BMW X2 vs Jaguar E-Pace vs Volvo XC40 - Carbuyer

Video: BMW X2 in-depth review: carbyr.uk/2Faxh9p
Video: Jaguar E-Pace in-depth review: carbyr.uk/2FejfUj
Video: Volvo XC40 in-depth review: carbyr.uk/2Ff1R1Y
4x4s and SUVs playlist: carbyr.uk/2alTzoD
SUBSCRIBE to Carbuyer for new videos every week: bit.ly/17k4fct
Sign up to Carbuyer’s newsletter for the latest videos, news, reviews and advice: carbyr.uk/2jFdbFj
SUVs are all the rage and in particular small premium ones. They have stylish designs, classy cabins and have desirable badges on their noses.
Three of the very latest to arrive are the BMW X2, Jaguar E-Pace and the Volvo XC40, but which one is best? James Batchelor and Ginny Buckley find out.
BMW X2 full written review: carbyr.uk/2Fe8Act
Jaguar E-Pace full written review: carbyr.uk/2FncaAO
Volvo XC40 full written review: carbyr.uk/2Ffq87Y
Follow us: Twitter.com/CarbuyerUK - Facebook.com/CarBuyerUK - carbuyeruk
Subscribe to Auto Express magazine: subscribe.autoexpress.co.uk
Carbuyer makes car buying simple. We're the only automotive brand that's approved by the Plain English Campaign, delivering you clear, concise and easy to understand information about the things that really matter when you're choosing - and buying - your next car.
www.carbuyer.co.uk
Every week, Carbuyer's KZbin channel brings you simple and entertaining reviews on every major make and model that's available for sale in the UK. Plus you'll find frequently-updated top 10 features and the occasional group test for good measure. If you want even more helpful information, head over to Carbuyer.co.uk where you'll find in-depth reviews of more than 500 cars, alongside the best buying advice and dozens of features helping you to narrow down your car buying shortlist.

[@redspin2ify]

Would never have considered volvo as a serious contender before their recent design refresh. Stunning

[@sweetfreedomGB]

Designs are ok-ish but reliability pooe..awful in fact.

[@6770connor]

My parents V40 is 4 years old and has never put a foot wrong, easily the most reliable car they have owned!

[@tattoodrdoke]

I currently drive a 2015 quashqai. I think my next car will be a volvo. When they updated them i nearly took my car in to trade on a new one however i have decided to wait until 2020 before getting the Volvo.

[@josingh20]

@@sweetfreedomGB ummmm...why do you say that?

[@sweetfreedomGB]

@@josingh20 survey of new cars by whatcar. .. not used cars but cars under 12 months old. XC90 has an appalling reliability record. Volvo as a brand gas a solid reputation but the latest XC's are poor.

[@lightweight8789]

I’m from Malaysia. Can’t wait for my XC40 T5 R-Design to be deliver on March 2019! Now i know i make a perfect choice. Thank you for your review&comparison.

[@godprint]

good chemistry for 2 of producers to be in 1 video. keep this up

[@emmavandewetering1632]

I like them all for different reasons, but the BMW has my vote every time for the simple fact it doesn't rely on touchscreen for the infotainment controls. I have an X3 now and I LOVE the controller down by my gear shift, it's far safer than using a touchscreen where you have to take your eyes off the road while you press icons. And it was really easy to get used to the toggle, after a short time you memorize the clicks and do it instinctively WHILE keeping your eyes on the road where they should be.

[@KaldeaMaeve]

Waiting on my XC-40 R-Design to be built and ready in February. I'm so excited :D

[@galloping5273]

Great video.. love the relaxed “chat show” type format. Keep it up

[@amberleighherman9898]

really great show you two... was a very entertaining watching the both of you carry on ....... show itself was really informative and factually apt.

[@almulholland5355]

I like the co-presenting with Batch and Ginny - hope to see them do more reviews together.

[@eekkalavonen7471]

I definitely agree.

[@MaZEEZaM]

@@eekkalavonen7471 Not for me, I found the woman a bit annoying.

[@Kingdonnerkebab]

MaZEEZaM annoying!? Shes a stunner man!

