Can We Combine All Planets Using Roche Limit? - Universe Sandbox²

[@not2tired]

This channel is something like 85% informative, 15% cosmic demolition derby. Love it. Please maintain this healthy ratio.

[@Smolrysncrisin]

ikr 90 -10 accually

[@bluesapphireinteriordesign8871]

?

[@matthewgillespie2835]

Universe sandbox is such a fascinating simulator.. I'm so glad I have it

[@rock3tcatU233]

Thank God for that game.

[@WhatColourIsYourBugatti_]

Can you get it free on Mac?

[@Jerakk30]

Yeah but it's not an accurate simulator. It's not even close to being accurate at all. The equations it tries to use to simulate anything don't apply to the nature of those simulations themselves. You cannot use newtonian physics to describe events that require relativistic physics. If you do.. you end up getting fake results. Fake information. Things that just can't happen in reality and will never happen in reality. It's like trying to show someone what it's like to fly a plane using the old NES game Top Gun.

[@lemelangedelevurefarinetea7323]

>:(

[@bluefongalt3714]

I have universe sandbox The first one

[@justin2142]

anton, can you please make a video about terraforming pluto. You can make different versions. 1 will be in its normal distance from the sun. 2 you can place pluto in the goldelock zone.

[@atechcomps]

Justin Collotta I

[@ijdouglas6348]

BizSolutions wut is u typing wat dus I mean?!?!?

[@fohbuuihbuihjbijnjknjjknji9815]

the Phantasm i think if you get the top comment they just comment something like , or just your name in the hope to get attention and likes

[@ijdouglas6348]

Lispy Jimmy oh k it's just annoying

[@55panpan]

Juegos del universo Iguhbbbbg bbngnjh - Blhkiuhihillkjljk

[@Deltamedic68w]

"It just ate the whole Venus". Wife walks in "What are you watching?" 😂

[@Ian-cw7rx]

Coo

[@svetlanakostioutchek8004]

I don’t have a wife...

[@SM64_Mario]

@@svetlanakostioutchek8004 neither

[@canadaball687]

lol

[@MRMONEYIS_COOL]

lol

[@marvinabarquez8915]

*venus has mars and mercury in it* well my ex also had 2 in her

[@adriens8273]

Yeah bruh

[@kijetesantakaluSokete]

bruh

[@theorangeoof926]

Srsly bruh

[@insertname.5985]

Which Mercury??? Elemental Mercury or the planet?

[@politicallyinaccuratetoast4757]

Everyone is literally bruhing instead of actually getting the joke

[@darkenergy436]

Anton: who will win? Mercury: wait it was a contest? Venus: always has been.

[@famoli891]

Lol

[@bitchesa]

Yes

[@BOASYDOG]

Then it will be called Meunsrtharsupiturnanustune

[@uyscuti5805]

Awesomebossydog Meunsrtharsupiturnanustunuteresmakemea***

[@MedK001]

Menearspiturnusune. Then, we make it shorter where possible. Menearpitunune. Let's try again. Mearpitune. Again Mearpite. Ta-da!

[@suwinkhamchaiwong8382]

GokuK Somearpite Our Solar System is named

[@himansubhusan5960]

Bossydog u r ..... _______ fill box

[@welp4576]

Mvemjsun Mervenurthmarjupiturnustune

[@danialramzan]

5:19 venus mass: 0.911 earth VENUS DID 9/11

[@stickyman18]

Danial Ramzan not funny

[@tonk9246]

no, venus is a police

[@alexreeves7242]

9/11 joke 😂

[@milkyayyy9177]

Danial Ramzan VENUS DRAGGED THE PLANE WITH ITS GRAVITY

[@eleanorpathak5142]

We could realllllllllllllllyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy use that death star. Frick yuo rebels, er kinda.

[@pHdoFogo31]

I wish this fragment system could return to the game now, it was so epic and it could simulate the formation of moons planets and even stars if you want to waste your time.

[@pineapplewhatever5906]

My rule of thumb-more massive always wins, UNLESS the other body is a black hole(black holes cannot break up, all their mass is in the Schzuratchild radius(how do you spell it again?). And if they are BOTH black holes, they eventually merge, due to GENERAL RELATIVITY. I'm so proud of you, Einstein, and wish you were here to see my comment).

