Can You Guess Which Item is Cake?

[@chithead3768]

I want to see you make a hyper realistic baby cake so bad.

[@lunazebracat]

bro imagine seeing someone cut into a baby cake-

[@jellydarling1008]

that be hilarious.

[@noatmealcookie02]

Same

[@noatmealcookie02]

@@lunazebracat i mean, she had those with realistic animals And even her face cake

[@bpr5211]

I didn't know how bad I needed this in my life until I seen this comment 😭

[@ktrmeadow]

I don’t know which you’re better at…creative cakes or spectacular storytelling? The wood riser was fantastic.

[@derekrobertson60388]

With so many cakes looking so hyper realistic I can one day imagine just stepping out of my home to find out that the sidewalk is made of cake Reading the replies so she’s done it before?? She might as well create another earth made of cake

[@Marsiix]

"wait why the fu- is my shoe so dirty- and why is the ground so soft-? Ohh.. its a cake."

[@MisterNohbdy]

She's done it before! KZbin keeps hiding my attempt to post the link, but search her past vids for "edible sidewalk".

[@khalilahd.]

If you live near Natalie I can definitely see that happening 😂

[@sm-65datlas23]

knowing that she also made a sidewalk hyperrealistic cake makes it so much possible

[@crystalskeete976]

You may accidentally punch a hole in the wall and then see green buttercream.

[@Abithzer]

Technically this is still her remake of the older soap cake. There's so much improvement in this recent soap cake, the bubbles adds more realism. The cake is beautiful, bravo Natalie! 🍰♥️

[@khalilahd.]

Yes I agree!! And I even thought she was amazing in the first one and she somehow got even better!

[@RantingBaboon]

@@khalilahd. Hii! I always see you on this channel! Also I saw you comment somewhere else so I @ed you

[@nataliaaa18]

Thank you😂 my name is also Natalia

[@Ian_Mcrae43]

can you make a cake that actually looks like a cake?

[@beaniebooandlulu4664]

Yep,very correct!

[@sarahmorris3152]

I suggested trying to make a soap cake with edible bubbles several months ago, and I'm so excited that you ended up making one! It looks amazing!

[@insectoidabomination]

Please note that the bot on your comment is a scam bot, don't trust it :)

[@sarahmorris3152]

@@insectoidabomination thank you!! 🙂

[@leahmendelson6845]

Idea: Brain cake

[@Angie-p1p]

She made a brain cake before

[@randomdots7758]

Hey Natalie! I just want to thank you for all the effort you put into all these videos (and uploading every Monday!) Whenever I watch your videos, I laugh and just enjoy them! Whenever I show your videos to my friends, they immediately fell in love with what you do. Every Monday I get excited, knowing you’ll upload and especially when I had an awful day or even sick, I put on your videos and it cheers me up :) Just wanted to stay thank you for all the effort ❤️ have a good day! (Congrats on 3M too!)

[@khalilahd.]

Couldn’t have said it better ❤

[@Chaotic_lesbi4n]

I love how much pride she has about how weird her cakes are! Also pleeeeeeease make a baby cake!

[@gigahorse1475]

People will get mad when she cuts it 😂

[@Chaotic_lesbi4n]

@@gigahorse1475 holy crap I hadn’t thought of that. It would be disturbing though lol

[@sophiamccullough9975]

I’d be like the dog reaction to the puppy cake

[@tobiasdeutsch563]

My wife and I discovered cake wrecks about 11 years ago. Comedic gold, even as a non baker. You know what would be horror gold? If you caked a facehugger from aliens cake!

[@mildredthegoat8340]

The portrait cake is actually better than I was expecting it to be, I thought it would look really terrible, but it's not too bad. ( I think that's meant to be a compliment!)

[@cassiopeaknack]

I was right about the bar of soap being cake but I only thought that because I figured it was something you’d like to make. The bottles had a shininess that seems too perfect to be a cake but I did think the box was also a cake with printed edible paper. I suspected the wood base but it looked too real so I threw out that suspicion but it was cake! Wow, really well done

[@PyroWolfofEarth]

I was also right about the bar of soap and was surprised about the ate as well. I figured it was the soap because I remember her making foam or bubbles before. So that's how I came to the co conclusion it was the soap.