[@hectorandem2944]

@@MaZEEZaM What did she do that was so annoying? _Review a car?!_ 🐸☕

[@LFC-Star]

@@MaZEEZaM I find her rather sexy so big thumbs up from me :)

[@Mister_H]

Great video James and the interaction between you and Ginny was a joy to watch. I hope this new formula is here to stay and I look forward to the next 'double act' video 😃

[@paulcfyeung]

Great video guys! Rather enjoyable! Keep up the good work!

[@evol3852]

Thank you so much for this review. You guys answered a ton of my questions!

[@js986]

Someone turned up the production, nice

[@williambosworth4232]

I bought a new xc60, broke down on the way home after collecting it brand new, faulty wire on fuel pump, had trouble with EGR valve since, had too have a new type of EGR valve and cooler, running ok now.

[@bigbadbear2962]

@@williambosworth4232 oh damn sorry to hear that, I’ve bought 2 new xc60s and had no issues.

[@thetyrerjones]

Now that’s how you do a group test 👍 Informative, fun and with great production values... More of the same please...

[@robbie50302]

Great co - presenting.Had my XC40 R Design D4 FE now for 7 months and absolutely love it.

[@robbie50302]

Yeah the twin turbo makes my D4 surprisingly gutsy and it pulls well yet still economical. @@antifalibtardsandsnowflake3620

[@AngryBritain]

Absolutely brilliant video. Had me in stitches. You should do more together.

[@onkarsawantbhosle3146]

BMW was never supposed to look "wow" either inside or out. It's the built quality, engineering, handling and driving pleasure in general.

[@rimmerblues1586]

Indeed, so it's a real shame that BMW have begun going all "wow" on the interior on recent models rather than keeping with that philosophy.

[@tomstudioSLO]

Doing the review with two presenters is great. Love to see this concept in the future. More squabbling would be even better. Keep up the good work James & Ginny.😎 Greetings from Slovenia.

[@quinnzabukovic6778]

Tomy Boy I’ve been to Slovenia and it is drop dead gorgeous!

[@lukaaa6367]

@@quinnzabukovic6778 I live in slovenia and it sucks

[@lukaaa6367]

Ma bravo

[@quinnzabukovic6778]

luka polajner Then move lol

[@lukaaa6367]

@@quinnzabukovic6778 where to?

[@markkandie9423]

VOLVO XC 40, impressive...

[@vakasm8227]

i think the jaguar is the best from these three, even if it isnt aswell built. it has the best badge and the styling is the most cohesive so it wont date as much as the other two.

[@Mr-Faraz92]

Still No Android And Apple system is Shame For Jagur With TFT Secreen... 👎👎👎

[@iandavis8725]

Faraz Gill yes the the whole range now has Apple CarPlay. That car they had this in video didn’t have the latest software update.

[@Kelveron]

Ridiculously over the top and repeated criticisms of the X2's interior design in the review. To my eyes X2's interior looks fine and is far easier to use than XC40's, which is far too reliant on the touchscreen, and has too many functions on it.

[@Kelveron]

@@antifalibtardsandsnowflake3620 You should spend less time thinking about men's butts and instead focus on on your school homework.

[@marcobresciani544]

nice to see that my car wins this test. Happy for may purchase!

[@lash9400]

Car buyer is back on form. I like the banter between Batch & Ginny. Keep up the good work and I agree with the verdict, X40 is the one I would buy.

[@Atomicbri]

Loved the two of you on this review, Ginny and James! AND I totally agree with you all, I feel the Volvo XC40 is the best out of these. I think its look will also last for years to come and I am excited to go and check one out for myself. Hope you all continue these shared reviews from time to time. I really enjoyed this one and your banter between you two! (yaaaaawn says Ginny LOL!)

[@lewis72]

Ginny's rather lovely.

[@stevemichael9576]

Nice video guys. Different and good flow to it. 👍🏽

[@Wendys_lovinglife]

Love you two together doing reviews. I'm considering all 3 of these vehicles when I replace my 2017 Mercedes SLC300 with a compact SUV this summer. You gave me ALL of the information I need but I am still confused about which one I will choose. LOL. Not YOUR fault though. I'm making my husband crazy already with my indecision and "research". Thank you for this video!

