure out the watchmen twist though that one might be to well known

[@CassidyDylyn]

​@@MichaelHeide Not quite. The solution of Gilda Dent is still in The Long Halloween comic book, Alberto was revealed to be the true Holiday Killer in Dark Victory.

[@anne-zh2kd]

I think you should do Agatha Christie. Because there are actual clues in those. Something like Pretty little liars seems like it was an ass-pull with no clues. But maybe you know all of those already. I really like the green screen with clips from the movie. I just worry about copyright. But I really love it. My ADHD brain likes it.

[@ghostlobster6631]

Omg you're right, one of these videos on Christie would be amazing

[@mama_lyra5598]

PLL was pretty much an ass pull. the audience had guessed who A was and the showrunners wanted to go “AHA!! GOTCHA!!!” so they kept changing it

[@essaysandmore]

I’d recommend at Bertram’s Hotel. That’s a lesser known Miss Marple and the BBC adaptation is pretty good.

[@ikimeht]

Yeah watching Chase put more thought into who made sense as a killer than the showrunners ever did was both hilarious and sad Only Murders might be fun.

[@leikosakuray]

I like most of Agatha Christie’s stories, with the exception of „Murder on the Orient Express“. I just found the solution to be very… frustrating, I guess is the best way to put it.

[@standby75]

I only read the comic, so some of the changes surprised me, but you'll be glad to know Alberto and Gilda were Holiday (but not like a romantic subplot thing, they had different motivations). So really you did solve it in the first check in then nailed it during the second half too

[@CassidyDylyn]

There actually weren't many changes to speak of. Alberto was revealed to be Holiday in Dark Victory, not Long Halloween. It's very easy to conflate the two, I tend to do it myself.

[@standby75]

@CassidyDylyn lol no he was revealed to be holiday in the long halloween. Seeing as I've never read Dark Victory i couldn't get them confused. He's shown to be Holiday when he kills Maroni during the prisoner transfer. I think you must have gotten them confused again.

[@edzim10]

​​@@CassidyDylyn Alberto confessed in Long Halloween

[@Che1Angelius]

@@edzim10 Except it was two or three other killers.

[@edzim10]

@@Che1Angelius I'm not arguing that there aren't other killers but that Alberto confessed in the long Halloween comic and not dark victory

[@manskronqvist2537]

I think it’s very funny that your theory of the movie being themed after “Men leaving their loved ones alone to prioritize work” actually fits much better with the comic. Since in the comic Alberto is the first Holiday Killer because he never was able to spend time with his father (since Carmine was always working and his birthday was the same day as Valentines Day) and Gilda being the second Holiday Killer to be able to get Harvey’s attention while he got lost in his work.

[@kubamcmillan3078]

Don't forget Harvey

[@manskronqvist2537]

@ Technically it’s either Harvey or Alberto if you want to get into the thick of it. Gilda believes Harvey became The Holiday Killer to take out the Falcones. I probably phrased it very poorly

[@Che1Angelius]

@@manskronqvist2537 No, she was the second killer. Dent did the last couple of kills to cover for her.

[@manskronqvist2537]

@@Che1Angelius Starting to wonder which of you have actually read the miniseries- Tbh it’s a vague enough story for all interpretations to work but the only fact is that there were two.

[@Che1Angelius]

Aw, they are still actually three regardless. Different kills but for different reasons.

[@cadaverouspawn]

"The Royal Me"....I'm stealing that, lol

[@kd8663]

Same. It’s both nonsensical while also making perfect sense.

[@chasebridges]

What’s mine is yours 🫡

[@tiggerbane4325]

If you want to make it fancier you can even say “The Royal We”.

[@byebopp]

"When Maroni, the son, not the father or the holy spirit" 😂

[@hagridspal]

Read the book, it’s genuinely a masterpiece.

[@OmaSushi-z7k]

Oh baby, here comes another one in the series of 'my favorite videos about shows I don't know anything about'!

[@RankSpot]

Chase casually dropping a banger for me to watch before sleep, thanks sir

[@chasebridges]

I hope you enjoy 🙏

[@purpleomlet]

This was a great video! Often I don't actually know the movie/show you're trying to solve, so sometimes it can be hard to follow along. Like the pretty little liars video had me so confused. This one was very easy to follow and I really liked your explanation at the end for how you got to the answer. On the topic of green screen vs suspect board I'm torn. I LOVE the image of you looking absolutely crazy in front of a board of suspects tied together with string. On the other hand, I liked being able to see more snippets of the movie while you talked. If there was a sort of hybrid system that would make your videos perfect.

