Carvaka : The School of Metarialism

[@ajitakesakambali2388]

This is an excellent presentation of Charvaka philosophy given the fact that we only have historical records of the "opponent's views" of the Charvakas. I do want to concur and emphasize three points. Although the Charvakas "freed" themselves from orthodoxy, they did base their discussion on observation. In fact, I would say that this was the closest thing to the scientific method now used in the modern times where hypothesis graduates to theory and theory to law only on the basis of repeated observation. Even the laws (Newton's Law) are subject to modification (General Relativity) to accommodate observed anomalies (orbit of Mercury). Secondly, it should be mentioned that Ajita Kesakambali (a materialist) lived a very simple (non luxurious) life. Thirdly, positing "God" or "Gods" into the argument for the "ultimate cause" only begs the question which is a point the Charvakas could not have missed (speculation on my part entirely). The fact that this point is not mentioned anywhere supports my statement that unfortunately nothing from the great works of Charvakas has survived from the Charvakas themselves but only from the "mouths" of their opponents. Once again, an excellent presentation. Thank you for the fine presentation.

[@Curiousmind-CD]

So precise lecture thank you Sir

[@Dyslexic_Neuron]

excellent lecture !! Thanks a lot !!

[@shivashankara4708]

can I get the presentation in .pdf format , 🙂

[@pradeepsinghpaikrapaikra3074]

Thank you 🙏🙏

[@thepalebluedot4171]

ഒരു കാലത്ത് ചാരവകർ സംസാരിച്ചിരുന്ന ഭാഷയെക്കുറിച്ച് ഇന്റർനെറ്റിൽ എവിടെയും കണ്ടെത്താൻ കഴിഞ്ഞില്ല, ഞാൻ എല്ലായിടത്തും തിരഞ്ഞു.

[@eternalnihilist6415]

Please upload remaining lecture of philosophy in structured way.

[@EduPhilo-c9q]

Please make lecturera for Hindi medium philosophy students

[@dondavis911]

Are there any good books available on this philosophy ? Or do you provide any notes for further study ?

[@peteconcept6764]

Some material. One by esteemed philsopher Ramkrishna Bhattacharyawww2.units.it/eserfilo/art813/bhattacharya813.pdf The other is an entry from Stanford encyclopedia by Amita Chatterjee with referenecs to further plato.stanford.edu/entries/naturalism-india/

[@ShaktiSingh03]

The way you presented things is very strange...

[@foryoumatter]

He is too reading screen. Such a shame for such a glorious university like JNU

[@nainakharbanda507]

you haven't gave any example to explain charvaka properly I don't like your videos it's doesn't help me

[@Yuyyy126]

Not qualitative at all. Govt pls don't waste time and money on such useless ways. Try to give us qualitative, because it's people's money. Pls don't mind on my words. But it's truth

[@nainakharbanda507]

you haven't gave any example to explain charvaka properly I don't like your videos it's doesn't help me