Case Files: Wife accused by the state of killing her husband inside their matrimonial home

[@rommieowino1002]

Google the names and you will get the judgment. Most of these people lie on camera but what happened in court is very different

[@chefabby3800]

Ooh really

[@ednagakii4702]

Musa would always complain that he wasn't safe and he was worried janet would eventually kill him.Continue resting in peace.

[@davidshepherd846]

We need to hear the househelp and relative give their side of the story

[@jchege14]

Ive read the full judgement and 1. The motive is what is yet to be established. 2.Everything is too coincidental. What was wrong with the car to leave it at the garage? Who was the fundi she was waiting for? did he come? why enter the estate thru the back gate at night? why is everybody on the ground except her? they tell everybody to remove their clothes except her,then she convinces them otherwise. the funny entries at the gate. the gangsters disappear in juja, then she proceeds to thika. why go to the petrol station? why book herself to the nursing home for shock? she came and left with the assailants, and finally, the family of the deceased inakushuku. they arent crazy? CAMAAN!!!!?

[@eliudmwangi1462]

She did a shoddy job for sure.. couldn't get away with it

[@chambagi]

I think the woman was wrongly accused, inlaws kweny kuna pesa ni mahasidi especially if they are struggling

[@mamachochi]

Sad to learn my former colleague demise here 5 yrs latter.He was such a good man

[@erickwainaina5708]

God forgive if iam wrong but I really think she is innocent.I don't see the motive behind this

[@gabrielmutisya6933]

If you expect her to implicate herself then..........

[@MrGeorgeMonday]

This is so sad... I feel like the wrong people are in jail and poor kids are suffering the lose of their Dad and absent Mom... I am in tears.. It better be looked at again... It is common for thieves to take one of the family members when leaving so that they can use her to pass the gate... She deserved sympathy for the trauma she went through not a jail term!

[@thomasmbugua7148]

Really Joyce the system of justice in Kenya is very strange one. It is our wish the appeal judges will restore her freedom.

[@Bbm-ii8hs]

+JOYCE CHEBELYON her husband is killed, she manages to drive the thugs all the way to thika..whether forced or not is besides the point. Again immediately she drops off the thugs at Juja, she drives ahead to Thika (impulse would have her drive back to attend to her dying husband being the "loving wife" she says she is), she then calls a mama lucy (a family friend!!!) why not a neighbor to find out how the hubby is? or her immediate family or in-laws which is consistent with confusion n shock. Then reports the crime of her being kidnapped n husband killed. Then she checks herself into thika nursing home complaining of...of all things shock!!! does this even affect Africans?! still how could she manage to drive over 50km with this shock!!! takes a sabbatical right there (still doesn't know whether the husband is dead or alive... n she doesn't show concern) Finally arriving home the next day at 10am...to the unfortunate news (at-least to her) that the hubby didn't die..but survived the ordeal. This is a no brainer, the hubby being a perrenial drinker must have had a mpango wa kando or she suspected..arriving home way past midnight et al is enough motive for this lady to put the father of her children to sleep. GOOD WORK OMBIJA!!

[@jimmyausten2228]

"put to sleep?" That's a rather cold way to make a point, don't you think?

[@steveykimson7238]

Bbm 2014 ...it's so unfortunate that I couldn't make my judgement n ths particular case since no enough evidence to crucify the mother.

[@steveykimson7238]

Jimmy Austen ...mmmm yeah

[@behappyalways9835]

reminds me of my dad...still going through a case for somethng am more than sure he ddnt do...kenya is crap..take heart .i pray things go well for the kids...

[@miminawewe2809]

Marisan Mitchkaline pole snaa ndugu

[@mr.vivitty1154]

I do not know whether she conspired to kill her husband or not, but the evidence is just too weak to convict her and the guard; it's all circumstantial!

[@nataliaoqwiza1473]

Mr. Vivitty I pity the guard more

[@susanapollo284]

I totally agree. They quickly accused her to deflect from the reall killers. Some thug police used to attack and Rob people or am I wrong

[@muriiki]

I knew Gituma he was my boss ...He was a very cool guy...what happened to him was really sad...anyway your report has omitted one very crucial point....Gituma's house was just a few steps from the police commissioner's residence...which was guarded by GSU officers...Actually that estate was well guarded...The abduction of this lady was questionable and even when she was released her demeanor afterwards was also questionable...People say she was fixed but I think she had something to do with this attack.

