Can't Decide Between Two Generals? Watch This Video.

[@Maath_Faseli]

If you saw my last community pole all four videos were very close, so I decided to make the easiest one first. Keep an eye out for the other three videos, and another one I'm working on that I think you'll like!

[@timash6691]

POLL and it is "EL IN NORE" not "EEE LEAN ERR"

[@Maath_Faseli]

@@timash6691 I misspell and mispronounce things just for you timash 😉

[@blujustin4175]

@@Maath_Faseli 🤣🤣🤣

[@roberthulsey8547]

Thanks a lot for taking the time to put all of this together. It's very useful for deciding if switching general setups is worth it

[@Poppykkuda]

Trail of knights Event rewards are changed. Now it contains, louis lX, agrippa, lu xun and pyrrus.

[@LuciferMorningstar-zl7vf]

Hey great progress as this format makes everyone’s life easier. Thank you for your great videos! My only criticism is that the base stat buff can be a significant reason for a choice in a general when a generals scaling is really high or low for a base stat. Additionally the base stat buff decision point only increases as the level of the general increases. I get the difficulty in making this adjustable, as it is much more complicated. My advice is to use the base stat calculation for the current highest level possible, Level 45 versus the Level 30 you said you are using now. A generals level is only impacted by Monarch Level so the vast majority of competitive players are already at Monarch 40+, even though they are K36-K38, again nothing to do with Keep Level. An additional reason to do Level 45 is that an investment to change a General is not only based on today but the future as well. We don’t have a crystal ball to see whether a new mechanic may be released, like Awakening, but we do know that a Generals level will increase with time. Thanks again for all that you do!

[@Maath_Faseli]

At some point I do want to add an option for their level. The reason I chose lvl 30 originally was because that was my level lol. The difference between 30 and 45 isn't huge, for example King Arthur goes from 149 Atk to 210 Atk, Marco Polo goes from 178 to 250, so the difference goes from about 30 to 40, like I said it might be +/- 10% when you change the level

[@DM-kr3dk]

@Evony Academy - Could you please update the defence generals doc to this current standard and include new generals? I find it a bit difficult to navigate compared to this one

[@Maath_Faseli]

I'll add it to the projects

[@joshuabolin930]

Awesome work on updating these sheets! Unfortunately the link doesnt seem to have the updated versions?

[@Maath_Faseli]

Apparently I put the new ones in the wrong folder, I'm trying to fix it at the moment, but my Internet is being slow, so it might be a few hours or a day until it's fixed

[@Sinister_Crimson_Titan_MW_2800]

On which general should our primary focus should be as a F2P A general whoch we can at least ascend to 8 star or above Or Doing several generals 6 syared at once

[@Maath_Faseli]

You should focus all of your resources into one or maybe two generals at a time. I would make your first general that you develop be a defensive general or one that has the leading clause.

[@johnnie5793]

Hope you eventually add Issac Brock to the Wall Generals sheet.

[@Maath_Faseli]

I have him on the spreadsheet, but I had the wrong version shared, it should be fixed in a few hours or a day at most

[@mohankumarcs9002]

hey... It seems that my alliance loves your channel and content.... Now that evony has a legal in- game auto join feature, my alliance has realised the importance of stamina .... It would be great if you can make a video on which monsters to focus on like -" Value per stamina"

[@Maath_Faseli]

That's a good idea, I'll look into it

[@masgondrong7120]

Saya mendapatkan ide untuk pemain gratis seperti saya. Jenderal pasukan berkuda saya beralih ke Ullyses grant (fafnir) + Marco polo. 😂 saya kecewa Poligenus berhenti di 8 bintang. Tetapi saya masih menyimpannya untuk masa depan😅😅

[@masgondrong7120]

ULLYSES + (FAFNIR)🐉 ADALAH DUAL SKILL . MOUNTED AND SIEGE. HANYA PENYESUAIAN UNTUK ASISTEN

[@grantmccormick4747]

So how do i use this to find the best assistant to the 10 star gens i already have

[@Maath_Faseli]

If your main general can take the attack book then add 25% for the assistants that can take it, if your main general can't take the book then just look at the highest on the chart. Same goes for MS book if any of your generals have issues with that one

[@grantmccormick4747]

@@Maath_Faseli so the sheet would tell me if the added march size is better if i cant use an attack book?

