Can You Guess Which Half is CAKE?

[@SideserfCakes]

💚 If you like guessing Which One is Cake, you’re gonna love this video 👉 kzbin.info/www/bejne/iaiwd5uqj9ebm9U

[@That_Christian_Girly2.38]

Can you make a Nutella cake pls. 🥹 If not that’s fine, I just really LOVE Nutella 😋😍

[@JacobHGamez]

Awesome

[@thisuserisme]

Pls do Nutella

[@MalissiaCreates]

Only could tell because of watching so intently while you actually painted the details on the top of the cake! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 bravo 😘 excellent and yum 🤤

[@Boyina_Dream]

Try and make your onion plush into a cake

[@rokad7741]

I think something that let me know which one was the cake, was that the left half was slightly shinier than the real pizza.Other than that it was extremely realistic

[@Tiagocf2]

yeah, the shine gave it away.. she should have stroked some oil on the other half to make it more realistic 😂

[@abbydabby]

that's how I could tell too, I thought the crispy cheese on the crust was too shiny

[@HelloMyDoods]

Yah the shine kinda gave it away but I mean it’s still so realistic that if you saw it in a pizza box with no comparison pizza you’d be completely fooled

[@ayushpandey268]

@@HelloMyDoods exactly 💯

[@skyerobinson4148]

For me it was the imperfections in the crust on the right that were too perfect on the left. But I had to look HARD

[@ayushpandey268]

It's extremely difficult to guess which one was the cake...hats off to you Natalie....you are such a good Baker and an excellent artist as well...

[@kiraflint2023]

Definitely

[@anayahpanwar6797]

Actually!

[@kiki-jf5id]

Very true 👌

[@offimoo9995]

No…I guessed it. She always adds wayyy too much detail sooooo

[@daryl7745]

meh. The edges were too obvious

[@puddindancer]

That is incredible. I only guessed correctly because it was ever so slightly shinier than the real pizza. The overall look of it is amazing and woulda had me fooled to the point that if you served me it and I bit into it I would've been completely freaked out that it was actually cake.

[@CrimsonAkato]

I'd be very mad if I bit into that I rarely eat cakes not my type and if I'm expecting a pizza yeh nah screw the cake I'm going to be mad someone else can take it

[@amandaandneesa7126]

Yea same

[@wrenethajones5663]

Just imagine if someone thought that a pizza cake was a real pizza, and served it to you 😂

[@Rawt173]

The balloon dog itself might make for a challenging cake! I remember the pool float being insanely mind boggling, and I love the memory associated with the balloon animal. If you could pull that off someday, that would be spectacular.

[@Kanelle88]

CAKE SUGGESTION: How about a Mirror Cake? (I'm not sure if you can make something reflective but it would be cool if you could) Anyways nice pizza cake, it looks just like it. 🤤

[@fantasystaplesuwu1554]

Well, it wouldn't be a very long or interesting video. It would just be a silver glaze poured onto a cake.

[@Kanelle88]

@@fantasystaplesuwu1554 Yeah, but there might be a problem with ripples along the surface, it might be more difficult then you think. Also a mirror would have to have a frame wouldn't it? A really nice wooden frame with carved flowers and such would look pretty.

[@fantasystaplesuwu1554]

@@Kanelle88 none of my mirrors have frames, just smoothed down edges

[@th_medshitten]

@@fantasystaplesuwu1554 she could make it a fancy antique hand mirror with jewels on it

[@Theanimalfarm077]

All my mirrors do, all 6 of mind.

[@ittybittyrampagingcommittee]

Just wanna say, I love the production of these. They’re really fun and pop out as a unique style for editing / creating, not just the content itself but also just the vibes of the entire thing. ❤️

[@cakerbaker9965]

Really? I haven’t been here in awhile and I found the vid kinda hyper and chaotic …I even had to lower it.

[@ittybittyrampagingcommittee]

@@cakerbaker9965 Maybe it’s cuz I’ve got unmedicated ADHD out the ass but I enjoy it a lot. So, yes, really.

[@cakerbaker9965]

@@ittybittyrampagingcommittee Lol…fair enough

[@LexTheBombOffcial]

The cake looked more realistic than the actual pizza 😂

[@LavenderOnPawzz]

Lol fr 😂

[@MissLilyputt]

The left side of the pizza is shinier, so much so that makes the “red sauce” look more like jelly. Everything else looks on point.