[@tinaodero4949]

+Bob Kantel The commissioner was her husband's cousin so you know ... and there is a story to how the husband finally succumbed to his death

[@erickwainaina5708]

what do you think was the motive

[@petermwangi2862]

Bob Kantel ,,,,,she s innocent

[@erickwainaina5708]

how did he?

[@steveykimson7238]

Bob Kantel ...we'll it's very difficult to understand ths However I would agree with the son who spoken and argued that he doesn't think the mother would've wanted to kill dad n the his presence,then I would want to know before I rule my judgement the motives of killing since it was never mentioned. .

[@nyamburamacharia5810]

these children are orphaned in a way. my heart aches for these beautiful souls. God see them and mom through.

[@EdgarKimutai]

The lady is innocent no doubt.....but I am proud of the son, he is so strong.....I now believe many people in our correction facilities are damn innocent.

[@assaonyiego608]

GUILTY AS CHARGED.. Those saying she's innocent are just being emotional to a one sided story.. Read the ruling of this case first before you say anything.. There is someone who has posted the link here

[@milkahkariuki1238]

Where I need it

[@mrdennisonsarigo]

We always strive to stick to facts and nothing but the facts. At times i have reservations about judgments and the prosecution's case against the accused and the kind of defence mounted but i cant "carry" the same into the story. If you listen carefully to my narration, the verdict is clear not necessarily the one handed down by the trial judge. Keep watching. Thank you!

[@christinembugi4464]

Sad story here.... I watch lots of such cases on CI and Discovery ID, good coverage but where is forensic evidence to this case? Its wrong to have someone in jail who did not commit a crime :(.... Am aware Kenya lack modern equipments and proper infrastructure to solve many mysteries of murder and other crimes in our society. I fell for the children since am a victim when am mother was murdered and no arrests to date 6 years down the line!!

[@thomasmbugua7148]

Christine Mbugi me too im mourning this judgement because the trial was not taking seriously by both police and trial judge but the good news the lady has arldy appealed en we hope the appeal judges will overturn this decisions and grant the lady her freedom because those killed her husband are still at large while innocent person who loved the late husband and her children she is suffering and living in pain of her late husband and be separated with her loving daughter en son. the trial judges should carefully look her appeal in hope her freedom will be restored so as she cause reunited by her family.

[@EdgarKimutai]

have been watched "medical detectives" I believe you are among the best......I hear Kenya will soon have a forensic lab.....Big up bro your future is bright, the lab will up your game further.

[@IsabellaVSpik]

My God this is a lady i used to know they were my clients when i was selling properties in Nairobi.Woiye they loved each other so much.May God see her thru and the children too.

[@Bbm-ii8hs]

+Isabel Wangui anet had been robbed, her family harassed and her husband hacked [apparently almost dying] yet she had all the strength and courage to drive alone from Garden Estate after 2.00 am up to Thika instead of turning back at Juja to rescue her husband

[@IsabellaVSpik]

God is her deliverer that's all I can say so sad

[@meriamuthoni3663]

May Allah intervene for this family.

[@bethcomputer4705]

everything shes saying dose nt add up,mabati inaleak,gari iko na shida sijui light za get man hazi work,in one day izo vitu zote aii,the wife knows something others don't know guilty ones are always very very afraid

[@Queenlean247]

You nailed it. There was too much going on to believe. There is a lot that people don't know. People need to pursue the proceedings before judging the judge. The whole Janet's story is confusing.

[@elvistaller6469]

Very true I don't know why people are sympathetic for her

[@eunicewanjira128]

shame on those saying that the lady was a Kikuyu

[@amosnjoroge2957]

The truth will set you free,but the fact is innocent people have suffered a lot through shoddy job from investigators relating almost every crime with '' inside job".

[@sallynjenga35]

Can't agree more, so much immorality in the society. Only God knows how many people are behind bars as a result of miscarriage of justice.

[@binaonderi9499]

Isnt it weird that the judged pegged his judgement on the fact that "she led them to her home", a criminal cannot be that stupid.