[@SchnitzelRada]

2:50 I'm surprised that whole time "calendar man", who's gimmick literally is committing crimes on holidays, didn't pop into his head.

[@TheUchihaCub]

I don’t think Calendar man is in the first 30 minutes- At that point in the video he said he only watched the first 30 of the movie.

[@SchnitzelRada]

@TheUchihaCub I do forget that outside of the games, Calendar Man is more obscure, I assumed he knew about the character before watching the movie.

[@cantankerousklept2675]

Unironically love the calm whimsical nature of your videos!

[@archer111000]

Only 1 second into this video, but I'd like to make my guess. In this order the killer is probably: 1) Andy the Crying Cop 2) Lucas the Yearbook Guy 3) Some random D-tier Batman villain I've never heard of

[@sarafontanini7051]

so 3) calender man

[@nohpe]

I don't hate the green screen but I miss the pictures on the wall you could point to

[@chasebridges]

Yea I feel the same way

[@666hellmoose]

​@@chasebridges to be fair, if you plan the background out a little bit you could weatherman that shit over the green screen 🤔

[@horhar4706]

No joke, you have a better understanding of the story's themes than the majority of Batman fans.

[@Gen-ZChristian]

Another review from detective Bridges, can’t wait!

[@JeremyDuncan]

I thought to myself "oh shoot! I love this dude! I gotta subscribe to him!" and then i realized i'm already subscribed😅

[@chasebridges]

I appreciate it!

[@ISwearImHuman]

I read this comment and realized I wasn't subscribed, so thanks for inadvertently reminding me.

[@echothesilent4693]

Pro riding

[@JeremyDuncan]

@@echothesilent4693 If I like the channel enough, I won't deny it. 💯

[@HighEffortUsername]

​@@echothesilent4693The tricks are well deserved

[@WillowDrawsStuff670]

very good video but i knew from the beggining, the killer is obviously andy the crying cop, his evil knows no bounds

[@DamianFire21]

YES NEW VIDEO! "Thank you Chase" we all say in unison

[@chasebridges]

You’re welcome Damian we all say in unison

[@xAlegoss]

I watch a ton of KZbin, and it's safe to say that you are the best underground KZbinr of the last years, I found your channel this summer with the twin peaks video and I was hooked, I couldn't stop watching. Since then I have seen and loved all of your videos (particularly the pretty little liars ones, even tho your videos are my only interaction with the franchise). Not only I find your videos extremly fresh compered to the other copy and pasted content that's floating on here nowadays, you can just feel the dedication and the hours that get put into this. I can't stress this enough, you are great, please never stop doing your thing

[@chasebridges]

I really appreciate this, thank you!

[@TheLars2300]

Bro, you Snapped. Love that thematic analysis was the key. Great video!

[@chasebridges]

Glad you liked it!

[@BaylesOfHay92]

I discovered your channel today, watched about half your videos (still working through the others of course lol), subscribed, and then you posted a new one prefect timing! You're really entertaining and I love seeing your logic and reasoning as you create theories 🕵️‍♂️

[@AdrianWoodUK]

Spoilers below Leaving space for spoilers Abandon hope all ye who enter (of not getting the vid, and Batman films, spoiled) 56:39 - "...the only reason that I suspected Gilda at all in the first place was for like two very distinct reasons... I'm using my knowledge of story structure and storytelling, and once I noticed the theme about the 'leaving the women out of it' and the whole 'families being neglected and torn apart', I figured that the reveal would have to tie into that theme in some way" I think that's why this is one of my favourite of your vids so far. You weren't just watching the films on a surface level, you were paying attention to the themes behind them, the story the creators were trying to communicate. They spoke, and you listened. Great work!

[@fantasmicmed]

This video was fantastic! Not only did you solve it but also delivered an amazing video essay (AP English class worthy) on the family themes hahaha. I loved the green screen as well

[@dazedheart9006]

45:17 I personally like the drafting board the best. It’s just easier for my brain to follow stuff especially with me who doesn’t really watch tv.

[@zackary6278]

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, me and everyone else watching your content rn are getting in on the ground floor. You’re so good at making quality content. Huge fan.

[@Scowleasy]

I think there was a copycat killer at some point, it helps explain the seemingly different motives at different times.

[@benm.4875]

In the comic there are multiple killers, but they changed it for the movie.

[@ottone007able]

Love all of this content. Hope all this effort continues to find growth for your channel.

[@chasebridges]

Thank you!

[@orngcreator6115]

Hell yeah! Nice job on finding the themes in order to help you figure out the culprit. A lot people dismiss the idea of that stuff existing in comic book stories.