[@Narzissist]

Now you have made me utterly hungry in all the ways possible 😂

[@HRae87]

Right? 😂

[@o6crepuscular9x]

The sculpt, texture, and color work were so convincing! I was only able to guess correctly because the outside curve of the circle was too perfectly even/symmetrical. Whereas the crust on the real pizza isn't a perfectly smooth half circle.

[@zactherailfanner]

I don’t know, but your cakes are so realistic that I would love to try one

[@Expired_Antidote]

I watched this with my onion cake stuffie with his green buttercream insides ;) I was so stoked when he came in the mail!!!!! Congrats on your pizza cake! You did fabulously like always 💜💜

[@shenayaheerschop5342]

Wow! Its like magic how u make that!

[@ZephyrinSkies]

This is one of your most realistic food cakes so far. The textures and the color of the cheese and tomato sauce were perfect.

[@thahseenabanu6442]

I love the fact that every week you challenge yourself with something harder and harder

[@UnknownID_1]

Ok someone give her an Award instantly ❤👀

[@angelofmusik16]

ikr

[@salinabeachy6379]

You are so talented!! I loved this cake(I love all you cakes)!

[@kiel5390]

Haven't watched a SS video recently and OH my. The editing, cinematography and music is sooo good. It just keeps getting better

[@terriemartinez9989]

The pizza cake looks more delicious than the pizza pizza. Great job! 🕊️🍕❤️🍰🤘🇺🇲

[@reborn_p0et]

BRAVO Natalie!! Another one for the books, your videos "cheer" me up bc of the positive energy you give us!! Much love from Pennsylvania

[@gilliantague]

This is a great one - it was so hard to tell! It's up there as one of your most realistic cakes ever. 😁♥️

[@ShibaMomma143]

The bread-y, dry-looking crust on the right made me think that the right side was the real pizza. The cake versions are generally shinier, like this one, but not by that much! Amazing work, as always! 🤩

[@oldshoes5199]

AMAZING!!! And It’s awesome to see you hand sculpting and painting again!

[@catalilac]

You should make a balloon cake! It would be another reminder and I LOVE your cake! :D

[@frog_lover14]

I am always looking forward to your videos every Monday. They are so funny and they make my day better. Thank you Natalie and Husband Dave! ☺️

[@sadddiee]

I almost couldn’t tell which one was cake! Very excellent job but what gave it away was the glossiness of the cake but you have improved so much and I love your channel!! ❤

[@msseeah]

At this point, at the end of the videos, I just pick whatever looks more like the real thing and decides that's that cake. You make the actual real thing look fake with your surreal talent!

[@nyxthewolf4660]

I think the one thing making the cake stand out from the real pizza is the glossy top layer It's just a little too smooth and thick. It's a wonderful imitation for the grease on a pizza, but the pizza's oil is a little spottier and more shear/matte in certain areas, and absorbs gradually into the crust. Nonetheless, you've absolutely outdone yourself. This is a fantastic work of art!

[@anayahpanwar6797]

Your videos are catchy, I never miss a single second of them! I am genuinely amazed by how talented you are! Natalie hats off! The amount of work u put into making your videos is very evident.....I always feel like (know) you are smiling every single second of making your videos! You have progressed alot and I know u will and can more! Great job and wishing u luck for the amazing future ahead of you!♡ Sending loads of love!

[@cherylanderson1462]

The texture of the sauce and the matte-ness seems really hard to replicate. You fooled me at first. You are very talented. Good job!

[@theechobee]

Well thank you for NOT making me hungry, because the fact that they TOUCH kills me

[@turidaugestrand]

I saw wich one was cake, but it was very hard! You are so talented! I really enjoy watching you videos!❤️✨

[@Totallysteak]

WOW! Amazing job Natalie!! Now I'm really craving some pizza... 😆🍕

[@noahpehowic6080]

You're not just a culinary expert, you're an artist.

[@AnnaAnna-uc2ff]

Love the close-up of the icing！

[@yellowlush2184]

This is brilliant ! Amazing talent...Could you make an instrument themed cake next ?

[@cookietastik603]

This is literly perfect timing lol, right when the notification came up I clicked because I was looking for a video and I was like "phew" can't wait to watch it! I remember last time you made a pizza cake i think

[@thegreatkate8]

Could you make a disco ball cake? That’d look so cool! 🪩

[@Whatyoulookinat3]

“Do you wear clothes?” “Or know someone who does?” Scared me

[@eniseekay]

I love your videos and love seeing how happy you are to make cake. The balloon dog story was adorable. :)

[@youtubeaccount5862]

Love your videos heres a recommendation a tiger cake! Only if you can i know theres hardly a chance of you seeing this but please make it if its possible. Also keep up the good work i have been a fan for a very long time😍💓💓

[@greenberrygk]

The left half was shinier which would make sense cause the pizza had to sit there for a while, and also the cheese inside the split part was just perfect enough to give it away.