[@lindaoduor1532]

This people claiming to read her body language, I wonder why the government hasn't contacted you yet for your "skillful" talents. The watchman entry story, watchmen often fill in those entries by using their personal individual watches or mobile phones. If I took 10 people randomly, I'm 100% sure that their watches/mobiles would have different times. Even television stations and radio shows aren't always consistent with their "top of the hour news". Someone questioned why she led them to the house and further drove them away...isn't it common sense that when a gun is pointed at you....unless you are in a movie, you do as instructed. They were four people...what was she to do? Scream and get shot? Even if she told the watchmen as you say...what would the watchmen do??? Or do watchmen carry guns too? And that term 'escorted the thugs to her home'??? You underestimate robbers. They 'wanted their money' they had to know where the man stayed. They knew his wife and the estate...othey literally timed her. All in all, this case has too many loopholes. All evidence is circumstantial, from law, all criminal cases have to be proven beyond reasonable doubt. Here, nothing of the sought. Two, the charge of murder....faulty. Even if it was she...the cause of death varied from the actual injuries he succumbed to during the robbery. Kenyan lawyers ought to pull up their socks. Most just carry the name but lack the passion for it. The love of money is priority for them. We have a terrible system if circumstantial evidence can give you 30years imprisonment. If it was some big wig somewhere who was the accused, I'm dead sure they would have been acquitted on grounds of lack of sufficient evidence...

[@Bbm-ii8hs]

+Linda Oduor her husband is killed, she manages to drive the thugs all the way to thika..whether forced or not is besides the point. Again immediately she drops off the thugs at Juja, she drives ahead to Thika (impulse would have her drive back to attend to her dying husband being the "loving wife" she says she is), she then calls a mama lucy (a family friend!!!) why not a neighbor to find out how the hubby is? or her immediate family or in-laws which is consistent with confusion n shock. Then reports the crime of her being kidnapped n husband killed. Then she checks herself into thika nursing home complaining of...of all things shock!!! does this even affect Africans?! still how could she manage to drive over 50km with this shock!!! takes a sabbatical right there (still doesn't know whether the husband is dead or alive... n she doesn't show concern) Finally arriving home the next day at 10am...to the unfortunate news (at-least to her) that the hubby didn't die..but survived the ordeal. This is a no brainer, the hubby being a perrenial drinker must have had a mpango wa kando or she suspected..arriving home way past midnight et al is enough motive for this lady to put the father of her children to sleep. GOOD WORK OMBIJA!!

[@susanapollo284]

Agree. How about the guards organized with thugs to attack the family and what if those thugs were police

[@wambuinyagai3755]

@@Bbm-ii8hs you need to stop having the mindset of a village lady!!!

[@armstrongmugambi2934]

@@wambuinyagai3755 she confessed to have planned on her husband murder.check her appeal

[@wambuinyagai3755]

@@armstrongmugambi2934 people are promised shorter life sentences if they agree to confess how do i know this is not the case

[@lucywachira5162]

may justices prevail janet,God is with you

[@kinyuastella5304]

Followed the case file and this lady is guilty as charged

[@eliudmwangi1462]

I agree with you 100percent

[@normandalef]

Foul Play ...That guy was Killled and It sounds like an inside Job ! there are reasons behind all this .

[@miriamnyamus5138]

my dear freds,this woman is not guilty,for those who r saying her face is prooving hr lies n again she don't cry,wud like to tell you that,when someone is telling the truth don't cry,I was in lang'ata n I was judged for nothing bt .this woman has reached to apoint of being strong coz she is innocent n judged for nothing she never know will happen at the end of the day n that's why she was in hr business the whole day,may God inspire our kenya judges n give them knowledge to judge,she has brought up hr children n husband well,,,,,when someone is innocent don't cry while talking

[@vimbainashedube4938]

Miriam nyamus she is innocent the case must be revisited. I don't know wat is wrong with the justice system in many Africa countries

[@josephwafula6850]

Miriam nyamus

[@TheMatakwei]

A judge and a panel of jury can't wake up and decide to slap 34 years for suspects for no tangible and good reason.

[@chepkoechc]

if what they say is true, then the jury must have been totally drunk, or they swapped cases?

[@afropages2322]

they can they are hyman theycan err

[@faymiipompeii1964]

this is Kenya nani...when you are accused...you'll take this back... it happens...to people all the time ...especially those accused of rape

[@dr.jfmfalme9323]

Find a good lawyer and appeal the case. To me there was no enough evidence to convict the two.