[@malcolmbrown5261]

Had my X2 for about a month , love it , nippy light on the steering, fuel consumption is reasonable, toys are good easy to operate, nothing to moan about

[@sullysullivan1187]

THE VIEWER SHADE AT THE BEGINNING LOL. Wish this channel was bigger its fun.

[@mgdu46]

Having driven the 3, I choose the X2 xdrive 20d. The volvo is boring to drive and the E-Pace would be great but too heavy and the infotainment does not convince me... maybe because I have the same on my F-Pace... So I go back to BMW because I drive a lot and I love to drive. 🙋🏻‍♂️✌️

[@jameswarden9136]

I love Volvo, even old Volvo's

[@cristicristi2668]

for women the are

[@jonnydavis6066]

Me too

[@sweetfreedomGB]

old Volvos are the best ones to have

[@lotusinfotech4580]

I think Jaguar f-type is much better than Porches, BMW, Mercedes and Audi

[@raffica26]

X2: Do not touch the screen when driving. The central control is super easy to use, completely convenient. IMO the touch screen is should rather be seen as a useful add-on for the pillion seat passenger. Otherwise unnecessary, and as said, raises safety concerns.

[@3204clivesinclair]

I choose the European Car of the Year 2018 - XC40.

[@Mustafafilming]

XC 40 is breath of fresh air. Rest of the bench seem boring.

[@danishviking6254]

Very true. Very much not trying to look and be like the rest.

[@MiniEggs1999]

Yeah take that commentors ... talking about our clothes 🤣 Great first co-lab video. Really liked you are having proper conversations from the off rather than taking turns reading spec sheets whilst driving the cars. . It also appears there is a bit of a Kirsty and Phil dynamic going on 🤣

[@geraldbuttelwerth7670]

Just purchased the 2019 Volvo XC40 Inscription. It is absolutely beautiful and comfortable. Loving it!!

[@MrMarcob73]

mee too it is a fantastic car

[@fkim8449]

Ordered my xc40 4 months ago said i would get it the end of april 😢😭😢 and monday i got a mail that i get it the end of januari 🤗🤗😀😀

[@geraldbuttelwerth7670]

Costel Coaie don’t feel sorry for me. I’m loving this car. Feel sorry for someone who cares!

[@fkim8449]

@Costel Coaie i can't help but feel sorry for someone who buys a bmw that got the same styling from 20 years back

[@fkim8449]

@Costel Coaie lol, i know more then you so don't be arrogant ty !!! Cause you said it and i respond too you and your being childish way to go 😉😋

[@wayfaringcookie8142]

Great video! Love the new style more entertaining.

[@alexbrownr]

love the two presenters! Keep up with that

[@amintaslneto]

Couldn't agree more. Great vid folks

[@ricardoprado6250]

Excellent, thank you very much!

[@0911relax]

Just paid deposit today on the R Pro T5. If you like to drive you have to have the T5 with close on 250bhp. The T4 is just not powerful enough at about 190bhp. The car feels much more relaxed with the bigger engine with a small variance in mph. I test drove against the new Macan 2lt and can vouch this is a more enjoyable car with much more “tec” as standard. Also, the Volvo is a completely new platform and does look much more modern.

[@qbal7562]

Good, balanced review.

[@gabrielgabro4755]

Loved it! Keep on.

[@Kingdonnerkebab]

Ginny and Batch perfect combo! Id choose the Volvo too they make some very interesting cars nowadays.

[@hxhx]

great video !

[@shriyutdubey946]

I'll choose jaguar e- pace don't know why but i seriously like it !!!

[@Nnomadd]

I wander what is the fascination for storage of bottles of water when choosing a car

[@robertmarsh3588]

Great review. Ginny and Batch co-presenting works really well too. Don't fancy a SUV though...not the answer to our environmental concerns and there are far better drivers cars out there for less money.

