Carrier Pilot's Nightmare Story About a Prowler Landing on Top of His Viking

Retired S-3 Viking pilot Greg "Walleye" Wallace joins Mooch and Hozer to talk about the fatal night aboard the USS Enterprise (CVN-65) when his jet was hit from behind on the flight deck by an EA-6B Prowler attempting to land.
Subscribe to THE MOOCH REPORT (this channel's free weekly behind-the-scenes update) here: eepurl.com/hDfbsj
Support this channel by using the SUPER THANKS (heart icon above) or by becoming a Patron at / wardcarroll
Buy one or all three of the books in the PUNK'S TRILOGY, Ward's popular first three novels about life a Tomcat squadron, at www.usni.org/punks-trilogy-re....
Also available in KINDLE format here: www.amazon.com/dp/B09R1MX8SY
And as an audiobook here:
PUNK'S WAR: www.audible.com/pd/Punks-War-...
PUNK'S WING: www.amazon.com/Punks-Wing-Pun...
PUNK'S FIGHT: www.amazon.com/Punks-Fight-Pu...
Get official channel gear at my-store-b7f9c9.creator-sprin...
Find Hozer's books at www.amazon.com/stores/Kevin-M...

[@DDucksOne]

The VFA-37 F/A-18 shielded the 7 of us from the vertical stabilizer of the S3 being knocked off. Our 7 man team of trouble shooters from VFA-105 wouldn’t be here if not shielded by the drop tank of that F18. It was wedged under the net next to us, only a few feet away. I remember looking up and seeing the ejection seats shooting out of the humongous ball of flames. Then flaming debris started falling to the flight deck. We had to run in circles to avoid getting hit by falling debris. Then we all ran towards to fire hoses to help put out the fires. I am sure this memory is etched in everyone’s brain who were involved. I still remember like it was yesterday. Thank you for sharing sir 🙏🏾

[@jeremyespil6297]

I was a Plane Captain with VMFA-312, and had just came up on deck in the six-pack when that happened. By far one of the scariest experiences of my life.

[@pathann99]

I ran like hell for the cat walk and next thing I know a yellow shirt is pulling me and I had a hose in my hand. Definitely unforgettable.

[@kevinmiller5780]

@@pathann99 thanks for extinguishing that fire, shipmate.

[@pathann99]

@kevinmiller5780 The worst was we did not know they had ejected because it happened so fast. I just remember the fire pouring out of the front left canopy and thinking the crew was still in the aircraft.

[@DDucksOne]

@@pathann99 like Walleye mentioned time slowed down for me. I witnessed the ejection seats shooting out of the ball of flames.

[@stevevanvalkenburg5449]

My son was a mechanic with VMFA on that cruise, SGT JR VanValkenburg.

[@rodmacdonald279]

Walleye's recollections of that mishap were riveting. His thoughts about the situation, survival and activity on the deck and in the water were stunning. I was struck by his memories of his burns and thoughts of his mortality and family. Incredible episode that I'll remember for awhile. Wow

[@karlbrundage7472]

His recollection of the voice that came to him in his darkest hour is haunting.... And reminiscent. I too was in a bad circumstance and had a calming voice telling me how easy it would be to let my life end. Thankfully, he listened to the same Angel I did and is here today.

[@ghprose]

My exact thoughts. May those lost rest in n peace.

[@kurtpena5462]

I agree. What a compelling account. I'm pro-gloves. If Don Garlitz and Mario Andretti can wear them, then so should a pilot. I've been a sailor and worked in various industries. If you don't protect yourself, you are doomed. I would have loved to have gotten more information on the incident report. I see an number of contributing factors and suspect a few others, such a sleep deprivation. Working at sea can make regular sleep difficult. A 4" mattress on a steel cot is a tough way to go. This holds true for CQ's, as you are training sailors that might not be acclimated and are under stress to perform at a high level.

[@mickwilson99]

That was probably the most human and vulnerable recount of an aviator's surviving a "mishap". Thank you to all

[@user-iq1cs7rw3o]

Praise God for His care, help, and provision to the pilot in the water. And for the antenna catching the other. We'll have to wait to see why the others' time was up so soon, and what depths of God's love and care were for them.

[@vidar7106]

I had recently left VS-22 for duty as a FASO Acoustic and Oceanography instructor. The Viking model behind his right shoulder was of Vidar 706 in the accident and it was built by me as a gift. I’m glad he still has it.

[@TzunSu]

Crazy! Crazy fitting name too :D

[@chipsawdust5816]

Very cool, very cool.

[@jmtraylor1]

Great video, Ward. As for gloves and sleeves, as a newby LT in Army flight school, the cadre had a retired Air Force colonel speak to the class in the first week. He was missing an ear and was horribly disfigured, obviously from a fire. He told his story of crashing his T-80 and as the plane came to rest his ungloved hands hanging over the railing of the cockpit essentially melted away and how he spent weeks in the burn ward in San Antonio with his burnt hand sewn into his abdomen in an attempt to save it. I'm not sure how many classes he spoke to, but it made an impression. You rarely see Army aviators flying without their Nomex gloves tucked tightly under their flight suit sleeves. We even took it so far as to wear our dog tags under the collar of our flight suits so the chain wouldn't burn our necks. Granted, Army helicopters refuel and rearm "hot" (while running) so the threat is higher, but I never forgot those lessons and the ones who taught them.