[@keyabrian2488]

The Applicant planned and carried the execution of her husband, the victim of the crime. The plan was elaborate and well thought. She had accomplices. After inflicting injuries to the deceased which later proved fatal, the Applicant put in place an intricate hoax to put off the investigators from her trail. Unfortunately for her, her ruse came unstuck. The reason she gave for committing this heinous crime beggars belief. She indicated in the re-sentence report that she intended to scare her husband from his infidelity. This court noted that at the time the Applicant and the deceased had been married for eighteen (18) years. Much as this court considers the Applicant’s positive change in behaviour, it will not overlook the heinous nature of the crime that the Applicant committed. All along kumbe she was guilty.

[@johnnyagandwiga2779]

May God bless Janet and his eyes are seeing and may he be the judge. Pole mum Qatar

[@babyboss2886]

Its sooo sad, innocent souls crying for help while the actual n real wrong doers are out there @large. My heart is bleeding for this

[@codelabs9989]

Painful

[@lucy-ll1qf]

I really feel sad for these mama and her children. My brother was robbed in his house in Jamhuri estate after which the robbers went with him and left him very far, gave him fare and told him not to report to the police or they would come back for him. They had left the other family members tied. Not everyone in jail is guilty. So many people are innocently there in jail . i wonder what these judges will tell God on the day of reckoning

[@nakndu1623]

Wow , i would die yo be in the shoes of this family ; but the story is not ading up straight ooo

[@jamesgakahu9645]

She killed the husband. She appealed and confessed to killing him

[@kenmwiti02]

Are for real?

[@erenestawanjiru1935]

Update

[@jeffkhisa9817]

Yes. Her appeal in 2015 seemingly made the appeal judges so angry that they substituted her 30 years with the death sentence. She then decided to tell the truth during her petition for resentencing in 2018 because she saw that no judge was buying her story.

[@eliudmwangi1462]

Thugs would never ask you to drive them!!!!one mistake they all did

[@wanguikwaruiwarui3463]

They do don't say thst

[@bensonmwakyando5776]

Polisi wa kenya,hawajui kufanya uchunguzi. Nadhani kenya inanuka sana Rushwa. Pia kenya imechafuka sana kwa ujambazi na uporaji.

[@KKE1978]

Kenyan detectives go for the easier suspect for an easier conviction. Incompetent at its best. I believe her. She does not look like the type. Why would she pick a day when her kids are in the house. She makes so much sense.

[@suleimanadan6708]

This woman must have conspired in that Killing of the man her story is not adding up

[@logic5204]

If only there was a way to sign a petition for immediate retrial. I would be at the forefront. Things don't add up. I don't think she killed her husband. From what I've heard here, this was a mistrial.

[@that_bloke_kiri]

did you get this?

[@johnndirangu9138]

Both successful men and poor men are at danger in this society. You either get robbed, killed, or maimed...or you get rejected by family and friends

[@paulnjeule2510]

Police unearthed cellphone communication between her and the assailants. There's no way you can get out of that .

[@marymuthumbi355]

But why report her phone stolen if she had something to do with it,,,, at the same time her story doesent really add up.

[@ilikepremios.amanofunofhyb4751]

There is a key here

[@suleimanadan6708]

I agree with you

[@jeremyclyde3006]

If she had a good lawyer just maybe things would have been smoother

[@kanyangendirangu8667]

Janet's story does not add up but God will judge those who did it even if it was a plan,for the man, RIP and may your soul find eternal peace

[@samuelkiragu7416]

She knew something

[@lordless_keila2633]

Why do you say that

[@kazibure2008]

I knew Gituma very well, he used to irrigate our throats sasawa. However I don't buy the wife's story at all at all. How did she end up with phone numbers of these criminals? Word on the street is she did it...guilty as charged. I feel sorry for the kids though!

[@leonardkikuvi1800]

true

[@mercynjoroge6259]

Mr Kazibure,please tell me Janet was set free from prison am reading this very late,i used to see this couples in church QUEEN OF APOSTALS ......i feel very confused because i saw a beautiful family in front of my eyes.....am shocked to see that what GOD had joined together everything has fallen apart,where are the sisters to Janet,brothers...hope their are really supporting the kids......i've gotten the shock of my life.why would Janet do that,Gituma looks like a man who loved his family......i hope she never did that.