[@jackbenny984]

I dont see the link

[@blujustin4175]

Fantasic; I've really been wanting detail on this subject. But the first example is Andre and you SAY and put in the spreadsheet he has 45% Attack , 0 Def, 0 HP, 12% March *but* the description clearly shows 15% Attack, 15% Defence, 20% HP and 0% March size. Has it changed from an older version and Evony changed him? Or am I missing something? I'm assuming the 12% March size is because you think it's obvious to put the L4 Skill book on him but I don't see why he get's 0% Defence and HP when those are in his base skill you showed on screen

[@Maath_Faseli]

Those weren't his base skills on screen, that was my Trajan I showed on screen. If you check In game Andre is 45% Atk and 12% MS

[@blujustin4175]

@@Maath_Faseli D'oh! Sorry... just my brain assuming you'd use the same General in the image as you were talking about and my eyes not looking to check! That said, where does the sheet take into account things like some Generals being able to take the Attack Book and some not? If I missed it just say and I'll rewatch paying more attention... I think I was trying to take in too much at once! Oh, another question if you'll kindly indulge me. When you input the Troop Tier do you suggest entering the _highest_ level in your March or the _majority_ ? For example I _own_ T14s but I use Red Evony's suggested Marches (I did my own spreadsheet for that!) for the best Power Exchange balanced with combat which means I have a ratio of _about_ 4 T12s to 3 T13s to 2 T14s, so T14s are a lot less numerical than T12s) BTW I *could* probably modify your amazing sheet to do Generals at multiple red star levels but it would require *MASSES and MASSES* of data input on other pages and would be rather complex to say the least... if I have a go I'll let you know how I get on if I try!

[@Maath_Faseli]

@@blujustin4175 skill book aren't accounted for since the assistant you choose will change what skill books you can use. At some point I might add an update where you can select you main + assistant and do that calculation, and it would be factored into that. For which tier to use for the calculation, I would probably use the biggest tier you use, but changing from T12-T14 wont be much of a difference. For the skill 5 column I could add a drop down to choose the star level, but most people aren't comparing 4 star to 4 star, they want to see 3 star vs 4 star vs 2 star.

[@blujustin4175]

@@Maath_Faseli Thanks for the clarrification; great info... I agree most people will want to be comparing the 3, 4 or 5 star F2P vs 0, 1 or 2 star Premium so the way to do it would be an individual (identical 0-5) star selection in that column per General; if you've named your drop down and refer to it by name rather than by cell references, you could just drag the link down the whole column to repeat it, then individually select for each General... but of course you need to enter the 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 star Att, Def, HP, MS separately, for _every single General sindividually_ on another data sheet to take the data from; supposedly it wouldn't be that complex once you'd sorted out the way to reference the correct general from one sheet to another BUT it would take a heck of a long time I imagine.

[@Maath_Faseli]

@@blujustin4175 yeah I think that's outside my time or skill limit at the moment, but perhaps one day lol

[@cryptowarrior55]

Hi bro, i have elektra with 3 red stars and merlin with 2 red stars and 3 step covenant both are max on specialities which one is better as the main general for my ranged?

[@blujustin4175]

I believe he showed in this video how you can work it out! FWIW my strong gut feeling is *Merlin* because a 1 star *Merlin* is _about_ the same as a 5 star *Elektra* (all other things being equal) but _for now_ I'm still with *Elektra* because she's almost on her next red star, I have her skin and I am a big softy and like the brother/sister team of *Martinus* / *Elektra* leading out the troops...🤣

[@Gaucho-i8r]

quiero hacer mi defensa con Richard Lion, me sirve a futuro? soy jugador gratis

[@lucasgucci]

defensa para jugador gratis es un poco complicado, depende del nivel de tus oponentes pero en cierto punto empieza a ser cada vez mas duro, a partir de k41-42 las personas empiezan a tener 3000% de ataque, vas a necesitar construir mucha cantidad de t1 lo cual es bastante costoso a nivel de recursos

[@Maath_Faseli]

I think Richard is the best general for free to play players. @lucasgucci also makes a good point, you will need millions of T1 mounted troops if you want to be competitive

[@lucasgucci]

@@Maath_Faseli t1 mounted + flat refines on wall general gear and golden dragon... another way to play evony is a ghost keep being a rally filler, doing max research on marching/rally attacks buffs

[@Gaucho-i8r]

@@lucasgucci si ya soy casi k40 amigo con casi 5 billones de poder con mas de 600 millones de tropas, solo estoy buscando un general que me ayude, ya recibi golpes arriba de 3800%, y los tolero, pero regular

[@Gaucho-i8r]

@@Maath_Faseli entonces me jugare por Richard para mi muro

[@zlatode]

Goog News! ❤ just one more request, I'm Italian, I understand the English language if spoken slowly.. Thanks for the work you do. 😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@paulovaz3387]

you can just slow down the video play velocity 🤗

[@zlatode]

@@paulovaz3387 😂😂😂😂 You're right too 😂😂

[@Siri_UsV]

clicca sull'ingranaggio delle impostazioni, sottotitoli, inglese. Poi clicca di nuovo su ingranaggio,sottotitoli, traduzione e cerca italiano, avrai i sottotitoli in lingua che ti possono aiutare