[@mariaelenamura3861]

The gelatin bubbles are Genius!!! And the table made of cake.. genius as well 😂

[@khalilahd.]

I thought your first soap cake was great but this second one is unbelievable!! Definitely watching that episode of Nailed it 😅❤

[@helpmereach45ksubswithoutvideo]

Congrats to Everybody who is Early and Found this Comment 🥳

[@Kaaylinn]

🎉

[@Pool_Kids]

U too!

[@oliviadoonan5686]

thanks u to

[@fatimaperez9181]

🙄

[@sophiaodyssey1448]

Early

[@stlndvlk]

I like it how she tells stories about her life experiences while making the cake

[@Chaotic_lesbi4n]

There is something so satisfying about watching her make these!

[@kanadeyoisakiren2525]

I suggest making a wolf cake with all the little furs and details. It would be so cool of you actually pulled it off! But of course it is up to you. And I'm so exited that you made this cake SOO realistic. I mean the bubbles even! I love it.

[@annierism]

I know she did a Minecraft wolf but she hasn’t done a real wolf. I would love that too. Wolves are my absolute favorite animals.

[@woodymurphy2249]

Excellent as always. Pine Tar is my absolutely favorite Dr. Squatch scent. The worst thing, cake wise, I've had happen to me was dropping my son's spider-man cake in the floor. Thankfully it was still in the container. I had to remake it myself in a short amount of time using a zip lock bag as a piping bag. I somehow managed to make it passable as looking the way it was supposed to. The things we do for our kids?!?

[@valvihk3649]

Yep, I guessed the soap as the cake. The bottled content was obvious due to the lighting. It was hard to choose between box and soap. I didn't even look at the bark. The bark got me lol.

[@slay9468]

HOLD ON YOU WERE ON NAILED IT?!?!?! Seriously I watch that with my parents SO MUCH I’m going back to rewatch you

[@anakelly76512]

Oh, my word! I love Dr. Squatch products even though I'm a female. I use the more subtle scents. I have the soaps, shampoos, conditioners, deodorant and the toothpastes. Loved to see them turned into cakes. They have a chocolate scented soap called Chocy Milk. You could make your cake chocolate to the it in with the soap. Awesome job!!

[@lydia9638]

Oh my goodness! I am so happy right now! I have no idea if you made the wooden platter because of this or not, but I have commented that I thought a log cake would be cool. And now I have a log cake!!!! Plus soap! Again, don't know if this was the reason for making the log, but it makes me happy either way!

[@ritsidragunfly2057]

You successfully bamboozeled me. I knew something on top of the plate was cake, but not the plate itself. Great work!

[@Iluvfictionalguys]

The more you see it……….. The more you get deceived.❤😂

[@GodsBestFriend888]

I knew it was the soap as you're so creative you would choose the most difficult one to re-create. Fantastic!!

[@Lolxplayz_WasHere]

Can you try making a ice cream Sunday hyper realistic cake?

[@noodles3133]

I was watching a piano video and thought, you didn't make a piano hyper realistic cake, so I am asking for you to make one please

[@tarynkeppy9156]

OMG I’ve been waiting for you to do this for forever I love this cake it’s really cool! thanks for making it! Your awesome! 😊

[@No_one7602]

I love your cakes Natalie! You and your husband keep up the good work! I will forever love your channel and continue watching! And you go make that cake of a baby!!

[@IChangedMyName_123]

She has a husband?!

[@_zylith9251]

I was so happy that I got the soap correct BUT WHEN YOU CUT / MADE THE WOOD! MY SMILE WENT AWAY SO FAST 😂😂😂😂

[@laurenschenck5355]

You make MOST BEAUTIFUL CAKES Natalie! ❤

[@CoolCat-db3yk]

Can you make a cake of a open pencil case with overflowing pencils/pencil crayons/markers? I think it would be so cool! Love your cake, as always!