[@Jancias]

Try to make your own system, using MATH

[@Sometheus]

JanKaszanka Dobry Pomysł

[@anarex0929]

Cake, get of your ass and look up all the greats that used human calculators to do just that. Localize your time index to World War 1 and World War II. You should have known that if you looked at your history closer.

[@restlessgamer712]

I'm waiting every day on a new video from you. It's so educational and fun to watch!

[@adammumad5606]

I saw a little piece of saturn

[@CDJAM-webm]

OH MY GOD IS THAT A KIRBY REFERENCE

[@macaronisalad3038]

2:17 why does mercury look like the death star???

[@snowykaze]

Meme Machine my question is, how come all the planets' dark side stayed in a constant position even with a light source on it?

[@macaronisalad3038]

magic

[@beyondw01f3]

Meme Machine "That's no moon."

[@heh7879]

Meme Machine omg it's the moon

[@georgechaplain8906]

Blizzard_gamer that's no moon... :OO

[@allendove8244]

So cool that pretty much all of the planets combined minus Jupiter still get ate up by Jupiter inside the Roche limit.

[@ChlorineRaven]

"Earth wins yaay" Who cares. It is being litteraly torn appart by enormous levels of temperature.

[@bananathebread4678]

Ahah

[@tjonkysjonky3555]

Not torn apart tho

[@Kodaiva]

But... but the earth is still fine

[@adambartlett114]

@@Kodaiva No, no, no it isn't... Whatever you call whatever remains, it's going to be a ball of lava. Nothing will survive that. Adam Adam

[@ronillomardajr2022]

Wow eart have a big place in the solar system the earth has the most thingi

[@gobyg-major2057]

Anton: earth survived the encounter with Uranus Uranus: not on my watch *gobbles up the earth*

[@comeandtakeit8215]

Anton: Oh Earth is fine, it’s just a little hot. Everyone: AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@tkldn8412]

I don't like maths but watching your vid with you explaining maths is Stupefying

[@stankfaust814]

Great video and cool simulation. Can we talk about Jupiter for a bit? Jupiter is a VERY deep gravity well. Deepest in our solar system next to the sun. Acceleration at the top of Jupiter's atmosphere is 24.79 M/s2 (and that's not even on the terrestrial surface to make a like comparison to the earth meaningful.) Your simulation showed that we can combine the matter in virtually all the other planets (gravity wells) in our solar system and still not be as massive nor as dense nor have the magnetoshpere of jupiter. In fact, Jupiter is more than twice as massive as all of the other planets combined... it did not get that way from accreting gasses nor form having a small rocky core... I'm extremely dubious of any model showing the accretion of light gasses into a planet like jupiter without substantial seeding by a lot of very dense matter accounting for the majority of its mass. (for instance you could take all the helium and hydrogen off of jupiter and put it around the earth and it would just blow away... our gravity well, + the additional mass of the gasses would not create a jupiter) It's the depth of Jupiter's gravity well that captures, and retains and all the gasses and makes it the gas giant that it is unlike on earth where hydrogen and helium regularly drift off and escape into space. And Jupiter has enough acceleration to compress these gasses to a density where we get these dazzling bands of fluid dynamics showing across the surface of the atmosphere. As matter stratifies by density in a gravity well, this would put all the heavy, ferrous matter at the core or center and the lighter elements like gasses (albeit compressed) in the atmosphere. Jupiter very likely has a large metallic core not dissimilar to the inner planets with the exception of its size and its core is spinning very fast. (relative to earth) Depending on which cloud band you choose to track on the atmospheric surface of Jupiter it takes about 10 earth hours for one 'day' on jupiter, but the core is spinning faster than this (it's general relativity) creating the truly massive magnetosphere.

[@Planet360YT]

When he placed another earth I face palmed

[@midwestmama972]

Lol me too, it ruined the whole thing

[@imnotfuckingusingthisaccou2574]

Midwest Mama How so?

[@solarisdevorak]

@@imnotfuckingusingthisaccou2574 it was supposed to be only the planets in the solar system... We don't have 2 Earths

[@soulfame2778]

By far my favorite KZbinr this guy is awesome!

[@alexleo-wolf4339]

I brought up the Roche limit in science class, everyone said I'm an idiot, but they don't know what a "Roche limit," is.

[@TmanTyler619]

PLEASE remake Interstellar and how to planets orbit a black hole PLZZZZ

[@czargs]

I would love that you continue showing us a little bit of math or formula like in this video

[@VIRTUALESENCE]

How do you enable the Roche limit? (The particles flying from the planets) it doesn't work for me

[@user-ed1mj5zk6f]

Anton love your show and the new program!