[@DonWan47]

Wow, the S3 pilot is a very lucky man. May those sailors rest in peace.

[@garrysekelli6776]

I landed on top of a few of those once or twice.

[@roderickcampbell2105]

Indeed. A lucky and very tough man. Folds of Honour baby!

[@edmundmcalister119]

I was just off active duty in the Army, and a junior lawyer in a big firm. One of my colleagues was a Navy brat, married to a Naval Aviator. We had a friendly Army-Navy rivalry. I was aware of the mishap, but she came to my office, shut the door, and told me: LTJG Duffy was her brother. That young officer was third generation USNA on both sides of his family tree. Such a loss for the family, for the Navy, and for our country.

[@edwardlittle5686]

Brendan Duffy was my college roommate. His ship was coming to relieve ours. I still feel his loss today.

[@edwardlittle5686]

This video impacts me on so many levels. I was on the USS Eisenhower in the Persian Gulf at the time of this mishap. The Enterprise was coming to relieve us. I was also an LSO. The right-seater (NFO) in 503 was my college roommate. His name was Brendan Duffy. As his friend I was tremendously saddened that he died so young, and it hit me really hard at the time. It will always be an emotional hotspot for me. As a Naval Aviator and LSO I was disgusted by how he was let down by every level of protection and professionalism designed to keep him (and his crew) safe. At the time, Navy Doctrine claimed there was a benefit to flying a night pass even knowing it would end in a wave-off. This mishap proved that to be wrong. The S-3 should never have been allowed to land knowing it would lock the deck. Afterwards, instead of immediately waving off the Prowler, CATTC told 503 to go "hook up". What?! The deck is locked and foul. What's the difference between hook up and hook down when you cannot land at all?! I was a Wing-qualled LSO and I will say without a doubt the primary blame for this mishap was the LSOs. The deck was forever foul and really they should have waved off the Prowler at the ball call. But they were being pressured to allow crews to get as much "practice" as possible, because it was CQ. Had the S-3 been waved off much of this problem would have been resolved. The Handler was wrong for allowing the S-3 to land. The Air Boss was wrong for encouraging night touch and go's, and for allowing a foul deck landing. Plenty of enlisted could have spoken up knowing the deck was foul (this would be unfair to expect, because the enlisted have all been trained to defer to the officers). As painful as it is for me to admit, the LSO's are primarily to blame. They never waved the Prowler off, even though the deck was clearly shown to be foul the entire time. My friend (and 3 others) died that night because my colleagues failed them.

[@airmike1271]

AD2 here. I was an aircraft maintainer for VFA-37 on that difficult cruise on the Big-E. This was my second cruise, my first cruise being on the Theodore Roosevelt (the Big Stick) which I was on when we collided with the Leyte Gulf, which is another story for another time. You know, there has been a lack of complete information until this day since this mishap happened. I appreciate very much, you interviewing Walleye, who I remember his call sign on that aircraft. These were what was known to me and I speak on behalf of my fellow sailors who served with me on that deployment: 1. I thought it was the CO and XO of VS-22 (Checkmates) in the S-3 mishap aircraft. 2. LSO at 100% fault and never knew what happened to this person since then. It was nothing short of a miracle that anyone survived. Thank God. A buddy of mine who was an AD with HS-7 (Dusty Dawgs) manned the fire nozzle fighting the fire on the S-3, which the number 2 engine which remained running. Before they grabbed fire hoses, that S-3 rolled to a stop, or stopped against another aircraft (it is possible the parking brakes were set before ejection/don’t know). Somehow, they were able to shut down that engine. But right after ejection, it was witnessed that one, or both pilots were ON FIRE and it was assumed ejection was the only course of action because of the fire. During this mishap as it unfolded, our pilots of our F/A-18 squadron were following the hand signals of our Plane Captains getting started up. At this point, the APUs were started when a flaming wing came sliding under one of our VFA-37 hornets. Our junior Plane Captain had to dive out of the way. Another junior pilot in that very aircraft, immediately egressed as the plane was burning with the APU left running. This plane was later craned off when we stopped at Crete. The S-3 was stripped and dumped out at sea. It didn’t occur to me that the Air Boss contributed to this. This is new information and I thank you Carroll for your channel. Walleye, that aircraft that crashed in Fallon, I think you are referring to Lt Nolan of our squadron. I was very much a part of the team of people recovering aircraft parts that week. HS-7 had a helicopter go down a week or two later/before causing a Safety Stand Down. Lt Nolan was a very humble and nice man to us maintainers. His memorial service was sad, but his friends that he flew with really cheered everything up by reflecting on memories and in a aviator’s sacred way, get us laughing with funny memories. So deployment with the Big E that this mishap took place was really a challenging deployment. Not only did this deadly mishap take place within the first week of our 6 month deployment, but we had a significant fire onboard the ship on Thanksgiving morning that resulted serious smoke damage to our aft berthing sections. It was again, a miracle that no one died from smoke inhalation. A month later, we were engaged with Operation Desert Fox, sending ordnance and Tomahawk Cruise missiles into Iraq and watching this unfold live on CNN as the lights go out in the background as Christiana Amanpour (sp?) is reporting a explosion in the background. That was another surreal experience. Again later in our Persian Gulf deployment, the Big E suffers a fresh water incident in the engineering area and we can operate at a maximum speed of 7 knots with one operational screw. The ship vibrated pretty badly like this until we made an unscheduled port visit in the UAE (kitty box) as civil engineer took up some space in the Galley with blue prints, fixing the problem. Thank you, for the interview and additional insight into this mishap. What an honor to serve with all of you 🫡🇺🇸 Mike