[@laurenschenck5355]

YOU ARE THE BEST CAKE ARTIST EVER!! You are so special unique unbelievable blessing angel and remarkable and and so proud of you of everything you accomplished over the years xoxo ❤

[@Bellllllz]

I looooove that soap! Awesome cake and storys =) p.s. I'd LOVE to see a baby cake hehe

[@jo.comics]

Make the baby cake. Please. Pleeeeease. Oh, it would make my day!

[@hehe69652]

Your videos are always so entertaining and it is so cool with how much effort you put into your videos. 🥰❤️

[@Moon_Thief_420]

Lost my mind when I heard my name come up in this video. 😂 It's fairly rare to hear/see/meet another Brenna in the wild.

[@summersasthetic6041]

First ahhh posted 11 seconds ago!!!

[@liltlemissmeany]

First

[@HiSkyHigh]

Nice

[@RollerCoasterFreak]

Nice

[@liltlemissmeany]

@@RollerCoasterFreak ty!!

[@cinnamonbunbun2]

Hey Natalie! I haven't ever watched any videos that were posted on the same day. I'm so happy I saw the notification! Well, your hyper realistic cakes totally rock! I never know if it is cake!

[@Mo_Thecat]

Natalie, when you misspelled the word “Birthday” it’s okay. My mom bought a birthday banner that said “Happy Birbirtday.” I think that’s the worst fail ever…

[@mystery_artist]

YOU SHOULD SIGN UP FOR SUGAR RUSH!!!!😭❤️🙃 You would easily win tho tbh😂💜

[@sarahsworld9840]

Can you make Ariana Grande cake I’m her Ariana’s biggest fan ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@ValeriaXSandra]

How about those cute babylike dolls, as a middle ground? They have similar proportions to a BABY, but their cartooney eyes will not send us into uncanny valley

[@avleonar]

I literally just watched you make the wooden platform and I completely forgot it was made of cake! 🤦‍♀️

[@basudhasanjay7925]

Heyy Natalie, I ❤️ your cakes so much...... 😊. Can you make a knife cake and cut other cakes with it??

[@NullPointerException7]

I predicted the soap being cake BUT NOT THE STUMP WTF YOU ARE SO GOOD

[@LanakilaMiller]

What are you do with the cake that you’re done making? Personally I know after making a couple cakes a year by the time I was 20 I was kicked out but I can’t imagine making dozens of cakes weekly and one way or another that you enjoy eating anything from them. Do you donate them or do you give them to family or friends or just throw them away?

[@RDasian]

You should make a CLAY 2 tier cake (a regular cake and however u want) and then make a cake knife and as u pretend to cut the cake, the knife breaks instead of the cake. That would cool asf!

[@invizig9137]

the gender reveal cake makes sense to me, judging by the missing S it was probably a recent immigrant who made it, and I think it's only recently that people outside america learned what gender reveal parties are (they were on the news a lot because some people caused forest fires)

[@KhadijaQasem-q7p]

ask the customer how the baby looks like and put the gender reveal colour inside and the cake has to look exactly like the baby

[@SweetGreenYT]

I have a chanlange! contineue to read if you want to see You want to see? Okai than! Try to make a bad cake than show how to make it better you make ze bad cake in real life not looking at a foto giving vice Have a wonder full day!😊

[@luzalvarado6084]

I actually found you thanks to that Netflix show and started following you since, i love youu!

[@victoriahan2520]

You should rlly collab with jonny cakes i bet you guys will make the most hyper realistic cake in the world together

[@Cloudy_ra1nxx]

Day 7 of asking if you could make a pool noddle or towel cake. Please make an open towel with wrinkles as a challenge and the pool noodle could have an awesome texture

[@deliriouscheeto]

One question. Shouldn't she legally be disclosing that this is an ad for that brand?