[@jamestaulbee4753]

Anton petrov do you have a podcast??? If you don't I suggest you start one. You're very knowledgeable and I know I wouldn't be the only one who would be interested in listening to you on a podcast but either way keep the content coming man. Thank you.

[@Planet776]

The way of earth getting rings in the video just is realsistic

[@powerzx]

Mercury is made of iron (mostly), so I don't think that Venus would win. You would need a lot more force than you could have in that scenario to rip metal apart.

[@timlizzard]

Its also made out of silicite (half and half) Half of venus is bigger than mercury thus venus winning

[@sagewilde-mcdowell4218]

i made interstellar bodies stars using the roche limit

[@Barnardrab]

How long does it take for them to tidally lock at this distance? Is there a mathematical formula to determine this?

[@watchery.819]

Jupiter, king of the planets, and destroyer of comets

[@randomgamer2274]

And bodyguard of earth

[@watchery.819]

Daniel Romero bodyguard of the (vip club) inner planet

[@randomgamer2274]

ymir We should respect Jupiter more

[@watchery.819]

Daniel Romero we should, it does so much

[@ronillomardajr2022]

Eater

[@Ziplock9000]

"it just ate the whole venus," Glad it wasn't Uranus!

[@termikong4537]

😂😂

[@thorium9190]

Could you heat a gas giant by a binary system by the Roche limit and put earth in the habitual zone of this hot gas giant system. Basically a neverending heat from tides heating

[@CUBETechie]

I have heard that saturn has a satellite which has ice on the surface but under the ice it could be liquid water. The reason for this is the tilde force. Could you place 2 earths so they can rotate around each other and through the tilde force on the planet both would have liquid water?

[@delvigamer606]

CUBETechie 👢👢👢👢👢

[@voicev8426]

Can a blackhole lose tho, like if a very small blackhole approached huge neutron star, does the star have any chances at all?

[@abdullahmalik267]

None at all

[@lukedekiewit1977]

Anton I'm new to Space Engine and I enabled Grid mode somehow....How do I disable it again?

[@photonic083]

If u mean universe sandbox it's view>grid

[@KGTiberius]

Merge Pluto, Mars, and mercury. Then time lapse ahead 1a millions years. How similar to earth is it if in the Goldilocks zone?

[@ngocbinhtruong5358]

I Can A Question,Uranus is Thirth Coldest Planet in Universe?

[@SMunro]

So if planet X is orbiting jupiter up through the solar plane at an angle what is its distsnce from jupiter, period, and effect on earth?

[@lecisteim_1945]

I was just playing the game and I made planets orbit each other, this explains a lot

[@RoronoaDeep]

Earth got absorbed by Uranus.... LOL.

[@randomgamer2274]

Oh god

[@politicallyinaccuratetoast4757]

Uranus Myanus Hisanus Heranus Everybodysanus Nobodysanus Somebodysanus

[@marvelfebrian9266]

You mean *_Your Anus_*?

[@koreythomas7850]

You immature

[@Audexsi]

WHO'S ANUS IS THAT BIG??!!

[@valsodar6723]

Its plausable Earth size exoplanet sustain life without star, but tidaly heated by small but extremely dense moon ? How masive must be that smaller satelit ? How near must by to heating enaught but not break apart ?

[@premlatasingh8546]

Which software is this?

[@sergeleblanc8396]

Make Jupiter a black hole

[@Car1Sagan]

Interesting observation at the end, objects in orbit if colliding with earth would tend to hit equatorial areas. But our observation is just the opposite, them hitting more polar areas, such as Siberia & Canada. Why?

[@Schizniit]

I miss these videos of Anton destroying the earth/solar system in various ways

[@chanandsharp5760]

My theory : gravity also plays a role because it make planet's masses stick to them so with more gravity you get to survive long and you can rip other planets faster

[@newdoggerlandofficial]

Or you could have added Pluto

[@seiyong2006]

what happend to saturn in her roche limit

[@alamabrown3488]

0:45 look closely in the left and look up I see a planet that just formed 2:12when Mercury Dies and Venus wins they make more planets which kind of look like Pluto mini Pluto's

[@magness6903]

3:54 looks like Earth from bo2 zombies?! Are we going to Venus?