[@DDucksOne]

I was on both of the cruises with you shipmate. I was attached to VFA-105. I was one of the Gunslinger troubleshooters that were on deck and helped put the fire out.

[@michaelmappin4425]

Do squadron guys call every underway period a cruise? The reason I ask is I was on TR during the Leyte Gulf collision. It happened during COMTUEX a couple months before the 96/97 deployment. We were hoping it would delay or cancel the deployment. Nope, they bought a new fantail from Home Depot and welded it on in a couple weeks. We left only a few days before Thanksgiving for what would turn out to be a life changing deployment.

[@airmike1271]

@@michaelmappin4425 they deleted the Phalanx CIWS on that rear corner of the fantail after the repairs. The original in that area was dragging behind the ship.

[@michaelmappin4425]

@airmike1271 Yep, they don't stock those at Home Depot. There was a crewman inside that gun mount playing video games. He went to the head minutes before the collision.

[@stevevanvalkenburg5449]

My son was an aircraft mechanic with VMFA 312 on both those cruises.

[@toms1348]

"I just climbed right in....It was a beautiful thing" pretty much says it all. As much as Walleye through he was not in control, the training drilled into all naval aviators had him in control as much as the situation would allow! What a riveting account of this hellacious mishap!

[@freds5619]

What a riveting account of a horrible mishap. Thanks for putting this video together.

[@davidsmith8997]

Wow, what a total clusterf*ck!! Definitely powerful lessons to be learned and glad changes happened.

[@geraldstephens7481]

My dad was WW2 PBY crew chief petty officer and in charge of a bunch of men in maintenance as well. He told me many stories of men dying over inattention to detail and distraction. He always told me and I will never forget "Pay attention to detail or it will bite you in de tail." He was a hard man to work around as a dad very critical and I could not even look in the wrong direction during a task. I am very grateful for these lessons from my dad.

[@birdman85]

I served with Walleye when we were JO’s. He was two years senior to me and we cruised together in 1989 (his second, my first). As a senior LT and LSO, he was the guy you went to with questions about everything S-3 NATOPS and JO life in general. Just a genuine dude who was fortunate to survive that incident. I hope to see him at the Viking reunion next year!

[@toastecmo]

Gumby Barrich started out a a A-6B pilot,he was with VA-75 and weflew missions with them as VAQ-130 part of CVW-3 in Desert Shield/Desert Storm in 1990-1991. Later he transitioned to EA-6Bs and I flew a flight with him before this boat det as a PTI, I did his level 4 stan check. I remember seeing him in VAQ-130 spaces we talked a bit and I told him to have a good det and see ya soon. Three days later he was dead. The Air Boss was a good friend who I worked for at VAQ-129 and the mini was a EA-6B guy. This whole thing made me sick and I questioned whether I should stay in or get out. I lost some faith in the Navy at this point, luckily I went back to sea duty in 2001 on CVN-72 and that helped me rediscover my love in the Navy. Miss you Gumby.

[@markadog]

Thanks for letting CDR Wallace speak uninterrupted. His testimony was powerful, and his event dramatic. Go Team Mooch. Long live Naval Aviation and those who dare such.

[@charlesward8196]

It’s never just one thing. Seemingly minor glitches stack up, inoperable lights, field of view obstructions, short comm cord, some minor distraction, responses slowed by fatigue, maybe, and suddenly the margin of safety vanishes in the blink of an eye and it is a disaster. This is true in so many fields of human endeavor. Thanks for your service, gentleman.