[@maxyaleto254]

I feel like this mother is innocent

[@elvistaller6469]

She finally admitted to killing her husband back in 2019 but saying she only wanted to scare him,,,i was so sympathetic with her like most of you but a lot of things were just not adding up so i found out

[@xabbydeleopardleopard2809]

So she arranged the plan with the thugs??

[@priscillahkimani2098]

My God innocent people wanateseka wauwaji wako huru, hawa ma judge wanafanya nn.so sad

[@carencherop164]

Janets argument isnt fine,,that I wouldn't have given out my phone,at that time she should have been fearing for her life

[@bensonmwakyando5776]

Pia hata judges wa kenya warudi shule wana matatizo

[@cadhilaxmed6210]

I can't see innocence in her eyes

[@waridiiatum6491]

The lady is guilty as charged...First and foremost the coincidences are just too many...Then she lacks remorse whatsoever even when narrating her story....It totally lacks the emotional aspect of someone narrating the loss of a loved one..No tears, no pain in the face...She might as well be narrating about a lost handkerchief or pen or something not so valuable....She is cold blooded and very cunning....My last one to anyone,'The next time you want to sin, don't tag alone other peoples children like that 'Obongi'....sin alone don't mislead desperate people into your messes...My assumption is that he was promised a lot of money, and probably not told it was something as grave as murder, and being a security personnel, he was compromised...because we all know how compromised they can get due to poor pay and high cost of living in Nairobi...Lastly, for those who are doubting, read this.... kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/90652/

[@tinaodero4949]

+Waridi Iatum I have been with her ...so just know you dont know what you are talking about. She has been all that you may think ... is has not done. i hear you .. you are analising something thats been going on for years frm a mere story. She has been going through theray and counseling soo be on the know

[@machariakaguru3033]

I too on the bases of evidence before court, would convict her

[@Mkenya_Daima001]

True, there's enough evidence to place her at the center of the crime. What I've learned is most convicts play victim of verdicts issued by courts of law. While there might be cases where people are convicted wrongly, 95+% of cases are justified.

[@michaelmaina5885]

So the lady was frog Marched for 3 kms by 4 masked men,went through the guarded gate still with the four men(masked still) until she reached her house.note: she had called her son so that they could meet as usual,but the son who was called was inside the house with a relative when the mum arrived.She later drove the masked men out of the estate without anyone noticing she needed some help. Anyway she was sentenced to face the hangman's noose today by the court of appeal.

[@leonardkikuvi1800]

She doesn't mention how her and the assailants got to the car as it was in the garage. How did they access the garage as they are usually closed at night?Then which security light was faulty? Was it there residential place or business premises? If it's the residential the timing is telling and that loops in the guard. The woman does not mention what time she was accosted with hooded goons?If she was running a salon she cannot open past 8:30 pm. Whatever the estate you reside 8:30 pm is still busy with motorists and paedestrians alike. How can 4 hooded pistol wielding people walk an abductee 3KM and go unnoticed near the Commissioner Of Police residence. Then how can a lone woman risk walking alone for such a long distance at night? Why didn't she just drive back home after dropping the thugs and rush to the Commissioner' house and tell the guarding GSU what had happened? Alternatively she would have driven to Muthaiga Police station or Kasarani Police station. The shock theory does not add up. Africans don't have those shock issues only whites do and a select few. Lastly for people to carry out such an act new the Commissioner's house means they were very confident they would succeed and leave undetected. That confidence can only be achieved if you have an insider and that is the wife. She came with them and left with them. Secondly she is the only one who may have motive which is inherit the husband's wealth and/or avenge his extra marital affairs which is common with monied drunkards.

[@marymuthumbi355]

@@leonardkikuvi1800 the soldier says they got in with a taxi.... So many loose ends

[@kasyokanzyimi8079]

@@leonardkikuvi1800 in addition, in the history of robbery, there is always a get away plan, the robbers cant have relied on kidnapping the lady as their get away plan if they weren't sure she would come through.

[@ozone931]

These cases and convictions leave me wondering where these judges went to school.These cases even though real and lives are lost the handling look like "mchezo ya watoto" I think the whole system is messed up.How do you rule guilty or even not guilty without any forensic evidence? God have mercy on the poor countries.