[@destroyadora]

You should do Gotham by Gaslight!!! Lots of moving parts and a pretty good reveal

[@CDWHPASE]

Hilarious how he just immediately clocks Alberto and Mrs. Dent as the killers

[@IAmBlindProphet]

I never even considered something like this as mystery suggestion, the world has opened up

[@gavin_guidry]

You're doing a Batman! Maybe I'm biased, since I draw comics professionally, but: Awesome.

[@fegao9494]

I figured out the mystery the same time as you but you never connected that Alberto sent the flowers and that's a concrete link between them!

[@chasebridges]

Good point!

[@RigidHollywood]

Another BANGER added to the collection

[@GeoSage1137]

Chase is about to start gunning for Sherlock Holmes next

[@chasebridges]

He better watch out

[@GenbuMediaAndManga]

I was rooting for you the entire video to get the twist by the end and it was such a crazy roller coaster! It goes to show to remember that your instinct is usually correct even if it was previously shown otherwise. You were red hot at some point. Bravo

[@naptakr]

The greenscreen was great cuase you showed scenes from the movie, but as someone who doesn't actually knows the shows, it's hard to follow without images with names associated to them in the background. Great video!

[@Angryoyster]

Damn I’m so glad KZbin recommended me your PLL video. Love watching someone solve a mystery with low stakes.

[@760chivasboy]

Finished watching your Pretty Little Liars videos yesterday which I had no knowledge of the show before hand and let me tell you how instantly hooked I was in seeing if your prediction was correct or not. I'm excited to see how your prediction is correct or not for this video. I do prefer the method you used for pretty little liars compared to the green screen. I'm super excited for future videos. I would love to see you try and solve the mystery for true detective season 1 (maybe the other seasons in the future) if you haven't seen them already.

[@nicholassarkis1053]

The first mystery he’s covered I know the answer to! Really changes the experience.

[@SecondBestArtMuseum]

Well done detective. But, I bet you can’t figure out who the killer is in… HEAVY RAIN.

[@mawillix2018]

There's some nice editing partway through the video. I want to say that I haven't changed my opinion that I dislike the green screen, but I still need to tell you good job.

[@aydenstuckey7826]

That was really well deduced. I was completely surprised by the answer on my first watch through of the films.

[@chasebridges]

Thank you!

[@N_Phi6]

If you havent already you should do one on the batman movie set in victorian england. I think its called gotham by gaslight.

[@MagicJack4Life]

The wall and red string bring so much to the vibe of the style of your videos. It also allows me to follow along completely as I’m a more visual person with this many characters (same with the PPL videos plz do more). I’ll watch no matter what because this is a great niche of content and genuinely makes me laugh plus be intrigued. Thanks yo!!

[@jackiechan5815]

what about using the red thread board but each photograph of the characters is a greenscreen so you can edit the board in post with movie images and such

[@IAmBlindProphet]

Oh also, idk if you have any interest but it would be neat to see you try to solve the mystery in the original comic. The holiday killer is a different character there. Of course, the comic Holiday Killer was probably already spoiled for you in the comments here (or maybe you mention it at the end of this video, I haven’t finished it yet), but if you somehow don’t already know then I would love to see you try to solve the comic next Halloween. Side note, personally, I really like the choice they went with for the movie adaptation, and I think it was smart to change the killer to preserve the mystery for comic fans, but I know it was a point of contention when the film released. I love comics and I’m a bit of a historian for DC, but man I hate to call myself a comic fan sometimes because some people take things wayyyyy too seriously or are just insane. But I will agree with the fans on the Batman: Hush adaptation. That movie also twists around who Hush is to keep the mystery but it is a really whack change

[@DatBas]

Please keep making these kind of videos, such a fun and unique style. Especially fond of the animation ones

[@Erthradar]

Dude your analysis of theme and the holidays was great, I made the connection of the holidays with being neglected right before you mentioned it in the video. Love this series!

[@umbra1deus]

Love the vid mate, the green screen works to show off a bit of the media you're solving and to fill the background while you're giving the setup but I think the posters+red string is a better look when you're trying to solve the mystery. Regardlesss, great work and looking forward to the next

[@oldhiphopmaster]

Got recommended your channel out of chance prob cuz I enjoy Batman and I gotta say your hilarious, your timing is on point, and such an easy subscribe.

[@lolnou4219]

If you haven’t already watched it, I think ‘the usual suspects’ could be a really good movie for this kind of detective format

[@OmaSushi-z7k]

8:37 Most of the time - this video included - I have no prior knowledge about the show/IP you're talking about, my man!