[@vincenzochieppa689]

A really inpressive story and one of the best episode in the channel. May the four dead sailors rest in peace

[@jasonvandergriff7809]

I was there that night as an ordnanceman with VMFA-312, attached to CAG-3 that night. I worked CAG arm-dearm. The night of the accident, they were doing night CQ's, we were in the shop, just below the landing area, getting suited up to go topside and secure our airplanes for the night. The Enterprise had just left Norfolk earlier that day, recieved the airings, and about to transit the Atlantic for out Med cruise (which ended up being a Persian Gulf cruise with Operation Desert Fox, Southern Watch, and later Kosovo). Anyway, we were just about to head topside when we heard a loud bang, and the clatter of matter hitting the deck, and the TV automatically switched to the flight deck channel, and we saw the fire ball, and proceeding chaos. "Fire Fire Fire, Fore on the Flight Deck!" Followed by "General Quarters, General Quarters, All Hands to your General Quarters Stations!" Then "Man Overboard, Port Side, This is NOT a Drill!" We scurried through the ship, having to take the long route to come up behind the island because of the hatches locked down for GQ. By thr time I got topside, I just jumped on a hose team and watched for flair ups. Then casualty evacuations, then a for walk to pick up debris from the foam. It was a long and heartbreaking night. Great to see you doing well Walleye! ~Then LCpl Vandergriff, VMFA-312 Ordnance.

[@jasonvandergriff7809]

I remember the CAG lost an F18 out at Fallon, I think from VFA-105 or VFA-37, but I forgot we also lost a Tomcat from VF-32 during workup. They splashed off the port side when they flew over for the break and had a flight control surface failure. They both ejected safely. I witnessed that from the flight deck. That was a crazy workup and cruise. Unfortunately a CAT worker (green shirt) got sucked in to the intake of an S3 on the waist CAT, but luckily forhim, he only lost an arm, thanks to the quick reaction of the pilot who saw what was going on and quickly shut the engine down. Thanks for the great video and interview, Mooch!

[@pathann99]

IYAOYAS!

[@kevinmiller5780]

Thanks for extinguishing the fire, shipmate.

[@airmike1271]

Same for me. We were Port Side about where HS-7 lands and when we tuned into the Plat Cam, we thought it was an incident with the helicopter at first. I passed blood in our passageways from superficial wounds of others as we made our way to the roof.

[@airmike1271]

@@jasonvandergriff7809that would be VFA-37, Lt Nolan who perished that day. I was part of the recovery crew that whole week. He was a really humble and nice aviator to us maintainers. Back as a new Plane Captain at NAS Cecil Field, I helped prepare his plane, strap him up and get him going.

[@ellisvener5337]

I’m not an aviator but my FiL was. He was born in Berlin in June 1945 and as a child his family lived near the end of the main runway at Templehof and he and his brothers were on the receiving end of the “Candybombers” during the Berlin airlift. my FiL later flew in the Luftwaffe in the ‘60s-early ‘80s but this episode was a great way to spend an hour on July 4. It reminded me of what it takes to keep the USA the USA. My respect to everyone.

[@DonWan47]

Mooch this rivals your interview with your Father as your best video. Fantastic. Thank you to everyone.

[@rnich56]

I knew LCDR Kurt "Gumby" Barich. We served on NIMITZ together, he was Flag staff and I was COD OIC. He flew A-6's before and this was his first tour in Prowlers. I still remember the phone call I received from his former room mate on NIMITZ about his death. Sad day for all.

[@kevinmiller5780]

Gumby was indeed a great guy. In my novel Fight Fight a Growler pilot has the callsign Gumby, my tribute to LCDR Kurt Barich.

[@kevinfontes2466]

Hey knuckles, Groucho here. The memories are flooding back. Sure miss Gumby and think of him often. I also remember a field arrested landing at pearl harbor in a Cod with pilot knuckles. V/R groucho

[@landb1873]

Damn, great episode! Kurt was my cousin. I was a young Army Lt when he died. Later in my career, I was lucky enough to be an LNO to CAW8 on the Bush. I spent a lot of time on the LSO platform, and the LSOs there were awesome about letting me be the foul deck caller as a tribute to Kurt. I am glad that Walleye and Swinger survived the night and no one else died. The military business is inherently dangerous, and we are lucky to men and women who do it out there every day, acknowledging the risks as they defend our Country.

[@rogersjolly1]

Respect to all three of you. We know you loved the job, but we know you also knew the danger and still did it.

[@craigh1790]

..."Joining us for this conversation about what happened there is the guy who was the pilot in that S-3..." Just, wow.

[@user-om6tf4dp4g]

I have watched the Ward Carroll for years. This was by far the most spellbinding episode I have watched.

[@wagstaffe7]

Wow, what a tragic event. I served on the Big E with VA-196, thankfully we all made it home safely. Thanks Mooch.

[@bryanwing2378]

at the end of this podcast, I had a tear in my eye... thinking NAVY, I've got to put a plug in for my father who passed away recently... he was a lowly 17 year old seaman on the USS Grafton during the battle of Okinawa... he was NAVY through and through... love you Dad.

[@davefellhoelter1343]

RIP GREATEST! I miss them too! I Love You! Greatest and "I MISS" Y'all, YA"ALLL!!

[@DavidJones-ib3zy]

RIP , Your Dad . . We only have 1 'True' Earthen Dad & they work as hard as they can , most do a wonderful job as yours did . Take Care DJ

[@marks2920]

Compelling story from Walleye. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ episode.