[@Ririi20]

I thought the biggest bottle as the cake but it’s not! Wow your getting so much better than the last 10 years but I can never come close to what you did when you were 10 lol I suck at decorating cake s

[@garyhanshaw1970]

Nobody’s perfect, but take comfort knowing you’re closer than most!😀

[@laurenschenck5355]

Love you so much Natalie and thanks so much for everything you rock and most sweetest person ever and the BEST cake artist ❤

[@pranjalpandey4130]

Can make a cake of vecna from stranger things i love ur cakes ❤️ you are such a talented cake maker ur cakes always make my day❤️👑

[@charlotterimer4611]

You should try making a cake that looks like a cake. So you make a cake and then cover it and decorate it to look like a cake with exposed sponge on the sides. A cake within a cake

[@abbiedetrick3974]

I think you should remake a shrimp cake messed up with real ice, but I’ll kick just a mess up

[@shoes7899]

looking at the thumbnail i really wished that it was the soap, my hopes were low but you really nailed it!

[@rubbafunk]

It would be really funny if you made a cake of a butt. ( a cake "cake") haha!

[@randomdudeface]

Day 32 of asking Sideserf Cake Studio to make a Bonsai Tree cake.

[@daisyflowrs12]

Hey, I really want to see you make Chrissy from stranger things as a cake!

[@tocalifedariusLOL]

At some point can you make a hyper realistic house cake (not the size of a house, about as small as an actual cake)

[@micahjensen6825]

hey you should make a playing card cake box and deck idk i thought it would be cool

[@emmam9061]

Love your videos!

[@rigel6857]

I totally think you should remake one of these cakes!I also would love if you made a baby cake!

[@rubenarreola9993]

For valentines you should make a hyper realistic human heart

[@utkarshnarvekar8886]

Am a late??? By the way. I love this video. This video is comedy.

[@ElyaKaleua]

Another cake win. Thank you for the video! I would love to see a Final Fantasy XIV inspired cake.

[@4Rgames]

if you remake a cake fail, do it on April Fool's Day!

[@Ava48463]

Day two of asking for a Queen Elizabeth cake

[@Urfavgirlforlifee]

Pls recreate cake failss

[@fatemaesufally9798]

Day-3 of asking for a birthday present cake

[@complainer406]

Can you do a tombstone cake in October? 🪦🪦🪦

[@low-carbcrazy1336]

You're an incredible artist! Beautiful work!

[@nabayaseen9836]

Make a cake of your childhood please!!!!!🥺

[@Marina-vd]

Yay! It’s Monday😍 new Monday new cake

[@thewackywizard8312]

excellent cake! your so talented

[@thewackywizard8312]

gosh im early

[@spiderscout8407]

day forty-five of asking for the pyro from tf2

[@isabellerouse1740]

Do a carved jackolantern for the Halloween season! It would look epic!

[@genesisISjustgeneis]

Can you pretty please make a beared dragon cake

[@daniellemartin997]

You should make a strawberry cake

[@SK22520]

Yes we want to see the hyperrealistic baby!

[@_koky_]

Hi Natalie♥️ I love you vids so much And also every time am sad I open your channel to watch your vids❤️ Also congrats on 3 mil 🥳🎉 Your channel is growing up so fast Love u♥️💗

[@thatdaydreamer3233]

I love this channel!!!

[@Firegen1]

Cake wrecks was amazing! The usb cake was always my favourite. The weird ken doll icing polar bear rug trend. What was the that? Also the soap cake was lovely.

[@Bird-kq1ol]

You should make a Nike Air shoe cake.

[@RookVR_]

Please make a chess cake! (Also love ur vids)

[@annabelleioffe]

Day 1 of asking for a bonsai tree cake!

[@Idkwhattoputasmyusernameyay]

Day 2 of asking for a Pringles cake

[@canhanhtrainers632]

Hi Natalie! I love your videos and I just wonder can you make a hyperrealistic cake of a pomegranate. I would really appreciate that.

[@bennocara3708]

Can you make a side-serf mug cake?

[@invizig9137]

The soap bubbles really sell this one

[@Korok37]

Do you eat your cakes afterwards?

[@TakeAction321]

I can’t believe you were nailed it 😮

[@Sparklyprettyprincessbiana]

Could you try to use chocolate cake?