[@machariakaguru3033]

I too would convict her , read the whole case Republic vs Janet Karamana (2013)

[@leonardkikuvi1800]

This is a black man's country.

[@priscadavid5917]

@@machariakaguru3033 After your reply, today I read the trial judgment and appeal judgment. I concur with you I would have convicted her too.

[@claregichuhi6968]

God is the only person who can give justice here, our system has failed us kabisaaa

[@salomegikiu1141]

woiye GOD have mercy.....why they CID favour one side????

[@steveykimson7238]

Forensic science is so vital n such case's. ..police in kenya are known for doing shoddy job's especially where they ger bribes to crucify such pple n the name of property. ...too bad 2 children left orphans. However if police did their job properly without interference the real culprits could've faced justice ..Although I don wanna speculate without seeing the statement taken the very day.

[@cateogwayo8138]

This woman is lying guilty has charged, how can murderers tell you to drop them after committing a crime..no criminal can leave a suspect alive..she planned it but the deal went sour the man died,the children are supporting since I understand there position it's hard to remain parentless..

[@219790]

Body language can tell she is lying.

[@Truthfulmen_women]

🧐🧐🤔🤔😂😂😂 hunanga chills

[@bbc5043]

Onsarigo your program has been very good it helps people learn that crime will not pay but of late you are turning it to be a PR for criminals. You are doing a great injustice to the victims of crime.

[@karanjakamau57]

BBC50, please these programs by dennis PROVES THE TRUTH THAT KENYA JUDICIAL SYSTEM IS NOTHING BUT A ROTTEN CORRUPT AND STINKING SYSTEM; THE ONLY THING KENYA JUDICIAL OFFICERS ARE GOOD AT IS TAKING BRIBES AND OWE UNTO YOU IF YOU ARE A POOR KENYA ; NO MATTER HOW INNOCENT YOU ARE YOU WILL BE SENT TO THE GALLOWS; BUT THE RICH NO MATTER HOW GUILTY THEY ARE MONEY CHANGES HANDS AND THEY WALK FREE:KENYA IS NOTHING OTHER THAN A STINKING AND ROTTEN GORVERMENT.NOTHING LIKE PR HERE PLEASE.MORE THAN 50% OF THOSE IN KENYA JAILS ARE VERY INNOCENT.

[@NK-rl8he]

I ain't no judge. But, eee her story just doesn't add up...

[@tishna9414]

Those people saying she is not crying as she narrates people grieve differently

[@vivax5323]

Kenya has the best CID officers in Africa, With inadequate forensics they are able to solve cases, there is always two sides of the story, In order for her to be prosecuted, there must has been overwhelming evidence. Good show,but they should also hire actors to make the scenes lively. They will be able to creat a lot of oppotunities for the youth.

[@leonheart2788]

nick yawa

[@manofreality3656]

sura ngumu na kavu aki angekua yeye c mhusika asingeweza ata jieleza angekua analia tu bt angalia sura yake...

[@marynjeri8500]

umesema ukweli yeye anajua mipango yote juu ya kifo cha bwanake.

[@thisandthat4932]

Why killed someone because of love? The woman deserves a life sentence

[@phillipsidhojapap1461]

Guilty as charged

[@ferenzejoseph3940]

Injustice of the highest order. Kenyan investigators are highly incompetent. I can’t understand why the judges don’t follow beyond reasonable doubt for such cases. It is sad for the kids too. This changed their world completely. Are there any innocence projects in Kenya?

[@jamesgakahu9645]

She killed the husband. She appealed and confessed to killing him

[@eliphezra3878]

Weka emotions kando

[@tractors22]

Am no judge but can you release this woman with immediate effect,Relatives fashion is what made the judge jail this woman but relatives are just selfish, and the judge could have sensed this.I wonder which woman no matter how devilish she can be would get men to kill her husband in-front of their kids.

[@muriuki101]

circumstantial evidence... a judge who relies on theories and a jealous relative evidence to send an innocent wife to jail. wow

[@zalwango73]

I agree with you, this is a case of family jealous,meanwhile the kids are suffering.

[@muriuki101]

Am glad someone agrees with me

[@zalwango73]

Muturi, it is unfortunate that in African set up it is believed that wives are always the cause of their husbands' death. So the jealous relatives take advantage of this and revenge by accusing the poor and defenceless widows.