[@Wtpat2]

We met a Viking pilot at the Naval Air Museum in Pensacola. Very humble fellow. Having seen an S3 at the museum I was curious about how the crew would even get into the bird, and was impressed at the courage it must have required to serve as part of a Viking squadron. Today’s video took my admiration to a new level. So grateful for good ejection seats and for sharp minded pilots. What a humble and honest account from a man who never wanted to eject, but made the right decision in a fraction of a second in terrible circumstances late at night. Thank God!

[@williamlloyd3769]

In 1978-79, my destroyer, USS Hollister (DD-788) was plane guard when there was a ramp strike while supporting carrier qualifications off of San Diego. We stood by while the helicopter attempted to recover the NFO who was entangled in his parachute. Rescue swimmer got exhausted so we launched the motor whale boat and we went in and got the helicopter swimmer, NFO and returned to ship. Incident gave me nightmares due to heavy swells, entangling boat propeller, darkness, soaked in cold water and extreme movement as we recovered the boat with it slamming against the ships side. Unfortunately the NFO died but no one else did. RIP

[@nschlaak]

Wowsers, what a story and I'm glad that you're here to tell it, and I'm so sorry for the loss of your shipmates.

[@pdoherty]

Excellent episode sir. "Walleye's" explanation of events as they happened to him made you feel you were there with him. Thank you all for your service. USN PR2 1971-75

[@dennishayes65]

I was an A-6 plane captain in VA-42 (RAG)NAS Oceana . My service time was 10/18/71 to 8/15/75. ADJ-3 Dennis Hayes.

[@cdavidpaternostro2352]

Former S-3 NFO here. We had one ejection in October '83 during Grenada, all 4 got out. Don't recall a burn issue from the seats on our guys like this one. Ironically my crew almost took our lost S-3A but got another airplane at last minute, so we assisted in the SAR on them instead of the other way around. Rarely wore the gloves and I know should have. We only got dry suits when we went above the Artic Circle in early '84. You get used to it and if you don't wear it you are forfeiting your option to eject in the cold. I heard their SOP has the rear seats empty during CQs. Makes sense. Recall being in the TACCO seat while the 3 pilots all swapped seats to CQ at night while I sat there in the dark. Another NFO buddy was jealous I got so many traps which never occurred to me as a great deal. Should point him to this tape..... exciting times from the past.

[@ChrisBlanchard-vf6fe]

@cdavidpaternostro2352 Sounds like you were on the U.S.S. Ranger "Death Cruise" So was I. Bought the T shirt. Happy July 4 to you.

[@cdavidpaternostro2352]

@@ChrisBlanchard-vf6fe actually VS-28 on Indy. Two med cruises and IO 83-86. 👍

[@kurtpena5462]

I think the burns were from the S-3's wing tanks. It's not clear what the report on this incident found. I would have expected them to address findings. Wouldn't there be a watchstander on the island? That would make more sense than a third LSO looking forward. It sounds like the primary cause was the LSO's failure to recognize the fouled deck. They alluded to 5MC issues. But the LSO watchstanders would have been on sound powered phones and radio (I don't know, after my time). So would they have been in direct communication with the watchstander that called "FOULED DECK!"? Has nothing to do with 5MC. There are more circuits. 5MC is a PA system.

[@DragonPilot]

Retired US Army aviator here. I started flying helos in 1967. Our SOPs required sleeves down, neck collars buttoned up and gloves on…always! We started getting Nomex in ‘68. We rarely flew over open water, but in those cases appropriate overwater SOPs would dictate ALSE requirements.

[@ChrisBlanchard-vf6fe]

@@cdavidpaternostro2352 My A school buddy Dave did two floats on the Indy with Vaq 131 Lancers. He was probably on her for your first cruise. God bless America!

[@marlanappel6120]

Love to hear stories like this on your video. As an aircrewman on a P-3 in he 60's and 70's I have never forgotten the amount of training it takes to do that safely. Thanks again.

[@leananglesensor]

One of the most important lessons i learned in the navy is accidents dont just happen ,there is a cause that applies to every one that occurs

[@kurtpena5462]

Yes. It's called sleep deprivation. Ask me how I know! XD

[@rafaelcastillo2636]

All Gave Some-Some Gave All. RIP Aviators. Thank You for your service.

[@1boortzfan]

This was very emotional to watch. I'm sure all of us who have cheated death can relate. Praise God Walleye was spared and went on to be able to share his experiences that will hopefully save lives in the future. It's strange how little details compile and don't add up but multiply to create a perfect storm.