[@jackhynds175]

"I now know what it's like to be embarassed by Batman" supervillain origin story vibes

[@heyspeckle8782]

if you haven't seen Harper's Island, it could be a fun and rather short one (13 episodes) to solve if you're good with a pretty violent show 🕵‍♂

[@kos8571]

Good boy. But srsly this was great bro and I actually love that idea, no one who has plans for anything is how calender man figured it out Only thing I think the mystery neglected was just how she managed to pull off all the physicality of looking like some big brute and outrunning everyone and stuff tho :/

[@Lezl0rLetztlich]

Great job🕵🏻‍♂️!!! I loved the visuals just as much as the earlier videos. I like the way you talk out your reasoning the most!

[@itstomis]

THE WORLDS GREATEST DETECTIVE

[@chasebridges]

🫡🫡🫡

[@nz2737]

Love your videos so much! It would be so cool if you ever did a video solving one of those murder mystery kits like the cryptic killers one, it comes with a folder filled with evidence documents pictures etc and I feel like the reveal is actually logical and you’d have a great chance at cracking it

[@betheleanor]

this is the first of your videos i've watched that i don't know the ending to, so i'm super psyched to go on this journey with you!! also, season 4 of only murders in the building just wrapped and i think you would ACE the killers in that show.

[@louinaghdiani7977]

Gilda being the Holiday killer just doesn’t make sense to me. Why would she kill Alberto? Why does Holiday have the face of a guy if she’s a women? Why kill Carmines daughter? And the Maronis?.

[@algi1]

I found it hilarious when Batman said "I had no idea I had to be a detective." This is his first real case, he was just punching small time thieves before this.

[@GenocideJill-]

Another banger, love your murder mystery type videos

[@cstmollins]

2 videos in the same month? We eating good this year! The green screen is cool but nothing beats a classic board in the backround in my opinion.

[@soaphi7069]

6:00 I didn’t know that Harvey Dent becomes two face 🧍🏻‍♀️

[@notscullytv]

7:25 it’s always dent’s thing to have that coin be 2 heads. It’s after he’s scarred the coin becomes scarred too, or he just scratches it but my previous sentence is more poetic.

[@Scowleasy]

To do something illegal you need 3 things: Means, Motive and Opportunity. If you’re missing one of those the chances are you didn’t do it.

[@ngu_xxshortygang6966]

I NEED more pretty little liars

[@nzoocage4084]

You should at some point make a video on Batman Gotham by Gaslight could be really interesting, first video I’ve seen of yours and it was great, subbed

[@katyk2884]

set design idea: cut out a picture of every characters face and make a paper jail and you can tape your guess’ face behind the bars after every prediction 😂😂

[@batjackgames6838]

If there was ever a holiday based killer in Batman I'd just assume it was Calendar man

[@Galaktika113]

The Long Halloween, yes. I already forgot plot of the movie, even through remember comic plot. They are very similar but different in a couple major ways. And yes, I like comic plot in these aspects more. Spoiler: In the comic Alberto faked his death and after that he is responsible (as i remember) for 1 Holiday killing and after that he took responsibilities for all Holiday killings, because he was a fan and a copycat of the Holiday killer. In the end Albert is in Arkham in a cell near calendar man, became friend with him and took the name of the Holiday killer for the future. Real Holiday killer is Harvey Dent and his wife, Dent took the blame for all killings in the end and his wife burns the evidents that she started it all and was true Holiday Killer. As i remember she wasn't able to have a child with Dent because Harvey spend all his time working, so in frustration she just started to kill mafia. I explained the differences pretty badly, but I hope everyone gets it.

[@spepie9212]

Love this guy, keep it up mate

[@sarafontanini7051]