[@MyRyan12345678910]

JLR Incontrol pro is soon to be available with Apple CarPlay, and will be available on older cars

[@longtailgt]

More videos like this please

[@Star-dz3ei]

I have an X2 and I love ❤ the side BMW BADGE!💥

[@rob5896]

Like the BMW badge in the c pillar, nice touch a bit different and I love different…

[@chrismon-ke9849]

Excellent presenting and review. Please let Ginny and Batch co-present again!

[@ioannistsoukalas5393]

Nice presentation, but I believe you should be testing X1 instead of X2.

[@marekkemp3398]

Your English is such a pleasure to listen to. 🏆

[@menifo4334]

Why does James set the cam inside the car when reviewing the rear of a car giving us a good impression of how practical and comfortable the car is and Ginny outside? How are we expected to view the interior of the rear when Ginny's body is obstructing the view? Don't you have a protocol for everyone to follow there at Carbuyer's?

[@sydjaguar]

Guys, excellent review. Enjoyed it. These cars are not my cup of tea, however.

[@Eyedoc81]

Just bought an XC40 Inscription a few days ago and absolutely love it!

[@robbie50302]

I've got the D4 R Design XC40 FE and concur, it really is the best out of many many new cars I've owned over the years.

[@MrMarcob73]

me to i have t4 inscription...is top

[@eireboy100]

Top work

[@Reevueofficial]

E-pace for the win,got its looks from the F-type!!

[@wildanimalsnature]

volvo is a fairytale dream of every man who values quality and safety

[@raedkhmous1292]

I agree your verdict

[@boomhall]

You mentioned the XC40 hybrid, any word on when this might be available?

[@MrRoyck10]

Volvo XC series are quintessential middle class must have SUV.

[@wrestlemanfan]

I enjoy their chemistry.

[@robertl2856]

Great review....Batch took it all....in his strides !

[@sammyb304]

At least BMW continue to offer manual controls for things like climate control. Anyone who has driven a car that has almost every control hidden in a touch screen menu will understand how distracting this can be. I really don't understand how manufacturers get away with it - we aren't allowed to use a phone while driving (for obvious reasons) yet basic controls are on a touch screen that causes the driver to look away. Try dialling temperature up or down with your hand moving around as you drive across a bumpy road. So BMW interior may be considered dreary, I think it holds true to its values of putting the driver first because it allows them to concentrate on driving, while intuitively placing controls within easy reach.

[@garyphillips4177]

Why choose the X2 and not the X1 which would more the size and design of the other two?

[@alexqureitem4215]

Does the the glass roof slide back for air?

[@davidmanzano8055]

Shouldve gotten the tan interior to review and xdrive (AWD)

[@sergueikonovalov7784]

what about back seats ....... are they comfortable for a long-distance in Volvo?

[@MrSyrian123]

I wonder how much lucky this man is to see that classy jacket in the real world ,, why not me? "Sorry for any error in my english"

[@raffica26]

The bin is actually really a smart idea in the XC40. The douple tap automatic shifter is a pain...The "cristal" shifter version is laughable, rather slushy than elegant. That applies to the ones available in larger BMWs as well. The XC40 indeed offers quite large space but that also applies to the X1. Forget the X2. The BMW X1 is the one that should be compared with the others. Cheers.

[@jools99caithness17]

Enjoyed this and the Volvo will be on my wish list. But- just wondering how different things might have been had General Motors not killed off Saab?

[@raffica26]

We have been testing various cars in this category. I agree that the Beemer may not seem to have the poshest interior. However most cars nowadays are built around a touchscreen that demands multiple touches and looking at the screen. That is not only cumbersome but also very dangerous that probably should be banned. So having initially been interested in the Volvo that one experience is already a definite showstopper! VW group included. Safety first by a mile! Although it may be very subjective I just do not understand people who go for X2s instead of X1s, X4s instead of X3s as in a nice package the former variants kind of offer the same feeling yet significantly more space. It may actually be quite a success from the manufacturer's point of view, the customers are the ones I just cannot understand.

[@akasoof]

When will the Volvo XC40 hybrid be available in the UK?

[@josingh20]

I asked Volvo UK and they said end of 2019

[@mattjames4978]

I’ll save you watching: Jag looks best, Beemer drives best, Volvo all round best.