[@JiMMy-xd8nu]

can you make a video about wr-104? on universesandbox...

[@FreiNrg]

Sure that could happen, but this negates any notion that these planets have a charge to them like the sphere top on a static generator. Electricity is more powerful than gravity, but ignored in terms of cosmic bodies like the planets and stars. I think the events would be much interesting if we treated these bodies as electrically charged objects

[@ThelagKingStrikes]

Tl;dr little rocky bois gets ripped apart by bigger rocky bois. Little gassy bois get ripped apart by bigger gassy bois. Rocky bois are harder to rip apart than gassy bois but massive gassy bois can still rip apart rocky bois at close range. Everything gets hot.

[@amazingamx1255]

What app or game is that please tell me

[@filipinomapping334]

Amazing Abdul Muizz Universe sandbox it's 25$ in Amazon

[@Jerakk30]

It's also a waste of $25 if you want an accurate simulation of relativistic physics. It's a garbage program that's only used for making things "look pretty" and does not, in any way, shape, or form, give you any results that are based in reality.

[@amazingamx1255]

Jerakk30 I don't need accurate results but just a fun game

[@Jerakk30]

Yeah but the problem is... Anton is basically helping create a new generation of people ignorant of real physics. He constantly plays off this idea that these are accurate representations when they're not even remotely close. He's not educating anyone at all. Which is scary because he's a teacher. So I'm actually worried for any students under his charge. If he's willing to spread false information on youtube and try to play it off like it's reality.. then I shudder to think of what he's filling his students' heads with =(

[@sciblastofficial9833]

Can you make the planets orbit by size? Also, this includes the Moons, so do as many as you can and rearrange them in order of size.

[@notananimationchannel]

what is the largest a star can be?

[@Scythinite]

Here is an explnation:the more massive objects gravity crushes the less massive one cause think about a marble if you crushb it, it breaks but why?cause you have more mass and the crushing it it also applies to gravity

[@ЯношБан]

2:20 "even if a black hole was less massive than Earth...".Are you sure about this!?

[@TheGamerzTown]

Yes, because of the extremely high density of the black holes

[@ЯношБан]

Jonathantje / Bammerbom no,I think he wanted to say that even if it was much smaller!And that's simply because even the smallest known to us black hole has a mass of 2-3 suns (and yes,he used that BH in that video) P.S.if I did wrote something wrong,please write me back

[@uyscuti5805]

Янош Бан if a black hole was the size of a coin, it would be more massive than earth. think like that

[@appleappington7346]

Well technically speaking a black hole can be any size

[@TiO2_]

Янош Бан Are you sure about that ?! 8)

[@blazer897gaming5]

wait. at the start of the video, there was two earths. and they have the same mass. so, WHY IS EARTH 1 TEARING APART EARTH 2? DONT THEY HAVE THE SAME MASS? SHOULDNT THEY TEAR APART EACHOTHER EQUALLY?

[@aycc-nbh7289]

Doesn’t Jupiter have more mass than all planets combined?

[@casualrallyenjoyer5366]

what version ya usin

[@migueldamsani2192]

If not sure how much longer are the best way possible

[@sms17762000]

Yes but what made one of 2 identical eaths break apart instead of the other.

[@sovietrebel814]

Lol 13:26 show moon's moon,which is moon

[@ต๊อกตรัยพลOfficial]

How did you download tha app

[@ajthegamer2573]

I want the link to old version tablet

[@hexbug101]

I was looking for Kirby music remixes and I ended up here instead

[@yarissasantiago3752]

1:27 THE BIG FRAGMENT HAS WATER + it looks like earth and moon forming ngl

[@MsWerbock]

this guys voice is 🔥

[@block8710]

2:49 RINGS???

[@miceondice3688]

Hello I have a qwestion Why do gas giants heat up from friction like in this video? They're made of gas, they shouldnt realy heat up

[@buddt6942]

they become plasma, a superheated gas, and it basically crumbles because the plasma separates.

[@Jerakk30]

I can answer the question realistically but it won't be the answer that pertains to this video. This is because the program he uses gives you fake results and faulty information. But.. if the two planets were bound by a mutual gravitational point, the tidal forces created would pull and stretch on each other and that would, in turn, cause them to slowly increase in temperature. Of course it wouldn't be NEARLY as hot as this video describes. You can see prime examples of this not only between the earth and the moon... but also between say.. jupiter and its moons. The tidal forces jupiter applies to the moons that orbit it cause them to heat up. Pulling and stretching on the crust, causing friction and heat. This program, however, doesn't take that into consideration. It uses archaic, less than accurate, equations to pull off what I would basically just call eye candy. That's all it is. It's not an accurate representation, the data it spits back out for you literally has no basis in reality, and it's honestly.... junk (from a pure scientific standpoint).