so some things of interest, as well as answers to your questions (also spoilers for the graphic novel as there seems to be some differences): -"why did the holiday killer look bigger?" Gilda was likely wearing larger clothes to hide her figure and make it harder to indentify her. In the original graphic novel we never get a GOOD look at Holiday, so we can never be sure how tall or how muscular or wide they are, so it may be a holdover from that, the animators may have also cheated by making holiday look bigger to better hide the reveal -"what was the purpose of calender man?" several. One, her's a red herring, as his theming around calnders (specifically, how he'd commit crimes related to days on the calender) made him a suspect, but more so it acts as a way of helping determine who holiday is, as he'd provide some insight onto how holiday may be thinking during the story. It also is relevant in the graphic novel because he HATES Holiday for stealing his gimmick. Also since the point is we don't KNOW who holiday is for most of the story, calender man is meant to be a go between, to tell us how holiday may be as a person and thus help give them presence as a cahracter via his theorising. -Why did falcone hire a guy to shoot dent only to say "if i wanted you dead you'd be dead"? perhaps that was a lie, or perhaps he truly didn't want to kill dent, only scare him into confessing. -you seemed to be wondering what the various villains had to do with things, and the answer is really simple: in the original graphic novel it was split into several issues themed around each holiday, and part of this theming is to have a villain appear in the issue, though I can't remember if they were meant to be themed around the holiday too or just picked at random. Riddler is brought in by the Falcone's at one point to help figure out who Holiday was. now some things from the graphic novel, as it sounds like they changed some things: -Calender man brings up the possibility of there being multiple Holidays. -ALberto didn't die and in fact claims to be Holiday, and thus he is arrested and put across from Calender Man so they can argue with each other. -we still get the final reveal of gilda burning her Holiday costume in the original graphic novel its meant to be ambiguous who the true holiday was, as to wther it was Gilda, Alberto or even Harvey Dent himself, as not only could any one of them be wrong or lyign (alberto could be confessing just so people think he's a real tough guy so he can get attention) or suffering a mental delusion. I think the general consensus is that ALberto and Gilda were the true Holiday, killing a set of people each for their own reasons (Gilda so she can free Harvey from the Falcones and ALberto so he can finally get respect and some revenge).

[@felipeveloso1578]

It's crazy that even though your original guess was wrong, it was still right. Spoilers: Alberto is actually Holiday in the original comic story(kinda). The original Long Halloween is very good but the ending can be a little confusing, basically there were two/three Holidays, Gilda was the original one, she was killing the Falcone family so that Harvey would stop neglecting her, she did not kill Alberto, she thinks it was Harvey, but the thing is that Alberto did not die, he claims that he faked his death and killed his family for neglecting him. In the end Alberto is arrested for the murders and Two Face kills Falcone, puting an end to the Long Halloween. In the movie when Batman says "Alberto was the simplest solution, but a wrong one" is a reference to how in the comics Batman never finds out Gilda was the original killer, and just arrests Alberto because he is the most obvious suspect, ignoring the possibility of there being two killers(even though both Two Face and Calendar Man imply there were two killers)

[@Theabiss98]

Great video. If you like solving animated Batman movies, I recommend Gotham by gaslight

[@goldjaw]

When you fell for the Alberto trick, I was in a similar space. The only reason soemeone would change motives like with the first three kills is a feeling of betrayal... or if it was someone else's motive....

[@grrrmlin]

To your defence with your Alberto guess, in the comic he was the one convicted for the holiday murders. As far as even batman was aware he was the holiday killer

[@antonkarnaukhov5089]

Great video ! Green screen or not, I just wanna see more investigations ! So whatever takes less time 😅

[@nunyabizness4584]

LIVING for the sauce you dropped on “born on a Monday”

[@Mark16-15]

You should try to solve Scream 1996 before the reveal or Clue the Movie.

[@dorememe8548]

I just watched the movie for the first time a few days ago! Great insights.

[@brandeezyc]

Great video man! I'm digging the green screen

[@Mars9471]

Return of the king

[@chasebridges]

👑👑👑👑

[@justalemon965]

So my running theory as I watched the movies alongside your video (maybe mentioning exactly where you stopped at the beginning of every discussion would be helpful in the future) was that Gilda was the brains and she was using Dent’s second personality which he was unaware of. She even has that line “Only what was inside him (Harvey) hadn’t been ripped out. That was… useful”. So I was guessing that the holiday killers larger figure was due to the actual person in the suit being Harvey, while Gilda instigated his second personality. My theory was helped when it almost looked like holiday was different when they showed up at the end to give Harvey an alibi. So I think the “hired gun” as Gordon called it was Gilda, hence why Harvey tried to keep the police from going after her, but all the other murders were from Harvey’s hands as Gilda planned it all. There was also that one scene where the old Maroni died with no gun on the table and no tie there, then holiday runs off away from the body without ever getting close yet when the young maroni returns, the stuff is there as if a second person placed it down.

[@nehuenregodeseves744]

you should really try to solve the "how to get away with murder season 1" murder. for context, the first episode already ells you who are present in the murder, but doesnt tell you why, how or exactly who murders (also, for extra points, at first you dont even know who died). i just loved this series, and every season is a new mistery and repeats the formula.

[@julysolchenberger5790]

I love that you called out the first red herring and fell for alberto falcone when he is another big one.

[@CatGuy803]

Can u try to solve some Poirot books or sum? They are actually logically solvable😭