[@skyepilotte11]

A riviting recollection of a tragic night of carrier ops...god bless all those that died that night and those that miraculously survived. Thx Mooch, Hoser and Walleye

[@WarHoover]

Amazing. I was a V2-32 Mauler pilot a few years after Walleye and have 200 traps on the Enterprise. I've had seen the footage and have been hearing about this mishap for years and always marveled that anyone got out. Hearing the direct eyewitness account was truly fascinating. I had always assumed the Prowler ran straight into the S-3 empennage from behind - which would have carried debris and burning jet fuel to the S-3 cockpit before any reaction was possible (literally less than the blink of an eye at landing speeds) - that assumption has left me scratching my head all these years on how anyone could punch out. From seeing the post-mishap aircraft photos, it looks like the left side of the S-3 was significantly more damaged. Perhaps it was more of a glancing blow on the left side of the S-3 fuselage (still causing lots of damage to the S-3, but not smashing it to bits), with the wing and horizontal stab destroying the Prowler and detaching from the S-3 in the process, while the glancing impact pushed the S-3 fuselage away with much of the high-speed debris passing down the left side of the S-3 instead of pancaking it. Pure speculation, but that could explain how the crew remained undamaged enough to eject in the few seconds they had to react. Would be really interested in seeing the accident report and more post-mishap photos. As much training as we had, and as much as we like to control our own fate, there are lots of situations where our lives are in the hands of others that we trust to do their jobs well every day - which they do 99.9% of the time. Walleye, Swinger, and the Prowler crew did everything they were told to do and really had little control of this situation - it's hard to describe how difficult it can be to see an unlit aircraft in the landing area at night while on final approach. Their lives were in the hands of others that night who failed them. Luckily, it's a rare occurrence and while Naval Aviation can't eliminate all risks and accidents, we're generally really good at learning from our mistakes. FLY NAVY!

[@livingadreamlife1428]

Emotionally-gripping episode and very professional interview allowing the pilot to get through his story in his own words without badgering him with questions. Carrier aviation is dangerous business. Takeaway for each sailor is to do your job or people can die. Thanks to all naval aviators for your service. Fly Navy.

[@LostandFoundonNorden]

I was on watch on the bridge of the USS Nicholas FFG-47 when this incident happened. We were only a few miles away (vacapes op-area)and watched as the events unfolded.

[@mrgnr-smith387]

What a powerful and personal episode “Walleye’s” description of his private conversation in the life raft probably hits home with a lot veterans that follow your channel, it certainly did with me BZ to you all

[@bobisaksen6669]

Thanks for letting walleye tell his story uninterrupted. Great story mooch

[@williammrdeza9445]

What a tragic story and superb great recounting of Walleye's story of survival after such a horrific mishap. Thank you Ward, Hozer, and Walleye for taking the time to share this emotional story.

[@StevenPalmer-cs5ix]

On May 9th when I wasn't at sea, I'd toast the 6 sailors lost in an engine room fire on USS White Plains (AFS-4). It was May 9, 1989. Our battle group departed Hong Kong and USS White Plains was transferring stores while we gave her DFM. She was departing the battle group after the UNREP concluded and returning to her home port in Guam.

[@TulsAmerican]

I was on the White Plains from 80-83, in B Division. I was out of the Navy and in the AF when this happened but it still saddened me. The White Plains was my home, RIP shipmates.

[@robjansen4551]

I was on the "Prize" for 4 years and It's interesting to learn certain characteristics you never considered such as the position of the LSO Platform. Having two F-14A's positioned on Elevator 4 was common. Great video gentlemen, I very much enjoyed the story. Tragic for the loss of life on the Prowler, but at the same time, a blessing for the S-3 Crew.

[@wayneroyal3137]

Chills watching this. God bless the men. What an amazing interview. My good friend Ltcmdr Mark Robertson was an S3 guy onboard the Kennedy. Thank you to all..

[@olentangy74]

Thank you Mooch, for this powerful and moving video. I WESTPACed on the Big (76-77), and watched many recoveries from Vultures Row. Even though this happened 25 years ago, watching the video of the S-3 sitting at the end of the angle deck, and knowing what was about to happen caused me to squirm in my seat. God was definitely with Walleye that tragic night.

[@nestorbarreto4169]

As a retired USA officer, I feel so proud of the men and women in our USN. USA is in good hands.

[@ajj4207]

This brought back so many emotions, thank you ward everything you do with your channel. And thank you for talking about this

[@jeffreyrichard9675]

Oh man. I was aboard the Big E that night. Being a DCman I was privvy to when drills were scheduled most times. When the GQ klaxon went off I knew something was wrong but was saddened at the end to see just how bad.

[@jugshangar573]

Really great recap of a horrible night. As a brand new LSO at the time who also knew all four crewmembers on 503, this really hit home. Great to hear Walleye's account of it. And kudos to all 3 of you for not necessarily casting stones but emphasizing the critical lessons-learned.

[@ronaldbrawders4992]

Great episode - thanks. I've experienced what Walleye talked about how our brains can instantly go into ultra slow motion at crucial times. I was copilot in a KC-135 when we had a very, very, near miss with a DC-9, like a few feet. I was the only guy in either airplane who saw it. We were nose to nose and he was very close when I spotted him. The first thing that flashed in my mind when I saw the DC-9 was a very vivid image of me curled up in the fetal position in the middle of a huge ball of fire. I then realized that he was slightly below us, so I reached for the yoke to pull the nose up, but It occurred to me that if I did that our tail would drop before the airplane started to climb and that might be enough to clip the top of his empennage. All that in a second or two. That was about 60 years ago and I can still replay that like a video tape. Amazing what our brains can do in a second or so.