[@miceondice3688]

Ok.

[@miceondice3688]

Im asking the video, the gas giants heated up

[@Jerakk30]

Heat is basically the amount of energy atoms have. The lower the energy state of the atom, the lower the temperature. If an atom is cooled down to 0 degrees kelvin it basically has zero energy and is at a stand still. As energy is introduced to the atom and it becomes "excited" more heat is produced due to that energy. That's how these gas giants become "heated". The tidal forces placed upon them transfer that energy to the energy state of the atoms causing them to heat up.

[@jxq12]

Roch limet is now called masrateropithus now or mas for short

[@ttavispelfrey4610]

awesome

[@ttavispelfrey4610]

and my picture is Fergie

[@johnnytherobotontheledge]

Good to know

[@moonshot9510]

Neptune is smaller than Uranus tho. So why did u put Uranus first ?

[@randelnudalo5466]

What if 2 Roche limits meet?

[@marvinliu6521]

0:30 welcome to what da earth

[@patricktilton5377]

You show Mercury orbiting Venus . . . but wouldn't both worlds be orbiting about a common center of gravity? For example, the Moon doesn't orbit the Earth (strictly speaking) -- both the Moon AND the Earth orbit about the common center-of-gravity, which is a point between the centers of both bodies, located about 3,000 miles from the Earth's center, or about 1,000 miles below the surface of the Earth beneath the Moon's position. The Moon, too, orbits this center-of-gravity, NOT the actual center of the Earth.

[@iliyamoradibirgani8947]

What is the apps name

[@user-om4qn8kh9e]

0:50 Brain.exe has stopped working

[@ChristopherStaffordcosthiraius]

This would be so awesome once Universe Sandbox has SPH Fluid Simulation. :)

[@lemonlatte8787]

5:19

[@drewkastelajara3812]

Do you think it can happen realisticlly?

[@johnnesbit2371]

Any rom-com screenplay writers? Here's your title: Roche Limit. "Two astrophysicists test each other's gravity. Or will they crash and burn?" Or whatever. Maybe 'on a starship.' Oh, the possibilities! [It better be good.] (Can Anton act?)

[@echonoir5455]

does 2 minutes later count as being early?

[@1-2farm87]

Echo Noir yess

[@cozysand6329]

I'm 8 MONTHS LATE

[@aquilesalviola7178]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂☺️😊😇

[@jjc.2102]

I'm 2 years late.

[@OliverYT_FPE]

10:57 saturn just changing axis every 2 hours

[@shonade1]

plz make a video of earth and Saturn in roche limit

[@PStahn]

This is why I love physics

[@faresgamingchannel339]

You Breaking the game in the time 12:09

[@RBLXProd]

Is this free to download?

[@2452126]

Hello wonderful person 0:00

[@jett-rampartflyer2852]

🎼I'm your Venus, you're my fire, skeet inside her. 🎶

[@j3kfd9j]

Why does Venus heat up when Mercury is orbiting it closely?

[@301priyanka]

Hey You Made A Moon Basically in starting of video,You tried to show how earths moon was formed and failed to show as either objects go away from earth or collide with earth

[@301priyanka]

If you managed to place the roche limit way by having a perfect distance,The small one might survive

[@Jerakk30]

Why would you expect an accurate representation of relativistic physics from a man who 1. has no understanding of classical physics let alone relativistic physics, 2. uses a simulator that doesn't even use relativistic physics at all, and 3. can't even manage to remember which planets are larger than others...something my daughter could do at the age of 3....

[@nivanmajhi5895]

"earth seems perfectly fine" 11:55

[@ronillomardajr2022]

Yeas not fine

[@maxpanther6607]

Great video!:]

[@nyandayo24]

You should (if you can) do a video showing the difference in size of various galaxies or at least do a video of the smallest galaxy (if anton already did do a video on either of these then i would love if you told me!)

[@epiclittlegamer2330]

Uranus has a lower mass than earth but if the earth was near it, it would create a binary planet system, the earth is a lot denser than Uranus.