[@thomasmbugua7148]

100% i agrred with u nicholas jealous relative give wrong pieces of evidence and the african judges accepted to jail an innocent african lady really very sad

[@lindaoduor1532]

plus I thought such evidence against an accused person needed to either be proven beyond reasonable doubt and in this case by corraboration......no one else testified in support of the relative, not even the people in the same place with him/her. Plus weren't they all locked up in some toilet? How loud were these thugs speaking that only he/she heard? Just bonkers

[@glokapf9113]

I feel the pain of this son. May the Lord heal you. Ladies we learn from this. We destroy our families. Put our kids under a heavy pain. I felt bad

[@henryjoevenosa9059]

In 🇰🇪 you are jailed by use of circumstancial evidence. Kenya is one country you will never understand cos the rot is just too much. No physical evidence, no motive but found guilty. What a country

[@bildad3]

Normally as with all casefiles, after watching the clip, I read through the judgement and tell you what, there was overwhelming evidence. That aside the woman deep down seems cunning, even the fact that the children don't say 'she is innocent' speaks alot, that even the daughter chose not to say a word on camera. It's sad they all know their precious mother planned all this, and that is beyond reproach.

[@Positivevibes-tq5mg]

Where can one get the judgement?

[@kingchwaky4554]

also wondering how the two gang members in front new the direction to the house.......she seems cunning to me also

[@jeffkhisa9817]

Just search the internet. She appealed in 2014 and was convicted to death. Then she petitioned the court for resentencing in 2018. This time she was resentenced to additional 10 years from 2019. Needless to say, in that petition for resentencing, she admitted she killed her husband but that she only intended to scare him

[@joeymuthoni]

she planned it i can see how her facial expression n body language plus she doesnt mean a word she's telling . They are way too shallow....She is as guilty as charged and the guard too... i feel sorry for her kids --------------->THANKS Sir Dennis onsarigo great show !

[@DannioArts]

This woman loved her husband .even in death she called him daddy

[@vanhelsing4041]

Note that the son says that he and the other victims were locked up in the bathroom while the mom states that they were locked up in the toilet.

[@leonardkikuvi1800]

AYALA-They can be in the same room

[@godschild7745]

Maybe individually or bathroom and toilet are together.

[@Truthfulmen_women]

The bathroom/toilet might be one. In most cases ziko pamoja.

[@fabianjoy12875]

Kikuyu

[@dukemokaya6544]

when the law caughts up with someone its when one becomes in reality

[@amayoh.b]

After watching this episode for the sixth time, from my end I can categorically say that those gangs used this woman and she was not part of the scheme. Circumstantial evidence was majorly at play here. If this would have happened in countries like US the truth would have been out long ago. I wonder if the investigation team dug deep on information like cell phone pinging. If she was part of the scheme then she must have communicated with them. Funny part is how would a woman plan for such when her own son was in the house? Some people appeared to have been wrongfully and wrongfully convicted while the main suspects are outside enjoying their free time. A case like this needs a fresh trial to determine whether she was part of the plan or not. With all the technology at our disposal at the moment she really needs a free trial including the security guard.

[@silviahkwamboka740]

was she released this is 2019

[@franklineototo6465]

she was later sentenced to hang after a failed appeal trial but the soja was released.

[@yogaexperiencesafrica]

So she engineered a roberry to rob herself of the cash she collected, at her own salon?

[@toshdidon4434]

The woman is innocent ,,

[@7428tony]

How can those gang ask the Janet to drive em after the incident, how stupid is that! something is not adding up, in my view i think conspiracy ili tembea , but God knows best.

[@berylabongo7428]

Anthony Trueman same ..

[@rosemaryauntie3872]

Can the kids re-appeal for their mother i feel she is innocent & besides there was no motive....