[@BatoosTech]

Jag = time in service. Beemer = good. Volvo = Chinese brand.

[@Gandalf606]

Jag = it's a 'JAG'; Beemer = Not An SUV; Volvo = as Matt Watson says "Just Go Out And Buy It"

[@j800q]

@@BatoosTech why does it matter if it is a chinese brand?

[@user-mi3hk8dx7p]

@@j800q wise

[@mrglaister3937]

E pace best 👌

[@rob5896]

BMW with a light interior such as Dakota Oyster would be a good option If you want a sporty practical car with good mpg, select a space saver wheel option to avoid run flat tyres should improve any road noise and comfort issue

[@MrTrull1]

I like each of these presenters on their own anyway, but there is an extra energy to the review when they work together. Good move. Do more. 😀

[@CaviDS]

Sorry, but the X1 would have been the correct to compare, the size and interior space are more apples to apples with the other two

[@thunder2086]

Volvo for life 😍

[@fynn6282]

The jag in complete black

[@iMitsubishiZA]

Nice comparison, the XC40 definitely stands out and offers a great combination of versatility and looks. Do i sell my Lexus GS350 for an R Design XC40.....

[@BMH1965]

The Volvo UX designers and processes are dinosaurs.

[@mariatrinidad2972]

Ayos magandang modillo po

[@Lastmanontrack]

I am a BMW guy but i have to say the XC40 nailed it easy, best car in this segment for sure!

[@nigelfulker2133]

The format of contradicting couples always works. It’s great to have two opinions of the same facts.

[@ingridkhan5847]

E-Pace every time.

[@paulreid179]

You two work well with each other, you give a good husband and wife impression. A true recommendation indeed

[@sarojkumarkar902]

Good one

[@MrTrull1]

And by the way Batch, at least Ginny matched the Jag's seats. 😉

[@Whowannabeu]

I'd love to see the back of the epace on the xc40.

[@loosabway3400]

It's amazing how road noise doesn't matter to motoring journalists - just shocking

[@aaronmills3105]

Love volvo ❤️

[@hugorri1754]

Would've loved a talk about off-road capabilities. It is an SUV after all.

[@mattjames4978]

That’s like trying to run in a pair of puma classics. It’s all about the appearance of being sporty, without the actual necessity.

[@mariatrinidad2972]

👍🥰 Bagay na po talaga

[@shehryar1091]

If Jaguar is coming out with SAVs, Land Rover should making Sedans

[@petercavellini3232]

The Jag, don’t like the red leather interior, I be talking about because it catches your eye every time you get in, it’s just as bad as the BMW, BUT, like most makers, you can option the interior to your taste, it’s not difficult, you’ll be able to see you choice on a screen before you commit.

[@kingsizesoufleris2]

i recently bought a bmw x2..... it's absolutely brilliant... but it's for a specific niche of the market.. exactly as is the mercedes gla...its for us who don't really want to buy an SUV, we just want a higher ride and somewhat bigger volume than a hatchback, without making compromises in the area of sporty driving.... x2 doesn't belong in this test... its just the poor man's macan

[@youngalwyn1124]

I'm with you! New BMW X2 owner here. :-)

[@BionicRusty]

And I agree as well. The BMW here should have been the X1, which I own. I really like the Volvo’s but they’re just too minimalist for me.

[@chrisalbertdeleon5354]

I agree - BMW X2 owner here. This review is a bit biased towards Volvo. Tested all three cars and the BMW won coz of the sporty drive. Felt more in contact with the road and the lower stance..nice!

[@rimmerblues1586]

A shame we didn't get the 28i or 25d variants in the UK. Though the 4-pot diesel sounds loud n rough and feels slow at town speeds compared to the 2L petrol.

[@antonp.1523]

Love my bmw x2 x20d and your line „ it‘s the poor man‘s macan“… considering that the car war 65k

[@esteban75lover23]

Jaguar is rolling out apple CarPlay and android auto as we speak:

[@josingh20]

Great. Yawn. Still want the XC40 and pay £300 for apple carplay and Android Auto