[@DeadlyPink22]

Cake and Pizza hmmm. Possible flavour combo?🤣

[@Winchguy]

It was a bit hard but then I realized that one halve of the pizza looked more shiny, it was the cake that was more shiny, and also the crust was a tad bit darker

[@buddyholly4672]

Pizza and cake...classic combo 🍕 🍰 Amazing work as usual! 👏👏👏

[@kimberskin]

I love your vids Your so talented

[@thatcatgirl13]

I love watching your videos with my little brother 💕

[@Whatshouldmomdrawtoday]

Wow! Every time I think you can’t possibly get any better, you do! I could see this becoming a staple at kids birthday parties. A sort of Russian roulette with a half cake/ half pizza. The kids have to claim their piece ahead of them and then find out later if they get cake or pizza at a party. Lmao!

[@TheMoonsMistress]

The shine and uniformity of the crust thickness helped me figure out which side was cake but if i saw it without knowing there was cake at all it would have fooled me for sure. Great job

[@erickisip9955]

Love the videos

[@Deathshot.691]

The cake looks great almost thought the cake was a real pizza at the end

[@veggiet2009]

The fact that both halves look like they are touching

[@laylaiscringe]

hi natalie i love your videos they are very cool and interesting! your cakes always look so good! ❤️

[@jennaarko9913]

Oh my gosh. That really got me! My jaw was on the floor with this cake! I really thought the right pizza was the cake. Until she cut in to it I really didn't have any idea! Love your channel!

[@pawtcha]

It looks real. The thing that gave it away for me is that the cake is more reflective. It can't really be helped, different foods reflect light differently, you did an amazing job!

[@shay4854]

I think this is your best cake yet! I am literally amazed 🤩

[@imxni16]

2:13 “Do you wear clothes, or do you know someone who does” LMAO

[@kasper_phizz]

Hey, I just want to say that your videos seriously help me sleep, relax, and calm down a lot

[@Slayeditz456]

Those close up shots where so pretty and satisfying your literally my favourite KZbinr I love your cakes sooooo much!!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@snape-itachiel6167]

that story only emphasize how talented you are and oh my all of this out of self teaching is so impressive!!!

[@angelofmusik16]

you tricked me after i watched the vid also you have gotten so much better over this month!! i would scream if i saw you in real life!!

[@anonymouscreature9483]

I could tell because I could see details better, those slightly burned details were of higher quality then it usually is. But other then that I can't tell the difference, it's AMAZING!

[@kimberlyplante9688]

You're so talented! I love your videos!! Keep up the good work!! You're so fun 😁

[@moooncestay741]

To be honest, I could tell when the camera got closer to the pizza, espesially the melted cheese, but that's a really good work, it tricked me for a few seconds!

[@TamiHoshiyama1957]

I love how the halves are even connected by sauce and cheese! It's almost perfect. I say "almost," because the crust on the cake side is a little too shiny. You're amazing! Now I'm hungry for 🍕 🎂!

[@younatehfouna7514]

I love her videos especially that tomorrow is my birthday so this cake was really cool❤✨

[@rychartist]

Love your videos!! Could you please do a video making a ball full of green grapes???? Green grapes have translucent skin and I'd like to see how you'd go about making something like that

[@Ivy2Wang]

Cake Suggestion: What about a lamp cake? I would love to see what you would make the lampshade out of if possible. Or what about a violin cake?

[@averagejoe77_]

Definitley one of the best realistic cakes I've seen on this channel! Great job! :)

[@jenniedraws406]

Oh my gosh!! The ground round!! You just brought that back for me. My family used to go there for birthday parties.

[@fullmovies9024]

1:04 as an Italian, thank you so much for putting our national treasure, Bella Ciao, on the background 🥰🥰❤❤🇮🇹🇮🇹

[@dogboi_thatrealdog]

I love your videos and work, but here is something that gave it away for me. I saw your famous green buttercream underneath the cake pizza

[@JustRoviene]

i used to watch your vids alot and i still lovee your hyper realistic cakes!

[@Sam_Peterson]

Who else loves the closeup shots of the Signature Green Buttercream?