[@mikebridges20]

Wow, Mooch, just wow. So glad to hear stories from aviators like Walleye; so thankful for his recovery from that tragic event. Thoughts/prayers go up for the families of the crew of the Prowler.

[@bethfrench9064]

Mooch, thank you for the thoughtful way you presented this story. I was still at the Center for Naval Analyses when that happened. Sending prayers for all who were touched by the incident.

[@ghprose]

The thoughts and recollection of from eject until air rescue actually lifted this aviator out of the water is increadable. Training i believe has to do with alot of their survival but i actually herd that voice he spoke of. Of course my situation was much different but that's a incredible story. Rest in peace for those lost. God bless you all.

[@Utahdropout]

Ward.... Wow.... I always get a rush of amazement that you and your colleagues are able to recount those intense experiences you've had that bring into focus just how important it is to have your timing correct and to keep the situational awareness that is necessary to keep those operations from resulting in this kind of tragedy. It brings home the fact that, as you said, there are men and women out there doing it at this time and succeeding. We must continue to give them the recognition they deserve for doing it right. Thank you again for making that possible with programs like this that shows just how difficult it is to keep doing what they are doing. It is a tribute to those who have, as you have said, written those procedures in blood. Thanks again.

[@Kyzyl_Tuva]

Thank you for this video Ward. Bless you all.

[@ubercaulking3656]

This pilot is a great story teller and a true hero. Thank you for your service. Mooch - keep'em coming. Really good stuff.

[@BSaunders3754]

Sobering story. Thank you all for your bravery and skill!

[@barryjenkins8654]

Very moving video. Thank you for honoring the survivors and the departed 😢. May we continue to learn and improve...

[@emmettjones5165]

Outstanding interview. Thank you for bringing Walleye on the channel and making us smart on the mishap aboard Enterprise that Ward has touched upon briefly in other episodes. His story, how it resonates up to today, Hoser's insights... Wow. Thanks, Ward! 💯

[@fredflintstome6532]

Awesome video. Thanks Walleye for sharing glad you made it.

[@gregorylewis8471]

Absolutely riveting story. Thank you for your service and all the best! Mooch, beautiful tribute at the end of the video, thank you! Go Navy!

[@DarenLewis]

Amazing episode sir. Sharing with my crews. Different operations and risk profile in our business… but the lessons are the same. Respect for the candid observations from all three of you. BZ!

[@carabela125]

That was a great survival story. I was reading the mishap report and it said the LSO was having trouble hearing the Air Boss. The Air Boss had previously been instructed to let the LSO do wave offs. The Prowler hit the wing tip of the Viking, spinning it around which is why Wallace ended up on the starboard side and the Lieutenant ended up on the island. As an aside, LtJg Loughran went to the same college as my mom 💜

[@normbond8888]

What a wonderful recount ability of such a horrible incident that brought tears to my eyes hearing how his faith & concerns for his fellow aviators dragged him to safety along with the rescue personnel. Sorry for the loss of life of the other aircraft. Thanks Ward for this.

[@blakesail]

Walleye's incredible story had me shaking throughput... and I'm still finding it hard to catch my breath. When father was on active duty in the late '50s, he flew an AD-6 Skyraider off the USS Hornet (VA 145). I heard a number of his incredible experiences in recent years, but they were unique to the time and aircraft and missions he was charged with. Thanks to all three of you for sharing the tale, and for showing us just how critical it is to learn the lessons as we all move forward.

[@jackjones391]

Ward, Thank you for hosting the review on this mishap. Gentlemen thank you all for your service, sacrifice, and knowledge shared here. God bless all the men and women who serve and sacrifice so this nation can exist in the state of freedom that we so much enjoyed. Her freedom was paid for by the blood of our brothers and sisters before us. A heart felt thank you and please continue to educate us and the new folks.

[@DennisC43]

Good job to all aviators on the video and especially to you Mooch for bring this to us.

[@philnovak6787]

Love your channel CDR, and watch just about every episode - this one hit home. Brendan Duffy was my cousin and one of the best people I ever knew. When he was in flight school, my home in New Orleans was his home away from home. It was really inspiring for a young boy to have a house full of student Naval Aviators on the weekends. Those guys were were my idols, and a big reason I served in the military. Some of my fondest memories was Brendan waking me up on those Saturday mornings for yet another adventure. He truly was the big brother I never had. I miss him everyday.

[@paladin0654]

What a tale. Thanks Walleye for bearing your soul....great video.

[@thomasquinn284]

Thank you for the honesty and courage to share This tragic moment.