[@eliphezra3878]

I am reading comments and i can conclude that common mwananchi cannot be judges because they react based on emotions.This video is not a court live proceeding and obviously cannot reflect the true judgement

[@jahgalbity1285]

only in Kenya your guilty until proven rich woiyeee

[@steveykimson7238]

Jah Gal Bity ....WAH bur I agree

[@samwelochieng3030]

You are guilty unless you can afford to be innocent in Kenya, sijaiona tajiri akienda jela

[@atangastephen6670]

The Security guards failed their job. Rip Gituma

[@mosessemwogerere6448]

Only God knows the truth this case is so confusing but why did you allow to home with pipo you dont know

[@wanyamuthimookariuki2012]

I hope she was let free,,,its so sad

[@tinaodero4949]

TO ALL who have watched, read Janet's story. Just know there is more to it. Only God knows better but behind the scene there is much more that's unknown and known to me is the bigger mightier forces behind this case...The evidence is weak too. I have had a chance to journey with Janet and i must say she is a strong Woman. Over the years she has displayed integrity of higher level and has managed to keep her family strong even while in Prison ... her children have suffered emotionally .. lets me say they have been through it all and that they are the most strongest people i know. Janet's son had an accident awhile back and no member of their dad's esteemed family was there for him... other than Aunties from mum's side and a cousin who stays with them. As i always say ... the guilty one's are free and fit. Such cases makes me question the manner in which murder cases are investigated in this country. Well ...ours is not to judge but to walk with the victims. Still waiting for the moment of truth in this case. Assacinators, car Jackers behave exactly the way they did with Janet. They will kidnap a person to disguise their identity/intention. so who suffers in long run... the victims.

[@AustineMalala]

Read Judge Ombija's ruling. I would have also convicted her given the evidence provided by prosecution.

[@newtonnzungula3156]

And where are carjackers if at all you now much about the so called evidence?? this woman is just a victim of poor justice process and shoddy police investigations period!!!! spare us mr Evidence

[@AustineMalala]

Keep your feelings to yourself!!!Read the judgement before commenting. There was no any carjacking, all that was a coverup effort by the accused.

[@AustineMalala]

You do not know what you are talking about. Every one (may be except you) knows that a case with shoddy investigations can not stand in court, it will definitely be thrown out for lack of evidence. But even the court of appeal concurred with the High court's ruling based on evidence before the court.

[@newtonnzungula3156]

Maybe you live in Mars.

[@shamain4640]

You mean nobody alerted the husband prior to his arrival?

[@logic5204]

From what I've heard. I think this lady is innocent.

[@frankguantai4079]

Why come with the robbers and leave with them.

[@gracejayden5520]

The dead too deserve justice!!!!!!

[@thomasmbugua7148]

but @grace justice cannot be search by presuming another victim is resposible for killing the husband!!! she has arldy made an appeal and we hope appeal judges will overturn high court judge decision en set her freedom.

[@davismutahi5668]

Guilty.

[@davidikanyi994]

The judge in this case should be dethroned and the woman released. It is clear to me that innocent people have been sentenced to death by incompetence of judges. That is why we have the court of appeal.

[@jeffkhisa9817]

You may be interested to know that when she appealed the judge substituted her initial sentence of 30 years with the death sentence. Later on, the death sentence was removed when she was resenteced. The point, though, is that all the judges she brought her case to did not believe anything she said. And you would not believe her too if you read the case files

[@martinsmaureen3586]

i heart goes to the kids.

[@ritagicheru5186]

The evidence itself was not enough to convict anyone..

[@karumbawinniegathoni3638]

Huyu mama siwezi mskiza

[@urbanstylesv4201]

Her phone and six other circumstancial coincidences fixed her up. Did she appeal?

[@manofreality3656]

u gys a fool wapi umeona case file mtu akakubali kua alihusika? n if sm1 is lyng utamjua tu kwa maneno yake, dnt expect this woman to agree kua alihusika wakati stl analilia awe huru akaponde mali ya mtu ameua.....

[@fisherwoman546]

She might have killed him...He came with the thugs and left them..Do you realise he didn't harm the son.

[@Truthfulmen_women]

Why didn't the things hurt another person , only the husband ???? Watu Si wajinga buana , 😂😂😂

[@florencewilson4821]

I feel like this woman was jailed without enough evidence

[@danielmboya936]

I KNOW THIS YOUNG MAN,HE WAS MY CLASSMATE IN CAMPUS

[@danielmboya936]

YES KEVIN GITUMA,A PERSONAL FRIEND

[@okuchuigwee5814]

daniel mboya who ask you

[@franciskamau9575]

Wow so many police officers here i wonder why the government has not hired you all

[@zipporahkakungu2945]

Some things not adding up...

[@eliphezra3878]

Judges are not fools...she is guilty as per the judge's statement