[@caileyrookids]

As the others were saying, the left one was slightly shinier. Also it just felt slightly heavier, with it touching the table where the one on the right curved up a little.

[@meihelaniitaaehau1539]

girlieeeee you GOTTA make a seperate asmr channel for the eating of your cakes!! I know you give em to friends and all, but seriously, that would be so cool1!!

[@lunabelletheinsane]

Natalie! I think a better option for your videos, when you are trying to see if you can fool us, is to show a shot of them at the beginning and ask us to decide, AND THEN show us the process and then show us the shot of the real vs cake again so we can see if really got it right, because sometimes, when I watch you make it, I can tell simply because I watched the process and where you put a decoration down - and it's more fun to try and guess and see if I was right than to pick yours out because I saw how you laid something down in a particular way. It's not an issue particularly in this video - but in some of your other videos, you know because we saw you make it.

[@SyrenSongg]

Really close! It was given away by being a touch over saturated in color and a little overboard on the lighting for the grease look! It’s still so cool to see how closely they look!

[@StrangerHappened]

*Your cake is impeccable, as always, but what kind of "pizza" is that?* It has like two centimetre thick dough, which is a crime for pizza. Italians would die just from seeing it on the video.

[@melindarivera6598]

Yay! So glad for a new side surf cake video.

[@n76543]

yes guessed correctly, it's the close up of the browning part in the crust that give it away and the shiny to matte difference

[@taggykikuku3185]

Both sides look delicious. You did a great job. Also your hair is so perfect 😍

[@StephanieGodfrey-ox7ki]

My daughters love watching your cake tutorials! They want to know if you would make a globe?

[@krankarvolund7771]

"Pay what you weight" Wait 40 $ seems a lot for a kid pizza "My parents paid 40 cents" Oh, that makes more sense XD

[@Blue_J-th2fd]

I commented on the short featuring the pizza cake, and I tried to edit it, but I couldn’t find it again! I only answered which side was the cake, and I didn’t explain that it was still an excellent hyper realistic cake! Other than the shininess giving it away, the detail was fantastic, as well as the presentation! Putting it next to the real pizza was a great idea, and I’m sure it was a fun challenge! Great work, Natalie! 💛

[@jfisher4156]

I can not wait until the knife is the cake

[@FernFluff]

It’s shiny yes, but I think even if it wasn’t shiny, the depth would give it away, it was a bit thicker, like a cake. But it did take me some time to figure it out. You’re really talented, keep it up!

[@conormcgregorsbrokenleg9847]

It was just a lil glossy but was PERFECT. Totally couldn’t tell if it wasn’t for a lil glow it hard. ALWAYS impressed

[@goldlemur8]

This one was amazing! I was just barely able to tell which one was cake. The left side was a lot shinier than the right side, so I knew it had to be the cake. Still, great job!

[@nolife8209]

i was able to guess due to this clip at 4:54 the cheese wasn't touching the bottom at the right, but on the left, it was and the one on the left was thicker than usually it would be after cheese is pulled

[@alyssahall3744]

We live in Thailand and my kids LOVE watching your cake videos. My four year old son was just eating his fried rice when he started saying “And there you have it. Fried rice, that’s actually a cake!” So I vote you make a fried rice cake. 😉🍚

[@janisebenjamin278]

I HAVE SEEN THE WHOLE PROCESS BUT STILL CANNOT TELL THE DIFFERENCE!!!!!! But actually, you are really talented AND my inspiration.

[@jillyb350]

You got me, I thought your cake was the real pizza! Love your videos and your cakes!! 🍰

[@mele4827]

For me, it was the shine and the center cut. The pizza crust gives, it doesn't remain flat like the cake.

[@aliceouzounidou5350]

i literally watched you make the whole think and in the and i still go it wrong !! That it really impressing skills right there!!

[@collwyr]

I guessed right, so it was nice to be correct, as a few comments I saw rightly said, the shine was a good indicator as to which was which, but also for me, what sealed the deal was the crust tear in the bottom corner of the pizza slice itself, that sold it for me as to which was which as I wasn't confident that was something easy to do for cake making, but also, it would seem like a weird design choice, when you're trying to replicate something as something else you tend to be conversative and play it safe, not just throw in a tear for no reason.

[@spreaky]

I love how you just make cakes that looks so yummy that I want to eat the real food like this

[@janea2585]

I love these videos. They have made me really good at recognizing cake replicas 🍰 they make me really happy 😁

[@purplolart]

really great cake!! only thing that gave it away was the shine .3. keep up the awesome work!!