[@captainsalty9022]

My father, a pre WW2 Marine Aviator, always wore his gloves and wore no finger rings. As you might imagine, it was because of the threat of fire from the radial engines and forward mounted fuel tanks. He maintained the habit into the jet age. He wore no rings because he had friends who lost fingers while bailing out, the rings simply catching on metal edges.

[@kevinmiller5780]

Wise man.

[@anim8torfiddler871]

Thank you for this detailed review. I learned more about flight ops in this video than from all the conversations I've had with navy fliers I've known over the decades.

[@daveboatman4024]

What a powerful video! Thanks Mooch!

[@robfredericks2984]

Ward, I am a retired (medical) Naval Aviator, survivor of an A-3D crash at Whidbey Island NAS, February 1970. I have watched all of your videos with the attention and critical analysis only a fellow Naval Aviator can have. This is your best and most meaningful to the Naval Aviation group, in my opinion. I read many of the comments from other readers. They all agree that you did an outstanding job presenting this. Thank you for all of your excellent videos.

[@chloehennessey6813]

The VA: we found your injuries are not service related.

[@DDucksOne]

Better yet, the VA saying your PTSD is non combat related. And needing to fight and get service connection. 🙁

[@CraigJensen-tq7sq]

This interview so vividly puts into view just how dangerous carrier flight ops is, under any condition or circumstance. I’m retired E-7, ANG, plain old ground troop CE bum, but I have associates who were blue water Navy, carrier duty, and I have nothing but the highest respect for our carrier crews. Great interview, Mooch.

[@carlfischer4163]

Wow. My first cruise FID 82 was a very bad on for VF 74 Bedevilers . Last cruise with F4’s . Broken bridle in the Red Sea, night recovery in the med round down strike. Both incidents we lost the front seat and didn’t recover them. I was with HS 3 but it really shook me up. It’s a dangerous place. Thanks Mooch great episode.

[@horus10]

Great episode. Very moving and motivating story. Thanks

[@budoka34]

More of this please Ward. What an amazing recounting. Thank you all for this sharing.

[@mstallion98]

What an amazing story in this tragic situation. Thanks for this.

[@coldisle]

Absolutely riveting. Nothing but admiration and thanks for all of you. Walleye’s sharp memory, naturally phenomenal storytelling gift, and complete authenticity as a man is just incredible.

[@niccracknell9780]

Another informative and interesting episode!! Thank you gentlemen, a difficult event explained with dignity!

[@joeblow6417]

One of your best video's Mooch. Thank you for posting. I was U.S. Army 1968 to 71. Two of my older brothers were on Aircraft Carriers in the late 50's through the 60's. God Bless all of our service members past, present, and future.

[@n539rv]

Wow…. What a humbling story!! Thank you all for sharing!

[@brockmiller574]

Its amazing that this aviation passion project you started a few years ago has turned into a real training asset for the benifit of others.

[@flyjarrett]

I can’t fathom going through something like this and with the traumatic events, am amazed that Walleye is able to recall in such detail. Condolences to the families of those who perished.

[@jimlthor]

He probably had to recall it 1,000 times to the Navy during their incident investigation, right after it happened

[@g.willikers7712]

Amazing story guys. Thank you for your service and sharing this story. Salute you all!

[@tommychew6544]

What an excellent episode, thanks for showing it to us!! Walleye's description of time slowing down has happened to me a hand full of times and it is real. Some more recent times experiencing it don't even seem possible but, my mind's eye saw what was happening. I think it's part of what is known as fight or flight or act or die in this case, they correlate in this situation.

[@NVET92]

Ltjg Brandon Duffy was the son of Jim Duffy (known to us "Middies" as the "Silver Fox"), who was my company officer at USNA 68-69. I met Jim later at the Philadelphia Naval Shipyard when we both were attached to carriers undergoing SLEP. At that time (1985?)he was Air Boss on CVA-62, I was Weapons Officer on CVA-59. Later, at the time of this mishap, I learned that his son was killed. Jim has since passed away.

[@JonathanReed1970]

Regardless of the horrific outcome Ward, I really do enjoy these videos where you have heroes discuss their story. Salute.

[@alsecen5674]

Incredible story. Thank you for sharing it.

[@jkbarr30]

Definitely one of your best episodes, thank you for sharing!

[@ronmoore5827]

Thanks for sharing this horrific event with us. Flying airplanes off carriers is not for the faint hearted. My utmost respect for all who have, and those who continue to do it for their country.

[@SpikeJackson]

Just love it when the notification pops up that Mooch has posted.

[@jimgutshall4855]

Wow, so tragic .! Great episode, but very sad for the other crew. Walleye, thanks for your service.

[@billgrabher444]

Another outstanding session. Very good Mr. Carroll.

[@markadog]

Thanks for letting CDR Wallace speak. His testimony was moving, and his experience dramatic. Your end photo of his jet is one of the most dramatic images I've seen. While I appreciate your current events coverage, Naval aviation stories like the Carrier Pilot's Nightmare Story are why I found and follow you. Mooch on!